Main Topic: This episode of Pivot, a podcast from the Vox Media Podcast Network, covers various topics in tech and business, including the future of tech companies, antitrust probes, and the impact of social media on society.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Support for this show comes from Robinhood. Wouldn't it be great to manage your portfolio on one platform? With Robinhood, not only can you trade individual stocks and ETFs, you can also seamlessly buy and sell crypto at low costs. Trade all in one place. Get started now on Robinhood. Trading crypto involves significant risk. Crypto trading is offered through an account with Robinhood Crypto LLC. Robinhood Crypto is licensed to engage in virtual currency business activity by the New York State Department of Financial Services. Crypto held through Robinhood Crypto is not FDIC-insured or SIPC-protected. Investing involves risk, including loss of principal. Securities trading is offered through an account with Robinhood Financial LLC, member SIPC, a registered broker-dealer.
Kara Swisher
A lot of people do not like the new version of ChatGPT. They hate it so much that OpenAI brought back the old version to please them. This week on The Vergecast, we give our take, now that we've had a week to try GPT-5 in the wild. And we tried vibe coding, and it did not go very well. Plus, Gen 2E talked to a man whose smart home products stopped working. So he did what anybody would do: bought the company that made them. That's this week on The Vergecast.
Hi, this is Pivot from the Vox Media Podcast Network. I'm Kara Swisher.
Scott Galloway
And I'm Scott Galloway.
Kara Swisher
This week, we did Pivot Live in New York City at the Lesbians Who Tech Summit. We came on right after Roxane Gay, so I had to behave myself or risk an all-out war on Twitter.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, which you would lose, Scott.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, no kidding.
Scott Galloway
We're live in New York to talk at the Lesbians in Tech and Allies Summit. Everybody say hello. So, how do you like being here? Do you like being here? And we're going to talk about all the different tech issues of the day?
Kara Swisher
Yes and yes, Kara.
Scott Galloway
All right, okay.
Kara Swisher
All right, so one of the things that we did talk about is how you can be a better ally.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, say more. Say more.
Kara Swisher
And so what I did is what naturally, what I think is really important for you to wear is I brought you a T-shirt. It says Lesbro.
Scott Galloway
Lesbro. Who wants to see a 54-year-old man change his shirt?
Kara Swisher
Oh, my God. Scott, no one's interested in you here.
Scott Galloway
Well, most places, actually.
Kara Swisher
Fantastic. Thank you, Scott. Okay. All right, so we have a lot to talk about this week. We're going to use Pivot. We use Pivot as a different platform, but it's really important that we use it to talk about the issues in tech that affect all communities and try to push for more diversity. So we're very excited to be here.
So speaking of interesting things, I interviewed Marianne Williamson this week, and tomorrow I'm going to interview Bill de Blasio. So I'm going on the people who didn't get into the debate tour, essentially. It was a really interesting interview with Marianne Williamson.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, and I'm actually hosting Michael Bennett, another guy I did make. It's interesting to think about unexpected consequences. The Democratic National Committee wanted to ensure that it was more inclusive. They were accused of basically railroading Hillary through, so they tried to be more inclusive and came up with all these rules. They're sort of damned if they do, damned if they don't. But the notion that you have to get a certain number of donors, what's ended up happening is that people are paying $70 to Facebook and Google to get a $1 donation.
Kara Swisher
Right. And it's also, I feel as if we have some people on stage. The big winners through all of this are the off-card people, the Andrew Yangs, the folks you're talking about, who've gotten incredible awareness. And they're going to have to flip it back because you're going to literally see 100 people run for president in the next cycle.
Scott Galloway
Next cycle.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. So is that a good thing or a bad thing?
Scott Galloway
Yes. I think your point is that it shouldn't just be people who've been politicians their whole life, but I think the DNC has an obligation to probably screen out earlier some people who shouldn't be on the stage. I think it's taken a lot of oxygen away from people who have an important message.
Kara Swisher
Who should?
Scott Galloway
I mean, that was an interesting discussion I had with Marianne Williamson. She feels she's more in tune with Americans than she was saying. She's in 2019 politics and most of the candidates are in 1985 politics, which was kind of interesting. And when you actually meet her in person, it is kind of interesting that the media has to portray her. David Brooks wrote a column where he called her a wackadoo, and then agreed with everything she said, which was fascinating. It's really interesting how she's portrayed because there's some controversy around what she said about vaccinations, which she had a relatively good explanation for, but a lot of people still don't believe her.
She didn't say she was praying away the hurricane. She was talking about prayer in general, which I think a man would be allowed to do very easily. So it was a really interesting interview. And I was surprised. One of the things she said, I think you'd like her too. I think a lot of people would like her in person. She thinks that if we don't make a change, that young people are going to storm the Bastille. And so that was the most interesting thing she was talking about. She was talking about how the populism in this country and the hate that's growing is problematic for politics.
I think there's a huge divisiveness. But typically throughout history, when we get to this level of income inequality, it self-corrects. And it self-corrects via war, famine, revolution. And I think we're going through a soft revolution where people have just had it. Just had it with wealthy people, most of whom are tech people. The top 1% have doubled their income, while the income of the bottom 50% has been halved. 13 people are worth the same wealth as the southern hemisphere plus India. And it's pretty basic logic. At some point, when 3.5 billion people go, the easiest way to double our wealth is to take away the wealth of these 13 people.
They figure out a way to do that. It's kind of happened over and over in Central America and different economies. If you don't have some level of empathy or redistribution and all the wealth and all the spoils and all the good stuff aggregates to fewer and fewer people, at some point everybody else says, all right, we've had it. When you see all these very wealthy people talking about we need higher taxes, it's not that they're being progressive. It's self-preservation. They recognize at some point people are just going to show up with pitchforks and lanterns.
Kara Swisher
This week at Code Commerce, you were specifically talking about Amazon, didn't pay any taxes or paid very low taxes given how much money they make.
