Main Topic: The decline of birth rates in America and the factors contributing to it, particularly the unsustainable model of high-pressure parenting.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Theme music fades out
Georgia Howe
Welcome to Morning Wire, I'm Georgia Howe.
John Bickley
And I'm John Bickley, Daily Wire Editor-in-Chief. Today's guest argues that the common explanations for millennials' hesitance to embrace parenthood aren't fully supported by the data. He says an unsustainable model of high-pressure parenting is to blame.
Georgia Howe
Joining me to discuss his new book and the real reason millennials are rejecting parenthood is father of six and senior fellow at the American Enterprise Institute, Tim Carney. Tim, thanks for coming on.
Tim Carney
Thank you.
Georgia Howe
So you've written a book about why millennials and Gen Zs are avoiding parenthood. A lot of people say it's because kids are so expensive, but you say it's not primarily economic.
Tim Carney
So, of course, affordability has something to do with family and those decisions. But the fact is that millennials are not poorer than Generation X was or than the baby boomers are. Economists go and they look at the wealth and you just for inflation and they find that millennials are just about as wealthy at a given age as Generation X was.
Georgia Howe
[pauses] That's interesting.
Tim Carney
Also, it's just not true that wealthier people in America are having more kids. If you go by income quintiles, you know, from the poorest to the richest, there's not much difference. In fact, the poorest quintile has a few more kids per woman.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
So it's hard to argue. And also look at 2019 when the economy was the best it's ever been. We were having far fewer babies then than we were during the Great Recession when the baby bust started.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point. So it's not about affordability or wealth or poverty.
Tim Carney
So that's why I point to the culture. And just one example out of many that we could talk about has to do with the effort that parents have to put in.
Georgia Howe
[pauses] Go on.
Tim Carney
So when I was a kid, we used to ride our bikes around the neighborhood and mom and dad would say, come home when the streetlights turn on. Nowadays, you might get child protective services called on you if you try to do that.
Georgia Howe
[laughs]
Tim Carney
Or parents just think, oh, well, they're wasting their time if they're riding their bikes around the neighborhood. They need to be doing enrichment. They need to have, you know, intensive violin lessons and all these things.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
They exhaust parents. My wife and I, we have six kids. People say, how the heck do you do it? And the truthful answer is often we don't do it. We let the kids be free.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
And guess what? That childhood anxiety, that's an epidemic now. In the Journal of Pediatrics, experts recently wrote an op-ed saying the root cause of that childhood anxiety is a lack of independent play. Kids are being watched and bossed around and supervised too much.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
We need to create a world where it's more normal to set them out and set them free.
Georgia Howe
Now, you talked about a few different styles of parenting in your book. You described helicopter parenting a bit. You also described something you called the travel team trap.
Tim Carney
So the travel team trap is where you fall into this idea of thinking you need to give your kids the best coaches, the most intense training, and you sign them up for a sports team.
Georgia Howe
[pauses] Go on.
Tim Carney
And next thing you know, you're spending every other weekend at some tournament in Delaware. It's a trap because a lot of parents feel they don't have any other choice.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
They think, oh, well, if I just let my kid play Little League, he's going to fall behind the others and he'll never make the JV squad.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
I actually have heard from JV coaches who say they tell their kids they have to play travel baseball. They have to play year round.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
And I use sports, but you could talk about Irish dance. You could talk about swimming. You could talk about all sorts of stuff.
Georgia Howe
[pauses] Go on.
Tim Carney
And one of the things this does is it makes the game less fun because it becomes all about intensive training. It makes kids specialize which is not good for their psyche or their bodies.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
It leads to more injuries. It leads to more depression. It breaks up family culture.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
I've had lots of dads say to me, I wish that my family's schedule was set by me and my wife rather than by the swim coach.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
And all of these things, we do much more than our parents did as far as putting kids in these intensive things.
Georgia Howe
Now, a phrase we hear often, and it's taken a little bit of a new meaning when invoked by politicians, famously Hillary Clinton, is it takes a village to raise a child.
Tim Carney
So I don't know what Hillary Clinton meant when she said it takes a village. Her village might have been the Department of Health and Human Services.
Georgia Howe
[laughs]
Tim Carney
But the village that humans actually have relied on forever starts with extended family.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
Starts with your mother-in-law coming and helping watch the kids. Starts with your kids having cousins to play with.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
It starts with you having older siblings who are sort of mentors and role models, younger siblings and younger cousins who are babysitters.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
And then they're the babysitting clientele for your kids years down the line.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
But then it expands out to the neighborhood, to kids running around and somebody else's mom sitting on the front porch and yelling at your kid when he does something dumb and then telling you.
