Main Topic: The podcast episode discusses various topics, including the hacking of Jeff Bezos' phone, the geopolitics between the US and Saudi Arabia, and the implications of big tech companies on global economies.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Support for this show comes from Robinhood. Wouldn't it be great to manage your portfolio on one platform? With Robinhood, not only can you trade individual stocks and ETFs, you can also seamlessly buy and sell crypto at low costs. Trade all in one place. Get started now on Robinhood. Trading crypto involves significant risk. Crypto trading is offered through an account with Robinhood Crypto LLC. Robinhood Crypto is licensed to engage in virtual currency business activity by the New York State Department of Financial Services. Crypto held through Robinhood Crypto is not FDIC-insured or SIPC-protected. Investing involves risk, including loss of principal. Securities trading is offered through an account with Robinhood Financial LLC, member SIPC, a registered broker-dealer.
Love espresso, drip coffee, and cold brew? With the Ninja Luxe Cafe, if you can crave it, you can brew it. Espresso, balanced. Drip coffee, rich. Cold brew in a flash. With barista assist technology, you brew with no stress and no guesswork and make perfect silky microfoam hands-free from dairy or plant-based milks. Shop the Ninja Luxe Cafe at ninjakitchen.com.
Erica Anderson
Hi everyone, this is Pivot from the Vox Media Podcast Network. I'm Kara Swisher—just kidding. This is Erica Anderson in for Kara Swisher. She is not feeling well today, and to my surprise, I got a text asking to step in. So, Scott, how do you feel about that?
Scott Galloway
So, not feeling well, let's be honest, is Latin for cocaine-filled orgy. I want details. This is such bullshit. You're going on probation as an employee of Vox. I got a picture from Cheryl last night where she was out partying with a bunch of her friends. I think things got a little dirty, and now she's nursing the mother of all hangovers, and she tells you to step in. I think this is total bullshit. What was she really up to last night?
Erica Anderson
I mean, Scott, let's be honest. You're projecting. That's more you than Kara. I'm just angry I wasn't invited.
Scott Galloway
If you have the photo, I implore you to post it. Otherwise, I know that Kara doesn't get sick often. So let's be nice to Kara. Or do you want to troll her since she's not on?
Erica Anderson
We'll soon know, as I sent her a video to download on WhatsApp. So I'll soon know everything by the end of the day.
Scott Galloway
Great. All right, good. See, that's some political humor there.
Erica Anderson
Okay, so now that she's out, let's do what we should do best, and that is talk about Kara behind her back.
Scott Galloway
I think Kara is the type of person that remodels a home just so she can drive up in a pickup truck and yell at everybody. Your turn.
Erica Anderson
Yeah, oh, do you? Your turn. Well, I think Kara... I don't know, man. It's so hard. I can't talk shit about my boss, Scott.
Scott Galloway
Oh, that's right. She's your boss.
Erica Anderson
That's right, yeah.
Scott Galloway
She's kind of my boss, too. She doesn't get mad, but she's direct.
Erica Anderson
Oh, she gets even.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, she gets even.
Erica Anderson
It's been a good year working for her. I started a year ago, and we've had some fun experiences, like going on the set of Silicon Valley. I insist that I'm on her rider and get to go in the trailer with her and eat all the food. But the reality of that situation was that she didn't even want to run her lines before the show. So I had to sit her down and prep her. But no, to be honest, she's such a pro. So she's fun to work with.
Scott Galloway
And you were at Twitter and Google before taking this job, right?
Erica Anderson
Yeah. I think my career has been a bit of a... I don't know, it's been all over the place, but actually very specific. I'm obsessed with media, and I'm also really interested in strategy. My work with Kara is combining those two things. How do we take this ecosystem that Kara's built for herself—the column, the podcast, the appearances on CNBC—and make her bigger? It's part editorial strategy and it's part business and partnership. So we kind of do it all together. It's really fun.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, actually, Kara's enabled me to bring two of my favorite things together from a professional aspect: indignance and anger. She's helped me meld those two things.
Erica Anderson
Good. So let's get on. What's the news today?
Scott Galloway
A lot of news, Erica.
Erica Anderson
Yeah, there is. Let's talk about Bezos. Last year, Scott, as you remember, Jeff Bezos had his phone hacked and some embarrassing pictures came out. Well, it turns out now the story that's unfolding is how the hack happened. And spoiler alert, we are back to the Saudis. This week, reports came out that Jeff Bezos had his phone hacked by the Saudi crown prince months before the assassination of the Washington Post journalist Jamal Khashoggi. In 2018, Jeff Bezos had a running WhatsApp conversation with the crown prince of Saudi Arabia, and MBS sent Bezos a corrupt video file, which then got a lot of information on Bezos' phone.
