Main Topic: The Biden administration's alleged pressure on Facebook to suppress right-leaning media outlets, including The Daily Wire, and the potential First Amendment implications.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Theme music fades out
John Bickley
Welcome to Morning Wire, I'm Editor-in-Chief John Bickley.
Georgia Howe
And I'm Georgia Howe.
John Bickley
It's Friday, August 4th. We're examining all of our legal options at this point, and we have no hesitancy whatsoever about going at the Biden White House again. We did it before, we'll do it again.
Georgia Howe
The D.C. judge assigned to the case against former President Trump has a history of tough sentences for J6 defendants and a career at a law firm with strong ties to the Democratic Party.
John Bickley
If I'm Donald Trump, I don't want to be tried in front of her. I want to be tried in front of a judge who has a fairer and better background. And I want to be tried in front of a jury that isn't 90-something percent anti-Trump voters.
Georgia Howe
And Oklahoma Governor Kevin Stitt signed a sweeping order this week defining the word woman and designating protected women's only spaces.
John Bickley
We discuss the first of its kind statewide order. Thanks for waking up with Morning Wire. Stay tuned. We have the news you need to know.
Pause
Memos recently obtained by Congress reveal that the Biden White House pressured Facebook to stifle the Daily Wire's reach in an effort to promote the administration's policy goals related to the COVID vaccines.
Georgia Howe
Here to discuss the development and the potential congressional and legal fallout is Daily Wire reporter Amanda Presta-Giacomo.
Amanda Presta-Giacomo
Hey, Amanda. So Facebook, under subpoena, recently handed over these notes to the House Judiciary Committee. Daily Wire has obtained the documents and reviewed them with obvious interest.
John Bickley
First, tell us what's in these documents.
Amanda Presta-Giacomo
Well, they're pretty damning for the Biden White House and possibly for Facebook. When you read through the notes, which were first reported by John Solomon at Just the News, it appears the White House was working to censor Americans they viewed as adversarial to their COVID goals through the private sector.
Georgia Howe
In this case, Facebook, now called Meta, would be working as the government's surrogate to censor.
Amanda Presta-Giacomo
Typed up notes from Facebook dated April 14th, 2021, show that the White House met with Facebook executives to pressure the tech giant to change its algorithm, to downgrade posts from the Daily Wire, and other, quote, polarizing entities.
John Bickley
White House Digital Director Rob Flaherty asked Facebook to promote what he called authoritative media, such as the New York Times, over the Daily Wire.
Amanda Presta-Giacomo
Other notes that are pretty jarring show, Flaherty becoming frustrated that Facebook couldn't provide some of the data the White House wanted. So he pushed the company to, quote, play ball.
Georgia Howe
Keep in mind, just last week, House Judiciary Chairman Jim Jordan revealed that a Facebook employee in April of 2021 circulated an email from Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg and COO Sheryl Sandberg that said, quote, we are facing continued pressure from external stakeholders, including the Biden White House, to remove posts.
Amanda Presta-Giacomo
Yeah, indeed. Now, the fallout from this has been pretty fierce and swift.
John Bickley
What has the reaction been so far?
Amanda Presta-Giacomo
Well, various legal experts have already weighed in and have said this appears to be a First Amendment violation by the White House.
Georgia Howe
Daily Wire co-founder and editor emeritus Ben Shapiro was on that same page.
Ben Shapiro
We are absolutely pleased to look into the effects on our business of the Biden White House engaging in an absolute First Amendment violation.
John Bickley
There's no question this is a First Amendment violation. It is as simple as that. It is a First Amendment violation because the federal government cannot force or even pressure a private company into censoring information. That is a First Amendment violation pretty clearly.
Ben Shapiro
Shapiro stated very bluntly that The Daily Wire is exploring all legal action.
John Bickley
As Shapiro noted, The Daily Wire successfully sued in 2021 over the administration's COVID vaccine mandate for some private businesses. The Daily Wire prevailed there and the Biden mandate came to an end.
Ben Shapiro
We helped overturn the thing and prevent 80 million Americans from having to take the shot if they didn't want to take it.
John Bickley
We are perfectly happy to do the exact same thing with the Biden White House right now to stop them from ever violating the civil rights of Americans by pressuring Facebook and other social media companies again.
Ben Shapiro
And by the way, we have looked at the traffic on our website and whether it declines in the aftermath of this conversation. Suffice it to say, evidence will be presented.
Georgia Howe
I'll note that the Daily Wire's monthly engagements have fallen from a high of over 100 million a month as a top publisher on the platform, down to as low as 4 million per month.
Amanda Presta-Giacomo
Yeah.
John Bickley
Now, there's also the question of Facebook's liability in this.
