Podcast Episode Summary
The podcast episode features an in-depth conversation between Ryan Handley and Chris Baran, a renowned expert in the insurance industry. The main topic of discussion is the current state of the insurance market, with a focus on the hardening of the market, data, and agency valuations.
Key Points:
Takeaways:
Participants:
Recommendations:
Became a Master of the Close: https://masteroftheclose.com
Chris Burand, president of Burand Associates, a leading P&C insurance consultancy, joins the podcast for an incredibly deep discussion on the coming hard market, why we're insuring the wrong things and how "Clean Data" will play a major role in agency valuation over the next ten years. Get more: https://ryanhanley.com/
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Episodes You Might Enjoy:
Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.
Ryan Hanley
In a crude laboratory in the basement of his home. Hello everyone and welcome back to the show. It's great to have you here. I have a guest today, one of the smartest guys in our industry, someone who thinks about our business at a depth that many of us just can't reach because we're so busy running our agencies.
The fact that Chris Burand has the ability to deep dive into agency operations, valuations, E&O exposures, and all the education he does around lines of business, coverages, and obscure policy forms is incredible. I wanted to have Chris on the show for a while, even before he was on Cass's show, which is a great episode you should check out. It was such a pleasure having him on because I love nerding out on this business.
I think there are so many nuances to the insurance game and all the different places you can take it. When you can have an hour with someone like Chris, who thinks so deeply about the business, there's always going to be an incredible amount of value extracted. That's exactly what this episode is.
I'm Chris, you can get him at baran-associates.com. Everything will be linked up in the show notes. If you go to ryanhandley.com, you can check it out as well. We also talk about his education, which is baraneducation.com. I highly recommend you connect with Chris on LinkedIn and subscribe to his newsletter, which is tremendous. Just have him in your ecosystem. You will not be disappointed.
If you haven't already, make sure you subscribe to the show on iTunes, Spotify, Google Podcasts, wherever you listen. That's how you get all the new episodes delivered right to your phone or computer. And if you're feeling super froggy, head on over to iTunes and leave us a rating and review. It helps more people find this show, helps more sponsors find the show, and helps more guests find the show.
Finally, before we get to the actual episode, I want to give a shout out to today's sponsor, Agency VA. Agency VA is changing the game for me. We talk a little bit about VAs in this episode. I wanted to get Chris's take on VAs in general. He had some interesting thoughts.
I have a VA who's helping me with two aspects of my business. One, cleaning up my accounting and getting basic accounting processes taken care of, making sure commissions paid versus expenses going out are coordinated, itemizing expenses so I can better understand what I'm actually spending money on. As I've said on the show before, my accounting has been, "Is there more in my checking account than on my credit card?" As long as there was, I felt like I was doing okay.
Agency VA, Wes and Ben and their entire team, I have a part-time VA helping me with that. I have another individual helping me get my data squared away, my onboarding squared away, making sure all the information from my better agency and from different quotes is properly set up in my agency management system, along with some prospecting stuff. It's a game changer because it allows me to free up my time to prospect and sell. Put revenue on the books. That's the name of the game for me, and Agency VA is helping me do that.
If you're struggling in that spot, if you're feeling overwhelmed by the day-to-day tasks and not growing your business, stop what you're doing. Go to agencyva.com. Reach out. Talk to Wes, talk to Ben, talk to someone on their team. Get a feel for what a VA can do. I promise you, you will not be disappointed. If you set it up right and commit to the process, you are going to move your business forward. Agencyva.com. Tell them Hanley sent you.
Let's get on to Chris. The ruling just came out of Great Britain that a whole lot of COVID-19 related business income claims should have been paid and not denied. Let's start there. What does that mean? It's Great Britain, so does that actually mean anything to us other than just a judicial precedent? What are the ramifications for us? If all these claims start getting paid, it is a game changer in so many ways.
Chris Burand
For sure, yeah. There are a couple of things that could potentially come out. The ruling was literally just announced 20 minutes ago, so I don't have the details yet. One is it sets a precedent and causes people here to look a little deeper and wonder if they should be paid here. But depending on the scale of the claims the court says should have been paid in Great Britain, it could affect the reinsurance markets here. Without question. There's a direct, potentially a direct ramification to that ruling in the US.
Ryan Hanley
A lot of the legacy carriers in the United States have large sets of reserves of their own. But these insuretech carriers, the Lemonades, the Hippos, the Swifts, they have very small reserves in relation to how much they leverage reinsurance in their business. Could they be the most vulnerable to something like this if all of a sudden reinsurance rates are going through the roof or if reinsurers just start hopping off different contracts?
Chris Burand
Yeah, it could definitely create a problem for them without question.
Ryan Hanley
What are the ramifications of that down to a retail agency like mine? I've had agents say this to me before, mostly in jest, but there's always a hint of seriousness. They say, "That's interesting, but if I'm writing a $1,500 BOP, what does that really mean to me?" Does it trickle down that far to a Main Street retail agent where these global ramifications and reinsurers and catastrophe losses, at face value it sounds bad, but does it really impact us day to day?
