Main Topic: The Housing Market Bubble and Its Potential Implosion
Participants: Georgia Howe, Daily Wire editor-in-chief John Bickley, and financial analyst and author John Rubino.
Key Points:
Takeaways:
Implications:
Upbeat music fades out, followed by the sound of a news theme
Host (Georgia Howe)
Why shop at Burlington? Maybe it's the deals that are new each time you drop by. Maybe it's the brand names you'll be shocked Burlington has in store. Or maybe it's the quality of the items, the amazing selection, and the newest trends. If you like to save, but also like to stay in style, Burlington is your answer. And the question you'll be asking yourself is, why go anywhere else? Burlington. Deals. Brands. Wow.
Music transitions to a news theme
Interest rates dropped this week to their lowest point since October last year, sparking a 20% surge in mortgage applications. While housing remains unaffordable for many, some real estate experts say we're on the precipice of a market crash, but only in certain regions of the country.
Music fades out
In this episode, we speak to a former Wall Street analyst and financial author about why this housing bubble is unique and what he expects to see in the near future. I'm Georgia Howe with Daily Wire editor-in-chief John Bickley. It's Sunday, March 9th, and this is a weekend edition of Morning Wire. Joining us to discuss what he's calling the weirdest housing bubble ever is financial analyst and five-time author John Rubino.
John Rubino
Oh, sure, Georgia. Good to meet you. Nice to meet you too.
Host (Georgia Howe)
So you had a recent substack where you said that we are living through the weirdest housing bubble ever, and you outline a few reasons for that. Particularly, you point to the age of first-time homebuyers. Can you unpack why this is such a unique time for homebuyers?
John Rubino
Well, yeah. Normally, the way a bubble works is that the price of something starts going up and it keeps on going up. And eventually, people get so excited by the rise in price that they experience FOMO, fear of missing out. And they start piling in. And you get a lot of action as the price goes up. But houses have become so unaffordable that the market is kind of frozen, even though prices are just insanely high.
Host (Georgia Howe)
And a normal person, especially a normal young person, cannot afford to buy a house in the United States right now. And the median age of homebuyers now is in the 50s. It used to be 30 or so, 30, 35-year-olds.
John Rubino
And now the only people who can afford to buy a house are basically people who are at their peak of their lifetimes of earning and have a lot of money saved. So you've got a market where even though prices are at an all-time high, the amount of deals being done, the amount of homes being bought are at 1990s levels.
Host (Georgia Howe)
Even though we had 50 million fewer people in the 1990s, that's the level of home buying and selling that's going on right now. And what are the reasons for that? One thing that comes to mind is there's sort of some consolidation among older people buying multiple homes and younger people buying none.
John Rubino
Well, kind of, that explains what's happening, but the reason it happened is inflation. We basically debased the currency. That means the price of things when measured in dollars goes up. And houses are one of the financial assets because you use debt to buy a house which makes it a financial asset. So house prices have gone up faster than the salaries of most people have gone up.
Host (Georgia Howe)
So houses get more and more unaffordable with time and that's not a function of houses changing in any fundamental way. It's the value of the currency going down. And what this does is it benefits the people who were there at the start of the inflation, basically baby boomers, my generation. We own a lot of the financial assets. We own the houses, we own the stocks, and we own the gold, and all of those things are going up dramatically.
John Rubino
So we're getting richer while the younger generations are being impoverished because they can't even afford the basics of adulthood right now. You know, if you're a 30-year-old and you want to start a family and buy a starter house, good luck, unless you make a quarter million dollars a year, you know, and very few people at the age of 30 do that now.
Host (Georgia Howe)
So we have basically screwed over younger generations while enriching the already rich. And that's what inflation does. And that's why it's so insidious. Now, housing market is a perfect example of that.
John Rubino
So where we go from here, though, I think is the really interesting part of the story because people are starting to put their houses on the market now, but they're doing it at current prices, which means nobody can buy them. So inventory of homes for sale is starting to pile up in a lot of formerly hot markets like Texas and Florida.
Host (Georgia Howe)
You're seeing a lot of people try to sell their houses, but there are no buyers. And so what happens then normally is that the people who are trying to sell their houses, some of them pull the house off the market in disgust and others cut their prices. And this sets off a panic in which people who really need to sell their houses basically have to sell them for whatever they can get for them and prices plunge.
John Rubino
And so we're headed for a time like that as inventory builds up dramatically in a lot of formerly hot markets and people get ready to start panicking. And are we seeing delisting rates climb? Is that where that comes in?
Host (Georgia Howe)
Yeah, delisting rates are starting to climb. And that's a sign that we're topping now, that all the things that happen normally at a top are beginning to happen. More listings coming on the market, more delistings as people can't sell their houses.
John Rubino
Oh, and there are also a lot of price cuts. You go to Zillow and you'll notice that a lot of houses have already been reduced.
Host (Georgia Howe)
Now, you and The Wall Street Journal highlighted that there are some very significant regional differences in the real estate market. For example, Florida and Texas have an overabundance of supply, whereas other places have a persistent shortage. What's causing that?
John Rubino
Well, there's just been a lot of action in Florida and Texas and a few other states. Those are the places that people have been moving to and where a lot of houses have been built in response. You know, there's a tremendous number of new houses in the process of being built there right now.
Host (Georgia Howe)
So in other words, the bubble markets, the really hot markets are the ones that break first and where the real action is. Now, is the migration of people moving to those states slowing?