Scott Galloway
Since 2008, or approximately over the last 10 years, Walmart has paid $64 billion in corporate income tax. Amazon has paid $1.4 billion. Our economy is just not used to a company being this successful and never paying taxes because it's not profitable. Typically the markets demand a company becomes profitable at some point. Our taxation system is based off of profits. In addition, you have this genius, and Bezos is a genius, who's figured out a way to perfectly game the system, where he never pays taxes. Remember, and we talked about this at Code, in the 1980s, there was basically this racist whistle call where Reagan had this caricature of what he called a welfare queen.
The mother of all welfare queens in our society is Jeff Bezos. Because he owns approximately 17 or 20% of Amazon. Amazon extracts billions of dollars in tax subsidies by gamifying the process to put their data center here. He makes it irresistible for a municipal official who wants to be the one to detonate a prosperity bomb in their city not to fork over tons of benefits and tax subsidies. So say $2 to $3 billion gets transferred from the city of Phoenix or Denver to Amazon to put their new data center there. That's technically a transfer from all of us who are taxpayers to Jeff Bezos of approximately a half a billion dollars.
In addition, he himself never pays taxes because anyone who's worth that kind of money just borrows against his holdings at a low interest rate of 2%. But he's worth $164 billion. He's the richest man in the world. And he is a net debtor or taker. So the National Park Service, the Central Intelligence Agency, the Navy, and Jeff Bezos are taking money out of the Treasury, not putting it in. Hands down, mother of all welfare queens for the ages, the wealthiest man in the world.
Kara Swisher
Alexis is a good thing. So we're going to move into actual news this week, because we do news, we do predictions, and everything else, and we have questions from you guys. I'm going to put on AR glasses, which are from Focal. They're at Lisa Zane's in the audience. And what's augmented right now? What's happening? There is a screen right here that I'm looking at and getting some information about you, Scott.
Scott Galloway
Yeah.
Kara Swisher
And it comes with this, it's really interesting. I'm kind of fascinated where AR is going and where these glasses are going. As you know, Google Glass, while it was not a hit, I think technically it was the right thing. It was the idea that we're going to have glasses on our face. I think these are pretty attractive. And what you do is you wear this ring. It kind of looks, no? No, not yet? That's not a wearable, it's a prophylactic.
Scott Galloway
All right, no, not quite yet. Oh, that's nice.
Kara Swisher
But let me, listen to me. I like these better. I think eventually these are going to get amazing. What happens is you use this as a joystick, and I can see time.
Scott Galloway
I see. Right now, yeah.
Kara Swisher
You want to touch my joystick?
Scott Galloway
All right, okay.
Kara Swisher
And so what happens? I get all kinds of information right now. I'm looking at Spotify, whether I want to turn it on and play it. I've got messages. I can see it in this little eye thing here. And then you can just, oh, it's on. I don't know if it's on, but anyway. So it goes to time, messages, all kinds of stuff that your calendar, just pretty much all I think. And I can call an Uber on it, which is interesting. And I'll actually send out texts, which is in my calendar and things like that. So it's coming. Eventually, this will have a lot of information on it.
Scott Galloway
There are technologies you want to overinvest in. There are technologies you want to underinvest in. This is absolutely when you want to underinvest in.
Kara Swisher
I think you're wrong. I think you're utterly wrong. You know who's in this? Intel and Amazon.
Scott Galloway
Well, and Mark Zuckerberg said it was going to unlock new worlds. No, it hasn't. It hasn't done anything.
Kara Swisher
Yes, but because it's early. You're wrong. You're 100% wrong. Everyone's going to have something on their face that is going to...
Scott Galloway
Yeah, Ray-Bans.
Kara Swisher
Okay. In any case, everyone's going to have these. And as you move through them, I agree, Google Glass was the first iteration of it. But eventually, this is how we're going to get our information. We're not going to be looking down at phones and staring and wandering around the streets. I think you're going to have a heads-up display and you're going to look at it. And this one is getting there. This is absolutely getting there. It's really interesting that Amazon and Intel would put this amount of money in. I think a lot of people do believe in it. Supposedly Apple's coming out with their own pair, right?
Scott Galloway
I'm sorry?
Kara Swisher
Supposedly Apple's coming out with their own pair.
Scott Galloway
Yes, Apple's coming out with their own pair, which will probably be super attractive.
Kara Swisher
So eventually this will get really interesting. It'll not be as heavy on the side. But this is a quantum leap from Google Glass.
Scott Galloway
Is it?
Kara Swisher
Yes, 100%.
Scott Galloway
And what's the name of the company?
Kara Swisher
This is Focal. They're from Canada, so they're very nice. So I'm really, I'm really, you know, I don't, if they make Ray-Bans, I may wear them, which will be great. But I think it's really interesting that this is kind of the new kind of investments that are being made in these kind of things, in food and agriculture and stuff like that. But let's get to the news of the day. Big story breakdown. Speaking of large, state AGs go after Google and Facebook, 50 state AGs. So basically all of them, including D.C. and Puerto Rico, are joining an antitrust probe of Google spearheaded by Texas state AG. California and Alabama are out. Go figure. They'll probably do it on their own. Last week, Letitia James announced that she would lead a similar probe into Facebook. Antitrust probes might be the thing that brings Republicans and Democrats together in this country, which is amazing because they can't agree on lunch. And it was sort of spearheaded by Elizabeth Warren. She was talking about it earlier. What do you think about what's happened this week?
Scott Galloway
I'm really, finally the thing has dropped. I'm really hopeful that there's finally a bipartisan issue. People are going after tech for different reasons, the red states and the blue states. I think it's really exciting. And the fact that they're coming together, it's well overdue. It'll take a while, but it's similar to tobacco where they said, look, we're sick of waiting on DC. We're going to do it ourselves. So it looks like the states are coming for Google. And we said this earlier.
Kara Swisher
Do you think something will actually happen? What would you predict would happen? How long will it take and how long can they agree to it?