Chris Burand
Yeah, it does. It truly does. I'll give you a great example on a homeowner's policy. I have a client who was complaining that a particular carrier wanted to get off these homeowner's policies that had never had any kind of a loss. Why? One of the reasons is because of the way the carrier's reinsurance contract works. You'll see actions that are potentially nonsensical on the surface. It's nonsensical to get off a homeowner's policy you've written for 10, 15, or 20 years that's never had a loss. Bridging what's actually happening behind the scenes with what's causing that action is sometimes really difficult for the retail agent to see. This is what happens when reinsurance markets change. You'll start seeing things like this. If you think it through or were lucky enough to have the data, you'd be able to see it all the way through and understand it.
Ryan Hanley
For a retail agent, my takeaway from that would be this is where having flexibility in your markets, access to markets, having the ability to pivot accounts from one market to another when things like this come up. This is where this is so valuable and maybe even plays into the valuation of an agency. If a carrier starts non-renewing your accounts and you don't have the ability to communicate with that client and move them to a new market, you're in trouble. You're going to start to lose business.
Chris Burand
You are. It's true. It's one of the funny things. We haven't really had a hard market since 2002, 2003. AIG said today that it was 2010, but I kind of disagree. I'd say it's 2002, 2003. That's a whole generation, Ryan. That's 20 years. People have lost the collective knowledge of how to use markets as you go through a market cycle. We haven't had one.
This is why every independent agent in America should always represent one of the top, most highly rated carriers. Those are the carriers that can bend and flex when times get tough. I had the CEO of one of these highly rated carriers ask me a couple of years ago, "Does anybody even care about our rating anymore? Do they care about the difference between an A++ and a B-?" In many cases, it had gotten to that point. But the market right now is such a phenomenal example. Every independent agent market should represent an A+ or multiple A+ rated carriers.
Ryan Hanley
Why is that? Explain it to me like I'm a fifth grader. Why does that matter? In my mind, I'm thinking carriers don't give two flying craps about me. All that matters is that I put this business on the books, that I get $250 so I can keep the lights on or put food on the table. Most agents are scrambling. It costs so much to get a piece of business that the last thing you're going to do is risk it by saying, "Hey, pay $250 more because this carrier is A++ and this one is B-." Even though you're guaranteed to have your claim paid because the state most likely has a fund that backs it up even if they go insolvent. And if the rate goes up, I'm just going to move you to someone else anyway. Why should I care if I'm a retail agent?
Chris Burand
Good question. One is that as a market hardens, those B- carriers are less likely to be able to write the account to begin with. It's not a matter of $250 more. You will have an opportunity to write it or you won't. A lot of the really highly rated carriers are less dependent on reinsurance. The differences can seem rather tiny. What's the difference between an A and A+ and an A++? But when you get to an A+, especially an A++, quite often the quality of their capital is superior, not just the amount of capital. They have flexibility in these marketplaces to do things that others won't have.
Ryan Hanley
By the quality of the capital, do you mean the institutions from which they're able to draw capital or the place where they have the capital that is safe, secure, stable, easily accessible if needed? Is that what you mean?
Chris Burand
Sort of. Quality of capital could be like one carrier has a whole bunch of their capital invested in junk bonds and another one has it in long-term US bonds. Which quality is better? Today, I don't know that that's an easy answer.
Ryan Hanley
I hear what you're saying. I know we're kind of nerding out on this, but I love this topic. This is all the stuff where you'll be at a conference and hear a carrier talk about these things. I would rather the listeners don't just gloss over these things because I do believe they're important. Even though we can re-rate people, everyone listening knows when you constantly have to re-rate someone because the carrier is getting off the market or they come in super low and then all of a sudden they're raked. You can blame that on the carrier, but if that's consistently happening because of the markets you're putting your business with, you start to look like the schmuck. For most of the relationships we have as independent agents, the carrier doesn't matter to the client. What matters is that the client believes you think it's a good carrier. If that carrier keeps jumping off, I'm trying to pair this for everyone who may not be following why these things are so important.
So they're in junk bonds which are highly volatile. You place the business with that carrier and they're in this volatile market as a way to place their capital. If that all of a sudden bottoms out, they may have had a hundred million dollars on the books that's now half as valuable. To equalize their quarterlies if they're public, they need to adjust rates or get off risks to minimize downside. Is that right?
Chris Burand
Yeah, they'll have to get off risk. It won't matter if it's risky risk or just plain risk. They'll just have to get off risk. For example, at the end of the first quarter, there's one carrier that literally lost a billion dollars in capital due to investments. A billion dollars is a lot for most anybody, so it makes a difference.
