Main Topic: The discussion revolves around the introduction of complex topics like sexual orientation and gender identity in classrooms, particularly with younger children, and the potential consequences on their mental health.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Upbeat music fades out
Host (Georgia Howe)
The NFL is back, and FanDuel's got everything you need to play your game. From same-game parlays to live betting. Right now, new customers bet $5 and get $300 in bonus bets if you win. 21-plus in president select states. 18-plus in Kentucky and Wyoming. Must be first online real money waging. $5 deposit required. Bonus issued is non-withdrawable bonus bets that expire seven days after receipt. Restrictions apply. See full terms at FanDuel.com slash sportsbook. Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER.
Music transitions to a more serious tone
The largest teachers union in America is openly advocating for more discussion of sexual orientation and gender identity in classrooms with younger and younger children. But are children developmentally ready to understand these topics?
Host (John Bickley)
I'm Georgia Howe with Daily Wire editor-in-chief John Bickley. It's Sunday, July 23rd, and this is an extra edition of Morning Wire. Joining us to discuss is psychoanalyst and author Erica Komisar.
Erica Komisar
Thank you for having me.
Host (Georgia Howe)
Now, in your recent article for The Wall Street Journal, you wrote that a majority of children are not psychologically and emotionally ready to discuss or even understand the idea of gender identity and sexual orientation. In your opinion, at what age are children and or teens prepared to start talking about that or understanding ideas around gender and sex?
Erica Komisar
Well, certainly not before adolescence. And we know that adolescence starts at around nine now. So pre-adolescence, early adolescence is around nine. Adolescence ends at around 25. So under the age of nine, the idea of identity is not something children are meant to be thinking about developmentally. They meant to be learning, they meant to be experimenting and exploring their strengths and weaknesses, building competencies, feeling emotionally secure. But they're not meant to really think about these bigger questions of identity. And it's not until adolescence that kids really start to think about their sexual and gender identity. And even then, it's really on an individual basis, meaning even some young adolescents really struggle to deal with some of these bigger questions.
Host (John Bickley)
Now, the National Education Association, that's the largest U.S. teachers union, they recommend asking preschoolers about their preferred pronouns. And the NEA's Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender, Queer Plus Caucus recommends that elementary school children read books with titles such as My Princess Boy, Jacob's dress. This seems like a very coordinated push for this kind of content for young kids, especially from the education establishment. Why do you believe there's a push by adults to introduce these complex topics to young people?
Erica Komisar
I think it's a little bit of tyranny of the minority over the majority. I think these issues are important and we need to be compassionate about them. But I think these issues should be taught at home. And so if a gay couple or a queer couple want to educate their own child, then they should be doing that at home. But to bring it into the schools where the majority of children are not ready for this kind of information and are not yet asking these questions.
Host (John Bickley)
Now, is this something that you see broadly in your field with other therapists, or would you say that it's a minority that are on board with this? I mean, I can't speak for the majority or minority of my profession.
Erica Komisar
What I can tell you is amongst my colleagues, we discuss these issues very openly, but that many therapists are afraid to come out with opinions about it. And if you know my background and what I write about, I've not historically been afraid to mention very difficult topics that are truthful topics. But I think there's a lot of therapists that believe this, but won't talk about it publicly.
Host (Georgia Howe)
Now, you mentioned you are a practicing psychoanalyst, and you've said in the past that you only write about issues that you actually see in your practice. What are you seeing that prompted you to give this warning? Are you seeing kids struggling with questions of sex and gender?
Erica Komisar
Absolutely. And very young children, mostly adolescents that I see, but also I do a lot of parent guidance for younger children and children are coming home and really developing anxiety as if they're supposed to answer these big questions that they're not even asking yet. And then parents are having to, I would say, sort of clean up the mess that the schools are starting for a lot of these younger children.
Host (John Bickley)
In my practice with adolescents, yes, I see adolescents and young adults who come in and are having panic attacks, are feeling a terrific amount of anxiety as if they're not asking the right questions. Am I supposed to be gay? Am I supposed to be queer? All my friends are saying they're queer. Is there something wrong with me that I'm not?
Erica Komisar
I would say it's become rather trendy for young people to identify as a group with their peer groups by saying they're queer, rather than really feeling it organically.
Host (John Bickley)
Now how many years have you been in practice and what kind of trends have you seen if any relating to gender confusion?
Erica Komisar
So I've been in practice for about 35 years. And yes, I've seen a lot of trends and they're not necessarily good trends. So each of the books I written has been about negative trends, which is why we have this mental health epidemic. I mean, certainly this transgender issue is not causing the mental health epidemic, but this issue of gender and sexual confusion is certainly a piece of that puzzle.
Host (Georgia Howe)
I would say this, in trying to be sensitive to and compassionate towards children who are seriously suffering from these issues. We have become incredibly insensitive towards the majority of children who are not facing these issues and their parents. And so there has to be a way to be compassionate towards the individual child. And I know many schools are, and charter schools are working with this and learning to be compassionate with individual children without having to overwhelm the majority of children.
Host (John Bickley)
So what would you suggest to parents if their child does come home expressing gender confusion? What should a parent do in that case?
Erica Komisar
Listen, ask good questions, be a really good non-judgmental listener. And as part of listening, it's important to ask open-ended questions without judgment and to reflect their feelings. So if they seem upset to say, I can see that you're upset about this. Tell me more. Or, you know, I can see you're sad that nobody seems to understand you at school. You know, how are you feeling? So being compassionate to your own child, showing empathy, mirroring and reflecting their feelings, being a great listener, and then waiting for more information. You know, parents don't need to react intensely to this. They just need to be really, really good listeners and track it, follow it and see where it goes.
Host (Georgia Howe)
All right, well Erica thanks so much for making time for us today.
Erica Komisar
Thank you for having me.
Host (John Bickley)
That was psychoanalyst and author Erica Komisar and this has been an extra edition of Morning Wire.