Main Topic: The podcast episode discusses various topics in the tech and business world, including Kara Swisher's recent win as the "Sexiest Podcaster Alive" and "Podcaster of the Year," her thoughts on Twitter's leadership, and her analysis of the company's potential for growth. The episode also touches on the topic of bullying in the tech industry, specifically in relation to the company Away.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Support for this show comes from Robinhood. Wouldn't it be great to manage your portfolio on one platform? With Robinhood, not only can you trade individual stocks and ETFs, you can also seamlessly buy and sell crypto at low costs. Trade all in one place. Get started now on Robinhood. Trading crypto involves significant risk. Crypto trading is offered through an account with Robinhood Crypto LLC. Robinhood Crypto is licensed to engage in virtual currency business activity by the New York State Department of Financial Services. Crypto held through Robinhood Crypto is not FDIC-insured or SIPC-protected. Investing involves risk, including loss of principal. Securities trading is offered through an account with Robinhood Financial LLC, member SIPC, a registered broker-dealer.
I'm 32, juggling family, working full-time, and earning a bachelor's degree. At University of Phoenix, I earn career-relevant skills with every five-week course. Skills I can use now, not just after graduation. Earn skills in weeks, not years. Visit phoenix.edu.
Kara Swisher
Hi, everyone. This is Pivot from the Vox Media Podcast Network. I'm Kara Swisher.
Scott Galloway
And I'm Scott Galloway.
Kara Swisher
And Cara, the big news.
Scott Galloway
No, no. You're not going to take my thunder.
Kara Swisher
There's no thunder taking. Hold on. Hold on.
Scott Galloway
The sexiest podcaster alive. That's right. Adweek said I'm the sexiest podcaster alive.
Kara Swisher
Stop. Stop. You're stealing my thunder, you narcissist.
Scott Galloway
Listen, cue the music, Rebecca.
Kara Swisher
My friend.
Scott Galloway
Tom, Tom. Yes, we are the champions, my friend.
Kara Swisher
I like that she used "we." Scott, we've got an exciting announcement. Rebecca, stop playing that awful music. Listen, Pivot won an award. We won Thought Leadership Podcast of the Year, which is very funny because we really do need to have some thoughts.
Scott Galloway
Thought leadership? I am... Okay, let me just say, I am so sick of not being objectified. I have my husband and everyone else I know gave me a Peloton, and I now have a girlish figure. I'm sick of being appreciated for my brain. I'm sick of it.
Kara Swisher
Is this like the Miss Congeniality Award, do you think? What the fuck does that even mean? Thought leadership? Have they met us? Literally, have they met us? We're very thoughtful people, I think. That's literally like the least sexy award ever invented.
Scott Galloway
But the sexy award was won by me, Kara Swisher, for Recode Decode, Adweek's tech podcast of the year and overall podcast of the year. I beat Michael Barbaro. I kicked Joe Rogan's ass. I mean, really. It's really fantastic.
Kara Swisher
Seriously. It's clear that Vox is... Does Vox own the company that owns Adweek?
Scott Galloway
I read that and I almost swallowed my tongue. I'm like, podcast of the year. I'm an important and smart... Did you see? I'm smart. I am just a really fantastic person. You're like Helen Reddy at the 1978 Grammys. You're just cleaning up everything. I am woman, hear me roar. Podcast of the year. The number's too big to ignore. Rico Tigo. Listen to me. That's really impressive. All the white guys who yammer away like you win all the time. It is time for a lady to win the thing. I'm sorry. No, you cleaned up. And congratulations. I think you're officially the godmother of podcasting. Seriously.
Kara Swisher
I believe I am. And by the way, guess what our next stop is? Pulitzers. They just announced an audio category for future awards.
Scott Galloway
You're now like Harvey Weinstein, out there trying to get yourself a Pulitzer.
Kara Swisher
So I just have a quick question. I'm getting a Pulitzer, and then you're going to bow down to me. That's all I'm going to say.
Scott Galloway
Like I do twice a week. Anyways. Yes. You know what? I'm just curious. When did you start podcasting? What got you into it?
Kara Swisher
Five. Five. I just suddenly realized these earphones and everything else. I think with the AirPods, it was five years ago or more. I just was sort of like listening to someone. I thought this is going to be great because you're in people's ears. These ear things are getting so much... These devices are getting so much better. I was starting to listen to them. So I grabbed an intern. I literally was running the Recode site or doing a lot of writing on the Recode site. And I just got tired of the texting and I thought, I'm going to do this. Because I was going to take the Code Conference 365 days a year. It was just on a whim. And Jim Bankoff let me do it. And nobody knew whatever I was doing. And that was that. That was the beginning of it. Thank you. That's my origin story.
Scott Galloway
Wow. That's it.
Kara Swisher
That's it. I just wanted to do it. Yeah. And it's a medium that's now, I think it's going to be over a billion dollars. It's the only ad-supported medium.
Scott Galloway
You know what was the first podcast I ever listened to?
Kara Swisher
What?
Scott Galloway
The podcast of you interviewing me on Recode Decode.
Kara Swisher
Oh, yeah. That's right.
Scott Galloway
And you know what I thought? That was cool. You know what? Because, you know, I'm a narcissist as well. I listened to the whole thing, and I had one word reaction. I'm like, meh, this medium will never work. What is this show?
