Podcast Episode Summary
The podcast episode features a conversation with Tanner Hackett, the CEO and founder of Counterpart, an insurtech management liability company. The discussion revolves around Tanner's origin story, his company's mission, and the challenges he faced in the insurance industry.
Key Points:
Takeaways:
Participants:
Additional Resources:
Became a Master of the Close: https://masteroftheclose.com
In this episode of The Ryan Hanley Show, Ryan Hanley interviews Tanner Hackett, CEO, and founder of Counterpart, a management liability InsurTech reinventing the Commercial Insurance industry using the most robust data sets and cutting-edge technology, with the support and guidance of some of the most respected insurance, investment, and brokerage institutions in the world.
This is an absolutely tremendous conversation you don't want to miss...
Episode Highlights:
Key Quotes:
Resources Mentioned:
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Episodes You Might Enjoy:
Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.
Ryan Hanley
Hello everyone and welcome back to the show. Today we have an absolutely tremendous episode for you. A conversation with Tanner Hackett, the CEO and founder of Counterpart, an insurtech management liability company, which is using AI and ML and third-party data sources to learn about what is ultimately a very specialized liability coverage, and particularly focusing this product on small businesses. We talk about why small businesses, why management liability. We talk about Tanner's origin story. We talk about his strategy to deliver Counterpart as a product through wholesalers versus going out to a broader retail market. And we talk about entrepreneurship and leadership. This is just a tremendous conversation. These are the kind of conversations when I'm meeting someone new and connecting with them. This is why I do this podcast. I love these types of conversations. I mean, I love all the conversations I have on the show, but in particular, when I get to meet someone new and really get this deep on business and in our industry, it's an absolutely phenomenal experience. I think you're going to love this conversation.
Before we get there, I want to give you, the listeners of this show, a huge shout out. You continue to listen. You continue to be part of this community. It is always so special to me that you guys take time out of your day and consider this show, because I know if you're listening to this podcast, then you're not listening to others. You're not focusing on other things, and that means we're continuing to deliver value, which is the goal of the show. I do this work to deliver value to you guys, and I appreciate that it's connecting and that you listen and give me that mind space.
If you're looking to go deeper, I recently launched a new content community, Finding Peak. The tagline is "the pursuit of peak performance in business, life, and insurance." You can go to findingpeak.com, subscribe, it's free, check it out. We do some deeper dives and some Q&A material that is paid, but it's like $7 a month. The reason I do that is to get buy-in from the people who are going to be engaged and asking questions. That buy-in is a super small barrier. After the fees and stuff of the platform, I don't really make anything. It's mostly just to know who the committed people are and focus my attention there.
But it's free for anyone, and 75% plus of the content is free. So go to findingpeak.com, pop your email in, subscribe. The reason for that community is to help you better understand what's happening at Rogue Risk now, what we've learned, what I've personally learned, what our team is constantly giving me feedback on about building out this digital, distributed, human-optimized agency that I consider at least one prototype for the agency of the future. The successes, the challenges, how we overcome them, how we think through things—that's what Finding Peak is all about. As we touched on a little in this conversation with Tanner, it's the emotional side of the equation that we often do not consider as leaders, when often it's the emotional side of the business that creates the problems and the fragility in our business.
So if you're interested in more beyond this podcast, go to findingpeak.com.
I want to give a big shout out to Better Agency. Better Agency recently launched a Raider on their platform, a PL Raider. Big fan of Better Agency. They are not a sponsor of this show, but I love the people over there. I love what they're doing. Whether you use Better Agency or not, you have to give Will and Nick and the entire team at Better Agency props for continuing to push and innovate. It's fun to see people that I really care about doing great work and providing new products to our ecosystem. So big shout out to Will and Nick and the entire team over at Better Agency.
Last but not least, huge shout out to my people, the parent company of Rogue Risk, S-I-A-A. If you're looking to maximize your book of business, take the game to another level, connect with other professionals and agencies, a network of insurance individuals doing tremendous things, and maximize the revenue out of your current book of business and create growth opportunities, I would consider SIA. Start the journey into what it means to become a member of SIA at siaa.com.
Alright guys, if you love this content, please share, like, whatever you do. That's how we continue to grow the audience. I appreciate you all for listening. Let's get on to Tanner.
Audio begins
We don't produce the video, so you don't have to... I don't know if that matters to you. Don't worry about that.
Tanner Hackett
Oh, it's just the audio.
Ryan Hanley
Audio only, yep. I just use the video so that it's easier to talk to somebody when you can see their facial expression. I actually like that.
Tanner Hackett
Yeah. Let's do that.
Ryan Hanley
Okay. Yeah. So yeah, I only produce the audio, but I use the video just for talking purposes.
Tanner Hackett
Okay. Wonderful. Cool. Well, I put on clothes for you. Kind of a color.
Ryan Hanley
You do. You look good. So that's a good thing.
Both laugh
Well, hey, I appreciate you coming on the show. Looking through everything that you're doing, I hadn't heard about you before your team reached out, but once I started digging into what you're doing, I was obviously very interested. I would love to get the origin story for you. Let's start with you. What's the origin story? I know it's not every little boy and girl's dream to grow up to be an insurance professional, at least not most of us. However, we all fall into it somehow. So I'm interested in where you come from and how you got here. We can start there and then dig in.
