Main Topic: This podcast episode is a conversation between the host and Sean Fitzgerald, a successful insurance agency owner and podcast host. The main topic of the conversation is how to build a successful insurance agency, with a focus on discipline, mental toughness, and embracing new technologies like AI.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Additional Insights:
Became a Master of the Close: https://masteroftheclose.com
Discover how to revolutionize your insurance business as we chat with the incredible Shawn Fitzgerald of the Scratch Agency podcast.
Shawn's unique blend of progressive technology and prospecting techniques, combined with a respect for traditional methods, will give you the edge you need in today's competitive market.
Together, we'll explore the importance of finding freedom within ourselves, overcoming limitations, and navigating the challenges of the current economic crisis.
Dive into the world of carrier sales centers as we discuss how they can help you maximize efficiency and grow your business.
Learn the ins and outs of working with carrier representatives and customer service centers and the advantages of carving out a niche for yourself in the insurance industry. We'll also reveal the power of AI tools like ByWordAI, Chat GPT, and Grammarly in revolutionizing your blog writing process, saving you precious time and resources.
Finally, we get personal with Shawn as we discuss the mental and emotional journey of being a scratch agent. Shawn shares the incredible benefits of starting a podcast to build relationships, learn from guests, and find a sense of community, from the loneliness to the self-discipline required.
Don't miss out on this insightful conversation that will inspire you and provide tangible strategies to elevate your insurance business to new heights.
Episode Highlights:
Key Quotes:
Resources Mentioned:
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Episodes You Might Enjoy:
Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.
Host
Hello everyone and welcome back to the show. We have a tremendous episode for you today, a conversation with Sean Fitzgerald. He's part of the Scratch Agency podcast and has his own agency. I've gotten to know Sean over the last year, spent some time IRL at Doug Benz's event in New York, which was awesome as well. You can go back and check out the Doug Benz episode if you want to hear more about that. I was also on the Scratch Agency podcast with Sean, and we had a tremendous conversation there.
We've had more conversations, social media stuff, and I think that I love the way that Sean is approaching the business. He seems to have both a progressive approach in terms of technology and new ways of prospecting, but also a healthy and heavy respect for the way the business was done and a strong work ethic. He also deals with all the stuff that scratch agencies deal with. I think that his perspective, his humility, his understanding, and his willingness to share and be candid is just phenomenal. I loved having Sean on the show and I'm happy to share him and his expertise with you guys.
Before we get on to Sean, I just want to let you know, if you're digging the show, if you love the show, if you enjoy the podcast and you want a little more, if you're looking for 10x ideas to build freedom into your life—the freedom that we need to be successful—that doesn't mean freedom from an overlord, although it can. It mostly means freedom from ourselves. That is the battle that I, and I think most of us who are trying to get better, struggle with every day.
I think we mistakenly misrepresent what is holding us back from getting where we want to be. I think oftentimes we look at external sources, and that is almost never the case. Sure, there are always going to be external things that we don't like, appreciate, or that create obstacles, but it is the internal limitations, the internal boundaries, the fear, the emotions, the feelings that we allow to steer the ship that ultimately keep us from getting to where we want to be. That's what Finding Peak is all about. It's finding peak performance in our lives.
I work on this every day and I take the ideas that I find. Sometimes I just find a quote. Sometimes I find research or hear someone who I follow say something and it triggers an idea that I start to implement, or something that I've been thinking on for a long time, or a story, or something that I've learned from. I take these ideas, I distill them down, and I put them out every Friday. If that's something that you want to be a part of, go to FindingPeak.com. It's free. You can just subscribe by email. FindingPeak.com. F-I-N-D-I-N-G-P-E-A-K.com.
Guys, I also want to give a quick shout out to SIA. As you know, Ro Grisk and myself were acquired. They didn't acquire my physical body. That's illegal. But they did acquire Ro Grisk and my services back in April of 2022. It's been a tremendous experience. I've learned so much about SIA over that time period that I just didn't know. If you want to maximize the value of your book of business in terms of cash flow and revenue into your business, they have the best contracts in the industry.
I know people that go there for market access, but I think the real primetime players, the PTPers that are choosing SIA, are going because it immediately increases the revenue of the book of business you already have, not to mention all the new business opportunities that you get from SIA. There are so many benefits. I don't want to go into all of them. But I know that money talks, and guys, in a crazy, crazy economic world that we're in today, I think positioning yourself in a place with stability and longevity and max revenue contracts like SIA could be good for your agency.
I'm not shilling SIA by any means. It's not for everybody. But there are 5,500 plus members in the United States who've chosen SIA and are doing well. So I'd love to give them a shout out. No obligation to do so for sure, but it's been such a positive experience for me and I've learned so much that I just wanted to put that in front of you. So go to si.com if you're interested in that and you're an insurance professional. Finding Peak if you want more stuff on Peak Performance. And as always, I just want to tell you I love you for listening to the show. Let's get on to Sean Fitzgerald.
Music fades
Yo, yo, what's happening, man?
Sean Fitzgerald
What's up, dude? How you doing? What's the good word?
Host
You know, playing a lot of defense these days with the craziness we have going on.
Sean Fitzgerald
Yeah, I would say it's a Long Island thing, but it seems to be a nation thing. So I'm dealing with it like everybody else.
Host
Yeah, I think there are definitely certain parts of the country that are getting hit harder than others. It seems like anywhere that is any kind of coastal or water, or really anything that isn't kind of very vanilla, is getting hit the hardest. At least that's kind of what I'm seeing. It's tough. It's freaking tough, man. It's tough when this stuff starts to happen. I know it's a natural cycle, but it's definitely tough.
