Main Topic: The podcast episode discusses several topics, including a young woman in the UK who is pleading with the National Health Service (NHS) to be given life-prolonging care, but a judge is denying her right to make her own medical decisions. Additionally, the episode covers the controversy surrounding the American Library Association (ALA) and its president's comments on being a Marxist, as well as the hypocrisy of the Chicago Teachers Union president who opposes school choice but sends her own son to a private school.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Theme music fades out
John Bickley
Welcome to Morning Wire, I'm John Bickley.
Georgia Howe
And I'm Georgia Howe.
John Bickley
It's September 16th, and we've got a lot to cover today. A young woman in the UK is pleading with the country's National Health Service to be given life-prolonging care. But a judge is denying her right to make her own medical decisions.
Georgia Howe
That's right, John. And we've got Daily Wire reporter Amanda Presta-Giacomo here to discuss this case.
Amanda Presta-Giacomo
Thanks for having me on.
John Bickley
So, Amanda, what exactly is going on with this case? What's this teen sick with and how did we get to this point exactly?
Amanda Presta-Giacomo
So, this young woman, who we can only identify as ST, has an extremely rare mitochondrial disease. It causes chronic muscle weakness, the loss of hearing, and damage to the kidneys. Currently, ST is dependent on regular dialysis, a feeding tube, and other intensive care.
Georgia Howe
Okay, so ST has already defied her doctor's odds and has survived well past their death predictions, and she wants to continue to fight for her life and potentially seek out experimental treatment in either Canada or the U.S. Both countries have offered her this option.
Amanda Presta-Giacomo
That's right. Her doctors, though, tell her no. They say she has no chance at survival. She's in the process of dying. And it's best course to take her off life-saving care and let her die. They argue anything else would cause more harm than good.
John Bickley
So, she wants to continue to fight for her life, but her doctors are telling her no. How did we go from this to the courts getting involved?
Amanda Presta-Giacomo
Well, this is the NHS we're talking about. It's a single-payer healthcare system wherein care is rationed. And that is part of the story here. Basically, an NHS trust was frustrated with ST not taking NHS medical advice. So, they took this case to court and successfully argued before a judge that the teen was delusional for not agreeing with her doctors.
Georgia Howe
Okay, so not trusting the experts, not trusting the doctors, is their rationale for defining her as not capable of making her own medical decisions?
Amanda Presta-Giacomo
Exactly. So, what is the status right now with this girl, ST?
So, the judgment handed over decisions about her medical care to the court of protection. It's pretty much out of ST's hands right now. Additionally, per this court of protection, ST is not allowed to reveal her name. As we've noted, she's not allowed to reveal the names of her doctors or where she's being hospitalized.
Georgia Howe
That's really troubling. And her family notably had to sell their business and they're pretty financially strapped right now.
Amanda Presta-Giacomo
I'll also note that ST's diagnosis is the same diagnosis as that of London infant Charlie Gard, our audience might be familiar with that name in Gard's tragic case, courts ordered that the baby's parents had to bypass possibly life-saving experimental treatment for Charlie and they were forced to watch their child die in a London hospital, that was back in 2017.
Georgia Howe
Right, so a whole other element here at play.
Amanda Presta-Giacomo
Have we heard at all from the NHS about this case? What have they said here?
So, the NHS trust that took this case to court, they put out a pretty generic statement saying that their focus is on providing the very best care and support for the patient, her family, and their clinical teams.
John Bickley
A really troubling case here, Amanda. Thanks for reporting.
Amanda Presta-Giacomo
You're welcome, John.
Georgia Howe
The president of the American Library Association, the oldest and largest public library nonprofit in the world, is under fire for describing herself as Marxist and for saying in recently leaked audio that libraries need to be a location for socialist organizing.
John Bickley
This is leading several states and counties to break ties with the organization.
Megan Basham
Thanks for having me on.
Georgia Howe
So, Megan, the ALA has become surprisingly controversial over the past couple of years. The organization has been an ardent defender of sexually explicit content in schools, as well as some of the drag queen events for kids.
Megan Basham
That's right. A number of red states have now cut ties with the organization altogether.
John Bickley
When did that trend start?
Megan Basham
So, it started when the ALA's new president, Emily Drabinsky, as I noted there, called herself a Marxist lesbian last year. But she denied that libraries have been trying to indoctrinate children with left-wing ideology.
Georgia Howe
And she actually called that accusation an extremist view.
Megan Basham
But after that, some social media users dug up interview clips of Drabinsky voicing pretty opposite intentions.
In my vision of a socialist future, libraries need to be seen as a terrain of struggle for those of us on the left. And for those of us whose queerness includes the subversion of those kinds of normal family types, this ideological story excludes us.
Georgia Howe
It makes it hard to make the decision to buy a book and make the decision to host a drag key story hour, make the decision to include a gay book in your collection.
Megan Basham
It makes it very, very scary because there have been bills passed to put a bounty on librarians' heads for circulating child pornography.
John Bickley
And then two weeks ago, Drabinsky was recorded at a socialism conference where attendees referred to one another as comrade.
Megan Basham
Because this was undercover audio, the sound quality is not the best. But this was her saying that libraries need to be used to further, quote unquote, socialist organizing.
Georgia Howe
We need some help to the libraries. We need to be on the agenda of the people who are organizing.
