Main Topic: The podcast episode discusses the book "Super Pumped, The Battle for Uber" by Mike Isaac, a journalist who used to work at The New York Times. The book explores the drama and struggles of the ride-sharing company Uber, including its business model, labor practices, and leadership.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Support for this show comes from Robinhood. Wouldn't it be great to manage your portfolio on one platform? With Robinhood, not only can you trade individual stocks and ETFs, you can also seamlessly buy and sell crypto at low costs. Trade all in one place. Get started now on Robinhood. Trading crypto involves significant risk. Crypto trading is offered through an account with Robinhood Crypto LLC. Robinhood Crypto is licensed to engage in virtual currency business activity by the New York State Department of Financial Services. Crypto held through Robinhood Crypto is not FDIC-insured or SIPC-protected. Investing involves risk, including loss of principal. Securities trading is offered through an account with Robinhood Financial LLC, member SIPC, a registered broker-dealer.
Kara Swisher
Hi, everyone. This is Pivot from the Vox Media Podcast Network. I'm Kara Swisher.
Scott Galloway
And this is Scott Galloway. Happy 50th episode, Scott.
Kara Swisher
This is You Remember. How are you feeling about our relationship?
Scott Galloway
You Remember. I remember you didn't. That was your line and you forgot it. One is paper, 10 is copper, and 50 is sativa. Okay, it's "get the hell out of here" is what it is. Or is it copper? Where are you again? You're again not in New York where you work. Where are you vacationing now?
Kara Swisher
I'm in Florida. I'm here for Never Forget Dorian. I had a plastic lawn chair blow over. So Florida strong.
Scott Galloway
Florida strong. We're hanging in there. You know, Florida, also known as Alabama, according to President Trump.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, there you go. What the hell? There you go. Oh, by the way, I did that. So you had no Dorian. I did that DNA. It's killing the rest of North Carolina, you know. I swabbed my fecal matter for that DNA test that guy sent us. And I just got the results.
Scott Galloway
What, really?
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Scott Galloway
And? What is that?
Kara Swisher
I did the DNA test, and according to this technology—
Scott Galloway
Yeah, I got it.
Kara Swisher
According to this technology, it predicts that tonight I'm going to have Forza, Coppa, and Cokes vape and watch Succession. So it's really amazing technology.
Scott Galloway
God. Succession's not on tonight, Scott. It's on the 8th.
Kara Swisher
That's my joke. I know what date it's on. That's my joke.
Scott Galloway
Okay, that's a terrible joke.
Kara Swisher
It's a terrible joke. That was awesome. I thought about that a lot. Also, don't joke about storms. It's hitting North—it's hitting the Carolinas right now very seriously. It was great that it avoided Florida. It was great that it avoided Florida. Were you scared at all? Were you nervous to be there?
Scott Galloway
Yeah, the West, for some reason, I'm not—I can tell I'm getting older because I'm fascinated by the weather, but I'm not really old in that I'm not scared of it yet. But, no, it's—
Kara Swisher
Oh, you should be scared. The Bahamas got hit really hard. Really hard. It was terrible. It looks like the Carolinas are going to get hit. This is going to be—it's bad. But you need to come back to New York City. I think it's time.
Scott Galloway
Well, it's nice to know you care.
Kara Swisher
Anyway, moving along, we have someone here today. We're trying a new thing. We're trying all kinds of new things on Pivots. And we usually do a big story breakdown. But we have in the studio Mike Isaac from The New York Times.
Mike Isaac
Hi. How you doing?
Kara Swisher
Mike used to work for me. I really, really am responsible for his entire career. But we're going to shift things up. We have big news stories. But first, we're going to talk about this big story breakdown of his book on Uber, which came out – is it today? Is it – Tuesday.
Mike Isaac
Tuesday. Okay. So this week.
Kara Swisher
Mike wrote a ton of amazing stories for The New York Times about Uber. And we're going to talk about his book, Super Pumped: The Battle for Uber. It delves into all the drama of the ride-share company in Silicon Valley, which is full of it. And we've got lots of questions. Scott, would you like to start questioning Mike Isaac about this book?
Scott Galloway
Oh, you mean the guy where the student has become the master, the guy that's putting out a bestselling book? Yeah. Okay, Mike. So first off, Mike, congratulations. I've literally seen your name everywhere. And this book is, I don't know if it's any good, but it's going to sell a lot because your publicist has done their job, which I think is the key here. It's a great book. So look, my question is the following. There's a bunch of data coming out that if you actually do the math, that Uber partners or the 4 million people who drive for Uber are oftentimes making less than minimum wage. Was there always, and I've always felt this sort of embodies the Lords versus the Surf mentality, where you have the nice mostly college-educated, mostly white people at HQ, and then you have the mostly non-white, non-college educated people actually driving the business.
