Podcast Episode Summary
The podcast episode features Kara Swisher and Scott Galloway discussing various topics, including the holiday season, technology, and business. They start by talking about their New Year's celebrations, with Scott in Montana and Kara in San Francisco. They then discuss the companies that profited the most from the holiday season, with Scott mentioning Apple and Amazon as the top performers.
The conversation shifts to the California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA), which went into effect on January 1st. Kara and Scott discuss the law's limitations and how it may not effectively address the issue of data collection and usage. Scott expresses his concerns that the law may be too focused on Facebook and may not address the broader issue of data collection.
The discussion then turns to the gig economy and the impact of the law AB5, which requires employers to classify workers as employees rather than independent contractors. Kara and Scott agree that the law is a step in the right direction but may have unintended consequences, such as affecting small businesses and freelancers.
The episode also covers the topic of online dating, with Scott sharing his experience on Bumble and Kara joking about his profile. They then discuss their personal aspirations for the next decade, with Kara wanting to be a better person and Scott predicting that people will stop carrying around devices in their hands and instead use devices in their eyes and ears.
The final topic of discussion is the future of technology and media, with Scott predicting that Amazon will become the first trillionaire company through its move into healthcare. He believes that Amazon's distribution of healthcare through devices such as Alexa will create enormous shareholder value and disrupt the traditional healthcare industry.
Takeaways
Support for this show comes from Robinhood.: Wouldn't it be great to manage your portfolio on one platform? With Robinhood, not only can you trade individual stocks and ETFs, you can also seamlessly buy and sell crypto at low costs. Trade all in one place. Get started now on Robinhood. Trading crypto involves significant risk. Crypto trading is offered through an account with Robinhood Crypto LLC. Robinhood Crypto is licensed to engage in virtual currency business activity by the New York State Department of Financial Services. Crypto held through Robinhood Crypto is not FDIC-insured or SIPC-protected. Investing involves risk, including loss of principal. Securities trading is offered through an account with Robinhood Financial LLC, member SIPC, a registered broker-dealer.
Tires matter.: They're the only part of your vehicle that touches the road. Tread confidently with new tires from TireRack. Whether you're looking for expert recommendations or know exactly what you want, TireRack makes it easy. Fast, free shipping, free road hazard protection, convenient installation options, and the best selection of Yokohama tires. Go to TireRack.com to see their Yokohama test results, tire ratings, and reviews. And be sure to check out all the special offers. TireRack.com, the way tire buying should be.
Kara Swisher
Hi, everyone. This is Pivot from the Vox Media Podcast Network. I'm Kara Swisher.
Scott Galloway
And I'm Scott Galloway. Happy New Year, Kara.
Kara Swisher
Thank you. You sound so mellow. Where are you? Did you have a good new year? Where are you located at this point?
Scott Galloway
I'm in Montana, the great state of Montana, where I am here for the first time ever.
Kara Swisher
And what are you doing there?
Scott Galloway
I'm skiing. Or I'm mostly not skiing. We try and put the boys on skis each year. It's wonderful. I'm not a big cold weather person, but it's very majestic. It was a nice new year. It's a great state and a place I hadn't been. So, wonderful new year. How about you?
Kara Swisher
Well, I'm in San Francisco moving children around the city doing things. I'm exhausted, actually. But it's beautiful here. San Francisco actually looks great. It's cleaner than it's been. The weather's gorgeous. But wait, do you know all the internet moguls go to Montana? You are in the ground zero of internet moguls, essentially.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, so I'm knee deep in them. Somehow I got into the Yellowstone Club. So I'm where the 99.9 percentile take refuge from the 99.98. It is unusual here.
Kara Swisher
How did you get into the Yellowstone Club?
Scott Galloway
They feel sorry for me. I'm like the charity actor. It's the same as Cannes and Saint-Tropez every once in a while. They invite a professor. So I'm kind of an interloper here.
Kara Swisher
Well, actually all the internet people I've been hearing from are all in New Zealand right now. I'm waiting for end of days. What is it, the Armageddon vacation? I keep getting pictures of people at the Hobbit hole. A lot of internet people are in New Zealand because I guess it's warmer. And it's not Hawaii. They move on to other things. The Yellowstone Club had some financial problems, I recall, but now it's back and bigger than ever, allegedly. It's where all the fancies are. Very nice, Scott. It's so nice that you live a life that way while I sit here and work my way through the holidays.
Scott Galloway
[Laughs]
Kara Swisher
Anyway, speaking of making money off the holidays, which companies do you think profited most from the holiday season? Was it Amazon? Apple? Who do you think?
Scott Galloway
Right out of the gate, just because of its industry and people look so closely at it, Amazon reported record numbers again. In terms of momentum through the holiday season, though, Apple finished the year as the best performing of the FANG stocks. It really was Apple's year. Apple was the second best performing stock behind some weird stuff like Netflix, or maybe that was for the decade. So it was the quarter for Apple. But it was the holiday for Amazon, just because of its core business, which shows no signs of letting up. We saw e-commerce growth jump something like 19%, which is insane when you think about the fact this is no longer a small business. E-commerce continues to finally realize its potential. We were so excited about it in the early 2000s, and now it seems to finally be growing into its own shoes. Brick and mortar is suffering again.
