Main Topic: The podcast episode discusses various topics in the tech and business world, including the impact of streaming platforms on the entertainment industry, the challenges faced by Twitter in innovating and decentralizing its platform, the encryption debate, and the struggles of Amazon in the fashion and luxury market.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Kara Swisher
Support for this show comes from Robinhood. Wouldn't it be great to manage your portfolio on one platform? With Robinhood, not only can you trade individual stocks and ETFs, you can also seamlessly buy and sell crypto at low costs. Trade all in one place. Get started now on Robinhood. Trading crypto involves significant risk. Crypto trading is offered through an account with Robinhood Crypto LLC. Robinhood Crypto is licensed to engage in virtual currency business activity by the New York State Department of Financial Services. Crypto held through Robinhood Crypto is not FDIC-insured or SIPC-protected. Investing involves risk, including loss of principal. Securities trading is offered through an account with Robinhood Financial LLC, member SIPC, a registered broker-dealer.
Tires matter. They're the only part of your vehicle that touches the road. Tread confidently with new tires from TireRack. Whether you're looking for expert recommendations or know exactly what you want, TireRack makes it easy. Fast, free shipping, free road hazard protection, convenient installation options, and the best selection of Firestone tires. Go to TireRack.com to see their Firestone test results, tire ratings, and reviews. And be sure to check out all the special offers. TireRack.com, the way tire buying should be.
Hi, everyone. This is Pivot from the Vox Media Podcast Network. I'm Kara Swisher.
Scott Galloway
And I'm Scott Galloway.
Kara Swisher
And, Kara, happy birthday. I just want to say you look amazing for 73. Happy birthday.
Scott Galloway
I'm an attractive 57. I don't mind saying my age. I had a very good week, Scott. You're 57?
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Scott Galloway
Oh, Jesus Christ, that's so old. Oh, my God. That's ridiculously old.
Kara Swisher
That is old, but I look good. I'm doing great. I'm winning awards. I'm having babies. I'm getting married. I'm just on top of my game here at 57, so I'm good with that.
Scott Galloway
You are. Good for you. So I watched the series finale of Silicon Valley last night.
Kara Swisher
Oh, yeah, I forgot about that.
Scott Galloway
Highlight of my week. I forgot about that, yeah. And I thought it was – I actually didn't think it was great. I thought it was just okay, but it stirs a lot of emotions when you have that type of investment in a program. And I was thinking, how do you develop an actual relationship with a media property? I guess it's anything you make an investment in over six years. It's easy to get sentimental.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, sure.
Scott Galloway
And, of course, you were in it, which sort of fucked up the whole thing.
Kara Swisher
I'm everywhere this week. This is a good week for Kara Swisher. Literally. There is like no escaping you this week. But I enjoyed it. Did you see the series finale? What did you think of it?
Scott Galloway
I liked it a lot. I thought it was very, very quiet. I love Alec Berg, who did the show, and I was an advisor to it for many years. I think I was paid like $16 or something like that. And I got a nice jacket from them pretty much.
Kara Swisher
I would argue you deserve $17. I thought your contribution was really like right in the $17 range.
Scott Galloway
I agree. I made more money from appearing on it. You get like $700 or whatever scale is and you get to join the Screen Actors Guild. But I thought it was good. It was very kind of sad and beautiful, I thought. I thought that was very sentimental and I like a sentimental ending. I also watched, of course, the ending of Madam Secretary, which I also loved. But I agree. You have relationships with shows. I mean, I remember where I was when I watched the last episode of MASH. You remember that. Or the last episode of West Wing. The biggest TV event in history in terms of viewership, which shows you how much TV has changed. So let me ask you this. What is your favorite series finale episode? Or what series finale do you think was most moving or did you enjoy the most?
Kara Swisher
I found Six Feet Under. I thought Six Feet Under had that amazing. Word to your mother. Is it yours?
Scott Galloway
That was my number one. Oh, my God. That literally blew me away. We're like the same.