And it goes to Senator Josh Hawley, who, by the way, I promoted to Wall Street Journalist last week. And I apologize for that. He's actually the junior senator from Missouri. But anyways, did you find there was much of a focus or a concern around the fact that there were a small group of people making millions, if not billions, and then this workforce that, in fact, was at certain times not even meeting minimum wage thresholds?
Mike Isaac
Yeah, I mean, I feel like the biggest thing that Uber unlocked besides shareholder value for their earliest investors was this idea of a hybrid labor force. The biggest proponents of labor rights now are saying that some of what Uber has done is really set back what that looks like for folks who are working now. There's this battle in California right now over what worker protection should be, whether Uber drivers should be full-time employees or still contract laborers. For a long time, the thought was they would land on something kind of in between, like maybe slightly more protections than just a 1099 contract worker but not completely full employees because it would just erode the business model.
Kara Swisher
Wait. First of all, is there a business model to start with? I mean, if you add on these costs, if you lard on these costs, which it isn't larding on, it's actually the people that are working there.
Scott Galloway
Right.
Kara Swisher
I'll never forget the comment that Travis made at the Code Conference when you were working on the code.
Mike Isaac
Yeah, when I was there, yeah.
Kara Swisher
Where he said, "The problem we have with our business model is the guy sitting in the front seat," which I thought encapsulated what Scott's talking about, this idea that these are disposable beings.
Mike Isaac
Yep.
Kara Swisher
And they used to call them "supply," not drivers, right? Supply. Like it was just sort of a very cold way of looking at what was essentially a giant math problem for them. And so the way of eliminating that, and that's what I talk about a little bit in the book, is this obsession with self-driving, which, again, is problematic too because there are costs that come with that that aren't really accounted for. But it is really just sort of, you know, either you increase prices for riders or you decrease wages for drivers at the end of the day. And I think for a long time it was just pushing down on those drivers and what they get paid.
Scott Galloway
Do you see this company – I mean the promise around the expectation that justifies a valuation that's – at one point was greater than Ford Motor – is that at some point they'll hit a scale where they can find profitability. And it looks as if lately their costs are maintaining pace with their scale – they're not hitting scale. After spending so much time with the company, do you think this company does in fact get to a point where it's making profits, or is this just a company that unless it can continue to spin a big story, it might in fact go to zero? Is there a there there? Or is it an Amazon? Because Amazon spun that story for a long time and it turned out they found a business that was true.
Mike Isaac
Totally. And that's their pitch right now: "Look, we are going to be this Amazon. We want to build this platform." I think early on, Travis Kalanick's proposition was—
Kara Swisher
This was the original CEO.
Mike Isaac
Yeah, the first CEO was like—
Kara Swisher
An entirely awful person.
Mike Isaac
"We're going to build this huge war chest of cash. We're going to out-raise all of our competitors, and we'll just spin them into the ground, and then we're going to own the whole thing." It's a winner-take-all thing. And that might have worked maybe five or ten years ago, but the environment has totally changed. The SoftBanks of the world have come in and they're very well-funded competitors across multiple continents. So it's not just Uber fighting Lyft in the United States. It's Uber fighting Ola in India and at one point Didi in China and regional competitor Didi in Brazil as well. So I think the landscape has shifted dramatically from what they thought the game was in the beginning. So now their whole thing is, "Because of our scale and because of our core ride-hailing business, we can move into a bunch of different categories like food and trucking."
Kara Swisher
Yeah, exactly.
Mike Isaac
And eventually, if you hang with us long enough, we can get to a point of profitability there. But it's still hard. I mean, that takes a market that is less risk-averse than I think we're in right now. I think Wall Street is looking at these losses and doesn't have the mettle that it did maybe five years ago to hang with Uber the way it did Amazon.
Kara Swisher
It's also not an Amazon-like business, right? I mean, or is it? The only thing they can do is raise prices. Because I think Amazon, I don't know about you, Scott, but when using Amazon, you're not thinking of price. You're thinking of convenience, quick delivery, which The New York Times actually had a great story today about the cost of that to workers again. And you're doing it at the expense of workers until you can replace those workers, which is far away. Or you can find another business that makes money. And I don't know. Scott, do you think there's other businesses there that could suddenly become Amazon Web Services?
