Podcast Episode Summary
The podcast episode "Pivot" from the Vox Media Podcast Network features Kara Swisher and Scott Galloway discussing various topics, including media ownership, Microsoft's market value surpassing Apple, and China's social credit system.
Main Topic:
The main topic of the episode is the changing landscape of media ownership, with billionaires like Lorraine Powell Jobs and Jeff Bezos buying up media companies. The hosts also discuss the trend of "Ritalin Retail," where companies create immersive experiences to attract customers.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Kara Swisher
Pivot is brought to you by our founding sponsor, Smart Water. What makes Smart Water delicious? It's pure, it's crisp, it's vapor distilled with electrolytes added for taste. Learn more at drinksmartwater.com. Hi, everyone. This is Pivot from the Vox Media Podcast Network, and I'm Kara Swisher. And I'm Scott Galloway. Hello, Scott. How are you doing?
Scott Galloway
How are you, Kara? In this freezing cold weather. I'm sorry.
Kara Swisher
So you pulled out the ultimate excuse for being late. Yeah. And your kid forgot his lunch. Yes, and he guilted me. Like, it was his fault, and then he blamed me for not reminding me, and then he got me to bring it to school. I just—and the whole—I'm an Uber driver, really, is what I am.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, aren't we all? Yeah, he's 13. I just—I don't know. I just brought it. I just remembered when—I don't know. I don't know. I don't know, Scott. So anyway—
Kara Swisher
They'll take care of us when we're old, Kara. That's what we have to remember. Yeah. Someone has to take care of us when we're old. Yes. Well, I hope that's the case. I'm like—I was thinking that the other night. I'm like, I wonder if these two bozos are going to take care of me when I'm older. I wasn't certain. I'm not certain. One of them may be. The other I'm not—the other will just pay for it, which I'm fine, too. That's fine, too. That works. Yeah. So what's going on this week? Well, there's a lot going on. I just reported a story yesterday that Lorraine Powell Jobs, who is the widow of Steve Jobs, but that's not her only criteria. She's also an entrepreneur. She's an investor. She's done a ton of philanthropy. She bought a company called Pop-Up Magazines Productions, another media buy. I thought you might have some thoughts on all these zillionaires buying up properties. This is a really interesting property. She's been buying interesting properties. We've got Microsoft surpassing Apple. We've got all kinds of things. Tell me what you want to talk about. A lot of good stuff. A lot of good stuff.
Scott Galloway
Well, it's interesting. The pop-up, that company, I had never heard of it before, but there's definitely a trend in what I would describe as Ritalin Retail, the Frosé Mansion or Museum of Pizza, and the notion that retail, in order to survive, needs to— Okay, go ahead. Frosé Mansion. Let's go have rosé and explore our imagination and unleash the bounds of our creativity for $45 to drink champagne. Anyways, the key attribute in these things is scarcity. And that is, you know, the Museum of Ice Cream is going away. So this seems to be a trend. It's going to have a lot of impact on retail, especially malls that are used to co-opting brands into signing 10-year commitments. Right. And I think this is an example of it turning content into sort of this, you know, quote-unquote experiential retail.
Kara Swisher
In terms of billionaires— Content, it's just a show. I mean, I don't know if it's experiential retail. I'm not sure if that's—it's just—have you been to one? I'm going to take you to one. They're great. They're really great. I'd like that. You know what's interesting about them? Oh, so you've been to one. Describe it. Oh, I've been to tons. I've been to tons and tons. I love them. They started in San Francisco, and they sell out immediately because they're so delightful. It's a magazine acted out. Like at one point, one of them, Jenna Wortham, who works for the New York Times, she took one of her New York Times story, and she did it in shadow puppets.
And it was so entertaining. It's delightful. And then they don't record it, so you can't see it again. which is kind of like most theater. Again, scarcity. It's fun. It's fun and interesting and inventive, and it always pushes you from a journalistic perspective. Anyway, and then they have a magazine that they've distributed. You know how Sunday magazines are over at big newspaper chains because they cost so much. And so they make one that is inserted into the San Francisco Chronicle and certain readers of the Los Angeles Times and the San Francisco Chronicle and some other places. And it's really great journalism, I mean, they've won—they've gotten very close to several national magazine awards in a very short time, and they've won—I know we gave them an award when I'm on the board of the Livingston Awards.
And they're just really a great little company, but she had invested $10 million in them and now has picked up the rest. Wow. Yeah, so Republicans buy football teams and Democrats buy media companies. Right. What do you think of that? What do you think about big—I mean, people have owned—big people—big rich people have owned media forever, but what do you think of that trend?