Kara Swisher
Blew me away. Yeah, well, it's death-related for me, and I was like, I love the idea of knowing how people die. Like, that was the whole trick of the show at the beginning. You learned how they got their bodies, essentially, in their funeral home. But that just made me just weep. And they had that song by, whatchamacallit, Sia? Is that pronounced Sia? That was a beautiful song and everything. The whole thing was just, it just got me right there. Incredible. I've watched it many times. I thought that show was amazing.
Scott Galloway
You know what's a close second is, did you see, although I think it moves men more because it taps into sort of our paternal instincts. Did you see the season or did you watch the series Breaking Bad?
Kara Swisher
No, I did not. But I heard it was great.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, the series finale there was really powerful. Really powerful. Yep. Yeah, and of course there's the famous Mary Tyler Moore ending.
Kara Swisher
Oh.
Scott Galloway
Where the studio gets sold. There's a lot of shows do a great. And of course The Sopranos is the famous, famous one.
Kara Swisher
That was awful.
Scott Galloway
Which I liked. I liked that. I know a lot of people had an issue.
Kara Swisher
I thought there was something wrong with my cable box. I didn't understand it at all.
Scott Galloway
Oh.
Kara Swisher
They were fucking with you. They were messing with you. Well, since we're talking about television and how much we love it, we talked last week that Netflix absolutely swept the Golden Globe nominations this year. I mean, they really did. They were just announced this week. You know, the Marriage Story did, which I haven't seen yet because I just got engaged. So I'm not going to talk about Divorce yet. But it was amazing that this might be the year a streaming platform takes home Best Picture. Morning Show was nominated for Best TV Series, Best Performance by Reese Witherspoon and Jennifer Aniston. So the Irishman and the Marriage Story were nominated. A lot of other shows like your beloved Game of Thrones were kind of zeroed out. So what is happening here?
Scott Galloway
Yeah, but they kind of lost all – I don't want to say they lost all credibility with me, but the Irishman? Really? I thought this was – I mean, it was literally, okay, let's do the same movie and see how long –
Kara Swisher
Yeah, I agree. See how old we can cast young people as. It's just –
Scott Galloway
I thought it was ridiculous. I mean, they're just such incredible actors. How young we can cast old people as because they de-aged him. They de-aged Robert De Niro in that. That was a bad use of technology, I thought.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, it just didn't work. The whole thing just didn't, in my view, didn't work. But they're winning these awards. These are a big deal among the people of Hollywood. They're winning these awards.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, but what I take away from all of this, Kara, is that over the long term, there's no core competence like capital. And that is culture of creativity can hold the wolves at the door for a while and hopefully use that to go and access capital. But if you think about, I mean, I'm just such an enormous fan of HBO, but because HBO's creativity either didn't, because it was stuck in a much bigger company, did it translate to the kind of cheap capital? No, that they could increase their spending and go toe-to-toe with these guys. And now I think they're totally screwing up and I've talked about it too much. But over the long term, it's just really difficult to compete with someone who has six times the capital of you. And Netflix is spending $12 or $13 billion a year versus two. I feel like there should be a second award ceremony that's ROI, and that is how much you spend per Emmy. That would be funny. So HBO spends something like one-eighth the amount per Emmy that a Netflix or an Amazon Prime has to spend to figure out creativity. But here's the thing. They're closing the gap. They're figuring it out. Capital, very hard to compete with cheap capital over the long term.
Kara Swisher
It is, 100 percent, especially in this area because people in Hollywood are so rapaciously interested in money in that way. And they'll move wherever they want.
Scott Galloway
You mean they're human? You mean they live in a capitalist society? You think they're more into money than any other? Versus those ethical people that want to save the whales on Wall Street?
Kara Swisher
No, that's not what I mean. I mean those tech people who don't care about their options. Those tech people who are always jealous. Hush your –
Scott Galloway
Go ahead.
Kara Swisher
Shut your piehole there. Okay. Listen. People in Hollywood always got cash, and I used to argue with them that they never got a piece of the action, which is the actual ownership of the IP. So they always, like, went for the cheap cash. I was like their well-paid employees. That's what I called them all the time.
