Podcast Episode Summary
The podcast episode features an interview with Amazon CEO Andy Jassy, conducted during the Code Conference. The main topic of the conversation is Amazon's future plans, leadership, and challenges. Andy Jassy shares his thoughts on various aspects of the company, including its growth, customer experience, and innovation.
Key Points:
Takeaways:
Participants:
Guests:
Notes:
Kara Swisher
Not all journalism is the same. Take The Guardian. Our coverage has something unique. Fierce independence. Nobody owns us or tells us what we can and can't say. So we're free to report the whole picture. We connect what's happening in Washington to the rest of the globe. Expose corruption wherever we find it. And give fresh perspective on everything. From wellness and soccer to culture, the climate and more. Read, watch and listen to The Guardian for free at theguardian.com.
Hi, everyone. This is Kara Swisher, and today we've got a bonus episode for you. It's my conversation with Amazon CEO Andy Jassy taped during this year's Code Conference. If you like this interview, which you obviously will, then I've got good news. I've got a new interview show out. It's called On with Kara Swisher, and it launches in late September. Go wherever you get your podcasts, search for On with Kara Swisher, and hit follow. Enjoy.
The interview begins
I want to talk a little bit. You know, it's interesting because I've been to Bill Gates a lot of times when I interviewed Satya Nadella. Talk a little bit about, so it reminds me of that kind of transition, though both of you had been at companies since a very young age and had been brought up in those companies. Talk about how you look at your CEO-ship so far. It's been how long?
Andy Jassy
A year.
Kara Swisher
A year, exactly. So talk about how you think about it because it's hard to come out of the shadow of a well-known entrepreneur.
Andy Jassy
Well, I've been at the company for 25 years. I really kind of grew up there. And so it wasn't a brand new place to go into. And it's been a very interesting, adventurous last couple of years for the company and in the world. I think that if you look at what happened during the pandemic, we really prioritized trying to do right by customers and trying to make sure that we could serve customers.
I think whatever importance Amazon had before the pandemic, once the pandemic happened and everything shut down, the level of importance Amazon played was even more magnified. With the amount of demand, if you think about 2020, we grew 39 percent year over year on a two hundred forty five billion dollar base. It was unprecedented growth. To do so, we had to double the size of our fulfillment network that we'd built the first 25 years and do it in 24 months. And then we also built a brand new transportation network to deliver packages that we expected to build over six to 10 years that we built in two years. So it was a very challenging, interesting time where we made a number of investments that really shaded on the side of making sure we could serve customers.
Kara Swisher
How would you characterize your leadership now? You know, again, Tim Cook is coming. He came after Steve Jobs. How do you think about coming out of a shadow of a well-known entrepreneur like Bezos?
Andy Jassy
Well, I don't really think of it that way. As I said, I've been at the company a long time. I think we share a lot of similarities, Jeff and I, in that...
Kara Swisher
You couldn't be less like Jeff Bezos.
Andy Jassy
Well, actually...
Kara Swisher
And that's a compliment.
Andy Jassy
No, I think the world of Jeff. And I think where we're really similar is that we both care about customers first and foremost. I think that we both have a real long-term orientation. We're trying to build a company that lasts all of us here. I also think that we both like to invent. Very high standards is something that I grew up with parents who had very high standards. I have siblings who had very high standards. Everywhere I've worked that's been the case. I think that's really important where it's so easy for people to have a lot of choices as they have today.
I would say that I believe that the best leaders are those that are both strategic and are willing to roll up their sleeves and get into the details. Because really where the rubber meets the road in customer experience is the details. I would say that I'm a truth seeker. I want to know what's real. I don't want people to obfuscate the truth from me. I'd rather know what it is and know what customers care about and what they don't like and what we want to improve and then work on it.
And then I would say that maybe of the strengths that I have, learning is probably my best strength. I'm a very avid learner. I think the second that you believe you know what there is to know, you're starting to unwind as a professional. I just think every three months I learn so much. I'm really eager to learn more and to get better.
Kara Swisher
So one of the things you did was build AWS, which you didn't know that much about. And you moved in and created the most important business at Amazon, giving you, probably putting you in position to be the CEO. When you think about that idea of learning and understanding, talk a little bit what you think is critical. Andy Jassy's Amazon, what do you think is the most important things going forward when you're thinking about it?
Andy Jassy
Well, it's not my Amazon.
Kara Swisher
I know. I understand.
Andy Jassy
Anything hard you do with a group of people. No different here. But I think that we exist to make customers' lives better and easier every day and to relentlessly invent to make it so. I think we have a pretty big business today, and I think we have very compelling customer experiences, but they're a shadow of what they're going to be 10 years from now, and that's what we're going to focus on. Some of them are existing businesses. I think the experiences will get much better and some will be new.
In our retail business, I think you fast forward 10 years, you're going to be able to get any item you can imagine. You can order online. You can get it in a store. You can order online, pick up in a store, any of those combinations. There won't be any lines in physical stores. You'll be able to use our Just Walk Out technology or the Amazon Palm identification technology. And while today most Prime customers get their items in a couple days, that will increasingly become one day and then within a day. And then with our Droid and the Amazon Air initiative that we're working on, it'll be within a couple hours.
Kara Swisher
These are drones.
Andy Jassy
Yeah, drones. So I think that that's how I see retail evolving.
In our technology, in our AWS business, where we enable startups and enterprises and governments to be able to build technology applications much faster and much more quickly. 90 to 95% of the global IT spend today is on-premises. That's going to flip, in my opinion. We have what I think is the best customer experience and the broadest functionality, but it's still a fraction of what it's going to be, a fraction of the geographies they're going to be in.
I think you look at something like Alexa, which today has a lot of traction, but it's going to be a much more broadly useful personal assistant that will do more than entertainment. It'll help you with your home audio and home automation. It'll do calendaring and communication. I think streaming, people won't be talking about cord cutting. It will just be cut. Virtually everything will be streaming. We're focused not just on the best quality but the broadest selection.