Georgia Howe
[laughs]
Tim Carney
And then it goes beyond that, most importantly, to community institutions.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
This can be and has been strong public schools, though these days increasingly the public schools are at odds with the parents.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
But it's certainly church communities. It's certainly just a local neighborhood in general, but things that we belong to that help us raise our kids, that provide mentoring, that provide examples, that provide support.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
Again, when it's church, that provide sort of aspiration of this is what you should aspire to, is to have a loving family with kids. That's the village.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
So it's interesting that you say that.
Georgia Howe
[pauses] Go on.
Tim Carney
My cousin group chat just circulated a story from the Atlantic that I think just came out about the decline of cousins because people are having fewer kids.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
Obviously that equates to fewer cousins and you get like an exponential shrinkage of your extended family.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
Absolutely. But that leads, let me just add, that leads to falling birth rates cause birth rates to fall even more.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
So some of you have heard the word Malthusian, Malthusian. Thomas Malthus was an economist who argued that birth rates were like prices, that they would self-regulate.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
When people have too many kids, they become poor. So then they're poor. So they have fewer kids, they have fewer kids. So they get richer and yada, yada.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
But that's not what's happened in the modern world. Countries whose birth rate falls below 2.1, they keep falling.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
And there's all sorts of reasons. But one reason is just that when you have fewer kids, there's fewer siblings, there's fewer cousins, there's less of that village to help people take care of their children.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
And then I sometimes think about, I'm in Washington, D.C., Capitol Hill staffers.
Georgia Howe
[pauses] Go on.
Tim Carney
Not only do these, you know, 28-year-old chiefs of staff not have families, they can go all day without seeing a single child.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
And there they are making the policy for our country with children not on their mind.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
And so the less that the world is built around families, the harder it will be for families.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
Now, are other countries having these same problems? I know most of the Western world is having falling birth rates. Do they also have this helicopter parent culture or is it different reasons in different places?
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
So there's all sorts of different cultural issues. Why, say, Italy and Spain have a low birth rate versus Northern Europe versus South Korea and Japan and the U.S.?
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
The helicopter parenting is sort of the unique U.S. problem, I think.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
But the hyper ambitious parenting, that's certainly true over in Asia, where there's just massive pressure to be a material success.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
And that interferes with family formation.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
And there other cultural issues down in Southern Europe. There a lack of a work culture which is the opposite.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
We have too much workism.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
But in Europe, if people aren't willing to sort of build up their lives and launch a career and become grownups in, you know, in Spain and Italy, then they're never going to start a family and have kids.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
And in Northern Europe, it is the workism. When they try to subsidize family there, they subsidize daycare, which ends up subsidizing work rather than subsidizing family.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
Now, I'm not sure if you've followed this trend, but have you heard of the term dink, dual income, no kids?
Georgia Howe
Yes.
Tim Carney
So what are your thoughts on that?
Georgia Howe
So I saw some of these videos and it, you know, a little bit annoying, you know, making fun of people with kids, but ultimately sad.
Tim Carney
They're talking about how they get to go on vacation. I get to go on vacation. I even get to go on vacation with just my wife and leave my kids with my extended family.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
But I also get to go on vacation with my kids. And that is totally awesome.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
And that lattes are what they celebrate. They go for a walk to a coffee shop and have a latte. That's what they're celebrating now in their early 30s.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
And so that's why they're so happy that they don't have kids. And really it just strikes me as a sadness.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
So you had asked me about the different cultures, Europe, Asia, et cetera. All these different cultures have different maladies that are anti-family, but the one that I think connects them really is a sadness.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
It really is a belief that, well, we're not that good or life isn't actually that valuable.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
And when you've adopted that sadness, it's easy to just say, okay, well, then I'm just going to settle for basic pleasures, like going on vacation whenever I want.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
And they really get addicted to being untethered, unconnected.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
And that's ultimately a lonely, lonely existence.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
Well, I think there's also this feeling of those are the choices, you know, that it's being a helicopter parent where you completely lose yourself in parenting and it becomes this marathon of constant activities and hamster wheel or it's vacations and drinking on a weeknight with your spouse who still has time to go to the gym kind of thing.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
And when people are given that false choice, it may seem more attractive to have the sort of perpetual youth.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
I wish I'd put it that way originally. But I mean, this is why what I try to do on Twitter sometimes is post the real fun parts of parenting.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
I still play basketball against my sons and I can still beat the one who's slightly taller than I am.
Georgia Howe
[laughs]
Tim Carney
And I demolish the nine-year-old in one-on-one basketball. If I could actually dunk, I'd be dunking on him constantly.
