Main Topic: The Supreme Court's ruling on Chevron deference and its impact on the fishing industry, specifically the case of Relentless Incorporated v. Commerce Department.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Sound of a news theme music fades out
John Bickley
This episode is brought to you by LifeLock. When you visit the doctor, you probably hand over your insurance, your ID, and contact details. It's just one of the many places that has your personal info. And if any of them accidentally expose it, you could be at risk for identity theft. LifeLock monitors millions of data points a second. If you become a victim, they'll fix it, guaranteed, or your money back. Save up to 40% your first year at LifeLock.com slash podcast. Terms apply.
Sound of a news theme music continues
In a landmark ruling last week, the Supreme Court overturned Chevron deference, stripping federal agencies of what had become increasingly unilateral power to interpret and enforce policies without checks and balances. The ruling was a result of a lawsuit, Relentless Incorporated v. Commerce Department, involving government overreach in the fishing industry. In this episode, we talk with the founder of an influential fishermen's association who filed an amicus brief in that case about what he says is a long pattern of government intrusion that's destroying whole industries.
Sound of a news theme music fades out
Since 1974, Saudi Arabia has sold oil solely in U.S. dollars, which was paramount to the dollar's strength and stability. But not anymore. That's why you've got to get in touch with the experts over at Birch Gold today. Right now, with qualifying purchases made by July 31st, you get a one-of-a-kind limited edition golden truth bomb. The only way to claim your eligibility, though, is by texting WIRE to 989898. Text WIRE to 989898 for a free, no-obligation info kit on gold and to get your hands on that limited edition golden truth bomb today.
Sound of a news theme music continues
Joining us now is Jerry Lehman, New England Fisherman's Stewardship Association founder and CEO, who filed an amicus brief in the case that ended up overturning Chevron deference. Jerry, welcome.
Jerry Lehman
Thanks for having me on the show.
John Bickley
First, tell us, if you would, about your background. How long have you been in the fishing industry?
Jerry Lehman
I was raised in Harpsville, Maine, by a commercial fishing family, lobstering and ground fishing, seining, urcheting, scalloping, shrimping, back when the state of Maine had it. I've been in all the fisheries. I spent since 2000 I spent 23 years at sea fishing 220 240 days a year multi trawling I been networked in all the major fishing ports here Portland Maine Gloucester Boston Mass., New Bedford, Mass., and I've covered a lot of the region's territory.
John Bickley
In terms of progress and decline, what have you seen in this industry that you've spent decades working in?
Jerry Lehman
I've been seeing decline steadily since 2000. I mean, we don't even see new participants really getting into the fisheries. We've moved the goalposts too far. And now with these restrictions and quotas, I mean, now you're forcing people to buy fish in order to catch fish. And the problem is the price that you pay to catch a fish is less than the market value once you've retrieved it. So sometimes, most times I go, when you go to buy lease quota, you're only buying it just for the sake of keeping the vessel active. You're not actually making any financial gain. If anything, it's a financial burden.
John Bickley
Now, this brings us to the case in which you filed an amicus brief, Relentless Incorporated versus Commerce Department. It's now the case that overturned Chevron deference. It came in response to a new federal law requiring government observers on fishing vessels. What sparked your involvement in the case?
Jerry Lehman
Well, it's just been watching what's been taking place over the years. And now that we're pushing for fishing vessels to pay for observers aboard our vessels, which if you do the breakdown, now they're going to account for the fisheries to pay more towards observers than we're actually paying our crews, which does not make for a viable business. So this really was a question of whether or not you can actually keep business open if this policy were to be enacted. This was a fisheries killer.
John Bickley
So what was the thinking from the government here that this would actually be viable?
Jerry Lehman
It's just more overreach and overwatch. I mean, we have less fishermen every year, and yet now we want 100% coverage. It's like, well, we haven't even broken any rules or laws, so why are we having to pay to have somebody watch us around the clock? I mean, our arguments were pretty easy. It was, I mean, look at how many truck drivers are in America. How would we feel if we put an observer and then made those truck drivers pay to feed those observers maintain them babysit and pay them more than what they paying their crews It was preposterous
John Bickley
Is this part of a pattern that you seen from the Commerce Department related to the fishing industry?
