Main Topic: The podcast episode discusses the relationship between producers and leadership in the insurance industry, specifically focusing on the challenges producers face when trying to create their own content and brand themselves within an agency.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Additional Insights:
Became a Master of the Close: https://masteroftheclose.com
Tracy Cotton, one of my favorite people in the insurance industry, joins the podcast for a deep discussion on the producer vs agency owner relationship and how producers can maximize their value over the long-term. Get more: https://ryanhanley.com
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Episodes You Might Enjoy:
Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.
Ryan Hanley
Hello everyone and welcome back to the show. Today we have one of my favorite people in the entire industry on the podcast, and that is Tracy Cotton. The reason I like Tracy Cotton is because when you look at her from the outside, you would think mild-mannered, you would think polite. But what you get is funny, ironic, sarcastic, thoughtful, introspective, and dynamic.
I just love this conversation. It was so much fun. Any time I get to spend time either virtually or in person with Tracy Cotton, I take that time. I think she's a treasure of our space and one of the great people. Anybody who could have Tracy Cotton working for their organization should consider themselves lucky.
The truth is, I've told her many times that the moment she wants to come work for Risk, I'll get licensed in North Carolina and Tennessee and any other state she wants, and I'll go get appointments with any carrier she wants. I'm joking, but that's how highly I think of her. She's just awesome. She's a worker, a salesperson, a marketer, and she just gets it. I love that she focuses on ag business, something I don't know anything about.
I think you're thoroughly going to enjoy this episode with Tracy Cotton because you are absolutely going to take something away. We push into many different aspects of the industry, a lot of which has to do with the relationship between producers and leadership, what that means, how it's evolving, and what recommendations she and I have for producers who may not love their fit with their current organization and how they can approach different things.
I think you're going to enjoy it. I certainly did. It's a pleasure to share these types of episodes with you.
Before we get there, I want to give a big shout out to Advisor Evolved. If you need a website—which you do—if you don't have a website, then slap yourself in the face right now. If you don't have a website that's functional beyond just being a postcard online, literally take your hand and slap yourself as hard as you can across the face because you need to wake up.
The people who are going to benefit from an Advisor Evolved website are people looking to grow their business because it's not just a website. It's not just a pretty picture in the magic box. It's a tool. I use QuoteVids almost every single day. It's one of the tools that comes with an Advisor Evolved website, and it has completely changed the game for me in terms of my ability to deliver that human experience in our digital space. It's part of my human optimized agency.
When people ask me what website provider they should use, there's literally no other answer. It's Advisor Evolved. It's Chris Langell and his team. You can go check out the other ones, and you can even choose them. You'll be making a bad decision, and that's okay. You just know you've made a poor decision. At some point, you will come back to Advisor Evolved where you should be.
Go to AdvisoreVolved.com. Check it out. Get your new website. Get up to date. We live in a digital world, my friends. Everyone's working from home. Everyone's shopping online. You have to have a good website. Advisor Evolved is the only website option in our industry.
Now on to the magnificent Tracy Cotton. There she is. What's going on?
Tracy Cotton
[Laughs] That's what you get when you have a zillion Zoom meetings and you don't want to enter the room unmuted every single time.
Ryan Hanley
Yeah, I get that. I haven't sold a single policy on Zoom. Not one.
Tracy Cotton
No, I haven't. I haven't had the need to. I haven't had one client where it even made sense. Every account I've sold, big or small, has either been through email or phone. I've sold two in person.
Ryan Hanley
So you know what just dropped this week? The new Jeb Blunt book, *Virtual Selling*. I see pictures of it everywhere. I went ahead and grabbed it. I've got a couple of good friends who are pretty excited about it. It's funny—it's not like we haven't had video for a while. It's just how to use it, I think, is the interesting part. It blows me away that he whipped it out so fast.
Tracy Cotton
Well, that dude is awesome, but he was also a content factory. He can pump stuff out. It's funny—some of these authors who make a living selling books are just so good at seeing a trend and getting a book out about it. It's not that they haven't talked about it before, but right now that's probably the perfect book to sell via Zoom. Every company is going, "How the heck do we do this?" Like they've never sold anything before.
I was just on an accountability call with this influence circle I have. One guy is selling furniture. How do you do that? He takes people on a virtual walkthrough of the showroom. He's got a camera on a gimbal, and he's super excited about it because the company he works for isn't really interested in doing what he's doing. Instead, they spent thousands of dollars on videos with staged people talking about the furniture. He's like, "That's all well and good, but I think I'm going to do better one-on-one with somebody on Zoom, walking through the showroom where we can actually interact. I've got their full attention." They're not going to start a video, get bored halfway through, check out, and go do something else.
Ryan Hanley
The other thing too—it's so specific to people's tastes. There could be one piece of furniture in one of those videos that someone doesn't like, and it throws off another piece of furniture that normally they would like because they can't see it or the room is a different size.
I think the most interesting thing about COVID and everything that came out of being locked in our houses and having to go virtual is that everyone who thought they had the answer and that it would always be the answer is both right and wrong. Everyone who thought they knew what the answer was going to be is also both right and wrong.
With my digital disposition and comfort level, I thought I would be Calendly-ing. I haven't had one person use my Calendly to set up an appointment. I thought it would be email to Calendly to Zoom. That hasn't happened once. Not one time. People are just like, "Oh, can we meet at two o'clock?" And I say, "Sure, I'll call you on the phone."
