Main Topic: The U.S. Army's massive restructuring effort, which includes reducing the force by 5% and reallocation of resources across various sectors.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Georgia Howe
Just this week, the Army announced a massive restructuring effort that would reduce the force by 5% and reallocate resources across a variety of sectors. This is the first formal contraction of the Army since the start of the all-volunteer force in 1970.
John Bickley
In this episode of Morning Wire, we hear from an expert about why the U.S. military is taking this action now and how it will likely affect our readiness for war.
Georgia Howe
I'm Georgia Howe with Daily Wire editor-in-chief John Bickley. It's Saturday, March 2nd, and this is an extra edition of Morning Wire.
Sound effects: Music fades out
Joining us to discuss the historic U.S. military contraction is Robert Greenway, director of the Allison Center for National Security at the Heritage Foundation.
Robert Greenway
Hey, thanks so much for having me on.
Georgia Howe
So the Army recently announced they are doing a major restructure. They say they're hoping to be better prepared for war. They've described slashing 24,000 positions, although many of those are already empty. And about 3,000 of those cuts are coming from special operations forces.
Robert Greenway
So appreciate you having me on. So the decision to cut 24,000, or roughly 5% of the force, 32,000 over five years, basically solidifies the vacancies left from the worst recruiting crisis in the history of the all-volunteer force.
Georgia Howe
The Army alone was 10,000 short last year. They'll be short again this year. And the Army is the lowest size and strength since 1940, since before the Second World War.
Robert Greenway
About two-thirds of the overall size of the force that we estimate the Heritage Foundation in our Index of U.S. Military Strength just published.
Georgia Howe
Now, Army Secretary Christine Wormuth just told reporters that these cuts are going to come from, quote, counterinsurgency operations.
Robert Greenway
First off, can you describe what counterinsurgency means and why do you think these are the places where they're cutting?
So it's a great question. I think in the end the Army is attempting to state that these are positions that are no longer required because the Army doesn't anticipate it going to be engaging in counterinsurgency operations.
Georgia Howe
And so special operations forces and other sustainment functions are part of this envisioned cut.
Robert Greenway
But it's a bit of a shell game. The reality is the Army doesn't have the manpower required to fill the force.
Georgia Howe
And so the rationale is less important than the fact that our Army is not large enough to do the job that we anticipate.
Robert Greenway
Under the current circumstances, and in our judgment, it is falling short of the requirement to confront Russia, China, and other aggressors.
Georgia Howe
Now, the plan also includes adding about 7,500 troops to other areas. For example, they mentioned air defense, counter drone. They want to start five new task forces.
Robert Greenway
They're mentioning enhanced cyber, intelligence, long-range strike capabilities. So these are specialized units.
Georgia Howe
How do you anticipate they're going to fill these slots? Are they going to try to reshuffle from within or try to recruit?
Robert Greenway
Well, they don't have a whole lot of choice, especially because the skill level required for some of those tasks and jobs take a long time to develop and can require specific recruiting challenges.
Georgia Howe
So they're going to, I think, at the end, they have to cannibalize within the existing force structure to get there.
Robert Greenway
And look, they're valid military occupational specialties, and they're a critical part of the force.
Georgia Howe
The reality is the force is too small and it's getting smaller.
Robert Greenway
And all we're doing with the most recent NDAA and this admission is we're just accepting the fact that the army is too small.
Georgia Howe
Now, what about technological advances? I know we have other jobs that are being cannibalized by technology.
Robert Greenway
So there's no question that technology has a critical place on the battlefield.
Georgia Howe
We're seeing this in Ukraine, but we're also seeing the fact that technology historically and now is not a substitute for having manpower.
Robert Greenway
And ultimately, war is an ugly business requiring a level of brutality that technology can't compensate for.
Georgia Howe
So there's a place for it to be sure. It always will be a component of our force.
Robert Greenway
It can offset the size of our force relative to our adversaries but it is not a replacement for manpower ultimately.
Georgia Howe
And the army I think as the Ukrainians I think they would be able to tell you exactly the same thing is that they've got a tremendous amount of technological advantages relative to the Russians.
Robert Greenway
But the Russians have a significant advantage in manpower.