Scott Galloway
Like engineers? I always thought that salespeople—
Kara Swisher
No, because they get a piece of the action.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, but I've always found in tech companies or the companies I've worked in that basically your tech team and your sales team are pretty much coin-operated. And we'll get a new job over lunch and not come in if someone offers them, you know, another 50 bucks a year. Whereas the other categorization of employees are more focused on their equity in the culture and career advancement. Salespeople and tech are kind of the engineers who are pretty much coin-operated.
Kara Swisher
Another fascinating insight from the CEO of nine companies, seven of which have failed.
Scott Galloway
Yes. Yes.
Kara Swisher
Okay. I want to talk about Jack Dorsey had a tweet storm about decentralizing the platform, which is against everything they've been doing for the past bazillion years. Now, I covered when they centralized and they got rid of all the third-party people making things on it or they just – or they sidelined them because everybody was making all this cool stuff and being very innovative around Twitter. And then Twitter sort of shut all that down by controlling the entire experience, which they had good reason to do at the time under – Costello, right? Dick Costello. But he announced, Dorsey announced his Blue Sky team, a five-person team of open-source architects, engineers, and designers to develop open and decentralized standard for social media. I don't understand it. Can you, do you have any thoughts on this?
Scott Galloway
Oh, no. I was going to ask you to give us a history.
Kara Swisher
Well, here's the deal. That they're doing, that it's not creative if they're not solving their problems fast enough. And this is a way to, like, create more creativity on the platform, presumably.
Scott Galloway
Well, when it's an open API, you basically unleash or, if you will, you surf off of the talent of other people who see an opportunity to take those tools and build cool little apps on top of a platform, right? And it creates the developer community. The most obvious example is iTunes and the apps that populate that community, and it creates a halo for. So Apple's always been able to inspire a more robust app community. And Android hasn't been able to garner the same sort of momentum, at least initially, which creates a less robust platform and ecosystem. And early on, my understanding of Twitter was that they wanted to centralize one look and feel because Costolo came from Google and wanted it to be an ad platform and so wanted to aggregate not only eyeballs, but eyeballs through sort of a similar rubric.
And people would argue, well, they've kind of shut out, unlike some of the other platforms, some of the creativity and investment, they weren't able to free ride off of other people's human capital, scrappiness, crazy ideas to build stuff on top of their platform. But I would, you know, I read this thing. I would argue this is kind of, talk about pissing in the ocean. So five developers, and in this press release, he says that whose impact may not be felt for years. It felt like, okay, the PR department wanted to respond, wanted to say, no, we're creative, we're open, we're innovating. But they have more people making sushi at their cafeteria trying to create a Xanadu environment for millennials than they've devoted to this project.
So it's sort of—
Kara Swisher
Yes, they have very good food, though. Let's be fair. They have delicious food.
Scott Galloway
Fair enough. Good food. But they've put almost no wood behind this arrow. So I'm sort of like, well, is this more of a press release? It reminds me of Burberry and Digital, that they would hire one person to do something on Snap and to talk about these huge Snap initiatives because they thought, okay, let's make – this felt like more like a –
Kara Swisher
Yeah, that's cool. You're right. More hype than reality. Here's my issue, is that they need to innovate on Twitter. They've got to innovate on the product. If they ran the company better, like, that they would have the edit button and everything else that we've been asking for. They just – the product hasn't changed a lot, even though you and I both love it. It's really the same old, same old for a long time, and I think that's what it is. And speaking of changing is encryption, that Facebook is following Apple's lead to develop end-to-end encryption, as Mark Zuckerberg previously talked about.
Lots of people on both sides of the aisle, Lindsey Graham and Dianne Feinstein, are agreeing on this. Democrats and Republicans have already hosted a hearing to demand Facebook and Apple give the government a way to sidestep end-to-end encryption for law enforcement purposes. This is going to be a big fight again, I think. And they are, you know, Apple's been pretty firm. And Will Cathcart, the vice president of Facebook sent a letter to A.G. Bill Barr also known as Trump's I'm not going to say. In short he said whatever the government gets access to so will bad actors. No, Bill Barr is literally as I said last week, he really should read Eric Holder's piece about how he unqualified for the job.
