Main Topic: The Israel-Gaza conflict and its global implications.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
We've teamed up with The Conflict podcast to answer your questions. These include Russia's role, the reaction from Israel, and what we can all do to be part of the solution.
Theme music fades out
Jackie Leonard
This is the third Global News podcast special edition on Israel and Gaza from the BBC World Service. I'm Jackie Leonard in London, and we are once again getting together with our colleagues from the Conflict podcast to put your questions to our expert correspondents.
Sound effects: Brief pause
Joining us from Jerusalem is the BBC's chief international correspondent Lise Doucette. And here in the studio with me in London is Frank Gardner, our security correspondent.
Sound effects: Brief pause
And you, our audience, have sent us a lot of questions to pick apart. So let's get started.
Sound effects: Brief pause
At the point we are recording this on Friday, the aid situation is desperate. You will remember that Israel ordered a complete siege of Gaza on October 9th in response to the Hamas attacks of October 7th. And almost a week ago, some aid trucks started crossing into Gaza from Egypt. Even then, though, there were far fewer than had been getting in before, and aid agencies have described it as a drop in the ocean of what's needed.
Sound effects: Brief pause
So on the subject of aid, here's our first question. This is Camille from Australia and my question's about all the aid trucks because I know just before this conflict started there was a lot of discussion about US funding and aid to Ukraine and now there's a lot of trucks amassed at the Egypt border. Was this aid that was already destined to go into Gaza? Because I've also heard reports that there was aid going in already but not as much as now. So just a note on how this manoeuvring had happened and if one affects the other.
Sound effects: Brief pause
So, Lise, if you could start with that one.
Lise Doucette
Yes, thank you very much for the question. It's very important. The UN and other agencies tell us that before this war erupted between Israel and Gaza, that as many as 500 trucks a day were getting into Gaza with all kinds of goods. And that includes commercial supplies as well. The United Nations on its own was sometimes 100 trucks a day, sometimes 200 trucks a day.
Sound effects: Brief pause
If you compare that to now, since the trucks started rolling across the border from Egypt through the Rafa crossing into southern Gaza, there was only about, at the time that I'm speaking, about 74 trucks, which is over the past few weeks since this siege was imposed by Israel. So that is why the UN says it is a drop in an ocean of needs. And it doesn't include fuel, which we're hearing from the United Nations today means that the aid operations they are able to still maintain in the Gaza Strip are collapsing.
Sound effects: Brief pause
Jackie Leonard
And Greg in the US also draws comparisons with Ukraine. This one is for you, Frank.
Frank Gardner
My name is Greg and I live in Logan, Utah. So, my question has to do with European countries' response to war versus the Middle Eastern countries' response. When war broke out in Ukraine, the European countries opened their arms to the women and children who needed safety. Why are the countries in the Middle East not doing the same for the women and children in Gaza who were in a similar situation?
Sound effects: Brief pause
And why is this question not being asked by both the media and by the U.S. in communication with these countries? The emphasis is on getting humanitarian aid into Gaza, but that seems like a very poor solution. It seems like the humanitarian thing to do would be to get the women and children out of Gaza and into a safe location similar to what took place in Europe.
Sound effects: Brief pause
Jackie Leonard
Well, Greg, thank you for your question.
Frank Gardner
There are several answers to this. The first is that in terms of human transit, human passage, Gaza is effectively sealed off from the outside world. Israel, which controls Gaza's borders on three out of four borders, and Egypt controls the last one between the two of them, there is no passage of people allowed in or out.
Sound effects: Brief pause
The second reason is that Arab countries and Palestinians are very wary of what's called a repetition of the Nakba, the catastrophe of 1948. That's what the Palestinians refer to, the mass displacement of hundreds of thousands of Palestinians and their families out of areas that they'd lived in for, in some cases, centuries, to make way for the new state of Israel.
Sound effects: Brief pause
And they ended up as refugees in neighboring countries like Lebanon, Syria, and Jordan. And Egypt, there's a third reason here, is that Egypt does not want to allow in large numbers of Palestinians, which could well include Hamas fighters, into northern Sinai, which joins on with Gaza.
Sound effects: Brief pause
Why? Because that's already a pretty precarious area. There's been an ISIS-led insurgency there for some years. There have been some horrific attacks on Bedouin and on Egyptian government soldiers. They don't want to see that area unsettled any further.
