Podcast Episode Summary
The podcast episode of Pivot, hosted by Cara Swisher and Scott Galloway, discusses the latest news and issues surrounding Facebook, including its handling of user data and partnerships. The conversation revolves around a recent New York Times article exposing Facebook's selective sharing of user data with various partners, including Netflix, Spotify, and the Royal Bank of Canada.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Other Topics Discussed:
Announcer
This episode of Pivot is brought to you by Microsoft Azure. To amplify your ideas and achieve more with artificial intelligence and advanced analytics, on Azure, your trusted cloud. Start your free account today at azure.com/trial. That's A-Z-U-R-E dot com slash trial.
Cara Swisher
Hi, everyone. This is Pivot from the Vox Media Podcast Network. I'm Cara Swisher. Scott Galloway: And I'm Scott Galloway, staring at Cara Swisher, which is an enormous treat in the same room, so you can probably feel the banter and the electricity and the buzz being in the same room, Cara.
Yes, here we are. Here we are in New York City. So there's a lot to talk about, so let's get into it because we've only got a few more shows before the new year.
Scott Galloway
But obviously, again, we're talking about Facebook. Another story from The New York Times, again, about Facebook's violation of privacy, which is something they've been doing since the beginning. But a really bad one, again, selective handing out of information to different groups depending on partnerships and things like that.
Cara Swisher
And what is your sense of how was this determined? Was this pure oversight or was it a pay-to-play thing? Who got special access? Different people got different things for different partnerships.
Scott Galloway
I think that's the thing is that they were sort of—they were giving special—they weren't selling the data. They were giving it away as part of partnerships. And then it depended on whether it was the Royal Bank of Canada or Netflix or Spotify or Bing or things like that.
Cara Swisher
And so various—they gave away various bits of privacy and sometimes the partners didn't even use it or didn't intend to use it. Didn't ask for it. Yeah. They were just—you know, they had this partnerships thing.
Scott Galloway
I think it was under Dan Rose who has since left Facebook. And I think they just were making partnership after partnership to advantage Facebook and part of the deal as they did with the Cambridge Analytica information to give to third parties to track people to platform. They give away different bennies essentially.
Cara Swisher
So I read this as consumers love frictionless content and things for free, and this is part of the downside. But have you heard—have you reached out to Facebook? What's their official response on this?
Scott Galloway
Well, they did. They gave responses that we have been trying to be transparent. I think the issue is that it piles onto other things, Facebook misusing data. And whether—you know, it's interesting because I put up something like this. More than anything, it shows kind of sloppy management of partnerships really.
Cara Swisher
People were like, no, it's criminal. No, it's this. It's not criminal necessarily. And the question is who's going to decide whether people gave consent, whether they should have gave consent.
Scott Galloway
You know, I think the—the issue is their sort of sloppy management of data and their voracious sucking in of data at the same time. So, but my question is this feels a little bit Trumpian in the sense that when there's so many dumpster fires, you just see a fire and one dumpster fire doesn't look any brighter than the other.
Cara Swisher
Are we just becoming inoculated or numb to this?
Scott Galloway
No, I think people—I think this kind of stuff does get Congress going and get regulators going. And you just saw today the District of Columbia is suing Facebook based on the Cambridge Analytica stuff.
Cara Swisher
So, I think just what happens is a pile on, which has happened to them before when they had Beacon, if you remember. It just was a much smaller environment. And now everybody is piling on and it's not just what's interesting is there's one sort of attack from the privacy angle and what people gave consent to and the misuse of data or the use of data properly but not in ways people thought it was being used and whether that was illegal or not illegal and then there's the question of malevolent actors using the platform as it was built and then there's an issue of addiction and then there's, it just, it all sort of mushes up together and gets away from the fact is are people using this product and do they like using this product even at the cost of privacy.
Scott Galloway
But at this point, I would argue there doesn't seem to be any evidence that consumers care. Yet.
Cara Swisher
I don't agree with that. I think young people don't want to use Facebook. I don't know if it's because of privacy issues. I think it's uncool, I think, pretty much.
Scott Galloway
But the issue is can they, facing all these various things, can they continue to innovate and run their company when they're facing so many inquiries? Which is, you know, what happened to Microsoft. It happens to all of them.
