Main Topic: The podcast episode discusses the recent New York Times article exposing Facebook's dirty tricks and attempts to discredit people exercising their First Amendment rights. The conversation revolves around the repercussions of this article, including the potential consequences for Facebook executives, particularly Sheryl Sandberg.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Scott Galloway
This is Scott Galloway. I founded nine businesses, and eight of those nine businesses, a key partner has been QuickBooks, which enables the management team to focus on the levers of really driving value and also provides a dashboard to gain insight into the key operations and finances of the company. QuickBooks has been a pillar of my entrepreneurial efforts. Check out QuickBooks.com.
Kara Swisher
Hi, everyone. This is Pivot from the Vox Media Podcast Network. I'm Cara Swisher.
Scott Galloway
And I'm Scott Galloway here with breaking news. HQ14A is Cara's, you guessed it, fiesta. Congratulations, Cara.
Kara Swisher
No problem. Well done. You know, we were going to talk about this Amazon HQ2 mess, which was also sort of bad press for them this cycle because of where they selected and some objections to them picking places where you had predicted they would pick. So it announces second headquarters in New York City and also suburb of Washington, D.C., along with a smaller facility in Nashville, which is basically one of their distribution facilities. But we were going to talk about this, but we really – there's nothing to talk about today but Facebook, right? Correct? I mean, this New York Times story, which really brought together a lot of stuff.
You know, a lot of amazing reporting has been going on over at Cambridge Analytica from The Guardian and from lots and lots of sources. I've been whacking at them in the New York Times in my opinion column and stuff like that. But this really brought together a lot of stuff and included some facts that were – and details that were so disturbing in terms of deflection and trying to push blame elsewhere that I was – even I, who have been really critical of Facebook, was astonished by it. So I'd just love to get your take on it or whatever you want to talk about. What are you hearing? I mean you just – before we jump on here, you just read a letter, started reading a letter.
You know these people. I don't. What are you hearing?
Scott Galloway
There are repercussions, especially for Sheryl Sandberg, who really comes off the worst in this story. Although I still cannot stand the ability of people to pretend that this is not all Mark Zuckerberg's responsibility. He is the CEO. He has 60%. He's an adult. And they're treating him like this sort of addled boy king who doesn't know what's going on. It's ridiculous. He knows exactly what's going on. And so I would – to begin, I would say let's put the responsibility where it belongs and the person who controls the company completely. And that's Mark Zuckerberg. But he's got all these executives, including Sheryl Sandbergs, who's the COO, Elliot Schrag, who has left, but he was the head of policy and communications, Joel Kaplan, their man in Washington.
And this group of people, and many others at the top, really did, as I have been saying, abrogated their responsibility for what happened. And not only that, they had a bunch of dirty tricks to do so, you know what I mean? And so I think it's, according to The New York Times, and so there's going to be all these repercussions on all of them in terms of their personal relationships, in terms So they're outside of Facebook profiles, which Sheryl Sandberg has a big one from Lean In and stuff like that. But this is a letter from Patrick. I just got it sent to me by someone, Patrick Gaspard, the president of the Open Society Foundations, just saying the notion that your company at your direction actively engage in the same behavior to try to discredit people exercising their First Amendment rights to protest Facebook's role in disseminating vile propaganda is frankly astonishing to me.
It's just – it's disappointing to see how you have failed to monitor hate and misinformation on Facebook's platform to now learn you are an active in promoting these distortions beyond the pale. I mean, you're going to see tons of this, I think. No question. There's going to be a lot of it. But my question for you is don't you believe in – people say I'm piling on, but I've been at the bottom of the scrum for a while. And I've always been very reticent to be critical of Ms. Sandberg because I believe she is a protected class of a protected class.
Kara Swisher
Meaning what?
Scott Galloway
Meaning? Well, she's an inspiring woman. She's written eloquently on personal loss and the important discussion around gender equality. And what has happened is I believe she's the ultimate sheep's clothing around a wolf.
Kara Swisher
Interesting. That's an interesting way to put it.
Scott Galloway
She has been the most effective heat shield in history.
Kara Swisher
Yes. I mean, think about this. Let's talk about Fox, right? What if Rupert Murdoch, what if it came out? And, you know, you and I have similar feelings about Fox. But what if it came out that the Wall Street Journal was taking ads that were sowing havoc and that their online properties had been weaponized by the GRU? And it ended up that Rupert Murdoch hadn't put in place any safeguards whatsoever to stop the contamination of our elections. I said it this morning. Would he even travel to the U.S.?
Scott Galloway
No. I don't think he would because I think he'd be worried he'd be arrested when he declined.