What's interesting, I read an idea on the Robinhood app for year-end predictions. Someone suggested that a large franchise, a Chipotle—I actually think Chick-fil-A would be an interesting brand for this—would go all delivery. They would just shut all their locations down and go all delivery. That's an interesting idea, maybe for a market where they don't have any locations. But QSR is about to feel the impact of disruption around technology. Anyways, Apple and Amazon.
Kara Swisher
What would you say were the big winners? I'm fascinated by why Apple is. I mean, I bought my kids a pair of AirPods, which were promptly misplaced a few days after the holidays. We have Apple Music. We went and got our new iPhone 11s because we're in that exchange program. So I have a real tight relationship with Apple as a brand. We were in the store several times. We didn't buy that much stuff there, but we bought enough. We're part of their ecosystem.
Amazon, I made a point to go to regular retailers this year to buy things. I did not buy a lot off of Amazon. I use Amazon all year round for convenience versus gifts. So I didn't do a whole lot. There were not quite as many boxes. In fact, there were none. I didn't do any shopping off of Amazon because I made it a point to go around to local businesses. But on the streetscape here, several stores in my neighborhood just closed down that have been here since I moved here. One was a regular store that sold t-shirts and nice clothes. They don't let brands in this particular neighborhood in San Francisco. So several different businesses that were here are not, including restaurants. It's a shock to see that happening in real time on the streets of cities.
Scott Galloway
It's funny what you're saying about Apple. One of the things I noticed this morning after the orgy of consumerism and ripping shit open, the thing both my kids—a nine and twelve year old boy—ended up on were an iPad and the new iPhone, respectively. Apple really has become, for any kind of upper middle class affluent family, the morning is won by Apple.
Kara Swisher
Interesting. That's not true. Your kids aren't old enough. It's won by sneakers and StockX. Have you heard of StockX? Owned by Dan Gilbert, who we hope gets better.
Scott Galloway
Yep.
Kara Swisher
My kid is obsessed with that and sneakers. He's a sneaker head. That was interesting, the use of those things. He knows all about sneakers, mostly through online relationships with people who love sneakers. So I think it was more sneakers. I believe StockX is amazing, right? StockX is tapping into that resale market. It does real-time tracking of prices. If you go onto StockX, what's so innovative is you can type in any shoe and it gives you pricing trends and patterns, which gives you the confidence to buy. It really is a fantastic platform from a UI standpoint. The other really wonderful thing about StockX is I believe it's one of the only unicorns—true tech unicorns—in Detroit. In the great city of Detroit, they're making their comeback. So there's a lot to like about StockX.
Yeah. I'm thinking of actually having them to code because I was fascinated by how he uses it and so many of the other kids' friends. It's sort of like the real real for teenage boys and girls. One of the things that's interesting, he was starting to buy sneakers for the baby, which was just disgusting what sneakers she would be wearing over the next 10 years of her life. I was like, oh my God, I better get another job. This show better get a TV show or something.
Anyway, let's get to the big stories of the week. There's a ton in California where I am. A handful of progressive California laws went into effect this week. We're going to talk about them because they're two very big laws. They're essentially the de facto law of the land at this point. The California Consumer Privacy Act, which I wrote about last week in the New York Times, went into effect on January 1st. It gets enforced in the middle of July because they're getting it into place. Everyone got all these emails about the online things. If you didn't get one, you're not online.
Let me just go through it really quickly. It'll give Californians a certain agency over how companies like Facebook and Google use their consumer data. It gives residents the right to learn what data companies have collected on them, to ask companies not to sell data—which I did with a lot of companies—and to request data be deleted. There are some limitations. You can't tell a business you don't want to sell their data, but there's no way to opt out of having that data collected. What I'm looking for was opt in, actually.
The second one is AB5, which is now active in California. It offers gig economy workers a slate of protection, including some benefits, and it requires employers in many industries to classify their workers as employees. Both Postmates and Uber are complaining about it in federal court and say it's unconstitutional. So those are two big laws, and they're essentially the law of the land because everyone has to comply with them.
Scott Galloway
CCPA, I think it's going to inspire or catalyze better legislation, but the legislation itself rings of GDPR in the sense that I think it's going to end up taxing or being heavy handed with the wrong people. At the end of the day, CCPA is largely motivated to create some redress around one company, and that's Facebook. Technically, Facebook will argue they are already in full compliance. Where this comes up short is this media agency called Copley had a pro-life client and was using locational data they had gathered from a platform. Because the platforms could in fact sell that data, they were targeting people with anti-abortion ads based on location, trying to figure out if women were on their way to or near a family planning clinic. This is exactly the kind of thing we're trying to stop.
But if Facebook all of a sudden decided to have a service—Facebook doesn't collect data, or it doesn't sell it, I should say. They collect the data and then they use it and sell that service to advertisers, but they don't sell the data. Their core business is not selling data to advertisers. Because of some of the controversy, they haven't done it. But at what point does the legislation mean, "Well, you can't use my data to sell me or access to me"? That's where the symptoms are short. I worry it's just going to, as GDPR is, make it more difficult for small media companies, but the larger ones that have the lawyers to navigate around this are just fine. So I'm not hopeful for this one. I'm hopeful it inspires better legislation, but this one, I'm not a big fan of.
Kara Swisher
The minor stuff, I think, is great. Anyone under 16, they just can't collect any data. They can't use their collected data. It does sort of put something across the bow, saying there is a privacy act in a major state that matters where these companies are living, where they exist. That's what's important. It says these are the beginnings, the parameters of what we're doing. I get it comes up short in a lot of ways. Of course, if they don't have opt-in, I just don't see any point to any of this. You have to opt into the data collection so that you know what you're doing. People may just click on it, that's fine, but at least it forces them into that step.