Tanner Hackett
Yeah, well, first of all, thanks for having me. As I mentioned, I've been following your podcast for a bit. This is a great recognition that we're doing something right to be here today talking to you. We've intentionally been pretty quiet about what we've been doing publicly. We operate through the broker channel, so we've been galvanizing that distribution channel about all the good things we're doing. I wouldn't be surprised if you start to hear more and more about us as brokers tout our benefits to small businesses.
For me personally, even that was a learning, just looking at distribution and how that works in insurance. I come from more of an entrepreneurial tech background. I started a few companies before, one in the e-commerce space in Southeast Asia, a large e-commerce company that was actually bought by Alibaba a few years ago, and also built a large marketing company out in New York, close to you. I was working in Manhattan. This journey into insurance, as you hinted, wasn't what I aspired to at a young age. It was actually something I fell into as I became acquainted with this one product that I kept purchasing as a business owner, which was management liability. It was required through the covenants in raising venture money to purchase D&O. And in New York State, having EPLI is super important.
It was a roundabout way. You can tell from the name, Counterpart was actually begun as an HR tech company. I had to move back to Los Angeles for some family reasons, and I had this idea in the back of my head predicated on some success we had in my previous company, Button, the marketing company, where we really put people first. We did so by investing in software systems, compliance, collaboration tools that were just starting to come out. This was early 2013, 14, 15. HR software was starting to heat up. You had tools like Lattice and CultureAmp. You had PEOs that were beginning to take off. We saw how these tools could be applied to help employees with everything from finding the right employees—hiring, onboarding, training, learning and development software, collaboration tools like Slack. It was really taking off.
We were looking at how this framework could be applied to create workplaces where people were empowered to operate, where there was more collaboration across the team. People stayed for a really long time. We created this strong culture around this tooling. So I started this company, was very jazzed about bringing software tech, democratizing HR software to small businesses where I saw this need. At a certain size of company, you have compliance teams, risk teams, heads of finance, heads of HR. If you're 10, 15 people, you don't have that infrastructure. What are you going to do? Who do you reach out to? I saw this as a lightweight way of bringing this infrastructure in.
The challenge is that even this is a second-order priority for a small business. You're thinking about how you're going to make payroll this month, your goals this quarter, or just making the best product you can make, let alone thinking about compliance, governance, and collaboration. We struggled with this tool. There wasn't a lot of buy-in. Talking to all my entrepreneurial friends, I got a little bit of the Heisman where it's, "Come back to me next quarter, come back in six months." The red alerts go off in your brain when you hear this as an entrepreneur. I'm sure a lot of people listening can relate. When you hear that, you've got to pivot.
In my case, the realization was that this thing I had been purchasing for a while, management liability, actually had coverages for the externalities that occur when you're not doing these things. When you don't have a good hiring practice, when you don't have compliance, when you're not collaborating. That's when there's friction in the company that could lead to wrongful terminations, harassment, discrimination, negligence, misrepresentations—the things that lead to directors and officers claims, employment practices claims, judiciary claims, crime claims. Seeing an uptick in these in 2015, 16, 17 became very evident that there was a need for somebody to think about these products holistically: how do you attack the risk management piece while at the same time think about this product and what the needs are for a small business?
So here I am, this insurance geek now. I'm obsessed with insurance. I think this product is so powerful. I think it's so important for our society. But to be honest, we have a long ways to go with the adoption of technology in the same way that I've seen it apply to my previous companies.
Ryan Hanley
I have a whole bunch of questions in there. First, what was your initial feeling when you started this HR company, working on it and testing it out in the market, and then you start to pivot into insurance? For a long time, I fought the idea that insurance was different. I always heard "we're different, this is different, we're unique," and for a long time I was like, "Eh, everybody loves to say they're different, but they're not really. It's the same set of problems passed through a different set of filters." Well, I have come to really believe that insurance is different. I've been in the insurance industry for almost 17 years now, and it wasn't until these last three years that I launched Rogue Risk, my own digital commercial agency, that I really started to believe that insurance was different.
There are the state regulatory matters, the technology, the information capture, the disparate nature of the providers. You have all these different manufacturers in terms of insurance carriers distributing their product on all these different platforms and in all these different ways. In most other industries, there's a universal connector between all the manufacturers and the distributors. In insurance, there really isn't. So when you first started running up against some of these issues, what was the first one that made you go, "Oh wow, okay, this is a little different than building a marketing tech company or an e-commerce tech company"?
Tanner Hackett
Man, there are so many. I love the way you put this. And by the way, as an entrepreneur, I just want to celebrate that for you, launching your own company. It is not easy. It is a humbling experience in so many different dimensions. That is the backbone of our society. That is why we're focused on small businesses, because it is so hard. That bar is getting higher and higher every day to go and pursue your dream. We are dedicated to helping people understand what their exposures are and helping them grow.
There's that old saying that history doesn't repeat itself, but it rhymes. You can apply that same lens to just about any entrepreneurial journey. It's pattern matching the things that are very, very similar, and then you try and figure out where there's asymmetry. For me, that asymmetry happened in distribution. In my previous companies, e-commerce and marketing, you have partnerships, direct, affiliate, performance. There are lots of different ways to get your product to market. What's nuanced about insurance is that this is a very complicated product, especially in the case of management liability. Not many people know what it is. There's a great rationale to have a broker involved in this process. Then there's this wholesale broker side too, which aggregates the risk for retail agents because retail agents have to understand this very broad expanse of products. It's tough to keep all of these in their head—the difference in exposure between product liability and employer practices liability.