Cara Swisher
Yeah, it's just you know the mood there and you hear so little about it. I used to hear from Facebook. People would call me, the people I know there and say, Scott, you need to stop piling on. It sounds personal. You look ridiculous. And I don't hear from those people anymore.
Scott Galloway
I don't hear anything. They're gone. Yeah. A lot of people I've been talking to at Facebook are want to leave. They want out. They want out, yeah.
Cara Swisher
No fun. And where do they go? I mean, they just want to go somewhere else. They're worried about their personal reputations. A lot of people I've had coffee with are like, oh, how do I look?
Scott Galloway
They want to go to Instagram. Yeah, right. I know Instagram's owned by Facebook. What's up? No, the Instagram guy left because he was sick of this stuff.
Cara Swisher
Yeah, Kevin Systrom. He was sick of the meddling of Facebook and the misuse of his platform, I think, in a lot of ways.
Scott Galloway
And so what do you think, I mean, you know, I always have my talk track over breaking these guys up, but what do you think actually happens?
Cara Swisher
So death by a thousand cuts, but what does death look like? What's going to happen here?
Scott Galloway
I don't know. I don't know. It's a good question. I think possibly, you know, they could be spurred into management change.
Cara Swisher
I think that's probably what happens a lot of time. There's pressure from the board we got to do something like you can imagine there's a meeting right now going on at Facebook's board going oh Jesus either it's let's just sit still which is what they've done before in the past when these things happen and be very quiet and just promise things which is their way which has been their history that's how they handle a lot of this stuff or do they actually say okay we're going to get a new CEO in here to run things are we going to replace Sheryl Sandberg are we going to replace Blank you could see departures by certain people Maybe Joel Kaplan.
Scott Galloway
Maybe, you know, who knows? That just feels – when you say management change, there's only really two people that would constitute a management change.
Cara Swisher
There's more people, but you don't know them. But yes, OK. But from a public perception standpoint – Cheryl and Mark.
Scott Galloway
It's Cheryl and Mark. Yeah. And so you didn't agree with this, but I think Cheryl – I think the first time there's 90 seconds of calm or 90 days of calm, I think she announces she's going to run a foundation.
Cara Swisher
She declares victory and she leaves. I've heard she has said to people she has not.
Scott Galloway
Well, no one says they're leaving until the day they leave. No, I think she means it. I think she wants to clean it up.
Cara Swisher
But what the board should be doing is kicking Mark up to chairman and bringing in a new CEO.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. That would, in my opinion, restore the stock price. Yeah. Send a signal.
Cara Swisher
And also, everyone says, look, they can't do it because he controls the board.
Scott Galloway
But if you actually play it out, what happens? If the board all holds hands around the fire and gets in the boat together and puts out a press release saying we're removing him as CEO, he's going to be chairman, the next day he's not going to replace all of them.
Cara Swisher
Trust me when I tell you that. There's no way Mark Andreessen and Peter Thiel will do that to Mark Zuckerberg ever.
Scott Galloway
Because they are – They will not. Because they are such a fan of them? Because I know their personal relationships. They just won't. They won't. It's not their mentality.
Cara Swisher
They're very victim-y like we're being attacked. Yeah. Well, they aren't. The board has been – the board actually hasn't come under fire in my view.
Scott Galloway
No but we are in this together as a group and he hasn done anything that bad and he built the greatest company in history and blah blah blah blah That probably means you need new board members or you need to start calling out the board as responsible I think I will do that.
Cara Swisher
Well, just listing their names and tweeting at them and saying, what's your view on this? Hey, Reed Hastings, does this mean your platform is next to be weaponized?
Scott Galloway
Right. And also Netflix was involved in this, that they got some sort of private messages.
Cara Swisher
I wasn't really clear what the data they were getting. They were getting unusual. I mean everyone had a deal with Facebook. Why wouldn't you? Because that's where the information is.
Scott Galloway
And what it kind of comes down to is the reason Netflix won't be weaponized is that social media is nicotine. It's addictive. It's not good for you.
Cara Swisher
I would argue it's not that bad for you. But the tobacco here, the stuff that gives you cancer is advertising.
Scott Galloway
Because it's a pursuit of more engagement, which leads to rage, which leads to a lack of concern around screening content and advertisers.
Cara Swisher
That's the stuff that gives you lung cancer. So Netflix, Spotify, much less likely to be weaponized.
