Main Topic: The growing influence of Bill Gates in the agriculture industry, particularly in the promotion of synthetic meat and plant-based alternatives, and the concerns surrounding his motives and the environmental impact of these alternatives.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Theme music fades out
John Bickley
Welcome to Morning Wire, I'm Editor-in-Chief John Bickley, and I'm here with my co-host Georgia Howe. It's Sunday, May 28th.
Georgia Howe
Good morning, John.
John Bickley
Today, we're revisiting a topic that's been gaining attention lately: the so-called war on meat. Joining me is Daily Wire senior editor Cabot Phillips. Cabot, thanks for being here.
Cabot Phillips
Thanks for having me, John.
John Bickley
Last summer, we talked about this topic, but quite a bit has happened since then. If anything, the war on meat has only intensified in recent days. A number of cities have advanced measures to implement "meatless Mondays" in the name of student health. And last month, New York City Mayor Eric Adams vowed to reduce the city's so-called food emissions by 33%, in large part by cutting meat products from public meals to supposedly fight climate change.
Cabot Phillips
That's right, John. Those moves come as a number of prominent health organizations have labeled meat detrimental to public health and called for plant-based alternatives. But lately, we have seen some pushback from the scientific community.
John Bickley
We talked earlier this month about the Dublin Declaration, a paper signed by over 1,000 scientists from around the world, which touted the benefits of meat consumption and reaffirmed its nutritional value.
Cabot Phillips
Now, most people probably aren't aware of the fact that the largest farmland owner in America is Bill Gates. First, tell us about how he's amassed all of this land.
John Bickley
As of last year, Gates owned roughly a quarter million acres of farmland across 19 different states. There are 70,000 acres in Louisiana, for example, for corn and cotton, another 20,000 in Nebraska for soybeans. One of his potato farms in Washington is so big that you can literally see it from space.
Cabot Phillips
But it's not just the land itself that's drawing attention now. It's also how the land was amassed. Gates and his ex-wife Melinda quietly began purchasing large tracts about a decade ago, and they often used shell companies to try and hide the fact that it was them.
John Bickley
Now, this isn't the first time Gates has gotten involved in the farming industry, though, right?
Cabot Phillips
Yeah, he's no stranger to the world of agriculture. In the past, as part of what he called efforts to combat global hunger, he invested heavily in agricultural technology, specifically in companies developing genetically modified organisms or GMOs.
John Bickley
For example, in 2010, his foundation purchased a million dollars' worth of stock in Monsanto, the now-infamous agrochemical corporation.
Cabot Phillips
But in recent years, he shifted away from just acquiring shares of farming companies to acquiring actual farmland itself. And that is significant, especially because it comes at a time when he's also viewed as one of the world's leading climate activists.
John Bickley
Yeah, how does Gates' climate advocacy play into all this?
Cabot Phillips
Well, that's where an interesting overlap starts to emerge. While climate change activists historically focused on reducing greenhouse emissions by cutting back on fossil fuels, in recent years, they've turned much of their attention to cutting back on meat consumption, especially red meat.
John Bickley
In the past, the fight against meat was typically waged by animal rights activists, but now it's increasingly coming from climate activists. They claim that cows are an inefficient food source and harm the environment by consuming precious water reserves and emitting CO2 and methane.
Cabot Phillips
The growing idea among many in the scientific community is that red meat may have been necessary when options were limited, but now that humans have access to so many alternatives, we should be seeking out food that's less harmful for the environment.
John Bickley
And Gates has been totally on board and really leading that message.
Cabot Phillips
At the same time that he started amassing huge swaths of farmland, Gates has also become one of the most prominent voices in the world against meat. He's called it a threat to the environment and says that in order to combat climate change, we must move to alternatives.
John Bickley
And in his mind, those alternatives are synthetic meat or plant-based meat.
Cabot Phillips
In one interview last year, for example, he said, "All rich countries should move to 100% synthetic beef. You can get used to the taste difference."
John Bickley
He's also said that the push towards synthetic beef was so important that even if people don't adopt the shift willingly, government coercion could be necessary.
Cabot Phillips
Speaking to MIT's technology review about his latest book titled "How to Avoid a Climate Disaster," Gates said, "Eventually you can sort of change the behavior of people or use regulation to totally shift demand."
John Bickley
So, what sort of public reaction have we seen to Gates' involvement in this?
Cabot Phillips
So, there have been two main sides forming. Some have praised his climate activism, saying that Gates is just trying to educate people about the potential dangers of meat reliance.
John Bickley
They perceive his intentions to be purely philanthropic and say that billionaires like Gates should be exerting their influence on culture in pursuit of the greater good.
Cabot Phillips
But others have remained skeptical and questioned his motives. Specifically, they point out that he really stands to profit from the two main alternatives to meat, which are synthetic beef and plant-based meat.
John Bickley
Let's dig into that more. Tell us about plant-based meat.
Cabot Phillips
Yeah, plant-based meat is created with a mix of legumes like soybeans and lentils, as well as potato starch, pea protein, and other vegetables.
John Bickley
Critics have been quick to point out that all of those products are products grown on farms now owned by Bill Gates.
Cabot Phillips
Obviously, if meat is phased out in exchange for plant-based solutions, Gates would stand to gain financially. And then when it comes to synthetic meats, the process starts in a lab where scientists use stem cells to essentially grow meat in a Petri dish.