Scott Galloway
Well, people talk about Uber Eats and it does have a great brand. But it's not. We're talking about apples and oranges here. Amazon pretty early on could be cash flow positive. And they had a very legitimate argument that the only reason they weren't profitable despite having positive gross margins was the massive reinvestment in the business. And Uber has made that massive reinvestment, but it doesn't have cash flow. It doesn't have gross margins. There is no kind of – Uber is no Amazon. Uber just loses more money as it gets bigger. Unless they can find a business – and Mike, tell me if you disagree with this – that starts spinning off cash flow like an Uber Eats. This is a company that could, in fact, I wouldn't say would go to zero because it has such a powerful brand and someone would want it, but it does look incredibly overvalued. What is it? I think it's off something like 23% or 25% since the IPO, and people are actually starting to check back and say, "Does this thing make sense as an ongoing business?"
Kara Swisher
So let me ask you, Mike, what do you think is the most exciting or most viable business other than ride-hailing? Because they're clearly searching. Is it Uber Freight? Is it Uber Eats?
Mike Isaac
The sort of sleeping – I don't know if I would say sleeping giant – but this thing that they're kind of quietly working on right now is less sexy but interesting. Their payments infrastructure. In order to accept payments from riders all around the world, you have to build out a pretty robust payment system. And I think what they're doing is working on this version of, think of like a Venmo-ish type thing inside of the Uber app where you can build up cash or whatever. So imagine if you can save on the millions of transactions that occur per day and somehow eke out some sort of, I don't want to say profit, but find room in those margins to eventually build a business with that cash and maybe funnel it into Uber Eats orders or different other parts of the app where you can spend money. That's something that they're trying.
Kara Swisher
Well, they wanted to get into payments to public transit systems where you put your phone down, you use your Uber app to pay. But now public transit systems like New York just initiated its own. So, I mean, that's going to be an enormously difficult business to get into.
Mike Isaac
Yeah, and add to that that they never really played well with cities in the first place. Like, how are you – I don't know. It's very complicated. I think a lot of the hype right now is around Uber Eats. But again, with food delivery, there's so much money going into competition there right now. DoorDash is getting tons of money from SoftBank. Google, Amazon.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, exactly.
Mike Isaac
Amazon, what are they going to do? Postmates is still like a player even though they're kind of in trouble. So I feel like we are five years ago where we were with ride-hailing five years ago. We are at food delivery now. Just a ton of money being burnt just to get market share.
Kara Swisher
And then what do you – writing your book, obviously a lot of it has to do with the drama around Travis Kalanick and stuff, who ended up with billions of dollars anyway, the worst person in the world running a company and doing terrible things. One of the things that struck me was like you don't get paid, there's no payback for bad behavior in the end. At one point someone was talking to me about him like, "Oh, he really got it." I'm like, "Really?" Because he just got yelled at by me and others and you. But ultimately, he was just fine. I mean, he's a billionaire five times over right now.
Mike Isaac
Right. He's cashed out. He's doing this new startup doing like cloud kitchens, also in food delivery, which is based atop of Uber and food.
Kara Swisher
Writing on the sector versus the individual. Exactly.
Mike Isaac
Yeah, exactly. And so, when I get to the ending, like, what have we learned here? It's not like he's been ostracized from well-to-do company in Silicon Valley or anything. And I do wonder what the lesson is for folks walking away from this company. Everyone that was in early and everyone that was involved in the drama made out pretty all right. So I don't know if it's a cautionary tale or just another as the wheel turns in Silicon Valley.
Kara Swisher
What's the worst thing he did from your perspective in your book?
Mike Isaac
I mean, it just depends on worst in terms of like culturally or worst in terms of like a strategic mistake. I think, honestly, if he was able to grow and change as a leader, maybe there was a way that he could have still been there today. But I think the things that made him such a strong CEO from the beginning just did not scale when he became on top of the world. And I think there's this mentality among startup CEOs that you still think you're a scrappy small guy even when you're huge. And you can still feel like the big taxi or governments are the bullies and you should be the one that's the underdog and can fight dirty or whatever. When in reality, you're the dominant player at some point. And I don't think he was able to see that. And I'm not sure if he would ever be able to see that. Maybe that's the tragedy of his character.
Kara Swisher
I don't see much tragedy there. Scott, what do you think?
Scott Galloway
Well, you brought up an interesting point about secondary sales, that he's a billionaire. And I don't know how much of that was proceeds from the IPO. Did you do any analysis on secondary sales pre-IPO? In other words, who got out early? Adam Neumann's coming under a lot of scrutiny for selling $700 million before the IPO.
Mike Isaac
So it's funny. In the tender offer when SoftBank was buying in, everyone who was on the cap table from early investments from Google and Benchmark on down sold at least some of their shares and made a ton of money. And that's a different valuation than where we are today. Since they've gone public, the stock has taken a beating and it's just been brutal. But I would say everyone on the cap table from series probably C or D or something is doing okay. And even SoftBank I think now is underwater with their initial investment too. So if you got in early, you're probably feeling all right, especially if you sold into that tender offer. But everyone that came in late – it's kind of the story of the valley too, right? The later you came in.