Scott Galloway
It'll be years, no doubt about it. But at some point there'll be a grand bargain, either for an enormous fine or prophylactically Google will break itself up and come to some sort of deal.
Kara Swisher
So what do you think they're going to do? Break off YouTube, presumably? You talked about this. You predicted this. You think it's going to be a spin of YouTube. What's interesting is they're going after the ad part, the kind of the double click part. But something, the breakup has started. And what the markets get wrong is that the stock is going to skyrocket once people start doing that.
Scott Galloway
Why is that? Well, we make the mistake of believing that antitrust is bad for companies when they get broken up, that it's some sort of punishment. And what I believe we have to do is not look at it through the rubric of they're bad, so we're punishing them. But a natural part of our economic cycle is that when a company becomes an invasive species and kills small companies and prematurely euthanizes big companies, that it's healthy for the economy to go in and break them up. And when we broke up AT&T, within 10 years, each one of those nine companies was worth more than the original company. It was broken up into nine pieces. When eBay spun PayPal, PayPal's now worth five or ten times what eBay is. So you're going to see a massive unlock in shareholder value. So it's not punishment. So breaking up Google, pulling off YouTube or the ads off of Google, or taking Instagram off of Facebook, which it seems to be integrating even further with Facebook dating.
Kara Swisher
Which are you using Facebook dating?
Scott Galloway
Just curious.
Kara Swisher
Not yet. Okay. Not yet. Ever? Would you ever use... If you were married, would you use Facebook dating?
Scott Galloway
I'd use all of them.
Kara Swisher
Okay.
Scott Galloway
And I would just be, you know...
Kara Swisher
At work, for some reason, they call me Swipe Left. That's my nickname.
Scott Galloway
What?
Kara Swisher
Yeah, I would use all of them. But you feel good about Facebook. But they're using Instagram as the...
Scott Galloway
I think Instagram's the right brand for it. I don't think Facebook is. I don't think people trust Facebook. But I think Instagram's a great brand for dating. I think it could be huge for them.
Kara Swisher
But now it's called Instagram by Facebook. So this is interesting too, right? And this kind of signals the end of the brand era. And that is Facebook has decided to say, all right, Instagram by Facebook or WhatsApp by Facebook. And every marketing professor in the world had a grand mal seizure when they heard this.
Scott Galloway
But what this really indicates, and I thought about it, is the end of the brand era. The way we've traditionally created shareholder value is to come up with a marginal product and wrap great associations around it. An American car that's kind of a mediocre, shitty product, but make it feel tough and American and like a rock, right? And then print money with your marginal product, but great associations and great margins. And I think we've officially left the brand era for the monopoly era. And what Mark Zuckerberg has decided, I mean, this is equivalent of Volkswagen going, I know, let's call it Porsche by Volkswagen.
Or Boeing going, okay, the 787. Let's call it the 787 Max. Right. This just makes no sense. But what they've decided is they want to conjoin the triplets. And if they can in any way reduce the likelihood that they're broken up, which is a half a trillion dollar franchise or monopoly, that that is worth the erosion of tens of billions of brand value and brand equity. So they're trying to stick together in order to avoid being broken up. They're trying to put the three together such that he can say when the DOJ or the states come in, that he can say, look, if you try and separate the babies from one another, you're going to kill the whole being.
He's purposely trying to encrypt everything in context.
Kara Swisher
That sounds sneaky on Mark Zuckerberg's part.
Scott Galloway
Yeah.
Kara Swisher
What do you think? I hope it's not going to work. If I were the DOJ or the FTC, I would move in right now and I would say, look, whatever you do right now, just be clear. If we find...
Scott Galloway
They have said that. Makan Delrahim has said that. We'll break your ass up. The head of the Justice Department, Antitrust.
Kara Swisher
So you predict a breakup. You think that's what's going to happen eventually?
Scott Galloway
I think a combination of antitrust and regulation. I think all of them at some point either themselves proactively break themselves up. So prediction. I love predictions. By 2025 the most valuable company in the world will be AWS. Amazon Web Services. Amazon will spill into AWS and AWS will be the most valuable company in the world because right now there's no pure play way to play the cloud. The cloud is the fastest growing, most profitable part of technology right now globally. How do you invest as a retail investor, an institution, or endowment in the cloud? If you invest, you've got to crawl over a search engine to get to Google Cloud. Or Microsoft or Google. You've got to crawl over a software company at Microsoft, and you've got to crawl over an e-commerce company and a bunch of other things, and the marvelous Mrs. Maisel to get to the cloud of AWS. If the fastest growing pure play company and the fastest growing sector and the most profitable sector was a stock, we'd all own it or all of our pension funds, all of our unions.
Kara Swisher
Interestingly, I've actually spoken to the CEO of AWS and he said he's not going to go public several times. But we've had this conversation. No one can say, you know what? I'd like to be king because they end up dead the next day.
Scott Galloway
Right.
Kara Swisher
No one can say that. All right. No one can say, yeah.
Scott Galloway
So, but be clear, Andy Jassy wakes up in the morning and looks in the mirror and he goes, hello, CEO of the most valuable company in the world.
Kara Swisher
Right. Well, we'll see if he does that. It seems indicationless. Interestingly, as much as they protest going public, WeWork.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, go on. Go on. Go on.
Kara Swisher
So you have been riding the WeWork since the S1 came out, the most crazy S1 of all time. Its biggest outside investor, SoftBank, urged the tech company to shelve its IPO. I feel like we're responsible for that. I feel good about that.
Scott Galloway
That's definitely us. That and the fact this company makes absolutely no sense.
Kara Swisher
Okay. But now the company is supposedly going forward with the IPO.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. I don't think that's going to happen.
Kara Swisher
Okay. What's going to happen then?
