Main Topic: The Biden administration's changes to Title IX, a federal law that prohibits sex discrimination in education programs, and its implications for women and men.
Key Participants:
Key Points:
Takeaways:
Theme music fades out
John Bickley
Welcome to Morning Wire, I'm John Bickley, Editor-in-Chief of The Daily Wire, and co-hosting today is Sage Steele, host of The Sage Steele Show.
Sage Steele
Thanks for joining us, John.
John Bickley
Today we're talking about the Biden administration's massive changes to Title IX. Joining us now is Sarah Parshall Perry, senior legal fellow at the Heritage Foundation. Sarah, thanks for joining us.
Sarah Parshall Perry
Thanks for having me.
John Bickley
So, we've had some major developments here with Title IX rule changes that are seismic, really, in their potential. There's a lot of misconceptions, too, around what's been changed and what hasn't been changed. Can you first walk us through what the Biden administration has changed with Title IX?
Sarah Parshall Perry
So, they've changed the entire function and applicability of a law that's been around for more than 50 years that simply prohibits sex discrimination in any federally funded education program. And that means a dollar of federal funding received, whether directly or indirectly.
John Bickley
So, what does that include?
Sarah Parshall Perry
So, I think a lot of people believe immediately that Title IX is simply what they call the athletics rule and that it only applies to public universities or public colleges at that. When in fact, this applies to everything from Head Start preschool programs through K-12, through private colleges, private charter schools, no matter whether your institution is private or public.
Sage Steele
That's a lot of institutions.
Sarah Parshall Perry
Absolutely. The application here is going to be just about every educational program in the country.
John Bickley
So, to be clear, if you do not abide by these rules, your federal funding is stripped.
Sarah Parshall Perry
Absolutely. The federal government has an opportunity to perform what's called a directed investigation. And that means that they go in and determine if actually the sex discrimination provisions that are claimed in a complaint have actually transpired.
Sage Steele
And what are the implications of this change?
Sarah Parshall Perry
Oh, it's hard to overstate them, but it really does, you realize, stem from a very simple one sentence prohibition from the education amendments of 1972, of which Title IX was a part. And all it says is that discrimination in any federally funded program on the basis of sex is prohibited.
John Bickley
And what does that mean for women and girls?
Sarah Parshall Perry
So, you can see how expanding that to gender identity could be catastrophic because, in fact, as a law designed to ensure women and girls' equality in all federally funded education, by expanding that to gender identity, it's going to be significant.
Sage Steele
And what about sports?
Sarah Parshall Perry
Absolutely. And in fact, the administration has disavowed that this rule touches, impacts, or includes sports. But again, having been on a stakeholder call with Catherine Lehman, the Assistant Secretary for Civil Rights, just a few days ago, she was asked a direct question. Is the Department of Education continuing with rulemaking on Title IX's athletics rule?
John Bickley
And what was her response?
Sarah Parshall Perry
She completely dodged the question, instead responding that she was quite pleased to be introducing today's rule. Well, because I know and have done a thorough reading of the 1,500-page rule, there are 31 references to athletics within the actual text of the new rule. And in addition, it prohibits gender identity discrimination in any extracurricular activity. Well, you can imagine sports are an extracurricular activity.
Sage Steele
So, to say that it doesn't include sports is really very duplicitous on the part of the administration.
Sarah Parshall Perry
So we can assure all of the individuals who are interested in this issue that sports are going to be included.
John Bickley
Now, sexual orientation is also included. You said status of pregnancy, abortion also comes into play. Can you unpack those ramifications for us?
Sarah Parshall Perry
The sexual orientation issue may have some salience here because in the end, we're looking distinctly at underlying sex as being the divider between providing equal opportunity for men and women. And quite frankly, for years, Title IX has already worked in such a way as to protect biological women, regardless of their sexual orientation, or biological men, regardless of their sexual orientation.
Sage Steele
And what about pregnancy and related conditions?