Kara Swisher
No, I agree. I mean someone just – what's interesting – someone just wrote me this actually. I'll read it directly. "Some will settle down, but I think she looks really bad coming out of this. As you say, in a way, she's the most vulnerable since she's a professional hired woman and Zuckerberg is the founder, a dude. No one thought he had people skills, altruistic motives anyway. Everyone expects so little from men." I mean, you know what I mean? She will bear the brunt of this, but you're right, I think. That's interesting. But, you know, they're all responsible. Look, they're all highly paid. They're billionaires. They're beyond billionaires. You know what quote comes to mind for me? I love war history. And Winston Churchill said at the outset of World War II, "Never have so many owed so much to so few." And it got me thinking, can you think of any individuals who have made so much money doing so much damage?
Scott Galloway
No. No, I can't. I mean, they make tobacco executives look like Mr. Rogers.
Kara Swisher
Well, you know, it's interesting you say that because just this week I interviewed Mark Benioff for a show that's going to be on MSNBC. It's one of my specials there called Revolution. And thank you for that ad. And it's actually a really good interview. But in it, and there's clips out there. he talks about them being cigarette. He said, Facebook is a cigarette company. And then I said, well, people die, you know, from cigarettes. And he kept going. He goes, yes, and they're a cigarette company. They're dying on Facebook.
Scott Galloway
Yes. People are being pulled out of cars.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, and so it was really interesting that, so, you know, recently before Mark's interview, I did one with Tim Cook, and he, same thing, he had some real criticisms of Facebook. And at one point I asked him, what would you do if you were in Mark Zuckerberg's situation? He said, "I wouldn't be in this situation."
Scott Galloway
Yeah, that was a great line. It prompted so much anger from Facebook. I remember at the time they focused not on what Tim was saying, which was a very cogent discussion of what they should do, instead focusing on that one comment. And as it turns out, Mark was so petty that after he heard that comment in this New York Times article, he switched the phones to Android. I mean – Which is serious punishment.
Kara Swisher
Oh, my God. Have you tried to use an Android phone?
Scott Galloway
No, no, I don't. I don't use an Android phone. Oh, my God. Using an Android phone is like paying for dinner with a Discover card. It's like saying don't have sex with me. It's the ultimate prophylactic that says I should be screened out of the gene pool. If you use an Android phone or have a Discover card, your family tree should come to hand. Instead of listening to very cogent feedback from someone who is pretty good at his job, they would focus on that. And they were so focused on the comment. And I kept saying, can you listen to what he said? Are you not adults?
Kara Swisher
So they took a little shot at you.
Scott Galloway
Well, they're doing it for PR. As it turns out, they tried to slime Apple. Right? They tried to slime Apple. They tried to spline George Soros for some – because he said negative things. You know, it's really – they hired this horrible group of people called the Definers who believe in sort of like aggressive –
Kara Swisher
The Definers. I know. I've met them. Is that a cult where everyone's wearing Nikes and drinking Cyanide?
Scott Galloway
I know. They just like wander around. They're like tough – and the guy from the Definers quoted in the – we like to muddy the waters. He just said it. Like, good. And that's what he does. So it was fine that he said it on the record. But it's just, you know, right now the "I'm so, so sorry's" just are not going to cut it. The "I'm so, oh, once again," you know, like with Beacon or whatever thing that Facebook does that's shitty. "I'm sorry" is not good enough now. And they're going to – what's really interesting is what the repercussions will be. First, there will be personal repercussions on all these executives, especially Sheryl Sandberg. There's no question.
Kara Swisher
What does that look like though? I was thinking this morning. We're all going to be in violent agreement. Getting dumped from things. Getting dumped from committees, getting dumped from, especially around the anti, this stuff around George Soros and the sliming. All right. Getting dumped from lots of groups, I think, one, or boards or something like that. I do think that might be coming. Just not wanting to be affiliated with them. Two, and it depends on what comes out after this because once this floodgate opens and the New York Times is open, more is going to come out. You know, all of a sudden everyone's going to drop a dime on everybody.
So then that's the repercussions of everybody dropping more dimes. and that you know there's emails and everything else. So that's one thing. The second thing, which I think is more serious, and Facebook put out a statement this morning about it, was saying that one part of when they knew was incorrect in the New York Times story because they have testified before Congress. And these politicians coming after them, and they were already coming after them, is going to increase exponentially. And Facebook's attempt to push it off onto Google or Twitter or others is just not going to work. They are the target of these politicians.
And you know that Senator Warner, Senator Burr, Senator Klobuchar and various Congress people are going to just come at these people real hard. And that's really the danger to me. But when it comes after them, is it antitrust? I don't know. It's just worse. It could be anything. Like it's going to be worse. Now this is going to be worse. Now the issue is – let me be fair to Facebook. They've done a lot of things since then to fix stuff. Like I think they announcing some stuff soon about more to do it But they been doing a lot to fix it It just that Mark Zuckerberg and I quoted in a column I doing for the New York Times this week he cannot focus on what happened He only wants to focus on fixing things as if he, it's like you said, an arsonist, you know, cleaning up the mess or something.