Saudi Arabia denies the claim that they were behind this hack, but experts at the UN say that they have a medium to high confidence that the phone was hacked by the crown prince's corrupted video file sent through WhatsApp. The UN also concluded that the hack likely led to the leak of personal pictures of Jeff Bezos, later leaked to the National Enquirer. The National Enquirer has also denied having any connection to MBS. But before I toss it to you, as part of the UN statement, they added: "At a time when Saudi Arabia was supposedly investigating the killing of Mr. Khashoggi and prosecuting those it deemed responsible, it was waging a massive online campaign against Mr.
Bezos and Amazon, targeting him principally as the owner of The Washington Post." What do you think about that?
Scott Galloway
It reminds me of when Kara and I were talking about Davos. I remember the first time I was at Davos, they had Thomas Friedman speak at a dinner. He talked about the emergence, this was in 1999, of these supranationals or individuals that would take on nation-state-like complexions. They would become so wealthy and so powerful, and because capital can permeate geographic boundaries, they would take on this nation-state feel. It strikes me that in the geopolitical tension between the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia and the US, they've co-opted us mostly by saying, "All right, he's the guy in charge. I'll finance your next 10-carat display of garishness in Lisbon or in Riyadh."
If I'm going to be a source of money for you, I've kind of won you over. It's sickening how silent the administration or what apologists for the kingdom the current administration have been. Now they've essentially decided that this nation-state they're going to war with is Bezos, who has tremendous economic power and also owns the Washington Post, who they clearly see is an adversary to their interests. So they decide to, A, kill journalists and, B, try and discredit Bezos. This is pretty full-body contact, geopolitical, adversarial. I don't know what its term is. This is Thunderdome.
What strikes me is that one of the many things that have weakened us as a nation is the administration's actions embolden people to do things, including killing journalists, including going after our citizens. Does anybody actually think the US is going to do anything? It could also lead to a sense of chaos where you have people worth $150 billion or worth the GDP of Norway decide to take matters into their own hands. He has his own security experts now, his own security team. He has his own vehicle for his own side of the story in the form of one of the great media companies in the world, the Washington Post. So we now have three nation-states going at it: the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, the United States, and Bezos, the country and nation. It's so ripe with tells for our time and our era.
The notion that you're going to see a lot of people refusing to open files—that's the most immediate thing. It also brings up the notion that this very shadowy industry around hacks is not regulated. Supposedly this wasn't a government action, but you can pay people. There are a lot of firms, a lot of them located in Israel, to basically extract information from almost any phone. It's a very shadowy industry that requires more scrutiny and more regulation. It'll be interesting to see how this plays out, whether or not the administration actually acknowledges anything went wrong here, if they continue to be an apologist for Saudi Arabia, or if they just ask them to buy another destroyer or finance another hotel. Not coincidentally, both Jared and his brother Josh were in Saudi Arabia recently. This is really ugly. Unfortunately, when you look at the attention graph, we're all focused on this impeachment. So we're missing things like continents on fire, and we're missing things like geopolitical actions by adversaries that used to be our allies or claimed to be our allies. We're not punching back. We seem to be feckless.
Erica Anderson
What I was just thinking about as you were saying this, it's such a great angle, is that geopolitical conflicts are now being waged through corporations. As these companies are global and they have a footprint around the world and they rely on trade, they're dependent on other countries. One of the ways governments are messing with each other is through these companies. We have Huawei in the US with Trump making it difficult for Huawei to get semiconductors from US manufacturers this year. It's not so subtle anymore, but these big companies are becoming really important tools for these geopolitical chess moves.
Scott Galloway
It all comes down to money. If you have an individual with the GDP of a small northern European nation, we're about to see war break out. It won't be a direct war. It won't be a shooting war. It'll be how wars are fought now: proxy wars using third parties and cyber attacks. They messed with the wrong cowboy. This is an individual who has tremendous resources, has more access to technology and resources. I don't think Bezos is the kind of guy that scares easily. Typically, if an individual was attacked or their security was compromised or they were abused or threatened by a foreign nation, the government would step in and say, "Okay, we got this." Instead, he's going to realize they are going to be apologists and he's going to go around them and start fighting his own proxy wars. So we now not only have geopolitics between nations, we have politics between nations and very wealthy individuals.
