Podcast Episode Summary
The podcast episode features an in-depth conversation between the host, Ryan, and his guest, Mike McDonough, also known as the "Work Comp Renegade." The main topic of the episode is Mike's approach to providing value to his clients in the workers' compensation industry.
Key Points:
Takeaways:
Participants:
Recommendations:
Became a Master of the Close: https://masteroftheclose.com
Mike McDonough, the Work Comp Renegade, also known as "Maverick Mike," joins the podcast to break down his philosophy on Workers Comp as well as what it takes to be the best at what you do. Get more: https://ryanhanley.com.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Episodes You Might Enjoy:
Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.
Ryan Hanley
Hello everyone and welcome back to the show. Today is an episode for all my true player pimps out there, for all of you looking to go real deep on a product, on a niche, just become not just an expert, but the expert, the go-to source, the problem solver, the person that doesn't just stop their level of expertise at whatever the latest training is, but takes that training, applies it, and comes up with their own philosophy and process for doing what we do at the highest level.
My guest is Mike McDonough. He's the Work Comp Renegade, and you want to dial in on this episode. Before we get there, I'm going to save the advertisement and just say, I love you for listening to this show. Thank you for listening to this show. If you enjoy these episodes, if you're enjoying the two episodes a week cadence, tell a friend, share an episode, hit the retweet button on Twitter, maybe go over to iTunes, leave me a rating and review. That just helps more people in our business who are looking for resources find this show and hopefully do their business better, enjoy their business more, connect with people who can help them get where they're going. That's really why I do the show. I just want to connect you with people that can help you or help your agency or help someone you know. I just want to say thank you.
All right, guys, let's get to Mike McDonough. The way that you approach your business with both passion and a bit of panache and also expertise, I think that mashup is just interesting to me regardless. But really, you had the episode with David, which everyone who's listening to this should go back. I'll make sure that's linked up or just go to Carothers Power Producers podcast and listen to the episode you did because I thought it was awesome. I don't necessarily want to spend a ton of time in your background because I think that episode did a tremendous job of telling your story, how you got to this spot. I agree.
But what I'm really interested in, just in general, is at a high level the idea of taking it from where everyone else is. There's kind of how everyone else approaches their work, and we could even talk comp specifically, but just in general, and then some people take a step further. I feel like you have gone to the point of pure expertise. You really know you have a defined process that you've spent time whittling away at to deliver a product in a very thoughtful way. It's not just like someone told you how to do it and you're executing a plan. You've really spent time. How do you get to that place? That's what I'm really interested in because I think specifically from the comp side, this is how I'm growing my business. I find it tremendously interesting. I love being a value provider. I hate being associated in any way mentally with being just quoting. I just don't like that. I like providing value. So I'm on this path. So specifically to comp, it makes sense. But I think in general, if someone was really interested in property, I feel like they have a lot to learn from you as well. Does that make sense what I'm asking you?
Mike McDonough
100%. And I can give you my spin on that because I see it on a daily basis what the issue is and where the disconnect is for most brokers.
Ryan Hanley
Let's go. Tell me.
Mike McDonough
Between workers comp and the other lines of insurance, there's a huge disconnect. I don't think anybody's identified it. I did identify it. And that's where I've been able to make a difference. But it's not just about learning something. It's like, if you're going to be good at it, look at Brady, right? Look at Tom Brady.
Ryan Hanley
Yeah.
Mike McDonough
He took it to a whole nother level, didn't he? And that's really what it's about. So do you want to just write insurance and place policies? Do you want to have a little bit of knowledge or do you really want to knock it out of the park? And really, it's not about the workers comp and all that stuff. It's about you're here helping people. You're here to provide solutions. If you provide the solutions, you're going to get paid, and you're going to get paid a lot. There's going to be a lot more people who want your solutions. So that's really what I've done.
Ryan Hanley
So here's what I'll say. I think that wherever you want to start, you start because I want to see where you take it. I'll guide from there, but that disconnect that you're talking about, I feel like most people don't even take the step to learn it. Most people don't even take that step.
Mike McDonough
Correct.
Ryan Hanley
There's then the next gear. So you do take the time, you go get the certification or whatever. There's plenty of CICs that still struggle to sell. So why? Take me through that thought process. How do you keep making those jumps, those leaps forward?
Mike McDonough
As far as any certification, even that doesn't really put you at the level. It helps. It shows that you took another step that maybe somebody else wasn't willing to take. So any program that you can do to better yourself, I'm always for, and it's always going to move you in the right direction.