But then there's new things. If you look at there are 300 to 400 million people in this world who basically don't have connectivity in the Internet. And our low-earth orbit satellite initiative in Kuiper is going to solve that. Even in health care...
Kara Swisher
We're going to get to that.
Andy Jassy
I think if there's ever a customer experience that needs reinvention, particularly in the U.S., it's health care. And so that's part of what we're trying to solve with the one medical acquisition we're doing.
Kara Swisher
And then transportation. You bought Zoox.
Andy Jassy
And then transportation as well. I think the consumption of automobiles are going to be very different moving forward. The autonomous driving ride hailing initiative that we're pursuing in Zoox, I think, is a chance to make a real difference. So those are the ones we know about today. We have a lot of other ideas, but the common thread running through everything we do at Amazon is we're always trying to find ways to make customers' lives better and easier every day.
Kara Swisher
All right. So you've been in some rougher times recently because of record inflation. You grew rather largely during the pandemic, and too many. Many Wall Street think it's too much. You had to deal with COVID-19. You've got unionization issues and safety investigations. Supply chains has been a problem for everybody, not just Amazon. Obviously, Ukraine is another issue, gas prices and things like that. And then there's the Justice Department and Amy Klobuchar. She seemed intent yesterday. She had some thoughts about Amazon and others. What do you, what do you write in the now? You're talking about the future. What are you most consumed by as a CEO of all these many things? Or we could take them on like inflation, the economy itself. How are you looking at it?
Andy Jassy
Well, the number one thing truthfully that we're focused on, it's true all the time, it's true today, is just how can we keep making the customer experience better. And then you got to look at it business by business. We're pretty decentralized and each of the businesses are different. If you look at today, we've got an unusual inflation situation. Compared to a couple of years ago, the cost of line haul and trucking and ocean and air and fuel itself are much, much larger than they were before. Some of them may be attenuating earlier than others, but I think it's going to take a while.
And as I was mentioning earlier, we grew our fulfillment footprint. We doubled it in 24 months. We built a transportation network. When you do that that quickly, it's such a scramble just to get it up and running. But there's always things that you need to clean up and make more efficient.
Kara Swisher
You said this was going to be five or six years and it was in a year. Did you overgrow?
Andy Jassy
No, there are different issues. In the five, six years, we were increasingly having trouble with third-party logistics providers wanting to handle the volume that we needed to scale and the cost structure we need to provide low prices. We anticipated that we were going to have to build a transportation network, a significant one that was that last mile, in probably about six to ten years is what we thought. But then when all that demand came in 2020 and we had to grow so quickly, the third-party logistics providers just didn't want to or couldn't provide that capacity. So we took an effort that we thought would take us six to 10 years to build that transportation network and built it in a couple of years.
On the fulfillment center side, it takes typically about 18 months to build a fulfillment center. In the pandemic, it was taking a couple of years. So when we reversed to 2020, where we're growing 39%, you have to make decisions on what your capacity is going to be in 2022. We weren't sure what was going to happen in 21, let alone 22. We made the decision, which I think was a good decision at the time, that we would err on the side of building more because we didn't want to constrain consumers because we wanted to serve the straits people were in at that time. We also didn't want to constrain sellers. We knew that if we guessed wrong higher, if we were higher than we needed, that we'd eventually grow into that footprint. Virtually always you will see us optimizing for our partners and for our consumers. That's what we did there. I think it was the right call.
Kara Swisher
So the other thing is growing your employee base enormously. You doubled it, right?
Andy Jassy
We grew a lot.
Kara Swisher
Do you feel you have to do a pullback on that now for the short term at least?
Andy Jassy
Well, I think that where a lot of the growth came was in our fulfillment network. I think that we have done a lot of the work that we needed to over the last several months to kind of get our employee base to be the size that fits where the business is right now. So I don't think that you'll see us hiring at the same rates that we did the last couple few years, but we'll be hiring.
Kara Swisher
You'll be hiring, not laying off.
Andy Jassy
Yeah, that's my anticipation.
Kara Swisher
So one of the issues is obviously unionization efforts. You've talked a lot about it. We talked about it before. You've had a view that employees are better off without a union. You talk about it as ultimately the choice of users. I'd love to get a sense from you why you oppose unionization so vehemently if you believe the workers should choose.
Andy Jassy
Well, I wouldn't say that we oppose it so vehemently. And to your point, it's not our choice. At the end of the day, our employees will decide. We think, and we've been pretty clear about this, that we think employees are better off in the structure they're in right now. In part because we hire builders, and I think there are a lot of times you see things that you could do better for customers on the line or better for employees, where in our current structure, they can go meet with a few people and change it. Whereas if you're working through a union, it's slow and it's bureaucratic and it's very hard to change anything.
I also think it's really useful when you're in a company together to have a direct relationship with your manager and for us to be able to hear your voice as opposed to it all being filtered through one union representative. But if you want to have the structure we've got today, you have to have really compelling benefits. That's what we've spent the last number of years trying to do. We pioneered the $15 minimum wage. Today, the starting average salary is $18 an hour. Get full insurance benefits and 401k and 20 weeks of parental leave. And we also, for our fulfillment center employees who want to get a college education, will pay for their college education through a program we have called Career Choice.
Kara Swisher
So you think you can provide better benefits?
Andy Jassy
I think that set of benefits is very unusual.
Kara Swisher
How do they redress grievances? I mean, there were always those stories about drivers and going to the bathroom and this and that. How do they then get to address grievances if you're the one handing out the bennies to them, essentially?
Andy Jassy
Well, I mean, that's true in any company. If you're going to have a place where people are productive and happy and want to be there, we have a lot of mechanisms where employees can tell us what they don't like or what they think is going wrong. We have mechanisms that we can do it on a daily basis. It shows up on all the screens. Managers look at it every day. We made all sorts of changes really from direct employee feedback.