Scott Galloway
I don't think the company's going to get public. For people who don't know, WeWork, you've probably all been in one. How many people have been in a WeWork? Lots of people, right? It's very nice. You have the beer and the kombucha and the wallpaper and the slightly above IKEA tables kind of thing. And they have put out an S1 and we've always felt that, I've always felt they're a real estate company essentially and the guy who runs it has very luxurious hair and says a lot of things about feelings and happiness and whatever but he's a real estate company and they've been proliferating like kudzu all around the country. When this S1 came out it was pretty shocking how much he owned a lot of the buildings in it, which is a lot of self-dealing. He got a giant $700 million loan essentially or took $700 million out. He owned the brand. And then the business is just terrible. It's a terrible business. So we started, especially Scott, started banging on this IPO, which was comical. It was weird that they even put out this S1.
Well, first off, you got to be dangerous of cults. Cults of personalities are usually terrible stocks. So typically a CEO...
Kara Swisher
Well, Apple. Hello?
Scott Galloway
No, that's not true. Come on, I'm on a roll. Okay, all right. So on average, unicorn CEO prospectuses, they mentioned the name. You know, they mentioned the name Dara in the Uber S1 23 times, and Lyft it was like 18 times. The term Adam is used 169 times. And this is Adam Neumann, the CEO. You have a company that is scaling its losses. So it'll do $3 billion in revenues this year, and it'll lose almost that much. So I take Uber, which is SoftBank, all the time, because for a $15 ride, you pay $10 for. So it is economically irresponsible not to take Uber everywhere, because it's being subsidized by SoftBank. And right now, WeWork is losing almost a dollar on the dollar. So you have a company and it has no gross margins, meaning that as the company scales it just loses more money. And the thing that's going to actually probably ruin the WeWork IPO is Uber, because Uber has shown that you can't scale a company with negative gross margins. You just scale your losses.
Kara Swisher
They're right. They're starting what I believe is an inexorable spiral. A lot of we had the Uber had at Code, and even Uber Eats looked like it wasn't making much money, and that's considered their growth engine, which was interesting. But Uber's talking about rumors of layoffs, there's marketing issues, there's obviously the costs coming in, and that's also a SoftBank investment that's up. They put an enormous amount of money in at the end. So Uber is showing that you can't run these, you can't have businesses that lose money into eternity.
Scott Galloway
Correct. Well, it's okay. So if you, SmileDirect is going public tomorrow. I Invisalign. I don't know if anyone else here Invisalign. It's nice to be doing orthodontia at 54. But it's a great company, great technology, and a company came in at a lower price point, about half the price point, and cut out the orthodontist and has stores and spends their money on marketing and is growing. It's going to grow to a billion dollars this year. It's growing about 150% a year. It's incredible technology and it's got gross margins of 69%. So it's losing money, but when you're making 69 cents on every dollar of product you sell, at some point, if you get big enough, you're going to start making money.
But the thing about Uber and WeWork is that for every dollar in incremental business, they lose $1.05 or $1.50 or $2. So this company shows no signs that scale or size would ever result in profitability. They would fundamentally have to change their business model. And Uber is showing that doesn't work. There's just a very basic analysis showing that the companies that have lost the most money the year before they go public are generally terrible performing stocks. And all of a sudden, the market, which is prone to fits of sanity, has kind of sobered up and said, look what happened on Lyft, times that by two.
And that's what we're looking at with WeWork. So WeWork, by the way, great product. Actually, I think it's a great, interesting company. It's probably worth five or seven billion dollars. But the problem is they've invested 12 to build a company worth five to 10 billion, and the market is realizing that. There's going to be this ripple effect with SoftBank because they have raised money based on debt that was securitized by the value of their stake in WeWork, which they valued at 47 billion, and the markets are about to remark that debt or that collateral at a much lower price. So what happens, SoftBank has wandered into handing out $200 million checks to everyone in Silicon Valley.
By the way, half that money comes from the Saudis. We'll get into that in a minute. Thugs is what I like to call them from Jamal Khashoggi. So this money has sort of changed venture capital in Silicon Valley. This has been like a crazy time because what happens is someone does a deal that's already crazy and SoftBank walks in with their giant checks and makes it 10 times crazier. Venture capitalists hate, who are never really controlled in Silicon Valley at all. There's not enough rat holes to shove all the money down there. But they hate what SoftBank has been doing to the market.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, SoftBank's basically come in and blown all the traditional masters of the universe out of the water.
Scott Galloway
So typically what's been happening is you're the leading something in cloud, and you want to raise 50 million. And you get a term sheet from a tier one VC in Andreessen Horowitz. And then SoftBank shows up and says, you were raising money at a valuation of 100 million. You wanted to raise 50, so we get a third of the company. Tell you what, we'll raise your valuation to 200 million. We're going to invest $100 million, and if you don't do this, we're going to the number two space, and we're giving them $100 million. And they're literally blowing every other VC and every other term sheet out of the water.
So they're hugely disruptive. But what it looks like now is that they've been drunk, that they've been throwing too much money at too high valuations. And I think we're going to start to see an unwind. And whenever you have a recession, largest post-war expansion in the history of our economy, 11 years, recessions always happen. That's the bad news. The good news to go away, but we're due. And it always comes from an area we're not expecting. And this could be an area when we see the information economy start to unwind and implode, that could be it. I personally think it's going to be the deficit.
We're not worried about the deficit. It's ridiculous that we've managed to have the lowest unemployment and the greatest deficit in the history of the country. That's hard to do and we're doing it. But it could also be, SoftBank could be ground zero for the recession if all of a sudden all the stuff starts unwinding and all these unicorns start crashing and all these private companies can't get out. There's layoffs in the part of the economy that we thought was going to drive all the innovation. This could be SoftBank in this story could end up being much bigger than we think.
Kara Swisher
But people think WeWork might be the moment. I've gotten so many texts. It's the firewall.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, like everyone's going to go just a second, even though it's kind of a relatively silly company in comparison to a lot of them.