Sound effects: Brief pause
So Egypt is wary of the mass transfer of Palestinians, but primarily it's that Arab countries fear that if they moved out of Gaza, they'd never be allowed back in and that Israel would simply recolonize it.
Sound effects: Brief pause
Jackie Leonard
Now, we've talked a bit before about the US response to what's going on. It has pledged its unwavering support to Israel and backed that up with military aid. Here's a question on Washington's military strategy.
Sound effects: Brief pause
My name is Jonathan Paulman from Dallas, Texas. What if the U.S. deterrence measures aren't working? We've seen that they have moved carriers from the eastern Mediterranean into the Middle East as a deterrence, yet threats and violence are rising, even with F-16s, F-15s and B-52s flying into the region. What if this deterrence doesn't work? What are the next steps the U.S. can take rationally in this conflict?
Sound effects: Brief pause
Frank Gardner
Okay, so we're referring here particularly, I think you're referring to the presence of a massive US naval and air force just offshore in the eastern Mediterranean. That was deployed there led by the USS Dwight D Eisenhower aircraft carrier as an immediate response by the US Department of Defense to the attacks of October the 7th.
Sound effects: Brief pause
The US said to Israel we got your back. And that been being joined by a second carrier group. It meant to be a deterrence primarily to Hezbollah in Lebanon, and by extension to Iran to basically say, look, don't think that while Israel is preoccupied fighting a war in Gaza, you can take advantage of that and start a second front on the Lebanese border.
Sound effects: Brief pause
Because if you do, and you declare it and you start a major war there, then we, the United States, will help Israel out. And the implication is, although they've not said so specifically, the implication is that the US would deploy that massive air power and missile power with all these cruise missiles and so on to devastate Hezbollah's positions in southern Lebanon.
Sound effects: Brief pause
It would also cause a lot of damage in Lebanon itself. So that, I think, is causing Hezbollah second thoughts about whether they really want to get involved in this. They are skirmishing with the Israeli forces on that northern border. There are constant exchanges of fire each day. It's fairly low level. It's nothing like the intensity of the 2006 war that Hezbollah fought with Israel, which ended inconclusively with neither side winning ready.
Sound effects: Brief pause
And you mentioned there Iran's role. That brings us to this question. My name is Jimmy Vulembera. I live in Washington, DC, but I'm from the Democratic Republic of Congo. My question is that when someone does a quick search on Hamas online, one of the first things that comes up is that Hamas is a Sunni organization. However, for the last three weeks or so, news coverage from many news organizations has highlighted that Hamas gets funding and the type of support from Iran.
Sound effects: Brief pause
Now, how did the Shia regime in Iran become a sponsor of a Sunni organization?
Sound effects: Brief pause
Lise Doucette
Good question. Iran's relationship with Hezbollah in Lebanon, with Hamas and Islamic Jihad in Gaza, with the Houthis in Yemen, with proxies and militias in Iraq and in Syria, is part of what Iran would say an axis of resistance. Resistance groups who are willing to take on the might of the United States, of imperial forces.
Sound effects: Brief pause
And this does mark a change. If you go back to, for example, the establishment of Hezbollah in Lebanon, Hezbollah means party of God. It was established in 1982 in the midst of the Israeli invasion of Lebanon, which went right into Beirut.
Sound effects: Brief pause
And when it was established, it was established by Lebanese clerics who very much tried to model Hezbollah on Iran, on Iran's Islamic system. That relationship is absolutely a symbiotic relationship, very, very important coordination between these two groups.
Sound effects: Brief pause
But in recent years, as so many Arab states moved away from the Palestinian file, Iran had been providing support for Islamic Jihad. But it also started providing more support for Hamas because it was standing up to Israel and Iran saw an opportunity that it could have an ally in Gaza in its fight against the Jewish state.
Sound effects: Brief pause
So this is why we, I think this is why it has reached the point in which it is now where Iran seems to have a hand in, not just with the Shia militias, with which it has very, very, very, very strong ties for religious, historical and other reasons, but also Sunni groups like Hamas.
Sound effects: Brief pause
Jackie Leonard
And I think we should also mention that one of Hamas's other backers, or at least where many of the Hamas political leaders are based, is the Gulf state of Qatar. And Qatar also has very strong ties with Iran.
Sound effects: Brief pause
Sorry, do you want to chip in there?