Kara Swisher
But what about mechanisms of power though? Because a suggestion box is different than a union which can hold you up.
Andy Jassy
Again, I think if we didn't act on a lot of the requests from employees, I think we'd have a different situation than we have today. We get a ton of feedback. We've made so many changes in so many areas. Like anything, you have to prove it over a period of time. I think employees have to decide at the end of the day in our fulfillment centers, do they prefer to have the compelling set of benefits they have today with us and work directly with us and have a voice and input? Or do they want the union structure where they'll pay some sort of meaningful fee to the union? And it's unclear what benefits they'll get, whether it'll be as good as what they have now or not. But employees will get to make that choice.
Kara Swisher
Were you surprised that they won in Staten Island?
Andy Jassy
Well, I think if you look at that, we only have one facility right now that has voted for a union, the one in Staten Island you mentioned. We were surprised at that time. There are a lot of irregularities in that vote, which is why we've filed the objections that we have. But again, I think one of the reasons why we've had the structure as long as we've had and employees have been willing to continue to work in that structure is because I think the benefits are compelling, and I think they're really good jobs.
Kara Swisher
That's going to be your argument. The benefits are compelling. You now pay $15?
Andy Jassy
We average $18 an hour in starting salary.
Kara Swisher
Why not just say $25 minimum wage?
Andy Jassy
Well, again, remember, the federal minimum wage is $7.25.
Kara Swisher
You sort of swallowed when I said that.
Andy Jassy
Well, you know, I'm trying to be respectful, Kara. But the federal minimum wage is $7.25.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, that's wrong.
Andy Jassy
It would be a great place to start for the federal government to bring it up to $15. That would be great. As I mentioned, we're at about 18 now. I think the other thing to remember in all these businesses is that you have to build a business that has sustainable economics. The retail space, and we're not different, is a mid-single-digit operating income business. If you think about we have a million plus employees in our fulfillment center, there is a limit to the economics you can pay and have a business that can be profitable. That's what you got to always look at. You got to have economics that you believe can make the business work over a long period of time and that you also feel like are competitive in that space. I think our benefits and our compensation is quite competitive in that space.
Ad break
Kara Swisher
We'll be back in a moment with more from Andy Jassy at Code.
Ad: Avoiding your unfinished home projects because you're not sure where to start? Thumbtack knows homes, so you don't have to. Don't know the difference between matte paint finish and satin, or what that clunking sound from your dryer is? With Thumbtack, you don't have to be a home pro. You just have to hire one. You can hire top-rated pros, see price estimates, and read reviews all on the app. Download today.
We're back. Now, more from Code.
Okay, on that same genre of work, what does it look like now of the staff employees at headquarters? You built that strange thing in Seattle, the bubble. What do you call it?
Andy Jassy
The spheres?
Kara Swisher
The spheres, whatever. It's strange. The bubble? Whatever. I don't like it.
Andy Jassy
I don't like it.
Kara Swisher
In any case, it's fine. I don't like a lot of things.
Andy Jassy
I'll give you a tour. It's pretty interesting.
Kara Swisher
I'm excited. I will do it. [Sarcastically] Sound excited.
Andy Jassy
I'll probably be the only person there.
Kara Swisher
How are you thinking about remote work right now? Because I'm going to ask this of Tim Cook later, but there's a huge sea change in terms of people are staying home, getting stuff delivered by Amazon, including desks and things like that. And you have an employee base that also doesn't want to come into work, the headquarters staff.
Andy Jassy
I think that it's an evolving work in progress. We decided about a year ago that while people had different opinions on what they thought they were going to want to do coming out of the pandemic, when you really spoke in depth with folks, nobody really knew how they were going to feel. But what they did want was some level of control over how they came back to work. We decided about a year ago that we would allow directors of teams to make the decision for their own teams. For teams that work on hardware or some of the creative areas, they tend to be in the office most of the time. There are other teams who tend to work largely remotely, particularly engineering teams when they're in the coding process. Most teams come in with some mix between in-office and out.
I don't really believe that we're going to end up coming back to the office, not just we, meaning collectively, quite the same way we did before. I think there was a lot more remote working than people realized before.
Kara Swisher
Right, right.
Andy Jassy
I continue to think there will be a significant amount of remote work. Do I think that we have the balance right today? I don't know. We're doing a lot of experimenting.
Kara Swisher
Are you trying to require people? Some companies, like banks, are doing that.
Andy Jassy
Yeah, I know.
Kara Swisher
The Washington Post is doing that.
Andy Jassy
Yeah, we haven't at this point. We're doing a lot of experimenting. Last year, we did a lot of experimenting. All sorts of teams are trying different ways. We're trying to look at what, at the end of the day, we have to deliver the right results for customers. People understand whether they work remotely or in the office, that that has to be the number one priority. We're trying lots of experiments and we'll see over the next year. We don't have a plan to require people to come back.
Kara Swisher
You don't.
Andy Jassy
We don't right now. But we're going to proceed adaptively as we learn.
Kara Swisher
And you imagine you're not going to make them?
Andy Jassy
I don't know. I mean, I...
Kara Swisher
Is there any benefit for having them? Creativity?
Andy Jassy
I think that... I do think there are some things that are harder to do remotely. I think it's a little harder to invent remotely. If you have conversations, so much easier to riff with one another when you're in person. Whereas you're on video, everyone's so respectful, you wait till everyone finishes.
Kara Swisher
Not everybody, but yeah, respectful.
