Main Topic: The podcast episode covers several topics, including a judge's decision to drop charges against former President Donald Trump in a Georgia election interference case, the UK's ban on puberty blockers for children, and two California bills that would grant more benefits to illegal immigrants.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Theme music fades out
Host (Georgia Howe)
The NFL is back, and FanDuel's got everything you need to play your game. From same-game parlays to live betting. Right now, new customers bet $5 and get $300 in bonus bets if you win. 21-plus in president select states. 18-plus in Kentucky and Wyoming. Must be first online real money waging. $5 deposit required. Bonus issued is non-withdrawable bonus bets that expire seven days after receipt. Restrictions apply. See full terms at FanDuel.com slash sportsbook. Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER.
Short pause
A Fulton County judge drops several charges against former President Trump in his Georgia election interference case. These, I think, are among the most offensive counts in the indictment in terms of constitutional law. Why did the judge throw out the counts and what does it mean for the case? I'm Georgia Howe and John's on vacation this week. It's Thursday, March 14th, and this is Morning Wire.
Short pause
The UK bans the use of puberty blockers for children. What led to the reversal? And will U.S. medical bodies follow suit? And two California bills would grant more benefits to illegal immigrants. What's been the response from lawmakers in the Golden State? It's unconscionable, and I think they're confused about who they represent. They represent the citizens of the state of California. They don't represent the citizens of other countries.
Short pause
Thanks for waking up with Morning Wire. Stay tuned. We have the news you need to know.
Short pause
A judge in Georgia has dropped six charges in a sweeping election interference case against former President Donald Trump and his co-defendants.
Guest (Amanda Prestigiacomo)
So, a surprise development in this case that was brought by Fulton County DA Fonnie Willis. First off, what charges did the judge dismiss?
Host (Georgia Howe)
So, Judge Scott McAfee has dismissed a total of six charges, three of which are against Trump. All of the dismissed charges concern allegations that Trump and his allies asked Georgia officials to break their oaths of office.
Guest (Amanda Prestigiacomo)
One of the charges affecting Trump is connected to a phone call he made to the Georgia Secretary of State about needing around 11,000 votes to flip the seat in 2020. In that call, Trump contended that he had fairly won the state and urged the secretary to identify the corrupt ballots.
Host (Georgia Howe)
Now, Trump co-defendants also saw charges dropped, including three of the 13 against Rudy Giuliani and one of the two counts against former Trump Chief of Staff Mark Meadows. Trump is still facing 10 other counts.
Guest (Amanda Prestigiacomo)
Now, why were the charges dropped? Basically, Fannie Willis' office lacked specificity in these charges. The judge found that the facts were missing. And if those are missing, it's nearly impossible for the defendants to try to offer a defense.
Host (Georgia Howe)
Here's a quote from McAfee. They do not give the defendants enough information to prepare their defenses intelligently, as the defendants could have violated the Constitution's and thus the statute in dozens, if not hundreds, of distinct ways.
Guest (Amanda Prestigiacomo)
So what does this mean for Trump? Well, notably McAfee left intact the highly controversial RICO Act charge. So that will stand on its own.
Host (Georgia Howe)
However former federal prosecutor Andy McCarthy told Morningwire that he always found that count particularly weak.
Guest (Amanda Prestigiacomo)
My position from the beginning has been that this is not a RICO. I mean, basically, this is a very confused case that the district attorney has brought. And her big problem is that there's no overarching conspiracy offense. Trying to overturn an election is not a crime. In fact, every state in the United States has a legal process by which you can challenge election results. So you can't have a conspiracy to do something that's legal.
Host (Georgia Howe)
Now, Willis' team, in an effort to try and reinstate those dropped charges, she could try for a superseding indictment. That's when prosecutors go back to the grand jury and change the original indictment. That would further delay the trial.
Guest (Amanda Prestigiacomo)
And Democrats really don't want further delays in any of these cases against Trump. They want convictions before the 2024 election.
Host (Georgia Howe)
Now, same case, but a totally separate issue. Judge McAfee is expected to make a ruling this week about the potential disqualification of Willis and her office over Willis's alleged misconduct.
Guest (Amanda Prestigiacomo)
You know, it remains unclear. This will likely come down to McAfee using the standard of an appearance of a conflict versus an actual conflict with Willis and special prosecutor Nathan Wade, with whom she had an affair.
Host (Georgia Howe)
The latter of those two would be a higher bar to clear.
Guest (Amanda Prestigiacomo)
McCarthy told us in his opinion, Willis and Wade should clearly be disqualified. I personally believe that they should be disqualified, both on conflict of interest grounds and because I think they've engaged in what looks to me like false information being provided to the court.
Host (Georgia Howe)
Certainly, if the standard is, is there an appearance of impropriety in connection with their continued participation in the case, I think that's been satisfied.
Guest (Amanda Prestigiacomo)
Now, switching gears to another criminal case against Trump, the former president is expected at a hearing in Florida later today over alleged mishandling of classified documents.