And that wasn't you, that was Anand. But, you know, the idea that they're the ones to clean this mess up.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, it's, what surprises me is that people are surprised because this is an individual. And I like your point about, you know, the fear is all right, big tech. And all of a sudden what might happen is we fire the woman, right? There's only one woman who's the senior executive. And all of a sudden she's about to become, I think she was unfairly protected, but I wonder if she's about to be unfairly punished to your point.
Kara Swisher
I think that's an interesting point because you're right. He's responsible. He's the CEO. And the controlling shareholder.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. And he controls the company, but I'm always surprised that people are surprised that he's not they're Jesus Christ. Because look at his background, all right? He dropped out of college. He screwed over his close friends in college. Then he royally screwed over his best friends soon after he started Facebook. His first professional endeavor was a website that evaluated women on their physical appearance. And he last year proposed a third class of stocks such that he could sell all his stock in Facebook and still control a flock more vast than Christianity. I I mean, what could go wrong? Doesn't this person just reek of poor character and been totally insular?
And it's hard not to imagine. It's hard to imagine how a guy like this who became a billionaire so young, became so powerful, doesn't become totally insular and detached. I remember that interview you did where he started sweating like a maniac when he just didn't understand that people were worried about him knowing a lot of information about them. And he just seemed totally flummoxed. By the whole thing. I'm just surprised that people give him as much credit, that they're shocked that this stuff is going on. Because the article, some of it's really ugly, but isn't it just more of the same? Isn't it everything we already knew?
Kara Swisher
Yes, it is. It is. It is. It is. It is. This is something – this is why I've been going crazy about this for so long. It's because they literally are the personification of this sort of – this groupthink in Silicon Valley that everything they do is like bathed in gold, right? And everything they – every decision they make. And they live in these – they live in violent agreement with each other. Like there's no – you can see it in the lack of diversity. You can see it in the lack of like without a lot of voices in the room. You can see it. Now, they say they disagree, but they don't. They absolutely – there's nobody putting a brakes on any of these people because we treat them like boy kings. Like it's like – it's as if my teenagers were running the show. You know what I mean? And by the way, they do – my third junior will do a better job, honestly.
Scott Galloway
I agree.
Kara Swisher
You know, kind of thing because they think about these things. And so I think whether this has repercussions – and we should move on to the next thing. Whether this has repercussions, here's the deal. Young people aren't using this product as much. And the issue is that's where we're going to see it. Is it going to affect advertising? Is it going to affect usage and stuff like that? And I do think there is a lot of risk with congressional inquiries into this.
Scott Galloway
I think you're half right. I think that a red state DA or kind of a flyer might be a small Latin American nation or a small northern European nation just outright bans Facebook.
Kara Swisher
Well, yeah. Marie Gerd Vestager has been so strong on this for years.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, but you might see someone like Earl Glyde just say, you know what? We're banning Facebook.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. We just can't have it here.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. You could see a country just go gangster on these guys. In terms of the actual business, I've always maintained that people talk a big game about being angry at Facebook. And where do they go to express their outrage? Facebook. Instagram.
Kara Swisher
Right. Well, you know, I don't see I actually don't see the business, the business lighting up and advertisers don't really have any. I don't know what the Kevin system, you know, I wrote about that him leaving. I thought that was a very bad sign.
Scott Galloway
That was.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, but I don't know. Nothing. I don't see their business decelerating. That's the weird thing.
Scott Galloway
I'm going to disagree with you on this. There's there's a dissonance here. But where where where does P&G and Unilever go? They'd be if they decided to pull their advertising from Facebook and Instagram. We've seen this before with AOL. I'm sorry. I've seen it.
Kara Swisher
But they've been lauded. Hold on. They've been lauded. They'd be lauded for their noble principled stand. And then their stock would go down 3% to 5% the next day because everyone would wonder how they're going to drive traffic to Tide.com. These guys have no choice. This is a danger of a monopoly or a duopoly. These things die very slowly. Advertisers don't have any choice. I just don't. This is not – these are not good directionals because the question is if they fire anybody, which they won't, the lack of accountability. I mean, at the very least, this lawyer, Joel Kaplan in Washington, seems quite, his misjudgments are quite perplexing to me. The, including sitting behind Brett Kavanaugh at the hearings, you know, talk about conflict of interest. You know, this is the person who's Facebook's person in Washington. And he can have an opinion about Brett Kavanaugh. He just can keep it to himself, like in terms of, on both sides, by the way, speaking of, I can't believe I used that term. But, but it's, it's just, we'll see. We'll see. I just, I'm going to disagree. I think this is a really bad.