Opening up these backdoor lines would affect innocent platform users. This is what Apple has stuck to and now Facebook is sort of putting, speaking of wood behind an arrow, that a big deal. And so what do you think is going to happen this situation?
Scott Galloway
This is a big deal. The boring stuff is the important stuff, and that is, and I think you and I differ a little bit on this. And I got, I think, the most pushback I've ever, probably the most pushback I've ever received. But I think if the FBI finds a terrorist phone who's just committed a mass shooting and wants into the phone to see if there's other shootings being planned or underway, I think that a tech company has an obligation to comply with that court order. At the same time, I also believe that tech companies have an obligation to work with our government. And I've never really understood these employees protesting. You and Jeff Bezos.
Kara Swisher
Oh, I'm totally with Jeff on this one. I think that you may not—I don't think you get to cherry-pick our government's actions. I think if you're a U.S. citizen and you've benefited from the extraordinary opportunities, occasionally we get a bad king. Occasionally we have the wrong decision from the FBI or the CIA. But I think it's ridiculous that these companies are trying to pick and choose which government departments or initiatives they want to be involved in. I think our government—
No, I disagree with you completely. I completely disagree with you. Let's go back to the encryption issue. It only takes one king president to ruin an entire century.
Scott Galloway
Well, yeah, but 49 percent of the population always decides they don't like their president. Anyway, so let's go back to encryption. I get that, but look, if our government can't find other ways to catch terrorists besides getting into a phone and then exposing so many other people, millions and millions of people, to get exactly what they want, which is access to everybody's phone, as we know from Edward Snowden and everything, whatever you think of Edward Snowden, they want in on all our stuff.
Well, then you're saying, okay, but hold on. You're saying you trust Tim Cook more than you trust federal judges. You trust tech CEOs more than you trust our judges?
Kara Swisher
I think these—look at some of the stuff this week around the FISA courts. I am. I do. I do. I do. I do. I have to say.
Scott Galloway
Okay, so we just have a fundamental agreement there. I believe that rule of law in courts, I trust more than tech CEOs. And case in point, encryption, what they're trying to do is put all of their data out of the reach of our government and our law enforcement agencies. So, one, I mean, they'll claim it's privacy, but two, it's because I think they want to abdicate responsibility for the damage that's happening on their platforms. They can just throw up their arms and say, oh, these people planned an attack or this person was a pedophile. We didn't know. Not our fault. And so the notion that they're trying to put this out of the reach of—
Kara Swisher
They are constantly complying. They are constantly complying with justifiable federal demands. They are constantly complying. In this case, it's just the phones themselves. And so they're constantly giving information. You should see all those requests for information from the government, tons, and they comply all the time. As they should, but this will make it impossible to comply.
Scott Galloway
Well, on certain things, these communications on the phones. Let me ask you this. Has the complexion and the format and the gestalt that tech has brought to civic and defense issues make you confident that we should head in the way where more of their content on these platforms becomes out of the reach of regulators or government officials? Is that the direction we want to head?
Kara Swisher
All right. In this case, and I thought Apple was on the right side. I don't love Facebook jumping in here. You're right. It's right. It's depending on the company. I don't trust Mark. I do trust Apple to do the right thing around privacy comparatively. So I think that's the problem. And as others jump in, as Google and the others, yes, you're right. And by the way, lots of people are – Australia passed a law that mandates the company's break encryption if requested. And so, you know, they don't want to have a key. They don't want to have a key that could open up everybody's door. That's, you know, the skeleton key of all time.
But it's an interesting – it's going to go – this is going to – this never was going to stop back with James Comey fighting. It was James Comey actually who was fighting with Apple back then. And then President Obama was on James Comey's side on that one. But it's an interesting time. This is a big deal. This is a very – this is a big, big deal, this encryption debate. And as we get into quantum computing, it's going to get even bigger because there's going to – speaking of the last episode of Silicon Valley, that's what it was all about. It was something that could break AI, that could break codes.
