Main Topic: The recent farmer protests in France and the underlying issues that led to the demonstrations.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Upbeat music fades out, and the sound of a newsroom or studio environment can be heard in the background
Georgia Howe
Welcome to this extra edition of Morning Wire. I'm Georgia Howe, and I'm here with Daily Wire editor-in-chief John Bickley.
John Bickley
Thanks for joining us, Georgia.
Georgia Howe
Today, we're talking about the farmer protests in France. They've been making headlines for their intensity and disruption. Let's go straight to our guest, Bill Wirtz, agricultural analyst for the Consumer Choice Center. Bill, thanks for coming on.
Bill Wirtz
Thanks for having me.
Georgia Howe
So, over the past week, France has seen some very intense farmer protests. Tell us what those look like.
Bill Wirtz
They're very disruptive. What we're seeing right now is that the farmers are blocking the roads in and outside of Paris, sort of now called the siege of Paris. And what the farmers are showing is essentially that without the food system, it's not possible for people to operate. So why should traffic operate as well?
Georgia Howe
That's a pretty strong message. What's the contrast between the French protests and what we've seen in other countries, like Germany?
Bill Wirtz
So, there's a big contrast between the German and the French protests in that sense. The German protests were more peaceful, whereas the French protests have been more violent. We've seen that fast food chains were broken into, big retailers were broken into and vandalized.
Georgia Howe
That's a significant difference. What are the French farmers protesting against?
Bill Wirtz
So, the French farmers are protesting because they are really struggling to make ends meet. If you're running a farm business these days in Europe, it's become increasingly difficult to comply with all the regulatory burdens that are put on you. Whether it's how much farmland you can use anymore or the environmental regulations, or all the regulations relating to pesticides, it's become increasingly stringent for many farmers in Europe.
Georgia Howe
That must be incredibly challenging. I understand there's also been pressure from the government to bring down the price of food because of inflation. What is the government trying to do to control or manipulate food prices?
Bill Wirtz
So, the French government has conversations with big retailer chains and essentially tries to negotiate to bring prices of certain products down. But what they don't say is that the retailers just go back to the farmers and say, "Sorry, we can only pay you this much this month." So the farmers are essentially squeezed by the retailers, but at the behest of the government in order to bring down overall price inflation.
Georgia Howe
That's a clever way of putting it. Now, what about the pivot toward importing food? How is that affecting prices?
Bill Wirtz
Yeah, so France has prided itself for quite a long time on being self-sufficient in terms of food production. But in recent years, and essentially for the first time, France has now had to import food. And the reason for that is because of the European Union agreement, France cannot erect protectionist barriers, cannot reject foreign products from European countries coming in.
Georgia Howe
That must be a big change for the country. How do the protests in France compare to farmer protests in, say, the Netherlands or Germany?
Bill Wirtz
Well, so France has many different characteristics about its protest because the French farmers have waited a lot longer before they started protesting. You have to look at the fact that the Dutch farmers were already protesting in 2021 and later 22 against specific regulation. This is where the Dutch government wanted to bring the overall environmental emissions of fertilizers down.
Georgia Howe
That's a great point. What about the average French citizen? Do they feel more connected to the farmers and their struggles?
Bill Wirtz
We have to wait for reliable polling on this because it's rather early at this point. But what we've seen in Germany is that, you know, Germany, even though they were blocking the streets, about 80 percent of the population, even those not associated with the agricultural profession, said that they support the farmers in their protest.
Georgia Howe
That's a remarkable statistic. And finally, is it your sense that citizens across a variety of countries are souring on some of these policies that are leading to these farmer protests?
Bill Wirtz
Yes. What we see is that overwhelmingly environmentalist political parties are losing in those elections. I mean, this is from tiny Luxembourg to countries in Eastern Europe where many environmentalist movements weren't particularly popular in the first place.
Georgia Howe
Well, Bill, it's been very informative. Thanks so much for coming on.
Bill Wirtz
Thank you for having me.
Georgia Howe
That was Bill Wirtz, agricultural analyst for the Consumer Choice Center, and this has been an extra edition of Morning Wire.
Music starts playing again, and the sound of a newsroom or studio environment fades out