Main Topic: The Decline of Independent Play and its Impact on Mental Health in Teens
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Theme music fades out
Georgia Howe
Welcome to Morning Wire. I'm Georgia Howe, and I'm joined today by Daily Wire Editor-in-Chief John Bickley. It's Tuesday, December 26th, and this is a special edition of Morning Wire.
John Bickley
Thanks for having me on, Georgia.
Georgia Howe
Today, we're discussing why independent play is crucial for kids. Joining me to talk about this is research professor of psychology and neuroscience at Boston College, Peter Gray. Peter, thanks for coming on.
Peter Gray
You're welcome.
Georgia Howe
Now, first off, tell us a little bit about this paper that you published that's been getting a lot of attention.
Peter Gray
So the paper is a review of many studies, all of which support the thesis that the rise in mental disorder and anxiety, depression, even suicide among young people over the past decades, because these have been rising for decades now, is largely the result of a decline in young people's opportunities for independent activity. Independent play, other kinds of independent activity, the kinds of activities that bring immediate pleasure to young people and that also build the sort of character traits that allow them to face the bumps in the road of life without falling apart.
Georgia Howe
My reason for publishing this in the Journal of Pediatrics is I believe that pediatricians and other practitioners, family doctors, child psychiatrists and psychologists and so on, are not sufficiently aware of this, surprisingly to me, not sufficiently aware of the ways that young people's freedom has declined and how that might influence their anxiety and depression. Also because I believe that these are the people that have the most possibility of creating change. When pediatricians talk with parents, they can talk not just about safety, but also about young people's needs for some degree of adventure, some degree of risk, some degree of independent activity in order to develop the kinds of character traits that are necessary to grow in a mentally healthy way.
So it was deliberately oriented. I haven't previously published in a pediatrics journal, but we deliberately published the article there in order to reach pediatricians.
Peter Gray
How do you define independent activity? What specifically do some of those activities look like?
Georgia Howe
So independent activity really means activity that children engage in themselves without being in any direct way controlled or monitored by adults. So especially for younger children children under the age of about 12, the primary form of independent activity is play, free play, play with other children away from adults. This is the way that children normally played throughout human history, but in recent times, we have increasingly been preventing them from playing that way for various reasons.
Peter Gray
But it also includes things like walking by yourself to school, taking public transportation, doing errands for your parents, having a part-time job, all of these kinds of things which give children the opportunity to prove to themselves and others that they are competent to do things on their own, that they are reliable, that they can be trusted.
Georgia Howe
These are the things that we have been very much depriving young people of in recent times.
Peter Gray
Now, you kind of touched on it, but what are some of the character traits that are built with independent activity that you think can't so much be built with more structured activity?
Georgia Howe
So there's a lot of ways of describing this. There are various different kinds of terminologies that psychologists use. So one way to describe it has to do with a character trait called locus of control. Locus of control is a dimension that goes at one extreme from high internal locus of control, meaning that you have the sense of I'm in control of my own life, I can solve my own problems, I am the master of my destiny.
Peter Gray
The other extreme towards the external locus of control is that I have little control over what happens to me or how things play out in my life. I'm kind of a victim of circumstance, powerful other people, luck.
Georgia Howe
So, of course, most of us are somewhere in the middle on this, but it turns out to be healthy, even to the degree that it might be error, to be on the side of internal locus of control. I believe that I can control my fate. I believe I can solve problems and so on and so forth.
Peter Gray
Now, a high internal locus of control has been shown for people of all ages, not just children, but adults as well, to be healthy in the sense that you are far less likely to suffer from anxiety or depression if you have a high internal locus of control.
Georgia Howe
That makes sense, because if you believe that you can solve problems that arise, if you believe that you can control your destiny, the world is less scary. You feel less hopeless than if you believe you're kind of a victim of whatever happens.
Peter Gray
So it's not surprising that a high internal locus of control is a healthy characteristic to have. But to develop a high internal locus of control you have to have practice in exerting control and we have been depriving children of that practice.