Understanding the dimensions, the roles of these different participants in the distribution chain, where we should fit as a specialty product—management liability isn't necessarily required by law. It's usually contractual or highly recommended depending on the industry or state. It's often seen as a luxury. To a lot of startups, purchasing this product is a luxury, like you hit a certain level of success and then you get this coverage. To me, this is day one kind of stuff. You hire the wrong person in the wrong way and your idea is over before you even get out the door for no reason that has to do with your product.
Ryan Hanley
I love the way you said that too, because it's existential. One of these things goes wrong. You're human. We say things, things happen. We make a mistake. And that's game over for your company if you get hit with one of these claims or lawsuits.
Tanner Hackett
Exactly. That was the big learning. It's like, "Oh my gosh, this thing is so important." There's this distribution chain, the scale of knowledge about these products. Where do we fit? How do we help communicate our novelty in the market, the way we're approaching this, the value we bring to the small business in the most efficient way? We work with wholesale brokers. Wholesale brokers are the experts in the space and they help to distribute to retail agents. Obviously, the retail agents are working directly with the small businesses. We're trying to figure out ways to partner with our wholesale brokers to help educate the retail agents who are at the point of sale of small businesses, and make sure that this message is delivered about why we're different from the 10 other markets that might be providing a competitive service.
Ryan Hanley
Why did you decide to go wholesale to retail versus just going right to bringing on retail brokers and working with retailers directly? This isn't a judgment, I'm just interested.
Tanner Hackett
It's kind of the power law. Looking at having tens of thousands of agents and then looking at wholesale brokers who are already experts in this product line, it's a pretty easy sell to show them how we thought about this differently, what our unique coverages were, how quickly we could get a product to them, our insured services, our claims management support. You talk to a wholesale broker for three minutes and they get it. It was a much longer sales process for a retail agent to wrap their heads around: "Okay, got it. Management liability. It should be in the toolkit of any small business. And here's where Counterpart stands apart." The wholesale agents have been fantastic from giving us leverage with this distribution channel. They're aggregators of this risk. We can go to work with one group, and we work with the largest wholesale brokers in the world. I think we have about 30, 35 wholesale brokerages that we work with today. They give us volume of submissions, but they're also our disseminators. They're the shepherds of our product. They're galvanizing adoption with the retail agents and with small businesses. It's been a very strong partnership with our wholesale brokers.
Ryan Hanley
Have you found that they've been willing to take on the product and distribute it? Obviously for them to push your product, they're not pushing a relationship that they previously had with another carrier. I like to think of carriers as manufacturers. You're moving in on a space where they already had relationships for management liability product. Have you found that your value propositions—which I'm really interested in and would like you to get to—have you found that they see your value propositions as a competitive advantage and a differentiator? Or has it been just, you're another one in the mix that they're quoting? What has been your experience? I'm sure it's different with every single one, but in general, has the uptake been fast or have you had to really work for it?
Tanner Hackett
No, it's been remarkably consistent. When we share with them not only the forms, but also our service model, which is based on speed and using third-party data to be smarter about a risk so we can get really aggressive in certain cases—in other cases, we explain why we're not comfortable with the exposures of the small business—it's that quick turnaround time. Brokers need to see in this small business space where they're being flooded with submissions. These are premium values that are pretty low, also pretty low risk. These are very transactional accounts. In large part, they just need somebody that's going to be there to respond quickly, to pick up the phone, to discuss options with them. That's through combining technology, workflows, and data with an unbelievable team of what we call risk engineers, underwriters that are there to support our broker community. It's been remarkable how much support we've received from the wholesale broker channel and how quickly we've been able to grow with them.
Ryan Hanley
This is anecdotal, but do you find when you say "risk engineers," people look at you like you have three heads? They're like, "What the hell are you talking about?"
Tanner Hackett
I do. And people not only look at me, they say it to my face. I think it goes to the point you mentioned before about this industry having a certain philosophy and a certain inertia in moving forward. I want to question certain things. I think there's too much around this idea of "disrupt." That's not what I want to do. But I want to create transparency. I want to question: should an underwriter be doing underwriting jobs in today's environment where data is so accessible and can get you a large part of the way there? What is the point of an underwriter? An underwriter is actually to help a system learn, to train a system, to create the rating factors so that there's consistency in the system.
It's observing what the externalities are, how the market is shifting, and how our rating model or our coverage needs to evolve. Then for unique risks, they can jump in and support the broker and the small business, and use this as a data point to retrain the system. I truly do see them as these engineers, more so than underwriters. "Underwriters" doesn't capture all the value and all the contributions they make to the system. It's too account-based, and that's not our philosophy. Our philosophy is about building a system.
Ryan Hanley
The reason I ask you that is we call our service team members "client success." I started out with "client success advocates" as the original title when I wrote my business plan, because I wanted the philosophy to be: I want you as a service person to think of yourself as advocating in every way for our client. You don't work for the carrier. I'd almost rather you pushed against me in moments where you think our client needs something that maybe they're not getting. You are a client success advocate. I hope this doesn't happen to you, because I love what you just said and I agree with your philosophy, but I have been worn down by people saying, "You mean account manager, right?
