Main Topic: The legislative battle over the LGBT agenda in several states, particularly in regards to the protection of transgender-identifying minors and the rights of parents.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Theme music fades out
John Bickley
Good morning, I'm Daily Wire Editor-in-Chief John Bickley with Georgia Howe. It's Saturday, May 25th, and this is an extra edition of Morning Wire.
Georgia Howe
Joining us to discuss the movement in several states to push increasingly radical concepts about gender and sexual orientation is Sarah Parshall Perry, Senior Legal Fellow at the Heritage Foundation. Hi, Sarah.
Sarah Parshall Perry
Hi, thanks for having me.
John Bickley
First, you recently wrote an article about policies you say expose children to predatory behavior. What did you see in today's states and schools that prompted you to write this?
Sarah Parshall Perry
Actually, it was set off by a story coming out of Minnesota. Lee Fink, who is a transgender-identified biological male, identifies as a woman, a legislator in Minnesota, put together a bill declaring Minnesota not only as a refuge state for the medical transitioning of minors, but actually, and this really caught my attention, proposed an amendment to a current state law that would classify sexual attachment to children as a protected sexual orientation.
Georgia Howe
That's shocking. Can you explain what that means?
Sarah Parshall Perry
I wanted to know exactly how far this went and started looking into other state legislatures, one of which was Colorado, where the Democrats in the House of Reps just voted down making indecent exposure to minors a felony. And their justification was that it unfairly targeted the drag and trans communities.
John Bickley
That's incredible. I want to go back to the Minnesota bill. You said it proposed an amendment to classify sexual attachment to children as a protected sexual orientation. Can you unpack that for us?
Sarah Parshall Perry
Sure. In fact, gender identity had been previously defined under Minnesota's Human Rights Act, which has been described as the most expansive of categories of non-discrimination in the country. Originally, there was language that explicitly excluded sexual attraction to children as a protected sexual orientation. Representative Lee Fink introduced a bill in the appropriations process. So this goes to the whole funding of government. Obviously, the way many people get things done is through appropriations if they have pet projects. It was introduced through appropriations and eliminates that exclusion.
Georgia Howe
So, by removing that language, it raises a red flag. And you're saying that this legislator, Lee Fink, has created a trans refuge state through authorship of a bill creating gender identity protection for minors who are fleeing into the state from other non-supportive locations where families might not want these treatments.
Sarah Parshall Perry
That's right. The combination of those two together raises not only a red flag, but it really does pave the way for the inclusion of sexual attraction to children as a protected category.
John Bickley
Now, Fink's transgender sanctuary bill, which has raised alarms among those who want to protect parents' rights, that's not the only one in the U.S. What have we seen in some of the other states?
Sarah Parshall Perry
Washington state is the newest of this particular ilk of sanctuary law states. Colorado is also a sanctuary state, as is now California. But Washington state law gives sort of lip service to the fact that individuals should ostensibly be reunited with their parents and that social services should make every attempt to contact custodial parents except in the case of reasonable cause.
Georgia Howe
And what does that mean in practice?
Sarah Parshall Perry
And it only when you cross a bill that says reasonable cause with other laws on the books that you realize they've shoehorned in descriptions of reasonable cause, including their failure to feel safe and affirmed in an environment where the parents disagree with desired gender modification attempts. So if this child feels unsafe in any state, not just in the state of Washington, that's a reason to keep these children hidden away from their parents and to create a safe space for them.
John Bickley
As the mother of three teenage children, it is truly eye-opening. And it's incredibly damning on the part of those individual legislators in Washington who have made very clear that they have absolutely no appreciation for longstanding parental rights law and what the Supreme Court has said.
Georgia Howe
There's also a movement to promote some of these policies in schools as well, what activists call protecting children from their own parents. What are we seeing on that front in education?
Sarah Parshall Perry
Quite a number of federal lawsuits, and the platform for those lawsuits is almost invariably the same, that it is a violation of a fundamental liberty interest on the part of parents to raise, to educate, to oversee the health and welfare of their own children.
John Bickley
This was a principle that was articulated in 1923 with Meyer v. Nebraska. Now we're all the way 100 years later, and as recently as the year 2000, in a case called Troxell v. Granville, the Supreme Court said this is among the most vaunted, our oldest liberty interests recognized.
Georgia Howe
So all of these lawsuits taking place specifically in a public school format where these children are being socially transitioned against the express will of their parents, where they are given different names, different pronouns, allowed to use bathrooms and sports teams according to their gender identity, is standing in place of this fundamental parental right.
Sarah Parshall Perry
And I'm hopeful that we'll see some common sense from many of these circuit courts, including the 11th Circuit, where a case is currently pending, Little John v. School Board of Leon County, Florida. That's the most recent one. It's on appeal currently, and we're hopeful we'll finally see a federal court weigh in and say these types of procedures in public schools are illegal.
John Bickley
Do we see any connection between these issues, between the arguments for gender treatments for minors and those defending so-called minor attraction?
Sarah Parshall Perry
We do. And I going to tell you it is one of the more disturbing elements of where we seeing this debate on gender identity and transgender status go particularly because it goes to the issue of capacity for those minors who can say I feel like a girl or I feel like a boy and can, with such a representation, get access to cross-sex hormones, puberty blockers, be subject to voluntary mastectomies. These are huge decisions.
Georgia Howe
But giving those individuals, those minor children, the perceived agency, the sense of mind, the maturity to make decisions like that gets us closer to that line for youth-attracted people.
Sarah Parshall Perry
Because if after all these minors are themselves capable of entering into such life-altering decisions, they can also be capable of entering into life-altering choices and having sex with adults. We know, for example, Mermaids, which is one of the organizations, the top organization for all LGBTQ corporations supporting transgender children in the United Kingdom, recently had a trustee of their organization have to resign in October because he spoke at a conference openly supporting pedophilia.
John Bickley
Final question. What about the medical community? Why has it complied with these new radical gender interventions and treatments?
Sarah Parshall Perry
That's a great question. Part of it is because money talks, but in the transgender cultural tsunami, it really screams. We discovered that the Human Rights Campaign's Equity Index, for which they would rate organizations based on their inclusiveness and in specific, their treatment of transgender individuals or what are called sexually diverse cultures. That study was being underwritten by Pfizer. Pfizer, of course, a major pharmaceutical corporation that makes many of the puberty blockers and cross-sex hormones that are being used for these minor children.
Georgia Howe
The inflection point here is always going to be following the dollar. It's why we see certain corporations like Bud Light tanking in an effort to make a profit. People made very clear how they felt. And it's why I believe Target has taken the precisely identical route.
Sarah Parshall Perry
But all of this can be traced back to money. There is money to be made in corporate wokeness and specifically in the sexualization of children.
John Bickley
Well, we'll continue to follow the money. Sarah, thanks for joining us.
Sarah Parshall Perry
Thanks for having me.
Theme music starts playing
John Bickley
That was Heritage Senior Legal Fellow, Sarah Parshall Perry, and this has been an extra edition of Morning Wire. Next to Back.