Scott Galloway
I have a couple of questions from a person who's not a journalist but a commentator. You're a journalist. The thing that – a couple of things stood out to the article. First is they're clearly going after each other.
Kara Swisher
Yes.
Scott Galloway
And that is clearly the board, board members went off the record. Erskine Bowles.
Kara Swisher
Erskine Bowles was very angry it looked like in that story. I heard that. And he's clearly going on background. Well, I don't know. I'm guessing. Or somebody is. I would guess, yes. Information's coming out of the boardroom.
Scott Galloway
Yes, that's what's going to –
Kara Swisher
And that means – The dime dropping is going to be the problem. I mean, I'm sure I haven't even looked at my emails today. I'm sure there's 20 dimes dropping into Kara Swisher's email. And a couple of political ramifications. I believed until about a month ago that Sheryl Sandberg was probably one of the five or six most likely nominees for the Democratic nomination for president.
Scott Galloway
I said no.
Kara Swisher
Oh, no, you're wrong. Well, I think she was planning to run for president. And that's done now. And the other thing is I think Charles Schumer just got or Chuck Schumer just got himself a competitor for his next election.
Scott Galloway
I agree.
Kara Swisher
I have to say, you know, I noted as I did a podcast with him in which he was kept praising Facebook. Here's a clip from that interview. [Audio clip plays] "You know, Facebook's a very powerful force. I think overall it's been a very positive force. I think now people are taking advantage of the openness of the net and Facebook has an obligation to try and deal with it. I think they, I've talked to them. I truly believe they want to. I truly believe they know that their future is at stake with this. I also believe it's a hard thing to do. And here's another thing I worry about. They tried to do certain things in the past, and the hard right went and criticized them.
Because much of this, the left does very little of this. I mean, we don't use bots the way the Russians would or the hard right people would. And we, meaning the left, not me. So I think when they do that, the hard right criticizes them. They're going to have to be a little more immune to that criticism and go after the fake stuff and separate it from the legitimate stuff, even if it's, you know, a little bit crazy what legitimate people are saying and doing." [End clip] But do you, when you talk about this power, you're pretty kind to the tech companies. A lot of people are less thrilled with them.
[Audio clip continues] "Yeah, I am more sympathetic because I think they're in a very difficult position and I worry about government regulation." [End clip] And I was like, what are you talking about? They're a disaster. Like, I put up the exchange today on Twitter, and at the time I was perplexed by it. But now this like that he went after Warner and Burr, like now I get it or Warner I guess, just Warner because he's on his side. But I was at the time I literally finished the podcast. I'm like what was that? He has no sense that there are some issues here with this company. And then I thought well maybe he's just a Luddite.
You know what I mean? I was like maybe he just doesn't get it. But I guess he got it.
Scott Galloway
I agree. And the last thing, the scariest thing I thought about the article, and you tell me what you thought the most disturbing thing, the fact that they actually fomented the notion that Soros was behind this.
Kara Swisher
Soros. Man. Oh, my gosh. So they're trading in conspiracy theories. The definers. It's just, wow, that is really, I mean, that is, you know, that's stuff of a movie.
Scott Galloway
I've got to tell you, how much of an asshole do you have to be to call yourself the definers? I'm sorry. The definers.
Kara Swisher
The definers.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, that sounds like a bad 70s rock band. We're the definers. Our latest hit.
Kara Swisher
Yes. It's just like, oh. Next up, the definers. What do you think the scariest thing that came? I'm sorry. It's got to be all guys sitting there going, yeah, that's a cool name. No woman would sit there and go, yeah, I'll call myself the definer. The definers. Oh, my God. That is dudes.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, that's dudes. Jeez Louise.
Kara Swisher
All right. So what was the scariest thing in your mind that came out of that article? What was the most shocking thing?
Scott Galloway
Oh, God, I got to read it again. I got to take notes. I got to. The dirty tricks.
Kara Swisher
The dirty tricks. I saw them react like petty assholes to a lot of stuff, but this was like, whoa. And then I remember what they did a couple years ago against Google. They fomented a fake kind of thing at Google and got in trouble for it. And then I'm recalling it. I'm like, oh, I remember when they did that. I remember when they did that. So, again, I shouldn't be surprised. The dirty tricks are very disappointing. And the treatment of Alex Stamos, who I know pretty well, who I knew at Yahoo, who had tried to uncover a lot of hacking stuff. And I don't think he probably should have told them quicker and stuff like that. But instead of focusing on the fact that he didn tell them quicker or tell them correctly it was that versus oh my God we have a leak So at least He clearly the whistleblower here right
Scott Galloway
Oh yeah he talking He the person who called the Times He comes out of this actually looking pretty good He's talked a lot. He's been on podcasts and stuff like that. He's now at Stanford teaching. I like him a lot. I've dealt with him a lot when he was at Yahoo. He was sort of—a lot of these CEOs want to cover up this stuff or find a way to make it less horrible. And he's not one of them. He's not one of them.