Andy Jassy
I think it's also a little bit easier to have a connection with people and to get the culture. We have a culture that's very direct. So you have a meeting, you have a lot of people questioning the presenter. It's much easier after those meetings when you're in person to say, "Hey, Kara, that's a tough topic. It's not surprising it's going to take two or three times. Next time, come in and focus on those first two things." Those types of things are just much harder to do remotely. They're things that bond people together and make people feel more part of a team. I think that even if we end up in a scenario that largely looks like where we are today, we're going to want to be really intentional about having people come back and see each other once in a while.
Kara Swisher
So I do want to get to products and other things you're making. But it's hard not having Senator Klobuchar here with the bill, the antitrust bill, which you've been very active. Jeff did not go to Washington as much as you do. I hear about you all the time. And you haven't called me, but that's OK. But you're in Washington a lot. And this bill, you and all of tech have put a lot of money against it. At the same time, there's investigations from the FTC, I think, and the Justice Department, of all the companies, including you. How are you looking at regulation at this moment? And what is wrong with this antitrust bill from your perspective?
Andy Jassy
Well, I think that the antitrust bill, the Klobuchar-Grassley bill, it's just so broad and overreaching and vague. I think part of the problem is that when you're explicitly targeting five companies and they're all a little bit different from each other, Meta's different from Apple, different from Google, different from Amazon, different from Microsoft, the only way you can build legislation that addresses all those issues is to have it be very broad and pretty vague.
As written today, it's got a few big problems. First, it forces us to allow any third-party logistics provider to fulfill Prime. We've spent $100 billion plus over the last 10 years building a very large fulfillment center network and sort centers in the middle and delivery stations and vans and all kinds of software machinery inside. It's really difficult to take an order and to be able to get it to someone's door in two days and increasingly one day. We've used third-party logistics providers to fulfill Prime 3.4, and they just can't consistently deliver it in the same time frame that we do. We have 200 million plus Prime members who like Prime in significant part because they get their shipments in a couple of days. I think that that has a real chance to significantly degrade the quality of Prime and potentially eradicate it if we can't deliver the shipments in a couple few days.
The second thing is that we have 500,000 small, medium-sized sellers who sell on Amazon. They don't sell on Amazon because they had e-commerce software that's easy and inexpensive to get. They do it because they get access to a few hundred million customers. It's completely changed the size and the capabilities of their business. If you look at the self-preferencing language as written today, it's very broad and very vague. We can't order our search results by Prime eligible, which is how our 200 million plus Prime members want it. Or use bestsellers or personalized lists if we have a private label product that comes above maybe a similar third party product.
You take that kind of broad self-preferencing language, you layer on top of it that the penalties, if you make a mistake, are so extraordinary. They're tens of billions of dollars with the way they've set them up. That would wipe out all the profits that we have each year. Then you layer on top of that an adjudication process where the FTC, which has a leader, Lina Khan, who's not the most objective as it comes to Amazon.
Kara Swisher
She made her career on a paper in law school. I believe that's why they picked her, but go ahead. It's probably right.
Andy Jassy
She made her career on saying break up Amazon, where they can file a complaint and we get to try to prove why we're innocent as opposed to the other way around. When you have that broad self-preferencing with the crazy high penalties and then not the fairest adjudication process, we have to look at as a leadership team, how many items can we let third party sell against without creating too much risk, which would really be very negative for half a million sellers.
Kara Swisher
The broader issue of too big of a size, one of the things you've been investigated for is being a marketplace and a seller. Is there a point where companies like yourselves are too big? I've heard, I would say a dozen different companies. And I've seen it on Amazon, Away Luggage. Suddenly you have a version of it. Suddenly you have a version of it. Suddenly you have a lot of information. I know Jeff has talked about in Congress about sometimes the lines get blurred. Should you have an ability to have a marketplace and sell? Should there be some rules in place?
Same thing for Apple, the App Store, et cetera. Look, what you're really talking about is private label. And we didn't invent private label. Private label is a 120-year-old practice.
Andy Jassy
You need more power than giant food. Actually, I mean, if you look at Walmart, look at Target, look at Kroger's, look at CVS, I mean, lots of companies do private label. And so my point of view on this, Kara, is that if we've decided that we want to relook at how private label works, I think that's a completely reasonable stance. Let's have that conversation. But let's have that conversation holistically. Instead of the way it's being done is this legislation you're talking about only targets companies who have $550 billion in market cap or higher, which conveniently leaves out the Senator's hometown company of Target. It leaves out Walmart, who's bigger than Amazon in the U.S. It leaves out all the other companies I mentioned. So if you want to relook at private label, let's relook at it. Let's relook at it online. Let's relook at it offline, where it happens in a very broad way.
Kara Swisher
Right.
Andy Jassy
But today, that's not really what we're doing. And I also think, I know one of the things you talked about when we talked about my coming and speaking was that you're looking for solutions.
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Andy Jassy
To me, there is such a crazy us versus them mentality in this country right now everywhere, including in how government is thinking about some of these larger companies. There aren't many, if any, big issues that have ever been solved by scapegoating or demonizing a group of people. And that's kind of what's happening right now. I actually think that we have a much better chance of solving an issue that we may want to regulate in a way that doesn't unintentionally hurt consumers or small and medium-sized businesses if the private and public sector work together and collaborate on that. That has not been something that groups are willing to do so far.
Kara Swisher
The tech industry's put $95 million in ads. I've seen so many ads that Amy Klobuchar's breaking the internet. I don't believe she's breaking the internet. You all play tough, too, if they're playing tough on the same way.
Andy Jassy
Look, we've been very clear for many months, and we've shared this with everybody, including the senator, that let's figure out what we want to regulate. If you want to actually stop censorship of data, write a bill about that. If you want to change the way data privacy is conducted, write a bill about that. If you want to actually, you know, you could argue about the retail business, which is wildly competitive. I mean, we have 1% worldwide market segment share.
Kara Swisher
You dominate online.
Andy Jassy
Yeah, but 85% of retail care is physical. That's who we compete with.