Lise Doucette
Yeah, I mean, I think the big takeaway from this really is that land trumps religion when it comes to this, because people have essentially put aside the differences between the Sunni and Shia branches of Islam, because for Iran and for Hamas, the most important thing in their view is what they would call the liberation of the land of Palestine.
Sound effects: Brief pause
So remember that neither of those two, neither Iran nor Hamas, accept the right of Israel to even exist. At all as a state, let alone the West Bank and so on.
Sound effects: Brief pause
Jackie Leonard
That brings us to this question. My name is Jared, living in Berlin. My question is, what role has Russia played in this conflict?
Sound effects: Brief pause
Frank Gardner
Okay, these are really interesting and good questions. Thank you, both of you. I think it would be unfair to say that Russia had a hand in the October the 7th raid by Hamas into southern Israel. But it has certainly benefited from it, because as Rizek rightly points out, it has proved a massive distraction from the Ukraine war, which hasn't finished, is still ongoing.
Sound effects: Brief pause
Ukraine is still, large parts of it are occupied by Russian invading troops. And it's coming still under constant attack from Russian drones, but it's just not on the news because all the attention globally is on the plight of those caught up in this Israel-Hamas conflict.
Sound effects: Brief pause
Now, in the last couple of days, there has been a meeting in Moscow with Russian officials, together with Iranian officials and Hamas. I don't think Russia will want to get involved in this, but they are certainly saying, well, all of this is America's fault for being such a useless peace broker in the Middle East.
Sound effects: Brief pause
And America I think has largely up until now lost interest in the Middle East. It was even under the previous President Obama it was talking about pivoting to Asia. And certainly with a huge presidential election coming up in about a year time attention in the US is focusing or was focusing increasingly on East Asia and China and whether Taiwan was going to get invaded and the South China Sea and so on.
Sound effects: Brief pause
And this I think will have temporarily refocused people on the Middle East. But Russia has become a very important figure in the Middle East. It embedded militarily in Syria. And it's now an important diplomatic player in the region where it wasn't 10 years ago.
Sound effects: Brief pause
Jackie Leonard
Now, as we record, Israel has not yet moved its ground troops fully into Gaza. Israeli airstrikes are continuing. Large numbers of people are getting killed every day. Meanwhile, four hostages have been freed by Hamas, but Israel says more than 200 are still being held.
Sound effects: Brief pause
We got this email from a listener who didn't want to be identified, so we voiced it up. I am curious about what Hamas and other Palestinian groups are doing at the moment, besides holding hostages. Are they also bombing and fighting back? Are many or any Israelis dying?
Sound effects: Brief pause
Lise Doucette
Well, I can certainly say that Hamas hasn't stopped its firing rockets into Israel since this war began. I've spent most of the first two weeks of this war in southern Israel where the air raid sirens went off constantly when we were in the southern community of Sderot, less than a mile from the Gaza border, where on some days rockets kept landing very close to us.
Sound effects: Brief pause
And it was Hamas making the point that for all of the nonstop bombardment by Israeli warplanes, they still had the capacity and indeed the determination to keep firing. And just before we started recording today, we heard that the air raid sirens were sounding in the coastal city of Tel Aviv as well.
Sound effects: Brief pause
Now, of course, what we don't know is where this vast network of Hamas, where are they now? Are they taking refuge inside that network of tunnels? Have some of them managed to escape? One Hamas leading political figure has turned up in the Lebanese capital, Beirut.
Sound effects: Brief pause
But from the beginning, it's been said that in the same way that Hamas put so much preparation, so much resources into this attack, this really unprecedented and very brutal attack against Israel on October the 7th, it would know there would be an unprecedented retaliation by Israel so that it would have made preparations to fight back when Israel does, as is widely expected.
Sound effects: Brief pause
Jackie Leonard
Well, several listeners have written in on the subject of accountability and Israel's alleged war crimes. And I do need to point out here that of all the messages that we received on this subject, they were all about Israel. This is a reflection of what listeners are discussing rather than any bias from our end.
Sound effects: Brief pause
Two listeners with similar questions. I am Sachin Arana, working as an English teacher. I am from India. My question, is it justified to use a disproportionate force against innocent civilian population because of the presence of a few thousand militants who are lurking among them.
Sound effects: Brief pause
Sachin Arana
And that is my question to the international community.
Sound effects: Brief pause
Jackie Leonard
Hello, my name is Nana. I'm calling from Japan. There are a number of alleged war crimes by Israel, including collective punishment, restricting basic necessities to civilians like food and water and fuel, bombing areas like schools and hospitals.