Kara Swisher
Sucker.
Mike Isaac
Yeah.
Kara Swisher
We don't have the sucker in the room. Last money in.
Mike Isaac
Yeah, exactly.
Kara Swisher
So we have to – you're going to stay on for the whole show. But when you think about this book, if you were writing the next chapter of this, like what Scott would say, would it be like my second AOL book was about the decline? The first one was on the way up. They managed to figure everything out. And the second part was the disaster that was. What do you imagine is going to happen? They've got this decent CEO in there who's just, you know, I always think of Dara Khosrowshahi like he must be opening a drawer and there's a dead body every time he turns for the first year. Like, "Oh, this dead body." But what can he do? He's obviously not as charismatic as Travis. He's not – he's a relatively honest person about the disaster. He's been that way. What's the verdict on Uber? What do you think the future of ride-sharing holds? Or is it just a big subsidized event that investors give to consumers that will eventually not be sustainable?
Mike Isaac
I think that the very difficult part of what's happening with Uber is the same thing for WeWork, which is that these businesses came up in a time where people had a better appetite for risk and losing money and being willing to sort of see this vision in which we hit a platform or we hit a point where this tips and it actually becomes a real business because it's going to be ubiquitous. But I think we're in a different time now where profitability is actually important to the street and to normal investors. And when it doesn't look like you can actually make a profit, it seems like not a super viable thing. So I think he has the unfortunate timing of coming into that. That's the climate in which we evaluate companies right now. And I don't think that was always the case five or ten years ago. So I don't think it's going to be positive. I think he's still going to sort of sell this story and be like, "Look, this is the drumbeat. Give us another year or two years and we can get there and we'll belt tighten." But it's going to be – I think it just seems like a very difficult time to do that.
Kara Swisher
All right. We're going to take a quick break now. We're going to stay here and talk about our other things, our other news stories. But when we get to predictions, you need to make a prediction of who's going to buy Uber because they are really the reservation system, right? So you have that part of it, the brand part of it, the network. And so you have to think about who's going to buy because that's where I think it's going. But you may not think that or disagree with me, but we're going to take a quick break now and when we get back, we're going to talk wins, fails, predictions, and listen to some listener mail.
Ad Break
Welcome back to Pivot. Okay, let's get in some wins and fails, shall we? Mr. Galloway, what are your wins and fails?
Scott Galloway
So my win is Walmart. I thought that they threaded the needle really well around some of the concerns or the very important topic around gun sales. And I think people, I think they addressed it thoughtfully after the shooting at their store in El Paso. If you look at what they've done: A, they decided to stop carrying ammunition or once the current inventories are sold out of ammunition that typically is purchased for assault weapons. And so they're going to take their share of ammunition sales in the U.S. down from 20% to somewhere between six and nine. They're going to stop selling handguns in Alaska, which was the last state that they sold them in.
They previously had raised the age for purchase of guns from 18 to 21. They do background checks and they've offered to give that technology to – or lend that technology, that background check technology, to other retailers. So I would argue that Walmart is actually where the majority of America is around guns. If you go into the Twittersphere, you hear the folks who want an outright ban of most or all guns. And then the other side is unfettered open carry everywhere. And also Walmart has said, when I thought this was hilarious, I'd have to actually articulate this, that we prefer you not have open carry in our stores.
And the funniest part or saddest part of the press release said that if someone is engaging in open carry, which means you have a visible weapon walking into a public place, a Walmart, an employee will in a non-confrontational manner address you and ask you to put your gun away, which I think is just good common sense to not be confrontational with someone who's carrying around a gun visibly.
Kara Swisher
They have to get old ladies to do it, right? Oh, my gosh. Don't you think? Like those old ladies who are at Walmart.
Scott Galloway
But if you think about it, there's a larger issue here. These corporate leaders – if Walmart is the largest private employer in the world, the largest retailer in the world, more people go into a Walmart than any federal agency every week – then effectively Walmart in many ways has more impact on U.S. citizenship than the government. And I would argue that Doug McMillon is kind of the president we want right now. He's making hard decisions and he's going where most of America is. So I think that Walmart handled this really well.
Kara Swisher
What's your take on this, Kara?