Kara Swisher
Well, I mean, okay, 85%. That's who we compete with for share.
Andy Jassy
And so you can decide if you need to regulate retail. But if you are, be specific. If you want to change private label, let's have that conversation. Let's have it together. We have a better chance of solving the problem together than really trying to go get people and demonize people the way it's been done today.
Kara Swisher
There has been no legislation for Internet companies ever. I mean, there's been no regulation. Every other industry has this happen to them. I don't know if it's demonizing or it's just your time to be regulated. I mean, you've probably seen a lot of the press and a lot of this speaking and a lot of the comments. It's not just, "Hey, it's time to find some sensible regulations for some of these larger technology companies." It's not how it's being positioned.
Andy Jassy
And if you really cared about doing it the right way, you would really get that input and you'd work together on solving it. That's just not what's happened so far.
Kara Swisher
We'll be back after another quick break.
Break
Support for Pivot comes from LinkedIn. From talking about sports, discussing the latest movies, everyone is looking for a real connection to the people around them. But it's not just person to person, it's the same connection that's needed in business. And it can be the hardest part about B2B marketing, finding the right people, making the right connections. But instead of spending hours and hours scavenging social media feeds, you can just tap LinkedIn ads to reach the right professionals. According to LinkedIn, they have grown to a network of over 1 billion professionals, making it stand apart from other ad buys. You can target your buyers by job title, industry, company roles, seniority skills, and company revenue, giving you all the professionals you need to reach in one place. So you can stop wasting budget on the wrong audience and start targeting the right professionals only on LinkedIn ads. LinkedIn will even give you $100 credit on your next campaign so you can try it for yourself. Just go to linkedin.com slash pivot pod. That's linkedin.com slash pivotpod. Terms and conditions apply. Only on LinkedIn ads.
We're back. Now, more from my conversation with Amazon CEO, Andy Jassy. And so you being able to sell and buy on a marketplace, that's the Amazon issue primarily that they're looking at in Washington. With Apple, it's the app store, Google, it's the search market. What is the sensible solution from your perspective to that? If we're looking forward, which I want to do, like what is, of these brands that are worried about, there's so many brands that are worried about being on Amazon. They don't know what you're going to do because you could do anything because you have such power in the online space.
Andy Jassy
Well, again, I mean, I'm trying, I'm deciding whether I should take that bait or not.
Kara Swisher
Okay, yeah, I think you should. I'm asking for a solution. Andy, I just want a solution so we can all get along.
Andy Jassy
Yeah, I would disagree with you about the power comment. And I think that when you've got two million sellers and a half million in the U.S. who are making a very different living because of their access to a few hundred million customers, I think you can always find certain sellers who will tell you things that we need to do better. And by the way, there are a lot of things we need to do better. We have a long list ourselves, but the overwhelming majority of sellers and feedback we get is very positive. But to your solutions question, it's what I said earlier. We should pick what we want to solve. Instead of like, this bill, I don't know how much you've looked at this bill.
Kara Swisher
I've looked very carefully at this bill.
Andy Jassy
It is so broad and so vague and so overreaching that it's going to do a lot of unintended harm. And so if we want to, look, I think there's a real argument to talk about some of the things you want to do with respect to privacy. I think that if people want to actually try and solve or change private label and address it a different way, we're very open to that conversation. But let's do it.
Kara Swisher
Is there too big for many of these companies? Because it does feel, through the pandemic, it certainly felt like tech companies, and your stocks reflected that, own the world?
Andy Jassy
I think you have to look at it case by case. So, in our retail business, we have 1% of worldwide market segment share in retail. In our AWS business, 90 to 95% of the global IT spend is on-premises. Just because we've had successful customer experiences in business in multiple areas that in combination make us a larger company doesn't mean that we have market power or some sort of monopoly in each of the areas in which we operate. People don't have to choose Amazon. You may not remember, but we launched a phone, and not a lot of people ended up using our phone. So the reason that we have significant businesses in various areas is that we've done a lot of inventing and tried to build really compelling customer experiences, and I think we've done so. But we still have relatively small market segments here in all those areas.
Kara Swisher
You're so small, Andy. It's so sad how small. You know, it's because you started there as a, it's not a disease of Silicon Valley, but a lot of people, whether it's Apple or Google, we're just small potatoes here. And I'm like, you're a billionaire. Like I often, I'm not, well, I'm sure you are, but the, I don't have any idea. But they do, there is this idea that you're still nimble and young and fresh and stuff like that, when you may be a little frightening to people. I think it's a really interesting thing. You don't have to take that bait. So one of the things that you and I did discuss last time, and I do want to talk about next generation things, was a spinoff of AWS. Many think it would be more valuable stock. There was talk of breakup. I think that's going nowhere, probably, in general. This is not an AT&T time. You've made the case for keeping it together. Do you see you spinning off any of your divisions at all?
Andy Jassy
We don't have a plan to do so. It's kind of the same thing we talked about last time.
Kara Swisher
Not at all.
Andy Jassy
Not at all. We don't have a plan to do so.
Kara Swisher
Not a plan to do so. When you're thinking, let's talk a little bit about the future. You talked about the things you've been doing. You've had bookstores. You've got all kinds of things. Jeff said Prime, Marketplace, and AWS were the three pillars of Amazon. What do you imagine the fourth is? Or do you need another pillar? Those are pretty good pillars.
Andy Jassy
It's a good question. We're working hard on trying to find additional businesses that could be pillars. So One Medical. I think there's a number of potential answers. It could end up being streaming entertainment. It could end up being Alexa. It could end up being transportation with what we're doing with Zoox. It could end up being the low-Earth orbital satellite that we're building with Kuiper. And it could end up being health care. I mean, those are all possibilities.
Kara Swisher
Talk about your health care purchase of One Medical. What is the thinking about it? Now, we talked yesterday. Someone said, well, if you just even replace Amazon's own medical needs, it pays for itself. Like, if you can save some money. How do you look at what you're doing?