Or you mean a CSR, right?" And I'm like, "Oh, yes, yes. I mean a CSR. Yes." But the idea is I don't want them to think of themselves as just CSRs, which has this kind of negative connotation. I want them to think of themselves as the most important person in our company to that client. You are their advocate in our company. That's what I wanted the philosophy to be, and it is how we still train them. But I've just been bludgeoned by people going, "You mean account manager, right?" And I'm like, "Yes, I'm talking about account manager, but..." Even though on their job descriptions they're still CSAs, we inevitably refer to them as account managers and CSR sometimes too.
I kind of hate myself after hearing how you've stuck to your guns. But it is funny how people just don't want to change. They just can't do it.
Tanner Hackett
That reversion to the mean is a very, very powerful force. It's going to be especially challenging as you grow. You're fighting against size and gravity. It becomes much more difficult to push against. The only advice I would give you is consistency in the way you message the team. Constant reminders and having a cadence for how you speak about it. It's like values in a company or nomenclature. It's just repetition. We go through our values every week as an organization. We speak about our values. I think a lot of the team can recite these off the top of their head. It creates stickiness, but old habits die hard.
Ryan Hanley
I completely agree with that. To the gravity piece, as you grow, you're fighting larger and larger battles. The battles become bigger and there are more of them. Some of these battles that seem smaller, like this particular naming of our service professionals, at a certain point you're like, "Oh my God, I am fighting this battle that is taking 90% of my brain cycles over here. I don't have the brain cycles left. Yes, account manager, whatever." I'm trying to take this mountain over here and I have this little thing happening over there. You just run out of brain cycles sometimes to fight these battles.
But if you can, I agree with you. We do try. The other thing that happens too, and I think it's incredibly admirable and awesome that you're talking about your values every week. I try very hard to do that, but it is easy to get lost in the shuffle. I have also found that at certain points in the company's evolution, you hit moments where there's more or less. When there's less, you can come back to things like, "Here's why we're here. Here's what we believe. Here's our philosophical beliefs." Then things get hectic and you're like, "I'm just trying to keep all 10 fingers and toes in holes in the dam."
Those things can get lost. The leaders that I admire the most are the ones that seemingly can stay consistent and push through that, even though those things are happening, or not let it bother them as they push through. So that's really good advice.
Tanner Hackett
I just appreciate the rawness that you're bringing in this conversation. It is so real. As an entrepreneur, to be able to compartmentalize all this and still grow and meet your investor expectations, this is exactly what I'm talking about. The reason I get out of bed every day is I want to support entrepreneurs like you that are challenging things, that are doing things different. You talk about culture, and there's so much said about culture. Culture is in large part planted by the founder and people rally around that. This idea of good culture and bad culture—I don't believe in good culture or bad culture.
I believe that culture is a function of the business, the mindset of the company, the vision, the principles. Where the dissonance happens is if there is not alignment between the people working there and the values of the company. That is bad. But there are some companies that just want to work 80 hours a week and they're perfectly successful because they're hiring people that want to work 80 hours a week. There are other companies that are creatives and they need the headspace, and people can be perfectly successful working 20 hours a week. I love the way you're thinking about things. I think it's the right approach.
There's so much knowledge out there about how to run organizations. It sounds like you're well-versed in this stuff too. We want to be advocates for small businesses, for leaders, to provide that support. Obviously it benefits us too when our policyholders are thinking about governance, business operations, compliance. It's something I've spent a lot of time thinking about. The data also yields that companies are less likely to have claims and are going to have better outcomes financially when they start to think about culture as well.
Ryan Hanley
What's up, guys?
Sorry to take you away from the episode. But as you know, we do not run ads on this show. And in exchange for that, I need your help. If you're loving this episode, if you enjoy this podcast, whether you're watching on YouTube or you're listening on your favorite podcast platform, I would love for you to subscribe, share, comment if you're on YouTube, leave a rating review if you're on Spotify or Apple iTunes, et cetera. This helps the show grow. It helps me bring more guests in. We have a tremendous lineup of people coming in, men and women who've done incredible things, sharing their stories around peak performance, leadership, growth, sales, the things that are going to help you grow as a person and grow your business.
But they all check out comments, ratings, reviews. They check out all this information before they come on. So as I reach out to more and more people and want to bring them in and share their stories with you, I need your help. Share the show. Subscribe if you're not subscribed. And I'd love for you to leave a comment about the show because I read all the comments. Or if you're on Apple or Spotify, leave a rating review of this show. I love you for listening to this show, and I hope you enjoy it as much as I do creating the show for you. All right, I'm out of here. Peace. Let's get back to the episode.
The episode resumes
I saw a quote. I was listening. Who knows? You read so much. I can't remember exactly what it was, but the gist of it was whether the leader is focused on driving culture or not, they are. You know what I mean? Whether you are focused on growing culture or you're not focused on growing culture, you're impacting culture. As a leader, you cannot get away from the fact that if you decided to take a leadership role, even if it's not the tippy top leadership role, even if it's the executive suite or a managerial role, you are impacting the culture of the company when you decide to take that position, because people watch you and they feed off what you do.
