The main topic of this podcast episode is the limitations of the scientific method and how it often relies on unobserved phenomena. The participants in this episode are Naval Ravikant and Sam Harris.
Naval Ravikant, a well-known entrepreneur and philosopher, makes the point that many scientific discoveries are based on unobserved phenomena. He uses the example of dinosaurs, stating that we have never seen a dinosaur, but rather fossils that we interpret as evidence of their existence. He also mentions that we have never observed the core of the sun, but we know about stellar fusion through theoretical understanding.
Naval Ravikant argues that even when we think we have observed something, we are often just observing the effects of a phenomenon through instruments, and then theorize about the underlying cause. He uses the example of the Big Bang and the movement of continents, stating that we do not directly observe these events, but rather infer their existence through indirect evidence.
The key points of this episode are:
Takeaways from this episode include:
Transcript http://nav.al/observed
Now, people might object at this point and go, how dare you invoke in science things that cannot be seen, things that cannot be observed? This is completely antagonistic towards the scientific method, surely. And I will say to anyone who's thinking that right now, almost everything of interest that you know about science is about the unobserved. Let's consider dinosaurs. Dinosaurs are unobserved. You say, oh, hold on. I've been to the museum. I've seen a dinosaur. No, you have seen a fossil. And a fossil isn't even a bone. It's an ossified bone. It has been metamorphosed into rock. So no one has ever seen a dinosaur.
We have seen things that look like dinosaurs and interpreted them to be huge reptilian, bird-like creatures that when we assemble their skeletons, we make up a story about what this thing was that walked the earth tens or hundreds of millions of years ago. In the same way, no one has ever seen the core of the sun. And no one will ever observe the core of the sun. But we know about stellar fusion. We know that hydrogen nuclei being crashed together there to form helium and in the process producing heat. We don't see the Big Bang. We don't see the movement of continents. Almost everything of interest in science we do not observe.
Even many of the things that we say we have seen, we've actually just seen instruments detect those things. So we're watching the effects through instruments and then theorizing that there are other universes out there where the photons are interacting with the photons that we can see.