Andy Jassy
Well, I often find that my kids roll their eyes when I tell them I didn't grow up with the Internet. In the same way we rolled our eyes when our parents said there was no color TV. And I think if you fast forward 10 years from now and you tell people that the way to get a primary care appointment was that you had to call, wait three to four weeks, drive yourself 20 minutes to the doctor, park the car, wait in the waiting room for 15 minutes, get called into an exam room, wait 15 minutes for a doctor. They come in for five minutes, prescribe you something, drive 20 minutes to the pharmacy. People are going to think you're out of your mind.
But that has been the primary care experience for the last many decades. And I think that's going to be radically different. I think that you're going to be able to have an app that has the relevant medical information for you there. You'll be able to ask quick questions via chat. You'll be able to have video appointments. If you need to see someone in person, you'll have an omni-channel solution where you can go in and get an appointment same day or next day. The doctors, at a place like One Medical, the doctors spend 30 to 60 minutes with patients.
Kara Swisher
I've been there.
Andy Jassy
Oh, good.
Kara Swisher
And then they're going to prescribe medicine that shows up at your door. That's a very, very different experience. And if there's one area that really needs to be reinvented, very obviously it's health care in our country. And I think we have an opportunity.
So doing it through services is the way you want to do it. And then you can deliver drugs or whatever they need. You know a lot about me. I use Amazon all the time.
Andy Jassy
But you don't know about me.
Kara Swisher
I know. I hope you're not doing that. That would be creepy and illegal. But you know a lot about the customer, right? You know a lot about what they want. One of the things I've been thinking about is these enveloping relationships you have with certain companies. Amazon, I definitely have one that's a very, I'm not going to say intimate, but it is. I use it a lot. Apple's another one. Disney, I have small children and more small children now. Disney is a relationship I have. Is healthcare that idea of creating this soup to nuts company that surrounds the customer of fulfillment? Is that how you look at it?
Andy Jassy
No, I mean, it comes back to what I mentioned earlier, which is, we decide to make investments in areas if we ask ourselves a few questions. A little different from maybe how other people do it. We don't pay much attention to pro forma P&Ls. We do them. But what we really ask is if we invest in it and it was successful, could it be big and move the needle for customers? Such as health care.
Kara Swisher
Such as health care.
Andy Jassy
Is it being well served today? Do we have some sort of differentiated approach? And do we have competence there? And if not, can we acquire it quickly? And if we like the answers to those questions, then we'll pursue an area. And the goal in pursuing that area is to change the customer experience and make customers' lives better and easier. So when we look at health care, really at the center of your experience is your primary health care experience. It's when you need to go see the doctor. There's something wrong and you want to know. And that experience is in dire need of being reinvented. We think One Medical has built something really remarkable there. And then we believe that in combination with them, that we can provide an additionally compelling experience. So you're going to need prescriptions. And we have a pharmacy that we're building. And you might need nutritional information, health information. Those are things that we have books and food and things of that sort that we think we can be useful over time.
Kara Swisher
Ah, I see you have an ulcer. Would you like this book on meditation?
Andy Jassy
Again, we'll be very thoughtful. I think we've been very thoughtful stewards of data over time, and we will be thoughtful here too. But to me, data is useful to customers if you use it to make their customer experience better and their lives better. So let's go all the way back to retail. Think about how many items many of us have found through Amazon, looking at what you've bought before and recommending items we think you might like based on similar aggregated folks who've bought things of the same milk. And so it makes your life better when you can do that. And we're going to try and improve that customer experience. We think that experience is going to be radically different. It really needs to be reinvented. And we're excited about being a part of that.
Kara Swisher
Are you expecting pushback from Lina Khan, who doesn't like you? I don't know. Do you think? You must have discussed it at a meeting.
Andy Jassy
We might have.
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Andy Jassy
I don't know. It's hard for me to tell. But we feel that's a very, very large space of which One Medical is a very, very small share.
Kara Swisher
It's interesting because when I interviewed her, one of the things she asked me afterwards is, what did I think of the MGM? I'm like, it's so competitive in Hollywood. You're not going to win that. I'm not a lawyer, but whatever. MGM has 1% of the film.
Andy Jassy
Thank you, Kara.
Kara Swisher
Well, but I didn't. If it was something else, I'm like, yeah, definitely sue them. But in this case, I didn't think. So lastly, I want to finish up, and then we'll get some questions, is you just released Lord of the Rings, the new Lord of the Rings. You've seen a lot of change in the entertainment space. It's very competitive right now. There's a real contraction in streaming, or there's a real competition, really, in streaming. Netflix is sort of on the ropes a little bit, although they still provide a great service as far as I'm concerned. What is your, in 2019 you won 15 Emmys. You got smaller this year. How do you look at this business? I don't quite still know what your theory is in it. How serious are you about the entertainment business?
Andy Jassy
Serious. We're in it for the long haul. We're really excited about it and we're really committed to it. I think that, as I was mentioning earlier, I think most media is going to be streaming, TV, film, audio, music. It's even, I think, over time, gaming. I think most entertainment is going to be streaming. And we've invested a lot of resource and time building what I think is the very best viewing experience in streaming, the quality of streaming, which is why so many third-party media companies have Amazon Channels. And we're also very committed and focused on building the best selection of streaming items that people can consume.
Kara Swisher
You don't have IP, just you're in the same situation as Netflix. Apple's in the same situation. I mean, Disney and others have, Warner does. Do you see yourself buying a big studio to get that?
Andy Jassy
Well, we did buy MGM. We have Amazon Studios, which I think is building a pretty significant amount of great content. We have MGM, which is really an amazing catalog and team. But I think that our streaming collection will be a combination of our original content, as well as third-party media companies having channels. And you see that with Discovery Plus, you see it with Paramount+. A number of companies have channels on Prime Video that allow people to see much broader selection and that also allow them to build a subscription business. So I think in the earliest days, our Prime Video efforts and our entertainment business, it makes our Prime subscription even more compelling.
