Main Topic: The impact of the Hollywood writers' strike on the entertainment industry and its effects on audiences.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Other topics discussed:
Theme music fades out
Georgia Howe
Good morning, I'm Georgia Howe with Daily Wire editor-in-chief John Bickley. It's December 9th, and this is a Saturday edition of Morning Wire.
John Bickley
Good morning, Georgia. Thanks for waking up with us.
Georgia Howe
We've got a lot to cover today. The Hollywood writers are back on the job, but where are all the scripts? We'll discuss the eerie quietness in Hollywood and what it means for audiences.
John Bickley
That's right. And we'll also be talking about a widely criticized UN-funded agency providing education in Gaza, which faces accusations of teaching anti-Israel content to young Palestinians.
Georgia Howe
And controversy engulfs the college football playoffs. Why are millions of fans and even a U.S. senator throwing the penalty flag?
John Bickley
Thanks for waking up with Morning Wire. Stay tuned. We have the news you need to know.
Music transitions
Georgia Howe
Though the second longest writer's strike in Hollywood history has come to an end, a new report suggests it's having a lasting negative impact. Studios are reportedly finding themselves without projects to buy.
Megan Basham
That's right. And according to this new report from The Hollywood Reporter, even though the writers were technically on strike for nearly five months, studios expected that they would still be quietly working on new projects during that time.
Georgia Howe
So when the strike ended, they expected new spec scripts to become available. If you're not familiar with that, spec script is just short for speculation script.
Megan Basham
And that means films and series that script writers write and then they take out on the market in the hope of selling. It's a very common way that content gets sold in the entertainment industry.
Georgia Howe
Well, studio and streaming producers told the reporter that that's not happening, that there's been very little new material to buy.
Megan Basham
So the theory that some analysts have is that while the Guild Strike did allow writers to continue writing those spec scripts during the strike, so long as they didn't then try to sell them.
Georgia Howe
Very few did that. They say that now that it's a return to business as normal, there's just not a lot of options for studios to choose from.
Megan Basham
Now, is there possibly some trepidation among writers about the kind of deals that they're going to get post-strike?
Georgia Howe
Yeah, that's absolutely what I'm hearing. Some writers and content creators are telling me that the softening market for content is a bigger factor than a lack of scripts.
Megan Basham
Basically, they're suggesting that big streamers like Netflix and big studios like Disney are signaling that the spending frenzy is over, so new content may not get the high bids it once did.
Georgia Howe
And that means that people are being very careful about what they bring onto the sales circuit.
Megan Basham
I asked N.D. Wilson, who is the creator of the popular Netflix kids series, Hello Ninja, about this seeming content drought.
Georgia Howe
And he told me that while it's always slow this time of year and he does expect to see more deals being made in the first quarter of 2024, streamers and studios are making it clear that they're not interested in returning to the pre-strike world.
Megan Basham
They're actually taking this as an opportunity to reset some expectations. So Wilson said that the current lack of pitching has more to do with agents and reps telling writers what the temperature is than with writers holding anything back.
Georgia Howe
So what does all this mean for audiences? Can we expect there just gonna be a severe content drought coming up?
Megan Basham
Well, you know, maybe not drought, but I think it is safe to say that we're gonna see something of a drier spell.
Georgia Howe
Everyone seems to be trying to figure out how this strike is going to impact the power balance going forward.
Megan Basham
The writers, as we all know, flex their muscles in a very big way during that strike. And some writers reps say that they're now more able to take advantage of possibilities outside the studio system, working with some independent backers.
Georgia Howe
So they're not as willing to settle for lower offers. But as we've talked about before, studios have taken advantage of the strike in resetting some creator deals.
Megan Basham
And they've got a backlog of series that were paused during the strike that they can now return to immediately.
Georgia Howe
As for consumers, it primarily means that we could see less variety and fewer options.
Megan Basham
And the reporter's story said that HBO in particular has made few offers this year and is reportedly encouraging writers to hold their pitches for the new year.
Georgia Howe
Their sources say that Apple and Netflix are doing the most deals right now and that Amazon is still willing to pay top dollar for competitive projects.