Sound effects: Brief pause
Nana
How are governments and leaders held accountable for alleged war crimes?
Sound effects: Brief pause
Frank Gardner
Okay, well, first of all, to answer the first question there, it is never justified to use disproportionate force against civilians on any side. There's no question about that. But where I think the Israelis would disagree with you is that they would say what they're doing in Gaza is not disproportionate.
Sound effects: Brief pause
Much of the world may disagree with them. But they say, look, what happened on October the 7th was so appalling, so reminiscent of pogroms and of the Holocaust. It was the worst single attack on Israelis in their entire history since the foundation of the State of Israel in 1948, that they said, we have got to do whatever it takes to remove the military threat to our people.
Sound effects: Brief pause
And that means destroying Hamas. And at the time, a lot of Western leaders said, yep, we've got your back, Israel, do whatever it takes, Israel right or wrong, effectively. People having second thoughts now, because certainly UN workers and from pretty much the entire rest of the Middle East are saying, what is going on in Gaza now is disproportionate.
Sound effects: Brief pause
Now, in terms of war crimes and bringing people to account for this, this is phenomenally difficult, because there is a precedent here. In March of this year, the International Criminal Court in The Hague brought charges against both President Putin of Russia and his Commissioner for Children's Rights, Maria Lvovopova.
Sound effects: Brief pause
So there are international arrest warrants out for both of them. And it hasn't stopped President Putin from traveling to Kazakhstan and to China. And I'm sure in due course, he'll go to North Korea.
Sound effects: Brief pause
Jackie Leonard
And I do need to point out here that of all the messages that we received on this subject, they were all about Israel. This is a reflection of what listeners are discussing rather than any bias from our end.
Sound effects: Brief pause
Two listeners with similar questions. I am Sachin Arana, working as an English teacher. I am from India. My question, is it justified to use a disproportionate force against innocent civilian population because of the presence of a few thousand militants who are lurking among them.
Sound effects: Brief pause
Sachin Arana
And that is my question to the international community.
Sound effects: Brief pause
Jackie Leonard
Hello, my name is Nana. I'm calling from Japan. There are a number of alleged war crimes by Israel, including collective punishment, restricting basic necessities to civilians like food and water and fuel, bombing areas like schools and hospitals.
Sound effects: Brief pause
Nana
How are governments and leaders held accountable for alleged war crimes?
Sound effects: Brief pause
Frank Gardner
Okay, well, first of all, to answer the first question there, it is never justified to use disproportionate force against civilians on any side. There's no question about that. But where I think the Israelis would disagree with you is that they would say what they're doing in Gaza is not disproportionate.
Sound effects: Brief pause
Much of the world may disagree with them. But they say, look, what happened on October the 7th was so appalling, so reminiscent of pogroms and of the Holocaust. It was the worst single attack on Israelis in their entire history since the foundation of the State of Israel in 1948, that they said, we have got to do whatever it takes to remove the military threat to our people.
Sound effects: Brief pause
And that means destroying Hamas. And at the time, a lot of Western leaders said, yep, we've got your back, Israel, do whatever it takes, Israel right or wrong, effectively. People having second thoughts now, because certainly UN workers and from pretty much the entire rest of the Middle East are saying, what is going on in Gaza now is disproportionate.
Sound effects: Brief pause
Now, in terms of war crimes and bringing people to account for this, this is phenomenally difficult, because there is a precedent here. In March of this year, the International Criminal Court in The Hague brought charges against both President Putin of Russia and his Commissioner for Children's Rights, Maria Lvovopova.
Sound effects: Brief pause
So there are international arrest warrants out for both of them. And it hasn't stopped President Putin from traveling to Kazakhstan and to China. And I'm sure in due course, he'll go to North Korea.
Sound effects: Brief pause
Jackie Leonard
This listener has a question about it. Hello, everyone. My name is Porik Sweeney, an Irishman living in Bogota, Colombia. And so one of my old Israeli friends, who I guess could be described as being a bit more critical of the Israeli government, explained to me one day that he felt that the Israeli government uses military service as a tool to brainwash the Israeli youth against Palestinians and Arabs in general.
Sound effects: Brief pause
So my question for your experts is, what role does the obligatory Israeli military service play in perpetuating the conflicts and in fomenting anti-Arab sentiment among Israelis? And if it does do this, how intentional is it?
