Main Topic: The Harvard University admissions case and the issue of racial preferences in college admissions, as well as the spread of Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) practices in medical schools.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Overall, this podcast episode highlights the complexities of the Harvard University admissions case and the spread of DEI practices in medical schools, and raises important questions about the role of merit and diversity in education and healthcare.
Sound of a podcast intro fading out
John Bickley
This episode is brought to you by LifeLock. When you visit the doctor, you probably hand over your insurance, your ID, and contact details. It's just one of the many places that has your personal info. And if any of them accidentally expose it, you could be at risk for identity theft. LifeLock monitors millions of data points a second. If you become a victim, they'll fix it, guaranteed, or your money back. Save up to 40% your first year at LifeLock.com slash podcast. Terms apply.
Sound of a new segment starting
For several years now, Harvard University has been embroiled in a legal battle over racial discrimination, facing accusations of bias against Asian students in an effort to achieve a more racially balanced student body. In this episode of Morning Wire, we talk to Kenny Hsu, president of Color Us United, board member of Students for Fair Admissions, and author of An Inconvenient Minority. Kenny has been covering the case, which recently was argued in front of the Supreme Court. It's March 11th, and this is a Saturday Extra edition of Morning Wire. Joining us to discuss the case is author and journalist Kenny Hsu.
Kenny Hsu
Thanks so much for coming on.
John Bickley
So you are a prolific writer, and you've been focusing your research on race-based preferences in public and private institutions. First off, can you tell me a little bit about how you started covering that?
Kenny Hsu
I got my start covering the Harvard admissions case against Asian Americans. So basically, for those listeners who aren't familiar, Harvard and the University of North Carolina Chapel Hill, by the way, has been accused by Asian Americans of having race preferences against them in the name of diversity. In fact, Asian Americans have to score 273 points higher on the SAT to have the same chance of admission as a black person to Harvard. These are huge, widely skewed racial preferences. That's discrimination.
John Bickley
So I reported on that and my reporting kind of made the mainstream. And I wrote a book called An Inconvenient Minority on the Harvard case an Asian inconvenient place in the racial narrative
Kenny Hsu
Now your book that the 2021 book An Inconvenient Minority you talked about how some aspects of the mainstream narrative around race have been damaging, specifically to Asians, but also to some other groups as well. Tell us a little bit about that. What about the conversation do you think is damaging?
Racial preferences is damaging to everybody, but to Asian Americans, it has a particularly bitter tone. So Asians are graded, actually every applicant is graded on three criteria, academics, extracurriculars, and personality. So Asian Americans score highest out of all of the races in Harvard applications on academics. They score highest out of all of the races on extracurriculars. But to make up for it, Harvard rates Asians lowest on this thing called a personality score.
John Bickley
What is a personality score?
Kenny Hsu
It measures things like likability, humor, leadership, a Harvard person. It's entirely subjective. And if you point to the objective data behind this, Asians actually score highest on alumni recommendations. They score highest in teacher recommendations. They score second highest on counselor recommendations. But there's no evidence to suggest that Asians have, in fact, a lower, quote unquote, personality than the other races, and yet Harvard ranks them lowest, and they do it playing into that stereotype that Asian Americans are test-taking robots with no personality.
John Bickley
And this is why this Harvard admissions case has become such a gut punch for Asian Americans, because it is unfair what they're doing to them, and not just what they're doing to them, but how they're doing it.
Kenny Hsu
Well, in the Harvard instance, the court documents actually showed systematic low ratings for Asian students' personalities, like you mentioned. But there are also some less obvious ways that schools have attempted to screen for race indirectly.
John Bickley
Tell us about that.
Kenny Hsu
Well, Harvard has, and many colleges across the United States, have been eliminating the SAT from admissions, claiming it doesn't serve a purpose, even though it does. Because the SAT is how a poor person from a bad school can stand up to a rich person from a good school and say I got a better score than you
John Bickley
That the only way you can compare toe applicants in our country. That's why we need the SAT.
Kenny Hsu
So Harvard might try to evade this ruling in some way. But what I'm hoping for, and I'm pushing for with my advocacy and my book, An Inconvenient Minority, is a stronger ruling. A stronger ruling that says colleges and universities who take public funding in our country have to adhere to merit-based principles in admissions. They have to define it transparently, and it has to be commonly agreed what these principles are.
John Bickley
Everybody knows that people should be admitted to college based on grades. Yep, absolutely. Test scores, 100%. A strong personal essay taken in an environment in which you can't cheat. Yes, I agree with that as well. But nobody in our country or very few people think that race is actually determinant of merit.
Kenny Hsu
So what I'm hoping is a ruling that says colleges and universities must adhere to commonly agreed merit-based principles for admissions and be transparent about the criteria.
John Bickley
Now, you've also recently been focusing on ending DEI practices at medical schools, specifically at UNC Medical School. Are you affiliated with UNC?
Kenny Hsu
I am the president of Colorist United. We advocate for race-blind America, and we do campaigns to tackle the rising spread of DEI and wokeness in our culture. Recently, it's come to our attention that really this spread is infecting the medical profession. This is dangerous. Woke medicine is dangerous.
John Bickley
Everybody wants the most qualified surgeon. But DEI and wokeness is lowering standards for diversity because we all love diversity. We all think that we are in a greatly diverse country. What I don't appreciate and what I don't want is lowering standards for diversity. That's what's happening at Harvard. That's what's happening in medical schools across the nation.
Kenny Hsu
In fact, they're starting to get rid of medical board exams And this is dangerous Not everybody should be a doctor Not everybody should go to med school We using UNC as an example for the rest of the nation and how far our health systems are going UNC Medical School and their health system is a $15 billion organization and one of the most prominent in North Carolina. So if we can get a win here, we can get a win anywhere.
John Bickley
In terms of the policies that UNC is doing specifically, we have a lot of evidence at UNC as well. They released a thing called a task force to integrate social justice in the curriculum. In this task force, which was released in October 2020, they pledged to teach their medical students about, quote unquote, unconscious bias and also, quote unquote, how America's medical system is systemically racist.
Kenny Hsu
This is not a way to inspire a doctor to succeed.
John Bickley
Now, we recently reported that the Texas A&M system is removing their mandatory DEI statements for admissions and hiring. Are you seeing other schools back off of DEI? Are schools experiencing significant pushback on this?
Kenny Hsu
We're starting to see the pushback. In fact, just two weeks ago, and I'm saying this in early March, but just two weeks ago, UNC voted to ban diversity, equity, and inclusion statements from being used in the promotion and hiring process. That's one thing that they had been doing, their medical school had been doing. If you wanted to be a doctor, you had to affirm certain DEI principles, which were basically nothing more than progressive leftist principles saying we affirm your conception of diversity and inclusion. or else you wouldn't get promoted.
John Bickley
I mean, it was a hostile climate to medical and intellectual innovation. And they finally stood against it. The board of governors did. And we influenced them as well on that decision. But that's just the start.
Kenny Hsu
All right. Well, Kenny, thanks so much for coming on today.
John Bickley
Yeah, thank you. Sign our petition, coloristunited.org. Buy my book, An Inconvenient Minority, The Attack on Asian American Excellence in the Fight for Meritocracy.