The other reason it matters, Ryan, and again we've lost the collective knowledge in many ways, is that historically these really highly rated carriers wouldn't grow very much during a soft market. But during the hard market, they would grow hugely. If an agent represented one of those carriers, they would grow hugely because they would have the only game in town writing new business. That's another reason why it does matter. I think it could matter in this marketplace today with the hardening of it.
Ryan Hanley
So you believe the market is hardening? By line of business?
Chris Burand
It's the weirdest hard market I've researched. I've researched hard markets back to the 1940s. This is the weirdest hard market I can find on the books because there's not a lack of capital. Hard markets are almost historically driven almost entirely by lack of capital. This one's not being driven by lack of capital. There's still plenty of surplus. It's that there isn't surplus in very specific lines of business, and there isn't adequate rate in very specific lines of business. It's very much by line of business as to how hard the market is or will become.
Ryan Hanley
What is the reason for seven-year consistent cycles, almost like clockwork? I remember when I first got in the business in 2007, we were a few years off of 2002. My father-in-law would tell stories, "You guys don't know what it was like." He was just busting our chops, but that was the way it was rolling into 2006, 2007. All you had to do was get someone's information and you were writing the account. There was always somebody cheaper. That's changed a little, but not really. You can kind of always find someone cheaper. It's been 20 years. Even 2010, I was still selling, and that didn't feel like a hardening. After everything that went on leading into the crisis, that felt more like a small correction because everything started going back down again. What has caused seven, seven, seven, and now we're looking at 20 years?
Chris Burand
That's a great question. There are a lot of reasons for it. One reason is that there's maybe better regulatory actions to keep carriers arguably more conservative in their reserving. That's helped some. But another reason that isn't being looked at very deeply is that insurance is less important today than it used to be. I've been trying to encourage carriers and brokers and everybody to wake up that it's not 1970s America, but our forms that we sell are based on 1970. They're not based on 2020.
I've got some diagrams based on AMBEST data that shows insurance is less important as a percentage of GDP and that losses are less significant relative to GDP than they were 20 years ago. The frequency of losses, one of the things that happened after 2010 was that the frequency of losses decreased precipitously, and it's never increased back to its prior levels. Even though we have millions more people, millions more cars, millions more businesses, millions more of everything, the absolute number of claims didn't go back to what it was prior to 2010. We just don't have as many covered losses, so insurance isn't as important.
There are two reasons for that, really important reasons. One is that the world is just a safer place, which is awesome. The safer the world is, the less important insurance is. Number two is we insure the wrong things, and if we don't start insuring the right things, nobody's going to have a need for us.
Ryan Hanley
That's like the best interview tee-up statement possible. What are the wrong things and what are the right things? That's the ultimate layup. You just put it right over the cylinder and I just had to push it right in.
Chris Burand
There's an argument to be made that outside of major fires, there isn't a whole lot of need for fire insurance. Almost nothing in the big scope of things burns down anymore. Take arson out, take wildfires out, there's not a lot left, honestly. But who is insuring intellectual capital? Aon did a study that showed that 87% of the S&P 500's total value is in intangible assets, i.e. intellectual capital. Where do you get that policy? Who's selling that policy?
Ryan Hanley
I want to jump in real quick because I had an issue with this. I had a company whose intellectual property was software that they had developed. My mind went naively to, "They just need a techie policy, right?" The name says it all. This is everything they could possibly need. It doesn't cover it. Because I'm a nerd, I start reading through the form and I'm like, "Wait a minute, this is basically a standard E&O policy except it has the word 'tech' in bold letters on the top." That's more of a classification of business than an actual adjustment to the policy language. Granted, I want to be fair, there were a few schmuggy givebacks to the fact that what they were building was a technology product, but it was more regarding intangible damage to a third party than it did to the intangible asset they had created. This actual software they're selling, if it goes poof or gets ripped or stolen, they're out of business or severely hindered.
Chris Burand
Yeah. Somebody comes and steals the contractor's tools. You have a policy for that. Someone comes and steals your software. Where's your insurance policy for that? It happens all the time.
Ryan Hanley
Oh, yeah.
Chris Burand
That's what we're missing. I'm a certified business appraiser, which is a pretty tough designation to get. In becoming a certified business appraiser for insurance agents, you have to be able to analyze the intangible assets because a book of business is an intangible asset. Someone steals your book of business, Ryan, where's your theft coverage? Our world operates not on screwdrivers and someone stealing tools. It operates on intellectual capital today. If the insurance industry wants to remain relevant, we've got to insure what is important.
Ryan Hanley
Is there anybody that's doing it?
Chris Burand
There are a couple of firms out there that do it, a couple of brokers that specialize in it. You have to really understand what you're selling and understand that there's probably not one single policy. It's usually going to be a combination of policies required to provide for all the coverage that someone needs. We teach some classes on it. A lot of people are selling cyber thinking that's where the coverage is, but most of the time, that's not where it is. Tech E&O, most of those forms will throw in a little bit this way or that way. But almost all the forms, like you said, are based on if it damages someone else. It's a liability policy. It's not, for lack of a better term, a theft policy.