I just turned off all my location data on Apple, which of course is still pinging. I'm going to have my kids talk on the Recode Decode show this week. They still collect your location data like crazy. Even Apple is doing that. We were looking over where I'd been specifically, including with the credit card and everything else. So I turned all of it off. I have to tell you, it's really interesting using a phone without location data. You have to put in where you're going. We went out to Muir Woods to go hiking and I didn't want them to locate me. So you can put in getting to Muir Woods from my brother's house, but I couldn't track it along the way. I had to follow it like a map, just like you would follow an old map because I didn't know where I was on the map.
There's a thing that says "only once." They can track you only once, which I think is very helpful on the Apple when you're using an Apple. You can also have it use it when it's always, only when you're using the app, or never. Apple's certainly given you a lot more choices, and I use them pretty actively. I don't think everyone will, but it's well done. It's not confusing in any way. Like, use it once for a movie ticket. But I do think a lot more about location to start with. They don't know where I am. They know where I've asked to go to, but they don't quite know where I am. I feel a lot better about that, even though it's somewhat onerous to do it that way.
Secondly, the data that's getting pinged back—I'm spending a lot of time being fully aware of how much data is being dragged into whatever app I'm using or what I'm downloading. I went through all my apps and got rid of a lot of them because they were sucking all kinds of information I never requested off of them. I removed them from my phone. I think I'm radical compared to most people. But I do think the idea that big legislative bodies, including other states, are doing this means that Congress has to act because you're going to have 50 different privacy acts that's going to be really problematic for businesses. So that's a good thing.
Scott Galloway
The most powerful thing about it is California. Whenever California passes legislation, there's a 50 to 70 percent chance it's going to become the legislation of the land, or a lot of states are going to take advantage of a justice department and a legal infrastructure that is really robust and really large in the state of California. The problem with this is that if you look at consumer behavior, like the behavior you were just describing, it's a straight line strange. Most people don't even have the skills to begin having the conversation that you just had. The majority of younger consumers have decided with their actions that they're fine with their privacy being violated as long as they get utility in return. Location-based data does provide incredible utility, whether you're on Waze, whether it's recommending a restaurant nearby, directions, all that good stuff.
What we want is to change the law such that if you abuse my privacy data or my data that's sensitive, you're subject to lawsuits. I think that's where this needs to head. It's not that consumers want their privacy violated as long as there's utility or a coupon at the end of it. What they don't want is to find out that their data was used to help target and suppress voters after the fact. So it's not even the collection process, it's how these guys are using it.
Then there's an interesting question. A guy named Benedict Evidence, a partner at Andrews and Horowitz, disagrees with me all the time on Twitter. I hate him for it because when he disagrees with me, he's almost always right. He had an interesting point. He said if you're going to go after these people, at which meta level do you go after them? Is it the technology? Is it the app that sits on top of the technology? Is it the company that coordinated, organized, and distilled the data? Is it the firm that purchased the data? There are so many players along the road. Where does the legal liability or the fault lie?
Again, if you look at this thing, Facebook probably gets off scot-free. Most of this legislation goes after the smaller guys. The question is, what has to pass to affect the biggest violator, which would be Facebook? I think that's something that Congress has to think about. I'm not sure they have the set to do it. Chuck Schumer has been a friend of Facebook, rather Facebook positive, although Nancy Pelosi has not been. So it depends on what happens.
What would be interesting is if Trump inserts himself here the way he did in the emissions issues with cars in California, where there are lawsuits flying right now over those issues because California has stronger emissions and some car makers have backed California. Others have not, and have gone with the Trump administration. So it'll be interesting to see if they insert themselves here, including in AB5, which is the protections for freelance work, essentially, giving them workplace legal protections. But it's also affected freelancers. Vox has been impacted, and others had to lay off some people because of the amount of time you can hire people before they move into employee status. Again, it's important to do this, to be able to start talking about gig economy workers and the protections they deserve. But definitely the paperwork is going to be enormous, small businesses are going to be more affected, and it'll cause more problems. I just think we have to radically rethink how we think of work going forward because everybody's a gig worker at some point. It's not going to be the same kind of system that we've had in the past.
It brings up a host of issues. In 2009, the NASDAQ was at $2,000 and federal minimum wage was at $7.25. Here we sit in 2020, the NASDAQ has breached $9,000 and federal minimum wage is still $7.25. That makes no sense. As an economy, if you think of us as a giant company and you think of the president and Congress as the CEO and the executive management team, they have these stakeholders. One, loosely speaking, is shareholders. One is capital or property owners. Another is companies, and another is workers. We have decided collectively through the people that we elect to put workers so far behind in the back of the line in terms of their rights.
I'm not talking about information age workers. As people talk about there being two Americas, there are two Ubers. The 20,000 employees who will split the value of Ford at Uber, who have educations and went to MIT or are so crazy brilliant they started coding Python in the 11th grade and got sucked up into the ecosystem as young people without college—those people have never had it better. But the 5 million driver partners, the other side of Uber, have never had it worse. The supply and demand dynamic that we would like to think creates or works in capitalism ends up in a society where a third of children are living in households that are food insecure.
