Main Topic: The podcast episode discusses the current tensions between Russia and Ukraine, and the possibility of a full-scale invasion by Russia. The experts, including Steve Rosenberg in Moscow, Sarah Rainsford in Kiev, and Paul Adams in London, provide insights into the historical context, the interests of both countries, and the potential consequences of such an invasion.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Our experts in Moscow, Kyiv and London answer your questions about the crisis.
Jackie Leonard
This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK. America's Social Casino. Download the Moto Casino app today.
Sound effects: Music fades out
In the shadows and flames, primals will fall, and from the blood and ash, new gods will rise. Poppy was never meant to awaken, and consequences are devastating, stirring ancient powers from their slumber, transforming Castile and Kirin in ways the fates couldn't foresee. The great conspirator has returned to stop the primal of death. The gods have awakened, harboring blood-soaked secrets, and every choice can undo everything. The primal of Blood and Bone, perfect for fans of Sarah J Maas and Rebecca Yaros. Available in print, e-book and audio book.
As tensions increase over Russia and Ukraine, is a full-scale invasion imminent? I'm Jackie Leonard, and in this special edition of the BBC World Service Global News podcast, recorded on Friday the 28th of January, we're putting your questions to some of our experts. In Moscow, Steve Rosenberg, formerly in Moscow, now in Kiev, Sarah Rainsford, and here in London, our international affairs correspondent, Paul Adams.
As we record this podcast, around 100,000 Russian troops are in place along Ukraine's border, taking up positions to the north, south and east. The US President Joe Biden has warned there is a distinct possibility that Russia might invade in February, and Russia says it sees little ground for optimism in resolving the crisis after the US rejected Russia's main demand. It wants a guarantee that neither Ukraine nor Georgia should be allowed to join NATO. That's the international group of 30 countries who have agreed to support each other politically and militarily if they are attacked. Moscow also wants a withdrawal of any NATO presence from Eastern Europe.
In this podcast, we will be putting your questions to our expert correspondents about how we got here, what Russia wants from this situation the broader view of world reaction and world alliances, and what might happen next. Before any of that, though, let's hear a little bit from some of the people in Ukraine who are currently living with this hanging over them.
Sound effects: Music fades in
Finally, some drills have started, so our kids know what to do in case of war. Of course, it makes no sense for a great war with Ukraine. But Mr. Putin, I'm afraid he's delirious. He's far from watching. For me, it's not surprising to see that a lot of people, women and men, will be ready to protect Ukraine. In the case, it would be necessary. I want to be prepared to any scenario. So I know that probability of hard war is not that high, but it still might happen. So if it happens, I'm already prepared. I'm asking my parents if they have prepared such emergency bags. They have not. So drills in schools, uncertainty, ordinary citizens, some wondering whether it's time to start preparing to flee or protect their homes.
So how did we get here? Paul Adams is our international affairs correspondent who helpfully has also reported over many years from Washington and Eastern Europe. So, Paul, this didn't just come from nowhere. A brief timeline, please.
Paul Adams
Well, I won't go back a thousand years into history, but I think it's worth just quickly sketching perhaps you know the situation over the last hundred years if you'll forgive me. So we had the Russian revolution 1917 communist Russia then dominated an empire from the baltic to the pacific that was the old soviet union that of course, came to an end with the collapse of communism at the end of the 1980s. And when it collapsed, around 15 countries, including Ukraine, achieved independence. That was 1991.
Jackie Leonard
For the next 20 years or so, Ukraine, like some of the other former Soviet states, wrestled with its political and economic identity, whether to look to the West and NATO, the European Union, or to Russia for support and protection and alliances and so forth. There were two moments of high tension. There was the so-called Orange Revolution in 2004, which pitted pro-Western and pro-Russian politicians against each other. And then the protests known as Euromaidan 10 years later.
Now, those were triggered when Ukraine's then president, Viktor Yanukovych, decided rather abruptly to scrap an association agreement with the European Union that had been in the works for some time and move instead to a closer relationship with Russia. That triggered enormous street protests in Kiev in November of 2013. In February, after some pretty deadly clashes in the city, Mr. Yanukovych actually fled and a new pro-European leadership took over.