There are certain countries out there. They don't come to the United States to steal screwdrivers. They come to the United States to steal intellectual capital. It happened to a neighbor of mine, a small businessman who made this really neat, unique little utensil. Another country stole the design, sold it for half the price. What happened to his market? He needed insurance for that. He didn't need insurance for the injuries that would cause somebody.
Ryan Hanley
You're a hundred percent right. When I was reading the tech language and the language of that particular carrier's tech E&O policy, I sold the guy anyway. I made him aware of what was happening, but I basically said to him, "This is covering you for your product doing damage to someone else, not necessarily someone stealing it." It was in flashing lights. I think it was $25,000 for intellectual property theft. This is a seven-figure business. What is $25,000? That doesn't even count for the lawyers to wrap the business up and shut the doors. It's not like you can go in and say, "Hey, I want this 25 turned into a million." This is not even an option. They don't have any way to rate for it.
I agree with you. It's almost why I've stayed away from the tech industry a little bit so far in this part of my career. The tech E&O policy, there's nothing special about it. A lot of carriers like to write it because there's not that much to it. The only thing they're really covering is damage to someone else through the software or services you've created, which is a relatively low risk item in truth.
This idea of we're insuring the wrong things is very interesting to me. Is there any other aspect of business in general that you feel like we're misaligned on for 2020?
Chris Burand
Yeah, I think business income. Just traditional business income. I do my regular consulting business, but we also have an educational company and we teach what I would argue is the most in-depth business income coverage available anywhere in the industry.
Ryan Hanley
Is this available to people? Do they have to be part of a membership program, or can they just sign up and take the classes?
Chris Burand
They can sign up and take the classes. Most of them are for a whole department at a time, but we've created one for individuals that just want to learn more than what their agency is offering too.
Ryan Hanley
And is that at burand-associates.com? They can find it all there?
Chris Burand
You can find it at Burand Education.
Ryan Hanley
Gotcha. I will have it on the show notes for everyone listening. I'll have a link over because I am an enormous believer in education in general. I just got my CWCA through Preston Diamond's shop. I'm an enormous believer in investing ourselves educationally into this industry. I really think it's a true differentiator.
Chris Burand
So, business income and business interruption. Most people take the class, and I'm not denigrating because their options have been limited, but there are three kinds of business interruption. One of the reasons people don't have the right business interruption coverage is because we're not offering all three kinds, and most businesses do need all three.
One is we need to understand just your basic business interruption and offer it in the right fashion. One of the observations we've made in our classes, studying and polling people taking the classes, is there's this centering around the worksheet but not the time elements. The worksheet without the time elements is kind of a pointless exercise. You have to be able to put the two together, and we find that there's a real lack of understanding of the time elements.
Then you have contingent business income. Contingent business income is beyond compare. It's so critical, and it's rarely sold. It's rarely even offered. When I do my E&O audits, I find probably a majority of people don't even know it exists.
The third kind is specialty business interruption coverage. Usually that kind of coverage is available only through specialty brokers, and it is by SIC code. You have to find that kind of business interruption coverage. It's usually a contingent type that is specific to SIC code for manufacturers, and then there would be a different program for restaurants and a different program for hospitals. It might even be more segmented than that. Those particular programs, if you find the right one for your SIC code, boy, do they make all the difference in the world for a client that has a business income problem related usually to regulation, which is a lot of what the COVID-19 business interruption issue is all about. Understanding that with the products already available can make a huge difference. Very underserved part of the marketplace.
Ryan Hanley
Why don't most agents... I won't say I have a master's education of business income with the contingent, but the SIC code specific, I'll be honest with you, I didn't even know that existed. I didn't even know that was a possibility or that there were specific policies that broke down business interruption into a line of business to cover there. Why do you think that is? Why do you think agents don't focus on this? Is it just tough to sell? Is it as simple as that?
I don't. I think part of it is that most of the insurance industry's educational courses are based on industry standard forms rather than proprietary forms. And that's where most agents learn about products available. I think that's one of the shortcomings of the industry is this focus on standardized forms.
Chris Burand
Yeah.
Ryan Hanley
So if you don't know something exists, it's hard to go look for it. And if you're going to educational classes and people aren't talking about it, it's really hard to figure out and find out.
Chris Burand
Yeah.
Ryan Hanley
I think that's the number one reason.
Chris Burand
Say that again.
Ryan Hanley
I think that's the number one reason.
Chris Burand
Yeah.
Ryan Hanley
Starting this agency has been eye-opening for me in many ways. As a producer, I thought I got a good education from my father-in-law. I got really solid producer education. When I went to Trusted Choice and built Agency Nation, I got to have so many conversations with so many amazing people like yourself. I did the podcast there. I came out of that thinking, "Geez, I've talked to people up, down, inside, left, right of the industry—every part from CEOs to marketing reps, to carriers, to underwriters, claims adjusters, to every type of agency that I thought existed."