Sarah Parshall Perry
And ultimately, what it's going to do is provide the colleges in particular, because we're seeing these rates increase as these individuals get into college. We're seeing more reports of unplanned pregnancy. It's going to require universities, colleges, higher education institutions to actually make accommodations for students who want to have abortions.
John Bickley
And what about due process issues?
Sarah Parshall Perry
So under the Trump administration, we wanted to make very sure, first of all, that sexual harassment was included distinctly as a form of sex discrimination under Title IX. We wanted to make sure that those individuals were protected, those who were experiencing pervasive, and that's a responsible sort of inclusion here, one that is directed at a pattern or a practice of conduct of which the school decided they weren't going to get involved and solve.
Sage Steele
And what about the process for investigations on college campuses?
Sarah Parshall Perry
And we've gone back now under this administration's rule to what's called the single investigator model. We like to call these lovingly or not so lovingly kangaroo courts, which is to say that a single unelected college bureaucrat, many of whom are just out of college or just out of grad school themselves, gets to determine whether or not an individual who is charged with sexual assault or sexual harassment has actually committed that offense.
John Bickley
And what about the right to be represented by an attorney, cross-examine, introduce evidence?
Sarah Parshall Perry
Now we have gone from a clear and convincing standard to now a preponderance of the evidence standard, which is to say about 51 percent. So one person gets to determine the future of an individual's educational and career opportunities and could essentially make a determination that would leave a mark on this individual's future academic record for all time.
Sage Steele
And what about the involvement of local authorities for simultaneous criminal investigation?
Sarah Parshall Perry
If these individuals have something that they've experienced that they believe is tantamount to sexual assault, we want to make sure local authorities are also involved so that a non-judicial and a criminal investigation can be performed simultaneously.
John Bickley
And what about the opportunity for reversal of some of these changes?
Sarah Parshall Perry
What happens next is that this rule has just been probably hand-delivered to both the House and the Senate chambers, in addition to the Governmental Accountability Office. Now the clock starts running on 60 legislative days, and within those 60 days, both chambers have an opportunity to mount what's called a Congressional Review Act challenge.
Sage Steele
And what happens if Congress rejects this new rule change?
Sarah Parshall Perry
If Congress rejects it, it would be finalized for publication in the Federal Register, and the enforcement date, according to the rule itself, is going to be August 1st of this year, conveniently or not so conveniently, in terms of application and enforcement for the new school year in the 2024-2025 season.
John Bickley
And what about the opportunity for public interest litigators or attorneys general to bring suit based on specifically an individual who has standing, who is going to be or has experienced discrimination under this new rule?
Sarah Parshall Perry
And many of those, I will say, are individuals who I think are probably going to be impacted by, for example, forced speech codes for misgendering or female athletes who are losing roster spots to biological men.
Sage Steele
And what about the end game here?
Sarah Parshall Perry
I think the end game is going to be the Supreme Court's disposition. They have eschewed many of these gender identity issues for a long time. And I think they've had to sort of deal with the progeny of the 2020 Bostock versus Clayton County decision related to protections for sexual orientation or gender identity within employment. But this is distinctly different.
John Bickley
And what about the role of Congress in all of this?
Sarah Parshall Perry
I think there's an opportunity for both. What happens next is that this rule has just been probably hand-delivered to both the House and the Senate chambers, in addition to the Governmental Accountability Office. Now the clock starts running on 60 legislative days, and within those 60 days, both chambers have an opportunity to mount what's called a Congressional Review Act challenge.
Sage Steele
And what happens if Congress rejects this new rule change?
Sarah Parshall Perry
If Congress rejects it, it would be finalized for publication in the Federal Register, and the enforcement date, according to the rule itself, is going to be August 1st of this year, conveniently or not so conveniently, in terms of application and enforcement for the new school year in the 2024-2025 season.
John Bickley
Sarah, thanks so much for coming on and providing your analysis for us.
Sarah Parshall Perry
Thanks for having me.