Megan Basham
So to reiterate, what she's saying there is that publicly funded libraries need to be employed as part of a political agenda specifically to further socialism?
John Bickley
Yes, correct. That is what she said.
Megan Basham
And though Drabinsky just began serving as ALA president in July, she's had important roles in the organization's administration since 2017.
Georgia Howe
For example, she's been the chair of the International Relations Committee, the Information Literacy Frameworks and Standards Committee, and several other committees like that.
Megan Basham
So she's had a hand in shaping the ALA's agenda for some time now.
John Bickley
And you also have to keep in mind that the ALA's agenda has widespread implications for libraries and schools across the country because it is seen as such a trusted authority.
Megan Basham
And these are the issues that led first Montana, then Texas and Missouri, and now a county in Wyoming, to announce that they're ending their contracts with the ALA.
Georgia Howe
Montana said that their state constitution forbids association with an organization led by a Marxist.
Megan Basham
And lawmakers in at least nine other states, including Arizona, Georgia, Pennsylvania, South Carolina, are vowing to follow them.
John Bickley
So we really are seeing this pick up steam now.
Megan Basham
A number of Republican senators, for example, are calling to defund the ALA at the federal level, and that includes Marco Rubio of Florida.
Georgia Howe
And then at the state level, the State Freedom Caucus Network, which is very active in at least 11 states, well, it's demanding that their states ensure that no taxpayer money is going to the organization.
Megan Basham
So they issued an open letter last month that called public libraries local treasures, but they vowed that they would, quote, not let them be overrun and held hostage by a radical organization acting well outside what its core mission should be.
John Bickley
Well, this fight has been long in the making.
Georgia Howe
Megan, thanks for reporting.
Megan Basham
Anytime.
Georgia Howe
One of the most vocal critics of School Choice, the boss of the Chicago's Teachers Union, is now facing backlash for sending her son to a private school.
John Bickley
Meanwhile, School Choice is exploding in popularity and has seen some huge wins in the past year.
Maraida Lordi
Thanks for having me on.
Georgia Howe
So Maraida, first off let's talk about the Chicago Teachers Union boss.
Maraida Lordi
Hi, Georgia. That's right. It was revealed last week that Chicago Teachers Union president Stacey Davis Gates, who has long been a vocal opponent of school choice, is sending her freshman son to a Catholic school on the south side of Chicago, where the average tuition is $14,750 a year.
Georgia Howe
When asked to defend that decision, Davis Gates blamed school choice for the lack of resources at Chicago's public schools.
Maraida Lordi
She told a local outlet that it was a very difficult decision for her family and claimed Chicago's public schools don't have a lot to offer Black youth in high school.
My son, he has the opportunity to play sports at his school. Sports, by the way, that are not offered at our neighborhood school or any school close to our address.
Georgia Howe
Well, she can obviously relate to parents who don't want to send their kids to public schools.
Maraida Lordi
What's her argument for why they shouldn't have that option?
Well, last year, she called school choice the choice of racists and claimed it was created to avoid integrating schools with black children.
Georgia Howe
Also last year, Davis Gates said, quote, I'm also a mother. My children go to Chicago public schools, arguing that this legitimizes her space within the anti-school choice coalition.
Maraida Lordi
Davis Gates also strongly opposed the Illinois Invest in Kids program, which offers tax credits to people who help fund scholarships for low-income students to attend private schools.
Georgia Howe
And we should note, this activism has been effective. In June, the Illinois legislature opted not to renew the school voucher program, so it'll expire at the end of this year.
Maraida Lordi
After Davis Gates' son's private school went viral online last week, she was slammed by critics who accused her of being hypocritical. School choice for her, but not for the rest of Chicago's kids.
Georgia Howe
So it sounds like Illinois took a step backwards when it comes to their school choice program, but that's not really been the trend we've seen nationwide.
Maraida Lordi
School choice has notched some very significant wins over the last year.
Georgia Howe
Tell us a little bit about those.
Maraida Lordi
Right. This has been an extremely significant year for school choice. Arizona had one of the most dramatic school choice victories.
Last summer, Arizona expanded its school voucher program to allow every Arizona K-12 student to get a taxpayer-funded scholarship account to pay for private school, about $6,500 per child.
Georgia Howe
As of May, about 61,000 Arizona students took advantage of that voucher.
Maraida Lordi
Katie Hobbs, Arizona's new Democratic governor, wanted to roll back the voucher program, despite attending private school herself, but was blocked by the GOP-controlled legislature.
Georgia Howe
At least seven other states have enacted broad education savings account programs too.
Maraida Lordi
Iowa, Utah, Arkansas, Florida, Oklahoma, Ohio, and Indiana.
Georgia Howe
The catalyst for this wave of school choice victories seems to be the pandemic.
Maraida Lordi
Many parents became frustrated with public schools over learning loss, political and sexual curriculum content, and school policies that intentionally kept parents in the dark about what was being taught and discussed in school.
Georgia Howe
Well, definitely a banner year for school choice, despite this recent news in Illinois.
Maraida Lordi
Maureen, thanks for reporting.
Georgia Howe
Thanks, Maraida.
John Bickley
That's all the time we've got this morning. Thanks for waking up with us. We'll be back this afternoon with an extra edition of Morning Wire.
Theme music starts playing
Georgia Howe
Thanks for listening to Morning Wire.