Kara Swisher
Love that episode, and that's where you predicted the Amazon Whole Foods thing. Yeah, that started it all. That's right. That built all this. This is why I'm in a panic room right now. Listen to me. Look, NPR's been doing it. A lot of people have been doing amazing journalism, but we have just stepped in and grabbed all the thunder. In any case. What podcast do you listen to? I'm just curious. What does Kara Swisher listen to other than herself? What do you listen to?
Scott Galloway
I listen to a lot of history podcasts. I like historical ones. Like Radical History or Visionist History? All of them. All of them. I listen to whatever is around. And I do listen to other interview shows sometimes. I've always liked Terry Gross. I listen to a lot of interview stuff, but I do like the historical ones. And I also listen to historical audio books on tape. Right now I'm listening to a podcast about the making of the Brooklyn Bridge, and it's riveting. John Roebling has just died, his father.
Kara Swisher
God, no wonder we're thought leaders of the year. Can you talk about the Kardashians? Jeez, that's rough. Anyways, congratulations, Cara. That's wonderful. Listen, it would be interesting to see if Spotify starts going after prestige journalism more, or if Apple starts putting more money in this, the way Netflix goes for Oscars and Golden Globes. It's an interesting... They just did it with The Irishman and Marriage Story, which is interesting. We'll talk about that later. Let's talk about big stories. I want to start with a letter you wrote to Twitter's board of directors. I know you don't talk about it too much. You got a lot of attention for it. You started this on the podcast last week, but then you wrote a very detailed open letter on your blog, No Mercy, No Malice... maybe a little malice. You actively asked Omid Kordestani, who I know very well from when he used to work at Google, who's the executive chairman of Twitter, to remove Jack Dorsey in a no-confidence vote. And you actually sort of slapped around him. And just to be clear, you disclosed that you are a Twitter shareholder in the letter. Talk about this because it got a lot of attention.
Scott Galloway
Boy, did it get a lot of attention. So, look, we talked about this off mic, and I'm not entirely sure how to approach it because I want to give the company a chance to respond before piling on.
Kara Swisher
They're not going to respond to you, but okay.
Scott Galloway
You never know. Actually, I think they will. But anyways, look, the letter speaks for itself. I think Twitter needs to start commanding the space it occupies. I think if you were to look at any company that has the equivalent reach or influence, it's a company trading at 20 to 40x the valuation. I think there's no company in the world whose opportunity relative to its performance is this out of whack. At the same time, I do want to kind of move on because I don't want us to be accused of using this platform to pimp my financial interests.
Kara Swisher
I get that. I get that. But you brought up some very pertinent things. I mean, I think more to the point besides the stock, let's move away from the stock, is these issues around the CEO not being present, which we talked about last week in detail, wanting to go to Africa and different things. And you honed in on the idea that he has two jobs, which I think has always been an issue. And that it's never been more important than ever, like you talked about it being in the Mueller report. There are a lot of very... It's a really smart... Whether Scott owns the stock or not, it's a really smart analysis of the situation. And whether it's doing well enough is another aspect to it. But one of the things is whether it's running the company well, whether it's making products well, whether, with the departure of a lot of executives... It's never been more in the news. And yet the management still continues to be up and down, even though Dorsey has done some great things like getting rid of political ads, which I think removes a pain point off his plate, which he has many.
Scott Galloway
Well, look, the primary... People have asked me what would you do that's different. And I think that, generally speaking, activist investors are frustrated operators that come up with a bunch of recommendations. And then if they get on the board, or what's happened to me when I get on boards of companies, is I generally find out that I'm not as smart as I thought and they're not as dumb as I'd hoped. So I didn't make a lot of tactical recommendations. But I just think it's kind of a basic IQ test of corporate governance that a company that's in the midst of an election year that has potentially been weaponized to huge effect on behalf of bad actors, a company that has the kind of reach and influence and hasn't been able to monetize it... I'm going to go out on a limb here and say it deserves a full-time CEO.
Kara Swisher
That's a little limb. That's like a regular tree trunk, many people feel.
Scott Galloway
I think Vijay Gade or someone like that should probably be...
Kara Swisher
Well, not only that, to be fair, I do think Jack Dorsey is a full-time CEO. Unfortunately, he's a full-time CEO of Square, where he has 85% of his wealth. But anyway, I've been trapped here. I'm going down a rabbit hole. We'll see what management says. I appreciate you bringing it up. But let's get to other news.
Scott Galloway
No, no, no. I'm not done with this one yet.
Kara Swisher
What's interesting about this is it reminds me of Chris Sacca did a letter like this many years ago. If you remember, he was saying how I'd run Twitter. And he's a big investor in it. You're allowed to comment on it as long as you disclose. And what was interesting is he got a lot of kudos. You're getting killed by the VCs. You made a stupid Twitter error this week. They piled on that. The circling of the wagons on this is fascinating to me by a lot of Silicon Valley people in terms of they can do no wrong. And that's a really interesting issue, I think.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. First off, I want to apologize. A guy named Vlad put out a tweet early in the morning describing the Peloton ad, and I used the exact same language, and I should have just retweeted his tweet or given him a hat tip. And immediately the same people whose WeWork investment I have queered or have come after Twitter began calling me a plagiarist, which is really nice for a professor. That feels very good. But anyways, Vlad was very gracious and responded pretty much saying... But the circling of the wagons part is interesting. That was just a dumb error. I was expecting it. I expected, it's interesting, I expected on this podcast and on Twitter that I would trigger a variety of cohorts. And the only people I trigger are white males between the ages of 40 and 55. When I stand, my analysis stands between them and their second billion. That is when things get really mean and ugly.
Kara Swisher
Do you have a name for this? What is this?