Sound effects: Brief pause
Lise Doucette
I've never done military service in Israel. I'm not Israeli, so I don't know what they're taught in classes. What I do know from having lived here for several years and having been here for many decades is that a large percentage of Israelis do carry out military service.
Sound effects: Brief pause
But there are many exemptions. Ultra-Orthodox Jews can get exemptions because they're studying at the yeshivas and therefore they have a higher, more noble task. Israeli Arabs also don't serve. They're not obliged to do the military service, although some can ask to serve. The Druze also do serve.
Sound effects: Brief pause
And for a very long time, Israel's military was described as the people's army. If you look at the statistics now, it doesn't cross all of the residents of the Jewish state, but it is a rite of passage here. It's a very formative experience for the youth.
Sound effects: Brief pause
What I would say is that it is such a formative experience that what you're seeing now is that we've met, we've spoken to Israeli reservists arriving here from around the world saying, my country is under threat and I want to serve. This is my war too. So it helped bring the nation together, whatever differences they may have on other issues, when the country feels at threat.
Sound effects: Brief pause
Jackie Leonard
And it's such a huge question, one for you, Lise. It is such an important question. And the answer to that question is the answer to whether or not this region can ever see peace, can ever share the land and allow, in this case, both Israelis and Palestinians to live side by side, a Palestinian state side by side to a Jewish state.
Sound effects: Brief pause
But at this particular moment in time, anger, anger is running very, very high. Anger is boiling over. Passions are inflamed. Around the world, we have seen streets filled with either anti-Israeli protests or anti-Palestinian protests. And there is nothing in between. It is a zero-sum game at the moment.
Sound effects: Brief pause
I think perhaps the only glimmer of hope that I can see that is blinking away, buried amongst all this awful news coming out of this conflict, is that there is, I think, an acceptance around the world that the problem in the Middle East of a just solution for Israelis and Palestinians cannot be ignored.
Sound effects: Brief pause
Because it was being ignored. A number of Arab countries, UAE, Bahrain, Morocco, and potentially Saudi Arabia, they had made peace with Israel. They had normalized their ties. Saudi Arabia was poised to do the same.
Sound effects: Brief pause
And this would have certainly sidelined both Hamas and the Palestinian Authority with an idea, well, let's just get on with life normally. There is no such thing as normal life for Palestinians and many cases for Israelis who've come under constant fire from Gaza.
Sound effects: Brief pause
So it can't go on unnoticed. You can't keep kettling 2.3 million people into this tiny real estate, tiny strip of the Gaza Strip, not able to get in or out in most cases, and denying the Palestinians a homeland, according to UN resolutions and so on.
Sound effects: Brief pause
So until that is resolved, sadly, I think the cycle of violence is going to continue. There may be ceasefires, there may be pauses, there may be lulls, but ultimately it's going to grind on until there is a fair solution for both sides.
Sound effects: Brief pause
And yet in the midst of this bonfire, you still hear those voices. And it's very, very touching to hear that even some of the family members of hostages, Israelis whose family members are now being held hostage by Hamas, they are saying we need to find a way forward. More violence is not the answer to this solution. We have to find ways to live together. Neither of us is going to go away.
Sound effects: Brief pause
There's voices in the midst of a much larger roar in a very polarized situation. And if I would give you advice about how you can be part of the solution, and I think both Frank and I, this is the job we try to do, try to listen to both sides. Try to understand why they're angry. What is the root of their anger? What is it that is fueling these emotions for them?
Sound effects: Brief pause
And I think we have to not just listen, but we have to really hear what people are saying. But unfortunately, now people are talking past each other. And it's not surprising given the intensity of this war.
Sound effects: Brief pause
And there we must end this special edition of the Global News podcast. Thank you to Lise Doucette, our chief international correspondent in Jerusalem and our security correspondent, Frank Gardner, here in the studio in London.
Sound effects: Brief pause
And thank you if you've sent in a question. We do plan to keep doing these question and answer specials as long as they're useful. So if you have anything that you would like discussed or explained, please record it or just write it and email globalpodcast at bbc.co.uk.
Sound effects: Brief pause
You can also find us on X, formerly known as Twitter, at Global News Pod. And do subscribe to The Conflict wherever you found this podcast.
Sound effects: Brief pause
This edition was mixed by Mike Regard. The producers were Anna Murphy and Judy Frankel. Our editor is Karen Martin. I'm Jackie Leonard. Until next time, goodbye.
Theme music fades in