Sean Fitzgerald
Yeah, it's scary too. I mean, I have a nice base of property insurance on the South Shore of Long Island. Now, if you get within like two miles of the coast, there are like three carriers that will write you, and then you're going non-admitted. I guess I have to be blessed that there are still a few admitted regional carriers left, but once I see them tighten up, it starts to make me worry a little bit.
Host
Do you have any part of you that also sees that as an opportunity? Like sees it as an opportunity to step in and say, "Hey, look, there's only this many carriers left. A lot of people are going to freak out, or if it's not their specialty, they'll run or they'll let it go because they don't know what to do." And you can kind of come in, being that you're there and you know how to do it, and step up and put some business on the books.
Sean Fitzgerald
Totally. So I have three of the regional markets that are right within two miles of the South Shore. We purchase a lot of homeowners leads. I know some people are against that, but those people are idiots.
Host
Yeah.
Sean Fitzgerald
I mean, we have a really good close ratio. I think it's a good close ratio for the leads. Just doing the math, we're around like 10%. So if I pay $150 for 10 leads and one policy pays me $300 plus in revenue, I'm really happy with that because I'm going to get the residual on the back end.
Host
Yeah. And that's not including getting the auto and the umbrella and maybe they have a business and referrals and things like that.
Sean Fitzgerald
Yeah.
Host
I honestly think that the whole lead buying thing, that's legacy bullshit thinking. Those are people who aren't growing a book right now, aren't starting right now. If you built your agency in the eighties, maybe you look at it and go, "Oh, we don't need to buy leads." It's like, that's not the way the world works today. My philosophy has always been, if you think of it like an insurance agency, then sure, maybe in some purest weird way, purchasing leads isn't appropriate. But if you think of it as an insurance business, then you need to bring in accounts and put revenue on the books. It's a business.
I think the ideology that some people operate with is crazy. Frankly, when I see someone or hear someone who has that type of ideology, I'm like, "I now know how to beat you. Now I know how to beat you." Your steadfast ideology creates weak points that can be exposed.
Sean Fitzgerald
So yeah, I think with the leads, you just have to come at it with a calculated approach. I used to, at my old agency, they used to purchase leads. It wasn't bad, it worked. But we never really had a process for how to handle the leads. Now there's a whole system. When the lead comes in, they're getting hit with an automated text, they're getting hit with an automated email, we're calling them right away. We're following up two more times on a phone call if they don't respond the first time.
It's gotten to the point where I brought up within two miles of the South Shore before. I'm only purchasing home insurance leads on Long Island within two miles of the South Shore because I know the captive carriers aren't operating in that space. There's not going to be as much competition. So I'm picking zip codes.
Host
Yep.
Sean Fitzgerald
And listen, if I'm going to have a 10% rate—I just talked about this with my producer the other day. I said, "Hey, we'll do four a day." Then we bumped it to five, then we bumped it to six. I'm like, "If we keep a 10% ratio, I'll just keep bumping this thing up until we can't handle it anymore."
Host
Yeah.
Sean Fitzgerald
So that's kind of where I'm at with it. It's math.
Host
It's math. That's the part that I've never understood about this business—all these unspoken rules. You know what I mean? Like, "You don't do this and you don't do that. Agencies don't do business that way." And it's like, what are you talking about? I've never understood the unspoken rules. I know what they are, but I've just never understood how you could possibly do business that way.
Now look, most agents are so terrible at sales that it's just—this is why you hear—I started doing this thing in my keynotes where I'll pretend like I'm being nice and I'll say, "Who works on referrals? Who loves referrals? Raise your hand. Who's a referral agency?" People will be like, "Oh, I'm a referral agency," and they'll raise their hand. I'll be like, "You are all lazy and you're terrible at what you do." They'll look at me like, "What?" And I'll be like, "You want to know why you like referrals? It's because they're easy. That's why you like them."
That's great. I'm not saying you shouldn't do them, but there are like 15 other ways to get business that would help you grow in addition to your referrals that you don't do because you're a referral-based agency. That keeps you growing at one, two percent a year, maybe flat. That's all you do. But if you added buying leads, or a little bit of inbound, or some networking or referral partners, or whatever, you could grow five, six, seven percent. You just don't want to do that work. I think our industry is so okay with just easy, and whatever that is, there's opportunity everywhere.
Sean Fitzgerald
Yeah, I think part of the problem is, in the beginning, some people are so hungry and they do all the extra things they should do to bring on new business. Then they grow their book to a certain size, and then they kind of just coast and work on referrals only. I think that's where the opportunity comes for us.
Host
100%. I couldn't agree more. I've told this story before, but back in my murder group days, there was this Travelers rep. I can't remember his name, but he would come around and stop in our office like two times a month. One day, I just was like, "Dude, what are you doing here? You're here all the time." He was a nice guy and he was funny. He was actually a cool dude, not like your normal, boring rep. But he would walk in just to hang out. I'd be like, "What are you doing?" And he'd be like, "I have 47 agencies in my territory and only five of them grew last year." Not grew with Travelers—literally grew their agency versus the year before.
He said internally they had this name for it. Basically, it was like they have a number. Everybody's number is different. Could be $175,000 in personal income. Could be $250,000. Could be $500,000. Doesn't matter. The minute they hit that number, submissions plummet, business plummets, their growth flat lines. He said, "We don't hear from them anymore. They don't care. They don't come to conferences. They don't go to trainings. Nothing." He said it's like all this activity, they hit their personal income number, and whack—they just shut everything down. He said you see it over and over and over again. There's part of me that's like, maybe those people are smart. And then there's part of me that's like, maybe I just couldn't live with myself.