Scott Galloway
Yeah, I call them the third basers, the people who have conflated luck with talent and have decided that basically... The arguments back and... Go on my Twitter feed and look at it. I wouldn't even call them arguments because I don't respond. But their basic notion is I'm rich, so fuck you. I must be right. You don't know. They call you moronic. I find it... I'm a moron. No data, no response to the argument, just "I'm a moron." And it's interesting because young people respond more thoughtfully. They come up with data, they disagree with you. You get the bots and the crypto guys or the Tesla guys that don't make any sense, but those are just bots. But if it's an ad hominem attack, it's always from a 40 to 55-year-old white male, usually in the venture capital alternative investments industry. And their basic notion is, have you met me? Do you know who I am? And there's just absolutely no desire to have a substantive dialogue. And by the way, I would benefit from a substantive dialogue because I get this shit wrong all the time. And I try to acknowledge when I'm wrong.
Kara Swisher
The people suggest we have them on. It's Keith. I've interviewed him on the podcast and Jason Calacanis has also been. He's trying to take your place on this podcast, I think. But one of the things that's interesting, those are among the people that complain about you. It's really interesting. It's fascinating to watch them because they never do that to me.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, but there's a difference. Okay, so I've been very critical of WeWork and Uber. And the first individual you referenced is a big angel investor, and you guessed it, WeWork and Uber. The last individual you referenced is about to go down as Adam Neumann minus the charisma or good looks as he is incinerating more capital for SoftBank at Opendoor and DoorDash. So, yeah, there is a reason why these individuals...
Kara Swisher
Wait, who's that? Who's that? Jason? Jason's not at SoftBank. No, the teal guy. He's not at SoftBank, is he?
Scott Galloway
He's not at SoftBank. Yeah, but he's the founder of Opendoor, another SoftBank incinerator, and also DoorDash, which will go down as, again, another one that's not going to get out, that's incinerating literally billions. So, look.
Kara Swisher
I just find it interesting. I find it interesting because I literally have been tough on many of their companies, and I've never seen them take an ad hominem attack. I think that's... Listen, guys, y'all, Keith and Jason, besides the fact that I have to threaten you physically with my children... Thanks for that. Which I hope you know. I will have my children take care of it if you'd like. But, you know, make some... If you're going to do this on Twitter, calling someone a moron is not really the way to do it. You look like idiots, and you need to actually have some cogent arguments that Scott can then respond to. And if not, I will send my children after you. How's that?
Scott Galloway
I like it. Thanks for that. I feel much safer now. I agree with you. The "moron" thing is ridiculous. It's ridiculous. They need to make their arguments besides "I'm rich and you're not." They really do. They need to have some cogent analysis. And we dare them. We double dare them because we're award-winning now.
Kara Swisher
That's right. Sexiest podcasters. There we go. We did not win sexiest podcaster alive. It doesn't exist, although we should award it to ourselves. Listen, the other thing, speaking of Uber, they released a report detailing and analyzing incidents of sexual assault in their rideshares as they had promised they were going to. The company disclosed more than 3,000 incidents of sexual assaults that happened on the ride. That's about eight assaults a day. Obviously, they do billions of rides. That was their sort of talking point. But it's the first time that any major ride-hailing service has released this kind of data. Scott, can you talk about this from a brand strategy or PR perspective? They just got booted from London for misconduct. Is this transparency an attempt to get ahead of the issues or just a smart brand and optics management?
Scott Galloway
Well, the first thing is, and I'm really curious for your thoughts. The first thing is it's shocking, right? And then as a data person, you immediately go, well, is this worse on Uber or is this just a function of someone actually doing the data around what happens with ride hailing and taxi cabs? But I mean, at first it really shocks you. It's already changed my behavior. I was starting to think that I could have Ubers take my kids to Little League practice and there's just no way I'm going to do that now. I mean, it really was shocking and upsetting. But the second that you go to the next thing, my genuine belief here is that trying to get out ahead of the issue and be somewhat transparent and take the lead around it is a smart move. And they did, I think, concurrently announce some of the safety features they're trying to build in. So, like, I think they get... It's easy to say it's a problem. And they're trying. Is this something specific to Uber about their culture? I don't think it is. I think it's something specific to the activity that's creating a dangerous atmosphere.
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Scott Galloway
But to a certain extent, just having the data out there is productive because I do think you're going to see action against it and hopefully a reduction in it. But, again, it's another thing as a male. I just never would have... You're safe in the back of a car. People don't start acting weird with you. I mean, they might take the wrong bridge and then you go insane. But I've never, as a 6'2" male, I've never felt threatened. So, again...
Kara Swisher
Well, welcome. That is my column in the New York Times this week, oddly enough, about safety, this idea around safety. I think what's interesting is...
Scott Galloway
You're right. You're right. Human beings behave... Whether you're in a hotel or a car sharing, you're going to get these kind of behaviors everywhere. Like no matter what you're selling, if you have these encounters. It happens in taxis. It's happened... Taxis would be the most... It's obviously... There's been lots of assaults. There's tons and tons of assaults in taxis. No one's really keeping track of those particularly. And so that's good that they're keeping track. That's one of the things. But I think Uber from its early days did not focus on safety in any way. They did not make sure they vetted the drivers, did not ensure that this was the safest ride, did not vet the cars.
And so this is what's coming to haunt them, I think, in that way. And I think under Dara Khosrowshahi, I think they're trying to do that. Obviously, there are issues around payments and things like that that are still problematic for this company in economics. But they didn't do this for the longest time, and they didn't do a very good job of vetting. They didn't do a very good job of safety. And now they're trying to backfill this problem. And the reason being, which is what I'm going to argue in the New York Times column this week, is that these people have never felt unsafe a day in their lives and therefore they don't understand it.