Now, I do use Langell's QuoteVids tool a lot. So my process instead of using Zoom has been to package it all up, do the QuoteVid where I break it down—I try to keep it between three to five minutes max—and explain why I decided to use this carrier. I give them the prequel. With the email link to the video, I also include the PDF of the proposal. Then we just get on the phone and talk about it.
I've found that to be a lot easier because people get messed up with video. Some people care what they look like. Some people care where they're sitting. Some people don't have the time. Some people have background noise. I just don't want to have to deal with that.
Tracy Cotton
I don't blame you. I've been using video proposals for a little over a year. I don't remember what pushed me to finally do it other than it was my sales process. I deal with so many smaller accounts that I just can't spend a tremendous amount of time going back and forth.
I don't know if I'm going to reach them on the first call back. I've got the proposal ready. Kelly Donaghy Pura would tell you not to send out just a naked PDF and let them figure it out—you need to walk them through it. But I also don't know if I'm going to catch them on that call. By going ahead and doing the video proposal, I've walked them through the whole proposal.
I would say my closing ratio on a video proposal is probably 70 or 80 percent. By the time they've watched it, all their questions have been answered. I've highlighted all the things I know they're probably going to ask because I know that part in advance. They just call me up and say, "I saw it. Let's do this." It shortens my process.
Ryan Hanley
That's an important proposal. I love the video proposal. I'm a huge proponent of it. Everyone is so busy. You could spend the next two weeks trying to catch them at the right moment. They're busy, they're on the phone, they send you to voicemail. Or you just send them that email with the link and password and say, "The answer to all your wildest dreams is behind this gated website. Watch this video and all your wildest dreams come true."
The other thing I like about Chris's platform—and I know other platforms have this too—is there's a button that says "Accept Proposal." It doesn't actually bind the coverage. It's just visually going, "Yup, I'll take this." Now your next call is so easy. "Hey, so happy you decided to do business. Any final questions? No? Okay, how do you want to..." Boom, boom, boom, done. That call is not... and they feel like they engaged with you because of the picture-in-picture thing where they can see you talking, see your face, see you animated while you're talking through your proposal.
I'm not negative on Zoom selling. I just haven't needed it yet. But video proposals are a no-doubter at this point in my mind.
Tracy Cotton
The thing it did for me—and I am totally jealous because we don't have Chris's product—I had to do it on my own. I started using Vidyard because of a Marcus Sheridan plug. It was super easy. I can do anything I need with it. I love doing the little personalized thumbnail so they see it and are more likely to open it.
A lot of my clients I don't get to see face to face. I just got a call a couple minutes ago from someone about four hours away in another part of the state. They were referred to me by NC State through a program they're going through. Maybe we'll do business, maybe we won't. But I may not actually meet them face to face. The Zoom idea is great, but at the very least, even with the video proposal, I've run into those people later and they knew me because they got to see that video. Not that they couldn't look on our website and see a picture of Tracy or go to my LinkedIn, but they felt like they knew me. We'd only talked on the phone and I'd only put that one video proposal out. We'd never Zoomed because that wasn't as big a deal as it is now.
I'm looking at the idea of being able to walk through a showroom from the other aspect. Could I get a farmer to be willing to Zoom with me and walk me through their farm? That would save me several hours round trip. If they're going to be out there walking around doing something anyway, just take me along with you. Show me and walk me through it. Let me get a better feel for what you've got going on, knowing that I'm not going to be able to come out and visit you on your timetable, or it's just not convenient, or maybe you don't feel comfortable with me being there face to face, mask or not.
I think they probably won't care, but that possibility is interesting. I'd like to play around with it. There are a lot of possibilities out there that people haven't thought through yet. We've got to be the ones thinking through it.
That's one of the things I wanted to talk to you about today. Whose responsibility is it when it's time to recreate the wheel? Is it up to the producer? Do they get to have that kind of say in what they do for an agency? Is it respected? Is it accepted? There are a lot of questions out there.
It's been on my mind recently because I've spent the last few years doing things a little bit differently. I've been really fortunate because the agency I work for, five years ago when I said, "I've got this niche I want to work on. What do you think?" They were like, "Do we have markets for it?" I said yes. Nobody else in the agency is working on it. Nobody else wants to. They said, "Go ahead. Go for it."
Then I said, "Well, I'm going to do this, and then I'm going to do that." And they said, "Okay, whatever you want to do." Not that they were going to pay for me to do any of those things. That didn't mean they were going to fork over cash for me to get a separate website for that marketing angle. They weren't going to get me business cards with my logo versus their logo. But they also didn't care, as long as I was busy selling business. They were okay with it.
But I think there's a little bit of controversy there. Is it a threat? If I'm an agency owner and somebody wants to start branding themselves within the agency, is that cool or not? There's a lot there.
Ryan Hanley
There are a couple of things. One thing I wrote down that I have to get out of my brain so I can answer your question is this: I think there is a tremendous piece of content you could create to teach farmers how to do a video review that they could then send to you. You don't actually have to be on the call.
You could say, "Here's what I need to see." Show them how to do a video, package it up, and text it to you. Then you can do everything you need to do off that video. "Here's how you do it. Here are the things I need to see." They can just take their phone out, video the thing, email you the video, and boom—you're working. You don't have to be on the call with them because that adds an unnecessary layer.