Then when I started the agency and I started getting smacked in the face day after day with the realities of having to think about all this stuff—which can be so heady and so high level—but at the same time keep the business actually operating, actually do it, it's a really difficult process to manage. You hear things like what you're talking about, the depth of what you're talking about. I think every agent worth their salt hears that and says, "I would love for all my clients who need a coverage that rich to have a coverage that rich."
At the same time, the idea of actually investing yourself, creating the brain cycles, implementing the process, finding access—whether through a specialty broker or a carrier—and actually implementing it into your client base feels so overwhelming that you just don't do it. That one simple thing is such a huge process when you break down all the pieces, which is why I feel like we all default to standardized forms. It doesn't take me 40 brain cycles to wrap my head around a standard form where a business interruption class form specific to plumbers or whatever, I'm like, "How is it different than the one for electricians?" It just feels like a lot of brain cycles. That's a very tough aspect of our business. As much as a lot of this stuff feels like it can be straightforward, very little in our industry actually is.
Chris Burand
You're right. It can be really overwhelming. No choice about it. I live that and see it daily. It is really overwhelming. There are a lot of options to help make it more bite-sized. One is to learn about it. One of the reasons it takes 40 brain cycles is because it's part of the learning curve. The more you learn, the faster you cycle through the process. The key to it is learning, taking the time to learn it in depth and probably go a little further than industry standard.
I think CE is one of the worst things that ever happened to our industry. What I recommend to people quite often is go do your CE on one of those programs where you can get six hours and 45 minutes for a hundred dollars. Then go spend your real money on real education elsewhere and not worry about CE.
Ryan Hanley
I think that's really good advice.
Chris Burand
It's the best way to get the education so you don't have to think so hard about some of these things. Then if your book is big enough, start picking some kind of a specialty. It'll make it a lot easier and a lot more rewarding. I've got a buddy who built a multi-million dollar commission book on nothing but contingent business income for one SIC code. One of the ways to not have to worry about all these things is just that focus.
Ryan Hanley
I think most producers listening would be very happy with a multimillion dollar commission book.
Chris Burand
I think they would too.
Ryan Hanley
I always try to put things in context to the struggles that I'm having personally, because if I'm struggling with it, I'm assuming others are as well. I know unequivocally that finding some sort of niche or focus or specialty is the answer. There's not really a counter argument to it. What makes it legitimate is that there is a counter argument that just doesn't actually add more value. A generalist would be the counter argument, but I feel like highly profitable generalist agencies are more of an edge case than a rule. Highly profitable organizations with three to five specialties, or maybe one to three depending on what they are, are more often profitable. That proves the case—you need to have a counter argument, otherwise it's a conspiracy theory.
That being said, it is so difficult to say no to business. I know the answer is just pick something. It honestly doesn't matter. I should just put post-it notes up on my wall, have my kid take a dart, close his eyes, throw it at the wall. Whichever one he hits, it's like, "Okay, I'm into barbershops run by women on the west coast. Okay, there it is. Let's go." And you just fight it.
I have an account that I'm going to write today that is a $986 BOP, and I don't know why I'm doing it. I have no idea why I'm doing it. I don't want it. I'm not interested in it. The guy's kind of annoying, but he called me. I rated him up while I was on the phone with him, and I'm going to write the account. I don't want to belittle that because it's business and I should be happy. The mechanism is working because he found me online and it was kind of already sold because he'd watched a couple of videos. So I shouldn't complain. But at the same time, that's not the future of where I'm going. I'm going to write it anyways, and I'm sitting here telling you that I shouldn't. I found it very interesting that while logically it makes so much sense to dial into a niche, emotionally it is so incredibly difficult.
Chris Burand
It is hard. No choice about it. It's fear driven. The fear is, "If I don't write this $986, where am I going to get the next $986?" It's not ready. It's not right there. Especially when you're starting out, it's next to impossible to stay that disciplined. When you're just first starting out, it's best probably to write whatever you can write. But at some point in time, those that express the discipline in some form or another, they always win. 100% of the time.
Ryan Hanley
I want to pivot just a little bit to agency valuations, as much as you're willing to talk about that topic. I know it's a big part of what you do, and you're one of the best in the country at it. A good buddy of mine, Chris Langell, he runs Advisory Evolved, an insurance website business. He put out a tweet the other day that said simply, "We don't sell insurance to sell insurance." His point was, we sell insurance to feed our families, go on vacation, have a lifestyle that we want. There's a reason why this is the mechanism for many people.
