Main Topic: The potential collapse of the Chinese economy and its implications for the global economy.
Key Points:
Participants:
Upbeat music fades out, and the host, Georgia Howe, begins speaking
Georgia Howe
China has experienced a meteoric rise over the past half century, with many projecting it will overtake the United States as the most influential global power in the coming decades. But some experts say its foundations are crumbling, and a China collapse is more likely.
Music transitions to a gentle background
Thanks for waking up with us. It's Sunday, August 21st, and this is your Sunday edition of Morning Wire.
Producer Colton speaks in the background
Colton
Hey everyone, producer Colton here. Back to school season is upon us. And while many kids are excited to get back into the classroom, many may not be able to access and afford nutritious meals to fuel their growing minds.
Georgia Howe
Good Ranchers will donate a nutritious meal to a child in need for every box ordered through August 31st. Help them donate 100,000 meals and get $30 off plus free shipping at goodranchers.com slash wire.
Music transitions to a gentle background
For this episode of Morning Wire, we speak to columnist and author of The Coming Collapse of China, Gordon Chang, about China's growing challenges and how a Chinese collapse could affect global markets.
Gordon Chang
Thanks so much for coming on.
Georgia Howe
Now, there's a lot of evidence showing that the Chinese economy may be contracting, but you've actually said that it's in freefall. What makes you say that?
Gordon Chang
The property sector is the heart of the Chinese economy. It accounts for somewhere between 25 to 30 percent of gross domestic product. We know that the large property developers, including Evergrande Group, but many others, are defaulting on their bond and other obligations.
Georgia Howe
And this has caused a number of anomalies. So, for instance, we see the mortgage boycott. In other words, homeowners in about 90 cities, maybe more at this moment, are not paying their mortgages.
Gordon Chang
They have contracted to buy apartments. They got mortgages. They realize that those apartments will never be finished or might not be finished. So they are not paying their mortgages. Suppliers to the property developers, they're not paying mortgages.
Georgia Howe
We see the bank runs. And the reason here is that we have sales of prices of new homes plunging about 40% in the first half of this year compared to the same period last year. That's an enormous fall.
Gordon Chang
And no economy can sustain that, especially when property forms the core of it. So I think Chinese leaders right now are in a panic. They have tried some desperate measures. So far, those measures have not arrested the fall in sales or property prices because now this has become a crisis of confidence.
Georgia Howe
And how does all of this affect the world economy?
Gordon Chang
This so far has not really affected the world economy too much, but we can see that it will. Part of it is because I think that countries around the world have been underestimating the problems in the Chinese economy, and they've been overestimating the ability of Beijing to deal with them.
Georgia Howe
At some point, this becomes a crisis. It takes the financial community and everybody else by surprise. And that, of course, is going to send shockwaves through equity markets.
Gordon Chang
But, Georgia, I think we have to understand that China is far less important to the global economy than most people think.
Georgia Howe
You know, people will tell you, oh, you know, there's a lot of growth in China. China is an engine of global growth. Well, that's not really true, because to be an engine of global growth, a country has to buy the goods and services of other countries to create growth elsewhere, to be that engine.
Gordon Chang
And China, through criminal and predatory policies, has been taking growth from other countries. So if we wake up one morning and magically the Chinese economy just disappears, actually, I think it's going to be good for the United States and good for other countries.
Georgia Howe
Now, do you predict that in the near or moderate near-term future, there's going to be an actual collapse of the Chinese economy?
Gordon Chang
I think that there will be. You know, Beijing has been able to postpone this problem for quite some time. To put this in context, China decided not to have a 2008 downturn and they overstimulated their economy and they created debt as no country had in history.
Georgia Howe
So right now, China is starting to have its 2008 crisis. The difference between the rest of the world in 2008 and China in 2022 is that because China has deferred the crisis by creating this debt, it's made the situation bigger and I think so big that there is no solution to it.
Gordon Chang
So Beijing has been trying to solve the problem by again, flooding the country with money. But the problem is that Chinese companies don't really want to borrow because they don't see a return. And that means that China got to essentially go to the state companies and force them to build because they can direct them to do things which are not economic.
Georgia Howe
But that ultimately will just postpone the problem and make it bigger by accumulating debt. So right now, I think China's regime pretty much has hit a dead end.
Gordon Chang
Now, how is culture impacting the economy of China? For example, one phenomenon we've read about is the lying flat movement.
Georgia Howe
How are they doing in terms of maximizing human capital?
Gordon Chang
The lying flat movement is something that really worries the regime because it really means that younger workers who are supposed to be extremely productive are just opting out or doing the bare minimum.
Georgia Howe
This so far, I don't think has been a substantial effect on the economy, or at least it's hard to quantify it, but clearly long term, this is a problem for China.
Gordon Chang
There are a number of long-term issues that are working against the Chinese economy. And demography is one of them. Change in attitudes is another. And these are just accumulating the issues that Beijing faces and isn't making it any easier.
Georgia Howe
There's a whole sense of pessimism right now in China. Part of it is triggered by the COVID lockdowns, but also you get a sense that people feel that they've been overworked. They feel that there is no future in China.
Gordon Chang
They are unhappy about some of the things the regime has been forcing them to do. So this is not a country that's headed in the right direction.
Georgia Howe
The biggest long-term problem that China faces is demography. Beijing claims that 1.41 billion people. But by the turn of this century, as we go into 2100, China will have somewhere in the neighborhood of 550 million people, maybe 600 million people.
Gordon Chang
In short, this is the steepest projected decline in population for any country in the absence of war or disease. And part of this is the one child policy that was ingrained and indoctrinated into the Chinese people. Now they have a three-child policy, but it's not really encouraging increased births.
Georgia Howe
Matter of fact, China's continuing to go the other way. But it's not only that. It's the concern over the Chinese economy. In every society, demography, population births normally decline because people don't feel optimistic about the future.
Gordon Chang
And that part of China, but also there the problems of modernity. As China becomes more developed, we see this across the world, couples have fewer children.
Georgia Howe
The Communist Youth League about a half year ago published the results of a survey which showed that 44% of urban Chinese women have said they will never get married.
Gordon Chang
And this means China's society is going to go through incredible changes that we just don't know what they will be like because no society has ever gone through this.
Georgia Howe
Now, we do a lot of our manufacturing in China. We get a huge portion of our goods from there. If China experiences a collapse, how would that affect us here?
Gordon Chang
I think the business and financial communities in the United States and around the world, I think, underestimate the problems in the Chinese economy. And at the same time, they overestimate the ability of Beijing to deal with those problems.
Georgia Howe
More important, though, is China's belligerent external policies. They're causing tensions around the world, especially with the United States.
Gordon Chang
And that means that long term, I think the oceans and the skies will not be reliably safe. And we will find that trade is disrupted.
Georgia Howe
We Americans tend to focus on what we do as affecting relations with others. But with China, it's more who we are. Because we are a democracy, because we have values, that form of government and those values have an inspirational impact on the Chinese people.
Gordon Chang
And the regime is deathly afraid of it. So Beijing views the United States as an existential threat, not because what we do, but because of who we are.
Georgia Howe
And that means long term, trade between China and the rest of the world, I think, can't continue as it is.
Gordon Chang
All right. Well, Gordon, thanks so much for coming on.
Georgia Howe
Thank you so much, Gordon. That was Gordon Chang, columnist and author of The Coming Collapse of China. And this has been a Sunday edition of Morning Wire.
Music transitions to a gentle background, and the host, Georgia Howe, speaks
Thanks for listening to this episode of Morning Wire. Don't forget to subscribe to our podcast and follow us on social media for more news and analysis.