Episode Summary
The podcast episode features Bobby Collies, a power broker who recently made a big move from Grange Insurance to Coterie Insurance, an insurtech company. The conversation revolves around Bobby's decision to join Coterie and her thoughts on the insurance industry's future.
Key Points
Takeaways
Participants
Guests
Became a Master of the Close: https://masteroftheclose.com
In this tremendous episode of The Ryan Hanley Show, We're joined by the one-and-only Bobbie Collies, Vice President of Distribution at Coterie Insurance. Bobbie is the perfect blend of a carrier professional the industry needs to cultivate; traditionally trained but insurtech-minded.
We're honored to have Bobbie on the show…
Resources Mentioned:
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Episodes You Might Enjoy:
Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.
Ryan Hanley
Hello everyone and welcome back to the show. We have an absolutely tremendous episode for you. A conversation with the great, powerful Bobbie Collies, who just made a big move in her career from Grange Insurance to Coterie Insurance. I wanted to see what that was about. Why that move? Why Coterie? Why going from a very well-respected company, but a more traditional company, to an insurtech? What that looked like, what Bobbie was seeing in the market. Obviously, I have a tremendous amount of respect for Bobbie, and it was great to have her on the show.
Before we get there, quick shout out to the companies that make this show possible. First, Tarmica. T-A-R-M-I-K-A dot com. Tarmica. The number one commercial rater in the game. If you're looking to write more small business insurance, Tarmica is the place to do it. That's what we use at Rogue, and that's what we recommend you use.
Next, Podium. If you're not capturing leads on your website via chat in a format that allows you to then reply in text, you are missing opportunities. Podium has many tools, but their chat function alone makes them the number one text-to-chat bot in the game. Easy to use, easy to set up. We use Podium at Rogue as well, and we're happy to have them as a sponsor of the show. Visit podium.com if you want that. Go to tarmika.com if you want to check them out.
Let's get on to Bobbie Collies. The one and only Bobbie Collies, ladies and gentlemen. How's it going?
Bobbie Collies
Ryan, can you hear me now? Gotcha. It was my fault, my fault. I got a slightly new setup. Still getting configured.
Ryan Hanley
Got it. What's going on?
Bobbie Collies
Well, I got a new gig since the last time we talked. So that's cool.
Ryan Hanley
I know. I'm super excited for you. When a power broker like you moves, it just shakes the industry. I'm so excited for you. I think it's very cool, and obviously no disrespect to Grange, but it's very exciting to hear. I'm very interested in the thought process behind the move, what you're excited about, what's going on at Coterie, what you'll be doing, all the things.
Bobbie Collies
Yeah. Well, thought process behind the move. Ryan, reflecting back on my career, I think working for a legacy carrier was probably a little frustrating for me at times because I like to move fast. The typical corporate carrier world just moves too slow for me. Secondly, it wasn't exactly Coterie, but it was a similar model and business case that I proposed to two companies I worked for in the past five years. "Let's do this. Let's fund it, let's incubate it, and let's go."
So when Ray Lynch called me and said, "Hey, I think you should come and think about working with us," I said, "Okay, I'll think about it. Let's have a serious talk." Because this is something cool. This is something I've wanted to build. You guys are already building it. You're two years into it. I can come in and just help drive the growth and go fast and go hard. Which is exciting.
Ryan Hanley
It is exciting. It's very fun to work somewhere where you can have an idea and people don't look at you like you're crazy, or immediately start discussing all the reasons that idea shouldn't work, or that now is not the right time. I've worked in both situations. When you're sitting in a room and you can be like, "What if we did this?" and everyone goes, "Yeah, let's try that," it gets you so jacked up. Your brain never just has that one idea. You open yourself up to another cool idea, and another cool idea. It doesn't mean you do every single one, but it gets that momentum going.
So many of the legacy players, ideas are almost frowned upon. There's almost social cred taken for who can knock that idea down. Who's the best at finding the reason that idea won't work? There's social cred for that. That is a soul-sucking place to be.
Bobbie Collies
Well, and here's the thing. A lot of the legacy carriers are doing really well. They're growing above market. They're making money. In many cases, there's really not a strong reason for them to try anything new or bold, Ryan. They're operating just fine.
Ryan Hanley
Do you think that's true? Not to cut you off, but I did cut you off, so I meant to, but not in an offensive way. I want to dig into that idea. Yes, legacy carriers are doing as well as they've ever done. Plenty of business coming in. Even the small innovations that they've implemented—some have done really good work—but even the ones that have done small implementations have helped grow. But all of that is still based on a surveyed agency plan that is going to phase out in the next five to seven years.