Remember that software the media was outraged over a few years ago that automatically clocked out workers at fast food restaurants? "Okay, there's not enough people in the restaurant. We're automatically clocking you out such that you're no longer making $7.25 an hour. Go have a smoke break outside, but we're not paying you for the next 17 minutes." There was outrage over that. Imagine that times 2 billion, because effectively everyone now has that software in the form of a phone. When you think about what Uber and DoorDash and the entire food delivery system is, the massive dynamics or underpinnings of shareholder value and big tech have been: one, innovation.
Their products are just superior, more power to them. They deserve everything they get. Then two, it moves to obfuscation. "Our incredible products give us monopoly power, so we're going to avoid any sort of regulation. We're going to avoid any sort of antitrust." Then the really sad part is it then moves to exploitation. I would argue Uber doesn't really have that sophisticated a technology. DoorDash, Postmates, Uber Eats—their primary means of value creation is the exploitation of workers at the hands of this automatic clocking in, clocking out software of the phone. And the lack of regulation that says, "If you're an independent contractor, we don't have to offer you bathroom breaks.
We don't have to ensure you're making $7.25 an hour." A lot of them aren't.
A long-winded way of coming around to acknowledge your point: there should be a middle ground between independent contractors who have no protection and employee status where the company is forced to provide benefits and immediately raise the cost of that employee by 30%. The problem with this law is that it differentiates between workers. There are a bunch of carve-outs for white-collar workers, like doctors, lawyers. Low-paid workers like construction and janitorial services get legal protections, but then they let in marketers and grant raters, but not journalists. If you're a freelance journalist—there are so many journalists that do freelance work. Vox Media, full disclosure, had to cut more than 200 California freelancers. There's transcription services. There are all kinds of people who do that kind of work. Being an independent contractor is a good thing for a lot of people because they like it, but then they can't work. Or they work only a short amount of time and then can't make their living.
Kara Swisher
The sophistication of these laws, as you start to get into it, gets rather deep. Of course, it calls for the idea that we should have a national healthcare initiative. Healthcare is really at the center of this, along with other benefits. Having healthcare benefits is critically important. The fact that we don't across this country continues to be a problem. We have Obamacare, but it's under attack.
My nephew lives in Australia, and my other one lived in Japan for a long time. We were talking at Christmas, and they were like, "We couldn't believe how much Advil costs here. We can't believe how much..." They're sort of like, "God, it's like you're all on your own here," compared to the kind of quality care they're getting in the countries they live in. It was an interesting discussion. They've come to expect it. I think the problem is our people in this country have not come to expect this kind of ability to have these things.
I like that California's passed these things. We've got to move on, but we'll see where they go. They're going to be attacked in court by all these companies going forward, both laws. The question is, where does it end up on a federal level? Eventually the Supreme Court, I'm guessing. These kinds of changes between employment law and privacy are going to have to end up being determined at a very high federal level where we all can agree on things. I don't think either of these laws are going to be the end. This is the beginning of them. I'm glad California has done this, however problematic they have created problems. At least we're discussing those problems.
Scott Galloway
At Subaru and DoorDash, I've already devoted or allocated tens of millions of dollars to propose legislation or a ballot initiative that directly counteracts it.
Kara Swisher
Right. Ballot initiatives in California—those who don't live here, they do ballot initiatives on a wide range of things. Sometimes people aren't really paying attention. I was joking, we picked the paper clips that San Francisco uses. It's a crazy way to legislate. I think most people in California don't like it, although it was meant to give power to people. Now it becomes like a circus when you're going to vote. Anyway, we'll see where it goes. I think we're on deck this year maybe to have privacy legislation in Congress if we can get through this horrible...
Scott Galloway
I don't think we're going to get through anything until November, until it's very clear who's president, who's running the Senate, and who's running the House. This year politically is going to be insane, so there won't be much being passed.
Kara Swisher
Anyway, we've got to take a quick break now, but we'll be right back after this. Scott, you sound so mellow. I like it. You got the mellow thoughtful professor thing. I envision you in a sweater vest kind of thing, smoking a pipe, looking out at the snow among the rich people. I think it's a nice mood for you. I like it a lot.
Scott Galloway
That a good look on me? No, it's mostly me in a dark room who's just yelled at his kids not to come into the room under any circumstances. Still recovering from my New Year's Eve hangover.
Kara Swisher
Anyway, when we get back, we're going to do wins and fails and predictions. Everybody, welcome to the new year 2020. We'll be back after this.
The Disney Plus Hulu HBO Max Bundle.: Plans starting at just $16.99 a month. No one will ever break us apart. Catch Marvel Studios' Thunderbolts, The New Avengers on Disney Plus. You can't escape the past. Alien Earth on Hulu. This ship collected monsters. And Final Destination Bloodlines on HBO Max. Death is coming for our family. The Disney Plus Hulu HBO Max Bundle. Plans starting at $16.99 a month. All these and more streaming soon. Visit DisneyPlusHuluHBOMaxBundle.com for details.
This episode is brought to you by Buffalo Trace Distillery.: Powerful yet smooth. Contained but never tamed. Proudly going their own way, but never going alone. This is the spirit inside Buffalo Trace bourbon. Made at Buffalo Trace Distillery. The world's most award-winning distillery. Buffalo Trace is always perfectly untamed. Distilled, aged, and bottled by Buffalo Trace Distillery. Franklin County, Kentucky. 90 proof. 45% alcohol by volume. Learn more at buffalotracedistillery.com. Please drink responsibly.
Okay, we're back. Scott, wins and fails. It's early in the year. People really missed us. They didn't like us being away for a week.
