Main Topic: The Supreme Court's Fall Term and Key Cases
Key Participants:
Key Points:
Takeaways:
Recommendations:
Theme music fades out
Georgia Howe
Welcome to Morning Wire, an extra edition. I'm Georgia Howe, and I'm here with Daily Wire editor-in-chief John Bickley.
John Bickley
Thanks for joining us, Georgia.
Georgia Howe
Today, we're discussing the Supreme Court's fall term and some of the significant cases that could have widespread effects across all industries in the U.S.
John Bickley
That's right, Georgia. Joining us is Zach Smith, legal fellow at the Heritage Foundation and manager of the Supreme Court and Appellate Advocacy Program.
Zach Smith
Thanks for having me on.
Georgia Howe
Zach, thanks for coming on. So the Supreme Court came back in session this past week on October 2nd. Can you give us an overview of some of the big cases that you're going to be watching that have implications for the American people?
Zach Smith
Well, there are several cases that the court has agreed to hear involving important administrative law issues, involving separation of powers issues. One involves something called the Chevron Doctrine, whether courts should give deference to administrative agencies and their interpretation of ambiguous or unclear statutes. Another is Moore v. United States, which involves whether a potential wealth tax would be constitutional in the future. And there are others as well, but this is certainly a term where administrative law issues will be front and center for the court.
Georgia Howe
So let's zoom in a bit on individual cases. You've alluded, I think, to Loper-Bright Enterprises versus Raimondo. That's the Chevron deference case. Moore versus United States. That's the case related to a potential tax on unrealized gains. And like you said, there are several others before the Supreme Court this term as well. Which cases do you think are most important and or interesting to watch in terms of having the furthest reaching consequences?
Zach Smith
Well, I think the Loper-Bright case will certainly be at the top of everyone's list. Many of your listeners may have heard of something called Chevron deference. It's a very controversial doctrine in the law that basically says that where a statute or regulation is ambiguous, essentially courts should defer to an executive branch agency's interpretation of that statute or regulation.
John Bickley
That's right. And can you explain what's at stake with this case?
Zach Smith
Now, this is problematic for a lot of reasons. Essentially, what courts are doing by deferring to an agency's interpretation is they're essentially transferring power to unelected, unaccountable bureaucrats to decide their own power. And so in this specific case, the Loper Bright case, a group of New England fisheries are challenging a regulation put forward by the regulatory body that oversees them that said not only did they have to allow fishing monitors to accompany them on their boats but they also had to pay for those fishing monitors for their services.
Georgia Howe
And can you give any examples off the top of your head of other industries that might be affected?
Zach Smith
Every industry that's regulated. So when I say this would have far-reaching consequences, it would literally touch every aspect of administrative law as we know it, everything from the FTC to the SEC, to name any other regulated entity.
John Bickley
That sounds like it. And is there any indication of how the justices are going to rule on this?
Zach Smith
You know, it's hard to say. Some of the justices have expressed skepticism, rightly so, I think, about the Chevron doctrine in the past. The case is being argued for the fisheries by Paul Clement. He's a former U.S. Solicitor General. He's one of the most respected Supreme Court advocates practicing today. And so I think the fact that the court took this case, the fact that Paul Clement is arguing for overturning Chevron. Both of those facts indicate that at least some of the justices are very interested in revisiting their current Chevron deference doctrine.
Georgia Howe
Now, another case that we've been tracking is the Harrington v Purdue Pharma case. So the court going to weigh in on this important bankruptcy case involving the Sackler family.
Zach Smith
Yeah, this is a fascinating case that has flown under the radar in a lot of respects, but it could have far-reaching implications not only for this specific opioid-related bankruptcy, but also for many other bankruptcy cases because what's fundamentally at issue here are certain due process requirements.
Georgia Howe
Can you explain this bankruptcy case a little bit for us and what the arguments are on each side?
Zach Smith
Essentially, what the Supreme Court is being asked to decide is whether in a bankruptcy case, certain agreements that are reached, whether they can release all claims from people who are not part of that bankruptcy process. And it's unique in this particular case, because the Sacklers, the family who owned Purdue Pharma for many, many years, they're not technically part of this bankruptcy case. But essentially, they were facing a lot of liability, many claims by people and family members who claimed that their family members were addicted to opioids that Purdue Pharma produced.
John Bickley
And can you break it down for us? So the Sackler family is offering to pay a settlement on behalf of Purdue. And if accepted, that'll release the family from all future claims relating to opioid settlements. And that's what they're trying to get off the hook for.
Zach Smith
Yeah, that's right. So Purdue Pharma is the entity that declared bankruptcy. The Sackler family is not technically part of this bankruptcy case. But that's what is so odd about this case in some ways because the Sackler family separately is facing a lot of potential liability. And so basically by putting in several billion dollars into this bankruptcy reorganization plan, they're providing some money that could go toward victims and settlements, but certainly it's not the liability that they would face if many of these claims remained.
Georgia Howe
And so the exact issue that the court is being asked to decide is whether under chapter 11 of the bankruptcy code, a release that extinguishes claims held by non-debtors against non-debtor third parties, that's the Sackler family, without the claimant's consent can extinguish those future claims.
Zach Smith
But at the end of the day, what this is all about, the Sackler family is trying to limit their exposure against future tort claims.
Georgia Howe
All right, we probably have time for one more case. Is there one other that jumps out to you as something that our listeners might want to keep an eye on?
Zach Smith
Yeah, I think the Moore versus United States case is also a very interesting one. This case is very important because depending on what the court does with it, it could set the stage for a future wealth tax if the court upholds a law that Congress passed several years ago that allowed a one-time, supposedly one-time tax on unrealized gains involving foreign corporations.
John Bickley
And can you explain the argument in this case?
Zach Smith
The argument in this case is that the 16th Amendment is the constitutional provision that allows the IRS, the federal government, to implement an individual income tax. Before that, the Constitution said that taxation had to be equally apportioned among the states. The argument in this case is because the gains at issue are unrealized. They don't count as income as we have traditionally understood that term to be. And so because of that, the 16th Amendment doesn't really apply, and any taxes levied would have to be apportioned as required by the original Constitution.
Georgia Howe
Well, definitely a pretty loaded term for the Supreme Court. We'll be keeping tabs on several, if not all, of these cases. Zach, thanks so much for coming on today.
Zach Smith
Thank you for having me on.
Georgia Howe
That was Zach Smith, legal fellow at the Heritage Foundation and manager of the Supreme Court and Appellate Advocacy Program. And this has been an extra edition of Morning Wire.