Erica Anderson
Yeah, right. It's a strange situation. I remember Bezos' response last year to the leaked photos to the National Enquirer where he basically didn't hold back. It was basically like, "You threatened me. I'm going to come at you." So that's interesting that he's the target. But the thing I want to say before we move on is, what do you think Facebook's response should be to this? WhatsApp, they own it. Do you think they're going to do anything? Do you think they care?
Scott Galloway
I'm always looking for reasons to be angry at Facebook. But in this instance, if a file is transmitted over a technology and that file is then downloaded knowingly by the person and that file contains malware... Supposedly Apple is better, or it's not as easy to send malware over iOS as it is across other platforms or Android. So it's an opportunity for an organization to say, "All right, we're better at screening stuff or checking it." You get those alerts saying, "We weren't able to check this. Download at your own risk." But I don't, at least immediately, see how Facebook here is guilty. A lot of people immediately came out on Twitter and said, "Oh, this is about encryption." I'm like, "Well, no, this is about cyber attacks and about nation-states versus individuals." It's not really about encryption. It's about malware and cyber attacks. So I don't think, at least on the face of it, you can really hold Facebook or WhatsApp accountable here. What are your views? Am I missing something?
Erica Anderson
No, I think that's a good point. There are a few issues here. One is that these tools like WhatsApp and chatting with people are, as Kara would say, being used exactly as they were meant to. The problem is that there are unintentional consequences that occur, which this is one of them. This is a malicious attack, to your point, and it's dangerous. I think one of the biggest issues is the literacy of people who are using these tools. They're at fives or sixes where they should be at tens in terms of understanding how to use this technology. Jeff Bezos probably should have known better not to download something. But I get emails all the time from my family members sending me files saying, "Download it. This is so funny." The thing is, these companies tend to pass that off. They say, "It's not our job to teach society how to use these tools." Maybe they'll invest some money in literacy efforts or training people, but there's a gap. A lot of people just don't understand the severity of their actions using these tools. I think that's a concern. That'll continue to be an issue for these companies.
Scott Galloway
To put a dot on the exclamation point here about how potentially damaging this is, one of my colleagues at NYU, Professor Paul Romer, Nobel Prize winner, such an incredible thinker. He pioneered—he was into cities before it was cool. He was talking about the power of cities, that all the economic growth would go to cities. I don't know if he coined the term, but "when ideas have sex"—people bumping off each other in close proximity creates a tremendous amount of innovation and new ideas. One of the most harmful things around some of these terrorist attacks that involve aircraft is that when people are scared and don't travel, ideas don't travel.
Ideas don't bump off each other. Global commerce comes to a halt. Ideation and people being in the same room comes to a halt. The economy and the global economy becomes less innovative and less productive. The same is true if all of a sudden data gets scared or we get scared to transfer or let data travel. You're just going to have less innovation and less ideas. If all of a sudden we're very reticent to download data, we're very reticent to communicate with people online, we're cautious about the business we can transact online, and all of a sudden the global travel of zeros and ones gets slowed and there's more restrictions put in place, fewer ideas are going to have sex.
This is not only a threat geopolitically, it's a threat to innovation and the productivity of our economy.
Erica Anderson
That's interesting. I think we have gone from zero to a thousand in the last 20 years of sharing ideas and information and traveling across borders, especially for those people who are privileged enough to do it. But I don't know if it's a bad thing that there's a little bit of correction in the other direction.
Scott Galloway
That's an interesting point.
Erica Anderson
My sense of WhatsApp, though, is that it's primarily where it's really gained traction is among a lot of the global middle class or people who couldn't afford traditional long-distance rates across telco. It's just gotten such...
Scott Galloway
True.
Erica Anderson
And again, I'm suddenly a Facebook apologist, but I do think WhatsApp has been an incredible boon for people in terms of some of the onerous long-distance charges they were having to pay through their own local monopolies. Anyway, we shall see.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, we shall see.
Erica Anderson
So listen, the next story I want to talk about, speaking of privacy and data, we're continuing to follow the balance between user privacy with tools like encryption and a government's right to access that information through things like backdoors. In this area, we have Apple Encryption Part 2. This is a story that Reuters came out with a few days ago. It basically said that Apple had been working on an encryption system that would allow iPhone users to fully encrypt all of their iCloud data. Reuters reported that the company halted these efforts after pressure from the FBI to keep that information accessible.