They don't empathize. We don't empathize. You don't empathize because you wouldn't. You're not going to want to go, yay, this. But there's been enough incidents for them to understand that they need to be not perfect, but they certainly need to try harder. And so this is a great move. I did talk to Dara about it. And, you know, it's incoming every day, essentially. But this, I think, was a good thing for them to do. I think they have to keep doing it. And then, besides releasing this data, they've got to say what they're going to do about it. Like very cogent things that they need to do to make this safer.
Because there's going to be some level of lack of safety no matter how you slice it when humans come together. But they could do a better job. That's my thought.
Well, Roger McNamee, who I'm a big fan of, he had a tweet that sort of summarized the issue and the problem. And it goes to the gestalt of big tech. And that is big tech, a big component of their value add is innovation. They're incredible products. Regulatory arbitrage where they just bomb into a city and believe they can overwhelm the local authorities. There's, quite frankly, exploitation of people where they figure out that a lot of people who aren't working have smartphones so they can put them to work for below minimum wage standards. But there's also the basic ethos that wraps around all of it is how do we make this process more frictionless such that it could scale like no other business in this category?
So anything that adds friction, checking a driver's background, a probation period for the driver, installing a camera in the car, anything that adds friction, it gets a red light from moment one. And the reality is all of these safety issues, all of this porous nature that makes the platform weaponized, subject to abuse, that you can reach out and DM on Instagram underage girls. All of these things are a function of... These aren't evil people. But part of their gestalt around building shareholder value, their DNA, is to never acknowledge or greenlight anything that might result in friction of scale.
And the majority of the problems come from their inability to recognize that friction is a component of safety and of responsibility like mature construction of businesses.
Kara Swisher
You just used two thoughtful words, friction and gestalt. What was that?
Scott Galloway
Friction and gestalt. There you go.
Kara Swisher
Friction gestalt. There you go.
Scott Galloway
My wife's German. I use those words for foreplay.
Kara Swisher
Oh, God, I knew that would happen.
Scott Galloway
Sometimes I dress up like Poland and she invades me. That's our Sunday night.
Kara Swisher
No, no, no. No, no, that is not happening. That's some good Cold War humor. That's some good Cold War humor. And it's a good call to take a quick break. That is your one. You get one every episode. That's all you get. Thank you for that. And that is it. The itch is scratched. Horrible Polish sex joke, and it's not going anywhere. Poor Erica Anderson. She's like, I have had it with this guy. All right, okay, Scott, time for a quick break. I have had it with this guy. We'll be right back.
Scott Galloway
Listen, I am the podcaster of the year, so just back down.
Kara Swisher
Sexiest podcaster alive.
Scott Galloway
No.
Kara Swisher
Okay, Scott, time for a quick break. We'll be right back with more Pivot.
Scott Galloway
What bullshit.
Kara Swisher
More Pivot. Hush up.
Ad Break: The Disney Plus Hulu HBO Max bundle. Plans starting at just $16.99 a month. No one will ever break us apart. Catch Marvel Studios Thunderbolts The New Avengers on Disney Plus. You can't escape the past. Alien Earth on Hulu. This ship collected monsters. And Final Destination Bloodlines on HBO Max. Death is coming for our family. The Disney Plus Hulu HBO Max Bundle. Plans starting at $16.99 a month. All these and more streaming soon. Visit DisneyPlusHuluHBOMaxBundle.com for details.
Ad Break: This episode is brought to you by Dogfish Head Craft Brewery. The Grateful Dead and Dogfish Head have gotten the band back together with the release of Grateful Dead Juicy Pale Ale. A light-body pale ale brewed with sustainable kernza grains, granola, and heaps of good karma for a refreshing brew that's music to your taste buds. Available nationwide. Visit dogfish.com to find Grateful Dead Juicy Pale Ale in your neck of the woods. Dogfish Head Craft Brewery is located in Milton, Delaware. Please drink responsibly.
Okay, we're back. We've tamed Scott. Kara Swisher, comma, podcast of the year, comma, has managed to do her excellent job. Scott, we're going to do listener mail now. You got an interesting email last week from someone who wanted to remain anonymous about their experience at WeWork. They said that their family member worked as a salesperson at the company for about six months before quitting. They were paid more on commission than the rent the tenant was paying for WeWork for the entire lifetime of the lease they signed. Scott, can you talk about this from a management perspective? Basically, this shows there were indications this model was going to fail long before their S-1. And this is what the listener said. This is a Ponzi scheme, essentially. So what do you think about that?
Scott Galloway
I'm seriously, my mind stopped. I still can't get over the fact you beat out The Daily for podcast of the year. Anyways, my brain's just catching up to what's going on today. But anyways, so like, you know who caused this, this listener mail thing? Amazon. And that is Amazon basically reconstructed or reshaped the relationship between investors and the marketplace. And as a result, absolutely reshaped behavior and capital allocation.
Kara Swisher
Now, how did this happen? How are we getting to WeWork? But go ahead.
Scott Galloway
Let me see this. I'll get there. It's a long, windy road, but I'm a thought leader.
Kara Swisher
I'm a thought leader.
Scott Galloway
Let me just do a Michael Barbaro voice. Go on.
Kara Swisher
No, go on.