Well, I think there – we'll see about if there's a fake backlash of like angry people, but I do think you're right. I think he's exactly where his – I don't think he would do this if he didn't have some sense that his customers were okay with this, right, of course. But at the same time, I do think he's – I've interviewed him. I like him a great deal. I find him to be a very thoughtful, interesting leader. And I think you can't have an incident like this happen and not have something to say about your customers and keeping them safe. So I think it's a win. I think it's – and we talked about this, that they had to do something. There are a few digital people on that board. Marissa Mayer is still on that board, I think. Enrique. And then the woman from, who's the CEO at Nextdoor, Sarah Fryer. There's a lot of – it's interesting. I think it's an interesting way to deal with it. I think it's a smart way to move forward. We'll see if he gets a lot of pushback politically from the NRA and everywhere else. But it's certainly a step in the right direction for sure. Mike, what's your win?
Mike Isaac
This is going to sound funny. I think a win is probably going to be Facebook Dating.
Kara Swisher
What? Yeah.
Scott Galloway
Oh, my God.
Kara Swisher
Callaway, we got to – I meant it. Say more. Say more.
Mike Isaac
Oh, my God. No, look. I mean, if you own the largest network in the entire world and all these existing connections between people, I feel like slapping that on and sort of knifing IAC and Match Group is probably –
Kara Swisher
Yeah, right.
Mike Isaac
With Tinder and all the dating properties they have is probably like a real – at least they have to show a different model, different revenue streams like this.
Kara Swisher
When is this rolling out, Michael?
Mike Isaac
It just happened this morning. In the U.S. And it's connected to Instagram as well. And like, look, I think the kids, so I'm told, find each other through Instagram and Twitter.
Scott Galloway
They do not.
Mike Isaac
Do they not?
Scott Galloway
No, I have kids. You have children. Okay, this is old me. I think it's just inane that it's so deeply uncool to bet on Facebook. I don't know.
Mike Isaac
I think the fact that it's tucked into Instagram as the network actually makes it a little bit more – maybe if Facebook is the Match.com or the eHarmony for folks who are 40 and up, and Instagram is the one that's the Tinder-ish age, then maybe that's a better corollary. But I think it might actually be a smart way of monetizing data.
Scott Galloway
Mike just went gangster. You know what? That's actually a great one. I'm embarrassed we didn't bring it up. Facebook and Instagram are going after your buddy Diller or IAC. It's basically an online dating company. And when you think about Instagram and Facebook, they could be huge in this. This is a big category. One out of five marriages start online. It's still something people are willing to pay for. They're able to segment the marketplace with different niches. This could be – I think Mike's on to something.
Kara Swisher
Their phone was so great. Their phone was so good. Everything they do that's not necessarily related to what they basically do, just steal your information, they suck at. So actually this is a lot of information, so maybe they'll be good at it. But the idea of putting more information on Facebook about your sex life is like no thank you. I mean maybe you're right. Maybe it's like maybe the time right now people are just like, "Oh, now you're going to get into my – this is who I sleep with or whatever." That's not what I want to share.
Mike Isaac
I mean that's fair. You kind of do say that it's complicated, all that stupid stuff. I don't know. I think Instagram is really the killer part of this. I think that's how the youngs find each other.
Kara Swisher
What do we think Kevin Systrom would think of this? That's, you know, I mean, it's Mark's company now, right?
Scott Galloway
Yeah.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, that's true. He's Instagram by Facebook. Oh, God. What do you think of that, Mike?
Mike Isaac
We didn't like that. I don't like it. I think you're ruining your brand for the sake of, what, putting your Facebook stamp on it? Just don't do it. He's trying to keep away.
Kara Swisher
All right. Fails, boys. I'm not going to do any this week because I'm giving Mike my win and fail slot. What's your fail, Scott Galloway?
Scott Galloway
My fail is, again, WeWork. They cut their valuation in half in order to try and say to the public markets, "No, check us out. We're now only going to cost you $20 to $25 billion in the public markets for our IPO," which I call "fleecing feces at the Tourist of the Unicorn Zoo." I don't think this – anyways, it's just ridiculous. And by the way, I'd like to think we played a role in this, we're the $6 million woman and man. Adam Neumann announced he's giving the money back that he charged the company for the trademark to the term "we," which he had adopted for his own personal asset management firm. So it's nice to see that. And also just along, I'm pinging around here, but Tristan Harris has clearly had an impact on legislation with what Josh Hawley has proposed for Missouri. But my loss or lose again is this ridiculous foisting on the public markets, this crap or this shit called the WeWork business model and the recognition today that they're in no way going to get the valuation they initially floated. And I'll even bridge to a prediction here, and then Mike, I want to hear your loss and your prediction. I don't think WeWork gets public.
Kara Swisher
Mike, what do you think?
Mike Isaac
Oh. I think you're right. No, I honestly – I was talking about this with someone yesterday. Even this morning, I think I saw something that said they're considering delaying it. But it's so brutal. I haven't even read most of the S1, but I just keep hearing how absurd the whole thing is.