What do you think? This happened a few years ago. Apple sources who were not named in the story said that probably one or two reasons why this feature or this plan got killed. One is the legal team killed it for various reasons that they didn't disclose. The second is that actually users would get super confused and lock themselves out of their iCloud data if this encryption occurred. As a side note, Scott, we should have people on, encryption experts, with you and Kara since we got hundreds of emails about this from listeners. But what's your take on this move from Apple? They're saying, "Look, it's just not true that we're not cooperating with the government.
We've done this around iCloud."
Scott Galloway
I also think that they're coming to the realization slowly but surely that encryption poses a lot of downsides. There are a lot of low-probability, high-severity scenarios that Apple could come under tremendous fire. It's that Jack Bauer moment where we say we don't ever want to torture anybody, and we need to put in place an absolute that we don't torture people. But you find a guy, you find out that there's six nuclear bombs about to go off, and you say, "Okay, it's that Jack Bauer moment." Are there going to be certain moments if we decide to build a fail-safe box?
I want to apologize to the Daniel Kahneman fans or disciples. The Nobel Prize winner wrote this great book around fast and slow thinking. I misquoted him last week saying that people were subject to slow thinking. Slow thinking is actually the good part when you rely on the better notions of your instincts or your brain to slow down and really think through stuff and offer some nuance. I'm worried about the encryption debate that immediately people go to fast thinking and go, "Okay, encryption is Apple, who we like, and Tim Cook seems like a thoughtful, likable guy. And the backdoor solution is Trump and Bill Barr."
It's strange that—and we were talking about this—if you do a heat map of iOS versus Android, basically iOS is Democrat and Android is red state. If you look at a city, concentration around a city and where there's wealth, it lights up iOS for the wealthy areas and it lights up Android for the lesser wealthy areas. The general compact with people around Android is, "We'll molest your data, and in exchange for that, we'll give you cheaper phones, cheaper data." And iOS has said, "You deserve privacy. Privacy is now a luxury item. You'll have to pay more, but we'll only pull 80 to 120 data points."
Where that heads is that people immediately assume this debate. They take a shortcut because they're busy and they go, "OK, encryption bad because it equals Trump and Barr." But if you look back at what Obama said, "We should be able to find a solution." To go immediately to an absolutist, to fetishize the phone—Hillary Clinton and Bernie Sanders both said there should be some compromise here. There should be some middle ground. So I hope this debate moves from attaching it to Tim Cook or Donald Trump to actually the issue, and that we do it, as Mr. Kahneman suggested, and take advantage of our frontal lobe and cortex and have some slow thinking around this.
Erica Anderson
I think slow thinking is right. I think what Kara was saying in the episode last week was that there just has to be a public debate on this. It can't happen behind closed doors. It's an interesting debate about this being completely politicized. On your point on Android versus iOS, Android has historically had lower price points. That was the whole reason they scaled pretty quickly. But they just came out with the Pixel, which obviously they're trying to get into that market, which is the same price point as the Apple iPhone. But listen, I think from an optics standpoint, we have Trump tweeting last week that Apple should kind of get on board and help the government. And then it's kind of like the right hand maybe not knowing what the left hand is doing, the other side of the government working closely with Apple. But the reality is, I don't know if it's that. Trump might know all of this. It's just the fact that he's building a narrative. He's building an us versus them narrative, which is the great creativity and the great thing to watch of this administration—they know how to build narratives. A lot of people follow them.
Scott Galloway
But wait, I found the quote. I found Obama's quote. He said, "You cannot take an absolutist view on encryption. If your view is strong encryption no matter what, that does not strike the balance that we've lived with for 200 to 300 years. And it's fetishizing our phones above every other value. That can't be the right answer." Go on, Barack. Go on, you crazy young man who managed to leave Washington with your reputation pretty much intact.
Erica Anderson
Did you see his photos of Barack and Michelle that he posted for her birthday?
Scott Galloway
I did not. Let me guess. He's like the wonderful husband.
Erica Anderson
Yep, yep.
Scott Galloway
Is he the wonderful hubby?
Erica Anderson
The internet loved it. Yeah, really sweet.
Scott Galloway
All right, Scott, it's time for a quick break. We'll be right back with Listener Mail, Wins, and Fails.
Ad break
Erica Anderson
All right, Scott, we're back. So let's dig into some listener mail, shall we?
Scott Galloway
You got mail.