Georgia Howe
And so in fact over these same decades that I been describing roughly between about 1960 and today the same period of time in which anxiety and depression has been continuously rising in young people, this measure of locus of control in research studies among young people has been continuously declining.
Peter Gray
The measure of internal locus of control, ever more external locus. So that's one kind of characteristic. By engaging in independent activities, by solving problems, you learn that you can engage in independent, you can solve problems, you can control your fate to at least a large degree, you develop this internal sense that you can do that.
Georgia Howe
And that helps you deal with the unknowns in life as they occur.
Peter Gray
So what are some of the barriers to parents allowing this kind of independent activity? What do you think are the reasons why kids are engaging in so much less of it now than in the past?
Georgia Howe
I think there are a lot of changes that have occurred over the decades that I'm talking about. But the two biggest changes are an increased fear that we have, an increased belief that it's dangerous for children to be out of our sight, to be on their own in any kind of way.
Peter Gray
It's an irrational belief in the sense that the truth is the dangers that people are afraid of are no more present than they ever were. The kinds of things that most frighten parents about letting their children out, that their children might be kidnapped or molested or even murdered by a stranger on the street, almost never happens.
Georgia Howe
But when it does happen, it's very much played up by the media. And so people believe that it's a far more common kind of crime than actually occurs.
Peter Gray
So that's one of the events. We have a sort of general belief that it's dangerous for children, that we are negligent parents if we're not constantly watching and supervising our kids.
Georgia Howe
The other change that's occurred is what I sometimes refer to as a schooling mentality of child development. And school itself has become ever more salient in children's lives.
Peter Gray
It's become ever more stressful to children, ever more time spent on school. But in addition to that, this sort of schooling mentality, as I call it, has led to the belief that children grow best when they're carefully guided and taught and mentored by adults.
Georgia Howe
And that children's own activities, independent of adults, are kind of a waste of time.
Peter Gray
So that belief has pervaded the culture It pervaded the way parents think Parents more and more believe over this period of time that their job is to teach their children their job is to guide their children their job is to help their children do well in school.
Georgia Howe
And as part of that, there's a focus on putting children, encouraging children to go into adult-directed activities even when they're not in school.
Peter Gray
So adult-directed sports have largely replaced the old way that kids used to play of going out to the vacant lot and getting up their own game but this is not a replacement because these kinds of activities are just more adult-directed activities children are not learning to create their own activities to direct their own activities to negotiate with other children how to solve the problems they're not learning the same skills in these kinds of adult-directed activities that they would be learning on their own.
Georgia Howe
So it's good intentions in a sense that has led to this change. We want to protect our children and we believe that the way we protect them is to watch them all the time, to not let them out where there may be dangers.
Peter Gray
And we want our children to do well in the world and we have come to believe that they will do well in the world if they are guided and taught by adults. But this is mistaken.
Georgia Howe
Of course, they do need some guidance and mentoring by adults. And of course, they do need some protection. But what we have forgotten in all of this is that they also need lots of opportunity to do their own things, to behave independently, to figure out what they themselves want to do, to pursue those activities and to learn how to solve the problems that are necessary when they are doing things on their own.
Peter Gray
Now, your paper briefly mentions the Let Grow organization. What is that?
Georgia Howe
So Let Grow is a nonprofit organization that was founded about a decade ago. I was one of the founders, along with Lenore Skenazy was another of the founders. She wrote the book Free Range Kids.
Peter Gray
And the purpose of Let Grow is to help change the culture in such a way that children's independent play and other independent activities becomes more possible and more acceptable than it has been.
Georgia Howe
So we work with schools among other things in order to bring free play into schools and also to bring other kinds of adventures into schools.
Peter Gray
And we provide a forum for parents on how they can, through their own neighborhoods and through their communities, allow more adventure and free play for their children.
Georgia Howe
All right, well, Peter, we have a lot of parents in our audience, so I really appreciate you coming on and sharing this insight.
Peter Gray
You're very welcome.
Georgia Howe
That was Peter Gray, Research Professor of Psychology and Neuroscience at Boston College. And this has been a special edition of Morning Wire.
Theme music fades in