Starting an agency, even though I know we're near selling, you kind of can't help it at times. Think about the end. Think about where we're going. You've talked about how we're insuring the wrong things. With that understanding, I think it's fair to say that there are probably aspects that would build agency value over the next 10, 20 years that maybe weren't as important to building agency value the previous 10, 20 years. If that's wrong, that's fine. What are some of those things? If you are a young agency or a growing agency and you could step in right now and say, "If you just focus on this one thing, it'll tick your trajectory up in value. This will really help long-term. If I could interject right this moment and fix it for you." What's something like that?
Chris Burand
One of the biggest differences from 10 years ago or 20 years ago and today is data. Data, data, data. Clean data. Data makes scale possible. Lack of data prevents scale.
Ryan Hanley
If this were Cass's podcast, he'd be doing this thing where he acts like he's losing his mind. He'd be like, "Oh, Chris, hold on. Let me write that down." He'd be scratching it. Sorry, I can't help but make fun of Cass. He's my favorite. So that is an answer that makes complete sense to me. But I think for a lot of agents, that does not make sense to them. I don't mean that in a belittling way. I think the idea of data has been tossed at us and used both from a very deep, rich standpoint and at a very shallow kind of giving the word multiple meanings. When you say clean data, what does that mean in a practical sense to an agency owner who's sitting and listening to this?
Chris Burand
Very succinctly, let's start with accounting. Having good accounting data is crucial. Really good accounting data is really crucial. If you don't have good accounting data, you don't know what status your agency is in. A buyer comes in, they're going to discount it because they can't trust the numbers. It reduces your flexibility. When the pandemic hit, if the United States government hadn't stepped in and offered lots of loans with very little data required on the loan application, a whole lot of businesses in America would have gone kaput simply because they had bad accounting. A lot of agencies fall into that category.
Very practically, on a daily basis, good accounting on a client basis, actually inputting correct data into your agency management system—including going back to the SIC codes. Recording the SIC code of your individual business clients is unbelievably valuable on a go-forward basis from so many different angles. When I go into agencies and I'm looking at their files and I can't tell right from wrong what's happening, or they say, "Oh yeah, we don't always put that information in," or on their prospect module of an AMS system they're not inputting any of their prospects in there, it's like, how can you ever re-solicit these people? You have to start from scratch. You save so much money having a lead list that's been built over the years from people that you already talked to. That's worth a lot of money, that lead list. It's about very practical data being entered daily and accurately.
Ryan Hanley
That helps. One of the things that I found very interesting when I first joined my wife's family's agency—and I just use them as a barometer all the time, even though it's an incredibly well-run agency—one of the things that we had to clean up over the years was that there was a prior partner in the business. Obviously employees come in and employees come out, and they've been in business for 47 years. It's a testament to the work they do. But at the same time, you have employees who would use one field for phone number and another field, they would just put information in random text boxes. All of a sudden we would try to pull information.
One of the things that I started to implement when I was there was Infusionsoft because we were on TAM and there was no real way to market out of TAM. We said, "Okay, we'll take the data. We'll export it out of TAM. We'll put it into Infusionsoft and we'll start to market there. We'll have dual entry, but at least we'll be able to communicate and connect." We couldn't do it. The manual labor process once we were able to export the data out, just the differences in how people had used fields and how they had inputted things over the course of time was so... today you could hire a VA and have them clean it up, but it was too much work. It was literally too much work when we started to actually break it down for it to be valuable because it had been used so many different ways for so long.
What you're saying is that today or in the next 10 to 20 years, these are the kinds of things that are actually going to have an impact on value. When I bring up data to some agents today, they'll just say to me, "Yeah, Ryan, that's cool. Except you know how agents get valued. They take EBITDA, they times it by two, and then someone writes a check for that." I don't actually believe that it's that simplistic, though I'm sure it does occasionally happen. I can't believe as we become more sophisticated and systems talking to each other becomes a given part of our business that people are going to pay the same when the data's not clean.
Chris Burand
Two points. One, activity codes are maybe the worst example of people using multiple activity codes for exactly the same thing. Those activity codes are really valuable pieces of data. Putting telephone numbers in different fields is the same thing. But here's the other part. Let's say it is simple. Let's say it is two times EBITDA. Let's just leave it down to six times EBITDA or 12 times EBITDA or whatever the number is. If you have good data, you'll have a bigger EBITDA. So even on a simple basis, your value increases. If you have good data and you use it constructively, you will have a bigger EBITDA, all else being equal.
Ryan Hanley
Are you familiar with the Neon project? Seth and some of the ideas around how he's trying to anonymize and scale data over agencies so that we can be more efficient? What are your feelings on a project of that nature? You don't have to specifically reference Neon, just the idea as a whole. Do you think something like that is valuable to agents long-term if it can be pulled off?
Chris Burand
If it can be pulled off, there's a possibility. The problem with any of these data projects—and there are a number of them ongoing—is that there's no standardization of process in agencies, much less across agencies. Use activity codes for an example. Until you have some consistency, it's next to impossible to do any kind of analysis of what works best. I think that's one of the biggest issues that we have in those kinds of projects. Conceptually, there's a lot of value. A whole lot of value.