What I've seen in workers' comp compared to all the other lines of insurance is the huge disconnect. If there's an auto accident, you have them call the insurance company, car goes to the body shop, car's fixed in 10 days, get the car back, no injuries, claim closed. Homeowners, there's a water leak, they fix the water, water damage, new carpet, new floor, whatever it happens to be, claim closed. But when you get to workers' comp, or even in general liability, somebody slips and falls and breaks their leg, it's a liability claim. The insurance company paid $150,000, claim closed.
What happens is that brokers, in their minds, they're not claims examiners, which they're not. We're not trained claims examiners. We're here to sell the product. But what I see is that you can't treat workers' comp like an auto claim, like a home claim, or like a liability claim. You're dealing with a human being. You're dealing with injuries. You have to get involved. If you just turn it over to the insurance companies and let the claims examiner handle it, you're basically letting some person you have no relationship with deal with your client who you signed up for their insurance. Now their claims examiner is doing things, and every claims examiner is different. You're introducing somebody that your client doesn't even know. They're talking to a stranger.
More importantly, if you get an injured worker and they really don't know the system, they're talking to a stranger. It just makes the claim situation a little more difficult, and the employee gets really uncomfortable. There's a lot more delays in workers' comp because there is medical treatments. There has to be approvals for certain tests like MRIs, or if you have to go and have to do physical therapy, or there's a certain prescription drug. Everything has to be approved. Those are all delays.
If you as the broker turn it over to the insurance company and think you've done your job, the injured worker is lost in the system and your employer client is lost in the system. They don't really know who to turn to. Everybody just thinks the claims examiner is doing their job, and that's the furthest thing from the truth. What I've realized by digging deep into the weeds, Ryan, is that I've learned how workers' comp claims are processed. I've learned where the hidden costs are.
You want to get back to David Carruthers. The guy's a master at this when it comes to cost of risk. He's absolutely 150% correct. Most employers just think that they look at their balance sheet, the cost of doing business, they look at their annual premiums. The annual premium is part of it, but the hidden cost, the cost of risk, is really in the indirect cost: loss of production, time off work, retraining, using staffing agencies, whatever you have to do to keep your business running. There's additional cost. In addition to that is the unseen cost that because the claim is out of control, it's driving the cost of the claim up, which in essence drives the mod up. There's a lot of moving parts in this thing.
To really understand workers comp, you need to understand the cost of risk. Forget premiums. Premiums are important, but what's really driving the cost is understanding your client's business, setting up proactive programs, getting into loss control. David will go in and ask, "Who's your safety advisor?" He asks all the different questions, and people normally don't have those positions in place. Those are all the things that drive workers' comp claims.
The disconnect is that brokers and agents think that it's just the insurance company and the claims examiner's job. In my agency, we handle an auto claim just like we handle a work comp claim. We don't ever refer our clients to strangers. We will interact and we will always introduce. Whatever it takes, before they call the body shop, we let the body shop know they're coming. If they're going to a doctor's office, we don't ever want our clients dealing with strangers because that's where they get upset. If you're not providing the service, Ryan, that's why people are going to the internet looking for cheaper auto insurance, home insurance. If the broker is not really providing any service, why not find one that does?
Ryan Hanley
This idea of don't let your clients deal with strangers is a hard one for me. Not hard like I think you're wrong, but it's something that I actually have started. When I launched my agency, one of the core ideas was I wanted to partner, knowing that I was a bootstrapping startup agency, single person. I was not coming into this with a stack of cash that I could have a service person. I was doing it by myself. So one of the core ideas was partnering with carriers that had best-in-class customer care centers or service centers. I'm talking about like a Cincinnati or a Hanover. Those are my number one and number two carriers just for that reason.
The idea was if I can work closely with them so it feels very much like a seamless experience, then that allows me to focus on being an advisor, selling, finding new clients, working with clients, and delivering services. I didn't have to worry about things like managing people, setting up all those systems, because I had the carriers backing me up. In practice, I have found, and I've said this on the podcast before, Cincinnati's service center is tremendous. It is essentially like having someone sitting behind me when one of them interacts with my clients. I've gotten nothing but positive feedback from the clients after I've called them and said, "Hey, how was your experience?" Nothing but positive feedback.
That being said, the deeper I get into the business and now that I'm starting to work with some larger, maybe call them smaller middle market clients, that does not feel like the best way to do business. If I have a $500 BOP, not that that person should not get a grade A experience from me, but that feels like the type of interaction where... I will say I'm starting to question this philosophy, not because I think the service centers do a bad job, at least some of the ones that I partner with, but I really do believe that in order for us to be successful in the future, this is the path that you are describing. The automation path is the other path, but you really have to be one way or the other. You have to be all digital, everything is automation, low touch, and be the best at that version. Or you need to go high touch, service, and anything in the middle is going to get the crap beat out of them. That's where my mind is.