Scott Galloway
So anyways, you know him. I love to have some dirt on him. He's very intriguing to me. Anyways, look, for the first time in history, a company got to be the third most valuable company in the world and arguably the most influential company in the world with almost no or negligible profitability. And what Amazon taught the markets to do, which drives everything as compensation typically drives everything, is they taught the markets to replace profits with vision and growth. And so all of a sudden, companies take a page out of that book and go, as long as we can massively grow the top line, profitability takes a distant number two. So if we, as a means of growing our top line faster than any real estate company in history, can incentivize brokers to get any tenant in these 10 new buildings or facilities we're opening up every week and create a top line growth that is unprecedented in the world of real estate, if we build it, they will come, they being massive shareholder value, even if it means an economic model that makes no sense, including giving 100% of the commission to the broker responsible for growing that top line.
Kara Swisher
All right. So why did it go wrong here? Like it worked for Amazon. Were people not paying attention? What was different here in this WeWork situation?
Scott Galloway
Well, everybody needs a little bit of sugar and then there's diabetes, right? So what happened as a species, it was drilled into us to want salty, fatty, bloody food. But once it became produced institutionally, our instincts didn't catch up. And now we have tremendous obesity in this country. And what's happened here is that investors are starting to catch up with the fact that we are overindulging or companies are overindulging in this notion of replacing profits with growth. And Amazon always had positive gross margins. I mean, in the year Amazon went public, I think it lost $30 million. It wasn't losing $100 million a week.
Kara Swisher
It was a big deal. It was called Amazon.bomb. I don't know if you remember those headlines and stuff like that. I think a lot of people were onto it then. It's just that Wall Street gave them a pass and Jeff Bezos just didn't communicate with Wall Street that much. The Google guys were the same way. So this is an idea that worked on steroids and the marketplace has figured out this isn't just wanting a little bit of sugar, a little bit of red meat, a little bit of fatty food. This is out of control. This has come to the point where, and it's a new classic company. It's a company where for a short time, a dumb investor or cheap capital fuels valuation as a function of top line growth. And they have access to that cheap capital and what I would deem incinerators. And there's no prospect of profitability. Amazon always had a fairly bright line path or a fairly obvious path to profitability. The only other company that's been able to get away with this to the same extent and has managed to replace top line growth with, quote unquote, subscribers is Netflix.
Scott Galloway
Netflix, you're right. For everybody else, it's like at one point, at some point, the music stops.
Kara Swisher
But let me, before we move on to Winsome Hills, what is the differentiation? Why do they get, why does Amazon and Netflix get a pass and WeWork and others do not?
Scott Galloway
Because Amazon, there was a path. I mean, for a lot of reasons. I mean, WeWork was no Amazon. Amazon got to a point where it was pretty clear if they stopped massively investing in everything from...
Kara Swisher
Or marketing or whatever, yeah.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. Not even marketing, but investment in smart speakers, fulfillment. I mean, they were making true investments that were going to result in flywheels. They had Amazon Web Services, which I would argue is the most valuable company in the world right now. It just stuck in another company. Whereas WeWork, let's look at it, was building no moats. It was just massively buying top line. It was guilty of incredibly poor governance. Its flywheel effect spun out things like WeWork, WeLive, a school. None of these things made absolutely any sense. And it was genuinely investing just to create the illusion and burning capital, whereas Amazon was investing in moats that would ultimately return shareholder value. There's just an enormous difference. I talk about moats a lot. You have to build moats.
Kara Swisher
Well, moats, flywheel. Amazon is the moatiest moat of its convenience, whether it's price, whether it's logistics, they have so many. And they got into operating margin. They immediately, not immediately, but I think 10 years into their life, they went profitable for a quarter. I just think as a means to show the market, the moment we want to be profitable, folks, we can get there.
Scott Galloway
Well, just to finish this up, back in the day, AOL was always saying, if we just stop marketing, we'd make money. If you remember, that was their little line. And, of course, it's like you can't... The revenue growth, the top line isn't going to grow without your crazy disks everywhere and stuff like that.
Kara Swisher
And cereal boxes. Jan Brandt, remember her?
Yeah. I know Jan. Jan Brandt had a whole table made out of disks.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. I've actually adopted a lot of her phraseology. She had a great line that I thought was hilarious. She used to get on stage at AOL conferences when I started Red Envelope. You had to go to AOL and basically kiss their ring to try and be in the only place that was doing e-commerce called AOL Marketplace run by a guy named Greg Chauvin. We ended up becoming a close friend. Talk about how the world has changed. And she used to get on stage and say, "To resist is futile. We're going to put a disc everywhere. And it's just going to be impossible." I love Jan Brandt. Jan Brandt's great. That is an unsung character in the history of the internet.
Kara Swisher
She's quite a bit in my book, but she's great. She's a great person.
Scott Galloway
That's right. You wrote a book on AOL.
Kara Swisher
Yes, I did. I know Jan Brandt. But I remember the table. It weighs like 400 tons. I think she's tired of hauling it around, but it was made of discs.
Transition
Anyway, wins and fails, Scott. That is a really cogent – by the way, that was another thoughtful thought leadership position. Go on.
Scott Galloway
You just feel sorry for me because all your buddies are being mean to me.
Kara Swisher
You just feel sorry. They're not my buddies. Are you kidding?
Scott Galloway
Yeah.
Kara Swisher
They're not my buddies. If you can't stand the heat, get out of the kitchen. I'm fascinated they're not mean to you. They're mean to you and not mean to me.