John Bickley
And it's worth pointing out, not only has Gates invested massively in the produce that's used to make these meat alternatives, he's also invested millions in alternative meat companies themselves, like Memphis Meats, Beyond Meats, and Impossible Foods.
Cabot Phillips
Critics say that it's no coincidence that he's simultaneously pushing for meat alternatives while buying up farmland that grows the products used to make those alternatives or investing in the companies that would obviously explode as a result.
John Bickley
What about the environmental impact of all this? How much greener are these meat alternatives?
Cabot Phillips
That's the thing. From the data we have right now, they actually appear to be worse for the environment in many ways.
John Bickley
On that note, I talked to Rob Wolf. He's a research biochemist and author and has also worked with the Navy Special Warfare Resiliency Program. He's basically an expert on all things meat and nutrition.
Cabot Phillips
Here's what he had to say about how synthetic meat is made as well as its impact on the environment.
Audio clip plays
Rob Wolf
It is an outright lie that these plant-based alternatives are better for the environment, are going to reduce carbon footprint or carbon emissions. This is a key piece that gets missed in this whole story. That tissue needs to be fed, and the stuff it needs to be fed has to come from somewhere. It doesn't just magically grow in a vat.
John Bickley
And this is one of the things that's so remarkably silly about it being sold as a climate change benefit. Because we have a lab. Yeah, all of the carbon footprint that went into building that lab. That lab environment needs to be temperature controlled. It needs lighting.
Cabot Phillips
The funny thing is when you look at these meat alternatives, they say it's good for the planet, but they never, ever, ever show you what's called a life cycle analysis, which is basically looking at all the inputs, all the outputs, and then comparing and contrasting those with, say, like conventional meat and pasture-raised meat.
John Bickley
Despite those concerns, the scientific community has really gotten on board with the call for meat alternatives.
Cabot Phillips
And it's interesting. If you look at the timing here, the call for cutting meat that's come from a lot of climate change activists has coincided almost perfectly with many in the scientific community going after meat from that perspective.
John Bickley
The growing message from many scientists is now that diets high in meat are unhealthy for humans, and we should move away from meat not just for environmental reasons, but for health purposes.
Cabot Phillips
Again, critics have argued that that message from the scientific community could have more to do with fulfilling climate change goals and serving their own self-interest and less to do with the actual science on meat and its nutritional value.
John Bickley
Yeah, what about that, the nutritional value? What does the research say about beef consumption?
Cabot Phillips
Yeah, as with anything surrounding diet and nutrition, there are conflicting sides. There are some doctors who claim humans can get the nutrients they need from a plant diet that includes synthetic meat.
John Bickley
But there is a growing amount of data that raises concerns over diets based entirely around plants.
Cabot Phillips
I asked Wolf about that as well. And he says that while some young people, primarily men, are able to subsist on a meatless diet, it often leads to nutrient deficiencies, especially among childbearing age women and those above the age of 50.
John Bickley
The short answer is that no, it is largely impossible to identically replicate the nutritional characteristics of a meat-inclusive diet using plant-based alternatives only.
Cabot Phillips
Some people can do it. The American Dietetics Association, American Medical Association, have made statements that vegan and vegetarian diets are appropriate for all stages of the human life cycle, and there's absolutely no data to support that.
John Bickley
This is a completely non-evidence-based claim that these folks have made.
Cabot Phillips
And it's interesting. According to Wolf, there's often pressure within the scientific community to avoid saying anything positive about meat because it could detract from the climate change movement, which, as we mentioned earlier, is calling for meat to be removed from our diets.
John Bickley
He says that questioning the science on meat and its impact on the environment can often result in being outcasts from the mainstream.
Cabot Phillips
You know, we needed nuanced discussion around climate change, and instead, we're getting a Holocaust-denying level of dishonesty in about three minutes.
John Bickley
And I think that academics are terrified of getting, you know, legaled in this way with cancel culture and everything else that's going on and these kind of McCarthy-era witch hunt type things that happen in academic circles.
Cabot Phillips
Even the people who know better on the science of this topic, they're in a really difficult situation.
John Bickley
To that point, there are also those who say that pressure from the scientific community to wage a war on meat in the name of saving the environment has resulted in a number of skewed or misleading studies on the topic.
Cabot Phillips
For example, take the Global Burden of Disease study. That is the authoritative paper on overall worldwide health each year. It's very influential in the healthcare decisions of countries, especially regarding their food policy.
John Bickley
In 2017, the study claimed that diets high in red meat pose almost no risk of death. But just two years later, in 2019, that same study claimed that meat-heavy diets actually kill well over a million people globally each year.
Cabot Phillips
The study claimed that meat-heavy diets killed 36 times more people in 2019 than in 2017. There was a huge spike in the number of deaths they attributed to meat-heavy diets in just a two-year span.
John Bickley
Critics say that such a dramatic change in the data over just a short period of time raises red flags, especially because it coincided so closely with this new environmentalist push to reduce meat consumption during that same time period.
Cabot Phillips
They say it's not a coincidence. And it's also worth noting, that study was sponsored in large part by the Gates Foundation.
John Bickley
So, seems like a direct line there between the scientific community's messaging and Bill Gates.
Cabot Phillips
Definitely appears that way.
John Bickley
All right, Cabot, thanks for providing this deep dive for us.
Cabot Phillips
Anytime.
John Bickley
That was Daily Wire's Cabot Phillips, and this has been a Sunday edition of Morning Wire.
Theme music starts playing