When I see that growth today, I think to myself, yes, I understand why if I'm looking at my growth numbers today, and I'm a legacy carrier who has not adopted and innovated significantly, I can say, "We're fine. Look at our numbers. We're doing great. We're hitting our quarterly numbers every quarter." But I feel like there's a cliff coming. All of a sudden, that surveyed agency plan of "Well, Ryan, our agents have never asked for that before" is going to come to an end. All those people are going to phase out, and the current 35 to 50-year-olds are going to be those decision makers. They're going to demand these things. Companies like Coterie and others were built for our generation of agency owners and decision makers. That feels like they're set up better for the future.
Bobbie Collies
I agree with that, Ryan, to a certain degree, especially with your traditional retail agency. A lot of those folks are heading into retirement. So what does that mean for legacy carriers when all those folks drop off that cliff you're describing? But then you also have large networks and brokers that are acquiring agencies and starting to build their tech stacks. I think they do have a lot of potential future to help carriers grow, including Coterie in our space. A majority of our growth right now, Ryan, is actually coming from the traditional retail agency.
Ryan Hanley
I believe that.
Bobbie Collies
We will continue that trajectory of having an independent agent be our primary source of growth moving forward. But what does that agency look like? That's a whole other question. What does our target agency look like? How are they acquiring agents or new prospects? What are their lead sources looking like?
Ryan Hanley
One of the things... I've had people ask, I've been with Coterie for a long time. Thank you for that, by the way. I love what you guys are doing. I latched on and I love the people, Ray, and I had him on the show. Someone asked me, "What is it about Coterie?" I said, "I'm going to give you a microcosm of why I think insurtechs are what I love."
When I want to get appointed in a new state, I have to talk to my local rep. Then that local rep has to talk to their regional manager, and the regional manager has to rubber stamp it. "How much business is he going to put in the state of New Jersey?" We don't live in a world where anyone gives a shit about the New Jersey-New York state border anymore. No one cares. The business could be five miles over the border, or it could be all the way down. It doesn't matter. Coterie is just like, "Okay, you're appointed. Whatever state you write in, just send us your license, you're in."
That's a microcosm of the mentality. When we had to put mail in a mailbox or hand it to someone on a horse to ride the note to the other location, states really mattered. That geographical state footprint really mattered. I get that each state has its own Department of Insurance. I get the reasoning behind it. But the next iteration of agency owners that are scaling and growing do not think, "I'm a New York agent. I'm a Pennsylvania agent." They're thinking, "Where is opportunity?" and attacking that opportunity. Their home base might be Pennsylvania, and they don't have another appointment except for Minnesota because they see an enormous opportunity there and can market into it. Being able to maneuver with that is a small microcosm of the mentality shift that I think is going to push the industry. I think companies like Coterie are going to push that mentality into the legacy carriers because it makes too much sense.
Bobbie Collies
Right. One of the things we're doing is challenging the traditional definition of franchise value. At Coterie, what does franchise value really mean in the independent agency plant now? Because it's not geography, to your point. So what does that really mean? That's a debate we're having as a team, and we're trying to redefine that for Coterie as we continue to build our distribution strategy. It's a fun conversation to have, especially with a bunch of people that are open-minded and crazy and bold. We're entering into a new stage for geography. We're not drawing lines anymore. We can't have only three agencies within a certain metro area of Chicago.
Ryan Hanley
You just used my favorite slash least favorite insurance term: franchise value. I love to make fun of it. Carriers will call and talk about appointments, not like "Hey, I want to give you one," but pitching, "Are we a good fit?" As soon as I get to franchise value, I chuckle because there's no franchise value in having a carrier appointment anymore. That whole concept is toast. I know how you're using it, but I gave you a hard time about this when we were talking in a different life. I find it so funny when a carrier comes in and says, "Look, we're going to appoint you. The franchise value of this appointment is through the roof." I'm like, "Well, how much more multiple do I get for having it?" That's not really the way it works. So it means nothing. You're selling me a made-up concept that doesn't work. "What do I get?" "Well, nothing." Let's just talk in real terms.
I'm sure it had value. If you're an Erie agent and you believe in Erie the way they're set up—kind of like a very Putin-esque dictatorship—they tell you what to do, who you can sell to, what you can write, what other carriers you can have. In that scenario, if you want to buy into that type of model, I could understand the franchise value because you get a territory. Because of their rating and how they go after it, I could see that. But the concept of any mainline independent carrier actually increasing value by having that appointment, I haven't seen it.