Scott Galloway
It's largely because I'm on the finale of Silicon Valley, which you did not know also. You're more powerful than me. Me and Dick Costello were there. He hasn't attacked you. That's interesting.
Kara Swisher
He was the CEO of Twitter. Excuse me.
Scott Galloway
Oh, Dick. He's a nice guy.
Kara Swisher
The comedian guy?
Scott Galloway
Yeah. The former comedian? Yeah, I met him in Europe. He seemed like a lovely guy.
Kara Swisher
He's lovely. He's quite lovely. Anyway, so wins and fails. So I'm going to do my wins first this week besides myself and you.
Scott Galloway
Is it a side note? Is two, I can't decide between the Wonder Woman videos and posters, the new trailer.
Kara Swisher
I love Wonder Woman. I cannot stand it. Linda Carter, who I met through you. I love that Wonder Woman.
Scott Galloway
And secondly, Ryan Reynolds' Aviation Gin ad.
Kara Swisher
Oh, that was mine. Go on. I'll give you this one. That was great. You take that one as your win. I'll take Wonder Woman. Wonder Woman is such a great brand. They've done such an amazing thing on it. It looks like a sexy as heck movie. The visuals. I love the director, Patty Jenkins. She is a huge talent. Literally, what a talent. You can see, just from the trailer, all I want to do is go see this movie. It's crazy. In the theater, actually. So that is my win this week. You may go on with the gin.
Scott Galloway
Aviation gin. Everyone talks about agility in the context of a bunch of programmers putting out a product quickly or copying a Snapchat feature into Facebook. That's what agility has come to mean. But agility and creativity, creativity still matters. And Ryan Reynolds, who I think is this incredible talent. I don't know how much he was involved in the production of this. But they saw an opportunity with the Peloton ad, which kind of documents the heartwarming journey of a 116-pound model to 114 pounds over 12 months. And by the way, I stole that from Twitter, and I don't know who you are. I apologize. If you reach out to me, I will credit you or hat tip you.
Kara Swisher
You're a Twitter thief. But you know what's really interesting? There was a fascinating analysis breakdown by, and I'll retweet, I think it's a her, this copywriter saying, "Why do we hate this ad so much?" And there was a real genius insight. And that was, it was filmed as if you were the husband giving her that bike. And they put you immediately in this feeling of like, "Okay, I'm a fucking idiot, thoughtless husband." And it made you squirm because it immediately said, it wasn't done in the third person. I guess that's the second person. And you were the husband, which immediately made you feel very uncomfortable. And I thought that was such a genius insight because you see the commercial and don't you immediately go, "This feels kind of awkward. I wouldn't give my wife a Peloton for Christmas." And they're saying, "I am giving," they put you in those shoes.
Scott Galloway
Anyways, I thought Aviation Gin's agility... They immediately found her. Her name is Monica Ruiz. By the way, this is the best thing that's ever happened to her. She did a good job in that ad, too.
Kara Swisher
Oh, she was fantastic. And her friends were. It was so pitch perfect. It was great. And she did a great job. We have a mutual win. I hope it keeps going, like one of those old Kodak ads with Marriott Harvey.
Scott Galloway
You and I, I want to hear on Twitter how many people think podcaster of the year, podcaster of the century, and sexiest podcaster of life. Saw leader of the year, big fucking deal.
Kara Swisher
Anyways, how many think we should do a Peloton ad? We should do a Peloton ad. You and I should absolutely do a Peloton ad.
Scott Galloway
Peloton, you have been our sponsor. We will do a Peloton.
Kara Swisher
I have a Peloton. We should do a Peloton. That would be so good. I like Peloton, too. I think it's one of the few consumer tech companies whose stock is actually up from the IPO. I don't care what Wall Street says. I got to tell you, the product is amazing. I just tried their treadmill.
Scott Galloway
No, it's up. Amazing.
Kara Swisher
I use their app. I use it for meditation. I do it for all kinds of things when I'm thinking big thoughts that I need to do because I'm a thought leader. I use it for exercise. They have all these exercises. It's a combination of like a Calm app, the 7-Minute app. It's great. I'm sorry. They do a great job.
Scott Galloway
Apple-like margins, recurring revenue, an app distinct to the hardware. What will be really interesting is as they come up on the first years of public company, they have to disclose their churn and renewal and dollar renewal rates. This will be really, really interesting. I think that I would buy it again. I think Apple should buy it. That's my feeling.
Kara Swisher
All right. Fails.
Scott Galloway
Fails. I don't think this is a fail, but I know you will. This will be mine. Elon Musk won the defamation case, which I think I said.
Kara Swisher
You think that's a fail?
Scott Galloway
No, I don't think it's a fail. I think it's a win for Elon.
Kara Swisher
I would agree. I thought this was just ridiculous to pull this Twitter scream fest. You did not. You were quite like, "How dare he do this?" But I was like, "Come on."
Scott Galloway
I want to be clear. I think you can do things that are wrong. I think it was wrong for him to call a cave diver who I would argue is a hero a pedophile. I thought it was wrong. But I don't think there's a legal remedy. I think you can say mean things and do mean things. And it doesn't necessarily mean you should be in court.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. So, I actually think the court got this right. I don't think it fell under the true legal definition of defamation. And I think occasionally, people can do mean things to you and it doesn't necessarily mean that it's a legal remedy. So I think the court's got it right. I also, to his credit, on the stand, he said, "I apologize. I just should have said, 'Well done' and moved on." So I think there was an actual moment of self-awareness.
Scott Galloway
But think about this, distinctive the morality or whether you think it was right. The CEO of a company that's trying to put a man on Mars or trying to electrify the automobile industry, should he be spending time in court defending tweets?
