Main Topic: The debate over continued funding for Ukraine's war effort and its implications for the United States.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Theme music fades out
John Bickley
Good morning, and welcome to Morning Wire. I'm John Bickley, Editor-in-Chief of The Daily Wire, and I'm here with my co-host Georgia Howe.
Georgia Howe
Good morning, John. Today, we're discussing the ongoing debate over whether the U.S. should continue sending aid to Ukraine in their fight against Russia.
John Bickley
That's right, Georgia. We'll be hearing from two leading voices on the topic, Ohio Senator J.D. Vance and National Review Editor-in-Chief Rich Lowry.
Short pause
Georgia Howe
Let's dive right in. Cabot Phillips, our senior editor, spoke with both Senator Vance and Mr. Lowry about the issue. Cabot, thanks for reporting.
Cabot Phillips
Thanks, Georgia. I interviewed two leading voices on the topic, one who supports continued aid to Ukraine and one who is staunchly opposed.
John Bickley
That's right. Let's start with the case for continued aid. Mr. Lowry, can you give us a brief elevator pitch for why the U.S. should continue funding Ukraine?
Rich Lowry
Well, Ukraine was attacked by Russia, an adversary of the United States that hates the United States, hates the West, wants to topple the U.S. and Western-supported order, and ultimately is a threat to the rest of Europe and potentially frontline NATO states. So it makes sense to try to stop them in their tracks to the extent we can in the far reaches of eastern Ukraine.
Short pause
Cabot Phillips
Senator Vance, you've argued that we can no longer afford to continue Ukraine aid. Can you explain your reasoning?
J.D. Vance
Yeah, so two years ago, a lot of Americans probably couldn't locate Ukraine on a map, but that all changed once Vladimir Putin invaded the eastern European state, launching a bloody war that's resulted in hundreds of thousands of deaths, and now a bitter debate at home over the role America should play in supporting Ukraine.
Short pause
Cabot Phillips
While the exact amounts differ based on what you consider foreign aid, to this point, Congress and the Biden administration have allocated anywhere from $75 to $115 billion towards the Ukrainian war effort.
J.D. Vance
That's everything from ammunition and weapons to economic stimulus. Now, early on in the conflict, there really wasn't much debate over whether the U.S. should come to the aid of Ukraine. But as this conflict has dragged on and turned into a war of attrition, with little ground being gained by either side, we've seen growing disagreements over just how long America can or should stay involved.
Short pause
Cabot Phillips
With that in mind, I spoke with two leading voices from each side of the debate. To kick things off, I asked each man to give a brief elevator pitch for their side. Here's Lowry to start.
Rich Lowry
Well, Ukraine was attacked by Russia, an adversary of the United States that hates the United States, hates the West, wants to topple the U.S. and Western-supported order, and ultimately is a threat to the rest of Europe and potentially frontline NATO states. So it makes sense to try to stop them in their tracks to the extent we can in the far reaches of eastern Ukraine.
Short pause
Cabot Phillips
As Lowry sees it, much of the hesitance from American voters and lawmakers to support funding stems from the prolonged wars in Iraq and Afghanistan.
Rich Lowry
I think the crucial background here is the failure of the Iraq war and the difficulties of the Iraq war, which I think have created kind of on a delayed fuse a real skepticism about any involvement overseas.
Short pause
Cabot Phillips
And for me, this seems misguided because we don't have any troops in Ukraine. All we're doing is funding an ally, which is really the ideal situation.
Rich Lowry
If you can fund a proxy force that directly fighting an enemy of yours, it doesn't get better than that. And this is a very traditional Anglo approach. The default has been finding allies and funding them so they can do the fight on the continent of Europe without us.
Short pause
Cabot Phillips
According to Senator Vance, there are two main problems with continued aid to Ukraine. First, he says it depletes our own military stockpiles, making us not only more vulnerable in a potential conflict with China, but also less able to arm other allies like Taiwan or Israel.
J.D. Vance
Really, for me, it's a question of focus. We have to sort of figure out how to respond in a world of scarce resources. If you look at some of the critical weapon systems that we would need to deter, for example, an invasion by the Chinese of Taiwan, there is a lot of overlap, not just between the weapon systems themselves, but also between the supply chain and components of those weapon systems.