Sean Fitzgerald
Yeah. The whole carrier rep thing is wild to me. There are good carrier reps out there. I love some of them. But the fact that they could just walk in unannounced—that stuff just drives me crazy. I actually got this from Mike Crowley. Mike didn't even tell me—Mike told Steven, and Steven told me. It was a telephone game. But I now set aside three hours once a month to talk to carrier reps. That's it. If a carrier wants to Zoom, they reach out to me now and say, "Hey, in 30 minutes, can we do a Zoom now?"
Host
Why do you talk to them at all?
Sean Fitzgerald
That's a fantastic question.
Host
That's a good question.
Sean Fitzgerald
I mean, I guess it's to keep the relationship with the carrier, see if there's any changes going on.
Host
Do they even know the answer to those questions? I'd probably have to fact check it. I'd say the reps are accurate in their info 60% of the time, maybe 45% of the time.
Sean Fitzgerald
It's a good point. I only meet with them when there's a reason to meet now. I've said it to them. I've just said, "Look, we're doing a lot of testing with carrier sales centers right now in commercial." I firmly believe in carrier sales centers. You cannot be profitable writing BOPs under $5,000. You can't be profitable writing accounts under $5,000. You just can't be in commercial lines. It's impossible. I shouldn't say impossible—highly improbable that you will be profitable writing accounts under that size.
We're doing some testing, and what's interesting is they're as good or better salespeople than most of us. They're way more responsive. They know their products better. They follow up more often. Last month with one of our carrier sales centers, we had a 47% hit ratio, which is pretty good. So I have been meeting with the rep, the manager of the carrier sales center department, and our underwriter quite a bit—like twice a month, three times a month—because we're working on a program together. Once we figure this out, I don't want to talk to these people anymore because there's nothing that I need. It's not a personal attack. I actually like all of them. I think they're all great. I don't have a beef with them.
There's no reason for you to tell me, "Hey, we want more bakeries this month," or "Hey, let me give you our hit list." You're telling me all the stuff you used to write, not the stuff that you're going to write in the future. How about this? You tell me now where the lowest rates will be in August so I can be ready to write that stuff in August. Telling me that you used to have a low price on bakeries back in May doesn't help me in June, July, and August because you don't control the pricing. You're a marketing rep, and the underwriter can change the pricing in a dime. So I do not meet with them.
Host
I don't think there's an island. You don't have an obligation to meet with them. They make you feel like you do. I would guarantee there is nothing in your contract with that carrier that says you have to meet with that marketing rep.
Sean Fitzgerald
I agree. I guess it's just the way I've been conditioned. But I feel like if I don't meet with them, I could lose the appointment. It's just in my head. I don't know why.
Host
You only lose appointments when you stop writing business with them. Because remember—and I don't mean to be like preaching here, but I just have very strong feelings on this—that person's entire motivation is more premium. That's their whole motivation. For them to get their bonus, they need you to write more business. They believe wasting your time talking about the things you're going to write gets them more business. What I tell them is, "The more time you spend with me, the less business you're going to get because I'm not doing the things I need to do to put business on the books. You're taking time away from my desk."
That's a half hour, an hour, once a month that I lose. That could be prospecting. It could be closing. It could be account rounding. You're costing me that time. So if you want me to write more business, stay away from me—unless you have a really good deal. You want to up my commission percentage to incentivize me to write more with you? Call me. I'm interested in that. You have a special niche program that no one else has that will allow me to crush my market with your carrier? Call me. Everything else? No thanks. I'm good.
Sean Fitzgerald
Well, maybe you have to have a good relationship with them first in order to get those insights.
Host
I think you're—look, this is just my opinion. I hear you. The good news is America. You can have differing opinions and everything's good. But I think you will find, being that you are a forward-thinking dude, that those meetings are fucking easy.
Sean Fitzgerald
Yeah, yeah. No, I hear you. The customer service center thing is an interesting conversation. Probably about a year ago, I just started looking into it. Again, maybe this comes back to just conditioning—being in the agency for so long and doing things a certain way. My first reaction without even thinking about it was, "I don't want to push anyone off to the service center. They're not going to handle them right. I'm going to lose business." But I've been using a national carrier—I'll just say Travelers for personal lines—and I've been using their dedicated customer service line that doesn't put the person into a phone tree or anything. People love it. I've had no complaints.
Someone wants to do a vehicle change? "Here, call this number." Someone needs a copy of their policy? "Here, use this number." It works great. I've had no complaints. And if they do cross-sell them on the phone, I still get paid on it.
Host
Yep.
Sean Fitzgerald
So Travelers is one of the carrier sales centers that we use in commercial. I'm very happy with them.
Host
In all these things, I think to myself, "Am I making this decision as an insurance business or as an insurance agency?" Insurance agencies want to control everything. Everything's local. Everything's high touch. Everything is the perception of what adds value. Very egocentric. Insurance agency owners are very highly egocentric. It is all about them—their last name, what they want, the way they want to do business. Highly, highly egocentric. Not wrong, just what it is. Not wrong. Everyone who just took offense to that, please don't. I'm not saying you're wrong. I'm just saying that's what it is. That's how you make decisions.
Then there are insurance business owners. It doesn't mean carrier sales centers work for you. I'm not saying that someone who chooses or doesn't choose a carrier sales center is wrong. I'm just saying they don't think about it through the filter of "How do I want to do business?" They think about it through "What helps my business grow? What helps my CSRs maximize their time with my clients that actually bring in revenue?"
If I have a $700 BOP and a $70,000 account on my books, which one of those should my CSR be spending time on? The larger one. The agency owner says, "Well, we need to make sure we're spending time with everybody." And they'll go, "No, no, we spend our time," but then they don't. That's the other thing. They'll tell you that they prioritize, but they don't. Because when that $700 BOP comes in, your CSR is answering their questions, taking up time, asking about their kids, and spending a half hour on an account that makes you $70 a year.