But some of these new wrinkles that Google has gotten into around quantum computing, this quantum supremacy, they're calling it, is certainly going to be problematic for encryption and everything else. So it'll be an interesting time. But last one, and then we'll take a break, is the Away CEO was, after we talked about this situation of you were like, who cares if she's tough? And I agree with you. She has been replaced, essentially fired by – and they brought in the former Lululemon executive, Stuart Hazelden, I think his name is. It's all very complex because it doesn't – there's lots of critiques about the work culture there.
It looks like they were sort of getting this guy to come in as COO to sort of move this Steph Korey CEO, one of the founders, out. And there's all kinds of like debate online about what happened. Jason Del Rey wrote a story about how they moved this fast forward to it. And some people are positing that they used it as an excuse to get rid of her, which is – anyway, it's fascinating. You still are on the too bad, suck it up.
Scott Galloway
I think she's the Tony Montana of CEOs. Say hello to my little friend accountability. Did you read those slacks?
Kara Swisher
Yeah, yeah. I mean –
Scott Galloway
I got to say, I don't disagree. She was a man. Jeff Bezos does that with his stupid percent. A hundred percent. Read the Everything Store. Jeff Bezos behaved this way over and over, and it was called leadership then.
Kara Swisher
Yep.
Scott Galloway
You know what the most—I think the most interesting thing about this is mediums, and that is the way people react, the way you establish relationships, the tone of something. You know, and I don't know if it was Kurzweil. I don't know who said it, and I'm sure Twitter will tell me a million times who said this in very crisp fashion. But the medium is the message. And there's...
Kara Swisher
Marshall McLuhan.
Scott Galloway
Oh, thank you. Thank you for that. And so you should be on Silicon Valley.
Kara Swisher
I was.
Scott Galloway
Slack has become... I don't use Slack. I have trouble with it. I think it's like Snap. I have trouble figuring it out. But every one of my companies uses Snap. And the thing about email is it piles up in people's email boxes. And it feels to me that basically Slack is like text messaging or group emails that have more immediacy. But the fact that it's always on...
Kara Swisher
It's very impulse-driven.
Scott Galloway
It's very impulse-driven. And a lack of filters. And this came back to haunt the CEO. But I read through her emails. And, I mean, there's a couple errors. There's a couple things going on here. Most of these young CEOs of tech companies don't have mentors. They don't have coaches. They also, I mean, they grew up and they're kind of their training was they read, you know, Ben Thompson's book or they read Peter Thiel's book. That's kind of the sum of their CEO training. And I think there's some basic general rules as a CEO, and that is you want to kind of praise publicly and provide feedback or criticize individually in a thoughtful, measured way.
Because people, especially I think younger people, need watering. And also the level of directness should be correlated to the seniority. I think it's okay to pull people in who are getting paid a lot of money and are senior and say, you know, basically, what the fuck, right? But junior people, I don't think – I think you call them into a room and not to sound too Hallmark Channel and say, okay, we're having a challenge here and this can't continue and I need all of your help figuring this out. But it did feel a little bit – I don't know. It felt a little bit bullying and grandstanding. But I don't think this is anything that male CEOs have been doing or just CEOs in general, which is redundant with male.
So I'll put it back to you. If she was a he, do you think she would have been asked to step down?
Kara Swisher
No.
Scott Galloway
No?
Kara Swisher
No. Travis Kalanick was there for years, and they grudgingly got rid of him when he crossed every single line possible. No, I don't. I think it's really interesting. There might be some other things going on there called her personality. I would imagine she's an inexperienced CEO.
Scott Galloway
Right.
Kara Swisher
But so they're all inexperienced CEOs. That's called tech. But women who are inexperienced CEOs in the startup game get killed. Like, look, Theranos fraud, everything else, there's lots of behaviors like Elizabeth Holmes is out there. And they just don't – there's 9,000 movies about Elizabeth Holmes, right? Like, why? And believe me, I'm no fan of what she did. But it's interesting that she gets like nine movies and 12 books and an excellent book, by the way, by John Carreyrou. But still, it's really fascinating.
Scott Galloway
I agree. I think some of her stuff was very much like I would have written an email. I'm sure if you could find my emails on certain things, it was tough. I've done worse. But what this also indicates, I think, is we've reached peak founder. And that is there's always a tension between capital and the investors and the founders. And because mostly of Steve Jobs and Mark Zuckerberg and Bill Gates, these founders who have just returned extraordinary return to their shareholders. There's what I would call founder fetish, and that founders are given way more license and way much more runway to fuck up than they should be given.