Moscow, not surprisingly, was furious. They've always called this a coup. And within days, we remember, Russian troops took control of the Crimean peninsula down on the Black Sea. Crimea, by the way, had been arbitrarily handed over to Ukraine from Russia back in the 1950s. And there were plenty of very pro-Russian people down there. And Russia supported armed men in two other southeastern areas of Ukraine, Donetsk and Luhansk, where pro-Russian sentiment was also fairly strong.
This led to a war which flared in 2014 and 15 and has continued ever since at a pretty low level, but has killed around 14,000 people so far. Paul, thank you for that. And welcome to Steve Rosenberg in Moscow and Sarah Rainsford, who is in Kiev at the moment. Welcome to you all.
Let's hear from our listeners. First of all, this from Ariane in Brussels. I would be interested to hear a more in-depth report on the geopolitical interest of Ukraine to Russia. This mainly from a geographical, natural resources, as well as historical perspective.
And a couple more. Hi, it's Victoria from New York. Why does Ukraine joining NATO pose such a threat to Russia? And that's echoed by Alexandre in France. I'd like to know if you can summarise for us what NATO represents, to give us some context of why Russia seems to care so much about who joins the organisation.
So Steve Rosenberg in Moscow, let's start with you. Oh, good questions there. I mean, as far as Russia's interest in Ukraine goes, Russia's interest is multifaceted, isn't it? It's historical, it's imperial, it's emotional, it's geopolitical.
Steve Rosenberg
Russia wants Ukraine to be in its orbit, in its sphere of influence for many reasons. I mean, these two countries, we've heard from Paul, but these two countries go back a long way, right? A thousand years, all the way back to Kiev and Rus. And of course, Ukraine was part of the Tsarist Empire, then the USSR.
Jackie Leonard
That's Steve Rosenberg in Moscow. Sarah Rainsford in Kiev, what about people in Kiev, in Ukraine? What are they saying about NATO?
Sarah Rainsford
Well, I think, yeah, the interesting question there was what does NATO represent? And Steve sort of describing what it represents, certainly for Russia's political leadership. But here in Ukraine, if you talk about people on the street, then I think it represents security.
Jackie Leonard
And what does that actually look like? What there is it fields and trees barricades? What is actually there?
Sarah Rainsford
Well, in terms of troops on the ground, first of all, you got the 100 Russian soldiers close to the border with Ukraine, right? You've got other Russian troops nearby, military exercises going on.
Jackie Leonard
As you say, there is a long history between Russia and Ukraine. How do Russians and Ukrainians feel about each other and what's going on? You first, Sarah.
Sarah Rainsford
Well, I think on a sort of human level, then there is very little antipathy. I mean, certainly Ukrainians would say they're not one nation with Russians, but there are strong bonds, cultural, historical, linguistic even, that go back many, many, many years.
Jackie Leonard
Steve Rosenberg in Moscow, how does that look from Moscow?
Steve Rosenberg
Well, it's interesting. I mean, the last couple of days I've been around the streets chatting to people here about what they think about whether people believe there could be a big war between Russia and Ukraine. And most of the people that I've spoken to simply can't believe or they don't want to believe that that is possible because so many people have said to me, look, Russians are Slavs, Ukrainians are Slavs, we're brothers. How can this possibly happen?
Jackie Leonard
This is Norman from Ontario in Canada, and he's concerned about how much people know or think they know. Over the last five years or so, I've developed friendships with people in Russia and in Ukraine. My Russian friends are very kind and intelligent people, and they are notably wary of state news outlets. However, when you have been reading crafted propaganda for 20 years or more, you end up believing some of it. So my question is, how do I respectfully deal with what I know to be outright lies that they may believe?
Steve Rosenberg in Moscow, is Russia worried?
Steve Rosenberg
Well, you know, Russia's been under Western sanctions for eight years now. And the position here, you often hear Russian officials sort of saying, well, you know, sticks and stones will break our bones, but sanctions will never hurt us.
Jackie Leonard
They've managed to survive the current rounds of sanctions. But of course, what Western governments are threatening now in the event of a further Russian invasion of Ukraine are much tougher sanctions, things like possibly cutting Russia off from the swift global payment system, possibly even sanctions against Vladimir Putin personally himself, a different level of sanctions. And that is causing concern here.