Kara Swisher
Scott Galloway is personally going to stop this IPO. He's going to get in the way. He's going to be like Gerard Butler in – what was Fallen? Angel Has Fallen. There you go. Gerard Butler. You're Gerard Butler, Scott.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, I get compared to him a lot except never. But thank you for that. Never. Thank you for that. It's like me and The Rock.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. Anyway, you're going to stop this IPO if it's the last thing you do. Is that correct, Scott Galloway?
Scott Galloway
Well, at some point, we got to recognize that our economy has just turned into a basic giant inequality machine where the VCs and the founders figure out a way to foist all this crap on the public markets once they've taken their money out and created all the value for themselves. And that the suckers are the actual endowments and institutions and unions and pension funds that have been hyped up on the stock who, because so many people have made so much money on Facebook and Google stock, think the same thing is going to happen. And so the venture industrial complex has decided to capture all those gains as long as they can foist this shit. And let's be clear, it is shit on the marketplace. Case in point, the company that Mike wrote that book about. I mean, Uber. I'm curious. Mike, yes or no? I think Uber is literally going to lose 80% of its value in the next 24 months. Your turn.
Kara Swisher
Oof. Oof. Your turn. Oh, my God. Mike, comment?
Mike Isaac
I don't know if I would say 80 percent. I do think that they're in for a hard time. Dara has sort of come in and is supposed to have this reputation of being the guy who's going to whip it into shape. I think culturally he has. He brought a lot of the internal dynamics around, and that's a good thing for them. But I think financially it's just a brutal business to be in, and it's going to be a brutal business for the near future.
So it's hard for me to say that the bears are going to just suddenly change their minds in the next year or so.
Kara Swisher
The thing is people do like it.
Scott Galloway
They're being subsidized.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. It's a product people like. It may not be an economic product. All right. So your fail, Mike? I hope you guys didn't talk about this last week before, but the Twitter Jack account getting hacked.
Mike Isaac
We did a little bit, but go right ahead since you covered that.
Kara Swisher
Please.
Mike Isaac
Please.
Kara Swisher
Please. Lay it down for us.
Mike Isaac
The reason it— I found it so funny and sort of ironic is because they used a method from a company that they acquired to grow in low latency regions throughout the world. So if you just do texting, SMS texting is your tweet to do on Twitter.
Kara Swisher
Right, totally.
Mike Isaac
And that's— so imagine if you're going to push your product into developing regions and they don't have high-speed connectivity or whatever, that was an indispensable tool for their growth in a lot of ways. And then it ended up becoming the thing that took their CEO out. And now they just— I think yesterday they said that they have to actually disable the option because it's too dangerous for anyone.
Kara Swisher
Right, like the president's account could get hacked, right?
Mike Isaac
Yeah, totally. Because he uses his phone. Although, honestly, what would be the difference?
Kara Swisher
Alabama! It was under siege. You really wouldn't know if it was different. It would be like, oh, this is way too logical. At this point, yeah. Sharpie gate. I can't believe either of you didn't talk to Sharpie. I want to talk to the Sharpie people. I can't believe they made him special Sharpies. That's what I want to understand.
Scott Galloway
They did. He talked about it. He didn't like the color, so they made them all black with his signature on it.
Kara Swisher
Sharpie, you have a lot to answer for in terms of your Sharpie situation. All right, those are very good. So what do you think is going to happen there at Twitter? I'm really worried about them. They just seem like they're stuck in the same place they were three years ago.
Jack had this sort of— you get a lot of credit when you're a founder coming back to a company. You just get cred of like, "I'm the founder." I think originally when he came back, he was supposed to be this mythical guy who can fix Twitter, and they haven't really done a lot.
Mike Isaac
No.
Kara Swisher
You know? I wonder if that's just his method or if that's just the product and what it is.
Mike Isaac
Did you go to their healthy conversation meeting?
Kara Swisher
I did not. Was that you?
Mike Isaac
Yeah, neither of us. They didn't invite us.
Kara Swisher
Did you see that? They had a meeting where you could go watch them debate healthy conversations. I think someone bid at the New York Times, and I was like, really? We weren't invited. Mike and Kara weren't invited to this.
Mike Isaac
They're very cerebral in how they think through policy, but it just doesn't seem to translate into action, which worries me.
Kara Swisher
Good point. All right. Those are very good wins and fails. Obviously the Brexit thing— we'll talk about that next week, Scott, because it looks like Downton Abbey with bad haircuts. Anyway, let's dig into some listener mail before we get to predictions.
Listener question plays
Scott, our listeners are smarter than us. Do you understand that? Are you getting that sense?
Scott Galloway
You mean they're smart.