Erica Anderson
Hey, this is Bhutani from India, former NYU student. "Kara and Scott, I had a question for you around Jeff Bezos' recent trip to India. It seems like a PR tour where he's promised a billion dollars, a lot of jobs, and has been wooing a lot of businessmen as well as small and medium business owners who he's promising a lot of employment to. Very curious what you think about what he's actually trying to achieve with this, especially given how Amazon India now competes with essentially Walmart-owned Flipkart and where this e-commerce war is headed in India." So Scott, this is an NYU alum, so I want you to start us off. But let me just give a little context. Obviously, Jeff Bezos announced last week that he would be investing a billion dollars into India over the next five years. I think the Indian retail market is $1.3 trillion, so it's a bit of money. But there are obviously a lot of challenges. I want to hear your take. What do you think about this move?
Scott Galloway
Well, committing a billion dollars or Jeff Bezos committing a billion dollars to investments in India is tantamount to the world's wealthiest man committing $961,000 to fight the fires in Australia.
Erica Anderson
Oh, wait, he did that.
Scott Galloway
He did that. This is pretty much insignificant. It's a drop in the bucket. India is going to be in the news a lot more around the innovation or obsession with the innovation economy. I went on the board of Gateway Computer, which I always like to talk about because it makes me feel better about myself and signals just how ridiculously impressive I am, Erica.
Erica Anderson
Right, right. That's right. As you would say, go on.
Scott Galloway
Go on. Say more. 30 years ago, or 20 years ago, there was Gateway Computer and there was Dell. They were neck and neck. Gateway decided to go after consumer and Dell went after small and medium-sized business focusing on supply chain. Fast forward 10 years later, Dell is one of the 10 most valuable companies in America and Gateway is on the verge of bankruptcy. We had to basically sell it, not for scrap, but we sold it for literally a shadow of itself. If you go back 30 years ago, China and India were seen as being somewhat neck and neck. They had these incredible emerging middle classes, an incredible consumer economy emerging.
Everybody knew something big was happening in both these nations. It wasn't entirely clear who was going to win or emerge as the next superpower. You had China, which had unbelievable manufacturing processes already in place, the ability to create infrastructure investments. You had India, where more PhDs than anywhere in the world, more English speakers. The thing we loved was that it was a democracy. But that part of it ended up being a bug, not a feature. Autocracy or central planning around moving towns to run a bullet train through it or relocating people to focus on how you allocate capital around manufacturing ended up being a feature, not a bug.
30 years later, China has absolutely, on every dimension economically, absolutely buried India.
So now people are looking to India and saying, "All right, with this massive population of young people, a decent opportunity, there is a fairly impressive education system." My most impressive colleagues at NYU all went to the same university in India. I think it's called IIT. Now people are turning their eyes to India. What's interesting is that we have to go all the way around the world to see Amazon versus Walmart part two. That's just interesting how it's shaping up to be the same battle here. The other thing that's interesting is the pushback they've received from small shop owners. I know you had some thoughts on this, but effectively, we're net gainers in the US and we have an obsession with innovators and the consumer.
That's not necessarily true in other nations. They've looked at big tech and said, "I'm not sure nations outside of the US have been net gainers from big tech." The idea that Amazon's going to come in and it might be good for Indian consumers, but it's basically going to decimate the retail market, decimate tax collection, create anti-competitive behavior. I think there's sort of like, do we want to be other nations that let big tech come in and start to suck all the oxygen out of the room?
So I'm not sure that India is as fascinated with Amazon as Amazon is with itself. It's going to be interesting to see the extent to which they embrace or don't embrace Amazon.
Erica Anderson
Well, it doesn't seem like they're embracing Amazon. I mean, aside from some great photos that came out of the event, and obviously Jeff Bezos probably had a great time over there with the 1%. But I think what I've noticed—and I think those are all great points—is your point about the shopkeepers. You kind of have to win over the shopkeepers to make Amazon India successful. One of the challenges in India is there are a zillion shopkeepers selling a zillion products, and they so far haven't really been on board. There's a lot of fear about what this means for them and their ability to sell. Maybe they are or aren't seeing the big picture of the pitch—scale and access, getting your products to more people. But that's going to be some tension to watch between the shopkeepers and the government, and whether the shopkeepers can sway the government one way or the other.