Ryan Hanley
The thing that I have been impressed with, and I'll just talk to Neon because of all the data projects that's the one I'm the most familiar with, was their ability to look at the second and third layer reasons for a particular high level action. It takes four days to get a quote back from X carrier. Bam, that's the data point. If we position that against five days for Y carrier, we could say, "Well, we need to stay away from Y carrier. It's taking us 24 more hours to get a quote back and we could be losing business." But when we're actually looking at this data at scale and it is clean, then we can dive down and really start to dissect. "Well, the reason it's five days is because John is actually the one who's submitting the business to that carrier. And John's submissions in general are twice as long as any other agency personnel." Now we can focus on what the real core issues are that are keeping our efficiency down.
I know some of what I just said made smoke come out of agency owners' ears. But for these agencies that really want to grow and understand how important internal efficiency is to that growth—not just on renewals or retention, but on new business—this clean data and then having the right system that can help you look at the second and third level, it is wild. You can see how powerful these systems can be over time.
Chris Burand
You don't even have to have a system. We've proven to a lot of different clients just within their own organization that there's an easy 20% operational efficiency to be gained from that kind of analysis. Even on a simplistic level, that means one out of five people on a payroll is superfluous. That's a big savings.
Ryan Hanley
The catch is that people that run agencies are salespeople by and large. They're not operational people. Even if you come up with all the solutions, which I totally agree with you how important operations is, you have to have an agreement that there'll be emphasis placed on operations by the person who mostly is focused on sales. Our industry never really achieved that. Very few agency owners of any size have that appreciation of efficiencies in operations.
One of the byproducts of looking into this—I am trying to figure out what the personality of this agency is going to be, where we're going to go. I obviously have ideas, but I also am a firm believer that you follow your strength. You don't try to force it. So I've tried to both operate in the areas that I think there'll be opportunity, but also kept an open mind. One of the places that I explored was high volume personal lines leads business and getting to know some of those agency owners who are very successful in that game. If I had to pull out one of the core similarities, it is that they have removed themselves from sales altogether and removed their overemphasis on sales as the primary thing they focus on and took more of a holistic approach of the agency.
They've really taken the time to dive into even simple things like onboarding new clients, setting expectations, working on carrier contracts. These types of operational and second level thinking—I think a lot of us who get stuck at plateaus get stuck there because we never want to leave the sales function and we only ever think about the sales function first, second, third in our business. Not that sales isn't important, don't get me wrong. But at a certain point, I think we have to replace ourselves as the head of sales and start thinking holistically, or we have to pay somebody to do that because it has to be done.
Chris Burand
Absolutely. You're right. I think one of the advantages—it's kind of interesting, the intersection of data and accepting the reality of better operational management, they're very closely connected. I would argue that there are a couple of the networks, just a couple, maybe three, maybe four, where everybody signs on and gets access to the carriers. The people running those particular networks have more insight specific to that than maybe anybody else I've seen in the industry. I think that they have something that maybe is pretty unique in that fashion. The networks for network's sake, I'm not so sure about. But scale and operational efficiency, and because they have the scale already, they can bring both of those things if they have the right mindsets and address what you're talking about. I think there's something there in a few that's just...
Ryan Hanley
I've talked about him before on the show. I'm part of Indium. The reason I joined was not necessarily because they're the biggest or had the most bells and whistles, but because Chad and his team—this is where they're moving. This is their mantra. They may not be fully up, fully dispersed, everything functioning exactly the way, but they are moving in this direction. They're using tools that allow them to be flexible and maneuver. In general, I agree with you. When you can look at data as widespread and once you hit a certain bar, once you get over a certain amount of data, you can really start to see trends and impact and how changes have a widespread effect. I think there's a lot there.
The last question I want to leave you with, and this could be shallow, you can go as deep or as not as you want. It's something that is on the minds of a lot of Main Street agents today: the idea of using VAs in your business and outsourcing in general. From your perspective—agency valuation, E&O, operations—when you think about this trend towards VAs, where's your mind going? Is it something you see as very positive? Net neutral? Where are you coming down on VAs in general?
Chris Burand
Outsourcing is pretty interesting. There are definitely some areas in which outsourcing is incredibly valuable, but it has to be very surgical in its use and in choosing which outsourcing firm to use. There's quite a bit of new technology coming down the pike, probably sooner rather than later, that's pretty much going to eliminate the need for mass outsourcing. It replaces them. The technology just replaces that whole duty.
The other thing that I've noticed in doing agency valuations and efficiency studies is that it's really hard to find true cost savings with most mass outsourcing. It's hard to judge in a smaller agency, but in a larger agency it's really hard to find the savings. We've done some detailed studies on it for large clients who use outsourcing on a large scale. One would think the savings would be there. One would think it'd be pretty easy to find. But it's pretty hard to discover.