Kara Swisher
So, yeah, it seemed like it. I don't know. I don't know. I don't know who's talking to who. But it's, you know, clearly there's 50 people talking here and there's going to be 500 people talking now. All right. Next thing. Let's go into an ad break. We'll take a quick break. And when we get back, we'll talk more.
Ad Break
Ad Content: QuickBooks story about Nat
All right, Scott, that was the overplayed. It's not overplayed by any stretch. But what's the most underreported story this week?
Scott Galloway
So I think a pretty big deal is that Apple has decided to officially distribute their iPhones on Amazon. That is a big deal.
Kara Swisher
It is a big deal. It didn't get a lot of attention. You're right. It did not.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. Yeah. So effectively, one of the keys to building a brand is your distribution, right? Hermes doesn't distribute through Walmart. Levi's, Red Tab won't even distribute through, you know, JCPenney's. Actually, they're in JCPenney's, but they won't distribute through the orange tab through different points of distribution because you want to line up, right? Aspiration. Macy's won't carry anything that's in Sears. The distribution has a big impact on a consumer's perception of your brand. And Apple, the ultimate luxury brand, is now on Amazon. And that's a big move. I believe that it's another signal that Apple has jumped the shark and we're at peak Apple.
Kara Swisher
Really? Okay. Let me talk about that. If you were to say what is the most value-accretive decision in the history of business, most people would say it's Apple's introduction of the iPhone, right? Okay. The rocket ship that took them to a trillion. And I think they get the brand right but the decision wrong. I think the ultimate gangster move here that created the first trillion-dollar company was Apple's decision to take literally billions of dollars out of broadcast advertising, actually under-indexed on advertising, and to pour it into this dying medium called stores. And they have made these just temples to the brand that are just mind-blowing in terms of how good they are and how good you feel about. I still am happy in an Apple store.
Scott Galloway
I have to say I was just in one.
Kara Swisher
Oh, they're wonderful.
Scott Galloway
And then if you buy an Android phone, back to Android, you go into a place with bad lighting with a guy named Roy. And he sells you an Android phone. And all you can think about is going back to the Apple store. So distribution is distribution. You should have food at the Apple store, don't you think?
Kara Swisher
Anyways. They should have a cafeteria there. I would live there. I would like to live there. I would work there. So anyways, they – incredible, incredible bold decision to create – I think they have $7 or $8 billion in leases, 500 and whatever, 50 stores around. When they go into Amazon, I think they're basically saying we need the growth and they're denigrating their distribution. And I worry over time if it's the beginning or the end of their margin.
That is an interesting point you make. I think they got to sell more iPhones. I do think about that. I didn't really buy the new iPhone. I didn't because it wasn't enough. You know what I mean? I probably will probably get to it. I'll probably replace it because that was on that weird year plan. I don't understand whatsoever. And so I'll probably replace them in some way and my kids too. But you're right. I think they have to sell more. And obviously the issues in China where they've been having a lot of growth are going to be myriad as going forward, especially with these tariffs and trade talks. That is if the Trump people can stop being in the reality show of attacking each other every day inside the White House, if they can focus on it. But some of this China stuff I think is problematic for them. And then there is the question of whether they have a new product that's really exciting that I will spend more money on. I will spend more money to maintain my Apple presence, but is there something exciting that I would spend a lot of money on? I think that's—
Scott Galloway
Everyone talks about services, but this is – it's going to be really interesting because even Nike, which you'd argue is one of the best brands in the world, when they decided to officially distribute or a limited number of SKUs on Amazon, it didn't work. Even Nike couldn't force Amazon to clean up all the gray market stuff, unauthorized distribution.
Kara Swisher
I've bought Apple things on Amazon. I have.
Scott Galloway
Accessories though, right?
Kara Swisher
Yeah, accessories. Or refurbished phones.
Not refurbished phones. I don't buy refurbished phones. Yeah. This is a fairly big deal, but it'll be interesting to see if it works. Under-reported. I agree with you on this.
Scott Galloway
Typically, Amazon, you know, they always say we're partnering. Amazon says we're partnering with Apple. Apple says we're partnering with Amazon. Typically, Amazon partners with a brand the way a virus partners with a host. And that is, it works out really well for one of them. So I'll be curious if this works for Apple. And it'll be reported kind of six months in what happened.