Kara Swisher
Founder fetish. They used to be not given enough. Now they're given way too much.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. Well, they brought in an executive who's got a great reputation. He's a turnaround guy. Well, Lululemon. Go ahead, I'm sorry.
Kara Swisher
They've got a great business but under a lot of pressure because there's a lot of copycats, et cetera. And so this is the moment they could really throw it all away. And I suppose they're not going to, you know, they don't want to lose the goose that laid the golden egg here.
Scott Galloway
Has Amazon done to Away what they've done to Allbirds? Have they basically come out with a knockoff that's 90% of the quality for 30% of the price? Go search for Away on Amazon and see what you get.
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Scott Galloway
It's a knockoff. It's a knockoff. They're all knockoff. They knock off everything.
Kara Swisher
All right. When we get back, we will talk more. We are going to listen to a friend of Pivot, and we have wins and fails of the week. And also, you're going to have a prediction, so you better think of one, Mr. Scott Galloway. All right, we'll be back after this.
Ad break
Welcome back to Pivot. All right, we're going to hear from a friend. Last week, Amazon elevated two more women to its S-team. That makes the S-team three women out of 22 people. That is not a very good number. One of the women promoted is its fashion vice president, Christine Beauchamp. So, demographic questions aside, it seems like an interesting promotion. Bezos is taking further interest in the fashion sector. So, Scott, what did you do?
Scott Galloway
I spoke to Joanna. I did an in-the-field reporting.
Kara Swisher
Explain who she is.
Scott Galloway
Oh, Joanna Coles, she's a total gangster. She was the chief content officer for Hearst, a position that was amended for her before that. She was editor-in-chief of Cosmopolitan. She worked in television for a long time. And she's British, so everything she says sounds, you know, reasonably smart.
Kara Swisher
So, I'm a big fan of Joanna. I love Joanna Coles. She's one of my, she's also on the board of Snap. All right, let's go. Let's hear from Joanna Coles.
Joanna Coles
Well, I know Christine. She was at Ralph Lauren. She was at Ann Taylor. She's absolutely terrific. She's a great executive and it's excellent news for her. And clearly, Amazon wants to eat shops. It wants to finish off fashion. I do think though that fashion resistance will be that fashion is frequently an emotional purchase. And it's hard to imagine a less emotional shopping environment than Amazon. Right. I'm very interested in Verishop that was set up by Imran Khan, who used to be the chief strategy officer at Snap with his wife, Kate, who actually used to work for Amazon. And they've set up what they want to be an alternative to Amazon with the guarantee that what you buy is the real brand. So there's not it's not an open platform where anybody can sell you anything. But Christine Beauchamp is a very talented fashion executive. So I think the fashion world is very excited to see what she does. And it may be that they have to create a spinoff of Amazon that just becomes its own fashion brand. That's what I would do if I were them.
Kara Swisher
Where can we start, Scott? Please talk about this. And you had an interview on your other show, Professor Galloway's Office Hours, on your Section 4 YouTube channel. So what does this mean? Give me some more insight to this, Scott Galloway.
Scott Galloway
Well, so Luxury has watched what's happened to other categories on Amazon, and they've said similar to what television said. So you can imagine YouTube went to every station and TV broadcaster and said, hey, Modern Family, wouldn't it be great if we could bring you more eyeballs and raise your awareness? And put on YouTube the next day the funniest moments from Phil last night. And to their credit, the content or the television industry basically said, no, girlfriend, we've seen what you've done to every other media. We saw what you did to print, and we'd rather just not go there. And so you can't watch the greatest hits of Modern Family on YouTube.
And it was absolutely the right move for them to say, no, we're not going to diminish, cheapen, bastardize, and let you slice up our content in exchange, give you dollars and you give us back nickels. And the luxury industry has essentially said, you know, we just don't need to distribute or we don't want to distribute. It's kind of a one-way highway in terms of the relationship or economic power being transferred. And they largely, largely speaking, the luxury industry has not embraced Amazon as a point of distribution. Now, the question is what happens in a downturn when they're all really hungry.