But we have talked about energy and whether Russia could hit back by reducing energy shipments. It's a very important question. Moscow insists that it is a reliable supply of energy, of oil and gas, and always has been, even going back to Soviet times. But of course, this is a concern that Moscow could use energy as a political weapon.
It's been accused of doing so by governments in the West before. And Sarah, what sort of international pressure would Ukraine ideally like to see its allies put on Moscow?
Sarah Rainsford
I think from the people I've been speaking to here, the more pressure, the better on every front. I mean, with Nord Stream 2, for example, Ukraine is no fan of that pipeline because it denies Ukraine a whole lot of money and transit fees that it gets for the gas that's currently flowing via pipes across Ukraine.
Jackie Leonard
So sanctions that would prevent the turn on of Nord Stream 2, Ukraine would be fine with that. But I was asking, for example, not about sanctions, but about military pressure and escalation and what have you here.
For example, a lot of people have been saying, OK, the West is is giving Ukraine weapons. It's arming the Ukrainian military. It's helping Ukraine to be able to physically fight back were Russian troops to to enter en masse, you know, an all out war here in Ukraine.
But some people have been saying, is that moral? Is that ethically right? when the West is then saying, but we won't send any troops, because let's face it, the Russian military is a bigger and more powerful force than the Ukrainians, even though the Ukrainians have been much strengthened by over the past few years by military assistance from from NATO countries.
And the answer I'm getting is, you know what, we're happy for the support we're getting. We're very grateful that we're getting lethal force now weaponry from the US in particular, but from the West more generally. We want the force essentially to hold Vladimir Putin at bay.
We want every single lever of pressure possible used to ensure that Vladimir Putin cannot make the calculation that it in his interests to send his troops openly into Ukraine.
We did actually hear President Biden talking about a response to an incursion rather than an invasion which caused some consternation it fair to say.
There are options short of a full land operation that could still have a massive impact, aren't there? Let's go to you, Steve.
Steve Rosenberg
Yes, I mean, anything is possible. I mean, we talk about possible Russian invasion of Ukraine, but there could be a more limited military operation. There's talk about possible cyber attacks. Anything is possible.
Jackie Leonard
And I think there would be differences amongst Western governments about how to react depending on what Russia did. One thing that the Kremlin is masterful at, it is identifying differences and disunity amongst Western governments and Western leaders and trying to exploit that.
And I think you'd see the Russians trying to do that, depending on what actually happens and develops. In the Russian press in recent days, there's been a lot of articles about alleging differences and arguments amongst Western leaders, between America and various European governments, about what to do, how to react to Russia.
And, you know, we've seen in recent years that Vladimir Putin has been quite successful at this, at developing relations with certain countries, driving wedges between various members of NATO.
And I think the Russians will continue to do that. Only this week we had Vladimir Putin meeting over Videolink with some Italian businessmen, very controversial at a time when the West is trying to put a unified position, talk about possible sanctions against Russia.
And he was speaking to Italian businessmen. So the government paper here published a letter by 40 German ex-diplomats and politicians and military men in support of Russia and calling on the West to have a more constructive relationship. with Russia.
So I think we're going to, we'll see the Kremlin continuing to do this, to try to pick away at Western unity and create disunity.
As you say, anything is possible. As we record this podcast, we are poised at a very delicate point. The US warning an invasion could happen in February, Ukraine somewhat trying to play that down. So how likely is it really? This listener thinks not.
Jamie from Hungerford in Berkshire. Surely nobody, including NATO, Kiev and Moscow, thinks that Putin is going to invade Ukraine. It will be committing his military to something far worse than the 20 years that coalition forces spent in Afghanistan, with no end except the total devastation of Putin's political position in Russia.
If he invades, then our principal worry should be that he's gone completely mad. Steve?
Steve Rosenberg
I would say that most people I've spoken to here believe that there won't be an invasion of Ukraine. But I would also say that eight years ago, I would never have believed that Russia would have annexed Crimea or intervened militarily in eastern Ukraine.
Jackie Leonard
I was completely taken by surprise by that. So anything is possible. And, you know, when you have so many forces down there, concentrated down there in that area, Even if an invasion war is not in the planning, there's always the room, the danger of some miscalculation, some accident, some spark that sparks a conflict that would be difficult to stop.
Sarah?