Mike McDonough
I think you're correct on both fronts. Somebody with a $500 BOP, and I have the philosophy that I don't care if it's $500 or $500,000, a policy, a customer is a customer. You do have to realize that there's cost involved, so you want to make sure you're spending your money wisely. But if you're going to use a service center like that and you believe in them, that's fine. You don't need to interact with the client every time. But when you're signing a client up, you can let them know that as part of our services, we're connected to this service center. We use them primarily because of the services they provide, and that's where we like to steer most of our clients. Is that okay with you? It's not up to your decision. It's up to the client.
When you sign on a new client, it's like, how do you want to be served? Do you like text? Do you like email? Do you like phone call? Think of it as a five-star restaurant. When they walk in the door, the maitre d' says, "Can I get you anything?" And that's how insurance needs to be as well. If you get your clients, they expect that kind of service. We don't get involved in every aspect of it. I'm just saying that we keep transparency with our clients so that they understand the process so they don't get confused. If they do get confused, they know who to turn to. Does that make sense?
Ryan Hanley
It does. No, it makes complete sense.
Mike McDonough
If you listen to Gary Vee, he says the people that are the Jetsons are the ones that are going to lose. The ones that are the Flintstones are going to win. What he's basically saying is that touch with the client. There's a niche and there is a part for tech. But when it comes down to a middle market business owner that has 100 employees, they have benefits, they've got HR, they've got moving parts, manufacturing, truck drivers, cost of risk, you need to go in there and give them the best program possible to be successful in their business. Being that expert on safety, bringing in that HR component, knowing that labor attorney that can help. In other words, I've surrounded myself with expertise in all the other areas. They don't work for me, they're not on my payroll, but they're part of my resources. My clients see me as the person they go to. I have people call me and ask me the simplest stuff because it's just like, "Hey, Mike's always steered me the right way." It's about giving that extra touch.
If you look at David's book, *The Two Minutes*, it's the same thing. We're in the business to solve problems. That's what we're paid to do. We're not paid to place policies. You and I know we can go to any grammar school right now and get kids out of kindergarten and teach them how to go online and place a work comp policy. There's the payroll, here's this and that, boom, you get a quote. That's the last piece. It's looking at the culture, meeting with that business owner. Ryan, when I walk into an account, and David knows this too, when you look at a mod that's 150, that tells me probably 20 different things. It's not just they've had claims. It's not just there's frequency. It's not that they've had a severity. It tells me they have a culture problem. It tells me they probably have a hiring problem.
I bet you, 95% of the time when their mod's over 100, I sit down with them. "Can I see your safety manual?" Don't have one. "Are your IIPP logs up to date?" "What are those?" "Let me see your employee handbook." "Let me see all these different things." When's the last time you did a training? "Well, we haven't done one in over a year." "Okay, so what are your hiring practices? Are you following the handbook? I see here in your handbook you have disciplinary actions for this. How often are you writing up employees for infractions?" "Oh, but here's what happened..."
So many employers today are so stressed out about making money, which we all are. But what happens is they would rather keep a bad employee on the books than fire them because they know it takes a lot more time and money to retrain that person. In reality, that employee is going to cost them more in the long run than it is to let them go and retrain and hire somebody. If they're not following their own handbook and they're not writing people up, those are the ones that eventually are going to file the work comp claim. They're going to come back and they're going to cost you a lot of money. There's a lot of things to identify.
Ryan Hanley
I was just getting back into the business and really, I was a policy placer the first eight years. I educated, I'd say my value proposition was over educating all the YouTube videos and that kind of stuff. But in terms of like a real tactician, I just wasn't there yet. I hadn't evolved into that place. That's very much where I'm going now. I'm starting to have higher level discussions with bigger companies that have more dynamic things going on.
I was walking them through just some of the basics of comp and some of the basic ideas. The guy's going, "Yeah, you know, we just kind of, they just kind of tell me if something happens." Because I was asking him, "How do you file a claim? Like, how does that look like? If someone gets hurt, what happens? Just walk me through." I was just trying to ask a high level question to get him talking about his process. Here's a guy who's got a mod over one. He's paying $200,000 for comp and he just would work under the assumption that it just was what it was. "Hey, that's just what it is, man. You just do this and they come in, they get hurt sometimes and try not to get them hurt. You know, we want to be safe." He's just saying stuff like that. I was like, "Whoa." You would look at this business from the outside and think these guys have everything together. It was obvious with the first question that that was not the case.