Where if you use a carrier sales center—just as an example, and this is what we've been testing with good results so far—that $700 BOP calls in. We talk to them and say, "Hey, we have a small business specialist that can work with you. I'm going to transfer you over to them right now. They're going to get you all squared up." Then we transfer them over, they get closed, and we never have to talk to them ever again. They're happy because we're sending them to a carrier that I know is the right product for them that will take care of them. It will make sure their business is properly protected, which is our job. I don't have to waste my people's time on an account that brings in $70. So that's the idea.
Sean Fitzgerald
You probably know this better than I do. I haven't done enough research on it. But how many carriers actually have this option for the service center? Is it more than I'd think?
Host
There are a lot that have the service center. The service center has become fairly ubiquitous. The sales center is still limited. We are testing three right now. One is a super regional, two are nationals that have a sales center. The service center is different. Service centers are—to me—anything under $5,000 in premium should be in a service center. That's my number. We're making that move right now. I've done the math 1,000 times. To me, it always ends up somewhere around $5,000. Maybe it's a little more, maybe a little less. Some people say $10,000, maybe $25,000. To me, $5,000 feels reasonable.
If your commercial account is $5,000 or less, you should be in that carrier service center. One, they're going to be able to do the things better. They know the internal process. They know the car change form. That person calls you. You have to take their information. You have to log into the portal, which is terrible because all the carrier portals are terrible except for Hartford's. Travelers isn't bad either. Then you have to figure out where to go, make the change, input it, then get a receipt back that it was done. Then you have to send out anything. How is that in any way a value add? The person just wanted to make a car change. Think about all that work and time and all the possible data entry errors.
You could have your absolute best CSR, and they're thinking about the fact that their kid is graduating from middle school today and just misses a number. Then that's messed up. The auto ID doesn't come in right. There are so many problems. That person could just call the carrier direct, make the car change, have their thing emailed to them five minutes later, and they're happy as shit. Service centers are a no-brainer. Not every service center is the same, but take Travelers, for instance. Travelers' service center retains business at a 93% clip. What is the best practices agency average? It's somewhere between 89% and 90%. So 93% retention rate in commercial lines, small business, Travelers' service center. That's pretty good.
Sean Fitzgerald
Yeah, I'm happy with that number.
Host
Right? Hanover's is north of 93%. It fluctuates between 93 and 94. They do certificates of insurance too. They'll do everything. You never have to talk to the person again ever, ever, forever. You never have to speak to them again.
Sean Fitzgerald
I guess I wonder how that would work. Because usually, the contractors I deal with, it's just an email request.
Host
They email the service center. That's it.
Sean Fitzgerald
Okay.
Host
Yeah. Their relationship ends up being with the service center. But the answer to the phone is you. They work as you. They have a whole bank of people. They work later hours, 8 p.m. How many certificates are you issuing at 8, 9 o'clock p.m.? None. So to me, that kind of stuff—now granted, you get into more sophisticated accounts. This is not the place for them. This is where we shine. Expertise, experience, coverage, consultation, caring. This is where we shine on accounts that have some meat to them. They have some moving parts. Maybe you have to go take pictures of the place. There are a lot of different things that you can do.
But these carrier sales centers—there are less that have the sales centers. There are not as many carriers that have the sales centers. But to me, this is the future of small business for independent insurance agents. We become lead creators and we pass them on to our partners. The decision on where they go is very, very important. There's still an aspect of consultation to it. I have to choose between, say, Hanover or Travelers or whoever else. But the truth is, at a certain point, you can't just continue to lose money on these small business accounts. As a business owner, as an agency owner, you can do whatever the hell you want. But as a business owner, your job is to create profits so you can pay your people and yourself and take care of your family. I just don't know how the math works otherwise. That's the problem. If the math worked, I wouldn't even be having this conversation. But the math doesn't work, in my opinion.
Sean Fitzgerald
I love this conversation because I think it's just being open-minded. We're not saying service center for everything. We're just saying for certain accounts of a certain size and a certain niche, service center is great.
Host
100%. You brought up contractors. Contractors are very tough. I actually think that contractors probably more often than not need to stay in-house. Now, maybe you can put some sort of good automation in or a self-service portal or something like that. I haven't tested it yet, but Glovebox has some stuff. There are a bunch of tools that do this. But for a BOP—John's Bakery on Main Street calls and needs a BOP, commercial auto policy, and umbrella. Total package: $5,500. Service center all day. Service center, because that's where he will be better served.
Your people take lunch breaks. They take smoke breaks. They take piss breaks. They make mistakes because they're not perfect. They're one person and they have hundreds of clients that they're servicing. They don't know the exact nuances of all the policies of all the carriers they serve. So there is an aspect to this where, in the right scenario, you're actually serving the customer better by getting them directly to the point or to the manufacturer in this case, which is the carrier. It's definitely not for every customer, not even close.
Sean Fitzgerald
No, I totally agree.
Host
So what else are you excited about, man? I know you guys have your own podcast. You're doing awesome. I love to watch it. I love seeing the little clips you guys put out. It was such a pleasure to be on the show. I love chatting with you guys. What other stuff—young agency owner crushing, doing fun stuff—what other shit are you playing with? What are you excited about? I'm interested in that.
Sean Fitzgerald
Thank you, man. Well, I can't be on a podcast with you and not talk about AI. I am very excited about AI right now, mainly as a tool to help me be a little more efficient. For instance, you and I talked offline the other day about using it to assist with making blogs for my website. I'm a terrible writer, and I went from it taking me about three hours to do a blog to about 30 minutes. I'm going to say this on air: I have no excuse to not blog consistently once a week. The way AI is set up now, it can create my title, it can help create the body of the wording. I can throw it in Grammarly, then go in and make my little touch-up so it's a little more personalized. And then it's done.