Megan Basham
But overall, that era of an easy sale is over. And they quoted Universal Studio Group's chair saying it is quality over quantity time now.
Georgia Howe
Well, as a consumer, I don't actually hate that. Right. I feel like Netflix got really overwhelming.
Megan Basham
Megan, thanks for reporting.
Georgia Howe
Anytime.
Music transitions
UNRWA, a controversial United Nations agency that provides education to hundreds of thousands of children in the Gaza Strip, is under renewed scrutiny.
Amanda Presta-Giacomo
Hey, John. So UNRWA, or UNRWA as it's known, is an acronym for United Nations Relief and Works Agency for Palestine Refugees in the Near East.
Georgia Howe
As implied in its name, the agency claims to support Palestinian refugees in places like Jordan, Lebanon, Syria, and the Gaza Strip.
Amanda Presta-Giacomo
Specifically in Gaza, UNRWA has 183 schools with around 300,000 students, and it employs 13,000 staffers.
Georgia Howe
The agency is mainly funded by Western nations. So more than 60% of its budget comes from the U.S., Germany, the EU, and Sweden.
Amanda Presta-Giacomo
And it also collects money from other nations, groups, and individuals. Now, UNRWA has been viewed as controversial for some time now, but since the Hamas terror attacks in Israel in October, there's really been renewed criticism underscoring the agency's ties to terrorism in particular.
Georgia Howe
Tell us about that.
Amanda Presta-Giacomo
Yeah, I mean, it's pretty clear why there's this new focus on the agency. There have been reports that 100 Hamas terrorists have been confirmed as UNRWA graduates.
Georgia Howe
And just this past week, one of the released Israeli hostages said his captor was an UNRWA teacher.
Amanda Presta-Giacomo
The hostage was held for nearly 50 days in an attic and barely provided food and medical attention. Other unread teachers openly praised the 10 attacks.
Georgia Howe
According to UN Watch, for example, one teacher celebrated the terrorism with exclamation marks and a heart emoji.
Amanda Presta-Giacomo
That same teacher in 2021 posted that he hoped rockets would strike Zionists, quote, wiping them entirely off this earth.
Georgia Howe
Critics of UNRWA are really not surprised by this, and they see the agency as what some have called an internationally funded Hamas front.
Amanda Presta-Giacomo
A report published last year from a watchdog group called Impact C found that UNRWA materials contained texts that glorified waging war and sacrificing one's life to liberate the motherland.
Georgia Howe
Texts also described the IDF as demonic and Jews as inherently treacherous and hostile to Islam and Muslims and impure.
Amanda Presta-Giacomo
This sort of anti-Semitism from UNRWA was even acknowledged by Secretary of State Antony Blinken back in June of 2021.
Georgia Howe
That was before that watchdog report. Here he is speaking before Congress.
Amanda Presta-Giacomo
We are also determined that UNRWA pursue very necessary reforms in terms of some of the abuses of the system that have taken place in the past, particularly the challenge that we've seen in disseminating in its educational products, anti-Semitic or anti-Israel information.
Georgia Howe
But the U.S. is still funding UNRWA despite these concerns.
Amanda Presta-Giacomo
Correct. Last year, the U.S. was the largest donor to the agency, handing over $344 million to UNRWA.
Georgia Howe
And Blinken actually visited the agency this past week, praising the group for its humanitarian efforts.
Amanda Presta-Giacomo
I'll note, though, that the U.S. under President Trump stopped funding UNRWA in 2018.
Georgia Howe
Trump vowed at the time that the funding would remain turned off unless the Palestinians came to the table for a peace deal with Israel.
Amanda Presta-Giacomo
That was a pretty short-lived bargaining chip, though, since Biden turned that spigot back on soon after he took office.
Georgia Howe
Well, it's important to know where our money's going.
Amanda Presta-Giacomo
Amanda, thanks for reporting.
Georgia Howe
You're welcome.
Music transitions
The College Football Playoff Committee made its final decision on the top four teams this past weekend, which led to much controversy when an undefeated team was left out of the final four.
David Cohn
Hey, John, this is easily the most controversial decision the playoff committee has made since it was first founded.