Short pause
Cabot Phillips
Now, the counterargument that I hear from this, from sort of good faith advocates of further funding in Ukraine is, well, America is the largest economy in the world, and we can walk and chew gum at the same time.
J.D. Vance
And I think that that fundamentally misunderstands where we actually are as a country. We don't produce enough of the weapons that we need to support both a Ukrainian war, but also potential contingency in East Asia or anywhere else.
Short pause
Cabot Phillips
One of the main arguments we hear from those who support continued aid is that without it, Putin will seize the country and potentially invade other allies in Eastern Europe.
Rich Lowry
Well, the Russians will win the war in some form if they break through Ukrainian lines and sweep towards Kiev. I'm not sure whether they'll actually be able to take Kiev. That would require street by street, house by house fighting.
Short pause
Cabot Phillips
But they'll certainly be in a position to impose a punitive peace on Ukraine to make it a failed state and be in a position potentially to threaten other NATO states.
Rich Lowry
If Ukraine comes under de facto Russian control, you get an enormous multiplication of the border between Russia and NATO, with Russia presumably being emboldened by this victory, by the West's failure of nerve at the end.
Short pause
Cabot Phillips
You know, just quitting after two years when there are no U forces or Western forces directly involved would be an extraordinary sign of weakness and lack of will.
Rich Lowry
And bad things would come of it. At the very least, we would have to pour more resources into Europe.
Short pause
Cabot Phillips
For his part, here's what Senator Vance had to say when I asked if he thought Vladimir Putin was testing the West to see how we'd respond if he invaded one of our non-NATO allies.
J.D. Vance
So I think he is testing the West, but I guess my question is, is he testing the West in terms of our resolve or is he testing the West in terms of our stupidity?
Short pause
Cabot Phillips
And I'd make the sort of same question when it comes to Xi. If you think about this calculus from China's perspective, a lot of my neoconservative friends will say, well, if we abandon Ukraine, we will send a signal to the Chinese that they can do whatever they want to and American resolve will be weaker.
J.D. Vance
And my response is, maybe what the Chinese are looking for is not our resolve, but our actual capabilities. And if we throw every weapon system that we have at Ukraine and we don't have anything left over for Taiwan, yeah, they've tested us and we failed the test by sending all of our weapons to a conflict they don't really care about.
Short pause
Cabot Phillips
Another key element of this debate is just what sort of impact U.S. funding in Ukraine has on the Russian military.
Rich Lowry
Supporters of aid say it's a good investment because the war has drained Putin of valuable resources and also weakened his ability to threaten the West.
Short pause
Cabot Phillips
But Vance and others argue the conflict has had the exact opposite effect and forced Russia to expand their military production and invest more in their infrastructure, which would actually make them more formidable.
J.D. Vance
I'm not even sure that I buy this argument on its own face. In other words, if we could support the Ukrainians indefinitely, I don't think degrading Russia's military capabilities is the reason to do it because we failed to do that.
Short pause
Cabot Phillips
They're spending, I believe, about 6% of their GDP on defense. They have massively mobilized in both manpower and weapons manufacturing.
J.D. Vance
The Russian army actually is better today than it was two years ago. And I don't think anybody would dispute that.
Short pause
Cabot Phillips
And if we want Russia to be weaker militarily than stronger, then we should be trying to get them out of this weird doom loop where their entire economy is geared towards defense.
Rich Lowry
Because we don't want the Russians making 10 times the artillery that we make. That means that we either have to ramp up our own production or we're going to be much weaker relative to Russia.
Short pause
Cabot Phillips
While Lowry did agree that Russia's military has grown stronger since the war began, he says that's no argument for cutting off aid to Ukraine.
Rich Lowry
Well, I think that's true, but this is the case in all military conflicts. People learn from their mistakes and try to produce more and gain advantages.
Short pause
Cabot Phillips
But let's think about that argument. What would be the alternative? That we just let an inferior Russian military win at the outset? Would that really be better for our interests?
Rich Lowry
So that one doesn't make a lot of sense to me.
