Main Topic: The Trump presidency's initial response from American voters, with a focus on non-white males and those without a college degree supporting Trump, and Democrats struggling to find a message.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Theme music fades out
John Bickley
Welcome to Morning Wire, I'm John Bickley, and this is a weekend edition. Joining me is Georgia Howe. It's Sunday, March 2nd.
Georgia Howe
Thanks for having me, John.
John Bickley
Today, we're talking to Signal pollster Brent Buchanan about how Americans are responding to the Trump presidency. Brent, thanks for joining us.
Brent Buchanan
Great to be back.
John Bickley
So, you released a new national vote trend poll this month. What were some of the trends that stood out to you?
Brent Buchanan
Well, there were a few, and I'd say the biggest is this finding that non-white men continue to move towards Donald Trump. And it's a really fascinating thing because if you go back and look at the exit polling, white voters as a whole basically gave Trump the exact same margin in the 24 election as they did in the 20 election. And that was two factors, one being that non-college educated whites continue to move to the right, college educated whites and higher continue to move to the left. And that trend on the educational attainment, we call it the diploma divide, hadn't really made its way into non-white communities in the same veracity that it had white communities from between 16 and 20 and 24.
Georgia Howe
That's a really interesting point. You mentioned non-white men, specifically. Can you talk more about that?
Brent Buchanan
Yeah, so a very dramatic difference there. So you're seeing that continued support that we saw from the election to this point, what are some of the things you found in terms of specific reasons that Trump's maintaining this support?
John Bickley
Yeah, let's dive into that. What are some of the reasons behind this support?
Brent Buchanan
Well, if you look at why people, especially those without a college degree, are moving to the right, it's because they don't trust the system at all. They believe that government works against them and not for them, and that it is an impediment to their ability to succeed, to take care of their family, to educate their children. They look at the lunacy of the left, how they're focusing so much on, let's ensure there's 10 transgender bathrooms in the school as being a more important priority than, can my kid do math at his or her grade level? And they just see tons of luxury issue views being touted by the left when they're trying to make ends meet and they're trying to help their kid and family be successful or even just get by in many cases.
Georgia Howe
That's a really interesting point about the priorities. You also mentioned the Democrats struggling to hone in on a message. Can you talk more about that?
Brent Buchanan
Yeah, so you've talked about the record support for Trump more support than he ever had before. What about the other side of the aisle though? We've seen reports of Democrats feeling rudderless, suffering record low support for them. What have you found?
John Bickley
Yeah, let's talk about the Democrats. What's going on there?
Brent Buchanan
They are in the doldrums to say the least. And it's all their own doing, because as I was mentioning, like they would rather focus on sexuality than they would the economy and have really radical views on it. And so they have earned this first off for themselves.
Georgia Howe
That's a really interesting point about the focus of the Democrats. You also mentioned the Democrats becoming less diverse as a party. Can you talk more about that?
Brent Buchanan
Yeah, so when you look at some of these, like I always like to look at data against some other pointed data. So how are the Democrats viewed versus how are the Republicans viewed, not just how are the Democrats viewed? Men are two to one unfavorable of Democrats. So Democrats are essentially buoyed by females. And when you dig further, they're buoyed by college educated females. So they're becoming less diverse as a party of who makes up their base and becoming more the party of the coastal elites and the big city elites.
John Bickley
That's a really interesting point about the demographics of the party. You also mentioned the Democrats' anti-billionaire message, particularly focusing on Musk as sort of the boogeyman. Do you think that will play for the party?
Brent Buchanan
It's class warfare, which has historically played well for the Democrats. The challenge is the number of people now within their constituency that that class warfare message worked with has dwindled because those folks, as we were talking about, you know, you've got the non-white, non-college educated voters, especially males moving to the Republican Party. They're not going to be voting for a Democrat. So their available pool of people to play this class warfare game with has shrunk.
Georgia Howe
That's a really interesting point about the demographics of the party. You also mentioned the executive orders and the unilateral action of the Trump administration. Do you feel that we have a window that's closing for congressional action here?
Brent Buchanan
Well, the first thing is we have to realize that most voters aren't watching the news constantly. So when they hear something or see something, they don't differentiate between the fact that Congress passed a law and Trump signed it or Trump signed an executive order or Trump just said something on Truth Social or randomly at a press conference. Like they do not delineate between any of those things.
John Bickley
That's a really interesting point about the public's perception of the executive branch. You also mentioned the discussions around the cuts to Medicaid and the communication about Doge in general. Do you think that's a concern for the Trump administration?
Brent Buchanan
I think the discussions around the cuts to Medicaid and this kind of in my mind goes to all the communication about Doge in general. We got to remember that this is dealing with people still. So to come at it cold or to appear cold in how we going about this cuts against our ability to do more of it.
Georgia Howe
That's a really interesting point about the communication strategy. You also mentioned the discussions around entitlement reform and the debt. Do you think that's an issue that needs to be addressed?
Brent Buchanan
Our debt is a greater threat, a more imminent threat to us. Even enemies like China, our debt is a greater threat, a more imminent threat to us. And nobody's talking about it. You know, we spent more on interest than we did our entire national defense. And we have the largest national defense budget by multiples of the second closest country on what they do in defense spending in a year.
John Bickley
That's a really interesting point about the debt. You also mentioned the discussions around DEI and the merit-based system. Do you think that's an issue that needs to be addressed?
Brent Buchanan
Well, if you ask, do you support or oppose diversity, equity, and inclusion, which is what DEI stands for, it has very high levels of support because who's going to say they're against any of those three things? But when you put it in terms of implementing DEI as a policy as opposed to a value system, means that instead of hiring people based on merit and based on their experience, we're going to say that your racial and gender or some other immutable characteristic is more important than what you have accomplished or what you're capable of doing when matched up with somebody else who could do the job.
Georgia Howe
That's a really interesting point about the DEI conversation. You also mentioned the crackdown on illegal immigration from the Trump administration. Do you think that's an issue that's resonating with the public?
Brent Buchanan
It is the item that gets the highest scoring on any poll that you see when voters are asked, do you approve or disapprove of the job that Trump is doing on and then they lay out the individual aspects as opposed to just job approval in general. And you start to get well above his job approval numbers when you ask about illegal immigration because that was front and center of his entire campaign.
John Bickley
That's a really interesting point about the public's perception of the immigration issue. You also mentioned the economic policies of the Trump administration. Do you think that's an issue that needs to be addressed?
Brent Buchanan
What we're seeing in our data and others is that it's not getting enough conversational attention. So voters are wanting it to be addressed or at least be spoken about. Tell us how things are going to cost as much or how my wages are going to be able to go up so I can make up for the gap difference between my wage and what things cost to just live now.
Georgia Howe
That's a really interesting point about the economic policies. You also mentioned the issue of inflation and the economy. Do you think that's an issue that needs to be addressed?
Brent Buchanan
Voters are a lot smarter than the media and sometimes politicians give them credit for. And they really just want to know that you're thinking about them and that you're trying to do something, even if the solution is not a quick fix.
John Bickley
That's a really interesting point about the public's perception of the economy. You also mentioned the issue of the debt. Do you think that's an issue that needs to be addressed?
Brent Buchanan
Our debt is a greater threat, a more imminent threat to us. Even enemies like China, our debt is a greater threat, a more imminent threat to us. And nobody's talking about it.
Georgia Howe
That's a really interesting point about the debt. Brent, thanks for talking with us today.
Brent Buchanan
Hey, great to be with y'all.
John Bickley
That was Signal Group's Brent Buchanan, and this has been a weekend edition of Morning Wire. Thanks for listening.