Host
All right, I'm going to get you to two blog posts a day in less than 30 minutes right now.
Sean Fitzgerald
Oh, no.
Host
This is the secret sauce. You guys are getting this exclusively. Ryan Hanley Show special. If you want the walkthrough for this, this is a hardcore plug. So deal with it. It's my show. I can do whatever I want. Go to FindingPeak.com and subscribe, and you'll get—I'm going to do a walkthrough for this for next week that people will get. So you can see how I do this, because this shit is blowing my mind. Our traffic is going through the roof. We produce two blog posts a day, 30 minutes or less. Okay? So here's how we do it. There is a tool called Byword.ai. B-Y-W-R-I-D.ai.
It costs money, so all you cheap fucks are going to have to open up your wallet, so just deal with that. But if you want to produce two blog posts a day in 30 minutes or less, you're going to have to pay something. You also have to buy the paid premium subscription for ChatGPT, which is $20 a month. So you can afford this stuff. If you can't, you should not be selling insurance for a living because it means you stink at selling insurance. If you can't afford these things, you stink at selling insurance and you should find another career. Otherwise, open up your freaking wallet, pay for these tools, and I promise you, you will start to rip really good blog posts out.
So what I do is I use ChatGPT 4, not 3.5, because I've found it not to be as good. I use ChatGPT 4 to create blog post titles. I would do something like, "Pretend or act as the owner of a bakery and give me 10 uncommon blog post titles about different insurance coverages I may not understand." That would be the prompt. And it'll give you 10 really interesting ones about workers comp, commercial auto, et cetera. I take those 10 blog post titles and I copy and paste them into Byword.ai. I copy them in and I hit start generating.
While it's doing that, let's take a step back. If you have WordPress or HubSpot, you can use Zapier to connect Byword directly to your blog. We use HubSpot for our blog. I don't recommend it. It's expensive. It's awesome, but it's expensive. WordPress is more than enough. So please don't go, "Oh my God, Hanley uses HubSpot, I have to change to HubSpot." Don't do that. Just use WordPress.
Sean Fitzgerald
Let me just say real quick too. I use Advisor Evolved. It's from ByWord. It plugs all 10 right into the website.
Host
Yes, exactly. Perfect. Perfect. Yeah, 100%. Couldn't agree with you more. Advisor Evolved is the best. Chris Langell is the GOAT. So, ChatGPT for 10 blog post titles, then into Byword. It immediately writes these articles, puts the article—you can set the tone and how long you want it to be—directly into WordPress. Then you go into WordPress and you have to use Grammarly. This is another paid tool. Guys, this is going to cost you. Grammarly is $120 a year. So that's $12 a month plus the $20 for ChatGPT. So that's $32, plus 10 articles through Byword is going to cost you maybe the $100 a month subscription. So you're looking at $150 a month for 20 blog posts a month. That's one a day.
This pushes the written blog posts directly into your WordPress as drafts, formatted. Then you use Grammarly to clean it up. Then maybe you add in a couple of internal links and some of your own language at the end, and you hit publish. In probably two hours of work, you could have all 20 scheduled for the entire month and never have to think about it. A new blog post every day, tailored, specific, unique URLs, the whole deal. You are now a blog post creating machine that's going to ramp up. You can do them tailored to your geography, different counties. All this stuff could be going all the time, and it will drastically improve your inbound marketing. It's inexpensive and fast.
Sean Fitzgerald
Yeah. And then you could even take it a step further and use MidJourney or Jasper to create AI-generated art to throw in the blog post.
Host delivers a brief ad break asking for subscriptions, shares, and reviews to help the show grow, then returns to the conversation.
Host
So here's the cool part. In Byword, they actually create an image that goes along with the post. The only problem is it doesn't push the image into WordPress. So you just go back into Byword and download the custom AI-generated image that goes with that particular title and use that. Now you have created nothing unique except you have unique content served to people. I had a guy the other day, an insurance guy, go, "Holy shit, who is creating your content for you? It is fucking brilliant." And you're just pumping it out. I'm like, "Yeah, bro, we got smarter people here."
Sean Fitzgerald
It's so funny you say that. That's how I knew I was a terrible writer. I did like eight or nine blog posts myself and no one ever said anything. Then I started doing the AI stuff and I got two comments like, "Man, these articles are great."
Host
Great. Yeah. And I fact-checked them. I haven't found any issues. Every once in a while, you might find a little something that's off, but it's really benign. They do talk in generality, so it's not giving specific shit that could cause problems. Just for the record, there's never been an E&O case associated with a piece of marketing content in written form as long as you're not making a guarantee. As long as you stay out of guarantees and talk in generalities, you're going to be fine because you're giving suggestions and education. You're not saying, "If you do this, this outcome will happen." That's where you can get in trouble. But that's how you do it. The process takes a little getting used to in the beginning.
Sean Fitzgerald
That's exactly how I'm doing my blogs now. When you told me offline, I was like, "Ryan's saying I got to try it." I threw it in the first couple of times and it took me a while, but now it's just clockwork. I almost feel like you can train a VA to do it.
Host
You absolutely could. That could be a job. That's what we do. You think I do it? I don't do it at all.
Sean Fitzgerald
Well, I'm still doing it myself. I gotta pass it along, I guess. But yeah, I'm using it. That's just scratching the surface. I've been using it to send emails more efficiently. For example, if I have a renewal coming up in two months for a commercial client and I want to give them something in writing that's like a state of the market in my own words, I can go to ChatGPT and say, "Create me a business email for a client that owns a nursery who's having a large increase on their renewal." It'll give me a beautiful response. I go in and personalize it, throw it in Grammarly, touch it up. It takes me five minutes compared to sitting there trying to type out a whole email for a half hour, thinking about it 20 times before I send it.