Scott Galloway
Oh, good. It's my favorite. Back to how awesome we are. That was a topic every week. Let's find a new way to talk about how awesome the jungle cat and the big dog are. I love it.
Kara Swisher
They did. People miss us. We got on a lot of lists and "best of" this and that. People really missed us going away, not talking to each other. But as everyone knows, we go twice a week. We're sort of fitting in with the formats as we move forward. We'd love any suggestions from everybody about what you think of the two, how we should do the second one, whether it should be different, if we should do wins and fails just once a week, if there's enough wins and fails, things like that. But let's go. Since you've been away for so long, I would like some wins and fails. A lot did happen over the holiday. It was not a quiet holiday season, even though it was two weeks of vacations for most people. So your wins and fails, Scott Galloway?
Before we get started, you wrote, and you know how much I don't like reading your material, but occasionally I stumble upon it. And I read your article in the New York Times. The thing that struck me, you made some predictions, was it was very optimistic. You said a few things that you thought climate change could in fact, that big tech could play a big role in terms of innovators addressing climate change and that the first trillionaire would be someone who addressed that, that privacy.
It struck me that the article was hopeful and optimistic, which is nice and I cannot relate to, but also that you think tech and what I'll call market-driven and capitalism-driven innovation and the rewards and the spoils are going to play a huge role in solving the problems of their own making. That's what struck me. You sounded like you could almost be, I don't want to say a lobbyist, but someone who is very pro-tech thinking a lot of these problems of their own making can be solved by them.
Scott Galloway
Well, it's interesting because the reaction was fascinating. People really liked it when I'm positive.
Kara Swisher
I like it when you're negative and they like it when you're negative.
Scott Galloway
Well, it's a shocker. They like it when you surprise them. I wasn't being positive so much as let's, like, I read all these year-end things, and I can't stand them. Or looking back at the decade, and they're all the same. They're all exactly the same. And they're all so short-term, right? Like, oh, we're going to have, like, even bigger AirPods on our helmets, AirPod helmets or whatever. I just find them really small-minded. I know it sounds crazy, but I do.
And so I thought, why don't I really just say what I would like to happen? Why don't I just do, like, visualization, as they say here in California? Why don't I visualize the future I want to have? And so these were some of the issues that I want to sort of set the tone for writing all year about solutions, which is what Code's going to be about this year. And it's not to say we're going to ignore all the shitty stuff Facebook does, because I'm sure they're gearing up and resting to do more shitty things all year. But I do want to think about where I want to set the tone.
I think in, I don't want to say attacking tech over the past year and a half but I'm saying chastising tech for their problems I think has set in motion. You know, I started sort of whacking at them back in 2016 on these issues of responsibility. Alright, now that we've done that it's time to like, what are we going to do about it? And so I think getting people in that mode including in the tech industry is a good one because at some point you have to. It's sort of like Twitter and Trump right now. It's like, that's enough. We're done with, and that's what I ended the piece on. Like, whatever you think, in 10 years, we do not have to listen to Trump on Twitter, probably. You know what I mean? Like, probably that'll be gone. So that's what I was trying to put in people's brains, is that the internet screaming at you is going to be over at some point and give people a little hope. That was what I was trying to do.
Kara Swisher
I like that. And I didn't realize predictions were what we want the world to make of it, what we want to happen.
Scott Galloway
So my big prediction then for the future is that me, AOC and Andrew Ross Sorkin, ARS, steal one of those stupid fucking rockets that those little dick billionaires are building. We take off, we hit the substrata. They look at me because I'm older and I have that face you distrust. And I say, let's rock, let's light this candle. Let's head into the sun. We fly together, me, AOC and Andrew Ross Sorkin into the center of the fucking sun. Our DNA fuses, and do we die? No, we create new antimatter. We emerge. We emerge as the vehicle, as the spiritual animal, the singularity that I warrant, that I do. I emerge from the sun, fused with AOC and Andrew Ross Sorkin, a golden god, and I realize my destiny.
Kara Swisher
Hello, golden god. This is an episode of Star Trek, in case you're interested. Into the fucking sun. This is not going to happen. I'm sorry, Scott. You're going to burn on like getting even slightly close to it and then you'll all be dead. And by the way, AOC and Andrew Ross would never get in a rocket with you.
Scott Galloway
But that's my posse. She's running for president. Did you see all these stories? There were all these like she's preparing for presidency.
Kara Swisher
Well, Julian Castro has dropped out. Julian Castro is no mas in the race. He dropped out. So AOC could fill the role. Let's use that as a segue. I'm going to start with a fail. And it kind of goes to why we need AOC or more people of color in the race. I think the Democratic Party has really failed us. And as we all try to get really excited about these candidates, I would describe the candidates thus far collectively as meh.
I think the Democratic National Committee has pivoted too far to the other side where we let these total whack jobs who should not be taking any oxygen during an incredibly important process on the debate stage. I think that they should have had debates where they said, okay, we believe that similar to being a heart surgeon or a VCR repair person, that there is a skill set and domain expertise and a certain level of respect to people who have actually governed. And our experiment around business people or people who have no experience in government has been a disaster.
And I would have liked to have seen debates with fewer people such that, as I told you, I'm in the great state of Montana. Now, I don't know a lot about Steve Bullock, the governor here, but I would have liked to have learned more and had him had a Democratic governor in a red state get more oxygen. And he just couldn't even get out of the box.