Kara Swisher
But it'll be interesting to see if they go public or not. You don't think they're going public.
Scott Galloway
I don't think they get out. I think the consensual hallucination between companies and the markets is ending.
Kara Swisher
All right.
Scott Galloway
And this company, it just, this company makes absolutely no sense. The governance is terrible.
Kara Swisher
Does it ruin the IPO market? There's a lot of people with startups here. They're trying to get funded. What would you do if you're in this market as it starts to unwind? Is it curtains for everybody or?
Scott Galloway
I hope not. I don't think so. I think there's a lot of fantastic companies out there, but companies that lose money. Here's what's happened. This really weird dynamic. Like Amazon invests so hugely invested. We've never seen a company make those sorts of investments and keep losing money. But Amazon has positive gross margins. Amazon was able to create this flywheel effect and spawn these amazing businesses. But everybody has adopted, not everybody, but a lot of companies have adopted this philosophy that if we just grow, regardless of the losses to fund that growth, we're going to be Amazon and we're going to be fine.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, they keep calling themselves Amazon. We're Amazon of.
Scott Galloway
No, I thought the most outrageous one is they've decided, let's take the names or the words of the most profitable sectors. So the fastest growing, most profitable sector is the cloud, or arguably in software, SaaS. So they've decided to call themselves Spaces as Service, SaaS. They use the word technology in their prospectus 123 times. There's no technology at WeWork. They're a real estate company. They have an app for meetings.
Kara Swisher
That's right. They invest long. They pointed that out to me in an email. They invest long. They do 10-year leases.
Scott Galloway
They do 10-year leases. They have $43 billion in long-term obligations. Very analog. $43 billion in long-term obligations. They'll do $3 billion this year in short-term leases. What could go wrong?
And there are companies that build nice businesses investing long and then arbing out short-term rental. Hertz does that. They buy a car long-term and they arb it out short-term to people who just want a car for a day. And they make money. That company trades at 0.2 times revenues. WeWork is claiming that it's worth 17 times revenues. Amazon is worth four times revenues. IWG, its biggest competitor, or the closest analog, Regus. Remember Regus? It's just bad plants and bad coffee, but it's basically WeWork. They trade at two times revenues, and they're profitable. So the company gets out.
Kara Swisher
Do you feel better about the scooter companies? You know my beloved scooter company?
Scott Galloway
Didn't they just open? Didn't they just drop in Brooklyn? Aren't there scooters in Brooklyn now?
Kara Swisher
Yes, they're coming to Brooklyn. I have to be in Brooklyn now a lot, which is interesting. But they're bringing scooters, which I'm very excited about.
Scott Galloway
So you scooter.
Kara Swisher
I do. Break down the scooter world and who wins and who loses in that. I think it's an interesting bit because they don't have the drivers. They don't have a thing. If they start to figure out the execution and the usage of these things, they can do that. I don't know if they'll be worth billions of dollars, but I think the two independent ones are really interesting: Lime and Bird. Lime is run by a really smart guy. I just did a podcast with him, Joe Kraus, and some others there. The way he explained it, he seemed to convince me, and maybe I'm being stupid, but I really enjoy it. I use them a lot. You can start to see it's much more sustainable than an Uber or a Lyft, I think, in terms of making money. I don't think it's worth the crazy amounts they're worth, but...
Scott Galloway
See, just as a citizen, I think they're a menace and the equivalent of littering. I hate cities with scooters. They're everywhere.
Kara Swisher
Well, get ready, my friend.
Scott Galloway
I don't agree. I think it's a great last mile solution.
Kara Swisher
You love it. I've seen you on them.
Scott Galloway
I love them. It's kind of a disturbing image. I'm in Austin, and I see Kara Swisher rolling with her Ray-Bans on the thing. It's like the weirdest, strangest invasion of an alien force in history.
Kara Swisher
You know what? Here she comes. I look good. I look good. And I like them.
Scott Galloway
You love them.
Kara Swisher
I carry my helmet around now.
Scott Galloway
You should wear your helmet, by the way. Lime and others are trying to innovate in helmets. That is a big problem, is safety.
Kara Swisher
Their biggest problem is safety, I think. Safety and figuring out the logistics of it.
Scott Galloway
Yeah.
Kara Swisher
And that's their issue, is people hurting themselves. My brother is always like, if you want to enjoy no elbows, Kara, go right ahead. He's a doctor. Anyway, speaking of not scooters, I wrote a column this week about Joi Ito of the Media Lab.
Scott Galloway
Yeah.
Kara Swisher
An appalling, sexist, horrible story of dirty money. They had taken money from Jeffrey Epstein, quite a bit of it. And the head of it, Joi Ito, who I know very well, had to resign from the MIT Media Lab because it turned out through a story by Ronan Farrow that he tried to cover up the giving of the money. They had given a name to Jeffrey Epstein within MIT Media Lab, which was Voldemort, he who must not be named. It was just one appalling detail upon the next. It turned out a lot of their scientists were hanging out at Jeffrey Epstein's island. He was involved in a lot of these dinners. I've been to one or two of them, not with Jeffrey Epstein, thank God.
But he was pervasive within these science and tech communities. There's going to be more coming out, I think. One of the things that was interesting is the emails that Ronan surfaced. I wrote a column in the New York Times, it was pretty tough on Joi, who I've known a long time. What I wrote was, not every fortune is clean and it is impossible for every donor, investor, advisor, or leader in tech to be perfectly pure. But if you can't manage to say a hard no to those responsible for the dismemberment of a journalist or to a predator of young girls, I am not sure what to say. It was incredible though.
I got a ton of pushback from lots of people in the comments and on a live Twitter. They're like, what's wrong with taking money from Jeffrey Epstein if it's for the good? I was literally like, he's a pedophile and you shouldn't take his money. I feel like that should be the way it is. It was really interesting that there was a big debate going on whether to take money from bad people. But what happened here at the Media Lab was they were covering it up because they knew that taking money from someone who was a convicted sex offender was probably a PR problem.