Kara Swisher
Okay, you take this one. These rental companies. I've talked about this. I think it's a really big trend. A lot of millennials I know are renting everything, not just special occasion dresses and wedding stuff. I think it's a big trend, and we're about to interview a lot of different people at Code Commerce about this. It's one of the topics. What do you think of these fashion rental companies? I think people are willing to do this.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, I think this is a fascinating space, and it's arguably going to be one of the most disruptive forces in retail. If you think about department stores, they've just gotten the crap kicked out of them. They're in the eighth inning of their life, whether it's Macy's, Nordstrom, Kohl's. They're all off somewhere between 20% and 70% if you loop in JCPenney.
The bottom line is no millennial will take an escalator to shop. You can do a strategic strike into a Sephora and get your La Roche-Posay in three to seven minutes. Anytime you step into a Sears— well, actually, there are no more Sears. But every time you step into a JCPenney or Nordstrom, you're there for 30 minutes. It's just not how America wants to shop any longer.
Then you combine that with sustainability. You combine that with young people not minding wearing other people's clothes. You combine that with the fact that a 30-year-old for the first time isn't making as much money as his or her parents were at 30, meaning they need to buy more with less. Projections are that rental or resale is going to be a bigger business than fast fashion.
All you need to think about is the type of wealth that was created for fast fashion families in Europe— the second and third wealthiest families in Europe. And you think about the kind of wealth that's going to be created in resale, and you're looking at massive disruption. Now, what people are missing around this is it's too late. Department stores have already been disrupted. They're already dead. Maybe they don't know yet, but they're pretty much already dead.
Who it's really going to disrupt is specialty retail. If you have a huge explosion in the amount of clothes getting useful new life or being recycled, it's going to put huge pressure on the initial or first-time sales organizations. The majority of specialty retail apparel is from specialty retail, and the number of leases held by the lease space or the square footage space in malls from specialty retailers and apparel is collapsing as evidence of that.
Great question, but disruption is on its way at the hands of resale. The big losers are going to be specialty retail. They're about to get their turn at the woodshed.
Kara Swisher
I agree with you. I think young people are very willing, the way they're willing to do Uber and cars and hotels and Airbnbs, and they're able to rent almost anything. Actually, my column in The New York Times this week is, again, about my car, the fact that I don't own a car. It's an update.
Scott Galloway
Did you get rid of your car?
Kara Swisher
Yeah, I got rid of my car. I'm doing an update. So I think people are willing to think about renting everything, in terms of stuff that they don't need beyond just a dress for a wedding or a prom or a tuxedo or anything else. But the people are very willing. And obviously, Eric from Red Hook, not underwear. I think that is always going to be—
Scott Galloway
I don't know. There's probably a niche dating site.
Kara Swisher
No, no. All right, Mike. Now, you've spent too much time with Scott Galloway that you're making dirty underwear. Let's roll, my brother.
Mike Isaac
You can't come, Turk. Let's roll.
Kara Swisher
No, no. I can't have two of you listen to me. I don't want to get canceled. I don't want to get canceled.
Scott Galloway
You're getting canceled right now.
Kara Swisher
All right. Last section, predictions. Predictions, boys. I'm not going to make a prediction this week. Again, I'm giving it over to Mike. Your prediction, we already made, Mr. Galloway, Professor Galloway, which was—
Scott Galloway
I think the firewall is going to— that we were not going to get it. I think the immunities are kicking in. I think the markets are prone to fits of sanity and rationality, and rational thinking is starting to seep in. I don't think WeWork is going to get public. I think it's the markets finally saying enough. So my prediction is WeWork, despite cutting their valuation in half today, doesn't get out.
And I have a question before Mike gets to his prediction. Mike, do you take Uber?
Mike Isaac
Oh. I will, and Juno if I'm in New York, sort of equitably. But I would say, yeah, I try to stick to Muni and Bart in the subway when I can.
Kara Swisher
Interesting. Interesting. All right, prediction?
Mike Isaac
So this is going to be kind of nerdy, but I think Dropbox is going to have a very big product revamp. The straw that broke the camel's back was Chrissy Teigen tweeting how much she hated Dropbox's new products because it was bloated and gnarly. If you use Dropbox, it's definitely gotten a lot more difficult to use as just a product that's very feature heavy.
I never understood it in the first place. These cloud services are supposed to be very simple from the outset. Once you lard it up with a bunch of new features and stuff, it gets gnarly. Your core, normal, simple user gets angry, and then you have Chrissy Teigen tweeting angry things about your company online. So they're freaking out. They're having a four-alarm fire over there, and I think they're going to have a big revamp in the next few weeks.
Kara Swisher
Sort of like Snapchat. Remember Snapchat redid its thing?