I think that particularly in insurance, oftentimes the individuals who hold leadership roles tend to be great practitioners, not people who necessarily chose to be and focus on being great leaders. That doesn't mean they aren't or can't be. It just means oftentimes the leadership roles tend to get given to great practitioners. So they're not necessarily versed in or love learning about and practicing and cultivating things like culture, things like mission. They see those as—and again, this isn't a knock—because they're great practitioners, they just haven't taken the time, nor do they value these concepts. Their idea is, "All we need to do is sell more stuff. We sell more stuff, we good. That's our goal. We sell stuff. I don't care if you hate working here. I send you a paycheck. Be happy with it." That's the way most people operate.
What we've really found at Rogue is—one, I didn't name it the Hanley Insurance Agency because I didn't want the business to be about me. I love the fact that I have this amazing team that every day is working to get me out of the business, out of working in the business, so I can work on it. That's a great thing. They're not upset. They're not fighting me. They're operating to get me out of day-to-day, which is an amazing thing, so I can work on things like culture. If I was a practitioner, if I was still getting value from doing the thing, I could never step out and focus on these things like culture, which I think is what you have to do.
All that being said, I think the point that you just made around whatever you want your business to be, it should be that thing. Whether it's an 80-hour-a-week job, a 30-hour-a-week job, or only nights and weekends, whatever your culture is going to be, you have to be hard and fast in marketing it that way and hiring that way. We hire a lot of moms. We just do, because a lot of insurance agencies, thankfully, are misogynistic and want people to work 8:30 to 4:30 on a punch-in, punch-out basis. If you're a mom—and there are dads too, but they tend to be moms—who have kids that get sick or have to go into school late, or need to do this or that, their lives tend to need some flexibility. We as a company, and I made this our mission from the very beginning, are completely willing because we're results-based to be flexible around those points. You need to take your kid to the doctor at 3 p.m.? No problem. I trust because you're an adult and we're a results-based organization that you will either come in later, come in earlier, or work doubly hard the next day to get your numbers and do the things you need to do for your actual job. That's the way we work.
We made the mistake of hiring a couple individuals who were slightly on the misogynistic side. They were of the opinion that most of the females in our organization didn't know shit. That was their general disposition. That did not fly. We punted those sons of bitches really quick. They were high performers, seemingly high performers—they were hitting their numbers and doing very good work. But you can't have that in your business if you're going to be successful if it doesn't match what you're trying to do. If we were a locker room mentality company where we all beat our chests and fought with each other and were competitive, like *Boiler Room* or *Wolf of Wall Street*, they would have been awesome in that environment. It just wasn't what we were building. You have to get those people out.
Unfortunately, especially early in a company's genesis, it's very difficult to let high performers go if they don't match culture because you're like, "Oh my God, who's going to sell this thing?" Since they've been gone, we haven't skipped a beat. Other people have stepped up and everyone is happier. I think that's a really, really important point.
Tanner Hackett
I love it. The thread here is consistency. Consistency is incredibly important, especially when you have strong vision and you're seeing repeated success. It is so easy to get off that path.
Ryan Hanley
It is. There's so many turns. It could be a partnership that seems all nice and fun and shiny. Could be an employee. Could be an investor. You have to constantly, as a business leader, take a step back. You also have to create an environment where you're open to that feedback from the team.
Tanner Hackett
One of the things we did—we had the entire company down in San Diego last week for a company on-site. We're completely remote. We flew everybody in to San Diego and we just had this open discussion. One of our values is "speak boldly and honestly." There were moments where people spoke very boldly and honestly about our OKRs. We use the OKR system—Objective Key Results. I highly advise anybody listening to take a look at this if they're looking for structure around goals on a quarterly basis. *Measure What Matters* by John Doerr is the book that really breaks that concept down. It's not perfect. There's no perfect solution. I don't want to pretend that this is just read the book and go apply it. This requires commitment, requires consistency. The team gave me great feedback that despite having all the structure, it still felt like we didn't have a clear focus. We walked out of that meeting and cut our OKRs in half. Now we're focused on half the OKRs. Everyone needs a speed check now and then. You need to invite people to be able to speak up and have trust.
Have you heard of Project Aristotle from Google?
Ryan Hanley
I have not, no.
Tanner Hackett
It's a really interesting study by Google, which is one of the most respected companies of the century. They tried to figure out what really makes for high-performing teams. Off the top of my head, I'm like, "Of course, it's talent, it's education, it's having certain people in certain groups." They couldn't figure it out for the longest time until they started to look at the psychological elements of the team. What they found is that when there's psychological safety and trust in a team, those are the highest-performing teams. Irrespective of backgrounds, irrespective of the talent of the team, when there's trust, that is the team that's going to perform better on a more consistent basis.
I challenge everybody to bring this into their organization, because what you're going to learn from somebody that's two levels down, what they're seeing in the field, is probably going to shock you. It probably doesn't bubble up to the top very much because people might be afraid of communicating it to you. You as an entrepreneur have to deal with all these things. It's really enlightening. You're not going to change everything. We're not superhuman. But creating that environment where at least people feel their opinions are valued and they're heard creates a very collaborative spirit. People are also more willing to take feedback themselves.
Ryan Hanley
Yeah. If they know the CEO is open to it, they're going to be like, "Okay, he can take a few punches about his philosophy. Maybe I can be better myself."