Scott Galloway
But go back to when he took the money. They took the money after he was convicted. He was a guy who was a sex offender. He, quote unquote, served his time. Were they cognizant of the additional crimes?
Kara Swisher
No, they weren't cognizant of the additional crimes. But they were cognizant of the crimes. There had been rumors about this guy for a long time. Even that shitty conviction that happened, that got overturned, that's why he was brought to New York to be tried here and he killed himself. Rest in non-peace, Jeffrey Epstein. But they were aware of the problem. What was interesting to watch in the emails was how much they went to hide the money this guy was giving.
Scott Galloway
My ex-wife is on the advisory board. There are like a hundred people on this advisory board where it's all luminaries.
Kara Swisher
She went there. And the links they went to hide the money were fascinating. I was sort of like, every day I think tech cannot get worse. This is an astonishing display of lack of any kind of judgment. Same thing, lack of consequences, lack of ethics, lack of care about anything. I was like, I've had it with these people. It's insane that you have to argue whether it's good or not. It's reached Trumpian levels, like we have to argue about the weather. We've reached a really weird place. Now he had to resign, obviously, and we'll see who they put in his place. But I think this thing goes a lot further because a lot of these dinners that Jeffrey Epstein was at were organized by another group called The Edge.org, which he had given a ton of money to. You had Gates there, you had Sergey Brin, you had Larry Page, you had Marissa Mayer. They didn't hang out with Epstein all the time, but it's a really interesting, weird, very male-centered environment where things just get passed over. There were clearly very few women, very few people of color, very little diversity. It was this weird little club. And he managed to take his reputation and rewash it.
Scott Galloway
I wonder if the bigger story is not as much a negative indicator on tech as it is on higher education. In the U.S., there's a direct correlation between your ranking as a university and the size of your endowment. I know this firsthand. You're at NYU. I'm at NYU. There's tremendous pressure to be raising money all the time. You can see how these institutions would rationalize weakened ethics to raise more and more money. It all reverse engineers down to this really terrible gestalt in the world of academia where we no longer see ourselves as public servants. We see ourselves as luxury brands.
We want to raise billions and billions of dollars, but we don't want to expand our freshman seats. Stanford has tripled the applicants for its freshman class, but they refuse to expand the number of seats. People like me can stand up in faculty meetings and listen to our deans say we rejected 90% of our applicants and say it with pride. That is tantamount to a homeless shelter bragging that they turned away 90% of the people who showed up last night. Money and prestige have totally invaded our academia. We've totally lost the script as opposed to being public servants. It's a race to become the premier luxury brand.
We need to totally shift. I think we should start taxing endowments unless you grow your seats faster than population. We need to dramatically expand the number of seats.
Kara Swisher
It will be interesting to see what happens at these companies. It really does sort of... it's not just MIT, it's Harvard, all of them. USC keeps getting dragged into one horrible story after the next. A lot of these places are centers of tech. The biggest question to me is what kind of influence did Epstein have? He had some weird ideas about genetics. He wanted to use sperm to create more Epsteins, which is horrible. But how much did it influence the actual science itself by who's funding it? It's the same idea of why we're taking our cues from very wealthy tech people. Anand Giridharadas talks about this: why do we go to someone like Mark Zuckerberg and let him determine how education should be reformed? Why don't we just tax him and then we decide?
Scott Galloway
Why is space exploration and the cure of infectious disease now the sole domain of rich people?
Kara Swisher
I want NASA putting us in space, not Elon Musk.
Scott Galloway
Why? It's very simple. Tax. I'm a capitalist. I've started companies. I think it's important that we have billionaires. But should we have people worth the GDP of Norway? Does that make any sense?
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Scott Galloway
All of these unbelievable, inspiring things that we used to pull together around government have so many negative consequences because we can't pull together as a people. Curing disease is something we can all get behind, and we can respect our government. We can all feel a collective investment in that. Putting a man on the moon is something we can all get behind. Now we've all got to worship at the... I call it the Pablo Escobar effect. He built parks. He cared about Colombia. Is that where we are? That only people who get money through what I think is fairly rapacious behavior and a lot of genius are the ones that build the parks because the rest of us can't afford it. We are becoming that nation.
Kara Swisher
Yep. I would agree with you. I don't think they should determine anything. All right. We need to take a quick break. We'll be back with more Live Pivot in just a moment.
Break for advertisements
Okay, Scott, let's get back to Pivot at the Lesbians Who Tech Summit in New York City. Let's get to winners and losers. I'm going to do the first win.
Scott Galloway
Yeah.
Kara Swisher
Obviously, Chrissy Teigen's Twitter feud with President Trump. Whatever you don't make, hashtag President Pussy Ass Bitch a trend. In the middle of the night, Trump tweeted about how John Legend and his, quote, filthy mouth wife had not given enough credit for his work in criminal justice reform. But he messed with the wrong woman, obviously. Chrissy Teigen is an expert tweeter and she called him a pussy-ass bitch. And that's where we are in our presidential day.
Scott Galloway
Nice.
Kara Swisher
He was busy with the Alabama stuff going on for a long time and then she got his attention. That's where we are. So she's a winner. I love Chrissy Teigen. I think she's a great tweeter. I think she's funny and she doesn't keep it clean, but I think she does a great job. I'm fascinated by his continued attacks trying to best her, which is going to end in tears for Donald Trump. So that's my win. What's your win?
Scott Galloway
Let's hope so. My win is California. The state legislature passed AB5, saying that independent contractors, or Uber driver partners, which is Latin for no health insurance, no minimum wage protection, they've reclassified what it means to be an independent contractor. They've said, to be an independent contractor, you have control of your own time. You have to kind of have your own business. Uber drivers or partners could qualify as that, but you also can't be offering the service that is core to the business. It's going to be very difficult for Uber to argue that the drivers aren't core to the business. This is an enormous victory. Union memberships have been cut in half. It's pretty straight math. Everybody complains about how we got to this point where the bottom 50% of America has about the same wealth as seven families in America. It's a direct correlation to the absolute shit-kicking that unions have had and the fact that we haven't really had a minimum wage raise in about 30 years. This is a firewall. This is us saying enough.