You could create a cool piece of content showing people how to do whatever it is you need to see. I've never written a farm, so you know that better than anybody. You could have someone film you doing it on one of your clients. You could have cuts of you actually showing them the shots, with B-roll behind you showing you getting the shots. You could come up with a really cool thing. Call Sydney—she'll help you put that together.
Tracy Cotton
That's amazing.
Ryan Hanley
Then when they call you with interest or get referred to you, you could say, "Look, I'm about to send you a video. It's three and a half minutes long. It walks you through exactly what I need from a video perspective to see your farm. Just send me that video. Once I have it back, I can get to work." That gives you another cool touchpoint. It makes you look like, "Geez, man, she knows our business so well." And you're also being very respectful of their time. You can say, "Look, you have so much going on in your day. Once everything's done, once you've fed the pigs and shucked the corn or whatever, just walk around real quick and get this video."
I think that would be really cool. I had to get that out of my brain.
Tracy Cotton
I appreciate you doing that because literally I have farm friends who are out there working on TikTok. I'm not even on there yet. They're out there doing videos on TikTok. So they can do that. They can take the time to do a video review for me. That's brilliant, Ryan. I'm going to do it.
Ryan Hanley
All right, cool. Sometimes you get something wedged in your coconut, and until you extract it, you can't think about the next thing.
To your question about the next thing—there's so much there. You and I have talked about this on more than one occasion. Where you're at is very similar to where I was at at the Murray Group. They were supportive in so much as they said, "Go ahead, do your thing." But it wasn't like they wanted it to be part of their philosophy. They didn't believe in it. They weren't supportive like, "This is amazing, let's run with this." They were just like, "If this is what you want to do, we're okay with you doing it."
Ultimately, there were some issues. There were people who started to think I was the owner or more than just a producer because of how out front I was. This isn't the only company where that's happened to me.
I think this is a common problem for producers who create content. I have a couple of ideas. My first idea—and this is probably the most draconian—is that there are plenty of agencies. It's 100 percent an ego thing. If there's a problem, just go find an agency owner who would be willing to support you.
Now, there are tons of caveats. I'm sure you have a non-compete. I'm sure there are issues with all kinds of stuff. If you don't have a non-compete, you'd have to go tell all your clients you're going somewhere else. There are a lot of issues to that.
I think you have to figure out how much of a problem it is. The other side of it—and maybe you've done this—is there's a point where you just say, "Look, guys, I'm producing this. Here's what's happening. I need to know what this looks like for us in the future." If the answer is just that you kind of turn the other way but you're not really supportive, that doesn't put me in a position for success long-term because I feel like I'm operating with one hand behind my back.
If you have issues, talk to me. Let's figure this out. I know a lot of producers haven't had that conversation. I certainly—and this is firsthand experience—never did. A lot of the issues I had at the Murray Group were because I was too immature at the time to sit down and have that conversation. It didn't work out exactly the way I had hoped long term.
Tracy Cotton
That's an interesting thing. Two things on that. First, I actually reached out to you at the beginning of the year when I went from being more of a hybrid role—selling, servicing, doing a lot of inside work, trying to grow my own niche—to becoming a full producer. With that came the typical things they do, like signing a non-compete after all these years of working for them. That was the smart thing to do. That was what they should do.
But I had to go back and look at it. I'm reading through this non-compete and realizing, "Wait, wait, wait. I get that you're going to have all the clients I've already written and all the clients I will write as long as I'm an employee here. I get that. But while you weren't caring what I was doing, I was building a brand that I now don't want to exist without. Or at the very least, I don't want to exist without it."
So I need you to confirm that I can take "Farm to Fork Insurance Agent." I haven't trademarked that, but by golly, that's what I'm known for. That's my tagline. My little owl, my little logo. I wanted it to go with me because who cares about your insurance? I still want to be able to use that. That's what I've been doing on my own dime for the last four and a half years before you decided you wanted me to be a full producer.
I also recognize the opposite. There was content I created during that time period that still isn't being utilized on the actual company website. But that part is finally getting ready to change. They approached me and said, "Hey, we want to put content on the website now. We realize you have an idea of how to do that and you already have some things you want to do. We're probably going to end up having to train some other people because you're going to still be the face of farm and agribusiness and Farm to Fork, but we may need somebody else over here who wants to be the face of work comp."
I get that. I think that's great. But they don't know where to start with that. They're going to come to me on that. I'm surprised it hasn't happened already.
Along with that, I started a podcast a few weeks ago. It's super exciting. I threw one of my ad contacts through somebody I knew on Twitter who already had an ag-related podcast. I called him up because I'd been wanting to do it for a long time, but it seemed too complicated. I'm not very good at editing, especially on the sound end. I was afraid of it. I tried to use some software before and it seemed really cumbersome.
He said, "I'm using Anchor. It's super easy. You can just trim by putting your fingers on a screen and moving it around a little bit. Next thing you know, you hit save and publish and it does all the work for you." I was like, "Done. I'm going to do a podcast."