Kara Swisher
Right. Well, my only unreported thing is this. Today, the Saudi prosecutor seeks death penalty for five people allegedly involved in the journalist Jamal Khashoggi's death. I mean, honestly, this was reported a lot, but it sort of fell off the pages during the midterms. But honestly, these people, like what I tweeted was the lying liars have lied. What a surprise. And they're thugs. And again, good luck taking their money, Uber and others. So I just think it should. So basically, these are the five guys. This is what we should keep reporting on.
Scott Galloway
The witnesses who are going to be killed.
Kara Swisher
Yes. That is what they are. That is what they are. So they're the fall guys.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. Well, we'll see. They were doing their job. They were sent to assassinate someone. I don't know. Well, hopefully not. Hopefully people will bang at it and it remains a reported story and they link it to the higher parts of the government.
Kara Swisher
There's no question to me that these people don't, like, breathe without permission. You know what I mean? Like, in these countries especially. So to pretend – again, it's not – because someone died. In this case, it was an actual murder. But like nothing happens at the top of any of these companies or any of these countries without these people knowing. Yes, I'm annoying. And pretending like you're like some addled – whatever. I just don't – you know, one of the things that was interesting in that New York – getting back to the New York Times piece was, you know, I had had a problem with Mark answering my question about the impact of his inventions on real people and about people dying.
And in the piece, in the New York Times piece, the board got really frustrated when he was – when they were revealing the Russia problems. He whirred through solutions without discussing why it happened. Like, you know what I mean? Like, the same thing. It's the same idea. Like, and they were very frustrated by this – it's whirring was the – I can – that's what he does. He whirs. Like, mm-mm-mm-mm. Like, and not discussing. Anyway, it was interesting. So, I think – Should we talk about a win of the week?
Scott Galloway
Win of the week. I want to plug something.
Kara Swisher
Yes, let's go that. Win of the week. Go ahead.
Scott Galloway
So my colleague at NYU Stern, Jonathan Haidt, who is just this rock star thinker.
Kara Swisher
Is this the guy who wrote the book? What book did he write?
Scott Galloway
The Coddling of the American Mind.
Kara Swisher
Coddling, yes. It just came out.
Scott Galloway
Coddling. I should have him on the podcast. It is so – oh, you should. He's fantastic. And it's really fantastic research that says that the rise of smartphones in combination with sort of this bulldozer concierge parenting where we clear out all the obstacles for our kids has created a generation of kids who have never been safer. There's less drunk driving. There's less, you know, teen pregnancies. But we've also created the most emotionally vulnerable generation. And they get to college and they're hugely depressed.
Kara Swisher
Interesting.
Scott Galloway
And you can literally track this generation. And now there's colleges, including my alma mater, that are disinviting speakers because, you know, they're offensive.
Kara Swisher
Oh, right. And they're worried they'll be traumatized. Oh, this is this gang who just cares about people. Oh, come on. This is not our biggest problem. I'm going to disagree with you on this one. I hate all these writers that write about this, but I will read his book. But I don't think them not being able to hear his speeches. We're creating a generation of snowflakes? Oh, come on. Like, that's what college students do. They're a pain in the ass. These people are like, oh, we can't speak at colleges. It's like, oh, I'm a victim. Oh, the mob of Twitter. Oh, come on. They disinvited Sam Zell. I mean, is he really that bad? I don't know. But that's what happens at colleges all the time. I don't know. I just, I don't think it's our national crisis, like the way some of these writers.
Scott Galloway
You have students yelling down professors in class.
Kara Swisher
Oh, no.
Scott Galloway
Oh, you're kidding. And where does that happen? It happens on the East Coast and it happens on the West Coast where we have wealthy parents coddling their kids.
Kara Swisher
I don't care. So I have a question. I know you're 13-year-olds in the other room. Are you a coddler?
Scott Galloway
No, I'm not a coddler.
Kara Swisher
I'm a total coddler.
Scott Galloway
No. Oh, my gosh.
Kara Swisher
I'm a total coddler. And here's why. Let me just say, if someone yells someone down, they yell someone down. Who cares, Scott? Like, honestly, this is not our greatest crisis of America. Like literally in America where everyone gets to blab all the frigging time, these people are complaining about not getting to blab.
Scott Galloway
Oh, no, not that. It's slippery. They say the word slippery slope. I'm going to push them down a slippery slope. We have a vizsla, and whenever my wife and I argue, the dog senses it and it goes upstairs. It just can't handle controversy.
Kara Swisher
Well, I'm just telling you. And I'm the same way. When my wife goes after one of our kids, I freak out and I have to go upstairs. I just can't handle it.