I don't really like revenue per person as any kind of a metric. I think it's a pretty lousy metric, except if somebody's way less than normal revenue per person, that's a problem. But the correlation beyond that is pretty much zero. If you do regression analysis, the R-squared value is nearly zero. When we've tested revenue per person and whether it's affected by outsourcing, it doesn't seem to have much of an effect, especially if you build back the cost of the outsources. Sometimes revenue per person actually decreases. I don't think it's usually used well. I think new technology is going to replace it.
Ryan Hanley
That's interesting. I have a client who used to work for Facebook. I wrote his insurance. He moved to New York and then we got into this geeky tech conversation. He was telling me all his ideas for disrupting the insurance space, which were interesting. Then he basically said, "I know the trend in insurance is VAs. I don't understand why. I think the technology can replace them."
I'm of two minds on it. I just brought in my first VA a couple of weeks ago into the agency. I can say unequivocally the advantages—the cost versus the time that it has freed up in my day to do things that allow me to produce more revenue and focus on the bigger, longer term projects that before I just could not get through. I also could not hire an American to do that. I could not take the time to bring in technology to do it. To me, it's a hundred out of a hundred times. That being said, there may be a point at which you are of a size where you have the time, resources, capacity to backfill and replace those processes. Setting up the technology is oftentimes just as much work or more than onboarding the VA, which is an interesting dilemma. Not right or wrong. I think it's an interesting dilemma. I think for smaller agencies, the VA can be a godsend. I really do.
Chris Burand
I recommend it to a lot of my clients, one way or another. But for larger ones, it's really a mixed bag. It truly is. And the technology is going to replace it. There's no two ways about it. On the large scale, the technology is inevitably going to replace it. It's going to replace it sooner rather than later. Furthermore, the better the data is that an agency has, the more quickly the technology is going to be able to replace the human at a far lower cost.
Ryan Hanley
I want to share this with you to this point. I'm testing a tool right now called Canopy Connect. What this tool does—and I want to give a shout out to Heath Sharon, he's the one that turned me on to this—your prospect logs into their current online platform and Canopy Connect pulls all the data out clean, exactly as it should be. No "Oh, did you say seven or four?" None of that. Just log in, boom. Now, again, we're not quite there. There's also some cultural things. Do people want to do it? Do they trust it? There's some of that. But man, it zaps that data out. 90 seconds later, you're staring at all the information you need to quote them. All that person had to do was put their username and password into the system. I look at that and I said, "Okay, that's step one of four that gets us to where we never have to ask them any of the underwriting questions ever again." That's really interesting. To the client who's willing to use that, it's very powerful.
Chris Burand
There are a number of those systems in place that are one step away from a light switch being turned on and made active.
Ryan Hanley
They're game changers. I've tested them. I've gone through the demos. They're total game changers.
Chris Burand
Then there's another set of systems that come in and do another aspect of the policy work. You put those two together, frankly, honestly, pretty much about 40%, 50% of all human processing is eliminated. It's just gone and it's automated. The tests that I've seen show that it's far more accurate than the humans.
Ryan Hanley
You have these API-driven systems like Tarmica that are going to be three-question quote to binds because they're so dialed into all the systems. Name, birthday, address, VIN numbers—all the information is pulled right in. It's all there. Now here's what I hope everyone understands. Here's what I actually believe these things do: it frees you up to actually be an advisor, actually think about SIC code specific business interruption coverage. That's the goal.
Chris Burand
That's the way it should work.
Ryan Hanley
That's my goal. That's what I want to see happen. How do people become better advisors? Exactly.
Pause
Hey, we're over. I apologize for that, but I appreciate your time so much, man. This has been absolutely tremendous. I'll have all the links up for everyone. Check out Chris's website. I'll have everything set up there. But if you see Chris's name on a podcast or a document or something that he's written somewhere, slow down, read it. I promise you, you will not be disappointed.
Chris Burand
My great pleasure, my friend. Thank you, Ryan. Appreciate it.
Ryan Hanley
Be good, brother. Take care. Bye-bye.
End of conversation
Ad break begins
Announcer
You go fuck yourself with your fat fucking ass! Yeah, please. Do you want to have a few drinks and smoke a joint, bubbles? Yes. Yes. I'm calling you my brother Charlie, I'm calling you my brother Charlie alarm, so we make 2, 2, 3 drinks and smoke a joint bubble? Yeah.
Different ad begins
Close twice as many deals by this time next week. Sound impossible? It's not. With the One Call Close System, you'll stop chasing leads and start closing deals in one call. This is the exact method we use to close 1,200 clients in under three years during the pandemic. No fluff, no endless follow-ups, just results fast. Based in behavioral psychology and battle-tested, the One Call Close System eliminates excuses and gets the prospect saying yes more than you ever thought possible. If you're ready to stop losing opportunities and start winning, visit masteroftheclosed.com. That's masteroftheclosed.com. Do it today.