I think you're wholly right. Especially about the last piece. You can't hold your employees to a standard that you're unwilling to live by yourself. If I've learned anything in the various leadership roles I've had throughout my career, if you are unwilling to do something or live by a standard, you cannot hold your employees to that standard. You just can't.
This is very selfishly why I have a flexible work environment. I'm a divorced single dad. I have to do shit during the day that is personal. Sometimes my kids have this, sometimes I have to do that. I haven't been grocery shopping in weeks and I have to run out and grab something so I can eat because I work from home. How can I, if I prefer as a leader to be held to a results-based philosophy with a flexible work schedule, then tell my employees, "You have to be in your seat 8:30 to 4:30 and punch this card, and that's how I'm going to judge your performance," even though I can run out and hit the gym at noon real quick and come back because I know I'll log in at 8 p.m. and get work done from 8 to 10? I can't tell my employees that they can't have that bit of flexibility in their lives. That disconnect is the number one way to completely trash your culture.
You see this a lot. You're the producer. You've been there for three or four years. You're sitting in an agency and you see the agency principal log out at 11 a.m. and go play golf every Friday for the entire summer. The standard philosophy is, "That individual invested time, money, resources, built this business. They've earned that right." I can buy that certain levels of seniority and risk-taking provide you with certain levels of flexibility. But it can't be "you live this way, I live this way." Maybe it's you get one Friday a month that you can go play golf or have a half day. Summers are a big deal up here because they're so short. I know people who have literally quit jobs because they've watched the owners have all this flexibility to enjoy their summers and they get zero.
I don't think people expect—I think people intrinsically understand the difference between someone who has taken the risk and earned the right to have the max benefit of a culture. But to give someone no benefit or to create a completely separate set of rules for everyone else versus leadership, that just destroys trust. It destroys all the things you just talked about that make a healthy environment. You're holding yourself to a different standard. How can you expect people to want to live up to it? It just doesn't work that way.
Tanner Hackett
Yeah. And you bring in the insurance lens. I've only been in this industry for about three years. There's that element which is consistent across every company. But then there's this big challenge in insurance, which is going from a digital 1.0 world to a 2.0 world. You look at a lot of the leadership across some of the big insurance institutions, and you use this word "practitioners." I love this word. In today's environment, you need to be a strategist. You need to be technologists. You need to be questioning everything because the way business has been conducted over the past 10, 20, 30 years clearly is not what it's going to look like 10, 20, 30 years from now.
There's been in insurance this general attitude of "Let's wait and see what happens." It's a fast-follower mentality.
Ryan Hanley
Exactly. Fast follower.
Tanner Hackett
Frankly, it's one of the last bastions of email processing and these workflows. The administrative work in this industry is kind of mind-boggling when I come from other industries. I think it's safe to say it's going to change pretty quickly. There are some folks leaning into this, but I also see this general hesitation to be the first. There's no incentive in a large insurance carrier to adopt these new practices because you're not rewarded for doing so. Nobody is patting John or Jane on the back saying, "Great job with this new digital platform," because most of the time people are irritated from having to change their behavior. People get their pitchforks out when you come and move their keys.
It's really tough to be a leader these days in the insurance space and move the industry forward because people are so entrenched in their current workflows and processes. I spoke at this conference, the Dig In conference, and they really prodded me for what I would do if I was in a big insurance carrier. I tried to caveat as much as possible, but I really challenged some folks. I was like, "What is your value? Come back to the core principles. How do you contribute value to the company? How is it today? What do you think it should be?" I saw people shaking their heads like, "Oh, this is a bit uncomfortable."
People were shaking their shoulders, looking around. It's a testament to—I think people want to change. There are brilliant people in this industry. We're shining the spotlight on the fact that maybe there are other ways you can contribute value. We're not saying we need to go off the rails. There's much more good than bad. But let's have an honest conversation about how we contribute value to these small businesses that need a better product, that need it faster, that need more transparency, that needs to be more consumable. A lot of times you're just getting a PDF document as a policy form.
What are they supposed to do with this?
Ryan Hanley
I have so many thoughts on this particular topic. About three weeks ago, I did a just-off-the-cuff video for LinkedIn. I was on a walk. I just got done with two consecutive carrier calls where I questioned the UX of the carrier. They were peppering me for why we aren't writing more business with them. I said, "Because your UX is terrible. It's incredibly difficult to do business with you." They pushed back: "That's not what we're hearing." I said, "Okay, I do a straight behavioral experiment every day. I send a shit ton of leads to my producers and they choose where the business goes. Do you think they choose because they dislike you? They hate your brand, your logo, your colors? Or do they choose it because some variation of your product, your pricing, and your user experience does not match up with what makes their job easy? We're all super selfish. We all want to do what's easiest."
A producer, 99 out of 100 times, with a bar of quality coverage—after you hit that bar of quality coverage, the next most important trigger for where the business goes is who's the easiest to do business with. Not price, not schmoozing, not cyber reports. It's how easy is it to do business with you. I've watched this over hundreds, thousands of opportunities coming into Rogue, watching where the producers put them. In this case, I said to them, "The vast majority of our small business goes to The Hartford. The reason is because The Hartford is really, really, really easy to do business with, considering they also have contingency and bonus programs. Companies like Coterie are great, except they don't have a contingency or bonus program. If I can get standard commission and contingencies with Hartford, I make more money there. So that's where I go."