Scott Galloway
What is that up to? I mean, it's a reaction to what happened with Hillary Clinton, which the DNC shut everybody down. It was an overcorrection, so to speak. But I think they've screwed up. I think the DNC has an obligation. I think government matters. And I think actually a lot of politicians do a very good job.
It's really interesting. I talked about this time last year, I had a tweet saying we might be inaugurating or welcoming Andrew Yang as Secretary of Commerce and Tom Steyer as Secretary of Energy. It's really interesting. The Yang gang is about as passionate as any group online, with the exception of maybe Tesla and occasionally fanboys from Apple in terms of pushback. They were angry that I suggested he might only be Secretary of Commerce, but let me just inspire a million mean tweets.
I think Andrew Yang is a fascinating guy with fascinating ideas, a successful business person. I think he's a good person. I think he has absolutely no fucking reason to be president. I think that would be a disaster. I do think it's important that the guy or gal shows up with some people who they actually have predetermined relationships, that they understand legislation, that they understand how Senate and the House work together. And people will respond, well, has it worked so far? And I would argue, I think it's worked better than people give it credit for. But the people who cut and run here, the Democratic National Committee should command the space they occupy and should have done a better job giving oxygen and giving us a better look at people who have spent their lives in government.
Kara Swisher
Well, that's not the Democratic Party, Scott, but that's okay. I think there's no way they were going to avoid this Thunderdome this year. Even if it's a dull Thunderdome.
Scott Galloway
Because of Hillary?
Kara Swisher
Because of Hillary? Yeah, 100%. There was no way. But couldn't they have had a half a dozen debates, just DNC debates? And quite frankly, they didn't invite Marianne Williamson. I mean, they just don't, they just said, okay, we're not going to invite business people who are billionaires. We have, we're the Democratic National Committee.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, but then why do professional politicians, I mean, Trump has blown that all to hell. Like, look, he's not qualified in any stretch of the imagination.
Kara Swisher
Right, I agree. He remains unqualified.
Scott Galloway
Shouldn't we learn from that?
Kara Swisher
All he does is tweet from Mar-a-Lago, the Southern White House.
Scott Galloway
Agreed.
Kara Swisher
Forever, which is just a grifter palace, as far as I can tell. But where they're just writing him checks, I'm assuming. They'll just bring checks like it's a mafia wedding. But it's, you know, I just, I don't know. I think this is the process. This is the process we have, especially with the Democrats. And that's the way it's going to go. And then we'll come, you know, we'll zero out on somebody. And, you know, it looks like it's moving into the regulars. Like, it's not like they didn't get there. And I think they're better for it.
I think the win, Scott, that's a fail for you. You got to explain your, the Tesla situation. I think people were coming at you because Tesla's at an all-time high. I don't know if it's a win. I want to, it's a win for shareholders for sure. So your win is an opportunity to embarrass me. Is that exactly? I want you to explain it. I was sitting there like, how are you going to explain this? He's going to avoid it or whatever, but you can't avoid it. So what do you think about this run-up in Tesla stock? That's really what I want to know. What do you think about it?
Scott Galloway
So just to be clear, so the Yang people now hate you. Let's have the Tesla people come after you. You know what, if you're gonna have enemies, have powerful enemies. So I said earlier in the year at South by Southwest, one of my big predictions is that this was the year Tesla was going to come undone. Yes, crash, full crash into a wall. It was trading at 300 bucks a share. The moment we said that, the stock went to 220, not because of us, but just because. And I thought, wow, I'm actually pretty good at this predictions thing. And now it's at an all-time high. And there's just no getting around it. I was wrong.
Tesla has, I thought all the incredible exodus of senior management was going to come back to haunt them. I still believe that greatness that's achieved in the agency of others. And I'm kind of, I don't want to say I'm doubling down. I'm almost a little bit tired of fighting people on Tesla and the heat I take. I own a Tesla. I think it's a great car. I think it's a great brand. My viewpoint though, is that at the end of the day, it's a company that bends steel and will begin at some point trading at a valuation that is the most valuable on any multiple or any reasonable metric auto company in the world, which puts it somewhere at like 80 to 120 bucks a share. So look, the company, congratulations to them. I was wrong. Still think the company is wildly overvalued.
Kara Swisher
But why did it go up? Why do you think it went up? That's what I want to understand. It may be a fake go up. I think that you're 100% right about this valuation is crazy. But why did it go up? What was the intervening factor that it keeps doing this? I mean, I see a lot. Let me tell you, being back here in California for a while, all you see is Teslas everywhere. Now I live in San Francisco but I was all over the Bay Area. And you see all levels of them everywhere being driven by people, which is interesting.
Scott Galloway
Well, there's just no getting around it. The company is tremendously innovative. It takes enormous risks. I forget the new model that they launched last year, the more affordable model. But that seems to be getting traction. The pickup truck inspired this kind of this Tesla-like wondery that people have come to expect. They're not afraid to do things incredibly different, especially their China production is coming online and now they're producing a thousand cars a day. So they've hit, they're starting to do something that they've never done before. And that is actually hit targets. They're famous for not hitting them.