Mike McDonough
That brings up a good point. I actually talked about that in my book. The myth for the employers is that it's mandatory that we carry the coverage. The insurance companies have control over the premiums. It's based upon my payroll. I have claims, my rates go up, and that's the way the system is. That's the furthest thing from the truth. That client that you're mentioning right now is part of that myth. Then somebody like yourself that comes in that knows, you say, "Are you open to a second opinion? Let me show you." You do what David teaches. You pull out the mod. You go over the last one. You pull out the reasons why the mod is the way it is. Then you start backtracking. "Let me see your loss control. Let me see your safety manual." They don't have these things. "Let me see your hiring practices."
Once an employer knows that they can do certain things to reduce their cost of insurance, and I'm not talking premiums, the cost of their insurance which is the cost of the risk, is by having... because basically, the best claim is no claim, and the second best claim is a closed claim. But these claims that stay open with ongoing medical treatments and indemnity going up and reserves going up and then surgery, and then in different states the attorneys get involved and these things get drawn out. The work comp system is a moneymaker for everybody except for the employer.
As advisors, we want to identify the costs: cost of risk, indirect costs, premiums, everything. Everything comes together, but the employer doesn't need to understand workers' comp. They only need to understand the points of, "I have an injury, I record it right away, and I need somebody that knows more than me that can help me through the process, help me reduce my costs." They don't need to necessarily teach me all about workers' comp, but they're there as a strategic partner that I know that I can trust is looking out for the best interests of my business. That's really what every employer is looking for. It's what you and I look for from anybody that we're using for our business. You want an IT person that's going to be helpful and reasonable and charge fair rates and not take advantage of your ignorance.
I see a lot in workers' comp is that there's a lot of advantage taking of the ignorance of the employers. Once the employer understands that they can control their costs, and like David shows them on the balance sheet, and you're showing them the true cost, that wakes them up. Especially if you show them over a three-year period, "Look, you spent $72,000 extra in workers' comp that you didn't need to spend had you done these things." That wakes people up. That's really all we're doing. We're providing solutions to problems. In workers comp, there's big problems. So you can see that it's not an auto accident. It's not a slip and fall. It's not a water claim or a theft out of a car claim. You're dealing with human beings. You're dealing with doctors. You're dealing with legal. There's a lot of things going on there that the employer is not aware of, and they don't have the time.
Now with COVID, you've got another thing to worry about because now you've got additional compliance, another HR issue. They're bombarded with compliance. You can come in, and Ryan, I applaud you for the courses you've taken because you've taken a bigger step than probably 90% of the brokers out there. You've already seen that in order to get where I need to go, I have to be better at my game. You went outside, and you're bringing in people that know more than you, just like I have. I continually bring more people that know more than me. I am always about hiring people smarter than me that know more than me because that's how I learn. I'm not afraid to ask questions. I'm not afraid to say I don't know something.
When I get around somebody like you guys were at that table in San Diego, I could tell you guys wanted to learn. You guys were like sponges. Look at Cass. Cass is writing these big, he's landing these big whales now, right? By getting associated with David Carruthers and learning from people like myself and you and everybody else in the industry. That's what I love about IAOA. We're all connected and helping one another. There's no egos here. There's no about hiding secrets. We're all just open books. That's what I appreciate about this program.
Ryan Hanley
I have to second everything you said. When I first got in the business 15 years ago, looking at the difference in widespread openness from then to now makes me very happy, makes me very bullish on the industry. Because today, you can pick up the phone and call somebody, and obviously as long as you're respectful of their time, and ask them questions about how they developed an expertise or how they approach a certain aspect of their business. There's a very good chance that they're going to give you that time and literally just say, "Here's exactly what I do. Here is how I solve that problem." I don't know that it has always been that way, but it is definitely groups like IOA and others. Cass's group is another great example where they've just developed these cultures where you just share exactly how you do the thing. There's no, "Well, this is my little secret that I'm going to cut out because I don't want you to know it because that makes me less valuable." There's just too much business for that to be the case.
The other side of it is, and I learned this from doing keynote speaking, most people just are never going to do the work. They're just never going to do the work. Within two days of this going live, 500 people will have listened to it. I bet one takes action on what you said. Maybe one.
Mike McDonough
100% agree.