He said, "I have an idea, Tracy. I know somebody who's doing somewhat the same thing you do. She's out in Kansas. I think the two of y'all should get together." That in itself opened a whole world. It was fantastic. She's been the most incredible co-host I could possibly ask for. We come from different backgrounds, and it's wonderful that we get to play off each other. Now we're starting to have guests. We can ask them different kinds of questions and really build on what the two of us are doing.
But she's the one who said, "Now we've got to make sure and put a disclaimer at the end." I said, "Okay, disclaimer. What do you mean?" She said, "Because of who she works for, she was afraid that if they heard the podcast, they'd want to regulate it. 'Oh no, you can't say that on the podcast because if you say that in conjunction with our name, that could... we don't want you putting out the wrong information. You actually have financial products you could be talking about, and that would be wrong.'"
On her end, it's a little bit more heavy in that. I hadn't really thought about it. But once she came up with the wording for it, I was like, "Bingo. That means if I don't mention my employer on this podcast, then it's my podcast. It's a personal podcast, and it gets to go with me. That's brilliant."
Thank you so much, Vicki Gibson, for figuring out the disclaimer at the end. She insisted on it. It was because of the experience I've seen somebody—maybe I'm talking to right now—go through. I surely didn't want to have a cease and desist over something as silly as something I really care about. Maybe nobody cares about what I'm doing with it. They haven't cared yet. But I just don't want them to care down the road because it's something I created while I was in that employment, if that makes sense.
Ryan Hanley
Yeah. I don't know who the owners of your business are, but I do know that old men get grumpy and you have to be careful. I said to my wife one day, "I am positive that someday I will be old, but God, I hope I'm not an old grumpy white guy." Because when they get grumpy, shit gets real.
I think you're doing the right thing. I love this idea.
One thing to help you with the editing—talk to Cas. Cas has a little side hustle helping with this. This podcast is completely packaged by Cas's company. I record the intro, I record the interview, and then I send those two files to one of his people. They do the intro music, the outro music, they package it all up. If there's anything—like sometimes someone will say something and come back and say, "Hey, I really wasn't supposed to say this"—they handle it. Not like a curse word or something. Just maybe they gave a stat out that was like your co-host, right?
Like maybe she says something that she didn't mean to say and it would actually impact something. You know, I'll go in and I'll just chop that up. But basically I take the finished interview and the finished intro and I send those off. And then I get an email. So every Wednesday night and Sunday night, the episode goes out to the podcast networks, and then every Monday and Thursday, the blog post, the corresponding blog post goes live. And I just get an email that says, "Hey, podcast live on Monday morning." And then I start sharing it out and that's what I do.
I will tell you that that has changed the game for me. Absolutely changed the game because now I can do an interview like this and in the back of my mind, I'm not going, "Oh shit, I gotta package this up and it's gonna take all this time and then I gotta upload it to this thing." Because that one, that doesn't work for my personality—it's soul sucking—and two, who has the time? So Cass's thing has been a game changer, complete game changer for me. So I'd reach out to him and talk to him about that.
Tracy Cotton
That's good to know. I knew that Bradley and Scott, the insurance guys, were using an outside service. I think that's actually somebody that they know maybe in Alabama. They like to do a lot of local things there.
Ryan Hanley
They want to stay away from Alabama as much as possible.
Tracy Cotton
Well, you know, I ended up—the one time that I got to be on their show, I got to do it in Vegas back when you could go to Vegas, and it was fantastic.
Ryan Hanley
Yeah, I'm just joking, by the way. I love Alabama.
Tracy Cotton
Oh, and I love Alabama too. I'm right here in the midst of it, between North Carolina and looking at Tennessee, and Alabama's right there with it. So that's just down the road.
But no, I just think that as far as the angry white guys—and we talk a lot, I say "we" as in you and I, but the rest of my circle of friends, we all feel that. We feel that from lots of different aspects. We've been poked fun at at times, like, "Oh, that's really cute what they're doing with such and such." And then literally those are the same people who are now actually doing the thing or paying somebody to do the thing. They're doing the thing that they made fun of. I think that's ironic, and it's just the way that it goes sometimes.
But I don't take offense to it for the most part. And like you said, with what you'd been doing, there's two sides to it. You've got the "Okay, maybe they aren't afraid of me doing what I'm doing to brand myself or to create my own content, but it's because they don't think that there's any harm in it." And that's great because they think that it's good for the agency. But if they're not willing to back me up—as in actually help with the expenses of, say, a podcast, if that's what I was asking for, but I'm not—or there was something that I was asking for, that's just been harder to come by.
On the other hand, I also recognize that I've got really good friends. One is a heavy hitter. He works for one of the name brand agencies, one of those large, large alphabet houses. And he's so excited about doing his own content and his own video now on LinkedIn. The reality is he knows that he can expect their content, their name brand, to keep doing what it's been doing for him. He recognizes that in order to move forward and keep moving forward, he's going to have to do a little bit of self-branding. And he also recognizes that he can't count on somebody else's content to do all the work. It's not going to be completely about the niche he's in. It's not going to be specific to him or what he can actually bring to the table for somebody. It doesn't do that relationship building that I think there's an opportunity to do when you're creating the right kind of content.
Ryan Hanley
I have a couple of thoughts on that. My first thought is they're going to be okay with you until you are more popular than they are. And then it doesn't matter how much revenue it's bringing in, you're going to have problems. I'm calling that shot right now. I've done things in the past that were very advantageous for people that weren't me and still had my hand slapped and all kinds of different stuff. So my point—and not just me, I've seen this time and time and time again. We have a mutual friend who is also in North Carolina who now works for a gangster agency that before had the same exact thing happen to him.