I used it to do a Facebook ad recently. The ad it generated blew my mind. I'm going to share it with you because I just pulled it up. I'm running it now. I only got two leads from it, so maybe it's not that great, but I love the wording. This is for homeowners coastally on Long Island. It says, "Attention Long Island homeowners, stop the insurance rate nightmare. Are you a proud Long Island homeowner experiencing insurance policy cancellations or jaw-dropping rate increases? Don't panic. We have an exclusive solution tailored just for you. Introducing LAF Advisors, your trusted partner in protecting your cherished abode. We aim to provide peace of mind and comprehensive coverage to high-value homeowners like yourself. Why choose LAF?" Then it has a couple of emoji check marks on why you should choose LAF. "Claim your free policy review now. Act fast. Contact us today with the link. Protect your home confidently and join the satisfied homeowners who trust LAF for their insurance needs. Your home, our priority." That is great. I could have never come up with that myself.
Host
Yeah. So using it for little things like that—creating the body of a Facebook ad, figuring out the best way to respond when someone fills out a form from a Facebook ad—you can go on and on with it.
Sean Fitzgerald
Yeah, it's something I'm definitely trying to use to make my life more efficient.
Host
The other thing you can do is take that ad and say, "Give me five similar but different versions that attack this problem in an uncommon way." It'll give you A/B test versions you can try. It's not going to displace the human, the consultation, the coverage, what we need to do. But it can make you so much more efficient. Right now, we're in a window where if you take the time to embrace this stuff and use it in your business, you can start to extend your lead on people. This isn't going to change the way you do business today. I think that's coming. I think there are major changes coming. This shit is going to start being baked into tools more and more, and it'll be seamless. Behind the scenes, you won't even know it's there. But right now, it's still just difficult enough that most people won't do it. That gives us the ability to really extend and grow if you're willing to take advantage of it.
Sean Fitzgerald
I totally agree. I feel like we're on the forefront of something that's really going to shake up the industry. I'd rather—listen, is there government regulation that could crack down on it? Maybe. But I'm not even thinking that far ahead. I'm just thinking, let me learn as much as I can about this so that if it doesn't crack down, Rogue Risk and LAF are the only two companies pumping out two blogs a day. I'm cool with that.
Host
Yeah. You and I just told everybody exactly what to do, and no one who's listening to this will do it. They'll go, "I don't have the time." Okay. Fine. That's the best part about our industry. I and Kat and other people have been giving them the product for a decade plus. And it's just recently that a couple of other guys started doing this—this new wave of guys and women. But for so long, we're just like, "Do this. We promise. It may not change everything, but it will give you more business for nothing." And people are just like, "No, no, no. I'm going to go drive from strip mall to strip mall handing out business cards because it's a grinder's business." Okay. You win.
Sean Fitzgerald
Yeah, man. There are so many ways to slice the pie now. It's the best all the time. It's a choose-your-own-adventure business. How many businesses do you get to literally pick exactly what you want to be, who you want to serve, where you want to serve them, and build a business around that? I hate personal lines. Hate it with a passion. So we don't do it. I can have an insurance business that just doesn't do personal lines. It's beautiful. Maybe someday I could add it or find a partner, but that kind of stuff is so exciting. You could only do coastal Southern coastal property within two miles of the Long Island shore. You'd probably be a multimillionaire just doing that one thing. You know how to do that. You have the markets for it. You know how to talk to people about it. You get a brand for it. That's fucking amazing.
Host
Yeah. I think you just have to figure out what you want to be. I struggle with "riches in the niches" because I feel like people get too hung up on it. I don't think it's not true—I absolutely think it's true—but there are a lot of other ways to be highly successful as well. If you don't have a niche, you're not screwed. We're a master generalist at Rogue. Our niche is small business. But we're not good at personal lines. We don't do health insurance or life insurance. We could add it. I think you just have to figure out what you want to be and then figure out the business model that allows you to be that thing. The beauty of our industry is you can absolutely do that. There aren't many industries that allow you to do that. That's why this is such a great space to be.
Sean Fitzgerald
Figuring out what you want to be isn't as easy as it sounds.
Host
That's true.
Sean Fitzgerald
I feel like I just figured it out three years ago, and it's probably going to change every quarter for the next 20 years. I think that's fine now. But it's something you should think about.
Host
Yeah. I had a call with a woman today who's relatively new to the business. She was asking me about Tivoli, and I didn't think it was the best fit for her right now. She was saying she's going after this niche and that niche. The best advice I could give her was just pick one thing. It could be a geography, a type of person, an industry class, or a crosscut of all those things. Pick a thing and become the person at that thing. She was struggling with how to get traction. I said, "Don't grab onto the way you think business should be done. Go figure out how those clients want to be served and go serve them. If you enjoy serving that client in that way, just keep doing it. You'll be fine because that's what's going to keep the fire burning."
Sean Fitzgerald
Yeah. A lot of people, especially early on—and I've made this mistake too—they're like, "I want to be this thing" or "I want to serve this." Then they realize what it takes or how those people want to be served, and they don't love it. Then they feel like they're doing something wrong. You're not doing something wrong. That was a mismatch between how they want to be served and how you want to do business. Just keep iterating until you find a type of client you enjoy serving. Then the job becomes super easy.
Host
It does. In our industry, I've made the mistake of going after things I didn't like. When you get to those hard times where you're like, "Oh shit, I'm not feeling it today," if you're not in a niche or a specific field you love, it's easy to skip out on that day. But if you love it, it keeps that fire burning. I hope that was good advice for her.
