Main Topic: The latest developments in Donald Trump's legal battles, specifically the denial of his presidential immunity claim by a U.S. appeals court and the potential implications for his upcoming trial.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Sound of a news theme music fading out
John Bickley
Good morning, I'm John Bickley, editor-in-chief of the Daily Wire, and this is an extra edition of Morning Wire.
Georgia Howe
And I'm Georgia Howe, co-host of Morning Wire. Welcome to our show.
John Bickley
Today, we're discussing the latest development in former President Trump's legal battles. A federal appeals court has denied his claim of presidential immunity. Joining us to break down this decision and what comes next is former federal prosecutor Andy McCarthy.
Andy McCarthy
Thank you for having me on the show.
John Bickley
So, a U.S. appeals court denied Trump's presidential immunity claim this week. Can you break down this decision and what you think of this ruling constitutionally?
Andy McCarthy
If there was a way to depart or carve this new ground, and it would be new ground to find that a president had immunity from federal criminal prosecution, I really think that has to be done by the Supreme Court. Whether I'm right or wrong about that, the 57-page ruling by the court is very thorough. I think it's mostly compelling.
Georgia Howe
That's a great point. The court did recognize that there is an ambit of presidential responsibility that can be reviewed by the courts, and that is the president's discretionary actions as president, which they distinguish from ministerial actions.
Andy McCarthy
That's right. So to be a little less abstract about that, we all know the president has pardon power. The president can issue a terrible pardon, one that's not got any justification in rationality, one that seems like it's obviously based on favoritism rather than merit. Nevertheless, there is no way that any court could review a pardon because that is within the discretionary authority of the president under the Constitution.
John Bickley
Now, you've made the distinction about whether or not he's acting to fulfill his duties as an elected official there. Is there constitutional immunity when carrying out the duties of your elected position?
Andy McCarthy
Yeah, that actually is, I think, the most interesting part of the court's decision today, because they do recognize going back to Chief Justice Marshall's observations in Marbury versus Madison they do recognize that there is an ambit of presidential responsibility that can be reviewed by the courts, and that is the president's discretionary actions as president, which they distinguish from ministerial actions.
Georgia Howe
What about Trump's double jeopardy claim? What was the panel's rationale for dismissing that?
Andy McCarthy
I've always thought that was the weakest claim that Trump had. The strongest claim I thought Trump had was the policy that if you don't give a president immunity, he's got to worry, especially if we now have politicized prosecutions. He has to worry that the actions he takes as president, some of which are going to be very edgy actions, could subject him to criminal prosecution if a new administration of the opposition party comes in and decides they want to investigate him, as happened here.
John Bickley
Now, Trump has already issued a statement and says he respectfully disagrees with the ruling and that he will appeal. What happens next?
Andy McCarthy
Well, this is very interesting because I think, You know, obviously what Trump is trying to do more than anything else is delay things so he can push it beyond election day because if he gets elected as president, then his Justice Department at that point can fire Jack Smith, dismiss the indictment. If the court gave him a hard time about that, he could always pardon himself. But he could basically end this case if it doesn't get tried before the election, if he wins the election.
Georgia Howe
So what's the timeline looking like for this case?
Andy McCarthy
Well, see, I don't think you can answer that question just in the context of the immunity litigation, because the wild card here or the other moving part that has to be considered is the fact that in a case where Trump is not a party, but one that's of immense importance to him, the Supreme Court has agreed to hear the challenge to the obstruction statute. That's been brought by a number of the defendants in the Capitol riot cases.
John Bickley
And what does that mean for the timeline of this case?
Andy McCarthy
I don't really see how Judge Chutkin could start trial until she gets the guidance from the Supreme Court on how to construe the obstruction statute. So to my mind, no matter what happens with the immunity, and I frankly wouldn't be surprised if the Supreme Court decided not to hear the immunity case and just let the D.C. Circuit's ruling stand. The real important thing to Trump at this point is the obstruction case, and we really won't be able to tell when this case can get scheduled until the court decides what to do with that case.
Georgia Howe
And what about the other cases involving Trump, like the Manhattan DA's case and the Fulton County RICO case?
Andy McCarthy
Well, the next interesting question, I think, is we now know that the Washington federal election interference case, the case we've been talking about, the case where Trump raised this immunity issue. We now know that that had a trial date of March 4th, but the court has taken that off the calendar and we don't know when the case can be tried. That's important because the case brought by the Manhattan District Attorney, Alvin Bragg, when he first brought that case about a year ago, the judge assigned to it gave it a trial date of March 25th.
John Bickley
And what about the federal documents case at Mar-a-Lago?
Andy McCarthy
That case is not going to get to trial, I don't believe, prior to election day because it comes under what's known as the Classified Information Procedures Act, where you have to work out all the admissibility issues regarding classified information prior to trial. Those cases are very, very hard to get to trial. They're complex.
Georgia Howe
Well, Andy, thank you so much for joining us today to break down this complex decision and what it means for Trump's legal battles.
Andy McCarthy
Thank you for having me on the show.
John Bickley
And that's all for today's extra edition of Morning Wire. Thanks for joining us.
Georgia Howe
And don't forget to subscribe to our podcast for daily coverage of the latest developments in politics, culture, education, sports, and more.
John Bickley
And if you want to get the facts first on the news you need to know, wake up with Morning Wire every day.
Sound of a news theme music fading in