Scott Galloway
I actually think on the whole it's a good thing I think organizations like the New York Times should be owned by a benign billionaire with the resources and the commitment and they need to be checks and balances but my sense is these organizations don't make great for-profit entities so if a billionaire with deep pockets and a commitment to democracy and journalism comes in I'm all good with that I think it's interesting because they're all tech people Like Mark Benioff buys Time Magazine. Lorraine Jobs, Powell Jobs, is buying – she bought the big piece of the Atlantic. She's bought a bunch of movie studios, really interesting ones, one called Macro, and it focuses on stories of people of color.
She's bought into Axios. She's bought into Gimlet Media. And then obviously Jeff Bezos. And so I think you're going to see – you're right. It's mostly tech people, which is really interesting to me because they're the people sort of ruining media at the same time, which is kind of ironic. But the fear is that these people are going to come in and turn it into their vehicle for personal use. Which used to be the case. The Sheldon Adelson model. Yeah. But I would argue both Rupert Murdoch – there was fear that Rupert Murdoch was going to ruin The Wall Street Journal. I think The Wall Street Journal is as good as it's ever been.
And I think The Washington Post has actually made a lot of progress since Bezos bought it. So we're four rich people buying media in other words. Yeah, there you go. OK. We're in agreement. How about it? I do worry about the idea. I mean, the thing is when I do worry about it, I think, oh, my God, the bankrupts on the Times, whoever on the Los Angeles Times, there's always been a rich family. And either they're good rich families like the Grams of the Washington Post or they're bad rich families, you know, like the Adelsons who meddle and do stuff with their properties. So there you have it. Yeah, but over the last 30 years, media has taken a lot of very rich families and turned them into just rich families.
I don't think the Grahams or the Sulzbergers have the economic influence they used to. Yeah, that's the case. I think you're right. And they still have a tremendous commitment to journalism. But the Bancrofts who sold to Murdoch, they look like geniuses. They do. They sold at the top of the market. That was a struggle if you remember that thing. I was at the journal at the time. And I knew them pretty well. And we had one of our conferences, our all-things-deconference that Rupert was at. and some of the Bancroft people, the family, and it was really tense. It was super tense because they fought.
I imagine you were one of the folks that was saying no way. No, I wasn't. You said sell. I was. You know, it was interesting because, no, I thought they should sell, maybe not to him. I mean, at one point, I know the Washington Post was worried, the owners of the Washington Post were worried that Ruben Roddick would try to buy the Washington Post, And so that's why they sort of sidled it up to Bezos, I think, in a lot of ways. I think they didn't want it being owned by Rupert Murdoch, for example. Anyway, so that's the situation in media. What's interesting, another one is Microsoft surpassing Apple in market value.
I thought you'd have some thoughts on that. Please eliminate me. Yeah, and it's not so much that Microsoft passed Apple. It's that Apple fell below Microsoft. And I think Satya Nadella, I would argue, is probably the tech CEO of the year. We'll explain that. Has been a real visionary. Well, under Balmer, the company went sideways for a good 10, 15 years. Yes, yes. And then two, three years into the Nadella reign, and this company is, again, the most valuable company in the world, or at least it was briefly on Wednesday. And it goes to two things, and I think there's key learnings here for what I talk to my students about in terms of the careers they want to pursue.
One is more just a financial that's smoothing out the lumps, and you haven't seen nearly the fall in Microsoft as you've seen in some of the other big tech. And that is the company is just more diversified. It has several distinct revenue streams, diversification, the market's like that. But more than anything, it's got the recurring revenue business model. And that is the ultimate monogamous relationship between corporate America and an organization is the relationship between global corporations and Microsoft Office, who every year are pointing up hundreds of dollars per worker. And then the renewal rates are practically 100 percent.
And the market just loves monogamy or specifically recurring revenue. And Microsoft, for a long time, has had just this tens of billions of dollars of recurring revenue in the form of Office. So Sayan Nadella and Microsoft as we all barking at the moon and talking about Facebook and Apple they just keep plugging along Yeah he a plugger It really it incredible He an interesting guy He got a really interesting he got sort of a tough family life too His kids have some learning disabilities. And he's just one of these really interesting, quiet guys who I've known for a long, long time. And when he was a product – you know, he was running different products at Microsoft.