Hartford seems to be incrementally building efficiencies into where the puck is going. Versus other carriers who I know call their biggest broker, who's probably 67 years old, who hasn't logged into the system in 20 years, who has Sally or Tammy or Jimmy or Johnny in the office who does it, who places the business there because they feel like that's what the owner wants. They don't give a shit because they're only placing a couple of pieces of business a week anyway. The owner comes back and goes, "Yeah, you're fine. I don't get any complaints." They go, "Okay, great. We're doing awesome." They're playing to where the puck is today, the way the business is done today.
If someone asked me on stage that same question they asked you, I would say, "I would make every decision based on where the puck is going. We would iterate to where the puck is going, not monumental tear-down, rebuild changes." The insurance industry isn't broken. That's the big secret that the disruptors of 2015 and 2016 didn't get. They went to Silicon Valley, did some sort of NBA dick regression analysis, and said, "Insurance is an opportunity. These people are all idiots. We're going to change it." What they didn't understand is it wasn't broken. Insurance is not broken. If your building burns down, if you get into a car accident, if you do something stupid, your insurance company shows up and hands you a check and says, "Here's as much as we can financially based on the policy you bought." That is how the business is supposed to work. Your town is not rallying to put your house back up if it burns down. They're just going to yell at you because you have a shitty smoldering building making their home value go down. The only entity that's going to rebuild that home for you is the insurance company. So it's not broken.
That being said, the vast difference between the carriers that I see today succeeding and the carriers that I see stagnating has to do with the singular idea of iterations to where the puck is going versus where it is. I think that startups like you, like Coterie—I love the people at Coterie, it's not a knock on them—they're new and growing. I feel like starting their own internal agency and going D2C, I'm completely fine telling them I think that was a mistake from a brand perspective. Everyone knows, and it kind of keeps agents who don't like to compete against carriers down, although we compete against all our carriers. They just need a contingency program and Coterie will be fine. I see Coterie, I see Pie, I see Cover Whale in transportation. I see you guys, this next generation—not disruptors, innovators—pushing the carriers that are thinking the right way to match it. The hard part is now you're competing against juggernauts. But I think it's worthy work. I know many of you are going to reap the benefit personally, but also from a purpose and meaning standpoint, do really important work and really change things, which I think is incredible.
I want you to comment on that if you have a thought. And then I have one more question. I want to be respectful of your time. Your product is marketed to a certain extent on being built on AI, which no one knows what that means at all. I would love to have any comments you have on what I just said, and then move that into what is AI and how are you using it.
Tanner Hackett
Yeah. Quick response to what you're saying. Brilliantly said. I would say that moving to where the puck is going to be—I can tell you where the puck is going to be. Think about the Amazon philosophy: people want better pricing, they want it faster, and they want more options. Put that in your head. Everybody should be thinking about this. The Internet of Things is creating more transparency. People are realizing, "Oh my gosh, I have more options. I have more agents I can work with. I have more wholesalers I can work with. I have more carriers I can work with." Options are becoming more evident to them. You need to be thinking, "How can I elevate? How can I provide better service, better pricing? How can I be smarter about how I underwrite? How can I just create more value?" That's really what it comes down to. It happens at every layer of the distribution stack.
As it relates to what we're doing specifically—being a tech entrepreneur several times before, most technology is grounded in data. It's how you apply data to solve problems, to be faster, to provide more options, better service. In our case, it was understanding what are the exposures of small businesses. I'm here in Los Angeles, California. There are like 10 restaurants around me within a mile radius. If I was to get a submission for these restaurants, they'd probably look all the same. Roughly the same number of employees, same zip code, probably a lot of the same practices around wage and hour and employment training.
They would come up on a PDF application. But there's lots of nuance between these actual small businesses that you can pick up from knowing where to look. This is looking at lawsuit information. Maybe it's not a claim against the company for management liability, but we want to know if this company has been operating compliantly within state regulation around accessibility. Things that wouldn't pop on a PDF application, but it just shows the governance, the compliance of this business. Or what are employees, customers saying about this company? What are the other financial variables that we can pick up about the business?
This is through public and private APIs that we're pinging information. As an entrepreneur, I'm sure you've spoken to a lot of tech companies. They talk about AI. Even to be able to talk about AI, which I'll get to in a bit, there is so much data engineering complexity to be able to find this data, to pull this data into your system structure in such a way that you can then build the AI models. The AI models are the application layer on top of massive data infrastructure that needs to be built. The AI layer is really understanding, "If this company is compared against similar companies, what's the risk profile of this business on a relative basis?"
If you think of what an underwriter does in a traditional company, if it's an account that's sizable enough to be worth their time to go search for this, maybe they're going to go to Google and say, "I'm going to query lawsuits against the Hyatt in Venice Beach." They'll be like, "Oh, great, nothing there. Fantastic. I've done my job." Or maybe they're going to Yelp and scrolling through to see if anybody says anything bad about this company. In our case, we're looking at a multitude of different factors. I think we have like 18 different sources for data that we're going to. We're able to ingest this information and get a relative score.
Maybe you do find something on Google about this company, but it's such a massive company. Is this normal behavior where you get a few lawsuits for a hotel of that size? Or is this something I should worry about and need to modify the account for?
So AI is able to ingest this information in such a way that it normalizes it. It normalizes the behavior and response of an individual that's trying to interpret this and tells them how meaningful the signal is and how they should change their behavior, the underwriting of this company.