So what happens here? This is unfortunately a huge ego issue, particularly with the baby boomer generation. And I'm sure there are baby boomers out there who are going to hate when I say this, but male baby boomers do not want to be upstaged. They just don't. It's the reason they haven't retired yet. This generation refuses to retire, which is okay. But the problem is when you have people in general—it's not a generation that is used to sharing the hierarchical structure. They've worked to get to where they are and they've earned their position, and that's perfectly fine, but they're not good at sharing that position in general.
So what ends up happening is, as long as they see what you're doing as a nice little side project for the agency, it's a pat on the head. "That's great, Tracy. We're so happy for you." The moment that the podcast and the blog and your brand start to become something that is being highlighted in trade journals, that people are talking about, that clients are asking about, that people might—they're at a chamber event and someone goes, "Hey, that Tracy, man, it's great that you've brought her in and made her such an important part of the agency"—they're going to be in their mind going, "Yeah, yeah, yeah." In the back of their head, they're going to be like, "That motherf***er thinks she owns this place. Screw that." That's what's going to happen. I'm telling you. And it's a shame, but it's what's going to happen. It just is.
I've seen this time and time and time again. The moment you get to a certain level, it's "Wait, wait, wait. This isn't a side project anymore. We need to take ownership. What are you saying? We want you to send this through legal before you say that. Can you make sure that our name is part of the logo? Have you mentioned our carrier partners yet?" You're going to hear all this crap and you're going to go, "What the heck? I'm the one who built this thing. Why don't you just let me keep rocking and rolling and everyone will be happy? I'm putting business through you. You're taking a piece of it. I'm not asking you for money. Let me do my thing." And this has happened over and over and over again across the country. It's a shame, but it's what happens.
Now, not every time. There are leaders who step up to the table and go, "I hit the gold mine. I got Tracy. I'm a rocker. What do you need? Let's go. Go be the queen of the Southeast of the country. We'll put all our money behind you." I just think that that's rare. And if you haven't seen it already, if they haven't seen it, then I struggle—I have no idea who your ownership is—but I struggle to think that they're going to all of a sudden see the light. Maybe it'll happen. Maybe it won't.
I told you the other day when you emailed me, I was like, "Shit, if you leave, I'll hire you tomorrow. I'll go get Rogue licensed in North Carolina and Tennessee and you can go do your thing." I just think—and there are plenty of owners—my point is there is this whole generation of owners, not just an age, just in mentality, right? There's this whole generation of owners who would buy that brand from you and see it as an asset to their business. And they would build it and nurture it and fan the flames and give you the resources to go as far as you want to go. There's not as many of them, but they are out there. It's not like that would be an easy transition, but it's there for you.
Tracy Cotton
Well, I think you're right on that point. And that's those expectations. I want to see more producers either step up and go, "Okay, I recognize that I can't just sit back on my laurels and expect the agency brand to sell something." Some of them are just super good at whatever they're going to do. I get that. They don't feel the need to have to do anything different because they are good with the logo on their shirt. They've got their nice polo and it's got the big agency logo. Why everybody has to have a tree when we still cut down too many of them to make paper out of, I don't know. But every agency I know practically has a tree in their logo somewhere. And the logo is great, but if that's really what they think is going to sell, I think the producers need to step up too.
I see that as something that goes both ways. There are going to be agencies that see the value in how to promote the agency better. And then they may end up having some pushback from those guys that are like, "Yeah, but I'm doing great with what I'm doing." Again, they may be of a certain age group and they are still having better luck with conversations on a golf course than with trying to get a Zoom meeting with somebody they don't know. "I just go and hang out at the Elks Lodge or whatever it is that they do." I think it's still a model that's working to an extent. I just don't see how much longer that can work.
Ryan Hanley
And I also just—Tracy, why can't we have both? Why can't we have the guy who goes and crushes the Elks Lodge? Go crush the Elks Lodge. Do it. Drink the cheap draft beer and play the bingo and tell old war stories. It's amazing, right? That's amazing. If you can crush that environment, rock and roll. What bothers me is, why can't it be, "Hey, I crush the Elks Lodge," and then sit right next to you and go, "And you do this podcast, virtual thing, and that's amazing too." Both are amazing.
I guess what I don't like—and this is a life thing for me, and this is my second interview today so I'm very soapboxy, so I apologize to everyone—but as a life thing, I don't understand why people put their shit on other people. You're not saying to the agency, "You guys are all jerks because you're not podcasting." Correct. All you're saying is, "Hey, why don't you support my podcasting efforts in the way I do business so that I can help bring more revenue into the agency? You go do exactly what you want to do." So often what happens is we say, "That's different from me, so I'm going to take my stuff and I'm gonna put it on you." I just don't like that. I really don't like that.
I think it's a big problem with a lot of the stuff we're dealing with in the country right now. Everybody on every side is trying to take their stuff and put it on everyone else instead of just living their life. But particularly in our business with this conversation, I think that's what happens way too often. Instead of just appreciating the difference, they want to either not support by just being silent, or literally try to keep you from being as successful as you could be.
