Main Topic: The Trump administration's multi-front battles with the courts, specifically regarding executive orders and the scope of executive power.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Sound of a news theme music fades out
John Bickley
Welcome to Morning Wire. I'm John Bickley, editor-in-chief of the Daily Wire, and I'm joined by my co-host Georgia Howe.
Georgia Howe
Thanks for tuning in to this weekend edition of Morning Wire.
John Bickley
Today, we're discussing the Trump administration's multi-front battles with the courts. Joining us now is Ilya Shapiro, Director of Constitutional Studies at the Manhattan Institute and the author of the book Lawless, The Miseducation of America's Elites.
Ilya Shapiro
Thank you so much for having me on.
John Bickley
So, we've seen a flood of judges' orders blocking the Trump administration's various attempts to enact his agenda. First, do these judges have the authority to impede the executive branch?
Ilya Shapiro
It depends. I mean, I'm sorry to generalize more than that, but the facts of the case and the specific legal authorities are different as between cutting funding versus the president putting in new personnel policies for the military.
John Bickley
But in general, what we've seen is a lot of judicial resistance, if you will, to the administration's actions.
Ilya Shapiro
In fact, there have been more TROs, temporary restraining orders and preliminary injunctions in these first eight weeks or two months of the Trump administration than we saw in all four years of President Biden.
Georgia Howe
So, Ilya, if you were advising the president how would you counsel him on structuring future EOs to better protect them from legal challenges?
Ilya Shapiro
Well, the executive orders have been very well lawyered. I mean, I was very pleasantly surprised. I was expecting an onslaught, but it even exceeded my expectations.
John Bickley
Now, one more general question. Florida Governor Ron DeSantis has suggested that Congress strip these federal courts of their jurisdiction. Is that truly an option on the table?
Ilya Shapiro
Well, it's hard to see anything of substance or of controversy passing a filibuster in the Senate. So practically, it's dead in the water.
Georgia Howe
Let's go case by case now. Trump's actions against USAID. We've had legal pushback to that. Where does that case stand? Do you think that the Trump administration is ultimately going to win in terms of their cost-cutting measures there?
Ilya Shapiro
Well, the one case that already made it to the Supreme Court, not on full briefing, I mean, this is all emergency stuff happening overnight and things like that, was on the order, it was kind of a breathless order to require the government to pay millions and millions of dollars for USAID programs.
John Bickley
How about deporting the illegals the administration says are criminals and gang members? Where does that battle stand?
Ilya Shapiro
Well, the invocation of the Alien Enemies Act is a rarity in peacetime, not under wartime situations, but it doesn't mean that that's not the law on the books.
Georgia Howe
And what about the order to reinstate 25,000 fired federal workers? Do you think that's going to hold up?
Ilya Shapiro
There are civil service protections, and it's unclear. or I haven't drilled down in this particular case about whether those were followed.
John Bickley
Now the ban on transgender identifying service members in the military. Again, there's been legal pushback to that. Where do you think that's going to land in the end?
Ilya Shapiro
Generally courts give a lot of leeway to the executive branch on regulating the military. And the executive order said that people questioning their gender identity affects negatively the operations of the military, the ability to go to war.
Georgia Howe
Is it a plausible explanation or is it just irrational or bigoted action against people?
Ilya Shapiro
Yeah.
John Bickley
Final question, broadening out again. Do you believe most of these cases will end up escalating to the Supreme Court?
Ilya Shapiro
I think the court doesn't like having to intervene so often. And that's all of the justices all over the political spectrum or however cautious they might be, what have you.
Georgia Howe
And so far, they've been unsuccessful in preventing the lower courts from issuing orders that are going to instantly be appealed and get back on the Supreme Court's doorstep.
John Bickley
So Ilya, thank you so much for joining us.
Ilya Shapiro
My pleasure.