The other issue is, Scott, I've been to India four or five times. I went when I was 11 years old, left Indiana, went on a trip to India. My aunt and uncle had moved over there. It was a really interesting experience in the 90s at the beginning of U.S. multinationals going over there. India is totally organized chaos, which is logistically antithetical to Amazon's business. You order something from Amazon India and it comes broken, which is the experience a family member of mine had in India recently. So it's a hard market for so many reasons to get right. It's obvious that Bezos wants to go to India and I love your point about competing with Walmart and Flipkart over there. But it's a hard market to get right.
Scott Galloway
I had about two or three years ago, just as Amazon was showing up on the shores of Australia, the CEO of this Australian conglomerate asked to come speak to me. They owned either the second or third largest retailer in Australia. He said, "How do we prepare for Amazon showing up on Australia's shores?" I said, "What's your objective here? Do you want to talk about employment? Do you want to talk about national interest? Or do you just want to talk simply about shareholder value?" He said, "Let's approach it from a shareholder value standpoint." I said, "Okay, you're a conglomerate. You can sell any division and do what you want. You're not dependent upon this. You don't have 100 years. It's not your family legacy. You're not the Nordstrom." He said, "No, we're not. We look at these things in a very shareholder-driven way. We get into industries and out of industries." I think they were in insurance and a bunch of other industries.
I said, "If you're truly shareholder-driven with Amazon showing up on your shores, you should do the following: sell your retail unit and take those proceeds and buy Amazon stock. Because if you look at Amazon's entry into almost any market, there's a transfer or reshuffling of stakeholder value. Consumers benefit and Amazon shareholders benefit, but jobs, businesses, and the market capitalization of that specific market get crushed as the retail valuation gets crushed." Even on the day Amazon announced it was coming into Australia, the Australian retail sector shed billions of dollars.
This goes back to Bezos and the level of implication these companies have on a global economy. The frictionless flow of capital and a company's ability to scare entire industries in other nations—it's more evidence that Amazon, in my view, has become too big and too powerful. A lot of nations—we're net gainers from Amazon in the U.S., which isn't an excuse for not regulating them or breaking them up. But on the whole, we're net gainers. I wonder if you do the hard analysis in a place like Australia or India, if they're coming to the conclusion that when you take everything into account, they're net losers. They don't have the same fetishization of Steve Jobs and all innovators, the need to fulfill this religious and spiritual void created by a decline in church attendance and lack of dependence on a super being that we have now filled with people like Elon Musk and Steve Jobs. I don't think they suffer from that same deficiency. That uniquely American issue.
Erica Anderson
Right. Bezos said he was going to bring jobs to India. They bring jobs in terms of construction jobs, building logistics centers. But long term, I feel like that's probably doubtful.
Scott Galloway
Oh, Amazon, like most innovators, will be a job destroyer. Amazon will grow a lot of jobs, but you would see massive hemorrhaging of jobs. A lot of people would say that's a function of innovation and productivity, and there's some truth there. Going back to Daniel Kahneman, we need to think this through.
Erica Anderson
So, India. Last thing before we move on, because there is a through line here of Bezos. One of India's government officials after this visit came out and made a comment to Jeff Bezos about The Washington Post's coverage of India. I just find it hilarious. This is also what's happening with MBS and not liking The Washington Post's coverage of Saudi Arabia. My perspective is this is insane. From what I understand, Jeff Bezos has no role in the day-to-day running of The Washington Post editorial newsroom. There's always a bit of a church and state, or should be, between the owner of a newspaper and their editorial staff. It felt like a cheap shot, kind of irrelevant. To say, "Yeah, bring your business to India, but stop covering us in a negative way." I think that's insane. It feels weird to be defending Bezos, but I think it's hard to argue that Bezos hasn't been a wonderful shepherd and steward for what is a national treasure in the form of The Washington Post.
Scott Galloway
He's not Rupert Murdoch, creating talking points and essentially creating a narrative that attacks. Now that Kara's not here, the first time I ever questioned going on Fox, I thought, "I'm not going to go on Fox anymore." Fox does these coordinated attacks on strong, emerging, progressive female voices across The Wall Street Journal, The Post, and Fox. I'm like, "How is that good for America?" When one journalistic institution starts attacking other journalists that happen to be liberal, emerging, powerful female voices. It's happened to some other really strong emerging female journalists. Kara was in their sights.
That was the first time I thought, "This really isn't good for anyone involved." That doesn't happen with Bezos. Or you look at Sheldon Adelson and how he uses his media. Bezos has been very responsible and hands-off. He has a lot of respect for the separation between ownership and editorial. It totally came back to his benefit because when that whole profile or amateur photography of Big Ed and the Twins got out, the media was so inclined to come to his defense. They appreciate that they want Jeff Bezos around for that kind of stuff because he has been seen as a great steward of The Washington Post.