Amanda Presta-Giacomo
Right. Some legal experts have already suggested that Facebook might have opened itself up to legal threat with their actions.
Georgia Howe
Meanwhile, Morning Warriors spoke to Congressman Jim Jordan about Facebook's actions generally.
Jim Jordan
Facebook knew they were wrong. There's a communication in there, an email in there, where one of the executives at Facebook says, we're really encroaching on the boundaries of free expression.
John Bickley
But they knew that the White House wanted them to do it. And they were so concerned about the relationship with the White House, they censored anyway.
Jim Jordan
Jordan made clear that his committee isn't done investigating and that they will take action to ensure free speech rights are better protected from such government and big tech collusion.
Georgia Howe
Well, obviously, we here at The Daily Wire are very much interested in getting all the facts out there on this. So more to come.
Amanda Presta-Giacomo
Amanda, thanks for reporting.
Anytime.
Pause
John Bickley
On Thursday, former President Donald Trump was arraigned in federal court in Washington, D.C., pleading not guilty to four charges related to his alleged efforts to overturn the 2020 election.
Georgia Howe
Here are the latest on the case against the former president and details on the judge presiding over the case's Daily Wire senior editor, Cabot Phillips.
Cabot Phillips
So, Cabot, another historic moment in the case against Trump. What can you tell us here?
John Bickley
Well, for the third time in four months, Donald Trump has been arraigned on criminal charges.
Cabot Phillips
The former president arrived in D.C. on Thursday afternoon and surrendered himself to authorities in the very courtroom where more than a thousand of his supporters have also been arraigned for their own role in the January 6th riots.
Georgia Howe
Trump appeared briefly before a magistrate judge and ultimately pleaded not guilty on the four charges against him.
Cabot Phillips
As in his previous arraignments, Trump was fingerprinted, but no mugshots were taken. He spoke to the press afterwards.
Donald Trump
This is the persecution of the person that's leading by very, very substantial numbers in the Republican primary and leading Biden by a lot. So if you can't beat him, you persecute him or you prosecute him. We can't let this happen in America.
John Bickley
Now, over the last few days, we've learned more about the judge in Trump's case.
Cabot Phillips
Yeah, on Tuesday Judge Tanya Chutkin was randomly selected to preside over the trial And that appears to be bad news for Trump for a variety of reasons First she already dealt a major legal blow to the president in the past In 2021, she ruled that the House January 6th Select Committee must be given access to a large number of Trump's White House files, saying, quote, presidents are not kings and the plaintiff is not president.
Georgia Howe
That ruling opens the door for Democrats in Congress to make public his call logs, internal strategy documents, and other private communications from his time in office.
Cabot Phillips
Judge Chuckin, an Obama appointee, has also handed down some of the harshest sentences to January 6th defendants over the last year, often giving them more jail time than prosecutors had even called for.
Georgia Howe
She's the only judge in the country who's done that.
Cabot Phillips
Chuckin has made clear in prior cases how disgusted she was by the events of January 6th and implied that she wants stiff sentencing for those who participated as a way of deterring future political violence.
John Bickley
Tell us more about how she's handled these past J6 cases.
Cabot Phillips
Well, when some January 6th defendants tried to argue that they were being treated far harsher than those who engaged in violent riots and supported the Black Lives Matter movement, Judge Chuckin immediately shut them down, saying in court, quote, to compare the actions of people protesting mostly peacefully for civil rights to those of a violent mob seeking to overthrow the lawfully elected government is a false equivalency and ignores a very real danger that the January 6th riot posed to the foundation of our democracy.
Georgia Howe
Chutkin has also alluded to President Trump's alleged role in January 6th, telling another defendant last year, quote, the people who exhorted you and encouraged you and rallied you to go and take action and to fight have not been charged. I don't have any influence on that. I have my opinions, but they are not relevant.
Cabot Phillips
Well, now she will have an influence on that issue, and her opinions on the case will be more than relevant.
John Bickley
How have Trump and his team reacted to the case and the fact that Judge Chutkin is overseeing it so far?
Cabot Phillips
Well, there are plenty of Trump allies who say that she's already displayed a clear bias against Trump. In addition to her comments in prior cases regarding him, Judge Chuckkin previously spent 12 years working for a prominent left-wing law firm, which at one time employed Hunter Biden and lobbied on behalf of Brazma, the controversial Ukrainian energy company that he worked for.
Georgia Howe
They say that she should be forced to recuse herself from the case.
Cabot Phillips
Trump allies and even some of his primary opponents, including Ron DeSantis, have also called for the case to be moved out of Washington, D.C. to Florida, where Trump resides.