So look, the company is firing. I would say it's firing on all cylinders if it wasn't an electric car, but it's conducting on all lithium iodine or whatever the appropriate analogy is. The company's executing. Congratulations to them. I'm glad the bulls won. I don't have a position in the stock. But yeah, I don't.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, but it's interesting. Well, Elon seems a little bit more reinvigorated. I mean, at one point he was tweeting from the China factory and then he was somehow, it's a SpaceX facility. It was like, what, he cloned yourself? Like what's, you know, it's interesting. He's quite, you know, I think he's probably emboldened by winning the case and sort of getting himself in line. And so, you know, he's got a lot of energy, that guy, I'll tell you that.
Scott Galloway
Well, it's huge vindication for him because, you know, the stock's up above where he said he was going to take the company private when he committed blatant market manipulation and proved that the SEC still lacks SAC and is not there to protect investors but protect management. Anyway, but there's just no getting around it. Tesla's on fire. I couldn't have been more wrong on that one.
Kara Swisher
All right. Another thing I wanted to ask you about, I missed you so much, I want your opinions on everything, was this Bumble blocking Sharon Stone, which was kind of a great, it was peak 2019. But what did she do?
Scott Galloway
What did she do?
Kara Swisher
So that's what I want to know. She was on Bumble looking for a date, and they kicked her off because they said she wasn't Sharon Stone when indeed she was Sharon Stone. And then they, of course, responded and said, oh, Sharon, come back. We're thrilled to have you. Date away. And then there were very, some very, my friend Hillary Rosen was like, forget Bumble. I'd be happy to date you. So it was very funny.
Scott Galloway
When I heard about Sharon being on Bumble, I decided to update my profile because my dating profile just says one thing. It says super into magic. And that wasn't working for me. So I changed it to I decided I needed to be a little bit more aggressive, a little bit more brute, a little bit more, you know, dog. And I'm like, an alpha male will not take shit from waiters, will protect your standing everywhere we go, will impregnate you, leave, then come back and eat the child. Alpha male.
Kara Swisher
Oh, my God.
Scott Galloway
That wasn't working. That wasn't working. I'm on a bit right now. Don't interrupt me. So I went back to the thing to attract the lovelies, and I wrote, super judgmental re-exotic vacations, but pretty easy going on everything else.
Kara Swisher
Speaking of exotic, which you're on right now. Oh, my God. Scott, please stay off of Bumble. No one's going to pick you on Bumble. Women have the agency on Bumble, and you will never get selected on Bumble. Release the hound in 2020.
Scott Galloway
No way. No way.
Kara Swisher
Oh, my gosh. Please say off all online dating services. I'm going to warn people. I mean, I know all the owners of these businesses. I'm going to have them put a warning label on anything that you do on a dating service.
Scott Galloway
One in five marriages, and I think like three and four hookups are now online. I think online dating is a wonderful thing. I have a friend who looks like he might be separating. And I'm like, dude, I got so excited when I heard about this. Not because of the pain and frustration and tragedy that is separation. Not that, not that. I made him promise me three months ago that if he ended up getting separated, I would get to write his dating profiles. I'm going to have so much fun because this guy is like me, but more handsome and more successful.
Kara Swisher
Oh, we're going to have so much fun. He's never going to date again, in other words.
Scott Galloway
All right. Listen, we got to finish up with predictions. You have made several weird predictions. I have a win.
Kara Swisher
A win. What's your win?
Scott Galloway
What's your win? Okay. So my win, I love this story. My win is Ava Gordon. And Ava just passed away at the age of 105. And she was a secretary. Her husband, Ed, was a stockbroker. They lived very frugally. And nobody had any idea about their wealth. And although she had never attended college, she left $10 million, her $10 million estate, to community and technical colleges in western Washington state when she died this past June.
Renton College put out a release saying, at Renton Technical College, Gordon's gift will be used to confer scholarships and grants upon students with financial and other barriers to attendance. The funds will help pay for tuition and other education-related expenses, as well as for financial emergencies, Renton said in a statement. Her and her husband used to teach classes. He taught on business because he was a stockbroker. She did warmup exercises for inmates at a correctional institute. And there's just so much, there's so many lessons to be taken from this.
I have this cottage industry of coaching young men. And what I find is that they aspire to have a big win and make just a shit ton of money and then consume. And there's just so much dignity in doing what the Gordons did and living below your means and then investing early. This shows the power of compound interest. One big part of the story was that she would take $30 or $40 of her salary, her secretary's salary, every week and buy stocks and utilities. And then ultimately she bought stock in Nordstrom and then she bought stock in Microsoft. She loved the markets, but was always investing from a very early age. And they ended up with $15 million in wealth, which they all left to nonprofits, mostly in education. But just this sort of philanthropy, this sort of dignity of living below your means, investing in education, which I still believe is the upward lubricant of prosperity in our society. So my win is Ava Gordon, this woman who never achieved anything more than a secretary.
Kara Swisher
So she's doing exactly opposite of what you're doing right now, being in Montana.
Scott Galloway
Pretty much. Pretty much. Excuse me, I have to go out and get a $45 Pokeball.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. I like that you're aspirational to live a life that you're never going to live. I really like that about you.
Scott Galloway
Karen, do as I say, not as I do. Do as I say.
Kara Swisher
All right. So let's finish up with predictions. See, here's the thing, Kara. You've made a couple of the insane ones today. Here's the thing. What is your aspiration for the next decade? What is your aspiration? Mine is I've had a wonderful time with my family. I'm very excited about my family in the next decade. I have wonderful children, and I'm very pleased with the situation around them. And my lovely, I call her my Beyonce. I'm very excited to get married and everything else. So I am excited about family over the next 10 years. What about you?