Host (Georgia Howe)
What's the status there?
Guest (Amanda Prestigiacomo)
Right. So Trump is at the very least trying to have that case delayed, if not outright dismissed.
Host (Georgia Howe)
There's been a lot more attention around this case recently, and this comes in light of Robert Hurd testifying before Congress on Tuesday about his findings into President Biden's apparent mishandling of classified documents.
Guest (Amanda Prestigiacomo)
Hurd declined to seek charges against Biden while Trump is facing this case from Jack Smith and Biden's DOJ.
Host (Georgia Howe)
We asked McCarthy about that contrast, and here's what he told us.
Guest (Amanda Prestigiacomo)
If his analysis is that it's appropriate to prosecute Trump, but not prosecute Biden because Trump obstructed the investigation and Biden didn't, that would be an argument for charging Trump with obstruction and not charging Biden.
Host (Georgia Howe)
But as far as the classified information counts are concerned, those offenses, they should be treated the same way across the board.
Guest (Amanda Prestigiacomo)
And if Biden's not going to be prosecuted, then Trump shouldn't be prosecuted on them.
Host (Georgia Howe)
Well, that perceived double standard has kind of become Trump's calling card in his reelection campaign.
Guest (Amanda Prestigiacomo)
Amanda, thanks for reporting.
Host (Georgia Howe)
You're welcome.
Short pause
If you're looking around at your business and seeing inefficiency, you should know these numbers. 37,000. The number of businesses that have upgraded to the number one cloud financial system, NetSuite by Oracle.
Guest (NetSuite): 25. NetSuite just turned 25. That's 25 years of helping businesses streamline their finances and reduce costs. One. Because your unique business deserves a custom solution, and that's NetSuite.
Learn more when you download NetSuite's popular KPI checklist absolutely free at netsuite slash morningwire That netsuite slash morningwire
Short pause
The UK National Health Service has announced that gender clinics will no longer be allowed to prescribe puberty blockers to children.
Guest (Megan Basham)
So, Megan, it seems like Europe is trending away from medical transition for minors. What led to the decision to end them altogether in the UK?
Host (Georgia Howe)
So in 2020, England's largest gender care clinic, Tavistock, came under fire after former staff said it was pushing blockers and cross-sex hormones onto gender dysphoric kids too quickly.
Guest (Megan Basham)
Some former patients who had been given these treatments sued. Then after that, inspectors gave the clinic an inadequate rating. And then well-known British pediatrician Dr. Hilary Kast reviewed the clinic's care and returned a really damning report.
Host (Georgia Howe)
She said Tavistock needed to offer a fundamentally different model of care.
Guest (Megan Basham)
So at that point, the clinic was then closed, and that prompted an independent NHS review of blockers and hormones for anyone under 18.
Host (Georgia Howe)
This decision is a result of that review.
Guest (Megan Basham)
So in a statement released Tuesday, the NHS said this, there is not enough evidence to support the safety or clinical effectiveness of puberty blockers to make the treatment routinely available at this time.
Host (Georgia Howe)
So NHS doctors will now only be able to give blockers to minors for research purposes, meaning if a child is enrolled in a clinical study, they may be given them, but that will be the only allowance.
Guest (Megan Basham)
So the British government said it welcomes this landmark decision because they believe this move ensures treatment is grounded in evidence and is in the, quote, best interests of the child.
Host (Georgia Howe)
Now, people here in the U.S. are pretty passionate about these treatments. What's the response been in Europe to the ban?
Guest (Megan Basham)
You know, as you might expect, LGBT activists are expressing a lot of unhappiness about it.
Host (Georgia Howe)
To give you just one example, the UK-based trans advocacy organization, Mermaids, said that trans youth need access to these kind of treatments in order to, quote, live happy and healthy lives.
Guest (Megan Basham)
And they said that they're going to continue to fight for kids who they say need them to have access to blockers.
Host (Georgia Howe)
Now, what about the AMA or the American Academy of Pediatrics? Where do they stand on this?
Guest (Megan Basham)
So far, both groups have resolutely opposed any legislation to limit blockers, hormones, and even surgeries for children, both at the national and state level.
Host (Georgia Howe)
And they have routinely cited the World Professional Association for Transgender Health, or WPATH as it's known, as a medical authority informing their positions.
Guest (Megan Basham)
But that panel has become increasingly controversial.
Host (Georgia Howe)
Just last week, independent journalist Michael Schellenberger obtained over 240 pages of internal WPATH files, as well as a number of videos from internal Zoom meetings.
Guest (Megan Basham)
Well, those meetings show that WPATH medical professionals who provide this treatment to minors know that they're not getting informed consent from their patients.
Host (Georgia Howe)
In some of these videos and emails, the doctors state that children and their parents aren't being warned about potential long-term harm, like loss of bone density or normal sexual function, before they make their decisions.