Sean Fitzgerald
I think it was. I think that's an issue a lot of people get. They do market analysis and say, "There's an opportunity here." But do you even want to serve that type of customer? Does that industry require massive amounts of certificates? Is that something you want to do? No right or wrong. These are the questions we have to ask ourselves. It comes back to thinking like an agency owner or a business owner. Business owners think through what's best for them, their business, profitability, growth, and their targets. They don't over-index on shit they read in Facebook groups. It doesn't mean you can't get great information from there, but they don't just do it because other people are doing it. Too often, agency owners are like, "Sean is crushing commercial coastal property. That sounds profitable, so I'm going to go do that." They've never been to the ocean. They have no idea what a wind-hail deductible is. They don't have the markets. They think they can figure it out, but it's not what they should be doing.
Host
Yeah, it's interesting. As a scratch agent, one of the first things I did was build my niche based on the carrier access I had. Sometimes you don't always have the option. But once you get to a certain point, you can pick and do what you'd like.
Sean Fitzgerald
A lot of it is discipline. I recently wrote an article on Finding Peak about this. It's just keep showing up, keep doing the thing. If making 20 cold calls to property owners every day will yield two opportunities to quote and one sale that works, that's not how you scale, but it gets you off the ground. It gets revenue on the books. For a while, you have to eat shit that way. That was my method until COVID hit. If COVID didn't hit, I would have been a middle-market cold-calling drop-in-a-day guy. Digitizing and killing commercial was my plan. When COVID hit and all those businesses shut down, I had to pivot hard to what Rogue eventually became. You just keep showing up and trying, and eventually you figure out what works—or you don't.
Host
Yeah. I love what you did with Finding Peak, talking about the fitness and mental side of the business. We talked about this on the other podcast previously. The mental side of this business is not talked about enough.
Sean Fitzgerald
Yeah. Cold calling takes a mental toll. Working out takes a mental toll. Doing the blogs takes a mental toll. We could sit here and make it sound easy with AI, but we still have to get up, plug in the info, and consistently do it day after day, even if we feel like crap or get punched in the face by life. You still have to show up. The mental aspect is something I need to do a better job of talking about. As a scratch agent, it can be lonely sometimes when you don't have a team.
Host
It's very lonely. It's not sometimes—it's lonely all the time. That's why I think the podcast you guys are doing is awesome. That's where I'd love to finish our conversation. How has that been going for you? What have been some of the benefits? I think it's incredible that you're doing it, and I'd love to hear more.
Sean Fitzgerald
One of the main reasons we started it was because Stephen and I were going through a similar phase in our career. We were talking about how it is lonely and it is a mental game. We said, "We talk all the time anyway. We should just record it because it's usually good information that could help other scratch agents." We have guests on, we learn from them, and maybe other people can learn too. The insurance industry is filled with so many great people. Where it's benefited us—we make no money off the podcast—but everyone we interview, if you watch on YouTube, I'm just looking down at a notepad taking notes 90% of the time. I'm paying attention. That was the biggest thing I got from it that I wasn't expecting. If you told me there were a hundred other insurance podcasts about building a scratch agency, knowing what I know now, I still would have done it. I've learned so much. The relationships Stephen and I have built from the podcast are invaluable. We all know how hard those times are being a scratch agent. If that can help one or two people, that makes me happy. We're just going to keep doing what we're doing and see what happens at episode 50.
Host
There's tons of discipline in that too. There are days where I look at my calendar and I have a podcast scheduled with someone I can't wait to talk to, but I'm just like, "Fuck." I don't have the energy. Sometimes I know the person is really dynamic, and I want to step my game up and match their energy, but I just don't want to do it. But you have to. That person is taking their time. It's on the calendar. If you don't record, it doesn't go out. It takes big-time discipline to keep pumping out episodes. I shouldn't say this out loud, but there have been times where Stephen and I are like, "Man, I hope this person cancels."
Sean Fitzgerald
Oh yeah. Just because you're mentally shot from running an agency during the day. It's all a mental game.
Host
Yeah. That's what Finding Peak was for me. It's basically a diary. I'm writing for people and hopefully it helps. It seemingly is helping. I've gotten tremendous feedback. But those are reminders to myself. The last article I did on discipline came out of a week where I wasn't motivated. I couldn't get the engine started. I read a lot—I was reading *Discipline Is Destiny* by Ryan Holiday. I listen to a lot of Jordan Peterson. I think it was Andy Frisella who said something like, "You think I want to fucking rucksack at 5 a.m.? No, I don't want to do that. I do it because I told myself I was going to do it.
If I didn't tell myself I was going to do it, I wouldn't do it. But I told myself I'm going to get up for 30 minutes, so I do it. That's discipline." Then I started googling, and Joe Rogan has said similar things. I was like, "Oh my god, motivation is complete and utter bullshit. Motivation is an emotion. Emotions aren't real. They don't control us. They fade away. Discipline is a practice. You're either disciplined or you're not. It's binary. You either show up and do the thing regardless of how you feel, or you don't." I was like, "This isn't going to be easy. I'm going to mess up. But I want to be a disciplined person.
I want to look in the mirror and say, 'You're disciplined.'"
Sean Fitzgerald
Do you know the feeling when you tell yourself, "Tomorrow I'm going to wake up at 4 a.m. and work out at 4:30. I'm just going to do it even if it sucks." You wake up and the first thought in your head is, "You're an idiot. Go back to sleep. This sucks. I feel like crap." But then you work out anyway. You get a sweat. You check that box. To me, that cures depression right there. I was listening to Andrew Tate the other day, and he said depression isn't real. I'm not going to debate whether it's real or not, but his point is it's an emotion—an emotional reaction to feelings. You can be depressed and still be disciplined. You can be miserable, hate your life, hate your station, and still get up, go for a walk, jump in an ice bath, do some pushups. You can be disciplined and depressed. Those two things are not mutually exclusive.