Georgia Howe
And that's making the difference right now on the battlefield.
Robert Greenway
And it will in any confrontation we have in the future.
Georgia Howe
Now, all of the armed forces are struggling with recruitment, with the notable exception of the Marines.
Robert Greenway
What do you think the cause is for that?
Georgia Howe
And I'll just mention the Army Secretary says these recruiting deficits began in 2014.
Robert Greenway
Well, so first, the trend might have been visible in 2014, but we really didn't start falling short of goals until about three years ago at precisely the time when we reduced our overseas presence.
Georgia Howe
So you would have thought that having a significant portion of our force in activity abroad and confronting active threats would have discouraged some from participating.
Robert Greenway
Quite the opposite.
Georgia Howe
I think we maintain that despite the fact that we were engaged in overseas conflicts for over two decades.
Robert Greenway
I think the challenge is now is that there's little trust in government as a whole and then within the military leadership in particular.
Georgia Howe
I think the disastrous withdrawal from Afghanistan and decisions to let our troops sit idle in the Middle East and receive incoming fire without adequate response, that continues to be a problem.
Robert Greenway
Few people, I think, want to sign up for a force that is also prioritizing diversity, equity, inclusion over merit and character, which has historically been the only way to determine performance and promotion within the military.
Georgia Howe
And I think that's undermining the recruiting population without a doubt.
Robert Greenway
And just a little addendum to my earlier question, is there a reason why the Marines are still successful?
Georgia Howe
Do you think they're positioning themselves differently in some way?
Robert Greenway
So they are. First, they're the smallest among the forces with the exception of the Space Force.
Georgia Howe
And so their problem is a little bit more manageable.
Robert Greenway
Second is the Marine Corps, to their credit, has always focused on the warfighting principle as an ethic within the force itself and also the way they approach the military.
Georgia Howe
They're not trying to claim to be a jobs program.
Robert Greenway
They're not trying to say you can see the world and meet different cultures by joining the Marine Corps.
Georgia Howe
They pretty clear about the purpose of the Corps.
Robert Greenway
And as a result they're attracting a lot of the talent that is not going to the other services, again, because their focus is misplaced.
Georgia Howe
Now, what about the growing interest in isolationism that we're seeing, particularly on the right?
Robert Greenway
So Donald Trump was the first president in a long while that didn't engage in new wars. That was very popular.
Georgia Howe
Do you think that's affecting recruitment?
Robert Greenway
Well, I think the way I would look at it is there is a general distrust of the government and its tendency to engage in foreign conflicts.
Georgia Howe
And at the end of the day, after over 20 years in Afghanistan, we left $83 billion of equipment and infrastructure in the hands of the people we took it from in 2001.
Robert Greenway
And so I think there's a reasonable reluctance to participate in this.
Georgia Howe
But at the same time, there's still a strong national commitment that exists in the segment of the population.
Robert Greenway
But too many schools, I think, are denigrating the country and service to it.
Georgia Howe
And that's having an impact on recruiting more, I think, than the proclivity to engage in foreign endless wars.
Robert Greenway
Now, if you were serving the president or the military, what changes would you make?
Georgia Howe
Well, first, I think, is I would get the military back to where a meritocracy is the only way that character and competence are the only characteristics that we're looking for for promotion and for retention and for recruiting.
Robert Greenway
Second is I would prioritize recruiting, restore trust in the chain of command and demonstrate that if you join our armed forces, the purpose of it is to fight and win our nation's wars, not to engage in reconstruction efforts and humanitarian causes.
Georgia Howe
There are other organizations that are expert at doing that.
Robert Greenway
And then lastly, I would focus ruthlessly on warfighting capabilities within the services.
Georgia Howe
Again, war is a brutal affair and we need to be prepared for it.
Robert Greenway
We need to man equip and train for it.
Georgia Howe
And so our focus has to be ruthlessly in that direction.
Robert Greenway
All right. Well, thanks so much for having me on today.
Georgia Howe
My pleasure. Thanks for having me.
Robert Greenway
That was Robert Greenway, director of the Allison Center for National Security at the Heritage Foundation.
Georgia Howe
And this has been an extra edition of Morning Wire.