Sarah Rainsford
First and foremost, let's bear in mind that part of Ukraine is already, Ukrainians would say, invaded. You know, there have been Russian troops, although Russia has denied it always. There were Russian troops in eastern Ukraine.
Jackie Leonard
So what we're talking about is how far would Vladimir Putin think he could go this time? I'd say from here in Kiev, the general feeling is it's unlikely that people here in the capital would be threatened by some kind of all out war, some kind of massive incursion into the country.
But the likelihood or the possibility of a serious escalation and an open involvement of Russian troops in the east of the country, in the Donbass region, well, people definitely aren't ruling that out.
I would say it's kind of similar to what Steve was saying. Generally speaking, people here say it wouldn't be rational. It wouldn't be logical for Vladimir Putin to go for all out war in Ukraine and to think he could occupy a country which believes it's made a choice to turn away from him and away from Russia.
You know, people I've spoken to here are pretty firm that they would resist. Kiev doesn't feel like a city on edge. It's not a nervous place. But talking to people, an increasing number of them are beginning to prepare these emergency banks, as they call them, kind of grab and go kits with the absolute essential essential stuff in it that, you know, if something bad happens, if they need to run to safety, they can just grab those bags, get in their cars and get out of town, go west.
And Paul, finally.
Paul Adams
Yeah, I was just going to echo what Steve said. I mean, I don't think many people believe that an all out invasion is likely. They also don't think, frankly, that there is nearly enough men and material arranged around Ukraine's borders to actually do that at the moment.
Jackie Leonard
But they do look at a number of options. One would be a kind of formal takeover of those breakaway areas in the southeast, in the Donbass region. That could be fairly easily achieved. Ukraine wouldn't necessarily put up all that much resistance if that were to happen.
But there is a question about whether or not that would be of any real utility to Vladimir Putin. Those are pretty poor parts of the world that have been devastated by eight years of war. And it's hard to see what he would really gain by formally taking them over.
Another possibility is a land corridor from those areas to the other part of Ukraine that is currently controlled by Russia. And that, of course, is Crimea. That would be a major, major military operation right along the coastline of the Sea of Azov to create this land bridge to Crimea, which the Russians would really like, not least because Crimeans are short of water, which comes from the mainland.
And that would be one way of sorting that out. But that would be a pretty substantial operation. And again, fraught with all sorts of risks.
One last thing, though, on the kind of military options. Of course, one of the things we've seen in the last week or so is the movement of Russian troops and equipment into Belarus, which, of course, is a significant development, moving Russian troops outside of Russia's borders into a neighboring country where they will be much closer to the Ukrainian capital, Kiev, in the event of some kind of much, much larger operation.
I don't think, again, people think that that's all that likely. But a lot of people do note that the presence of Russian troops in Belarus now is in itself a substantial achievement for Vladimir Putin. And they wonder how long they're going to stay there.
And we will end where we began with a reminder. This isn't just geopolitics and power, military might and finance. It's about ordinary people living their lives. Two people sharing the same hope, one from Kiev, one from Moscow.
I'm just living my best life right now and hoping that everything will be OK. I don't know. Somebody can pray, somebody can meditate for a peaceful resolution. And I think we need to urge our governments to do the same, not necessarily pray, but to resolve all of this peacefully because nobody in their right minds wants war.
Voices from Kiev and Moscow. All that remains is to say thank you to Paul Adams in London, Sarah Rainsford in Kiev, Steve Rosenberg in Moscow, and you, listeners around the world, for your questions.
Apologies if we didn't have time to get to yours. Normal global news podcast service will be resumed later. Our email address remains globalpodcast at bbc.co.uk. Not just for your comments on this edition, but also if you have any questions about other big world issues you would like us to tackle next.
You will also find us on Twitter at Global News Pod. Today's edition was mixed by Holly Palmer. The producer was Theopi Scarlatos. Our editor is Karen Martin. I'm Jackie Leonard. And until next time, goodbye.
Power up fall projects with Ego at Lowe's. Every tool delivers power beyond belief. So whether it's leaves, limbs, or lawn cleanup, count on Ego to deliver the power, performance, and innovation you need.
And now for a limited time, save up to $60 on select blowers, chainsaws, and pole saws. Shop Ego today at Lowe's. Offers valid through 10-1 while supplies last. Selection varies by location.