Main Topic: The Biden administration's push for electric vehicles (EVs) and the benefits and drawbacks of this technology.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Theme music fades out
Georgia Howe
Welcome to Morning Wire. I'm Georgia Howe, and I'm here with Daily Wire editor-in-chief John Bickley.
John Bickley
Thanks for having me, Georgia.
Georgia Howe
Today, we're talking about electric vehicles. The White House has set a goal of making them 50% of new car sales by 2030. We're joined by Daily Wire senior editor Cabot Phillips. Cabot, thanks for being here.
Cabot Phillips
Thanks for having me.
Georgia Howe
So, let's start with the basics. President Biden has made electric vehicles a core part of his climate agenda. What are his goals for EVs?
Cabot Phillips
Yeah, so earlier this year, President Biden proposed a plan to ensure that by 2032, two-thirds of all new cars sold in the U.S. will be electric. For context, while EVs have become more popular in recent years, in 2022, they still only accounted for 6% of new car sales. So we're talking about a tenfold increase here.
Georgia Howe
That's a big jump. What's driving this push for EVs?
Cabot Phillips
The push comes in large part from Biden's Environmental Protection Agency, which announced new emission standards earlier this year that would limit the kinds of new car designs they would approve. While the EPA is technically barred from forcing automakers to sell electric vehicles, they are allowed to set limits on the amount of pollution generated by the total number of cars produced by a manufacturer.
Georgia Howe
So, this would require a massive increase in the number of EVs on the market. What's the rationale behind this?
Cabot Phillips
Yeah, that is a big part of it. The Biden administration has made EVs a key component in combating what they call the climate crisis. The administration has made it abundantly clear that they consider climate change an existential threat to the U.S., even more so than a potential nuclear war.
Georgia Howe
That's a pretty stark assessment. How is this expected to impact the auto industry or everyday drivers?
Cabot Phillips
Well, first, it's going to radically alter production lines and supply chains that have for decades been producing traditional combustion vehicles. That shift is almost certain to eliminate thousands of jobs as EVs require fewer workers to build.
Georgia Howe
That's a concern for the Auto Workers Union, which has refused to endorse President Biden despite him appearing on the picket line this week.
Cabot Phillips
Yeah, they essentially view the EV push as an existential threat to their job security.
Georgia Howe
So, let's talk about the financial element. How is this shift to EVs going to impact the bottom line for automakers?
Cabot Phillips
It's worth noting, this is hardly a voluntary embrace of EVs from the automakers. Much of the shift comes down to pressure from large investment firms like Vanguard, BlackRock, and State Street, which are the largest shareholders in Ford Motor Company and General Motors.
Georgia Howe
That gives them enormous leverage over how automakers operate. And they're evidently all on board with the push for EVs.
Cabot Phillips
Yeah, that's in large part due to their commitment to ESG, which prioritizes investments in products and companies deemed pro-environment.
Georgia Howe
So, automakers know that to keep large investors happy, they've basically got to go along with the electric revolution.
Cabot Phillips
But beyond that, there's also significant pressure coming from state governments as well as federal.
Georgia Howe
For example, California has announced a proposal to phase out all new sales of gas-powered vehicles, with the total ban coming into effect by 2035.
Cabot Phillips
Not only does California account for 12% of the American population, but it has a lot of sway over other states' environmental policies.
Georgia Howe
Since that announcement last year from California, several states have announced plans to follow their lead.
Cabot Phillips
Now, the workers have a reason to be somewhat concerned, but how is this expected to impact the bottom line for the automakers?
Georgia Howe
Yeah, at the moment, that is the big issue. We're already seeing the financial ramifications of EVs, and they're not good for auto companies right now, at least.
Cabot Phillips
According to their own projections earlier this year, Ford is expected to turn a profit this year overall, thanks to their gas-powered cars, but their line of EVs is expected to lose the company $4.5 billion this year.
Georgia Howe
Those losses have led Ford to scale back some of their earlier EV plans and have led investors to question the company's EV prospects overall.
Cabot Phillips
Here's Ford CEO Chris Farley on Fox Business speaking frankly about the potential ceiling for EVs.
Georgia Howe
Is Ford building electric vehicles because it wants to or it's being forced to? Do you think EVs are better than their internal combustion predecessors?
Cabot Phillips
For some customers they are, but not for everyone. If you're pulling a fifth wheel in Wyoming, you probably don't want to own an electric vehicle.
Georgia Howe
But if you have three cars in your household and one's for short distances running around town or 100, 200-mile range, it's a better car.
Cabot Phillips
General Motors is in a similar spot. Their CEO said earlier this year that even with $2 billion in cost-cutting measures, they still are not going to turn a profit on EVs until at least 2025.
Georgia Howe
And even then, the outlook is still uncertain.
Cabot Phillips
According to one analyst, quote, no U.S. automaker is making EVs profitably aside from Tesla.
Georgia Howe
So, why is Tesla succeeding when all these other companies are failing?
Cabot Phillips
Right. And they're not just succeeding. Their Model Y is currently one of the world's best-selling cars.