And he was sort of the candidate nobody thought – they had all these big names for the head of Microsoft. and he sort of, again, sidled in there and very quiet, very self-effacing. And he had one little hiccup around when he said something wrong about women at one of the women's events. But in general, I think he's been a really solid person. And, you know, the era of Bomber was just, you know, I covered that whole thing and it was really something to see. He kept saying, mobile's not going to be there. Who cares about cell phones? Like it just went on and on, you know, about really missed calls.
all over the place when I was covering that company. And so, you know, Bomber's a salesman at heart, really. Just he could be selling Xerox machines. You know, he could sell anything, essentially. But they really did need someone who was more of a technologist, more of, you know, pulled the politics out of it, pulled the just quiet and steady wins the race kind of personality. And I really, I actually like him personally. He's very, you know, he's sort of geeky, but he can talk to you. You know what I mean? Like, he's a really—he's a very solid CEO that really is— He's very likable. Yeah, very much so.
And so it's interesting to think about that Microsoft now versus Microsoft 10 years ago, you know, 15 years ago even. You know, what was interesting, the reason I want to sort of pivot to the idea is that, you know, this is a company that underwent an antitrust scrutiny and then, of course, lost in court. And they've managed to pull themselves back and get back in cloud, which is another thing that Amazon was sort of running away with. And what's interesting is this week Google's cloud had left Diane Greene. And I think there's probably some tension between – I know there is. There was some tension between her and Sundar Pichai, the CEO of Google.
Now, what's interesting about her is she's also on the board of Google, which is kind of an odd situation for – yeah. So she left, and that was – and they replaced her with someone else, I think from Oracle. But Google has not kept up the same way in the cloud business that they should have and missed that turn, very much so, compared to Microsoft, which got it back, I think. Well, it's interesting you bring up the DOJ action against Microsoft in the late 90s. And I would argue that if the DOJ had moved in on Microsoft in the late 90s and said stop killing small companies in the crib as you did with Netscape, that we'd all be saying, I don't know, bing it.
They would have used their bundling and economic power to kill Google in the crib. And the object of every innovator's affection, Google, $750 billion in market cap, 75,000 great jobs created, is a function of antitrust action. And we forget that antitrust can actually be oxygenating and also birth control. Yes, absolutely. I think it was a big – that was a really interesting thing. I covered it for the Washington Post, that trial. And I just keep remembering that when Gates had that – when he was with the lawyers and he just messed up so badly. They were so arrogant. Like it just oozed out of that company.
And it's certainly a different company now. It's absolutely – and I think it's much more in Satya's image than it is in the two founders really, which was Steve Ballmer, even though he wasn't – well, he was a founder, I think, and Bill Gates. So I think they're just plugging away at what they do. And they got out of the media business, speaking of that, like a lot of their MSN. That went on for far too long, and it was sad to watch. So it's interesting. They're an interesting sort of dark horse of a company. You think of Microsoft as so scary, but they actually seem very pleasant, right? Very pleasant.
But surpassing Apple, what do you think about that part? I thought you'd have a thought on Apple. So, look, Apple is turned into the iPhone and the seven dwarves. People talk about the services component, again, recurring revenue. But it's really, you know, Apple is, and it's an incredible problem to have, but the most profitable device in the history of business and probably the most transformative device, the iPhone. You know, the company is, if the iPhone sneezes, Apple's going to get a cold. And there's some insecurity and some wobbliness around people not replacing their iPhone as often.
And I don't know if you saw the Supreme Court case. Explain that. Anti-competitive behavior. Well, effectively, of all people, some iPhone users are saying that they have no choice and that Apple is making apps more expensive than they need to be because effectively Apple has a monopoly on it and you have to go to the App Store and pay a 30% surcharge, which is what Apple charges. They take a 30% tax. And this all comes back to the same thing, and that is if you own the rails and you're shipping all the products and you get to see where every product is going, should you also own the businesses that you're shipping products to?
Do you have insight? If you're a platform, should you also be competing? Like Amazon. You could say the same thing about Amazon. Against all of them. And going back to Microsoft, the reason why the DOJ moved in on Microsoft in the late 90s and said stop killing small companies in the crib as you did with Netscape, that we'd all be saying, I don't know, bing it. They would have used their bundling and economic power to kill Google in the crib. And the object of every innovator's affection, Google, $750 billion in market cap, 75,000 great jobs created, is a function of antitrust action. And we forget that antitrust can actually be oxygenating and also birth control.