Guest (Megan Basham)
In one video in particular, an endocrinologist expresses doubt that some of his patients understand their decisions because he says, quoting, they haven't even had biology in high school yet.
Host (Georgia Howe)
And then another email chain discusses continuing to give cross-sex hormones to a patient the doctor suspects might be schizophrenic.
Guest (Megan Basham)
In some emails, WPATH members acknowledge cross-sex hormones cause liver tumors and cancer, and they acknowledge that genital surgeries are being done on minors.
Host (Georgia Howe)
So this was Schellenberger telling NewsNation about what he found.
Guest (Megan Basham)
I think what's so significant here is that we have WPATH members, practitioners, and leaders acknowledging that they not getting informed consent from the children adolescents and vulnerable adults for whom these procedures are on whom they being performed.
Host (Georgia Howe)
That extremely significant. That a breach of basic medical ethics. It's right up there with do no harm is that the people that are getting these treatments must understand what's happening to them.
Guest (Megan Basham)
And the files show very clearly that's not what's happening.
Host (Georgia Howe)
Schellenberger went on to say that these documents show that WPATH is not using evidence-based standards.
Guest (Megan Basham)
So his reporting will likely continue to bolster efforts to end this kind of practice in GOP-led states, but it does remain to be seen if it's going to have any impact in blue states or at the national level.
Host (Georgia Howe)
Well, anytime you make permanent changes, especially to a child's body, you really need complete certainty.
Guest (Megan Basham)
Megan, thanks for reporting.
Host (Georgia Howe)
Anytime.
Short pause
A California bill that would provide taxpayer-funded legal aid to illegal immigrants convicted of violent felonies is being pulled from consideration just one day before it was set to be discussed by lawmakers.
Guest (Ash Short)
So Ash, what can you tell us about this bill's specifics?
Host (Georgia Howe)
So Bill AB 2031 would allow nonprofits to use taxpayer dollars to provide legal services for illegal immigrants convicted of violent crimes.
Guest (Ash Short)
Existing California law actually prohibits the use of state grant money to provide legal services to those illegal immigrants who've been convicted of or who are currently appealing a conviction for a violent or serious felony.
Host (Georgia Howe)
AB 2031 would remove that prohibition.
Guest (Ash Short)
The bill would also expand the abilities of nonprofits to use taxpayer dollars to defend illegal immigrants from deportation, which would include those violent felons.
Host (Georgia Howe)
So why is the bill being pulled?
Guest (Ash Short)
We don't have an official answer, but California Assemblyman Bill Assailes stated he received a fair amount of backlash from constituents.
Host (Georgia Howe)
Here's what he had to say about the bill during an appearance on Stinchfield tonight.
Guest (Ash Short)
They want to pay the legal fees to help them fight deportation after they're convicted of a crime, the illegal immigrants. This is the stuff that's coming out of the state of California.
Host (Georgia Howe)
This is going to take tax dollars to defend criminal illegal immigrants in deportation proceedings.
Guest (Ash Short)
So we can have what more victims like Kate Steinle, who was killed in San Francisco, or the nursing student in Georgia?
Host (Georgia Howe)
Why? Why would we do this?
Guest (Ash Short)
Assaili has also introduced a bill to repeal funding for free health care for illegal immigrants.
Host (Georgia Howe)
Illegal immigrants in California can currently gain access to different government-funded medical insurance, but Assaili's bill would limit access to U.S. citizens.
Guest (Ash Short)
Now, there's also another bill in California that would expand taxpayer services for illegal immigrants.
Host (Georgia Howe)
Tell us about AB 1840.
Guest (Ash Short)
Right. So that bill would allow illegal immigrants to also qualify for the state's first-time home buying loan program.
Host (Georgia Howe)
The first-time home buyer program debuted in March of last year and quickly ran out of the $300 million it was granted to provide qualified first-time buyers with down payments.
Guest (Ash Short)
The program is set to reopen applications this April and Democrat Assemblyman Joaquin Arambula introduced a bill that would clarify that the program is open to illegal immigrants in addition to citizens.
Host (Georgia Howe)
It took less than a month for the program to run out of funding when it was limited to U.S. citizens expanding the pool of potential applicants would strain those resources even further.
Guest (Ash Short)
Here's what Assaylee said about that bill.
Host (Georgia Howe)
What you're doing is by picking an illegal immigrant to have that down payment program, they're taking it away from a California American citizen to have that opportunity.
Guest (Ash Short)
We can't have that.
Host (Georgia Howe)
Well, speaking from experience, it is very hard to stay afloat as a middle-class person in California.
Guest (Ash Short)
So I understand some of this backlash.
Host (Georgia Howe)
Ash, thanks for reporting.
Guest (Ash Short)
You're welcome.
Short pause
Host (Georgia Howe)
That was Daily Wire senior editor, Ash Short. Thanks for waking up with us. We'll be back later this afternoon with more news you need to know.