Kara Swisher
No, that was true. That was true. It was just an error in judgment. And the thing is, no one on his board, I think, has been able to get through to him and go, "Okay, do you want to think about picking your battles a little bit more here?" Anyway, I think the court got it right. And I do think he handled himself or acquitted himself well on the stand.
Scott Galloway
Speaking of which, he's been driving his cyber truck around L.A. right now. And he ran over like a pylon. What do you think of that thing?
Kara Swisher
I'm totally beflummoxed by that thing. Have you seen it?
Scott Galloway
Beflummoxed? Is that a word? Is that a thought leader word?
Kara Swisher
Befuddled. No, he's driving it around. I'm going to try to get a ride with him when I'm in L.A. I'm going to get him to drive me around. That's what I'm doing.
Scott Galloway
Oh, my God. He hit his pylon, apparently. He's off to his next thing. But have you seen it? I literally, if someone gave you a million chances to sketch what the pickup truck from Tesla would look like, it looks like something... looks like that Simpsons episode where Homer gets to design a car. And I just, I look at the thing. I'm like, "That's a pickup." It's either genius or it's going to be the biggest fail. I can't figure it out. What is your fail?
Kara Swisher
What is your fail? Well, my fail is more of a rant.
Scott Galloway
All right.
Kara Swisher
About Away. It is a fail. It wasn't a good story. This is a story about – The Verge published a story about the history of bullying from the CEOs of Away, largely one of the CEOs. And then the company sent out an email telling employees not to talk about or share the story. It's a tough environment. And this was a piece about how tough the environment is. And it just wasn't a very attractive photo of a company. It was not a good picture of the company, and it seemed rather accurate from all. They seem to be insane on Slack.
Scott Galloway
So what do you think? You do not think this is a fail necessarily.
Kara Swisher
Well, I think there's a word for that kind of stressful, unfair, high-pressure, full-body contact company that you're not going to find justice in, and it's called startup. And I think that we like to think there's this Hallmark Channel version of startups and that we can build amazing value and billions of dollars by giving everybody paternity leave and having snacks and saying to everybody, "Oh, no, you're not feeling well, go home." I have never been involved in a company that's been able to get out of infancy and create real value without management being all over everyone all the fucking time and creating an atmosphere of what I'll call productive chaos. And then some people obviously emerge and become managers themselves. But in startups, if you're looking for quality of life or balance and it's not aspirational, do not go to a startup. And I read it and thought, "Oh, I would invest in that company." Interesting. It's not aspirational. But, folks, I have never worked in a company that's created billions of dollars in value from zero without, quite frankly, the sausage getting made. It is a tough, intense environment.
Go ahead. We had them on the stage at Code Commerce, as you know. And they sort of have this happy, shiny look. Anyway, they sort of try to do this, "Hey, we have all these values." It's sort of like Google pushing this "Don't be evil" line. You think they're hypocrites. And then really presiding over really egregious sexual harassment, egregious treatment of women, and then not doing anything about it. I mean, one of the things about the Googles during the fail is that this investigation continues at Google over what happened around a number of executives there and how they handled a number of executives badly it looks like.
And I think there's no – like they sort of get out of it because they get to leave with this sort of kudos. The founders are leaving and this and that. But there's more there. The timing is not coincidental, for example. And so what I do think, I agree with you that startups ain't pretty. But it is irritating to sort of push this idea of your specialness and how much you care about your employees. Just say, "This is going to be a hard place to be." It's inconsistent. Jeff Bezos never pretended it was a rose garden over there. Neither did Microsoft really. So I just don't like when they do this happy, shiny people thing the way Google has done.
And it's not so happy. It's not so shiny. And that's my irritation, and that's where the fail is.
Scott Galloway
I agree with you, though, on the thing. That said, you can push employees way too hard and be insanely nonprofessional. I agree. And also, there is something to be said just in terms of competitive advantage. If you can provide people who have different needs and aren't maybe young and can't focus 110% of their time at work, if you can create an environment where you do give certain people more flexibility, and quite frankly, they probably aren't going to make as much, but I think if you do offer those opportunities, you end up with a better company. But I look back on every startup I've been on that worked. And, oh, my gosh, it was full body contact. It was ugly. Balance wasn't a word we ever used.
Kara Swisher
Yep. I used to work late at night at the Washington Post and places like that. I don't recall it being like – there is an interesting mentality of people now being able to speak out on Slack or wherever they can talk out, or Twitter or wherever, where the complaints are, I hate to differentiate. There are legitimate complaints, and there are other ones, especially around sexual harassment and behavioral issues and abuse. And then there's, "Oh, just suck it up." You know what I mean? Like, that kind of thing. It takes this long to do this. And so it's a really, in this environment, I think you cannot be hypocritical saying one thing on one hand and behaving a different way. You just say, "You know what, just like you're saying, startup, it ain't pretty. The sausage, it ain't pretty." And so I don't think it was a very good look for them. And especially because it's these two women running it and everything else. It wasn't a good look. And they're under enormous pressure because everyone's trying to copy their business.
Scott Galloway
Well, they have to support a tech valuation on a luggage company. I think the most recent valuation is $1.4 billion, which is greater than what Tumi was. I mean, this is a company that's got to pull off this kind of yoga babble illusion that it's a tech company, not a company that shapes plastic into a thing you put your toiletries in.
Kara Swisher
So they found an area of the market that wasn't taken advantage of.