Yes, absolutely. I think it was a big – that was a really interesting thing. I covered it for the Washington Post, that trial. And I just keep remembering that when Gates had that – when he was with the lawyers and he just messed up so badly. They were so arrogant. Like it just oozed out of that company. And it's certainly a different company now. It's absolutely – and I think it's much more in Satya's image than it is in the two founders really, which was Steve Ballmer, even though he wasn't – well, he was a founder, I think, and Bill Gates. So I think they're just plugging away at what they do.
And they got out of the media business, speaking of that, like a lot of their MSN. That went on for far too long, and it was sad to watch. So it's interesting. They're an interesting sort of dark horse of a company. You think of Microsoft as so scary, but they actually seem very pleasant, right? Very pleasant. But surpassing Apple, what do you think about that part? I thought you'd have a thought on Apple. So, look, Apple is turned into the iPhone and the seven dwarves. People talk about the services component, again, recurring revenue. But it's really, you know, Apple is, and it's an incredible problem to have, but the most profitable device in the history of business and probably the most transformative device, the iPhone.
You know, the company is, if the iPhone sneezes, Apple's going to get a cold. And there's some insecurity and some wobbliness around people not replacing their iPhone as often. And I don't know if you saw the Supreme Court case. Explain that. Anti-competitive behavior. Well, effectively, of all people, some iPhone users are saying that they have no choice and that Apple is making apps more expensive than they need to be because effectively Apple has a monopoly on it and you have to go to the App Store and pay a 30% surcharge, which is what Apple charges. They take a 30% tax. And this all comes back to the same thing, and that is if you own the rails and you're shipping all the products and you get to see where every product is going, should you also own the businesses that you're shipping products to?
Do you have insight? If you're a platform, should you also be competing? Like Amazon. You could say the same thing about Amazon. Against all of them. And going back to Microsoft, the reason why the DOJ moved in on Microsoft in the late 90s and said stop killing small companies in the crib as you did with Netscape, that we'd all be saying, I don't know, bing it. They would have used their bundling and economic power to kill Google in the crib. And the object of every innovator's affection, Google, $750 billion in market cap, 75,000 great jobs created, is a function of antitrust action. And we forget that antitrust can actually be oxygenating and also birth control.
Yes, absolutely. I think it was a big – that was a really interesting thing. I covered it for the Washington Post, that trial. And I just keep remembering that when Gates had that – when he was with the lawyers and he just messed up so badly. They were so arrogant. Like it just oozed out of that company. And it's certainly a different company now. It's absolutely – and I think it's much more in Satya's image than it is in the two founders really, which was Steve Ballmer, even though he wasn't – well, he was a founder, I think, and Bill Gates. So I think they're just plugging away at what they do.
And they got out of the media business, speaking of that, like a lot of their MSN. That went on for far too long, and it was sad to watch. So it's interesting. They're an interesting sort of dark horse of a company. You think of Microsoft as so scary, but they actually seem very pleasant, right? Very pleasant. But surpassing Apple, what do you think about that part? I thought you'd have a thought on Apple. So, look, Apple is turned into the iPhone and the seven dwarves. People talk about the services component, again, recurring revenue. But it's really, you know, Apple is, and it's an incredible problem to have, but the most profitable device in the history of business and probably the most transformative device, the iPhone.
You know, the company is, if the iPhone sneezes, Apple's going to get a cold. And there's some insecurity and some wobbliness around people not replacing their iPhone as often. And I don't know if you saw the Supreme Court case. Explain that. Anti-competitive behavior. Well, effectively, of all people, some iPhone users are saying that they have no choice and that Apple is making apps more expensive than they need to be because effectively Apple has a monopoly on it and you have to go to the App Store and pay a 30% surcharge, which is what Apple charges. They take a 30% tax. And this all comes back to the same thing, and that is if you own the rails and you're shipping all the products and you get to see where every product is going, should you also own the businesses that you're shipping products to?
Do you have insight? If you're a platform, should you also be competing? Like Amazon. You could say the same thing about Amazon. Against all of them. And going back to Microsoft, the reason why the DOJ moved in on Microsoft in the late 90s and said stop killing small companies in the crib as you did with Netscape, that we'd all be saying, I don't know, bing it. They would have used their bundling and economic power to kill Google in the crib. And the object of every innovator's affection, Google, $750 billion in market cap, 75,000 great jobs created, is a function of antitrust action. And we forget that antitrust can actually be oxygenating and also birth control.
Yes, absolutely. I think it was a big – that was a really interesting thing. I covered it for the Washington Post, that trial. And I just keep remembering that when Gates had that – when he was with the lawyers and he just messed up so badly. They were so arrogant. Like it just oozed out of that company. And it's certainly a different company now. It's absolutely – and I think it's much more in Satya's image than it is in the two founders really, which was Steve Ballmer, even though he wasn't – well, he was a founder, I think, and Bill Gates. So I think they're just plugging away at what they do.