Scott Galloway
It's the ad-supported. The bottom line is advertising, despite all the fun we have watching Mad Men, advertising really is the source of evil here.
Cara Swisher
It's the business model. What would be interesting is, I don't know if this could ever work, but if you tried to model out charging for Facebook or Instagram.
Scott Galloway
Someone was putting that up on Twitter just now, $12 for a social network that is just private.
Cara Swisher
Yeah, because what's shocking about advertising, is that the lack of respect that the ecosystem and brands have for your time.
Scott Galloway
So Modern Family, fantastic show. ABC and Disney are able to get 49 cents per viewer by pelting you with nine minutes of crap to convince you you have restless leg syndrome and you need a car from South Korea and interrupt that gorgeous content three times nine minutes.
Cara Swisher
They get a grand total of 49 cents. So if you think your time is worth more than $2 and whatever it is, I'm sorry, more than $2.40 an hour, you'll pay iTunes.
Scott Galloway
But I wonder if we are slowly but surely moving to a more subscription model.
Cara Swisher
And maybe that's wishful thinking, but if you look at the media that's increased tens of millions of dollars in the last few years, it's got one of two things.
Scott Galloway
It's either got massive scale, we're talking billions of people, right? YouTube or Facebook, or it's subscription-based.
Cara Swisher
It's Spotify, it's Netflix, and it doesn't have the carcinogen or the precancerous cells of ad-supported media, which when you look at it is really the source of all problems here.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, absolutely. I mean, I think lots of people have talked about Tim Cook.
Cara Swisher
Is it time for a commercial break, by the way?
Scott Galloway
No, it's not. No, it's not. No, yeah, speaking of that.
Cara Swisher
But there's different kind of advertising. We're not sitting around really highly targeting people in the way that this is.
Scott Galloway
This is a different kind of advertising that has changed things.
Cara Swisher
I mean, one is some spray and pray ad is very different from what's going on here.
Scott Galloway
And that brings to mind the detailed report given to the Senate Intelligence Committee, two of them, about how social media was used for the Russian election interference.
Cara Swisher
It wasn't just Facebook. It was Twitter and Google's YouTube and others.
Scott Galloway
The report also showed specific, one of the reports showed specific targeting of African-Americans on Facebook and Instagram.
Cara Swisher
It caused all kinds of things. There were lots of details in this.
Scott Galloway
But it sent, and then I think the shoe that really dropped is like that the government said that these companies are not helping us.
Cara Swisher
They're giving us information in dribs and drabs. They're not giving us all the information we need to figure out what happened.
Scott Galloway
And so we're really angry at them for that. That was also an accusation that they're not helping us figure out how their platforms were misused over the past couple of years.
Cara Swisher
Well, it was sort of the – if you look at what the judge has – all these judges have been saying to Michael Cohen and Michael Flynn.
Scott Galloway
They want it both ways. They want to look like they're helping for purposes of getting leniency from the court.
Cara Swisher
But they're not really coming clean, so to speak.
Scott Galloway
And the judges aren't having it. No. They're saying you either turn states – you either cooperate or you don't.
Cara Swisher
There's no middle ground. And they all sort of want to be able to say to the president kind of inadvertently, I held the line.
Scott Galloway
Please pardon me. Right. And I think these judges or people are saying the same thing about these social media platforms is that when Congress has asked for data, it turns out that they weren't as forthright as they could have been.
Cara Swisher
And I just I just wonder, do we have and this is this is the danger, right, is that when for profit companies become so powerful that they effectively become the government, they were just outgunned.
Scott Galloway
And if you have people who don't understand the technologies, people who don't have the will, people who are working on a reelection campaign and need donors, and this stuff is complicated and hard and you're up against huge adversaries, do Google and Facebook and Amazon effectively become our government and we continue this march towards tyranny?
Cara Swisher
Tyranny. The tyranny of Joe Biden. The tyranny of – well, the tyranny of technology.
Scott Galloway
But when you look at really bad areas – The tyranny of technology. There is in our history. There has been oftentimes there's been a common theme and that is private enterprise has become too powerful and become the government.
Cara Swisher
I mean I think that's the question. I mean government has stepped in before with big oil, big this, big that, Microsoft, AT&T.