Tracy Cotton
You're right. You're absolutely right. Whether it be sales style or how you go about branding or marketing, it is not one size fits all. If it was, we'd be really boring. I think it's much more fascinating to be able to see what people come up with and continue to come up with. I think you're right that that polarization is where we're running into trouble, where it's literally crippling certain operations.
I've got a good friend. She and I talk regularly. She's an agency manager in Georgia. She just feels like so much of her time is spent—because she's not really selling insurance anymore—she literally works with the CSRs, she's working with the producers, she's working with agency management, which is still doing a little bit of both. Most of them are still doing some selling. She says, "I spend all of my time trying to build bridges just for somebody else to come over and set another one on fire." She's like, "Every time I think that I've got everybody on that team aspect and they're all together on it, then somebody else has to come along."
We see it with technology when it comes into an agency. You've got agencies that are going to pieces because they don't know how to use something new and there's all that push and pull. It's kind of scary out there. I actually know agents that are like, "Well, I'm just hoping that person will just go ahead and retire. If they don't want to play by what we're doing, they just need to go ahead and retire." And it's like, yeah, but if they still could come in and be supportive, even if they're not going to be able to be 100% functional on all the technology, they still have something to offer. There's still something there. If everybody can respect that, that's the thing. If they're going to come back in and they're just the negative Nancy coming in and talking about how terrible it is and they aren't going to do it, that's different. Maybe they do need to retire.
I know that back when I used to do some consulting, that was kind of the thing. We knew that something or another wasn't even going to go over in an office until so-and-so actually retired. "Until so-and-so retires, we're never going to change agency management systems. Until so-and-so retires, we're never going to try to actually start using a new CRM. We aren't going to do email marketing." Fill in the blank. And that push and pull—the rest of the world is looking at us like we're fools. They're looking at us as an industry and wondering why we can't move forward. It's because we can't even decide how to move forward. That's producer autonomy, but it's also an industry thing.
Ryan Hanley
I was on a call with a carrier the other day. I'm part of their technology council, which is really cool because I love this carrier and I think they're doing a lot of things right. They're asking the right questions. I don't know that they have all the answers, but I think they're asking the right questions. So we're talking about this and they were walking me through an idea that they had. I said to them, "Are you building this for your top 20% or your bottom 20%?" And they said, "Our disposition is we believe there are agencies that are leaning forward and there are agencies that are leaning back. And we are building everything from now on for the agencies that are leaning forward. We are not even considering the agencies that we believe are leaning backwards."
I literally raised my hands and said, "Hallelujah. Hallelujah, sister." It was a woman. I said, "Hallelujah. Thank you. You have just—I don't even care what you choose to do moving forward—you've just made a course correction in a positive direction." Because for so long, the stuff that has been rolled out to the industry, particularly from carriers, has been "Here's what the most agents could potentially use." And what happens is the only agents that would ever be interested in using it look at it as a piece of garbage because they're like, "That's like five years ago, what you just wrote out." And then they go, "How come no one's using our tech?" It's because you're building for the lowest common denominator agency.
Let that agency live their life. Let's build for the people who are going to engage with you, give you feedback, use the tool, break the tool, give you more feedback. You're only going to get better. And then what's going to happen is some of those agencies that are leaning backwards are going to look at what's happening and go, "Oh, wait a minute. Let's engage. This looks fun. I want to be part of that game." And now all of a sudden they're going to start to lean forward. Versus let's put a governor on everybody because we want the guy who's choosing to not engage—we want to make sure that he has an option. Screw his option. He chose not to have an option. That's why we live in a free market capitalist environment. That's why we live here in America—because he gets to choose to not engage, just like those of us who want to engage have chosen that decision. I don't know that we all should have to wait because he—although most of the time it's "he," most female-run agencies are fairly forward leaning—he's chosen to just kind of take it easy.
And the counterpart to the woman who said this to me said, "What we've written down is we asked the question of our team: How many of our agencies are losing so slowly that they believe they're winning?" And I was like, "Oh, that's like some Confucius Buddha. That's some real hardcore stuff. You'd hear that in an Eminem song or something." That's like sitting in a boat and it's raining and you think all the water in the bottom of the boat is just from the rain, but it's actually because you're sinking. You just don't realize it because you've got all this water there and you think, "Oh, this is okay. We're cool." No, this is actually water coming in because you're sinking. You're not just sitting in a rainstorm. I just can't even.
Tracy Cotton
That's a really interesting thought. I was on the phone yesterday morning with an executive for a carrier that is really trying to up their game on crop insurance. I've got the opportunity to go and speak at a crop conference. Even though I don't sell crop specifically, they felt like I understood the audience enough. I wanted to know more about their audience. I thought if I talk to one of the carriers that I know does a lot of business in that state and happens to be one of the sponsors, why not give them the opportunity to give me a little feedback on what they'd like us to talk about.
His thing was, "We actually are now providing farmers with the ability on their cell phone to report the crops, to go ahead and take the photos for the claims—all the things that you would expect from those 1-800 number companies that are already promoting their app for. But this is something that's going to be available for crop insurance." That's staggering to me because I know it's a very paperwork-heavy line of business. We always made fun of in the agency about the fact that the lady that sold the most crop insurance in our whole agency—and really has done a tremendous job—there are certain deadlines they have to hit because it's government-based, like flood insurance or something else, it's so regulated. But she would be up at the office until 10 or 11 o'clock at night still faxing paperwork in for her farmers at the very last minute because it had taken them that long to get back to her with information. And now they can do it from an app.