Georgia Howe
So let's set the stage here a little. The college football playoff committee was established 10 years ago and is made up of athletic directors, administrators, former coaches and players from all around the country.
David Cohn
And their duty is to select the four best teams to compete in college football's playoff.
Georgia Howe
That language is key. The four best teams rather than the four most deserving teams.
David Cohn
Needless to say, tasking a committee with deciding which teams are or are not invited to participate in postseason play is incredibly bureaucratic and seems to always leave several teams unsatisfied, but nothing like the contention seen this week.
Georgia Howe
So the four teams selected this past Sunday were two unbeaten conference champions. That's Michigan in the Big Ten, that's my alma mater, and Washington in the Pac-12.
David Cohn
The other two teams each had one loss but won their conferences. That Texas from the Big 12 and then the final spot went to Alabama the SEC champion which just defeated the number one Georgia Bulldogs but who lost to Texas earlier this season.
Georgia Howe
The drama lies with the fact that Florida State, your alma mater, which was both undefeated and a conference champion winning the ACC, was left out of the four-team playoff.
David Cohn
It's the first time in history that the college football playoff that an unbeaten Power 5 team didn't earn a spot.
Georgia Howe
Now, the committee has its weekly show where they try to explain their decisions. What reasoning did they provide for leaving out FSU?
David Cohn
So the college football playoff chairman, Boo Corrigan, who also serves as the athletic director for North Carolina State, pointed to the impact of Florida State losing its star quarterback, Jordan Travis, who broke his leg a few weeks ago.
Georgia Howe
Corrigan said, and here's a quote, Florida State is a different team than they were through the first 11 weeks.
David Cohn
It was an incredible season, but as you look at who they are as a team right now without Jordan Travis and without the offensive dynamic that he brings, they are a different team, unquote.
Georgia Howe
Now, one thing to keep in mind, injury to key players is part of the criteria that the committee does take into account.
David Cohn
The frustration for many, and you can speak to this if you'd like, is that there is no objectivity when it comes to weighing that criteria.
Georgia Howe
Record, strength of schedule, head-to-head matchups, and eye test are all taken into account, but there is no set standard for how these metrics determine the final selections of what takes priority.
David Cohn
And many who were outraged by the decision point to the glaring inconsistency of the committee.
Georgia Howe
Why did they rank Florida State at number four going into the weekend after Jordan Travis had already broken his leg weeks ago?
David Cohn
So how can they defend flip-flopping like that?
Georgia Howe
Right. There's obviously a lot of money on the line with decisions like this.
David Cohn
Is there any recourse for a team that feels the system was rigged to favor one program over another?
Georgia Howe
That seems highly unlikely.
David Cohn
Even though Florida Senator Rick Scott did send a three-page letter to the committee chair asking for detailed information about the process used to deny Florida State a spot in the playoffs.
Georgia Howe
Scott called the decision to slide FSU out of the playoffs shocking, and he demanded total transparency for how the selection Committee reached its conclusion.
David Cohn
As I noted, the team had been ranked fourth just the week before. Despite these efforts, the Florida State football team will most certainly move forward and accept their invitation to the Orange Bowl, where they will meet up with the Georgia Bulldogs.
Georgia Howe
Now, Michigan and Alabama will face off in the Rose Bowl, while Washington and Texas compete in the Sugar Bowl.
David Cohn
One final aspect to consider for fans that have grown frustrated with college football, next year, the sport will move to a 12-team playoff.
Georgia Howe
That will help prevent another situation like this for two reasons. One, obviously, the number of teams will be tripled.
David Cohn
But more importantly, the metrics for entry should be more objective. The big conference champions will have automatic bids to the playoffs, while the other wildcard spots will be selected based on ranking.
Georgia Howe
Well, we FSU fans are still recovering from the letdown, but looking forward to the next season's new format.
David Cohn
Dave, thanks for coming on.
Georgia Howe
Thank you for having me.
Music transitions
That was Crane & Company co-host David Cohn. Thanks for waking up with us. We'll be back later this afternoon with an extra edition of Morning Wire.