And then it also allows for this human in the loop to provide a signal back to the model. The model says, "Okay, you showed me what was important. You kicked this thing out for referral." Me as a human, I can interpret this information. And then I can tell you whether the next time this thing comes up, the model should kick it out on a similar basis. So you're training the model as much as the model is telling somebody where to look. It's identifying the signals.
This is how you get what I call bionic underwriting. The system does most of the work, but you still have a human there to interpret the asymmetries of the risk and be able to say, "Oh, this is a great account. Our system is pricing here, but I see that we can probably do much better because I know that manufacturing in Ohio, we've built a really strong book here." Again, this reinforces the book. It says, "Hey, we should continue to mod to change our underwriting for manufacturers in Ohio."
Similarly, California, we know that the exposures are just increasing here. If you underwrite just historically, maybe it looks okay. But with the litigation trends in California, we need to be continuously modifying the accounts up. So that's one piece of it on the underwriting side.
But then think about this account during the policy term. Now we've written this account. Now we're on the policy. And I want to get back to risk mitigation because this is really why I started the company. You spoke about these employees that you hired. There was controversy around these employees where it wasn't a good culture fit. What probably happened was you had people that were leaving the business. There's a little bit of turnover. People were a bit disgruntled. Maybe it impacted your financials.
We're monitoring these signals throughout the term of the policy and saying, "Hey, are there things that we should be thinking about from a risk mitigation standpoint that we can propose to the company?" We say, "Hey, talk to our HR experts. We have HR experts on call." In the case of these two employees that you needed to fire, not many people know how to fire well. There's a very clear process depending upon the state of how you terminate an employee and do it without them suing you for wrongful termination. There's a very fine line that I advise everybody getting counsel about before they do this.
We are saying, "Hey, before you fire him, come talk to us. We'll give you the playbook on how to run this so you don't have a claim." Or somebody says, "Oh, somebody said this really uncomfortable thing to me that could be construed as harassment. Somebody reported this." We say, "Come talk to us. Come talk to us. We'll share guidance on how to communicate to the employee, how to communicate to the company about this event." So you're not burying this. That's where things go wrong. It's not the events, because humans say things that might be misinterpreted. It's how the company responds, how leadership responds in these events that lead to the adverse outcomes, the claims, et cetera.
We want to be partners to these small businesses. We have a handbook builder for companies. We have harassment discrimination training. We have tons of data on this new legislation. I think there's 60 new pieces of legislation coming out for small businesses just in 2023. On January 1, 2023, new pieces of legislation that I'm certainly not reading up on my municipal and state legislation about how this impacts me and wage and hour laws. We want to be advocates for these small businesses. We want to take this off their plate because we talked about how hard it is to be a small business already. We want to be educating these businesses about what their exposures are, how their risks are changing, and how our product responds to those risks. Things happen in a small business, and we want to be able to respond with great claims management when they do.
Ryan Hanley
I want to be respectful of your time, so we'll wrap this up. But just to finish off that idea, I love that. To me, the advantage of data is not just marketing. I think a lot of people immediately just think marketing and sales data, or maybe they think pricing of products with data. But so much of it can be the communications, the comms, the proactive outreach. You can subscribe to certain databases. You can see increases in payroll, increases in revenue within days of when they happen and send out messages. "Hey, your payroll just increased by a hundred thousand dollars. That means you're hiring people. What practices have you put in place? What's going on? Do you need to tell us something as your insurance provider?"
These are all moments that I think the disparate nature of how insurance is distributed creates a lot of user experience issues. A lot of bland user experience that I think can be rapidly improved upon as we start to connect. I love where you're taking it, man. I'm super excited for you. I'm going to be following along on the journey. I'm glad that we had a chance to meet. I'm a huge fan now of what you're doing.
Let's take this last moment before we finish here. Where can people learn more? I know you said that agents that are listening can get to your products through various wholesalers. If they go to your website, they can find those wholesalers and know who to talk to. But if they just want to follow you or check people out, where should they go? Where should they learn more about you and what you're doing?
Tanner Hackett
Our website is yourcounterpart.com. Come check out the website. We have our LinkedIn page, our Twitter page. We're here to educate the market about the potential for management liability. Again, it's not where it is today, but what it should be for them in terms of the service that we can provide and the quality product we can provide for the small business owners. We need to do this through partnerships. That was one point that I failed to mention. All these insurtechs are doing cool stuff, but we're standing upon the shoulders of giants. We're standing upon the shoulders of our great wholesale partners, these retail agents, these carriers that are leaning into the future. We're helping to nudge them along and show them what's possible.
Ryan Hanley
I love it, man. I'm super glad that we had a chance to connect. I'm glad we had a chance to share your story and your expertise with the audience. I wish you nothing but the best.
Tanner Hackett
Thanks for having me, Ryan. This was really fun.
Ryan Hanley
Awesome. Cheers.
Promotional message: This is the exact method we use to close 1,200 clients in under three years during the pandemic. No fluff, no endless follow-ups, just results fast. Based in behavioral psychology and battle-tested, the one-call close system eliminates excuses and gets the prospect saying yes more than you ever thought possible. If you're ready to stop losing opportunities and start winning, visit masteroftheclosed.com. That's masteroftheclosed.com. Do it today.