I said, "So what kind of engagement are you seeing on that app?" He said, "I've got some agencies that love it. They're promoting it to all of their farmers. They're getting good interaction. And then some—they're still really good agents out there and they could care less about it." I see that. But you talking about a carrier that's looking at it from "We're going to continue to put out the things that we know are going to carry our agents forward" instead of spending so much money—because it is money—if they're saying, "No, we're going to keep on sending out the paper manual or we're going to keep on doing whatever it is to keep the rest of the slow crowd or the no crowd involved," as an agent that writes for that carrier, eventually they're going to lose out. The fact that they're putting their investment in the agents that they know are going to continue to win as time goes by, that's a great bet. That's a pretty interesting model.
But this VP was just fascinating yesterday. His thing was the whole idea that they're seeing so many agents out there still assuming they know how the customer wants to be served. And that assumption, because we're not asking the right questions—we don't ask the right questions of our current customers, we don't ask the right questions of our prospects. "How do they want to be served?" To assume, "Do they want to be texted or they don't want to be texted?" If we're not asking the questions, we never know the best way for that particular client. We are in that time period now where we have to individualize because that's what they're getting from everybody else. They get exactly what they want. They get to design the teddy bear. They get to customize every experience they have pretty much in life. If they can't customize how they handle their insurance, then we're losing out on that opportunity. I can walk into the beer store and build my own four-pack of 16-ounce IPA pounders. Come on. And I can't tell you how I want to get my bills or how I want to pay? You're just going to tell me this is the only option I have?
Ryan Hanley
I had a client who was referred to me, $8,000 in personal lines. He said to me, "Hey, is it cool if you only communicate with me via Facebook Messenger?" I said, "Yeah, that's cool." But you just wouldn't, right? You would assume. He's like, "Hey man, every night when I get home, I check my Facebook Messenger. If you have a message for me, I'm not going to look at it during work. So just hit me on Facebook Messenger. I'll get back to you at the end of the night." I was like, "Yeah, dude, that's cool." There's probably someone listening going, "Yeah, I got tons of clients like that. It's cool." But the idea is we have to be able to accommodate that because it's going to continue. If I go, "You know what? We don't really do that here. I would rather just call you on the phone," he's going to go, "Oh, well, whatever." And a year from now, he's going to go, "You know what? This guy calls me on the phone." And a year after that, he's going to go, "Screw this guy. I'm just going to go see what Geico has to offer." And that's what he's going to do.
Again, speaking to the agents that are leaning forward, these are the adjustments that we have to be able to make.
Okay, I want to come full circle back to the original thought here, around producers and their brand. We have a few minutes left and I want to be respectful of your time. But I do want to come back to this idea. I've gotten in trouble multiple times for saying this from both carrier reps. This is a very brief tangent. This was a while ago, in fairness. I was doing a presentation in Illinois at the Illinois State Association meeting. This is maybe like seven years ago. I did my content marketing keynote. A producer raised his hand. He said, "Ryan, this is great, but what if your agency won't allow you to do this stuff?" I looked at him and I said, "Well, maybe it's time to find a new agency."
And this carrier rep—again, fat old white guy, and again I'm not hating on old white guys, they just tend to be grumpy, and that's who I get yelled at the most, more than anyone else in my life, I get yelled at by old overweight white guys—he comes boom, boom, boom. As soon as I'm done, I can just see him. He's got beef. He's coming hard. "You don't understand. That's not how this industry works. You can't be doing that. Think about what'll be happening if producers are just moving around and all the..." Blah, blah, blah. I just looked at him and I go, "I don't know what to tell you, man. I don't have a lot of sympathy for the agency owner. I have sympathy for the guy who's trying to feed his family and his agency owner is telling him he can't do everything that he can to make money." He looked at me and he's just like, "You don't get it." I just said, "That's fine, dude. It's good."
He was upset and he wanted to let me know that I did not know what I was talking about. In the back of my mind, I was like, "Bro, there will come a day when producers are hired guns, when they don't sign non-competes or the non-competes that they do sign are not as strict as they are today." I wouldn't sign a non-compete today. I wouldn't. If Rogue falls apart and I need to go find a job as a producer with someone else, I wouldn't sign a non-compete. I just wouldn't. Because I don't trust anybody. I don't know that anyone should trust the future of their family and their livelihood completely to someone else and give them free reign to say, "I can treat you like garbage because for two years after you leave here, you can't actually do what you know how to do." That to me is an antiquated idea.
It puts the agency owner in jeopardy. I am firmly aware of that. But the other side of the coin is if you hire right, if you incentivize properly, if you support, if you give people a path to—I don't know, ownership in the agency, but maybe some sort of shadow profit sharing, maybe just in their own book as a percentage. There's all kinds of ways you can incentivize a producer to align their long-term interests with your long-term interests. That's not easy. I am not saying that's easy. So no one send me DMs going, "You don't understand." I get it. That's not an easy thing. But I'm saying super talented producers should think twice about signing non-competes. I just think they should. It's a dangerous game. You are giving up way more than leadership is giving up. You just are. That's the way it is. I'm not saying you did anything wrong because I've signed them too, but that is my position.