Scott Galloway
This has happened. They're not that dumb. Like to say – to abrogate the responsibility of regulating these companies, I think that's what happened is these people have no rules and there's been no rules.
Cara Swisher
I was talking to someone today. They're like, well, we need more legislation. I'm like, any legislation. Anything.
Scott Galloway
There's no legislation legislating these companies or a very – a de minimis amount. I can't even think of – Well, even strip away kind of content decency acts.
Cara Swisher
You can name 10 media bills, media laws. What are any – Well, even just taking away regulations.
Scott Galloway
So there was regulation in 1997 I think with the Content Decency Act that exempted these nascent platforms.
Cara Swisher
Immunity, Section 230. Immunity and just take that – is that Section 230?
Scott Galloway
Thanks very much, guys. So it's – yeah, it's just taking that away.
Cara Swisher
But the keyword there and if we're going to be hopeful about 19 because I'm with Debbie Diamond on that stuff.
Scott Galloway
You would like to think that 19 would be the year of immunities kicking in?
Cara Swisher
Immunities. What do you mean?
Scott Galloway
Well, have we had enough? Are we going to start proposing regulation?
Cara Swisher
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Scott Galloway
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Cara Swisher
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Scott Galloway
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Cara Swisher
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Scott Galloway
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Cara Swisher
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Scott Galloway
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Cara Swisher
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Scott Galloway
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Cara Swisher
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Scott Galloway
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Cara Swisher
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Scott Galloway
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Cara Swisher
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Scott Galloway
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Cara Swisher
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Scott Galloway
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Cara Swisher
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Scott Galloway
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Cara Swisher
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Scott Galloway
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Cara Swisher
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Scott Galloway
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Cara Swisher
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Scott Galloway
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Cara Swisher
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Scott Galloway
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Cara Swisher
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Scott Galloway
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Cara Swisher
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Scott Galloway
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Cara Swisher
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Scott Galloway
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Cara Swisher
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Scott Galloway
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Cara Swisher
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Scott Galloway
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Cara Swisher
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Scott Galloway
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Cara Swisher
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Scott Galloway
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Cara Swisher
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Scott Galloway
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Cara Swisher
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Scott Galloway
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Cara Swisher
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Scott Galloway
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Cara Swisher
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Scott Galloway
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Cara Swisher
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Scott Galloway
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Cara Swisher
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Scott Galloway
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Cara Swisher
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Scott Galloway
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Cara Swisher
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Scott Galloway
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Cara Swisher
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Scott Galloway
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Cara Swisher
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Scott Galloway
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Cara Swisher
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Scott Galloway
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Cara Swisher
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Scott Galloway
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Cara Swisher
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Scott Galloway
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Cara Swisher
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Scott Galloway
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Cara Swisher
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Scott Galloway
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Cara Swisher
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Scott Galloway
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Cara Swisher
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Scott Galloway
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Cara Swisher
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Scott Galloway
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Cara Swisher
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Scott Galloway
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Cara Swisher
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Scott Galloway
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Cara Swisher
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Scott Galloway
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Cara Swisher
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Scott Galloway
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Cara Swisher
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Scott Galloway
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Cara Swisher
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Scott Galloway
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Cara Swisher
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Scott Galloway
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Cara Swisher
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Scott Galloway
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Cara Swisher
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Scott Galloway
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Cara Swisher
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Scott Galloway
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Cara Swisher
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Scott Galloway
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Cara Swisher
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Scott Galloway
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Cara Swisher
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Scott Galloway
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Cara Swisher
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Scott Galloway
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Cara Swisher
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Scott Galloway
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Cara Swisher
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Scott Galloway
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Cara Swisher
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Scott Galloway
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Cara Swisher
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Scott Galloway
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Cara Swisher
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Scott Galloway
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Cara Swisher
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Scott Galloway
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Cara Swisher
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Scott Galloway
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Cara Swisher
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Scott Galloway
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Cara Swisher
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Scott Galloway
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Cara Swisher
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Scott Galloway
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Cara Swisher
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Scott Galloway
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Cara Swisher
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Scott Galloway
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Cara Swisher
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Scott Galloway
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Cara Swisher
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Scott Galloway
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Cara Swisher
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Scott Galloway
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Cara Swisher
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Scott Galloway
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?
Cara Swisher
Are we going to start holding these companies responsible? Are we going to start holding these companies responsible?