Erica Anderson
The thing about Fox, though, is that a lot of what you're talking about is entertainment. It's not news. News gets a bad name when you consider Fox News to be all news. The majority of the stuff that's super salacious, they don't have any editorial standards. They're just going all out, doing whatever they need to do for their agenda. It's not just attacking female journalists. It's attacking legitimate ideas and facts. Facts are under attack at Fox News, and it's actually really destructive.
Let's go to wins and fails. Scott, you first.
Scott Galloway
You know what my win is? My win is Kara taking a day off, Scott. Just—enough of that. Whether it was her binge last night or the fact that she's legitimately sick, Kara, thanks for forcing me out of the nest and onto the mic.
Erica Anderson
There are three naked prostitutes on her couch that she's about to kick out.
Scott Galloway
Come on. Get on with it. Couldn't be further from Kara, but I love this fantasy. Actually, I don't. All right, so listen. My win is Britain's new privacy legislation that would protect minors' data. It will require platforms like YouTube and Instagram to turn on the highest possible privacy settings by default for minors and turn off by default data mining practices like targeted advertising and location tracking. Good for Britain on the privacy legislation.
Erica Anderson
Britain's also threatening taxes on big tech to try and incentivize the OECD to get their act together and create a pan-European approach to taxation around big tech. Going back to this notion that other countries aren't as in love with big tech as we are and realize that they can't continue to have these companies transfer billions of dollars of capital outside of their country and not leave any behind in the form of taxes. I agree, Britain. That was a strong move and a nice win.
Scott Galloway
My win is Michael Bloomberg, who has placed fourth in the new Monmouth National Democratic Poll. Biden came in at 30%, Sanders at 23, Warren at 14. Bloomberg actually came in ahead of Buttigieg at 9%. Bloomberg looks as if he's about to reach double digits. The gangster move from the mayor here, and something I thought was the right thing to do and an incredible brand move, is that he has announced that regardless of whether he's the nominee, he's going to maintain his staff. It sits in such stark contrast to these other billionaires who claim to be very concerned about the nation and say their number one priority is to get Donald Trump out, but only as far as spending their own money on their unique vision and their unique role as commander-in-chief.
I wonder, is Howard Schultz continuing to fund moderate candidates? He claimed there was such a need for moderates, but now that he's no longer in the race and he said he was willing to fund up to a couple hundred million dollars, has he decided that there's still such a need for moderates that he's funding them, or was it only his unique special vision? I assume Tom Steyer, and to his credit, he's continued to do this. I trust it wasn't political messaging that he's going to continue to be a warrior for the environment. But I think Bloomberg, my win, is committing that he is about getting Trump out of office as opposed to solely being about him being president. There is a path. You can see Iowa, New Hampshire, the Democratic frontrunners beat the shit out of each other and then show up to Super Tuesday where there's Michael and his $250 million that he's already spent driving up the prices of political ads, supposedly 20 to 25% all on his own, which raises a host of issues we need to address around money and politics. But my winner is Mayor Bloomberg.
Erica Anderson
Wow. I wasn't expecting that. But that's great. Who's your loser?
Scott Galloway
I'm too upbeat for that.
Erica Anderson
My fail would probably be Netflix. Reed Hastings earlier this week acknowledged that Disney Plus may have taken a bite out of their subscriber growth during the last quarter of 2019. As a consumer, I'm overwhelmed by the amount of things I need to subscribe to now to see great content. A fail for Netflix that they're starting to see a cut in their business. I'll be curious to see how that plays out.
Scott Galloway
Netflix will largely live and die by international growth or lack thereof because they kind of have everybody in the U.S. There's a decent argument that people aren't swapping out Netflix. Netflix is kind of a car, and Hulu is whether you want leather seats, and Apple TV Plus is whether you want a steering wheel or heated steering wheel. Everything else is kind of an accessory to the car, which is Netflix. But it's hard to imagine that this massive investment in the category doesn't begin to drive margins down or drive growth down. There are now 510 original scripted television programs. 10 years ago, that was 220. We're going to spend more on original scripted television this year than was allocated in the entire decade of the 90s. It's hard to imagine how that doesn't drive down margins and increase competition, and doesn't start to give the market a little bit of a chill around the prospect for Netflix stock. So I agree with you. It's going to be very interesting.