Kara Swisher
Gavin Newsom just signed it into law. Uber says it doesn't apply to them, or is making the argument that it doesn't apply to their contractors.
Scott Galloway
They've already funded, significantly funded, they allocated 20 or 30 million dollars along with some other companies, DoorDash et cetera, to fight this and take it to the Supreme Court.
Kara Swisher
But it's absolutely time for workers to rise up. I'm a member of a union. It will also ruin their business plans even further. One of the best interviews I've ever done in terms of getting someone to say something just awful, which is my goal in every interview, was when Travis Kalanick, the previous CEO and one of the founders of Uber. I asked him what his business's financial difficulties were in getting profitable. He goes, "Well, the problem I have is that guy in the front seat. I'd like to get rid of him."
Scott Galloway
He's the cost.
Kara Swisher
He's a cost. And once I get rid of him, I have a great business. The whole audience went, "What?" It was fascinating for him to admit that, because he was evil and that's what a villain does in a Bond movie. "I'm going to kill you now, Mr. Bond, by cutting you with a laser in six parts." I don't think they are going to be able to outrun this. Do you?
Scott Galloway
I don't think they will. Unless they get rid of the guy in the front seat.
Kara Swisher
Let's go to our losers.
Scott Galloway
Losers. I think Amazon and Twitter with continued lack of regard for the commonwealth. The Business Roundtable put out this wordy statement saying it's no longer just about shareholders, it's about stakeholders. 50, 70, 80 years ago, companies were evaluated. It was prestigious to have a lot of employees. It was prestigious to be seen as a really good citizen, paying your people well. Those were markers, not just your share price. We've seen Twitter basically file suit in San Francisco refusing to pay that tax. I think that's a big lose. Also Amazon, you want to talk about heroes. Amazon supposedly got very angry at questions around unionization and the pushback they got from local officials here in New York.
So they quote unquote took their bottle and went home and pulled out of New York. Remember that? That was six months ago. LinkedIn is amazing. You can scrape data and get a ton of insight. Apple has about 15 or 20 open job positions in New York. Google has 100. Amazon has 800 open job positions in New York right now. In the last six months since Amazon pulled out, they've increased their hiring. They've hired a thousand people at Amazon in the last six months. They've hired 500 people at AWS. That means they are on pace to bring those 25,000 jobs here. Why? Because Jeff Bezos was always coming here.
A 54-year-old man with 160 billion dollars wants to roll in New York, not Indianapolis or Denver or Columbus, Ohio. That was ridiculous to begin with. And guess what? They are bringing those jobs here to the greatest city in the world. That guy had to put his hand back in his pocket. AOC and State Senator Giannara saved us all three billion dollars by saying, "You know what, boss? You're coming here. This is the greatest place in the world. We do not need to pay you for your midlife crisis." This is a huge victory for us.
Kara Swisher
I love when you go all AOC on me. It's really nice. But it's true. Absolutely true. We don't need to pay them. The idea that we subsidize... I don't know about all of you, but I'm paying a lot to be here.
Scott Galloway
You pay to be in New York. You're right.
Kara Swisher
Exactly. All right. My fail is Trump tweeting about Alabama, tweeting about running in the election for 2024. Don't you just love when presidents talk about subverting the Constitution? That's just Wednesday for us in the United States anymore. The whole Alabama thing was insanity. The only thing I didn't know how to feel about was the whole John Bolton tweets. I hate John Bolton, so I was like, who do I vote for here? Who do I root for? I really think Trump's an asshole, but that guy is a real, persistent asshole for 20 years. It was an interesting thing. But the tweeting about this is really weird. Looking at his mental illness is something we need to take seriously by journalists.
Scott Galloway
Can I have a second win? I think there's a lot of good things going on right now. I'm really hopeful.
Kara Swisher
All right, then we're gonna go to questions.
Scott Galloway
I hate my life less and less every day. The repudiation of Boris Johnson bypassing parliament. He lied to the queen. One of the things I don't like about being a Democrat is I think we're wimps. Fox Talks has a week called Socialism versus Capitalism. They're constantly calling us socialists. I think it's time we started saying, "No, we're not socialists. The worst type of socialism is cronyism, which is happening on the other side." I'm hoping we're having sort of a reverse D-Day. The British Parliament, the Conservative Party, 23 members defect and go to the other side, which we haven't seen among Republicans here with this what I'll call soft fascism.
Let's be clear, this is a soft form of fascism. Fascism is nationalism, demonizing immigrants, a refusal to condemn violence. That perfectly describes some of the actions happening across extremist right wing in Europe and the U.S. So you call me a socialist? No, boss, you're the fascist. Britain just said no. I hope that begins to infect us. Will we start to push back on a president who's taking money out of our defense budget without any discourse with our legislative body? Boris Johnson tried to do the same thing in the UK and they said, "Not here, boss." We need to do the same thing here.
We need less fascism.
Kara Swisher
I like you in a lesbian... You've gone full lesbian, which is really nice. I wish that lesbian Lindsey Graham would do that.
Scott Galloway
What? Come on.
Kara Swisher
That's good. I think everyone has the photos or something. Anyway, let's go. We're going to have questions from the audience. All right. Marianne in the audience, I don't know where you are.
Audience Member
What can large tech platforms, Twitter, YouTube, etc., do to protect vulnerable communities while not accidentally preventing members of the community from reclaiming what used to be hateful slurs?
Kara Swisher
Do you want to go first?
Scott Galloway
No, you go.