Short pause
Cabot Phillips
Now, here's what Lowry had to say about the claim that America should not continue funding Ukraine because there does not appear to be an end in sight to the war.
Rich Lowry
Well, it's true that there's no end in sight. There's usually not a clear end in sight in most wars. You know, you open up the door and all is darkness and there you go.
Short pause
Cabot Phillips
But eventually there'll be exhaustion. There'll be exhaustion on both sides. Although Russia has more resources, its resources aren't unlimited either.
Rich Lowry
And usually when you're on offense, I don't know, you need like a three to one advantage. These formulas don't always hold, but that's a basic idea.
Short pause
Cabot Phillips
So at some point they're going to run out of gas themselves. So what you do hope to do is frustrate them as much as possible keep them to the extent possible to their current lines and then hope to cut some sort of armistice or peace deal that is as favorable to Ukraine as possible.
Rich Lowry
I think the problem with J.D.'s argument is he doesn't set out a clear end or endpoint. So if we just cut off Ukraine and they run out of shells and Russia begins advancing across Ukraine, is Russia just going to stop out of the goodness of their heart because they're really nice people?
Short pause
Cabot Phillips
Because they'll decide, oh, this was a terrible venture. It's immoral. We never should have done it. No, they're going to take as much as possible.
Rich Lowry
So the question is, eventually there'll be some sort of, absent a sweeping Russian victory, there'll be some sort of settlement. And I think it's in our interest to ensure that settlement is as favorable to a Western ally, Ukraine, as possible.
Short pause
Cabot Phillips
Now, in the last year or so, the conflict in Ukraine has largely turned into a war of attrition, with neither side really gaining much ground.
Rich Lowry
The Ukrainians launched a failed counteroffensive in the summer, trying to regain ground they lost in the east. But for the most part, things are at a standstill.
Short pause
Cabot Phillips
So the big question now turns to whether Putin will continue committing resources and men when his progress is ground to a halt, or whether he'll sit down for a peace deal in exchange for territory.
J.D. Vance
Well, I think right now it probably looks like the Ukrainians taking very aggressive defensive posture along the current lines, right? So they lose probably about 20% of their territory.
Short pause
Cabot Phillips
I think that it means they get significant security guarantees. You know, you can't trust that the Russians aren't going to violate any peace.
J.D. Vance
So you need a sort of longer term commitment for Ukraine to kind of rebuild. The longer the Russians go on with this, the more that they're going to be effectively committing their entire economy to a military buildup state.
Short pause
Cabot Phillips
They don't want that. That's not good for their population.
J.D. Vance
So I think that both sides have something to gain here. The Russians stop a military mobilization that will eventually destabilize their country. The Ukrainians stop a war that is fundamentally bleeding theirs.
Short pause
Cabot Phillips
And the Americans get to focus on our priorities, which I think, again, is East Asia.
Rich Lowry
I think they're going to have to give up territory, realistically. I've never been a purist on this question. You know, we've got to keep backing Ukraine until they take everything back.
Short pause
Cabot Phillips
It's understandable the Ukrainians would want to do that. That's a perfectly understandable expression of Ukrainian nationalism.
Rich Lowry
But I'm not a Ukrainian nationalist, so I just want an end to the war on as favorable terms as possible to Ukraine and to Western interests.
Short pause
Cabot Phillips
I think Crimea is going to be gone. They're not going to get it back.
Rich Lowry
And Russia is going to take its pound of flesh out of Ukrainian territory.
Short pause
Cabot Phillips
And it also will not be a peace deal that's going to stand forevermore. It's going to be probably a pause ultimately in the conflict with Russia.
Rich Lowry
But I think finding a deal that's favorable to our interests is better than one that's more favorable to Russia's interests.
Short pause
Cabot Phillips
As the debate continues to rage, all eyes turn to Congress, where the House is expected to soon vote on a foreign aid package that includes $65 billion for Ukraine.
John Bickley
Well, both men have made really compelling points, and this debate seems far from over. Cabot, thanks for reporting.
Cabot Phillips
Anytime. That was Daily Wire senior editor Cabot Phillips, and this was a Sunday edition of Morning Wire.