My loss or fail is a lot more serious and weird. I've been thinking a lot about family planning. It's always the stuff you're not focused on. The two biggest issues are the shit you don't see coming that really hurts you or that you're not talking about. We were talking about the deficit a lot six or seven years ago. Now we're no longer talking about it. Our deficit has become not only a moral issue but a real threat to our economy given the incredible reckless spending we've engaged in with deficit spending. The notion that Republicans can claim we have a strong economy when I would argue we're in recession if you take out that trillion dollars a year in sugar high stimulus in the form of debt and record low unemployment. I think it's incredibly dangerous. The deficit is getting to dangerous levels and we're not even talking about it.
The other thing we don't talk a lot about is family planning and choice. There's a bit of a misnomer or misperception. We always tend to couch choice in the context of it being a woman's choice. I saw your tweet yesterday. Tell us about this.
Erica Anderson
Well, it is a woman's choice. I get that, and it should be a woman's choice. But it's deeper than that. The number one reason cited for women deciding to terminate a pregnancy is finances. Access. And the number two is their partner, or specifically their lack of a partner. While we like to think we want to afford women this choice, oftentimes women don't really have a choice because they lack the financial means to support another child. The majority of pregnancies terminated are terminated by a woman who already has kids. It's not that she doesn't want kids, doesn't love children, doesn't want to have a family.
It's that four out of five men, when they get pregnant, do not end up marrying the mother of their child. It's that young men and young women don't have the financial wherewithal because of this systematic transfer of wealth from young people to old people that's taken place across America over the last 30 years. The notion that women aren't massively influenced, their choices are getting more and more limited around how do you responsibly raise a child and bring a child into this world because of the poor choices and the poor responsibility a lot of men exhibit in this process.
Scott Galloway
Scott, you're so woke. Bring it on! This is really deep. We should talk more about this, but we've got to do a quick prediction. We're getting kicked out of the studio. Scott, what do you have?
From abortion to stocks. I'm making some stock picks. Next week is earnings. We're going to see Uber shit the bed. Its stock is off 5% to 10% within 48 hours of their earnings release. We're going to see Facebook announce monster earnings and an all-time high off the back of Instagram commerce. Tech marches on. Ride hailing is a shitty business. Uber has now gone full into what I call fraud-splaining, and they're starting to report this bastardized form of EBITDA called segment-based EBITDA, where they take a bunch of costs out and pretend those costs are for some reason going to go away. They're not. They will begin to downplay Uber Eats as they will either exit that business or sell it to Grubhub, as it makes ride-hailing look like a good business, and ride-hailing is a shitty business. My prediction: Facebook on the back of earnings, all-time high. We'd like to think that their gross negligence and their tearing at the fabric of American depression will show up in their numbers. It will not. We're going to see Uber's decline resume in earnings next week.
Erica Anderson
Great. Those are my predictions. We'll be back next week to talk about it. Scott, it was a pleasure. Thanks for letting me sit in. I hope I—
Scott Galloway
I had no say in this.
Erica Anderson
Yeah. I had no say in this, Erica. Thanks for just going along with it, Scott.
Scott Galloway
My gosh. That's it. What are you saying, Scott? If you had to say you wouldn't allow this to happen? I'm up for any—we need new blood. I mean, Kara—
Erica Anderson
That's not true. Enough already. Let's bring in the clowns.
Scott Galloway
She's not going away, Scott. She's not going away. We're stuck with her. Kara, we hope you feel better. Clean up that apartment. Get Javier and Luisa. I was trying to come up with ethnically ambiguous names, and I failed there. Done. Out of your apartment. Put away the meth. Come back. We need you.
Erica Anderson
All right, Scott. She's a saucy little minx. What do you think she was doing last night?
Scott Galloway
Okay, Scott. All right. Remember, to all of our listeners, we love your questions. If you have a question about a story you're hearing in the news, email us at [email protected] to be featured on the show. Thank you so much for our listener question today. Today's show was produced by Rebecca Sinanis. Erica Anderson, that's me, is your executive producer and stand-in host. Thanks also to Rebecca Castro and Drew Burrows. Make sure you're subscribed to the show on Apple Podcasts. Or if you're an Android user, check us out on Spotify or wherever you listen to podcasts. If you like our show, please recommend it to a friend. Thanks for listening to Pivot from Vox Media. We'll be back next week for another breakdown of all things tech and business. And Kara will be back. Thanks, Erica. Well done.