John Rubino
Yeah, it's slowing, but it hasn't stopped yet. People are still moving to states that they perceive as better run and they're moving out of states that they think are badly run. That's continuing, but it's slowing down because nobody can afford to buy the houses in the hot markets that they're moving to now.
Host (Georgia Howe)
You know, for the past 20 or 30 years, if you sell your house in California, you could pretty much go anywhere and buy a really nice house. But now home prices are starting to equalize. They're going up. Even in, well, Nashville, for instance, is a super hot market in Tennessee. And a lot of other Tennessee cities are starting to boom. And that always leads to higher prices.
John Rubino
And in Florida and Texas, a lot of the formerly affordable neighborhoods aren't affordable anymore. So it's harder and harder to move to these places. Fewer and fewer people are doing it. And again, that's topping behavior. You know, once we reach the point where that rolls over and people actually start leaving the formerly hot states, that's when the real estate market really tanks.
Host (Georgia Howe)
Newsweek put out an article calling Austin, Texas ground zero for the market downturn. First off, can you explain what you've seen there? And also, do you think other hot cities are going to follow? And how long will that take?
John Rubino
Yeah, Austin has basically been the hottest city in the country for the past decade or so. But inevitably, the pendulum swings too far. And Austin is now unaffordably expensive. And the prices of houses are starting to go down there.
Host (Georgia Howe)
I don't have the exact number, but I think it's something like 15% from the peak. Prices are down in Austin. And there's an old saying that in a bull market, prices go up on the escalator. And in a bear market, they go down in an elevator. In other words, they go straight down when they start to fall.
John Rubino
And yeah, we're heading for that in a lot of hot real estate markets where prices just start to gap down. And Austin is definitely one of those places. Some places, for instance, Ohio, prices there just aren't that expensive. So it's not gonna plunge there, but in a lot of other places where home prices are wildly unaffordable, they're gonna tank.
Host (Georgia Howe)
You know, 30, 40, 50 percent declines are going to seem normal at some point in the next couple of years.
John Rubino
Now, you argue that the traditional boom bust resolutions aren't going to suffice this time around, in part because other costs are going up. What's unique about this bubble?
Host (Georgia Howe)
Well, as you mentioned, there are other costs of homeownership that have really spiked as part of the whole inflation thing. You know, the cost of homeowner's insurance is spiking and home maintenance is much more expensive than it used to be. And taxes are going up. Property taxes are going up in line with home prices.
John Rubino
So owning a home is not only expensive because you have a high mortgage rate and the price was very high but you got insurance and taxes that are much higher than they used to be. So first of all, there are a lot of people who are priced out of buying a house. They can't do it. And then there are a lot of people who own houses, but can't afford to keep those houses.
Host (Georgia Howe)
So add it all up and there's just a massive amount of inventory coming our way. Now, I know that in the past few years, I had read that companies like BlackRock are buying up a lot of housing. And I imagine that's different from past generations. How widespread is corporate ownership of things like single-family homes?
John Rubino
Yeah, it's not the dominant factor in housing right now, but it's a very big one. And like you said, it's a very new one. Two other new ones are Airbnb properties where people built little empires of condos and rental houses. They're not making nearly as much money off of them as they thought they were going to. And a lot of them are going to have to be dumped onto the market.
Host (Georgia Howe)
And finally, baby boomers. You know, we're retiring and that three-story McMansion with an acre of land to take care of just isn't as easy on our hips and knees as it seemed at the time when we bought it. So boomers are going to have to start selling their big houses and downsizing.
John Rubino
So you take Wall Street, you take Airbnb, and boomers, put them all together and you have this massive tidal wave of homes that are going to hit the market pretty soon.
Host (Georgia Howe)
And it seems to be reaching kind of peak complexity right now where home prices are starting to roll over. And the next year, the story is going to be instead of high house prices, it's going to be all the discounts you can get.
John Rubino
Wow.
Host (Georgia Howe)
Now, do you think there are going to be some areas that are insulated from price drops? I know, for example, in 2008, some places the price is leveled out and other places it totally cratered. Where do you think is going to be relatively stable?
John Rubino
Well, the places that didn't boom in the first place. I'm hearing a lot from a lot of people who are moving to like Missouri, for instance, where prices are still completely affordable. And Ohio, as I mentioned before, same thing. So they're insulated from the worst of the housing busts because they didn't boom in the first place.
Host (Georgia Howe)
And then other places that have some city-specific or state-specific thing going on, like for instance, there's a lot of technology companies that are moving to the Phoenix area. That will help support real estate prices going forward. In other words, they won't crash the way some other places will crash.
John Rubino
But just as a general principle, home prices will probably be going down irregularly in different places. But generally speaking, they're going to drop going forward, unless some really radical thing happens out there that's not on the horizon at all.
Host (Georgia Howe)
So generally, if you've got a house now, your house will be less valuable in two or three years. And if it was wildly overpriced when you bought it, it's going to go down by a lot.
John Rubino
Well, John, thank you so much for coming on today.
Host (Georgia Howe)
Oh, sure. That was financial analyst and author John Rubino. And this has been an extra edition of Morning Wire.
Music fades in
Thanks for tuning in to this weekend edition of Morning Wire. If you want to hear more from John Rubino, check out his latest substack. And if you want to stay up to date on the latest news and analysis, be sure to follow us on social media. We'll be right back after this break.