Scott Galloway
So my parents are Italian and German, which means I'm kind of, I know I'm fucked up, but too lazy to do anything about it. And that's a joke, Kara.
Kara Swisher
I got it. I got it. I wasn't lying. We're talking about personal aspirations, like New Year's resolutions?
Scott Galloway
Yeah, whatever, whatever. What's your prediction for the next decade? I want to be a quarter of the man I pretend to be in all media and shows. I'm sick. I'm just like, I do constant fucking virtue signaling. And I wake up and go like, gee, I wish I was the person I think I am. So I'm trying to connect. I want to connect what I know to be the right ways to be a good person and be a right dad and a good partner. I want to be like, it's like, it's one thing to identify what is the right behavior and to talk about it and to put blog posts up about it. It's another thing to be that person. So my goal is for those two moons to line up at some point.
Kara Swisher
Nice. Okay, now about mountain business. I had predicted at the end of my column this week that you finally read, which was a great moment in our relationship going forward for the next decade, that carrying around a device in our hand and staring at it will be a thing of the past by 2030. I don't think we will be having these phones. I don't think we'll be, I think there'll be another device that'll be in around the eyes, I think probably. So that was my prediction. This is by the end of the day that we're not going to, this is not going to be our relationship, our primary technical relationship that we have. So that is my prediction.
What will it be? How will we be interfacing with our digital world then? Something eyes up in the ear, in the ear eyes up, that will be talking to it. I take a lot of cues from movies and stuff like that. And I think a lot of the stuff that are in movies, they don't have a lot of holding of things. They have a lot of things in their ears and eyes and things like that. So I think we're going to have some sort of device around our head and ear area or embedded in some way that is how we communicate. So that's what I think.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, I don't. I don't. So wearables. I'll be very curious. And you think it goes to some sort of thing like Apple when Apple comes out with some sort of glass thing?
Kara Swisher
Yes, that's where it moves. Yeah, it'll be interesting.
Scott Galloway
Interesting. What about you? We're going to finish up on that. Scott, what's your big prediction for tech and media over the next what should we be watching out for as we move pivot into our new decade?
Well, you know, other than on a broader basis, revolution is coming. And then with the southern hemisphere realize the fastest way to double their wealth is to take the money of seven families, which ultimately they will figure out a way to do. Other than the impending revolution, Cara, in terms of tech, I think the thing that creates the most shareholder value, if you will, in that first trillionaire you're talking about is, for lack of a better term, distributed healthcare.
I think just as retail began taxing people by taking them to these empty parking lots and forcing them to go up escalators and then find a salesperson and the checkout and then navigate your way back to the car. I think that the concentration of healthcare in these facilities, which are unfriendly, very non-consumer welcoming, very inefficient, very time expensive, that we're going to distribute healthcare through these devices. Most people think it's going to be the Apple Watch. I think it's going to be Alexa. And we're going to find that the reason Amazon is becoming HIPAA compliant is they're about to start offering medical services and medical insurance at a lower price.
I think it's going to be tremendously innovative. I think it's going to create enormous shareholder value. I think Jeff Bezos is going to be the first trillionaire on the back of Amazon's move into healthcare. Amazon will be the first $2 trillion company once they start announcing basic health insurance and kind of basic medical services. So I think this is the decade where we go after the most disruptible industry in the world, which is healthcare.
Kara Swisher
I think this is a of health. Health tech. Health tech is the way I would summarize it. Right. I like it. I thought climate tech, but I think you're right. I think you're 100% right. I think you're 100% right about Amazon. I think Amazon is going to be bigger than ever, unless the government gets in his way, or Trump does. But I think he's going to roll right over Trump, I think. You know what I mean? In that fight, I'm like, sorry, Trump. Jeff Bezos is going to take you down on that. That's Conor McGregor and Floyd Mayweather. Bet on the guy with the fast hands who's actually in that sport, Bezos.
Scott Galloway
That's for the second time the guy with the red hair gets the shit kicked out of him.
Kara Swisher
Yes, indeed. All right, Scott. This has been very exciting. I want you to get back to the slopes and whatever you rich people do on the holidays. I am going to work today. I'm going to actually work today. Nobody's working, which is a really nice time to work. And I'm going to be doing some podcasts and things like that. But I'm excited to be back in 2020 with you on Tuesday on a regular thing and a bunch of live events and everything else. And as I said at the end of last year, which is that I'm very looking forward to working with you over the next year. I'm in a very good mood.
Scott Galloway
That's very nice. Thank you for saying that, Kara.
Kara Swisher
I know. You don't know what to do. I'll attack soon.
Scott Galloway
I feel the same about you. Well done. Let's make this a great decade, Kara. This is our decade. This is ours. And let's be offensive along the way as much as we can.
Kara Swisher
Offensive yet empathetic. I know. Offensive yet empathetic. Yes, let's be offensive too. I think people like our offensiveness.
Meanwhile, if you have questions about a story you're hearing in the news for us to answer next week, send us questions at pivot at voxmedia.com. Today's show was produced by Rebecca Sinanis. Eric Anderson is Pivot's executive producer. Thanks also to Rebecca Castro and Drew Burrows. Make sure you subscribe to the show on Apple Podcasts. If you're an Android user, check us out on Spotify or frankly, wherever you listen to podcasts. If you like this show, please recommend it to a friend. Thanks for listening to Pivot from Vox Media. We'll be back next week for another breakdown of all things tech and business.