Ryan Hanley
It's why it's so exciting to be on. It's why I love doing this show. You do stuff, you take action, you make things happen. Being able to associate with those people just elevates you, even if you can't do that thing right at that moment. This is kind of where I want to take this conversation. Some of the stuff that you've talked about is high level stuff: injury management, experience modification work, massaging culture, helping define roles, hiring stuff. That feels like a lot of really big bites. At the beginning, when you were first starting to develop your process, what were a few of the items that, or even if you're giving advice to someone like myself who's getting started, what are some of the first bites into this that you could take to be a value provider where you don't have to have 20 years of expertise?
Mike McDonough
Great, great, great question. You have to start somewhere. The first work comp policy that you write, the first claim that you get, just make sure that you don't just turn it over to the insurance company. If you're going to report the claim because it's reportable, engage with it. Find out right away. Tell your client, "Call in the claim. When you get the claims information, including the claim number, please share that with me. Then I will be in contact with your claims examiner." Once you get it from XYZ carrier, you get their name, their email address. You just send them a quick note: "Hey, I'm the broker for XYZ company and I would like to be kept in the loop on this claim." They will actually teach you. They don't mind teaching if you get a good examiner. You might get somebody that's younger and maybe been around a couple of years, but you get a seasoned veteran that's been around 15, 20 years, they love sharing their knowledge.
When they say, "Okay, well we're going to do this and I'm going to set this up or I'm going to put the claim on delay," whatever, you can just say, "Hey, could you please explain to me why you want to delay the claim?" And they'll explain it to you. Or, "We're going to deny the claim." As you start hearing that, that's what I did. Way back when, I used to do pretty much the same thing. I would treat insurance pretty much the same way. Of course I always tried to add value adds, but you can't really do it in the property and the GL. I mean, you can't do a degree. But I was on a claim with a claims examiner and she said something that didn't sound right. I asked her a question, which made me start looking things up and asking more questions. That's really how I got started. I just started getting involved in claims.
Then what I did is I hired somebody that knew claims management. I had that person teach me as well along the way. Here I'm paying a third party and we're working together. She's explaining to me why she's making the decision. She started introducing me to defense attorneys. It was an outside source that I decided to hire because I figured I don't know the claims. I don't know enough. So I hired somebody with 20 years experience that did know the claims. I started noticing the impact that she was making right off the bat with my claims. The reserves, the mods were going down. Claims were closing faster. It's like, "You know what? I want more of this." I got to the point where I wanted to learn as well. I've been able to learn it as well as some of them. But I have a 25-year claims manager, and she knows claims inside and out. I'll never be at her level. But I don't need to be at her level. I know enough just to talk to an employer that's having a lot of pain.
To answer your question, you have to start somewhere. Start getting engaged from the first claim that you have. I'm assuming there's two types of agencies, right?
There's the agencies that probably want to be involved, but don't necessarily know what to do with a lot of this stuff when it comes in, or it's more just transactional. And then there's the agencies that aren't even tracking the claims and are just, here's the company phone number.
I always think it's funny, the page everyone has on their website with the name of the company and then the phone number to the claims department. That page has always made me feel weird. I'm not saying it's wrong because I know some people do it for Saturdays and Sundays, or maybe they're not there and they want to give their customers a resource. But at the same time, that page has always made me feel weird because it feels very disconnected versus the classic agency value proposition. Then you just have this page listed with phone numbers where you're completely bypassed in the process of handling the claim to begin with.
That's where the cost of controlling the claim starts. Most agencies that I'm aware of, when an injury is called in, they call it right into the carrier. If you notice, some of the carriers now offer a triage. The reason they offer a triage is because it does serve two things. It does give you immediate attention where you're talking to an occupational nurse. But the insurance company, why would they offer a free triage service included in their program? Because they want you reporting everything. Why? Because it goes to NCCI or, in California, the Bureau.
My clients have my own triage. The reason I set that up is not to not report claims. It's to mitigate the number of claims that go to the carrier that shouldn't have to go there. If somebody just bumps their arm and you get on with a triage nurse and the triage nurse says, "Go home, self-care, ice it, maybe take an ibuprofen. If you're not feeling better tomorrow, then we'll send you to the clinic." A lot of those never go to the clinic. That claim never has to be reported. 60% of our claims that come in through my agency are never reported to the carrier because of the triage.
If the injury does go to the point where they go to the medical clinic and there are some work restrictions, by rule, now you have to report that injury. However, we've already talked to the employer. We've seen the work restrictions from the doctor. Can't lift more than 10 pounds, no bending, stooping more than 30 minutes, whatever the situation is. The employer says they can accommodate. Now, when we report it to the insurance company, we're going to say, "So-and-so has restrictions. We're going to accommodate these restrictions. It's medical only." What we're telling the insurance company is do not set up an indemnity because we have a return to work program. We're offering modified duty and the injured worker's medical bills will be paid through the carrier.