Georgia Howe
Tesla sold more than 330,000 EVs in the first half of 2023. That's more than twice as many as their next four competitors combined.
Cabot Phillips
Now, to be fair, General Motors did quadruple their EV sales compared to the same period last year, while Tesla sales increased by just 30%.
Georgia Howe
But Tesla is undoubtedly still head and shoulders above everyone else.
Cabot Phillips
As to why they're so popular, some of it may be brand recognition. They really were the first meaningful EV company in the game, but a lot of their success is driven simply by quality.
Georgia Howe
Teslas generally perform better than other EVs, and they're also often more affordable.
Cabot Phillips
The price of electric vehicles has long been a major barrier to entry for potential customers.
Georgia Howe
At the moment, the average new EV costs almost $64,000, while the average new gas-powered car would set you back about $49,000.
Cabot Phillips
So price is obviously a barrier of entry for EV.
Georgia Howe
What about functionality? So on that front, range is another big issue.
Cabot Phillips
In 2021, the median gas car could go 403 miles on a full tank while the median EV could go just 234 miles on a full charge.
Georgia Howe
That may be fine for most day travel but for longer trips it is a hassle.
Cabot Phillips
Filling up on gas might take a couple of minutes but even a lot of faster chargers for an EV usually take about 30 minutes.
Georgia Howe
And those rapid charging stations are not evenly distributed throughout the country.
Cabot Phillips
It's worth noting they're much more concentrated in affluent urban areas and a handful of more populous states like California, New York, Florida, and Texas.
Georgia Howe
At the moment, there are about 50,000 public charging stations nationwide, which means a lot of areas are miles from the nearest hookup.
Cabot Phillips
I actually experienced this conundrum firsthand while renting a car a few months ago.
Georgia Howe
I was pretty excited. I got upgraded to a Tesla for a drive from Texas to Oklahoma while renting.
Cabot Phillips
And the car was a ton of fun to drive at every bell and whistle you could need.
Georgia Howe
But halfway through the trip, I got a blinking thing saying I had to go 20 miles out of the way to one of the only charging stations in the area.
Cabot Phillips
And that trade-off has kept many Americans from purchasing EVs, especially people living in more sparsely populated areas like the one I was driving through.
Georgia Howe
Well, and in rural areas, people have to drive longer distances just to begin with.
Cabot Phillips
Right. And that means that rural areas and large swaths of many states are currently, quote, charging deserts, where EV drivers could be stranded with no quick way of getting back on the road.
Georgia Howe
Now, again, it's worth noting, Teslas generally go further on a single charge than other EVs in their price range.
Cabot Phillips
And the company has also built a network of nearly 2,000 supercharging stations across the country.
Georgia Howe
For now, that's a Tesla-exclusive perk, though.
Cabot Phillips
Most EVs use different charging ports, so they can't use Tesla's charging stations.
Georgia Howe
So EVs still face some serious roadblocks.
Cabot Phillips
I see what you did there, Georgia. I like that, roadblocks.
Georgia Howe
But Tesla seems to be working through them better than any of its competitors.
Cabot Phillips
Yeah, Tesla really has been the industry leader for years and seems to be the company best positioned to make widespread EV adoption possible.
Georgia Howe
Which is a little awkward because Tesla's founder and CEO, Elon Musk, has been an outspoken critic of the Biden administration on everything from social policy to the war in Ukraine.
Cabot Phillips
And that friction could be playing a role in how the Biden administration treats Tesla compared to other EV companies.
Georgia Howe
On several occasions, the White House has gone out of its way to snub Tesla while promoting other EVs.
Cabot Phillips
For example, last month, Energy Secretary Jennifer Granholm took a caravan of electric cars on a four-day trip across the southern United States between Charlotte and Memphis with the hope of ginning up support for EVs.
Georgia Howe
Her convoy included a Chevy Bolt, a Ford F-150 Lightning, and a Cadillac Lyric, but notably, no Tesla, despite being the best-selling EV producer by a long shot.
Cabot Phillips
So a publicity stunt to sell the public on EVs that didn't include the model that most people actually want.
Georgia Howe
And the trip did end up being a bit of a publicity nightmare.
Cabot Phillips
While it was meant to highlight the progress made on EVs, it actually ended up advertising many of their problems.
Georgia Howe
There were broken chargers, slow charge times, and long lines.
Cabot Phillips
At points, the trip devolved into a comedy of errors.
Georgia Howe
In one moment that went viral online, the secretary's convoy had the cops called on them after her staff blocked a charging station so that she would not have to wait in line upon arriving.
Cabot Phillips
Have a listen to that call.
Audio clip plays
Georgia Howe
So, quick backstory there. While on their way to a fast charging station in a suburb outside of Augusta, Georgia, Secretary Granholm's team realized that there weren't enough chargers to go around.
Cabot Phillips
Of the fourth station, one was broken and two were occupied.
Georgia Howe
So they sent a gas vehicle ahead to hold the remaining spots until she arrived, which left other would-be customers to wait on empty.
Cabot Phillips
That prompted anger from a number of drivers, including one woman with a small child in her car who called the police.