Scott Galloway
They disinvited people somewhat. She is doing what they need to do. One of Jonathan Haidt's great analogies is that we have so many – we're trying so hard using so many clean wipes around our kids' lives to disinfect them that they're not building the immunities they need.
Kara Swisher
Yes. And I thought that was an outstanding –
Scott Galloway
That is probably true. That is true. That was an outstanding analogy.
Kara Swisher
That is a good analogy. I mean, I was bullied a little bit. I don't know if you were bullied, but I look back on it.
Scott Galloway
Oh, really? I was. Never. Not once. Not once.
Kara Swisher
You did the bullying.
Scott Galloway
I did not. I protected people from bullies.
Kara Swisher
Wow. That's outstanding.
Scott Galloway
I ran the playground, Scott. What do you think? Hello. I ran it so well.
Kara Swisher
I can totally see that. I can totally see that.
Scott Galloway
I ran a tight playground.
Kara Swisher
I'm running your ass over in the Fiesta. So, yeah, but I think you learn coping mechanisms. And when I see what happens at my kids' school, they literally, there is just so much emphasis on protection. And it may have gone too far. No, I'm a more suck-it-up sister-mother kind of thing.
Scott Galloway
Sister. Good for you. Alex is going to. Alex and Louie, they're good. We're all going to work for Alex.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, that's true. That is absolutely true, 100%. The Jonathan Haidt, The Coddling of the American Mind, an outstanding book. The only thing I'm going to say is these intellectual dark web people exhaust me with their whining. Like, stop. If you say stupid things, you're going to get people attacking you. When I say stupid things on the web, people attack me. That is the game. And if they want to be famous, they have to suck it up. I'm sorry. They need to suck it up.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, but there is a – I do think there is a princess and the pea construct where all of a sudden everybody is just so offended and so angry at everything. And the moment you're a victim, you're right.
Kara Swisher
I know. Right? If you're offended by something, you're automatically right.
Scott Galloway
Oh, suck it up. And I don't think that's the way.
Kara Swisher
Suck it up, Scott. Suck it up. You want to be comfortable.
Scott Galloway
Well, right back at you. I'm going to suck it up.
Kara Swisher
Right back at you. Suck it up.
Scott Galloway
I'm going to suck it up. That's why I suck it up all the time.
Kara Swisher
Snowflake.
Scott Galloway
Snowflakey.
Kara Swisher
I'm not snow. I don't care either way. I don't care if people like me or dislike me. I do not care. It's fine if they want to bar me from things. I don't care. I'm not going to get all indignant. I'm not going to get all dignified to have a little hissy.
Scott Galloway
By the way, my brain almost exploded today. I can see you having a hissy.
Kara Swisher
I was about to go on. What?
Scott Galloway
I was about to. I was getting mic'd up to be on MSNBC. And I look up and you're there on Morning Joe.
Kara Swisher
I did it two weeks ago or a week ago.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. That was timing. That was tape recorded?
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Scott Galloway
Timing is beautiful. Wow. It seemed very timely. I know with the chemical spill and everything. I look like a genius. Like, I look like a frigging genius. I do. By the way, and you're going to hate this question. Is there just a ton of sexual energy between those two?
Kara Swisher
There is. I'm sorry to say.
Scott Galloway
I feel like they're about to throw down on the desk.
Kara Swisher
They did. They kissed for me. Go look at my Twitter. They kissed for me. I put it on Twitter.
Scott Galloway
Oh, my God. They're so hot. I would like to see them have sex.
Kara Swisher
I had – people were like – they have a lot of detractors on Twitter when I put that picture up. I was like, you know what? I had the most fun at that play. I was like –
Scott Galloway
They're dreamy. I'm down with their whole jam. I'm good with their jam. Their jam is good. I get why you don't like it. But I do. So just butt out.
Kara Swisher
Same thing. All right. The only thing I would say for the thing was the win was the forced arbitration thing that moved from Google to Facebook. We don't have Facebook and Airbnb. So fail. Last quick fail and then we'll go.
Scott Galloway
Fail. What's the fail?
Kara Swisher
Quick fail. Come on. It's got to be like this Facebook stuff. I mean I know everyone's piling on, but this is just really discouraging. I mean it's upsetting. It really is upsetting. So fail, you know, Facebook. I hope we have the backbone and our elected officials have the backbone to do more than just whine and actually address this problem.
Scott Galloway
I think the fail this week was Sarah Sanders, the editing of that video, the way they edited that video.
Kara Swisher
Oh, my gosh. Speeding it up. I love that Fox is on CNN's side.
