Main Topic: The podcast episode discusses the issue of transition regret among young people who have undergone gender-affirming surgeries and treatments. The episode features two individuals, Abel and Laura, who share their personal stories of detransitioning and the challenges they faced.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Theme music fades out
Georgia Howe
Welcome to Morning Wire, I'm Georgia Howe.
John Bickley
And I'm John Bickley, Editor-in-Chief of Daily Wire.
Georgia Howe
It's June 18th, and this is a Sunday edition of Morning Wire. Joining us to discuss the issue of transition regret is Daily Wire reporter Amanda Prestigiacomo.
Amanda Prestigiacomo
Hey, Georgia.
Georgia Howe
So Amanda, before we hear directly from Abel and Laura, do we know what percentage of people who go through with medical transition eventually decide they want to detransition?
Amanda Prestigiacomo
Well, this is a really new phenomenon, especially on the scale we're seeing it today. So large long-term studies don't exist yet. We do know that the number of hospitals and child gender clinics offering puberty blockers and surgeries for minors and young adults has just skyrocketed over this past decade. There are now more than 100 gender clinics for children, and some 300,000 minors now identify as transgender.
Georgia Howe
As far as desisting from this gender confusion, we do have research that shows that up to 88% of children with these feelings stop having them by adulthood.
Amanda Prestigiacomo
While there are some individuals who experience persistent gender dysphoria for a lifetime, the data suggests they are a very small subset. When it comes to young people post-cuberty blockers, hormones, and surgery, there is this odd consensus echoed in the media that hardly anyone regrets this medical intervention. That's not really true.
Georgia Howe
Again, the mass embrace of this medical intervention for kids and young people is fairly unique, so long-term studies are just not there. Most of the studies cited about regret just track patients three months post-op.
Amanda Prestigiacomo
We don't yet have data on how these treatments affect people as they move through different phases of life. For example, when young people reach the age where they might want to have children. That said, there are a few high-profile detransitioners speaking out about their experiences and even suing hospitals.
Georgia Howe
Right. Now, let's get to that. You spoke with two people who've experienced this kind of regret. What did they share about their experience?
Amanda Prestigiacomo
Yeah, that's right. One of those people is a young man named Abel. He experienced gender confusion as a child and then suffered a sexual trauma that intensified his desire to leave his body.
Georgia Howe
[pauses] Can you tell us more about Abel's story?
Amanda Prestigiacomo
Abel told me he was a shy kid who felt like he didn't fit into what he viewed as Mexican masculinity. He stumbled upon this idea of transgenderism on YouTube when he was in middle school and started to think that's what he might be.
Georgia Howe
[pauses] And what was his experience with the medical establishment?
Amanda Prestigiacomo
He waited until right after high school to see a therapist, and on his very first visit, which didn't even last an hour, the therapist told him he was indeed a transgender woman and approved him for a medical transition.
Georgia Howe
[pauses] That's quite a story. And what about the surgery itself?
Amanda Prestigiacomo
Abel had hormone treatments and went under the knife for breast implants. He stopped short, though, of facial surgery and so-called bottom surgery. That's when a surgeon removes healthy testicles and uses skin from a male's penis to try to create the appearance of a vagina.
Georgia Howe
[pauses] And did Abel try to reverse these treatments?
Amanda Prestigiacomo
Yeah, he did. He says he got a lot of pushback from the medical establishment, though, when he brought up detransitioning. This was a completely different experience than what he encountered when he said he might be transgender.
Georgia Howe
[pauses] And what about Laura's story?
Amanda Prestigiacomo
Yeah, that's right. One of those people is a young woman named Laura. She first started feeling distress around her body at age 15, and it was also around that time that she came across the idea of transgenderism on Tumblr.
Georgia Howe
[pauses] And what was her experience with the medical establishment?
Amanda Prestigiacomo
Laura told me she had undiagnosed complex PTSD from childhood abuse, a hormonal disorder called polycystic ovarian syndrome, and she's on the autism spectrum.
Georgia Howe
[pauses] And what was her experience with hormone treatments and surgery?
Amanda Prestigiacomo
Laura came out as transgender as a teenager and searched without any luck for medical help to deal with her depression. Instead, she ended up on testosterone and soon after had gender surgery.
Georgia Howe
[pauses] And did she experience any complications from the surgery?
Amanda Prestigiacomo
Unfortunately, there was a complication in Laura's surgery. She had to have a revision surgery to try to fix the issue. Also, one of her incision scars opened up and it had to be sewn back shut, creating an even larger scar.
Georgia Howe
[pauses] And what about Laura's experience with detransitioning?
Amanda Prestigiacomo
Despite the complications, Laura said she felt moments of contentment, which she now deems a placebo effect. And that didn't last long. By the time she was 22 years old, Laura realized she was still suffering from the same exact problems before, which were now compounded, and she decided to detransition.
Georgia Howe
[pauses] And what about the advice that Laura and Abel would give to someone who's feeling gender confusion and is thinking about gender medical treatment?
Amanda Prestigiacomo
Laura is a very vocal advocate of complete bans for transition procedures for minors, both medical and social, because children are not developed. They do not have the brains or bodies to be able to make long-term decisions about their reproductive and sexual health.
Georgia Howe
[pauses] And what about Abel's advice?
Amanda Prestigiacomo
Abel would tell anyone who wants a transition that the transition will not save them. It would actually destroy their lives. Actually take a step back and think about this for a while. Think about the actual negative side effects that nobody will tell you.
Georgia Howe
[pauses] Amanda, thanks for reporting.
Amanda Prestigiacomo
Thanks for having me.
Georgia Howe
That was Daily Wire reporter Amanda Prestigiacomo. And this has been a Sunday edition of Morning Wire.
John Bickley
[pauses] Thanks for listening to Morning Wire.
Georgia Howe
[pauses] If you want to learn more about the documentary "No Way Back: The Reality of Gender Affirming Care", you can visit NoWayBackFilm.com.
John Bickley
[pauses] And don't forget to follow us on Twitter at @MorningWire.
Georgia Howe
[pauses] Thanks for listening to Morning Wire.
John Bickley
[pauses] And we'll see you tomorrow.
Theme music fades in