Bobbie Collies
Well, what does that mean anymore? What does franchise value mean? That's our debate now. How do we at Coterie protect our brand and make sure that... It might mean, Ryan, the types of agencies that we will appoint. Our franchise value is that you're going to be able to play with other agencies who are at X level. But I don't like the term either. It's more about who is your brand associated with and how do we make a Coterie contract attractive to some of the best agencies.
Ryan Hanley
What would be a better term than that?
Bobbie Collies
We need a better term.
Ryan Hanley
You need a better term. You guys are so out ahead of the game in so many ways that hearing someone from Coterie use the term "franchise value" doesn't make sense. I'm like, "What are you talking about? You guys are so forward and you do so much cool shit. Why are you using that term that these old farts use?" I'm just busting your chops.
I want to talk more about the move. You made this move from Grange to Coterie. What's got you jacked up? I've seen you doing a lot more selfies lately, which is great. The internet needs more Bobbie. It seems like you're excited. What's got you fired up?
Bobbie Collies
Well, Ryan, number one, being surrounded by a bunch of people who are drivers. A bunch of really smart people, to your point earlier, that are open-minded. We're tossing around ideas all the time. We're thinking through new partnerships, new types of partnerships. Right now we're building a distribution strategy. That was my number one first goal. I have a draft. I'm meeting new people. I got really jacked up when I talked to Pete the first time about the automated underwriting and what's going on back there. My insurance geek went 1050 percent excited. I'm like, "Oh my gosh, Pete, this is amazing."
But really, it's all about the pace, Ryan. It's both kind of exhausting and energizing at the same time. I was telling Tim the other day, it's almost like I used to be a marathon runner and I took two years off and I'm retraining. I'm still running, but I'm tired instead of energized at the end of my run. My endurance is coming back. I'm excited to wake up every day and just go.
Ryan Hanley
That's awesome.
Bobbie Collies
We're building something. We're still in the infancy stages, but we're seeing a lot of growth. We have a really good run rate. It's exciting to be around people that are all trying to drive towards the same thing. Because of the size of the company, there's not a lot of ego going on. The co-founders have done a really good job of protecting the culture there. Because of the size of the company, there's not a lot of political governance or things that you have to have in a larger organization that slows things down. So we're just going.
Ryan Hanley
That's awesome. I'm so excited for you. Epic hire. I've said this before on the show, and I hope you take this in the most positive way possible. You've always been on a list I keep of people I would love to work with, or if I was ever in a position to hire or have as part of my team. You've been on it for like four years. When I saw you at Coterie, I was like, "Fuck, that's at least three more years I'm probably not going to be able to..."
Bobbie Collies
Well, you know, Ryan's always for sale.
Ryan Hanley
So, Coterie, small business insurance. That's the specialty. What's going on in small business? What conversations are you guys having inside there? Obviously, that's a big part of what we do, and I'm very excited personally about the small business space. I think there's a tremendous amount of opportunity. What conversations can you share that aren't secret sauce? What kind of stuff is going on internally that you're thinking about for small business? What are you prepping for? What are agents coming in and excited about? What's got you going on the small business side?
Bobbie Collies
Have you played at all with our SimplyBind product yet?
Ryan Hanley
A little bit.
Bobbie Collies
I'm super jacked about that. The concept is we're using enough third-party data sources to pull in enough data to automate our underwriting in the back end to quote off of a name and an address for small micro-commercial. Think about how that impacts an agency and their ability to make a buck off small micro-commercial when they couldn't in the past. It's two minutes to quote and bind versus 40 minutes to quote four different carrier portals and grab a quote. The whole process is brutal.
But if you think about how you can get creative on just taking a name and an address and returning a bindable quote, there's a lot of cool stuff that our team is brainstorming on how to take this and use it to help us scale. Not only at the agent's desk, but even dropping it in on an agency website. We can drop in our Coterie white-label solution. Clients can come to your website and quote 24/7, and it's yours. Or think about it in a big batch. Think about what we could do in a big batch with names and addresses. There's a lot of cool stuff.
Ryan Hanley
One of the things I was talking to—I think Ray, maybe it was David—back in the fall. I don't want to give away the secret sauce because there are a lot of people here. No, I'm just kidding. One of the things I think is great is that you can take contact lists, take lost lead lists, go out and buy lists. We'll take the gray ethical nature of that practice. If you can just run off the API or have someone pinging the system with name and address, and now you have... What we have in the hopper for the later half of 2022 is to start literally emailing people bindable quote numbers right into their email. "Hey, I don't know what you're paying for insurance right now, but I have a bindable quote for $975, $1,562. If that's less than you're paying, just respond to this email and we'll take care of it." You can just pre-quote these people. Obviously, you want to validate or whatever, put some language around disclosures. But this type of active outreach to people is almost a no-brainer with that.
