Main Topic: The energy policies of Kamala Harris and their potential impact on Pennsylvania voters, particularly in the upcoming presidential election.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Upbeat music fades out
Georgia Howe
Welcome to Morning Wire. I'm Georgia Howe.
John Bickley
And I'm John Bickley, Editor-in-Chief of the Daily Wire.
Georgia Howe
Today, we're exploring the critical energy issues on Pennsylvanians' minds and how Harris's policies might affect the 2024 presidential race.
John Bickley
That's right. And we're joined by Andre Beliveau, Senior Manager of Energy Policy at the Commonwealth Foundation.
Andre Beliveau
Thanks for having me on.
Georgia Howe
Andre, thanks for coming on. So first off, can you just characterize for us what Harris's energy policies are as of 2024? I know they've changed somewhat from the past.
Andre Beliveau
Yeah, so I think there's a few interesting points. One, obviously, there's been the flip-flopping on fracking. What I've been trying to say to people is it's almost irrelevant if she's actually flip-flopped or not, because in the same vein of saying that she now supports fracking, she's still celebrating the Inflation Reduction Act and certainly celebrating the same climate policies that we've seen coming out of the Biden-Harris administration for the last four years.
John Bickley
[interrupting] That's a great point. Andre, can you explain what the Inflation Reduction Act has done to our energy markets?
Andre Beliveau
Yeah, so the record has certainly not changed. And what we're seeing is Kamala Harris celebrating the IRA, which has poisoned our energy markets in the way that we do baseload energy generation, which has certainly been disrupting price signals, raising prices for consumers.
Georgia Howe
Now, when you say energy prices have gone up, can you put that into context for us? How much have they gone up and in which sectors?
Andre Beliveau
Well, when you ask voters and we have polling that we've conducted at the Commonwealth Foundation, we ask Pennsylvanians, you know, when you're thinking about energy and you're thinking about candidates, you know, what's the most important thing to you? And it's inflation. They say that energy affordability is one of the most important things that they're thinking about when they're choosing a candidate.
John Bickley
That's right. And I think our listeners would be surprised to know that 78% of Pennsylvanians said that energy affordability was going to be top of mind when thinking about who they're choosing.
Andre Beliveau
And that's a bipartisan supermajority. I mean, it's 78 percent of the electorate, but it was 81 percent Democrats, 68 percent independents, 81 percent Republicans. They're feeling inflation in their pockets and in the pocketbook.
Georgia Howe
Now, speaking about fracking specifically, how would it specifically affect Pennsylvanians if fracking were either banned or restricted through regulation?
Andre Beliveau
Yeah, I mean, Pennsylvania is the second largest producer of natural gas in the country. And Pennsylvanians are very aware of the impact that fracking has on their economy. So, I mean, if fracking were to end, it would be a tremendous economic burden on the state. You're talking tens of thousands of jobs being lost.
John Bickley
That's a staggering number. And I think our listeners would be surprised to know that 74% of Pennsylvanians support expanding infrastructure to transport natural gas and to expand natural gas infrastructure.
Andre Beliveau
And 75% said they would support expanding energy developments, specifically talking about the production or fracking specifically. And again, that's bipartisanly across the board, Democrats, independents, and Republicans.
Georgia Howe
Now, is Pennsylvania similar to other upper Midwest states in that way, or is this very specific to Pennsylvania this year?
Andre Beliveau
I mean, certainly when you're looking at the Marcellus Shale play region, it's obviously condensed in the western part of Pennsylvania, but you're also looking at parts of Ohio, certain parts of West Virginia, New York, if they still were allowing a robust fracking and natural gas environment there, which they're certainly not.
John Bickley
That's right. And I think it's worth noting that Pennsylvania is the keystone state, but it's also the keystone to American energy security.
Andre Beliveau
And we need Pennsylvania natural gas if we're ever going to have energy independence. And certainly if we want to break into global markets with LNG, we're going to need Pennsylvania natural gas to do it.
Georgia Howe
Now, I want to ask you about EVs. A recent Pew poll found that three in 10 Americans are willing to buy a fully electric vehicle. EV adoption has been a major priority for the Biden-Harris administration. How is this initiative playing with Midwestern voters like those in Pennsylvania?
Andre Beliveau
Yeah, our polling in Pennsylvania reflects that. I mean, Pennsylvanians are not sold on EVs. There was only about 5% of the respondents to our poll who said they would ever consider purchasing an EV as something to protect the environment.