Mike Isaac
Yeah, when everyone freaked out about the redesign or whatever. I think that just— yeah, I don't know if it was a Jenner or someone that complained, but once you get that—
Kara Swisher
Louis Swisher complained, and I forwarded it to Evan Spiegel. And that's it. I was like, Louis Swisher's pissed at us.
Scott Galloway
He loves you.
Kara Swisher
When you get those level of complaints, I think that actually drives the companies into that "oh shit" moment. Good one. Scott, see how creative Mike Isaac is? That was a good one. That's an awesome one.
Scott Galloway
I'm starting to feel a little bit threatened. Starting to feel a little bit threatened.
Mike Isaac
Do you know, Mike, every generation— I have backups to backups for you, my friend.
Scott Galloway
That's right. I have backups to backups.
Mike Isaac
That's right. Scaramucci's on the list.
Scott Galloway
Uh-oh. Isaac is on the list. There's a lot. But every generation has kind of a seminal moment, whether it was JFK or the Vietnam War or Reagan saying, "Mr. Gorbachev, tear down this wall." As a kind of a tell for this generation, the seminal moments are Chrissy Teigen saying she doesn't like Dropbox and also Jeremy Renner closing down his app, the Escape X.
Kara Swisher
Oh, my God. That is my favorite story. Isn't that the best? Where like-minded fans could come talk about Jeremy and buy stars. And it was weaponized. The platform was weaponized and decided the best thing for the polity and for society was for him to shut it down.
Scott Galloway
And I thought this is perfect if it had been signed by Mark Zuckerberg.
Kara Swisher
It's really good. All right. We're going to finish up. Mike, what do you think of his prediction? He was talking about Uber, the same thing, that it's going to be enough. Is that going to be enough for Uber? Make a prediction.
Mike Isaac
I don't know. I'm having a really hard time thinking that they're going to come out of this soon. I don't think that they're going to get any leeway in the near term. I think it's just going to be a lot of pain over the next few years, over the next two years at least.
Kara Swisher
Excellent. It's so nice having you here, Mike Isaac. Thank you. It's so nice to have you back. Listen to me. What's the name of the book?
Mike Isaac
The book is *Super Pumped: The Battle for Uber*, in stores right now.
Kara Swisher
In stores right now. And also it was excerpted in the New York Times.
Mike Isaac
That's right.
Kara Swisher
And as Scott said, your PR people are doing a great job. It's a great read. It's a really— if you like *Bad Blood* or that was John Carreyrou's book, it's that kind of book. And it's great. Actually, having written a lot about Uber and we also broke a lot of stories, I found out stuff I did not know, which is great.
Scott Galloway
And, yes, the student has surpassed the—
Kara Swisher
No, you haven't. You're being kind. But good try.
Scott Galloway
He's an amazing reporter and he covers Facebook and stuff like that.
Kara Swisher
And maybe we'll have you on to talk about when you write your Facebook book. Yeah. Anyway, Scott, we're going to be together in New York. Remember?
Scott Galloway
Yes, I'm excited about it.
Kara Swisher
I'm sending you some literature. Scott, don't get canceled. I'm sending you some literature. And so we're going to be live in person. You're going to be on your best behavior.
Scott Galloway
The lesbians.
Kara Swisher
Yes.
Scott Galloway
Oh, no.
Kara Swisher
I'm ready. Let me explain to you. There are very few people that you don't want to cross— this militia etherage. I'm just telling you. Speaking of Carrie, they carry a lot of things you don't want to get hit with.
Anyway, we're going to be talking at the annual Lesbians Who Tech Summit in New York. There's one in New York. There's one in San Francisco. We're going to do the New York one. And he's going to be on his best behavior. These are really talented, diverse women and non-binary women in the field of technology. It's going to be an honor to be there.
Scott Galloway
It sure will. Hey, Mike, congratulations and well done. I think the book sounds like it's off to a great start. Both Kara and I know how difficult and what a labor of love these things are. So well done and congratulations on the book.
Kara Swisher
Well done, Mike Isaac. You're the best. He's also a sweetheart. Anyway, today's show was produced by Rebecca Sinanis and Eric Johnson. Eric Anderson is Pivot's executive producer. Thanks also to Rebecca Castro, Drew Burrows, and Nishat Kerwa. Thanks again to Mike Isaac for joining us.
Hey. How do they find you, Mike?
Mike Isaac
You can go to Twitter and find me at @MikeIsaac.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, he's kind of crazy on Twitter.
Mike Isaac
Yeah, I wouldn't recommend it.
Kara Swisher
You should definitely follow him. Anyway, make sure you subscribe to the show on Apple Podcasts. If you like this week's episode, leave us a review. Thanks for listening to Pivot from Vox Media. We'll be back next week for another breakdown of all things tech and business.