Not to mention what you can do with forms and smart forms. One of the things we're working on too—and this is something that you guys are on a short list that I want to work with—is as someone fills out a form for classes of business that you know are automatic, why can't you immediately, instead of taking in a consultant who is right in your guys' sweet spot with the professional liability that you can add on, and it's very simple? You could have that consulting class come in on a form fill. Your people don't even have to talk to that person. For that class of business, they can be immediately pushed over to a form where their name and address is already in, and you have that number in seconds. Why are we wasting time shopping a $1,200 consultant's GL and professional package to four carriers? That makes no sense.
I think it's those types of automations for certain classes of business that save time and increase the customer experience. That $1,200 consultant most likely doesn't want to have an hour-long conversation about their million-dollar GL and million-dollar miscellaneous professional liability. They don't want to do that. They don't even understand it. That's why they need you to just tell them they're covered properly.
Bobbie Collies
Yeah. To your point, Ryan, there are a lot of small commercial, micro-commercial classes of business that are very easy to underwrite. They're easy to get the third-party data. That's where we can scale. That's where we can get really creative with some of these things you're talking about.
Ryan Hanley
How is... A lot of agents, when you talk about third-party data, and I think rightly so, have questions around one, the legality, two, the validity, and three, its usage. Could you talk a little bit about, from your personal take or the general Coterie line, on using third-party data? Why it's important. I'm obviously a huge believer and think it's an important part of our future. Where are you guys on it? How are you using it?
Bobbie Collies
Ryan, I think we have north of seven different third-party data sources that we're pulling in. We're using some machine learning in the background just to figure out which third-party data sources are most accurate. Over time, that model is going to get a little bit more sophisticated. A lot of our data that's coming in has been relatively accurate. The ones that are the hardest to get, which we typically will ask agents to verify, are the payroll and the sales amounts, because those are a little bit more estimates. That's what we're using with SimplyBind too. If it doesn't seem right, we're using an estimate based on some other data points. It's predictive modeling for the payroll and the revenue. That's really the one piece that is most difficult to get accurate and where we need some human intervention.
Ryan Hanley
Is there any, just to quell the concerns of those who may... Are there any legality issues around using third-party data? I think a lot of people don't necessarily even understand what that means. Essentially, and please correct me where I'm wrong, third-party data sources are just pools of information collected through different form fills, through different services you use. There are tools like Axiom and all these different databases that collect information. If I heard you correctly, what you're doing is taking seven or some number north of seven and mashing them together and saying, "If these five pieces of information are the same in these seven databases, then that must mean they're accurate. We're fairly certain they're accurate." And then you can just inject those right in and you don't even have to ask those questions.
Bobbie Collies
Absolutely. And Ryan, think about billing updates too. If I go back to my underwriting days and I look at an ACORD app, roof age updates, electrical updates—those were never truly accurate. I used 2015 for all of them, always. "Oh, I put a new outlet in 2020, but my electrical was updated in 2020." Even that data is getting more accurate on our side where we're able to pull building permit data to know exactly what was updated. Was it updated enough to be considered an update, or was it just a minor maintenance thing? We're getting a little bit more sophisticated there. On the legality side, I honestly haven't looked into it that deeply, so I don't want to speak to that. But what I can say is I do feel like the data is more accurate than what we would typically get on an ACORD form.
Ryan Hanley
I did an interview with Bill Martin, the CEO of Plymouth Rock, probably five or six years ago when Plymouth Rock first came out with that home feature where you just put the address in and they give you a number. I did it for Agency Nation. The long and short of it was what Plymouth Rock was doing at the time was all you had to do was plug in the address and they would send you a number. Everyone was like, "How can they do that?" How they did it was they did similar to what you're doing, but with homeowner's data. They would go out and underwrite and price every home in a state. Every single home would be pre-underwritten, pre-priced. It would just be sitting there. They already know what the price is. When you put the address in, they would just pull that information.
This was five or six years ago. There was a lot of "No way, agents, what's going to happen? How do you do a visual inspection?" All that kind of stuff. Basically, what he said was the days of visual agent inspections are over. We don't need them. What do you really get out of a visual inspection? "Oh, maybe you need a handrail or something." That's going to get picked up when we send our person by if we feel we need to do that. It's kind of redundant in many cases. He said, "I would bet 95 out of 100 times, the information that we get from the pool of third-party data that we pull from is more accurate than what the agents send us."