Scott Galloway
Oh, it's a great product. And by the way, if you're ever in an airport with a bunch of cool looking aspirational people, half those suitcases are Away. It's just whether or not... I want to be clear. I love the company. I just don't love the valuation.
Kara Swisher
Well, let me give full disclosure. Away is advertising with us this week, spending some of that money. But it's really – it's an interesting – they have found an issue in the marketplace at the same time. This is the kind of thing they're going to have to accept. And at the same time, employees are – it's a really – it's sort of – it's typical of so many Silicon Valley companies in terms of how they behave. And it's a fascinating time. Anyway, Scott, predictions?
Scott Galloway
I don't have one this week, Kara. I'm going to predict that you're going to be impossible now with all these wins. I can't believe you beat the Daly and Joe Rogan.
Kara Swisher
I did. And I didn't use weed, and I don't have that smooth jazz voice, as I said in my tweet.
Scott Galloway
Oh, my God. Congratulations. I mean this sincerely. Congratulations. That's a nice moment for you.
Kara Swisher
Thank you. That's really a nice moment for you. I'm already focused on the Pulitzer, my friend. I shouldn't even say that because you're not supposed to. Now I won't get one because they're very much snottier than these five jazz people.
Scott Galloway
Think about it. We're in the only ad-supported medium that's growing. You're literally the person of the year in a medium. In a medium.
Kara Swisher
Right. You're done. Ring the bell. Peace out. Drop the mic. I have, speaking of which, I have a great interview today with Neil Katyal, who is a Supreme Court litigator, solicitor, and he used to be a solicitor general, I think, about the impeachment. And he also does a lot of tech law. So it was really, I just want to say I'm going to continue to do. Someone was, oddly enough, saying, "Kara, get in your lane. Stay away from politics." What is your lane? That's what I want to know.
Scott Galloway
Oh, my God. I was so furious.
Kara Swisher
Your lane is a fucking 405. Your lane is a San Andreas fault. Define your lane. I hate when men say that. It's only men that say that to me, by the way. "Stay in your lane." I was like, "You know what? Tech affects everything. Uno, dos. I'm going to interview anyone the fuck I want."
Scott Galloway
Here comes the Spanish. Here comes the Spanish. Here it comes. Mayamo Kara.
Kara Swisher
Oh. Speaking of which, it was the funniest joke. Go to the biblioteca, Kara, and collect your award. We're going to close soon. But listen, I went to see Knives Out. And the funniest part was that discussion of immigration that Don Johnson had with the actress. I don't know her name. I forget her name. Merit Delmar. Alma Delmar. "Are you from Paraguay? Are you from Ecuador?" Like, it was like, Knives Out was brilliant.
Scott Galloway
Cute movie. Really nice movie.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. I can't believe you gave me a movie recommendation that I took up on.
Scott Galloway
Do you like it? It's a cute movie, isn't it?
Kara Swisher
Yeah. I watched Deadpool 2 with my son. It was just me and my son this weekend. It was really nice.
Scott Galloway
Oh, Deadpool 2 is great. Brian Reynolds.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, it's hilarious. But I'm saying that was a great movie. I'm thrilled that it's doing so well. I'm thrilled that it's doing so well because it's a smart movie. It was a complex movie. It was a movie like they used to be. Good for the whole family. 97% on Rotten Tomatoes. It's really good. We recommend it very much, and it's also super funny. The whole thing is a wonderful movie. It's hard to follow, which in a good way. I mean, it's good. It's interesting to follow. Anyway, I really appreciate it. But that one, the whole scene around her, the woman who's the nurse, it's just – with Don Johnson was very funny.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, that's wonderful.
Kara Swisher
Anyway, it was very funny. Scott, it's time for us to go. We're going to be back on Friday for a week's wrap-up. We still have more to talk about and more kudos, I say, for me mostly, but you too.
Scott Galloway
I was literally in that moment. I literally was registering an emotion. I'm like, "Well, I actually think I care about Kara because I'm actually proud of you." And then you just spoiled it.
Kara Swisher
I love that. I'm trying to do it. Kudos to me. That's it.
Scott Galloway
Yes, kudos to you. We are thought leaders. We're going to get t-shirts.
Kara Swisher
Rebecca Sinanis and Erica Anderson. We're going to have thought leader t-shirts. TL, we're the TL. We are thought leaders.
Scott Galloway
God, I just, thought leadership. Everyone loves me for my brain. It fucking sucks.
Kara Swisher
All right. Sexiest podcaster. I will give you that award. I will give you that award. But I'm lying. My brain can't wear high heels and date Brad Pitt. What is going on here?
Scott Galloway
In any case.
Kara Swisher
What is going on here? Podcaster of the Year, Kara Swisher, 2019. Yes, that is my podcast. All right, we got to go.
Scott Galloway
All right.
Kara Swisher
It's time for us to go. We'll be back Friday for a week wrap-up. In the meantime, we love your feedback. Tell us what you think by tweeting to us at hashtag pivotpodcast or email us questions at pivot at voxmedia.com. Today's show was produced by Rebecca Sinanis. Eric Anderson is Pivot's executive producer and thought leader. Rebecca, by the way, is best producer of the year. Thanks also to Rebecca Castro and Drew Burrows. Make sure you subscribe to the show on Apple Podcasts. And if you're an Android user, check us out on Spotify or, frankly, wherever you listen to podcasts. If you liked our show, please recommend it to a friend. Thanks for listening to Pivot from Vox Media. We'll be back next week with another breakdown of all things tech and business and a lot of leading thoughts.