We're not just having the employer call on a claim blindly to an insurance company where the insurance company doesn't know where the claim is going to go. They're automatically going to set up an indemnity and a medical reserve, which ultimately affects them all.
Ryan Hanley
Right.
Mike McDonough
That's why when we say we want to control the injury from the get-go, that's why we want to use triage. That's why we want them to engage with our agency versus the carrier first. The carrier is the support, but really, you're the main support because that's why the client hired you as their professional, the expert that knows workers' comp. Your whole job is to watch their money. If you just turn them over to an insurance company, you're not really watching their money. You want them to engage with your agency. If it doesn't need to be reported, it doesn't get reported. If it does, then you set it up.
We've trained our clients how to report those claims so that when they do get set up, within two to three weeks, we request the loss runs, we get a copy, and we make sure it's only set up with a medical-only reserve. There's nothing there for indemnity. If there is, we call the carrier and question it and have them remove it.
Ryan Hanley
Are you taking on any liability by having that triage service in terms of, say, the triage nurse does say, "Ice it, whatever." Three days later, the employee comes back, and now maybe they've been working through pain, there's an injury, and now it's something worse. Is there any additional liability that you're taking on as an agency by operating in this way?
Mike McDonough
That's a good question. Obviously, if anything happened, they could absolutely name my agency. However, the triage in your agreement, they're the ones taking on the liability. They're the medical professional.
Ryan Hanley
Gotcha.
Mike McDonough
So we're doing our job by getting them to an occupational nurse that understands workers comp injuries right away. If they misdiagnosed it or something like that, then that's on the triage nurse. Can they name my agency? I'm sure they certainly could. I can tell you in the last 13 years, that's never happened.
On the flip side of that, the employer actually, by having a triage, is taking liability off their managers. For example, let's say I own a manufacturing company and I'm in Europe with my family. My general manager is running the company while I'm gone. Johnny or Susie gets injured and they come in and say, "Do you want to go see a doctor?" "I'm okay." "Okay, go ahead and get back to work." Then Johnny or Susie passes out and ends up in the hospital. That's a liability for an employer.
That's another reason it's twofold. The triage right then and there, think of it as the school nurse. Somebody falls down on the playground, they take them into the school nurse's office to assess the injury. If Johnny's too bad, they'll call mom or dad to come pick him up, take him to the doctor. Otherwise, they'll check him out. "Okay, you can get back to class." That's what triage does on an elementary level. It does a lot of things. It starts the data. The call is recorded, so the injured worker is giving their statement. The forms are being completed. It's doing a lot of things in the system.
Getting back to your question, could something happen? Yes. But the liability is on the triage. I haven't looked at it any further than that.
Ryan Hanley
Yeah, that makes sense. I kind of already knew the answer, but it's a good question. Our industry likes to ask those kinds of questions, and for good reason. So, what is the feasibility of a triage nurse for, let's take my agency. I'm starting to move into the middle market. Hiring a triage nurse full-time under Rogue is not an option for a couple of reasons. Are there ways, is this someone that you work to have a partnership with? Are there third party organizations that you could hire to do this kind of thing?
I'm sure that there are people listening who are absolutely bought into what you're doing. If they're interested in comp or interested in being value providers in general, they'd be crazy not to. But I'm also positive that if they're like me, they're going, "I don't know how to deliver those services based on where I'm at currently." In a future state, I can absolutely see myself getting there. But today, is it just do as much as you can with what you have? Are there third parties you can hire out for some of this stuff before you bring them in house? How would they start to source some of these pieces?
Mike McDonough
It's a great question. There's only a couple really good ones out there. One of the firms is probably one of the largest ones in the country. Their starting fee is like $7,500, which I know most smaller agencies can't afford. The firm that I use, because all my clients are on it, I get a discounted rate. If somebody wanted to start that, I'm happy to introduce them through my triage. Eventually when they build up enough, they can go out on their own. There's a one-time setup fee, which is minimal, and then there's no monthly fee. It's just pay as you go. If you use the service, you get a bill.
If there's an agency out there that needs triage or wants to consider triage, I'm happy to help them under my label. If they have four or five calls, we'll just send them a bill for those calls and that agency reimburses us. That way they can start getting the ball rolling in their agency. Once they start writing more workers comp, start taking on more injuries, and they can branch out on their own, we just release them. They can set up their own account.