Not because the agents are trying to be nefarious, but because if I ask you, Bobbie, when's the last time you updated the electrical in your home, you're going to be like, "Ah, 2015." Who the heck knows? Maybe you remember, but no one really knows. If you bought the house X number of years... Humans are terrible at remembering this stuff to begin with. To think that you're going to remember it accurately, share it with me, I'm going to capture it accurately, and then accurately communicate that to the carrier is a big stretch. Versus pulling permit data and title data and whatever else you can get access to.
I fully believe that the concept that third-party data is actually more accurate in most cases than a human questionnaire process.
[To listeners] If you're listening to this show on Spotify or Apple iTunes, et cetera, this helps the show grow. It helps me bring more guests in. We have a tremendous lineup of people coming in—men and women who've done incredible things—sharing their stories around peak performance, leadership, growth, sales, the things that are going to help you grow as a person and grow your business. But they all check out comments, ratings, reviews. They check out all this information before they come on. As I reach out to more and more people and want to bring them in and share their stories with you, I need your help. Share the show. Subscribe if you're not subscribed. I'd love for you to leave a comment about the show because I read all the comments. Or if you're on Apple or Spotify, leave a rating review of this show. I love you for listening to this show, and I hope you enjoy listening as much as I do creating the show for you. All right, I'm out of here. Peace. Let's get back to the episode.
Bobbie Collies
Well, and Ryan, what it does for agents is it allows agents to stop being data collectors and data inputters and start to truly become risk managers and do and sell. Go sell more and help your clients manage their risks. Make sure they have the proper coverages. We're getting the data for you. Gone are the days of filling out ACORD apps for micro-commercial if you do business with Coterie. Check our work. We're pulling in third-party data sources. You can check our work on the back end, make sure it's all accurate, and get yourself comfortable with it. It's a new way of doing business. I describe it as kind of like... Do you remember when we first started using predictive modeling and underwriting in commercial lines? What was that, 2010? Here we are again. Trying to remember dates. It's like, "What was my electrical last update?"
That was, it almost seemed like a black box. Agents thought it was scary, but they didn't like it. But now it's the way we do business. And I think that third-party data is going to be exactly the same.
Ryan Hanley
I completely agree with you. I think it's very exciting. And your point about it allowing agents to be where they actually add value is key. This is one of the things our agency was based on: how do we remove these things that do not add value to the process? Me asking you the date your electrical was updated adds zero value to the transaction. If anything, it just annoys the crap out of you because you're like, "Why does that matter?" It's circuit breakers. You can see that. But you get into some of this nuance and you're like, "I can't even understand how that matters."
You're removing that layer of annoyance in the conversation. You get down to the nitty-gritty. You can actually do your job. You can figure out whether someone is full of shit and a good risk in like 10 minutes of conversation, whereas those conversations with a questionnaire take an hour. So now you're getting to the nitty-gritty in 10 or 15 minutes of conversation. You can have two or three of those conversations in the time you would have only been able to have one. Getting that time back is the key to growth and what makes me the most excited. Now salespeople can sell, service people can do service. We can be true advocates and advisors versus data collectors. If you're still a data collector, you're falling behind. There's no other way to put it.
Bobbie Collies
Absolutely. Well, I love to pick your brain on this a little bit too. I feel like in the last five years, if I visit a traditional retail agency, a lot of them will say, "My value proposition is I out-service the agent down the road." What does that even mean anymore, Ryan? I think we need to redefine service as an industry. Where is it needed in the customer experience for our policyholders? That's something we're tossing around internally too: what level of service do we need to provide to our policyholders to support our agency plan? How do we build up that model to make sure we're supporting our agents in the best way possible?
Ryan Hanley
My personal take on this is, if you guys have a dashboard or service capabilities for an internal service department in my agency to do everything they need to do, I don't need anything from you. The only time I need carrier help is when their functionality is so messed up, broken, or confusing that you can't get at it or you can't actually make the change. We write a decent amount of business with Chubb. I like a lot about Chubb. The servicing of policies with Chubb is probably one of the worst in the industry. I hope someone from Chubb is listening because your small commercial servicing is one of the worst. You can't do anything. I have to email someone for everything. And they are still having personnel issues because of COVID, like COVID still exists. It's like, go hire some people. You're Chubb. I can hire people, you should be able to hire people.
My point is, if my team has the capabilities to go into your back end and do the things we need to do—whether that's small updates, billing changes, named insured, address, just give us most of the standard stuff—then we don't really need a lot. I don't think service centers work in commercial. They don't work because no carrier is willing to service all of an agency's policies. There are very few clients in my agency who have just one carrier for all their policies. In personal lines, I think it's completely different with service centers because for the most part, you go home, auto, umbrella, it's all with the same carrier.