Jerry Lehman
Oh, this is something that's been taking place for quite a while now. And this is a good first step in the right direction in a long time.
John Bickley
You said first step. Are there some other things that you believe need to be overruled or overturned in terms of policies?
Jerry Lehman
I think that some of these policies that have been dictated to the fisheries, you know, didn't have logical excuse as far as the economics of the fisheries viability, which has been detrimental. I mean, if you talk to fishermen and recreational fishermen up and down the coast, nobody seems to see a problem in our biomass. But yet our surveys that keep coming back are depleting our allowable catches. And then on top of that, you know, they're requesting us to pay for observers. I mean, these are people that come straight from college, little to no experience at sea. And here in New England, we have variable weather. I mean, it's not very nice out there in the winter months. So now you have somebody that doesn't even know if they get seasick trapped on a vessel with us for 10 days, and now it's our responsibility to monitor them and to keep them safe. It was a lot of overreach.
John Bickley
What do you think the role of the federal government should be with the fishing industry?
Jerry Lehman
Well, I mean, we're a big part of our food securities. I mean, up here in New England, this has been a major part of this country's food banks, and now we're removing it from the populace. I mean, 94% of the product is now consumed as foreign product. So why are we restricting U.S. harvesters from providing wild, local, heart-healthy product that's environmentally friendly and sustainable? And meanwhile, we're purchasing product from other nations that do not abide by our rules and regulations. This has been something that's been going on for a while, and now we have less fishermen than we had in colonial days. And this was just one more further step in pretty much cutting the throats of the entire fishing fleet.
John Bickley
What do you hope to see in the coming years from both the federal government and state governments? How can they help the industry thrive again?
Jerry Lehman
Well, a lot of it has to do with the data that we receive. I mean, it'll be good to have knowledgeable fishermen who have spent their entire lives decades at sea using these equipment to garner the best data available using the science teams So this guess on modeling based on multiple surveys would be more accurate which would allow us to develop better marketing strategies put together working fisheries educational to be applied to the future.
John Bickley
What do you mean by that, that we don't teach fisheries?
Jerry Lehman
Well, we teach how fishing management works based on surveys allocations and statistical committees. But as far as using trawl gear, migrational patterns of our stocks and how to harvest these things responsible and sustainably, mending is a big part of trawling. We don't really teach that as well. We have no educational classes of getting fundamental, you know, educated employees to get the job done safely in a manageably environmentally friendly way.
John Bickley
So what's the solution there? Who should provide that education?
Jerry Lehman
It's going to have to be from the fisheries that are pre-existing. And right now we have an aging of the fleet. So we're on a ticking time bomb as far as passing that knowledge to the next generation. That has been my forefront of my arguments. It's like, well, you only know what you know and how do you know it? The fishermen that came before us learned from the fishermen in their region based on time and effort. And that's something that has been passed down through families and multiple vessels and skippers to their mates who passed that knowledge over time and effort to their mates. and that's how collectively we moved along and advanced ourselves. But now we have so very few people left and we don't teach these things. I mean, back in the 80s and 90s, a lot of schools used to offer programs with marine trades and that's something that went away, what, 25 years ago. And now what we're left with is a crippled fleet.
John Bickley
Final question. Do you have hope that this industry, the fishing industry, will bounce back?
Jerry Lehman
I think there is time to still salvage that knowledge and pass it on to the next generation, which will go back to the food securities of this nation. I mean, it's one thing to say we have it, but we have to be able to harvest it to provide it to the U.S. consumer and to do so in a responsibly, sustainably way. So this way, our food securities of the nations are here for the longevity.
John Bickley
Well, Jerry, thank you so much for talking with us and taking the steps you did to protect your industry.
Jerry Lehman
Thank you very much.
John Bickley
That was Jerry Lehman of the New England Fisherman's Stewardship Association. And this has been an extra edition of Morning Wire.