When I started out, I made an agreement that I would get all my clients on the triage services. They gave me a break, so I get a wholesale break. I've been able to do that. That's how you would do it. Otherwise, if you want to go directly to the triage service, if anybody wants to PM me or email me, I'm happy to help them and put them in contact with the owners. They can see what they can work out. There's a little bit more upfront cost. If they can afford it, great. Otherwise, they can take the second option. I'm happy to help them do it.
Ryan Hanley
No, that's great. I appreciate making that offer to the audience. I'm probably going to want to talk to you offline about some of that stuff too. So we've talked a lot about comp and about tactical insurance stuff, which I could ask a thousand more questions about. But there's a whole other piece to what you do that the sales and marketing guy in me finds incredible. I just want to talk through the Work Comp Renegade, the brand, the idea of it, how you've put it together.
I've seen Comp Shield and things like that. Whoever has Comp Shield, it's not a knock. That's a very kind of classic insurance risk management based branding for a product or process. Nothing wrong with that. You went with Work Comp Renegade and you have two samurai swords in your logo. I love it. I'm super interested in why so bold? Why did you go that direction versus something a little more traditional?
Mike McDonough
That's a great question. I didn't come up with the name. Doing what I've done over all these years, engaging my clients, having them attend depositions. The purpose of that is that the employer gets to see the defense attorney that's representing them to see if they're asking good questions, if they're actually working on their behalf. They see their 15-year employee on the other side of the table lying under oath. Then they see that there's no legitimate injury. The employee was let go for cause and decided to hire an attorney and file a work comp claim. The employer is paying out a $15,000 settlement.
After seeing that multiple times, an employer gets really hardened with the system. They become cynical just like everybody else in the system. When they see their hard earned money going out to a system that's broken, they basically said to me one day, "You know what, Mike? There has to be a revolt." I said, "I'm working on that."
In reality, what I am is an advocate. When they hire me as their representative, when that claim is first called into triage, and we're looking at the work status report, we're accommodating injuries, we're reducing and eliminating indemnity. We have a staff that is bilingual, talking to the injured worker, and we're reducing litigation. Really, that's what we're doing. We're an advocate for the injured worker, making sure they're getting prompt medical attention, and at the same time, the employer's dollars are being watched step by step.
I was working on doing some marketing and this woman referred me to this guy that does copywriting out of Canada. He said, "Why don't you just send me a little bit of information about your business and what you do?" I gave him a couple of pages of what I did. He calls me up and we're talking about it. He goes, "I've never seen anything like this. Never heard of any broker ever doing anything like that. You're kind of like a renegade." I said, "Yeah, I kind of am." He came up with the name Workers Comp Renegade. We sent it out to a graphic artist and she came back with that logo.
I sent it out to a lot of people. I'd say eight out of ten, or 80 out of 100, most people liked the logo and said, "Yeah, I love it." I showed it to defense attorneys, claims examiners, people within the system. They said, "This is awesome. You got to go with it." That's why I kept that logo. I kept the name. People understand that when they see what I do, they say, "You are the renegade." It's kind of taken off from there.
Ryan Hanley
I think it's tremendous for all the reasons that it's memorable. It's obviously a pattern breaker, which is the big part for me. I think so much of the struggle that agents have on a day-to-day basis is they fit the pattern. They do not break the pattern of what people are expecting. Therefore, there's no clear delineation. Even if they are real value providers, their brand, the way they talk, the way they present themselves is so exactly what clients are expecting that they don't even give their time or attention to someone.
When I see two samurai swords and Workers Comp Renegade, you can't help but stop and go, even if I don't like this guy, there's something different. There's something I need to at least figure out what's going on here because this is so much different than what I would normally expect. For that reason alone, not to mention the fact that you have all the substance behind it, to me it's absolutely brilliant. The very first time I saw it, I was like, "This is awesome."
Mike McDonough
I appreciate that, Ryan. It means a lot to me, especially coming from you. I spend a lot of time on social media and perception is everything. But to your point, go back to that client that you said their model is over $100,000 and their premium is like $200,000. The agent that's handling that account now, you're taking the time to get certified, learn more, get people like me on a podcast, learning from people like David Carruthers. You are doing exactly what I did. You need to keep asking and keep engaging and creating your own network of resources to put yourself on that platform. That broker is eventually going to lose that account to either somebody like you, myself, David Carruthers, or Cass.