I think it's an incredible value at the current price right now if you look at everything that's in there. But it makes it a very significant value proposition for customers. And a lot of people who, we have an increasing number of people who sign up for Prime because of the entertainment offering, and it turns out that a lot of them end up buying e-commerce items for us as well, so it pushes the consumers by well. I think over time our entertainment business has an opportunity to be a successful business in its own right, independent of what it pushes downstream.
Kara Swisher
Is it profitable now?
Andy Jassy
We don't disclose that information.
Kara Swisher
No, it's not. But are you worried about what do you think is going to happen in the streaming business? There's consolidation or there's so many players now? And I just got a notice from Hulu, they're adding higher prices.
Andy Jassy
Yeah. You guys charge a little more. I think one of the big questions that's unknown is how many subscriptions will people have? Over time when people aren't tethered to cable or DirecTV, how many subscriptions will people have? How much are people willing to pay per year for them? Which ones? Will people subscribe to certain ones? How many will they subscribe to all year versus just for a series that they want to watch and kind of jump in and out of that subscription? I think it's all TBD.
Kara Swisher
TBD. So last question, and then we'll get to questions from the audience. What is the biggest challenge you think both this country and tech and business faces right now? And what are you most excited about?
Andy Jassy
That's a very easy question.
Kara Swisher
That's not an easy question, yeah.
Andy Jassy
Well, some of the challenges are different maybe than some of the things I'm most excited about. I mean, I really, as I mentioned earlier, I think we're at a point in this country, and it's true around the world, but in this country too right now. I mean, leaving out, of course, the obvious, the economy is a very serious challenge for everybody. But I feel like we don't talk with one another today in this country. We just kind of talk at people, and people seem very unwilling to listen to one another. They seem very intolerant if you have a different view from the other person, and they just quickly turn them off.
And I think the country was founded on people arguing and debating with one another, but getting to a reasonable compromise. Because when you have as many people as we have in this country, they don't have an all-one belief system. And we've got to remember that we have to govern and we have to build communities and build businesses that work for the broad number of people we have here. So I am worried about that. I'm also quite worried about education, where I think if you look in this country, we are now 35th of 50 developed countries in the world in education. And if we don't think that's going to have an impact on our kids and our kids' kids and on our competitiveness as a country over time, we are kidding ourselves.
We've got to change that. And I think we want to try and participate in all the challenges that we see, including the ones I mentioned. I think there are so many unsolved problems and customer experiences. A lot of times people say to us, "Gosh, it seems like you're pursuing a lot of different businesses. Is that prudent?" And for us, we have a different way of looking at it than other people. But where we ask those four questions I mentioned earlier, and we believe that there's a compelling answer to go pursue it, we're going to solve it. And there are so many, I mean, those are the customer experiences that we're going after today that we believe we can really change people's lives for the better.
But there are a lot more, some of which we're pursuing that we can't talk about yet, and others of which we haven't even imagined or learned about. But there are quite a few challenges. And we believe we can bring customer focus and invention to those. And we're excited about going after trying to make it better.
Kara Swisher
We didn't get to talk about stores. I have some thoughts about your stores.
Andy Jassy
Okay. Well, anytime you just come on Amazon.com.
Kara Swisher
I will. I will. It's called merchandising. But anyway, let's go. Questions from the audience.
Audience Member 1
Hi there. As a primary care physician, I'm quite excited about Amazon and big tech trying to disrupt health care, create a better experience for patients. But thinking about the healthcare worker side, given the high rate of burnout among nurses and doctors, if Amazon was to become a new healthcare overlord, looking at the reports of Amazon warehouse workers being clocked for every minute of productivity and time in the bathroom, there's concern about what that looks like for healthcare workers. So my question to you is, what is your argument for why doctors and nurses should come work for Amazon Health?
Andy Jassy
Well, I'd say a few things. First of all, as you know, we acquired One Medical. And they have, I think, a customer experience and a physician experience that's quite good. And we didn't acquire them to change what they were doing. Especially, we paid a lot of money for that. We have a lot of admiration and respect for what they do. And I think that if you look at their customer satisfaction scores, if you look at their retention scores, if you listen to what physicians say about working at One Medical, it's very positive and very compelling. I don't think doctors like the habit trail that they're on so often.
The experience I mentioned, which is the typical experience today where you go through all that and you spend five minutes rushing through an opinion with a customer. I don't think doctors are like that either. I think doctors want to, you get in that profession to help people. And I think that they want to help people. So the fact that One Medical has appointments that customers choose whether they want a 30-minute appointment or a 60-minute appointment, and physicians get to spend the requisite time to talk to patients and to tell them what's happening and to talk about solutions and to answer questions, I think is very compelling, and we don't have any intention of changing that.
Kara Swisher
That's interesting. Habitrail is a good word. So thank you for being here.
Audience Member 2
I had a question for you around gaming. And A, what role will gaming have going forward for Amazon? And B, what do you plan to do differently to get there?
Andy Jassy
Well, we have, it's hard to build good games. I think people know that. And we have certainly learned over the last number of years that it's difficult. We've had some better successes over the last year or so, but it's hard to do it well. It requires really extraordinary talent, it requires a lot of creativity, it takes a long time. It's not like you churn out a new game in a year, it takes several years. It's a highly creative process and increasingly I think it's a highly technical endeavor with the way you're able to use compute to change what those customer experiences are like. So we're excited about the games that we're building. We have a number of studios that we've built over the last few years. They're all working on games that will take a few years to build.
Kara Swisher
Any purchases? Electronic Arts apparently is out there.
Andy Jassy
I can't believe everything you read, Kara.