I built my original model for Rogue to be built on service centers. What I found is that if I had two policies with Cincinnati and one with Liberty, the insured calls. Cincinnati only services the Cincinnati policies, and Liberty only services the Liberty policies. Now they're making two calls to two different carriers and two different systems. There's no uniformity in any of it. Everyone has their own little take. That is a terrible experience for customers. As an internal team, you're going, "Does this carrier even have a service center? Are they any good?" Because they are drastically different in quality. Cincinnati's is very high. Liberty's is not as high. That's a very difficult thing to manage.
So I do think you need a team to manage service. We call it internally "client success." I know that's nuanced and kind of like marketing, but I do think the mentality should be, "How do I make this transaction a success?" Not "I'm going to service your policies," because a lot of times the customer may want to do everything themselves. They just want you to stamp it and say, "What you're doing is right." That could be a three-minute phone call. "Hey, I'm going to do this." "You're doing the right thing." Bam. All good. Make a note. Off you go. That's all it is.
A big problem—Newfront, which is an agency that just got a ridiculous amount of money, $200 million at a $2.2 billion valuation from Goldman Sachs—runs their entire service operation off of foreign call centers. Their retention level has to be terrible. From some of my friends, I know their retention level is terrible. I think you need a hybrid of American licensed professionals mixed with a team of well-trained virtual assistants to do unlicensed tasks. I think that model optimized through technology can provide the most efficient, effective, and high-retention service model possible. That is my personal belief. That mix gets you where you need to be.
I know every VC in the country looks at American CSRs and says, "Too expensive, get rid of them, use a call center." And you watch your retention rate drop from in the 80s to in the 40s. It's happened over and over again. I absolutely refuse to do it at Rogue. I will not do it because you can't show me a retention model in our industry that's a foreign call center or service model that is retaining in the 80s like a local agency. If someone listening has that number, I would love to see it. I've been doing this for 17 years and I have not found one model where someone is retaining equal to a local agency and has exported all their service. I just don't think it works.
Bobbie Collies
I agree with you on that. I think there's a good mix there. There are certain tasks that offshore would be perfect for. There are certain tasks where you just need a little more control and influence, Ryan. That's the biggest piece. Domestic, close to it, licensed agents that can help counsel your client through some changes.
Ryan Hanley
I don't think it needs to be local. I think it just needs to be domestic. My head of our select business team, she lives in Jacksonville, Florida. We have maybe two clients in Jacksonville, Florida tops. The rest are all throughout the country. Nobody cares that Leslie lives in Jacksonville, Florida. I think they would care if she lived on the other side of the planet, didn't really understand our culture, wasn't from here, didn't have the same timetable. In a service capacity, I do think they would care about that. I'm not saying anything about the Philippines or India. It's more if they were in France or the UK. It's about being here. There's a sense of security that I think small business owners are still looking for.
Bobbie Collies
Security and trust. I think about a few service calls I've made outside of our industry in the last six months and how frustrating it was because what I was saying wasn't being ingested the way I wanted it to be ingested. Solving a problem probably took 90 minutes when it could have taken 10 if it had been someone who just understood what I was trying to get at. So I'm with you.
Ryan Hanley
The hard part is—and I don't want to be negative against virtual assistants in any regard. I'm very pro virtual assistants. But this service can be crappy from local small business Americans too. I just moved my bank to Chase from a local bank. As an independent agent, I'm supposed to use a local bank because the money stays in the community. Except they're terrible. They close their bank at 4 PM. I can't get ahold of anybody. Their stupid app for virtual check deposit works one out of three times. You go to the line and everything takes forever. I go to Chase and it's snap, snap, snap. Done, done. "Oh, you have this problem?" "No problem." "Okay, here you go." Snap, done, done. I just can't handle the pace of the local bank.
Bobbie Collies
That's the thing. There are certain customer experiences that are becoming so great that they're becoming a necessary evil. They're so great that you can't not use them. Think about Amazon as an example. The amount of stuff I buy from Amazon versus anything local is outrageous. Insurance has always been a relationship business since I started. But I think there will be a shift where the customer experience outweighs the relationship. That's what we're seeing with your bank. You might have had a great relationship with your banker, but your experience and the convenience of Chase has outweighed that relationship.
