Main Topic: The current situation in Ukraine and the impact of the US decision to suspend military aid to Ukraine.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
What future for Ukraine? Your questions answered. Global News Podcast teams up with Ukrainecast for a special Q&A, in a week that has seen US military aid halted. Can Trump and Zelensky get back to talks on a peace deal?
Jackie Leonard will be joined by Ukrainecast's Vitaly Shevchenko, the BBC's Ukraine Correspondent James Waterhouse and Chief International Correspondent Lyse Doucet.
Theme music fades out
Jackie Leonard
This is a special collaborative edition of the Global News Podcast with our colleagues from UkraineCast. I'm Jackie Leonard, and in the studio, we have UkraineCast presenter Vitaly Shevchenko and our Chief International Correspondent Lise Doucet. And in Kiev, we have James Waterhouse.
Pause
We are recording this edition at 16 hours GMT on Friday the 7th of March. That's 1,108 days since Russia's full-scale invasion of Ukraine. Events are moving very fast, and we'll be putting your questions to our experts and trying to unpick some of the issues that have come to the fore in the last week.
Pause
Now, we want to get through as many questions as possible, so let's begin with Denise. Hi, my name is Denise and I'm from Auckland, New Zealand. I'm exploring worst-case scenarios and my question and concern is what happens if US stops supporting Ukraine and eventually they will have no choice but to surrender to Russia.
Pause
Now, for the last three years of war, America has been Ukraine's largest donor. The decision to freeze military aid follows that very public disagreement in the Oval Office between Volodymyr Zelensky, Donald Trump and Vice President J.D. Vance.
Pause
James Waterhouse
Well, I mean, what any Ukrainian will tell you on a Kiev street is that they would never surrender. I mean, the idea of sticking it down in weapons and allowing Russia to occupy, take over the country, install a puppet regime is, and as always has been, a non-starter.
Pause
I think when you speak to those in military circles, it is accepted that Ukraine could probably fight on for months, maybe a little bit longer. But that is the reality, such as the quality and quantity of what America does provide.
Pause
Lise Doucet
I think when you look at US military support to Ukraine, you have to look at it from a number of vantage points. One is the quantity of the weaponry that the United States is providing Ukraine, that even though Europe is providing a lot, in some cases more, it cannot double that to provide what the United States is doing.
Pause
Secondly, it's the quality of what the United States, as the world's mightiest military power, is able to provide. We've already heard about intelligence being discontinued, which creates a huge problem for Ukraine.
Pause
Jackie Leonard
Now, let's go to Alex in Shanghai. Hi, BBC Global Podcast team. Thanks for your excellent work. My question to you regarding the war in Ukraine is, in light of the US decision to suspend providing military aid, meaning no more HIMARS, I'm curious whether the UK, France and Germany can supply Ukraine with sufficient ammunition of such kind to fill in the gap.
Pause
Lise Doucet
No, not quickly. I remember last year the EU foreign policy chief telling me with great frustration our cupboards are bare. Our manufacturing cannot keep up with the volume, the intensity of the warfare.
Pause
James Waterhouse
I think when you're on the front lines, the only artillery you could hear was from the Russian side. That's changed in some areas, but it's about suppressing fire. It's about targeting supply routes to hinder the sort of relentless Russian assaults you see on so many parts of the front lines.
Pause
Jackie Leonard
Let's go to James in Oxford in central England. Dear Ukraine cast, I am deeply concerned by the desire of the Trump administration to impose a quick peace deal, seemingly irrespective of the consequences.
Pause
And we have a similar question from Pauline. Hi, this is Pauline from the Philippines. And I've been following the Ukraine-Russia war and all of President Trump's decisions. and was curious about what the American people think of this.
Pause
Michael from North-Central Florida: From the moment that Russia invaded Ukraine in February of 22, I, as well as my family and the broader community, fully and enthusiastically supported Ukraine's struggle for freedom. And then last Friday happened. Now I don't know. It's as though I'm wandering through some alternate dimension.
Pause
Carter
And, you know, it's been said that Donald Trump is a transactional politician, which leads me to believe or at least hope that there is some sort of a strategy behind what feels like this complete 180 in the relationship between the U.S. and Ukraine.
Pause
Lee from Houston: I think it's unreasonable to think that if this war were to go on for three more years, that anything would be different other than more dead Ukrainians and Russians.
Pause
Anthony Zerka
I'd say it's a bit too early to have any kind of accurate polling on what Americans think about that Oval Office Trump-Zelensky dust-up last week. But there was a recent CBS poll that showed the United States narrowly divided on whether they approved of how Donald Trump has handled the Ukraine war so far in the month he's been president.
Pause
Lise Doucet
Yes, and Afghans certainly are mentioning it a lot. You see conversations on social media. I mean, they're very, very different societies, very different wars.
Pause
James Waterhouse
Well, Ukraine says it's got around sort of 5% of the world's what are called critical raw materials. So we're talking about graphite, granite, lithium, titanium, things that are used to make electric cars, cars, turbines, electronics, weapons, they're worth a lot of money, billions of dollars.
Pause
Vitaly Shevchenko
When it comes to American citizens acting as a human shield potentially well they're there now and just yesterday Russia targeted a hotel in central Ukraine where American citizens were staying as well as British citizens as well.
Pause
Lise Doucet
Well, for this question, we thought we'd go to our Asia business reporter, Surinjana Tawari. Major stock markets tumbled this week as investors around the world are trying to get a handle on Donald Trump's sweeping and shifting policies.
Pause
Caroline in Switzerland asked, how can a Trump administration be against Iran but supportive of Russia.
Pause
James Waterhouse
Well, America's kind of left Ukraine and Europe scrambling to come up with their own proposals. But I think what I will always remember is the sight of Pete Hegsif, the Defence Secretary of America, in an innocuous meeting in Brussels where he said, right, it's Ukraine. Getting all of its territory back, that is an illusion.
Pause
Vitaly Shevchenko
There are officials in Moscow saying that the special military operation will go on. Its original objectives will be reached. More land will be captured. Peacekeepers forget it. That's unacceptable.
Pause
Lise Doucet
I don't think you can say they're any closer to ending it, but it certainly is the main focus. That's the narrative now. It is about providing more military assistance to Ukraine so they'll be in a stronger military position once they actually get to the battlefield.
Pause
Jackie Leonard
Thanks to Lise Doucet, James Waterhouse, and of course Vitaly Shevchenko, and to you for all your questions. If you don't already subscribe to UkraineCast, you should, and you'll find it wherever you get your BBC podcasts.
Theme music fades in