Let's ask the brokers out there, Broker Nation right now. What's holding you back? What conversations are you having? Are you not willing to take the steps to learn it? You don't have the time? You don't care? What's holding you back? What I'm doing, anybody else can do themselves if they're willing to take the time. You don't need to take it to the level I have. I chose to do this because I want to be at that authority, that expert platform. When I walk in, I could walk into a Fortune 500 company right now with my team and beat any of the largest brokers. Marsh, Aon, I don't care. I know their brokers aren't as educated into the workers comp. They haven't done the homework, the resource. I know every component. You can throw pretty much any question at me and I'll know pretty much the answer.
Just like David Carruthers has done with his killing commercial. That guy knows commercial insurance inside and out. Why? He took the time. He said that his grocery retail set the stage for him in insurance. He already had that customer service. You have to be in customer service to be in our industry. If you're not into people, you're not into customer service, you can make decent money at this. You're just going to keep churning. I can't tell you the last time a client left my agency.
Ryan Hanley
To answer your question that was in there about why most brokers don't do this level of work, I think there's two reasons. One, the bar has been set so low for so long that it doesn't feel... I don't even know that people necessarily know what's possible. I think conversations like this, what Cass is doing on his podcast, the people that are on Carruthers' podcast, now that there are these podcasts and people like yourself are sharing their ideas, I think there are more people waking up to what's possible. For a long time, it was just, "This is what we do. This is how we do it. You try to get a good market, you try to wedge your way in."
The other side of it is, I knew I wanted to learn these things so I could be better. That has cut into some of my time selling and prospecting for the last three or four weeks. I know that's going to snap forward 10,000% in the next months. But even putting in that amount of time, I think people get scared. They get that scarcity mindset. "Oh my God, I'll never be able to find the clients." They just never do it because if you don't do it, you have an excuse forever as to why it didn't happen. If you put in the work and you don't make it happen, now that's real failure. I think that scares the crap out of people, and that's why they don't do it.
Mike McDonough
There's a lot of reasons, and I agree with everything you said. Everybody is different. The brokerages don't have to learn it to where I have. However, a lot of these larger agencies have staff and account managers that will contact the insurance company to look at the reserves and all these other things. They're doing a lot of the right things, but that's not really where you're going to save the money. Those things help. But if you really don't understand the other components, you need to understand it from the time the injury is reported until the time the injured worker is released to full duty.
There are brokers out there that can hire claims people. In your town right there, when you get to that level, Ryan, you can go to any of the insurance carriers and find a claims examiner. She's been there for 20 years. She doesn't like working for the carrier anymore and she wants to be your full-time claims kid. There's ways you can do this. In life, whatever you want to do, we can make happen.
On a simple scale, if you write two $50,000 workers comp premiums a month, just two a month over 24 months, and you're getting 15% commission, that's $180,000 in revenue just from 24 policies. Cut that in half, do a $25,000 policy, whatever number you want to use. If you write the workers comp, you do it right, you get the other lines of business. If you really want to triple, quadruple your income, workers comp, cost of risk, getting the other lines of insurance and just being solution-based minded, you're going to have a bigger agency than you ever dreamed of.
Ryan Hanley
Mike, I want to be respectful of your time. I appreciate this. It's been tremendous. I could talk to you for another hour about this stuff. That just gives me another reason to invite you back on the show sometime in the future. I appreciate you sharing so much. We're slowly getting to know each other a little bit, and I'm glad for that. I like what you do. I like the way you approach it. It's a pleasure. Thanks for sharing with the audience, man.
Mike McDonough
It means a lot to me, and it was my pleasure. I'm glad to help Broker Nation any way I can, IAOA members, and including yourself. We all just want to become better every day. We walk into our agencies trying to become better. Technology is moving, and we're all just trying to keep up with what's going on. There's no fault here. People will find their way. It just depends on what direction you want to go. If anybody wants to reach out to me, I'm happy to speak to anybody. Hopefully I can send you in the right direction, whatever direction you want to go with work comp.
Ryan Hanley
That's great, man. Thank you. Have a good one.
Mike McDonough
Thank you so much.
End of interview. The following appears to be an unrelated advertisement or outro from a different recording.
Ryan Hanley
Close twice as many deals by this time next week. Sound impossible? It's not with the One Call Close System. You'll stop chasing leads and start closing deals in one call. This is the exact method we used to close 1,200 clients in under three years during the pandemic. No fluff, no endless follow-ups, just results fast. Based in behavioral psychology and battle-tested, the One Call Close System eliminates excuses and gets the prospect saying yes more than you ever thought possible. If you're ready to stop losing opportunities and start winning, visit masteroftheclose.com. That's masteroftheclose.com. Do it today.