And they got out of the media business, speaking of that, like a lot of their MSN. That went on for far too long, and it was sad to watch. So it's interesting. They're an interesting sort of dark horse of a company. You think of Microsoft as so scary, but they actually seem very pleasant, right? Very pleasant. But surpassing Apple, what do you think about that part? I thought you'd have a thought on Apple. So, look, Apple is turned into the iPhone and the seven dwarves. People talk about the services component, again, recurring revenue. But it's really, you know, Apple is, and it's an incredible problem to have, but the most profitable device in the history of business and probably the most transformative device, the iPhone.
You know, the company is, if the iPhone sneezes, Apple's going to get a cold. And there's some insecurity and some wobbliness around people not replacing their iPhone as often. And I don't know if you saw the Supreme Court case. Explain that. Anti-competitive behavior. Well, effectively, of all people, some iPhone users are saying that they have no choice and that Apple is making apps more expensive than they need to be because effectively Apple has a monopoly on it and you have to go to the App Store and pay a 30% surcharge, which is what Apple charges. They take a 30% tax. And this all comes back to the same thing, and that is if you own the rails and you're shipping all the products and you get to see where every product is going, should you also own the businesses that you're shipping products to?
Do you have insight? If you're a platform, should you also be competing? Like Amazon. You could say the same thing about Amazon. Against all of them. And going back to Microsoft, the reason why the DOJ moved in on Microsoft in the late 90s and said stop killing small companies in the crib as you did with Netscape, that we'd all be saying, I don't know, bing it. They would have used their bundling and economic power to kill Google in the crib. And the object of every innovator's affection, Google, $750 billion in market cap, 75,000 great jobs created, is a function of antitrust action. And we forget that antitrust can actually be oxygenating and also birth control.
Yes, absolutely. I think it was a big – that was a really interesting thing. I covered it for the Washington Post, that trial. And I just keep remembering that when Gates had that – when he was with the lawyers and he just messed up so badly. They were so arrogant. Like it just oozed out of that company. And it's certainly a different company now. It's absolutely – and I think it's much more in Satya's image than it is in the two founders really, which was Steve Ballmer, even though he wasn't – well, he was a founder, I think, and Bill Gates. So I think they're just plugging away at what they do.
And they got out of the media business, speaking of that, like a lot of their MSN. That went on for far too long, and it was sad to watch. So it's interesting. They're an interesting sort of dark horse of a company. You think of Microsoft as so scary, but they actually seem very pleasant, right? Very pleasant. But surpassing Apple, what do you think about that part? I thought you'd have a thought on Apple. So, look, Apple is turned into the iPhone and the seven dwarves. People talk about the services component, again, recurring revenue. But it's really, you know, Apple is, and it's an incredible problem to have, but the most profitable device in the history of business and probably the most transformative device, the iPhone.
You know, the company is, if the iPhone sneezes, Apple's going to get a cold. And there's some insecurity and some wobbliness around people not replacing their iPhone as often. And I don't know if you saw the Supreme Court case. Explain that. Anti-competitive behavior. Well, effectively, of all people, some iPhone users are saying that they have no choice and that Apple is making apps more expensive than they need to be because effectively Apple has a monopoly on it and you have to go to the App Store and pay a 30% surcharge, which is what Apple charges. They take a 30% tax. And this all comes back to the same thing, and that is if you own the rails and you're shipping all the products and you get to see where every product is going, should you also own the businesses that you're shipping products to?
Do you have insight? If you're a platform, should you also be competing? Like Amazon. You could say the same thing about Amazon. Against all of them. And going back to Microsoft, the reason why the DOJ moved in on Microsoft in the late 90s and said stop killing small companies in the crib as you did with Netscape, that we'd all be saying, I don't know, bing it. They would have used their bundling and economic power to kill Google in the crib. And the object of every innovator's affection, Google, $750 billion in market cap, 75,000 great jobs created, is a function of antitrust action. And we forget that antitrust can actually be oxygenating and also birth control.
Yes, absolutely. I think it was a big – that was a really interesting thing. I covered it for the Washington Post, that trial. And I just keep remembering that when Gates had that – when he was with the lawyers and he just messed up so badly. They were so arrogant. Like it just oozed out of that company. And it's certainly a different company now. It's absolutely – and I think it's much more in Satya's image than it is in the two founders really, which was Steve Ballmer, even though he wasn't – well, he was a founder, I think, and Bill Gates. So I think they're just plugging away at what they do.