Georgia Howe
The secretary ultimately broke her convoy up and sent some vehicles to slower chargers, which diffused the situation.
Cabot Phillips
But even sympathetic journalists embedded in the convoy stressed that it was a bad look.
Georgia Howe
So, back to the original goal of increasing EV usage. What steps is the Biden administration taking to address all those barriers?
Cabot Phillips
At the moment, the Biden administration has committed billions of dollars to subsidize 500 new fast charging stations across the country.
Georgia Howe
Industry experts say, though, that in order to support their target for EV sales, that network would actually need more than a million such stations.
Cabot Phillips
So they're making progress, but they're still nowhere near where they need to be for widespread adoption.
Georgia Howe
The White House is also offering major tax breaks for folks who purchase EVs, in some cases offering up to $7,500 to offset the cost of a new car.
Cabot Phillips
But the problem there is that a lot of Americans simply don't seem interested in trading in their gas-powered vehicles.
Georgia Howe
According to a recent Gallup poll, for example, 41% of American drivers say they would not buy an EV.
Cabot Phillips
So Biden is clearly hoping to incentivize a shift in sentiment on that front.
Georgia Howe
The administration has also encouraged automakers to standardize charging ports.
Cabot Phillips
Ideally, every model would be able to use every station.
Georgia Howe
This year, Tesla announced plans to open up thousands of their supercharging stations to competitors by the end of next year.
Cabot Phillips
Now, all of this is being done in the name of cleaning up the environment.
Georgia Howe
How effective are EVs at that?
Cabot Phillips
They don't emit carbon, but they do use electricity.
Georgia Howe
Yeah, so on the environmental front, it depends on what metrics you use.
Cabot Phillips
While EVs do not emit carbon directly, manufacturing them still does.
Georgia Howe
Their lithium batteries in particular are carbon intensive.
Cabot Phillips
How long it takes for an EV to pay off its so-called carbon debt depends on where it's sourcing its power from and, again, how it was made.
Georgia Howe
Currently, most of our electric power comes from burning fossil fuels.
Cabot Phillips
And EVs are more mechanically efficient than traditional vehicles because they have fewer moving parts.
Georgia Howe
But even so, it does take years for emissions to even out.
Cabot Phillips
And remember, EVs are heavily reliant on special batteries, which need lithium.
Georgia Howe
And mining lithium is not exactly green.
Cabot Phillips
It typically requires 500,000 gallons of water to produce one metric ton of lithium.
Georgia Howe
And the mines are often in dry and poor areas around the world with a limited water supply.
Cabot Phillips
Climate activists have warned that lithium mines often pollute groundwater in the area and lead to a slew of other environmental problems.
Georgia Howe
And then there's the fact that lithium is also a very reactive element.
Cabot Phillips
So when the batteries are damaged, they can be prone to catching fire or even exploding.
Georgia Howe
Now, we use lithium batteries in almost everything, including our phones.
Cabot Phillips
But those larger batteries needed for the cars are more vulnerable to a runaway reaction and more dangerous.
Georgia Howe
To that point, battery fires caused by electric bikes in particular have become a serious problem in cities around the country, including New York and San Francisco.
Cabot Phillips
There were more than 100 such fires in the Big Apple last year, which killed 13 people and injured dozens more.
Georgia Howe
According to New York Fire Commissioner Laura Kavanaugh, damaged batteries are becoming a major risk in the city.
Cabot Phillips
It is quickly becoming one of the leading causes of fire deaths this year.
Georgia Howe
And we want to emphasize again, these fires are extremely dangerous.
Cabot Phillips
They create a large volume of fire very quickly and present significant threats to New Yorkers who are trying to get out of their homes and to our members as they respond to these calls.
Georgia Howe
So the takeaway here is there's just no free lunch when it comes to being green.
Cabot Phillips
But what about energy independence, though? That's long been a goal even just for national security reasons.
Georgia Howe
Yeah, so EVs might decrease our dependence on foreign fossil fuels, assuming we shift more of our grid to nuclear power or other green sources, or start producing more oil and gas ourselves.
Cabot Phillips
Remember, we still need to get electricity from somewhere.
Georgia Howe
But even then, most of the world's lithium is outside the U.S.
Cabot Phillips
The largest known reserves at the moment are in South America.
Georgia Howe
And manufacturing-wise, roughly 80% of the world's lithium batteries are produced by China.
Cabot Phillips
So until we can control the whole supply chain, we will not be independent on that front.
Georgia Howe
Now, that could change.
Cabot Phillips
The U.S. does have its own reserves, and engineers are experimenting with alternative battery designs that use sodium.
Georgia Howe
But we are years away from producing those alternatives at scale.
Cabot Phillips
So it sounds like we're in the midst of a serious EV push, but remains to be seen if Americans are going to step in line.
Georgia Howe
Exactly. All right, well, Cabot, thanks so much for reporting.
Cabot Phillips
Anytime.
Georgia Howe
That was Daily Wire senior editor Cabot Phillips, and this has been a Sunday edition of Morning Wire.