Host
I actually put out a clip on Instagram today in this vein. When I first launched Rogue and COVID happened seven days later, I was depressed. I put all this money and time in, and I felt like the universe kicked me right in the nutsack. I didn't know how to pull myself out. A friend of mine said to me—I was like, "Dude, everything hurts. I'm miserable." He goes, "Experience it." I said, "What do you mean?"
He goes, just experience it. Feel being miserable, feel miserable, be miserable because you are miserable, but do the things you need to do anyway. He said you can still send cold emails and work on your business, put marketing materials together, ask people for their insurance, quote insurance, and be miserable at the same time. Those two things are not mutually exclusive. You know that if you don't do these things, your business isn't going to exist. You are also completely depressed and miserable. Those two things are happening at the same time. Experience the misery, still do the things.
What happened was I just listened to him. I didn't know what else to do. Drinking and being an asshole wasn't working, so I just kept doing the things. They weren't perfect. I didn't do them as much as I could if I felt amazing, but I just kept doing the things. Then all of a sudden you wake up one day and you're like, "I don't feel miserable anymore. I feel pretty good." Because it chips away. When you check that box, it chips away at whatever depression you have.
Last thing I'll leave with — I forgot where I read this, it might've been Patrick Bet-David — he said something about a lot of bad things come from having too much time on your hands. When you're depressed, what happens? You stay in. Maybe you stop working as much as you should. You begin to have too much time on your hands. So maybe you pick up that beer because it's a Saturday and you want to barbecue like every other insurance agent. Before you know it, now you feel like shit on Sunday. So you want to stay in because you had a bunch of drinks on Saturday, and now you have way too much time on your hands. By staying disciplined and having a list of things to do every day, that's what's kept me really happy, to be honest.
Sean Fitzgerald
I think you're wholly right. I think it goes for everything in your life. If you've got a partner or spouse, girlfriend, boyfriend, non-binary human — if we believe that exists. No comment. I don't. Just so you know. But whoever that special person is in your life, even if they consider themselves a cat, it goes for all these relationships. I think back to my marriage and all the relationships I've had. At a certain point, I just kind of stopped being disciplined about the things you're supposed to do.
It goes for your relationship with your kids, your friends, your mentors, anybody. We stop being disciplined in connecting with them because, "Oh, I don't feel like having this conversation with your mom." Then you don't talk to your mom for a month. Then your mom's bitching at you or mad at you, or you feel bad. You feel like you let this person down because you just didn't pick up the phone. You weren't disciplined enough to say, "Hey, once a week I'm going to make sure I connect with this person who's really important to me." Doesn't mean you feel like it. You may not even have anything to say, but you connect with them because that relationship is important to you.
This idea of discipline from Marcus Aurelius to Jesus to Abraham — it doesn't matter what religion or philosophy you follow, Buddha — all of it comes back to discipline. Everything is a derivative of discipline. Everything you want in your life is a derivative of discipline. That's my feeling.
Host
I couldn't agree with you more. We have processes and procedures in place for our business. I have these lists that I do, but guess what? I could do a better job of having lists for things I should do in my personal life. Processes and procedures for my personal life. I'm working on that.
Sean Fitzgerald
I think discipline and a tiny dash of grace, and everything's going to be fine. Give yourself that tiny bit of grace when you aren't disciplined. Get back on track. I think sometimes we're a little too hard on ourselves. This concept I'm working through in my head: be as disciplined as you can possibly be in every aspect of your life. Doesn't mean not have fun. Fun can be a discipline. I like to golf. I like to have beers once in a while. I'm seeing this woman — I like to take her out to dinner. That can be disciplined. Making sure you make time for those things that are fun. It doesn't mean don't have fun. Just means be disciplined in it. When you fall off the horse, give yourself a little bit of grace to say, "Fuck it. I had a bad day. Tomorrow I'm back at it." I feel like that's the key, man.
Host
Hey dude, so glad we connected. We have to do this again. Tell everybody where they can get at you and your podcast. I love the podcast. If you like this nonsense, you're going to love the shit that they're doing. So tell everybody where they can get at you.
Sean Fitzgerald
For the podcast, you can check us out — the Scratch Agency podcast on YouTube, Spotify, Apple. To follow me personally, I like Instagram: Sean P. Fitz, that's S-H-A-W-N-P-F-I-T-Z, or Sean Fitzgerald on LinkedIn.
Ryan, before we go, thank you for having me on the podcast. I appreciate it. I think what you do in our industry — I commend you for it because I know it's not easy to have a podcast. And the way you do your podcast, you're very open and honest and you tell it how it is. Not a lot of people do that within our industry. So I commend you for that, man.
Host
Thank you so much, dude. It's been such a pleasure getting to know you over the last year and I'm looking forward to more. Even the time we got to spend in person at Ben's thing — it's awesome. I look forward to more of that, man. I wish you nothing but success. I'm so happy for you. Anything I can ever do, bud, be good.
Ad break
Narrator
One call. This is the exact method we use to close 1,200 clients in under three years during the pandemic. No fluff, no endless follow-ups, just results fast. Based in behavioral psychology and battle-tested, the One Call Closed System eliminates excuses and gets the prospect saying yes more than you ever thought possible. If you're ready to stop losing opportunities and start winning, visit masteroftheclosed.com. That's masteroftheclosed.com. Do it today. We'll see you next time.