Ryan Hanley
I could not agree with you more. There's a local men's clothing store I like to go to. Partially because I can be an open conservative in that environment and not have tomatoes thrown at me, and partially because they have cool, classically great clothes. Problem is, I'm six foot four and I have a size 13 shoe. They never have clothes that fit me. I look at the clothes and I like this jacket. I want this jacket. Then he has to send me to a website to buy it half the time because he doesn't carry my size or length. I really want to support this guy. He's a great guy. I really enjoy him. They'll give you a glass of scotch. It's a whole thing. But he never has stuff that fits me. I would love to support this local guy, but if I just go onto the same shop online and search size 13 shoes, there they are. Click, click. Two days later, they're in my mailbox.
Our lives are so busy. There's so much to think about today. When I talk to people, I talk about brain cycles. We only have so many cycles we can go through. Then you just don't have any more capacity. There are only so many things you can think about. At a certain point, even the smartest person can't think about another thing. Going back to my Chase versus local bank thing, I'm not proud to be supporting Chase Bank. They're a mega bank and I'm sure a lot of the financial issues we have are because of crazy stupid shit they do. But I can't handle doing a mobile deposit and having one go through and two not go through for whatever reason. Then I have to do it again or drive to the thing. I can't handle that. Those are brain cycles I don't want to waste on that activity. So I have to make the move.
I completely agree with you that in insurance, there's going to come that time. Granted, for complex accounts involving a lot of trucking or manufacturing, that day is way far away. But for the type of business we put with you guys—we put a lot of consultants with you because I really like your GL and professional liability thing. It takes two minutes. It makes complete sense. That type of person, do they really want to have an hour-long conversation with me about the dynamics of a professional liability exposure? No. They're like, "Am I covered?" "Yes." "Okay, great. Off I go." I don't want to waste time on this.
Bobbie Collies
It's more when insurance is a necessity for them to continue on with their day. It's the same situation with you and your bank. Small business owners just want to get it taken care of and move on. They don't want to think about their insurance, just like you don't want to think about your deposits that didn't go through twice. What are you guys talking about as it relates to embedded insurance or that concept? In 2015, 2016, the insurtech wave was going to disintermediate all that stuff. Obviously that didn't happen. But going through Rogue, channel partners is something we approach and work through.
Learning more about what embedded insurance really means—that scares the crap out of me. That feels like it could have a serious impact on the independent agency channel. When embedded insurance is actually working, the independent agent never even gets a shot at it. It never even comes down to their level. I create my business. I get my LLC. The LLC place is pitching me insurance. I set up payroll. They're pitching me insurance. I get a payment system. They're pitching me insurance. I've had three, four, five different insurance opportunities pitched at me by all the tools I'm using before I even get to the point where I would normally think about it and an independent agent would get involved.
Not today or even tomorrow, but that looks like it could make a real dent in the independent agency channel because there are just not as many at-bats available.
Here's what I'll say about embedded. David is actually talking about that on a panel at an industry event in the future. I think Coterie is set up based on our technology to play there. Based on my projections, even in the next five years, it could be a small portion of our distribution, but it's going to be the IA channel all the way. New in business risks are very hard to place for agents. Typically, an embedded experience is going to be a new in business risk. It's a risk that's out there with an LLC, to your point. They're going to get payroll services and there's an insurance option there. To some degree, yes, I think agents might lose out on that business. But it's hard to place business. How much time were they spending trying to place that business anyway? When those risks become a little bit more complex, that's when I think they're going to call an agent and say, "I don't know what to do with this anymore."
Ryan Hanley
How does that play? I'm a new in business startup contractor. I go to get a certificate of insurance somewhere and I buy insurance because I need a cert. Maybe it's quoted and bound through an embedded solution. But then now I have 15 employees, 10 fleet vehicles, or comp issues. My mod is going out of control. That's when I'm going to call an agent. I still think there's going to be a need for it. It's just what part of the cycle in a commercial lines risk will the agent need to step in.
Bobbie Collies
My concern there is, if we keep seeding new businesses to digital players, eventually those digital players are going to be able to provide the service and consultative offerings that that person never leaves. That is the argument you just made in small part. I get this from a lot of agents. "Ryan, you're writing all these small accounts, new businesses." Yes, we do. Based on how we acquire business, we do write a lot of small and new businesses. But 32% of our new business inquiries—the reason they're inquiring is their agent blows. Can't get a hold of them. Doesn't produce COIs. Doesn't get back to me. 32% of the accounts that come into Rogue Risk through our form field, the reason they're contacting us is because their agent isn't getting back to them.