Georgia Howe
[laughs]
Tim Carney
And it's tons of fun.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
And then we let them run the neighborhood while my wife and I do sit and have a cup of coffee or have a cocktail in the evening or go for long walks.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
And we replace, you know, we don't do happy hour that much.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
But guess what? We have big backyard barbecues where the parents all kind of sit near the grill while the kids run the neighborhood.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
And I find that a lot more fun at this point in my life.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
If I was still going to the same happy hours I was when I was 22, I'd be a little depressed.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
Now let's talk about religiosity. On this show, we've covered the decline of church attendance and the rise of religious non-affiliation. How big of a factor is that in the declining birth rate?
It's absolutely true that religiosity is correlated with and I think causally connected with birth rates and family size.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
Americans who go to church, synagogue, or mosque at least once a week are well above replacement level, 2.3, 2.4 babies or something like that.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
Americans who don't are well below.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
So that's one of the top predictors of it.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
So the secularization of America is a core cause of our falling birth rate in all sorts of ways.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
It's important enough I spend more than a chapter on it in the book.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
I visited neighborhoods that were more tightly knit communities that really supported families.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
And these were religious neighborhoods whether it Kemp Mill a sort of neighborhood anchored by two modern Orthodox synagogues in Maryland or going out to BYU Idaho a Mormon school or just other sort of Latter Saints places in Utah.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
In all of these places they talked about family, but not just we are told by the scripture and by our clergy to have children.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
In all of these places, they spoke about the sort of very concrete day-to-day ways that families were supported.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
In Israel, one guy said to me, the bus drivers have a real affection for little kids, all these little things.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
It's normal to bring your kids out to dinner. The ski slopes in Utah, basically you buy a family package for, and your kids ski for free all winter.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
And the support for homeschoolers that they do in Utah, all of these very practical, pragmatic supports for families, they trickle down from a culture that is really infused with religion.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
And that's the story in Israel. That's the story in Utah. That's the story in some of these neighborhoods.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
And so religion causes people to create these subcultures where they say, basically, send us your kids. We'll help you take care of them.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
Now, what about regional differences within the U.S.? Just anecdotally, I currently live in Tennessee.
Georgia Howe
[pauses] Go on.
Tim Carney
And just by virtue of the circle that I'm in, I do feel like I'm surrounded by young people who are more open to having bigger families.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
Rarely do I hear people talk about the financial cost of each additional child.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
But I'm from Massachusetts. And when I go home, I often hear people say, I'd love to have more kids. But realistically, they can only afford to have one or two.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
And they're sort of carefully budgeting those precious one or two kids.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
What does the data say about regional differences in birth rates and parenting culture?
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
So, yes, and some of it is economic, where land is more expensive, people are less likely to be able to build up families.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
Because I argue in the book that we need more housing and we need more density, but big apartment buildings are not good for community, and so they're not good for family.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
And one of the things is that people are more likely to do what's normal. And in some places, having three to six kids is normal.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
The way I put it in Family Unfriendly is I say pregnancy is contagious. It spreads almost like an airborne virus, that the more people around you that are doing it, the more likely you are to catch the bug and have a third or fourth kid.
Georgia Howe
[laughs]
Tim Carney
That's funny. We have a lot of people pregnant right now that work on our show. So they're obviously not wearing masks in the workplace, otherwise they'd be immune.
Georgia Howe
[laughs]
Tim Carney
Yeah. All right. So what concrete actions can parents and or community members take to create a more family-friendly culture?
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
So a lot of this is going to be individual decisions that then parents become leaders on.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
So I always say, don't give your kids smartphones, don't give them social media, and then also get together with the other parents and say, hey, can we conspire on this?
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
Also, do let your kids run the neighborhood and conspire with other parents on that too.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
If it's a summer day, finish your chores, boom, you're on your own, be back by dinner.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
And that works better when you have other adults who are on the same page.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
But that all points to the most important things to embed yourself in a good community, whether it's a church community, whether you have a good public school or just a local little league and join the board on it and volunteer like crazy.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
Plugging yourself into a community institution that is oriented towards family, that's going to give you the village that you need to raise your kids.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
And at the same time, you will be supporting everybody else who maybe is a little more hesitant about being free range or about having a second, third or fourth kid.
Georgia Howe
That's a good point.
Tim Carney
All right. Well, Tim, thanks so much for coming on.
Thank you.
Theme music fades in
Georgia Howe
That was Tim Carney, senior fellow at the American Enterprise Institute and a columnist at the Washington Examiner. His new book, Family Unfriendly, is out now. And this has been an extra edition of Morning Wire.