And they got out of the media business, speaking of that, like a lot of their MSN. That went on for far too long, and it was sad to watch. So it's interesting. They're an interesting sort of dark horse of a company. You think of Microsoft as so scary, but they actually seem very pleasant, right? Very pleasant. But surpassing Apple, what do you think about that part? I thought you'd have a thought on Apple. So, look, Apple is turned into the iPhone and the seven dwarves. People talk about the services component, again, recurring revenue. But it's really, you know, Apple is, and it's an incredible problem to have, but the most profitable device in the history of business and probably the most transformative device, the iPhone.
You know, the company is, if the iPhone sneezes, Apple's going to get a cold. And there's some insecurity and some wobbliness around people not replacing their iPhone as often. And I don't know if you saw the Supreme Court case. Explain that. Anti-competitive behavior. Well, effectively, of all people, some iPhone users are saying that they have no choice and that Apple is making apps more expensive than they need to be because effectively Apple has a monopoly on it and you have to go to the App Store and pay a 30% surcharge, which is what Apple charges. They take a 30% tax. And this all comes back to the same thing, and that is if you own the rails and you're shipping all the products and you get to see where every product is going, should you also own the businesses that you're shipping products to?
Do you have insight? If you're a platform, should you also be competing? Like Amazon. You could say the same thing about Amazon. Against all of them. And going back to Microsoft, the reason why the DOJ moved in on Microsoft in the late 90s and said stop killing small companies in the crib as you did with Netscape, that we'd all be saying, I don't know, bing it. They would have used their bundling and economic power to kill Google in the crib. And the object of every innovator's affection, Google, $750 billion in market cap, 75,000 great jobs created, is a function of antitrust action. And we forget that antitrust can actually be oxygenating and also birth control.
Yes, absolutely. I think it was a big – that was a really interesting thing. I covered it for the Washington Post, that trial. And I just keep remembering that when Gates had that – when he was with the lawyers and he just messed up so badly. They were so arrogant. Like it just oozed out of that company. And it's certainly a different company now. It's absolutely – and I think it's much more in Satya's image than it is in the two founders really, which was Steve Ballmer, even though he wasn't – well, he was a founder, I think, and Bill Gates. So I think they're just plugging away at what they do.
And they got out of the media business, speaking of that, like a lot of their MSN. That went on for far too long, and it was sad to watch. So it's interesting. They're an interesting sort of dark horse of a company. You think of Microsoft as so scary, but they actually seem very pleasant, right? Very pleasant. But surpassing Apple, what do you think about that part? I thought you'd have a thought on Apple. So, look, Apple is turned into the iPhone and the seven dwarves. People talk about the services component, again, recurring revenue. But it's really, you know, Apple is, and it's an incredible problem to have, but the most profitable device in the history of business and probably the most transformative device, the iPhone.
You know, the company is, if the iPhone sneezes, Apple's going to get a cold. And there's some insecurity and some wobbliness around people not replacing their iPhone as often. And I don't know if you saw the Supreme Court case. Explain that. Anti-competitive behavior. Well, effectively, of all people, some iPhone users are saying that they have no choice and that Apple is making apps more expensive than they need to be because effectively Apple has a monopoly on it and you have to go to the App Store and pay a 30% surcharge, which is what Apple charges. They take a 30% tax. And this all comes back to the same thing, and that is if you own the rails and you're shipping all the products and you get to see where every product is going, should you also own the businesses that you're shipping products to?
Do you have insight? If you're a platform, should you also be competing? Like Amazon. You could say the same thing about Amazon. Against all of them. And going back to Microsoft, the reason why the DOJ moved in on Microsoft in the late 90s and said stop killing small companies in the crib as you did with Netscape, that we'd all be saying, I don't know, bing it. They would have used their bundling and economic power to kill Google in the crib. And the object of every innovator's affection, Google, $750 billion in market cap, 75,000 great jobs created, is a function of antitrust action. And we forget that antitrust can actually be oxygenating and also birth control.
Yes, absolutely. I think it was a big – that was a really interesting thing. I covered it for the Washington Post, that trial. And I just keep remembering that when Gates had that – when he was with the lawyers and he just messed up so badly. They were so arrogant. Like it just oozed out of that company. And it's certainly a different company now. It's absolutely – and I think it's much more in Satya's image than it is in the two founders really, which was Steve