John Bickley
Their general argument is that people have a right to a jury of their peers and that D.C. would produce biased jurors. Remember, the district is overwhelmingly Democrat. In 2020, it went to Joe Biden by a margin of 92 to 5 percent.
Georgia Howe
So you can understand their concern.
John Bickley
Kevin, thanks for reporting.
Cabot Phillips
Anytime.
Pause
John Bickley
Oklahoma's governor signed a Women's Bill of Rights on Tuesday aimed at limiting women's spaces to biological females. That makes it the first state to enact such rules via executive order.
Georgia Howe
Daily Wire investigative reporter Maraida Lordi is here with the details.
Maraida Lordi
So, Maraida, first, tell us about this order.
John Bickley
Hi, Georgia. Oklahoma Governor Kevin Stitt signed this executive order, which he's calling the Women's Bill of Rights, on Tuesday. Supporters are calling it a huge move for protecting women and girls.
Maraida Lordi
The order defines women based on biology and it directs public schools to provide separate locker rooms and restrooms for boys and girls.
Georgia Howe
It also directs state facilities like prisons and domestic shelters to provide separate facilities for men and women.
Maraida Lordi
The Women's Bill of Rights says it aims to bring quote clarity certainty and uniformity to administrative rules in order to settle the unfounded confusion surrounding such basic questions as what is a woman It offers specific definitions of male and female and says there are definitional practical and material differences between the sexes.
John Bickley
Female is defined in the order as a person whose biological reproductive system is designed to produce ova, or eggs, and male is defined as a person whose biological reproductive system is designed to fertilize the ova of a female.
Maraida Lordi
Governor Stitt, who is a Republican and has three daughters of his own, states he signed the order for all the young girls in Oklahoma who should not be forced to undress in what should be a safe locker room.
John Bickley
Here's Stitt at the bill signing.
Kevin Stitt
Today, we're taking a stand against this out of control gender ideology that is eroding the very foundation of our society. And we are going to be safeguarding the very essence of what it means to be a woman.
Maraida Lordi
So this order is the first of its kind. certainly other states are going to be watching. What venues does it pertain to? Is this all public places or just government buildings?
John Bickley
The order pertains specifically to public schools and women's prisons, but those are places where we've seen some of the most significant issues.
Maraida Lordi
In public schools, parents across the country have sounded the alarm about minor students using the school bathrooms and locker rooms of the opposite sex.
Georgia Howe
Reports of sexual assaults occurring in bathrooms shared with trans-identifying students have only heightened concerns, and parents have showed up at school board meetings to demand that bathrooms be separated by biological sex.
Maraida Lordi
So what's the reaction been to this order?
John Bickley
Well, it's been mixed.
Maraida Lordi
Oklahoma's governor was joined at the signing by former college swimmer Riley Gaines, who has recently spoken about her experience sharing a locker room with trans-identifying male athlete Leah Thomas.
Riley Gaines
I and other girls who wanted to speak up about how uncomfortable it made them to have biological males in their locker rooms were put through emotional blackmail in order to keep them silent.
Maraida Lordi
Gaines called the order huge and also made some remarks at the signing on Tuesday.
Riley Gaines
In addition to being forced to give up our awards and our titles and our opportunities and our scholarships, we as female swimmers were forced to share the locker room with Thomas, a six foot four, 22 year old biological man equipped with and exposing male genitalia inches away from where we were undressing. And we were not forewarned. We were not asked for our consent. We did not give our consent.
Georgia Howe
Alternatively, Democrats called the law an attack on transgender people.
Maraida Lordi
Oklahoma House Democratic leader Cindy Munson accused the governor of deploying partisan, polarizing politics and said the Republican supermajority continues their government overreach.
Cindy Munson
It's pretty rich that a man would feel it's appropriate for him to define what makes a woman.
Maraida Lordi
Another Democrat, State Representative Melissa Provenzano, said she can't imagine there won't be challenges to this order.
Melissa Provenzano
It's pretty rich that a man would feel it's appropriate for him to define what makes a woman.
John Bickley
The executive order was inspired by model legislation developed by the conservative women's group Independent Women's Voice.
Maraida Lordi
And as you said at the top, Oklahoma is the first state to enact this type of women's bill of rights through executive order, although Kansas and Tennessee have adopted similar laws based on the model legislation. A federal version of the women's bill of rights has also been introduced in Congress.
Georgia Howe
Well, this continues to be an extremely contentious issue.
Maraida Lordi
Maureen, thanks for reporting.
Thanks, Georgia.
John Bickley
That's all the time we've got this morning. Thanks for waking up with us. We'll be back this afternoon with more of the news you need to know.
Georgia Howe
Thanks for listening to Morning Wire.