When I look at that, I say, we all assume independent agents are good at what they do. That's not true. They've been local, and local was their competitive advantage. A lot of them have gotten lazy and sloppy. Most of the agents listening to this are probably not that case because you're listening, you're spending your time, you're getting better. I'm not just stroking my audience's ego. You wouldn't spend this time if you didn't think about your business. But there are 36,000 plus independent agencies across the country. If we're all just going for the complex scaled risk and forgetting about all the new businesses, those new businesses are going someplace. Eventually, agencies like mine who say, "I'm going to take that new business and provide them with the same service they get from a local agency," and eventually some of these VC-funded ones are going to wisen up and start to add real service offerings. That contractor who starts with one truck and goes direct, as their business grows and they get seven trucks, eventually that digital player is going to have the consultative offerings. They're just not going to need to leave. They're going to escalate.
That's what it is for us. Everyone who comes in starts with Select. As they grow from a client perspective, they graduate to what we call Premier. It's a completely different producer set. It's a completely different service team. You get onboarded to a team that thinks and operates like what we cliche an independent agency does. We're capturing them new and then allowing the ones that need to, to graduate to our team that can handle more complex risks. With what we were talking about earlier, I feel like there's a cliff coming if you completely forget about new businesses because there's not enough premium or whatever. I know you guys aren't doing that, but I feel like that's a big risk because we're seeding too much new stuff because it's new.
Every business started with one or two people. Every business.
Ryan Hanley
Yep. Absolutely.
Bobbie Collies
Here's what I'll say, Ryan. Similar to you, there are a lot of independent agents out there that are investing in positioning themselves to be able to continue to play as our industry becomes more digitized. Some of those are big players. There are some big networks, some big brokers out there that are building tech stacks, and they're going to be able to continue to play. Those that aren't are going to fade away and fall off that cliff. That's why you're seeing so much M&A happen and some of your larger networks grow so quickly. Agents don't know what to do with it. They just don't know what to do with it.
We're doing some things at Coterie to help coach them and try to help set them up for success, but they have to accept it. That's one of the hardest things I've seen from a tech standpoint with the IA channel. They understand the concept, but operationalizing anything into their operations is very difficult. Pulling in any comparative raters or a new marketing tool—Agency Revolution or even Record Referrals—how do you leverage those the best to grow your agency or retain your agency through some digital experiences? The concept is sold to the agents, but how do you actually do it is very difficult.
Ryan Hanley
Bobbie, I think that you guys at Coterie are doing a lot of the right things. It's very exciting to have you in the space. I love that when David and the founding team came in, it wasn't this anti-agent thing. It was all about agents. I know personally a bunch of agents who are more personal lines focused who this has allowed to start to dip their toe into providing small business insurance. That's a huge thing. A lot of carriers hold small business appointments over the head of personal lines agents and won't allow them to get these appointments. I think that's a travesty. You guys have set them up and given them that opportunity. I think it's an absolutely wonderful thing. You have a huge fan in me. Obviously we do business with you too. The only thing I'm pissed about is that you work for them and not for Rogue. That kind of makes me upset.
Bobbie Collies
Maybe one day we'll work together.
Ryan Hanley
I'm super excited. You talk about speed, simplicity, and service at Coterie. To your point, you're not requiring our agents to do any free underwriting. You're 100% relying on the model that Pete's building in the automated underwriting and third-party data. That's what makes it exciting. Anybody who's an insurance agent that wants to write small commercial can write it with us. There are no pre-qualifications. You want to contract, you're going to write business with us. We can have a conversation.
Bobbie Collies
That's awesome. If they want to learn more about Coterie or connect with you, where are the best places to do that?
Ryan Hanley
I would say look on our website, coterieinsurance.com. C-O-T-E-R-I-E insurance.com. There's some cool information out there about our agency partnerships and what those look like. You can also connect with me on LinkedIn. Ryan, I'm sure you'll put my profile or something with this podcast. If somebody wants to, I'll have the links in the show notes and all that good stuff.
Bobbie Collies
I appreciate it so much. Appreciate you coming on the show. I wish you nothing but the best. I know that you'll do some awesome things and we'll be hearing a lot more from you and the Coterie team as you guys continue to develop. It's great stuff.
Ryan Hanley
Thanks for the invite, Ryan. I appreciate it. Looking forward to Brian McGroach.
Host: Close twice as many deals by this time next week. Sound impossible? It's not. With the One Call Close System, you'll stop chasing leads and start closing deals in one call. This is the exact method we use to close 1,200 clients in under three years during the pandemic. No fluff, no endless follow-ups, just results fast. Based in behavioral psychology and battle-tested, the One Call Close System eliminates excuses and gets the prospect saying yes more than you ever thought possible. If you're ready to stop losing opportunities and start winning, visit masteroftheclosed.com. That's masteroftheclosed.com. Do it today.