Kara Swisher
I can. Some of it.
Andy Jassy
But we're committed to it, and we think we have an opportunity to build great games. And I think we have, most significant game developers use AWS to build their games. And we have people internally who understand how to use AWS as well to create new experiences. And that's what we're going to do.
Kara Swisher
Great. I do believe everything I read, and especially the Washington Post is where I read that. But go ahead.
Audience Member 3
Hey, Andy. I do not work for the Washington Post. I'm Jason Del Rey. I write about Amazon for Recode. Two quick questions. One on health care. I recently spoke to a nurse who worked at Amazon Care and loved the fact that she could spend time with patients, unlike her experience, especially in COVID, in emergency rooms. So I'm curious, you announced One Medical. At the same time, you're going to shut down Amazon Care, which was an experiment to provide telehealth and in-home. Is there a future for in-home care at Amazon in the future, even with the Amazon Care closing? And then I have one clarification question on a private label.
Andy Jassy
Well, we decided, we learned a lot doing Amazon Care, and customers really liked the offering. But as we got further along in Amazon Care, we realized that the business model we were pursuing was not going to scale well, and it was more of a business-to-business offering as opposed to a business-to-consumer offering, or they could do both, and so we had decided before the One Medical acquisition that we were going to wind down Amazon Care. I do think the piece of Amazon Care that's unique, differentiated, where I do think there's some future for it, you have to find the right business model, is the in-person care. It's hard to find the right economic model, have people come to people's houses and to be able to charge enough to pay for that. So we're still working on that. But that could be something that we continue to work on over time.
Kara Swisher
Okay. We can't go to second. I know, Luther, just admit, we don't have a lot of time. But here, I want to do people who haven't asked questions before. Go right here.
Audience Member 4
All right. Thanks, Kara. And thanks, Andy. I appreciate all that you do with your customer focus. I have a package arriving at my home in a few minutes from Amazon. So thank you. One thing that surprises me is that you talk about really readily about your opposition to Staten Island. And the employees there found a value proposition. Employees across Amazon are finding a value proposition to unionization. So first question is, what's your budget, your 2023 budget for union busting? And more seriously, what are some of the countermeasures that you're thinking about to maybe prevent, avert the sentiment that these employees have?
Andy Jassy
Well, what I would tell you is that we have one facility out of the thousands that we have that have voted for a union at this point. And I think if you look at the details of that vote, there are a lot of very disturbing irregularities. If you haven't read the objections that we wrote, it's worth reading. And I think that's going to take a long time to play out, because I think it's unlikely the NLRB is going to find against themselves. So I think we haven't had it. It hasn't been a huge, broad union issue. But look, it's really what I said earlier. At the end of the day, we have to provide a really compelling set of benefits and experience for fulfillment center employees and they'll make the choice whether that's more compelling than whatever risk there is and paying a union fee and seeing what they get in comparison.
Kara Swisher
All right, we have one more question. Luther, I'm sorry but you've asked questions so I'd love to people who haven't. So you get the last question right here.
Audience Member 5
Oh hi. Glazier, how you doing? Sorry. This guy, thank you. Hi, Andy Barry Fry. I actually live in your old neighborhood. Great work you've done. I also run the global out-of-home trade organization. There's a big trend afoot in retail and with brands to put advertising in stores, Walmart, Target, screens, etc. You are planning more retail growth. You've also got a plethora of vans all around the world that could have screens on it. Do you ever consider those screens in stores, screens to A, B, an advertising vehicle, as well as B, to promote your video series on television?
Andy Jassy
And also Amazon's having a very significant advertising business now.
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Andy Jassy
So, I mean, the short answer to that is yes. I think that we're exploring all sorts of ways that we can provide value-added to the customer advertising. Our advertising business today — most of the team are machine learning experts who spend all their time trying to make sure that they're surfacing relevant items for people.
I think if you look in physical stores, there's a real opportunity to do that as well. Screens are part of it. But even if you think about the idea of what digital couponing could be over time, I think that's a real opportunity. If you know what people like to buy, you can provide them coupons that are relevant to what they tend to buy, as opposed to just random items.
So we are experimenting a little bit with our vans. You may have seen here in L.A. the *Rings of Power* images that we have in some of our delivery vans. So we're exploring that. And like everything, we're experimenting and learning what works and then trying to roll out things that do.
Kara Swisher
Okay, Rob. Very short. Very short.
Audience Member 5
Well, good seeing you, Andy. I have a question about Fire TV and third-party apps. There's a company that we spun out called Scenor that makes an app that does video co-watching and search. We submitted it to the store. We were told, "Please do it for the next version." We did it for the next version of Fire TV. And then we were told very politely but very firmly by the folks in question, "No, we don't want that to be a third-party app. We want to control that feature ourselves."
So my two-part question is: what goes into the thinking around that for why Amazon wouldn't want to have an open platform? And then if that really is the thinking, isn't Senator Klobuchar more right than wrong?
Andy Jassy
Well, I don't — without the details of what you're talking about, it's a very hard question to answer. I would encourage — I'm AJS at Amazon dot com. You should feel free to write me and give me the details.
But I would disagree with you about the notion that we don't have or want an open platform. If you look at the amount of third-party content that you can find on Fire TV, it's broader than you'll find anywhere else. And I think that, as I mentioned earlier, if you look at what our strategy is and what the customer experience that we want in our streaming business, it's really to have the broadest selection of streaming items anywhere.
So I don't know in that particular case what the programming was or why the team didn't want it. But if you send it to me, I'll run it through the team. I'll see if I can help.
Audience Member 5
I'll get you the feature.
Andy Jassy
Sure.
Audience Member 5
Okay. Andy, you're very thoughtful. I really appreciate it.
Kara Swisher
Great seeing you, Karen. Thank you. We'll have more conversations from Code in the Speed. Stay tuned. Bye.