Main Topic: Reforming the FBI to prevent its potential misuse and ensure it serves as a force for law enforcement rather than a tool for political purposes.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Theme music fades out
John Bickley
Welcome to this extra edition of Morning Wire. I'm Daily Wire editor-in-chief, John Bickley, and I'm joined by Georgia Howe. It's Saturday, July 15th.
Georgia Howe
Good morning, John.
John Bickley
Good morning, Georgia. Today, we're talking about the FBI and growing calls for its reform. Joining us now is Stephen Bradbury, distinguished fellow in the executive vice president's office at the Heritage Foundation. Welcome, Stephen.
Stephen Bradbury
Thanks for having me on.
John Bickley
So in your report, you write, "There is good reason to rethink the entire idea of the FBI at a fundamental level." Let's start with the evidence for this conclusion. You say, "The executive branch's misuse of federal intelligence authorities gives Congress clear and compelling grounds for enacting forceful reforms." What are some examples of those misuses or abuses of the FBI?
Stephen Bradbury
Well, thanks for asking. Happy to be on. Our report lays those out in some detail. The first part of our report, which is entitled "How to Fix the FBI," recites the record of abuses. And at this point, the evidence is mounting. We've seen the reports about the Crossfire Hurricane, the politicized investigation of the Trump campaign versus the protective treatment given to the Clinton campaign in 2016. That's detailed even further in the Durham report.
John Bickley
That's a great starting point. Can you walk us through some of the specifics that you discuss in your report? You say that Congress should define the scope of the FBI's jurisdiction, refocus its mission on traditional law enforcement, and put it under effective control.
Stephen Bradbury
Yeah, in the middle part, second part of our report, we walk through several important elements for what a reconstruction of the FBI might entail. And that's one of them. And by narrowing or focusing the jurisdiction, we mean, should the FBI continue to have jurisdiction to investigate and enforce every single federal crime that's on the books?
Georgia Howe
That's a lot of crimes, Stephen. How would you narrow that down?
Stephen Bradbury
Well, one possibility would be the FBI would no longer be the general all-purpose investigator, but would focus on those major criminal areas that are not covered by other federal agencies. Also, rethinking, does it need to be as broad as it is, or should it focus on large conspiracies, organized crime syndicates, interstate criminal activities that are beyond the reach of state and local law enforcement. That's sort of the traditional view of the federal jurisdiction.
John Bickley
That makes sense. What about the FBI's intelligence gathering function? Should it continue to have that role?
Stephen Bradbury
That's been a prominent part of its portfolio since the attacks of 9-11 made a lot of sense in the days and weeks and months after 9-11 when we were trying to stop a follow-on attack. But does it need to have that same robust, prominent role for intelligence gathering today? What we've seen, unfortunately, is it's misused those tools to target and track the activities, constitutionally protected activities of Americans with no basis to think there's been a crime or national security threat.
Georgia Howe
That's chilling. You mentioned the Twitter files and the FISA court unsealing opinions. Can you walk us through some of the specific abuses you're talking about?
Stephen Bradbury
Well, we've seen the FISA court unsealing opinions in which it found that the FBI had improperly accessed national security database information to gather information about Americans with no national security purpose, clearly improper, done more than 278,000 times, according to the FISA court.
John Bickley
That's staggering. What do you propose as a fix for these abuses?
Stephen Bradbury
One of the things we are recommending is that as a condition of re-approving, reauthorizing that Section 702 surveillance tool, which comes up for reauthorization at the end of this year, that Congress insists on insulating the FBI from the 702 program. So the FBI would no longer be allowed to dip into that database or participate directly.
Georgia Howe
That's a big ask. What about transparency? Are there any actions Congress can take to compel the FBI to be more transparent with the American public?
Stephen Bradbury
Yes, we have several suggestions along those lines. One suggestion is to put in place an inspector general for the FBI. They don't currently have one just for the Bureau. Another thing would be to require a inspector general report that discloses all of the past instances when information about Americans was improperly gathered. And then the third requirement would be for the attorney general to purge all of that improperly collected data from systems and certify that it's been purged.
John Bickley
That's a good starting point. Do you think this is actually possible? Is Congress likely to take any of these steps?
Stephen Bradbury
Well, certainly there should be bipartisan support. Unfortunately, in Washington today, these issues get so politicized and there's such partisan rancor that what you do see is members on the other side of the aisle saying, oh, you only want these reforms for political reasons, for example, to protect Donald Trump and his campaign, et cetera.
Georgia Howe
That's a shame. But if Congress can't get it together, what's the alternative?
Stephen Bradbury
The need to reauthorize this important surveillance tool, Section 702, that has to be reauthorized by the end of this year or it will expire. That creates a real opportunity and leverage for Congress to insist on, at a minimum, a certain minimum set of reforms as a condition of reauthorizing 702.
John Bickley
Stephen, thank you so much for joining us.
Stephen Bradbury
Thank you.
Georgia Howe
Thanks, Stephen.
John Bickley
That was Heritage Foundation's Stephen Bradbury, and this has been an extra edition of Morning Wire.