Kara Swisher
I think as long as there's a dollar bill at the end of it, they're not going to. I don't think we can call on their better angels. They've shown a masterful delay in obfuscation with faux concern. The underlying business model and the algorithms are the problem. As a species, we'd like to think we're generous and empathetic, and there's a large vein of that. But we're more tribal than we are generous or empathetic. We're very drawn to violence and conflict. It's the ultimate business model to create a model where advertising gets to target conflict. When we talk about engagement on these platforms, what we really mean is enragement.
There's an economic interest in letting anti-vaxxers go on and talk about this stuff without stepping in and saying, "This is not only not true, it could potentially be very harmful." It could result in an outbreak of meningitis. They will always default to, "We're worried about it. We're concerned about it. We'll do better." But don't get in the way of it. The bottom line is we need legislation. We pay 23 cents on the dollar to D.C. and to our state governments so they can prevent a tragedy of the commons. These companies will never make that connection. We need to elect officials that hold them to the same standards and scrutiny we've held other industries.
They're not going to get there on their own. When it's raining money, your vision gets blurred.
Scott Galloway
I agree with you on that one.
Audience Member
What will happen to Lyft and Uber drivers? Because you do predictions mostly. So what will happen to Lyft and Uber?
Scott Galloway
I think all of us probably need to take fewer Ubers. I don't know if it makes sense for a professor to be taking a Suburban for $80. I should probably be angry that it takes so long to get to the airports and vote for people and be willing to pay taxes so there's public transportation to these places, like they've done in Europe for the last 50 years. I'd like to think the workers get a little bit more dignity, the wages go up, that we go to minimum wage. Remember all the fear mongering about what happens if you raise minimum wage to $15? That hasn't panned out anywhere.
Kara Swisher
No.
Scott Galloway
Hasn't panned out anywhere. I hope just across the board, the gig workers and everybody else... that this California legislation goes national.
Kara Swisher
Do you think it's going to happen?
Scott Galloway
I do.
Kara Swisher
I did have a discussion with Gavin Newsom when he was lieutenant governor. He didn't have anything to do all day, so he had lunch with me. We talked about this idea of reclassifying workers and creating a new kind of worker. I think California, I'll be writing about this next week in the New York Times, is really the de facto national legislator for everything. Whether it's a privacy bill or this AB5 with the car deal. Gavin Newsom and the Senate there are determining a lot of our regulations for tech. And Margrethe Vestager just got a giant job and she got quantumly more scary, which she's a badass. Speaking of badass women. Who here is in a union? Anybody here in a union?
Scott Galloway
I went to UCLA. I was in a union. Junior year at UCLA, every summer I had basically 12 weeks to make $2,300 so I could afford to go back to school. I worked as a box boy at San Vicente Foods. This guy took an interest in me. He said, "Do this, do this, do this." He had me fill out a bunch of paperwork. He said, "It's going to cost you $80 up front." I'm like, "I don't have $80." He's like, "We're putting you in the union." I went from $4 an hour to $11 an hour. Someone taking an interest in me and the power of unions. Everybody seemed to be fine shopping in Bel Air at San Vicente Foods. It literally paid for my junior year of college. Someone saying, "There's dignity in work. Anyone who shows up here and packs other people's groceries should get paid eight or nine bucks an hour in 1986 as opposed to four bucks an hour." I got through my junior year of college. I think that needs to happen across millions of households. We need to raise... I'm really on my soapbox now. I would really love to see a reinvigoration of unions in America.
Kara Swisher
It's interesting that it's happening at internet media companies. There's been unionization efforts more than anywhere else. Vox went unionized. They're working on it at BuzzFeed and Vice News. It's a really interesting time because it's the media companies that are doing that, the internet media companies. I know it was a struggle at Vox, but they ultimately came to a deal with the unions. I'm not in the designation now for the Vox union, but it's an interesting trend. We'll see.
Scott Galloway
Unions have been so kneecapped, it's kind of hard to imagine they'll come back.
Kara Swisher
Yes. All right, last two.
Audience Member
2020 tech IPO predictions, Scott Galloway.
Scott Galloway
The biggest IPO or the most successful IPO of 2020 is going to be Airbnb.
Kara Swisher
Are you bullish on this one? Or are you going to slap them around?
Scott Galloway
Airbnb is gangster. Airbnb is an incredible concept. With Uber, Uber has no moats. The core business has low margins. Airbnb is the exact opposite. You have to have global supply. That means you have to have people who know about Airbnb coming in from Copenhagen and Tokyo. It has an incredible moat. It's well run. You like the CEO and the management team there. They have issues around what they do to cities and removing rental properties in big cities. But in general, he's very aware of these things. He's not just saying, "We'll do better." What I get from him is a really strong and interesting discussion. You can really shame him, which is always helpful. I don't get a, "We've made some mistakes, but we'll do better." What kind of internet do we want?
First Amendment. I'm proud of our progress. Without knowing what the First Amendment is.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, what? Yeah. And then, and then it's easier to pick the losers. Uber, Uber, Lyft, Tesla, Beyond Meat, all down 20 to 80 percent in 2020. How about you? What do you think?
Audience Member
I think Airbnb. Airbnb, maybe Pinterest.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, we'll see. You think they'll do well?
Audience Member
Pinterest, I have no idea.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, Pinterest. Yeah, I haven't paid attention in years. They've done well. Pinterest has actually done well.
Audience applause
All right. Thank you so much. This is Pivot, Scott Galloway, our Lesbro. Thank you very much. Scott, always lovely to see you in person. And thanks to Lesbians Who Tech for inviting us. Today's show was produced by Rebecca Sinanis and Eric Johnson. Eric Anderson is Pivot's executive producer. Thanks also to Rebecca Castro, Drew Burrows, and Nishat Kerwa. Thanks again to Lesbians Who Tech for having us. Make sure you subscribe to the show on Apple Podcast. If you like this week's episode, leave us a review. Thanks for listening to Pivot from Vox Media. We'll be back next week with another breakdown of all things tech and business.