And as a leadership, you're like, "Shit, I want a 10-year non-compete. How do I make it so that you've got to give me your income no matter what you do for the rest of your life?" I get that as a good business owner, that's what you're trying to do. I just don't know that I'll be able to do it because I've been toasted too many times by them. I think it immediately creates a combative nature between the producer and ownership because in the back of their mind, they know that agency owner can say no to anything and there's nothing they can do because for two years, they can't do their job.
Tracy Cotton
I get that. I think you're right about that. But one of the things that I was sitting there thinking as you were talking is going back to your experiences with the Murray Group. They did start to see that you were making a difference. As long as you don't get too popular, right?
You know, that point I get, but I soften a little bit about where I know that I'm at personally. It's been rewarding to recognize that they finally went, "Oh, well, Tracy actually did know what she was talking about." And that's not all there is to it. I don't need an atta girl every time I do anything. I just recognize that sometimes you have to kind of show that it does work because they aren't seeing it anywhere else.
Now they're starting to see it from other places too. I'm not the only one standing out in the middle of a desert going, "I think this is going to work." They also see that it's working for other agencies. And I hate that it took that for them to necessarily go, "We'd really like to get some videos done. When can we do that? Would you like to blog and put some more stuff on our website? Because we think that we could actually get some..." I know that because I know where my stuff usually falls on a page, even years later, it shows up.
But sometimes you do have to expect that there's going to be a little bit of, "Okay, we don't want to give you a whole lot for this right now. We're not really ready to fund this whole project right off the bat. We kind of need to see where it's going." And you might also need to recognize that this person may not have really gotten there quite yet. They might need to learn a little bit about it. Obviously, neither one of us were very good at the very beginning, and I'm still not an expert by any means, but it's taken me a long time to feel more comfortable. That person may need to go through that a little bit before they could actually...
But at the same time, I just don't want anybody to be held back by an agency that is just afraid to let them fly when it's really the right thing for them to do. So they may need to prove themselves a little bit, and do the work. Doing the work is definitely not something you get to skip. 100%. Yes.
Ryan Hanley
And so the other side of the coin is this is not carte blanche for some 24-year-old millennial trophy recipient to assume that they should be given equity in an agency that they have nothing to build. That's not the case that I'm making. I think there is a whole other side to this coin. If we had another hour we could do it, because the truth is I made a lot of very poor decisions at the Murray Group. As much as there were things that were misaligned from their side, it was a good place to work. But I also made a lot of poor decisions and I communicated very poorly as well, what my goals were and what my expectations were. So that was a learning experience, I think, across the board.
But the point is that established producers, established employees who are hungry — we're not talking about every producer should have these types of things. I'm talking about your good people, your people who you can build an agency around. I don't know that tethering them contractually is the best method anymore because they have so many options. The internet, social media, IAOA, Cass's mastermind, and all these other groups give all of us so much exposure to what else is available. I just don't know that contractually tethering your rock stars in a combative nature to your business is going to long-term create the best solution. That's probably the best way that I can articulate what my position is.
Tracy Cotton
As always, fantastic. Now I've got content to go make. You've given me work to do. Mission accomplished. I can't wait to see this video walkthrough thing. I mean, you can do a whole landing page about it. There's so much you can do. It's awesome. And it's that kind of stuff that just continues to separate you and your bubbly winning disposition that is irresistible. How anyone can choose not to buy insurance from you is beyond me. If I had a farm, you would insure it. I wouldn't even insure it through my own agency. I'd send it to you.
Thank you so much for your time. Where can people connect with what you're doing? You mentioned the website, but just hit them with it again, your LinkedIn or whatever. Let people know where they can connect with you.
Ryan Hanley
I'm on everything. Instagram is EntsWiseTracy. I have Tracy L. Cotton. And then of course, I still have InsuranceWiseTracy.com. It's a website that I'm not really doing anything right now with just because I wanted to kind of hang on to it. But I recognize that I may need to develop more behind the agency. And I'm cool with that too. That's what's going to help us both. That's what I'm going to do.
Tracy Cotton
Yeah, cool. All right, well, podcast. There's a podcast. Yeah, yeah. And what? So how do they get at the podcast? What are they... Protect and Grow. And it is available on Apple and almost any place else that you can listen to podcasts.
Ryan Hanley
I love that name. That's a great name. Okay, well, thank you so much. You are wonderful and I appreciate you and I'm glad that we got to spend some time together and just be good. I will... you take care.
Tracy Cotton
Thank you. You go fuck yourself with your fat fucking ass. Do you want to have a few drinks and smoke a joint, Bubbles? Yes.
Both laugh
Ryan Hanley
Take it easy, baby.
Ad break begins
Narrator
Close twice as many deals by this time next week. Sound impossible? It's not. With the One Call Close System, you'll stop chasing leads and start closing deals in one call. This is the exact method we use to close 1,200 clients in under three years during the pandemic. No fluff, no endless follow-ups, just results fast. Based in behavioral psychology and battle-tested, the One Call Close System eliminates excuses and gets the prospect saying yes more than you ever thought possible. If you're ready to stop losing opportunities and start winning, visit masteroftheclose.com. That's masteroftheclose.com. Do it today. Thank you.