Main Topic: The podcast episode discusses a potential landmark Supreme Court case involving a group of Jewish professors who are suing their union, the Professional Staff Congress of City University of New York (PSC CUNY), for allegedly discriminating against them and promoting anti-Semitism.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Next Steps:
Upbeat music fades out, followed by the sound of a newsroom
John Bickley
Welcome to an extra edition of Morning Wire, I'm John Bickley.
Georgia Howe
And I'm Georgia Howe.
John Bickley
Today, we're discussing a landmark Supreme Court case that could change the law of the land when it comes to unions and forced representation.
Georgia Howe
That's right, John. We're joined by Jeffrey Lacks, a professor at Brooklyn's Kingsborough Community College, and Nathan McGrath, president and general counsel at the Fairness Center, who's representing Lacks and his colleagues.
Sound of a coffee cup being placed on a table
John Bickley
Before we dive into the case, let's take a quick break to thank our sponsor, Black Rifle Coffee. Get an exclusive discount with code DAILYWIRE at BlackRifleCoffee.com.
Georgia Howe
And don't forget to text "WIRE" to 989898 for your no-cost, no-obligation information kit from Birch Gold.
John Bickley
Alright, let's get back to our guests. Nathan, you have a special expertise related to this case, correct?
Nathan McGrath
Right, I'm the lead attorney on this case. Glad to be here.
John Bickley
My background, I always say nobody wakes up dreaming to be a lawyer in our area. There's very few who do it, maybe less than 30 around the country. And in 2012, actually, I ended up taking a job with National Right to Work, spent five years there, cutting my teeth in this area of law, ended up being recruited by the Fairness Center and came up here and have just really devoted my practice to representing people who public sector union officials have violated their rights, whether it's constitutional rights or they've retaliated against them for exercising constitutional rights and even union corruption.
Jeffrey Lacks
Well, Jeff, you also have a legal background, but also years of teaching experience at the college you're now suing, correct?
Yes. I'm one of six professors who are plaintiffs in the lawsuit. I have five years of litigation experience, and then I went into academia full-time. I've been at Kingsborough Community College as a law professor since 2004. And I've been the chair of the Department of Business there since 2011.
Nathan McGrath
So let's talk about this case. What's the timeline of events that led you up to the point that you're taking legal action all the way up to the Supreme Court?
Jeffrey Lacks
Well, CUNY has been a hotbed of anti-Semitism for years. And I've been blowing the alarm on that personally. And then I founded a group called Safe Campus, Students, Alumni and Faculty for Equality on Campus a couple of years ago, well before October 7th. And we've been talking about the systemic antisemitism at the university for all these years.
Nathan McGrath
Yeah, I mean, how is it possible? It goes all the way back to the 1940s to a Supreme Court decision there. The Supreme Court said we going to allow this scheme basically where state law can force people to be represented by a union for collective bargaining you know terms and conditions of employment and for grievances and disciplinary matters those types of things will allow certain states if they want to, to force different, they're called bargaining units, basically groups of employees at different places of employment to be represented only by the union, meaning they can't speak for themselves, They can't make any deal with the contract for themselves. The union gets to do it all.
Jeffrey Lacks
So usually when I do interviews and I've been on Fox a lot of times and a lot of different radio shows, they always ask me, was I surprised by what happened on October 7th? And I say, yes, I was surprised by the events of October 7th, but I was not surprised by the reaction of academia and faculty of October 8th because I've been seeing it behind the scenes for a decade.
Nathan McGrath
Yeah, I mean, how is it possible? It goes all the way back to the 1940s to a Supreme Court decision there. The Supreme Court said we going to allow this scheme basically where state law can force people to be represented by a union for collective bargaining you know terms and conditions of employment and for grievances and disciplinary matters those types of things will allow certain states if they want to, to force different, they're called bargaining units, basically groups of employees at different places of employment to be represented only by the union, meaning they can't speak for themselves, They can't make any deal with the contract for themselves. The union gets to do it all.
Jeffrey Lacks
And the head of discrimination at CUNY, the person in charge of discrimination across all 25 campuses is Sally Abedala. She is a former CARE Minnesota director. Now, CARE Minnesota, for your listeners who may not know, is not just a CARE chapter. It is one of the most extreme CARE chapters. And she was the leader of the BDS movement, Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions Movement, an anti-Israel, anti-Semitic movement at that chapter.
Nathan McGrath
Yeah, I mean, how is it possible? It goes all the way back to the 1940s to a Supreme Court decision there. The Supreme Court said we going to allow this scheme basically where state law can force people to be represented by a union for collective bargaining you know terms and conditions of employment and for grievances and disciplinary matters those types of things will allow certain states if they want to, to force different, they're called bargaining units, basically groups of employees at different places of employment to be represented only by the union, meaning they can't speak for themselves, They can't make any deal with the contract for themselves. The union gets to do it all.
John Bickley
So, Nathan, what about the financial side of this? Are professors forced to pay union dues or is it just that you have no other voice than this union?
Nathan McGrath
Because of the great work of organizations like the National Right to Work Foundation and the Fairness Center, because of their great work, Janus transpired. And Nathan's organization was very much involved in Janus happening and allowing me to actually get out of the union.
Jeffrey Lacks
So our union at the time of Janus had over 30,000 members. Our union, and they have to publicize their data, I believe every year. The last time I looked, they only had just over 23,000 members. So that tells you how many people are disillusioned with our union. That's 7,000 people.
Nathan McGrath
Thanks to Nathan's work and his organization's work, they were able to opt out of the union and to answer your question more directly, not pay dues. However, the second part of your question, you said it exactly right, which is that we still are subject to, because of the state law, what's called the Taylor Law in New York State, we are required to be part of the bargaining unit, meaning that whatever terms our union negotiates for us, we are bound by those terms.
Jeffrey Lacks
And in my case and also I believe also I can speak for my five co cases it not just that we disagree fundamentally ideologically and find appalling the views of our union It's really not just that. It's much more practical. Our union right now has no contract with the university. They're negotiating a new contract now.
Nathan McGrath
So Jeff and his colleagues have, like we mentioned, filed before the Supreme Court asking them to take their case. Oddly, the other side, they waived their right to respond. And the court actually came back on September 12th, I think it was, and said, nope, we want to hear from you. We need a response. So that's currently due pretty soon here.
Georgia Howe
Gentlemen, thank you so much for coming on. Thank you for covering us.
John Bickley
Really appreciate it.
Music starts playing
That was Jeffrey Lacks and Nathan McGrath, and this has been an extra edition of Morning Wire.