Scott Galloway
And then Kellyanne Conway said, wait, they do that on ESPN all the time.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, I know. It's like slow-mo replay or something. You know who I love, though? Her husband, George Conway. Speaking of marriage jams that I love. He's now formed a group. It's called like—it has some fantastic legal name. What is it? It's like definers, but it's good.
Scott Galloway
What is it? I think it's the key to their marriage. I think that's foreplay.
Kara Swisher
No, I don't think—
Scott Galloway
I think he goes out and he says something and she comes home and she says—
Kara Swisher
We are so like five minutes from divorce or something. If you say that again and then they like go at it, I think it's total foreplay.
Scott Galloway
No, Scott. Scott, oh my God. I'm trying to keep this clean and you always manage to bring in like— Do you think he has an Android phone?
Kara Swisher
No.
Scott Galloway
Do you think that's killing his vibe? Anti-Trump clump. He's competing with the Federalist Society and it's called—hold on.
Kara Swisher
Oh, wait, this is such a good name. Do you know Kellyanne Conway? I know I've never met her.
Scott Galloway
Checks and Balances.
Kara Swisher
Oh, my God. The group is called Checks and Balances, started by George Conway.
Scott Galloway
I love him. Checks and Balances. I love him. I would like to be his friend. I would like to go to their house for dinner. If they would invite me, I'm here in D.C. Conway's, George Conway, I have a man crush on you. Like, I can't stand with his Checks and Balances. I think it's so good. It's better than the Definers.
Kara Swisher
I would not want to get in the way of Kellyanne Conway. You better be careful. You might disappear.
Scott Galloway
Don't worry about it. I just want to be his best friend. I just want to hang with him. I just want to like go over.
Kara Swisher
You want to roll with him?
Scott Galloway
Yes. There is a great profile in the Washington Post about the two of them that is brilliant. It's a brilliant depiction. And since then, I've just been – they've been my like Kardashians. I don't know.
Kara Swisher
Anyway. All right, Scott. It's time to get out of here. This is a lively one this week. I will see you next week. Last thing. I know I keep expanding this. Most interesting thing that came out of your Benioff interview.
Scott Galloway
Yes. The stuff about the homeless.
Kara Swisher
I think he has been pushing this, is shaming. Some people think of him as a blowhard. I asked him that directly. And I don't care if he's a blowhard. He's a good blowhard as far as I'm concerned. And he's been pushing on the homeless stuff and pushing for them to give money and to take their hands off of their giant sums of cash and hand it out to people as fortune. And look for solutions because it's not an easy solution in San Francisco, the homeless problem. And it's not nobody looks good. The whole gang doesn't look good there, but these people with money and means and ideas should be part of the solution. And I like that. Go, Mark.
Scott Galloway
Go, Mark. He looks like the guy you want to hug. He's very big and huggable.
Kara Swisher
He's big. He's like 6'5". He's like really tall. He was like eating food. He brought David Blaine. I don't know why.
Scott Galloway
The magician?
Kara Swisher
Yeah. And I said the magician, and he goes, well, he's a person too. David Blaine? Yeah, but he's the magician. He was there. I don't know why.
Scott Galloway
Yeah?
Kara Swisher
He had a crew. He brought David Blaine. So there you have it.
Scott Galloway
Wow. Whatever.
Kara Swisher
We had a great time. It was at the top of Salesforce Tower. You could see the – speaking of fires, you could see the fires and the smoke and the smoke from the fires. Speaking of underreported, right? I mean literally California is on fire and there's just so much chaos. We don't even – we barely notice. It's very sad.
Scott Galloway
I was there for two days. It was hard to breathe. It actually felt like it was in Beijing or something. It was really sad and it cast a pall over the whole city. And the people dying, it's just – the extent of it has not been known and it's sad that entire towns have been decimated and people have died in just terrible circumstances.
Kara Swisher
Actually, that's another fail of the week. And I know you deal with it.
Scott Galloway
I'm glad to hear it. To come out and say that the forestry services have fault here. Don't even.
Kara Swisher
And I'm thinking, okay, so I live in Florida. Are all the hurricanes the forestry services' fault as well? That's just so obscene. That was a depressing moment. But again, what a surprise. Anyway.
Scott Galloway
There we go. It's time to get out of here. I will thank you for doing it. We'll look forward to talking next week. It's Thanksgiving week.
Kara Swisher
And by the way, if you have questions for us or stuff you'd like to hear on this podcast, shoot us an email at pivot at voxmedia.com, pivot at voxmedia.com. Rebecca Sinanis produces this show. Nishat Kurwa is Vox Media's executive producer of audio. Thanks also to Eric Johnson. And thanks for listening to Pivot from Vox Media. Join us next week for more breakdown of all things tech and business. If you like what you heard, please subscribe on Apple Podcasts or wherever you're listening. We'll see you next time. Learn more?