John Bickley
That's a pretty low number. And I think it's worth noting that 68% of Pennsylvanians felt that it should be a higher priority for the federal government to ensure affordable energy, while only 32% believed that combating climate change should be a top priority.
Andre Beliveau
And EVs are certainly a part of the net zero goals that we're seeing come out of the environmental left, specifically about EVs. We asked Pennsylvania likely voters, how likely are you to consider purchasing an EV the next time you purchase a vehicle? And 59% said not likely.
Georgia Howe
Now, what about climate change? How has that been polling with voters and what are the trends there?
Andre Beliveau
Yeah, well, I just mentioned I think Pennsylvanians, certainly energy affordability is skyrocketing above anything considering climate change. And we conducted a poll early in the year and we asked them about environmental concerns. Our polling showed that while they obviously care about the environment and they want clean air, clean water, the idea of affordable energy and reliable energy was a top concern over combating climate change.
John Bickley
That's right. And I think it's worth noting that our polling showed that most Pennsylvanians feel that overregulation in government red tape has actually not only prevented energy and environmental projects from thriving but they believe that that also increasing their electric costs.
Andre Beliveau
Now, let's contrast this with President Trump's proposed energy policy. What has he said he's going to do?
Georgia Howe
Well, I think the idea of a fracking ban certainly would not come from a President Trump. I mean, he seems to understand the need for American energy security, and he seems to understand what something like natural gas and hydraulic fracturing can provide to that.
Andre Beliveau
So, I mean, there's definitely a difference. I think the emphasis there policy-wise seems to be more on affordable energy, seems to be more on American energy security.
John Bickley
Although, you know, there has been some interesting developments in the debate that we had with J.D. Vance and Tim Walls. We saw both J.D. Vance and Tim Walls supporting things like solar protectionism.
Andre Beliveau
And this sort of goes in the vein of Trump's views on tariffs and the idea of solar protectionism and sort of trying to onshore solar production.
Georgia Howe
It sounds good, but I think economically have similar impacts to what the Inflation Reduction Act would do.
Andre Beliveau
So I would hope that both candidates would avoid things like protectionist-style policies or central planning when it comes to energy policy.
John Bickley
But on the whole, I think you have one side that is focused on policies that are going to try to bring about American energy security and independence, and another side that is certainly trying to put climate alarmism or environmental, draconian environmental policies and prioritizing those over affordable energy.
Andre Beliveau
Now, last thing, you mentioned in your op-ed that 86% of Pennsylvanians believe American energy independence is essential. Do you think that translates to other states as well? Or is Pennsylvania particularly robust on that metric?
Georgia Howe
Obviously, Pennsylvania is unique in the sense that it's an energy producing state. So we're talking about these are specific jobs that people have and whether they are working themselves in the energy sector or it's friends or family they know and have a deeper connection to energy production.
Andre Beliveau
But I think across the board, I'm sure that Americans across the country are concerned about American energy security, American energy independence. And I think because of the fracking issue has been brought front and center in this current election cycle, it's certainly on people's minds.
John Bickley
While there is something unique about how Pennsylvanians think about energy and when making decisions about their candidates, this obviously is because of inflation across the board. This is literally touching the pocketbooks of every American across the country.
Andre Beliveau
I'm sure they're all concerned and thinking about American energy, security, and independence in a similar way as Pennsylvanians are thinking about it.
Georgia Howe
Well, Andre, thank you so much for coming on today.
Andre Beliveau
Yeah, thank you so much for having me.
John Bickley
That was Andre Beliveau, Senior Manager of Energy Policy at the Commonwealth Foundation.
Georgia Howe
And this has been a Saturday edition of Morning Wire.
John Bickley
Trust in the media is at an all-time low. And there’s a reason—endless virtue signaling and manufactured outrage. Finally, there’s an alternative. Morning Wire is presented by Daily Wire Editor-in-Chief, John Bickley, and co-host Georgia Howe. Get daily coverage of the latest developments in politics, culture, education, sports, and more. Wake up with Morning Wire and get the facts first on the news you need to know.
Georgia Howe
And don't forget to text "WIRE" to 989898 for your no-cost, no-obligation information kit on gold investing with Birch Gold.
John Bickley
And don't forget to visit LifeLock.com slash podcast for 40% off your first year.
Georgia Howe
Thanks for tuning in to Morning Wire.
John Bickley
And we'll see you tomorrow.