Basically, Gilt was launched as a distribution channel by a recession. And that is the recession came, Gucci woke up, had $150 million in inventory, needed cash fast, and then Gilt showed up and said, I know, we'll sell this stuff at 60% off, but it'll be a membership-only thing behind the wall so you won't feel as bad about discounting it. And a bunch of luxury brands went on this new distribution platform called Gilt, and it launched Gilt.
Kara Swisher
Yep.
Scott Galloway
Then all of a sudden, when the economy got better, they started pulling off that distribution because they're like, we don't want non-aspirational distribution or anyone that discounts our product. The real test of luxury will be what happens when we hit a recession and Christian Louboutin or a variety of wonderful smaller luxury brands say, we need the cash. And these guys can flip on a switch and solve our cash problems overnight. So resist. What you're saying is resist, even if you need that. Don't do it, right?
Don't give in to Amazon. I think a lot of people use the term partner, but I've always said Amazon partners with a brand the way a virus partners with a host. I don't think you're going to find a lot of companies that would say, as an industry, we're better off with Amazon. I think most are like, okay, we've entered into a deal with the devil. Now there's just no getting out. We're addicted. They have so much power. We have no choice.
P&G made this enormous early investment in Amazon. They let Amazon into their warehouses, which must have really pissed off Target and Walmart. And people have been working with P&G for a long time. There are moments on the platform where P&G products are not available because the algorithms find products from Unilever or Clorox for a penny less, or the algorithm of user reviews and stockouts puts one above the other. Whole Foods or Amazon products. They've been accused of stealing IP from Allbirds, doing these Amazon Basics brand replicas. They'll do it in fashion. They've already tried with Away luggage.
It'll be interesting how quickly, because Joanna was talking about this emotional relationship you have with the brands you like. My kids have switched from Nike to Adidas, but they only want that. They have an emotional relationship with their clothes and their shoes. One of the reasons Amazon, fashion, and luxury are one of the few categories where Amazon has really tried hard and just hasn't figured it out is that the power of Amazon is algorithmically driven. It looks at best sellers, reviews, stockouts, makes millions of decisions, and promotes into that golden buy box. Amazon is now the second largest search engine in the world, number one for product searches. It's key that the algorithm puts your product up first.
But the thing about an algorithmically driven shopping experience is that a boot from six years ago that sold more pairs than any other shoe comes up first because it's a top seller. The thing about fashion and luxury is the primary value proposition is someone with better taste than you is looking into the future and saying, this is the hot shoe. You may not have known that, but you can trust me because I'm Joanna Coles, or I'm the chief merchant at Stuart Weitzman. An algorithmically driven decision model at Amazon, as opposed to a merchandising or creatively driven one—no algorithm is going to tell you to buy a Gucci bag. I mean, have you seen Gucci bags? They are just out there. But the creative director there is a genius and sets the tone.
So, what would you do if you were Christine Beauchamp? And who is their biggest competitor? Then we'll get to wins and fails.
Kara Swisher
What would you do if you were her? Just keep copying?
Scott Galloway
No, I don't think so. I think they have to take a page out of Alibaba's book. Alibaba has tried to be the luxury-friendly platform with T-Mall. They respect distribution. They respect pricing. They try not to discount. They provide more data and analytics back. Shopify is probably one of the few brands you're going to hear more about in 2020. Because they are transparent in terms of analytics, and they realize they have set up a partnership model. Unless there's fundamental change, and she's not going to get to make those decisions, she's either got to overwhelm the industry with capital or wait until a recession when people are desperate to go on. Then they get the lips around the crack pipe of revenues from Amazon and won't be able to put the pipe down.
Kara Swisher
How did you get this to crack? How did you get this to crack? Jesus Christ. Crack is whack. I don't know. I just love drug metaphors. I am more into drugs than anyone who does as few drugs as me. Anyway.
Scott Galloway
All right. Teenage boy.
Kara Swisher
All right, teenage boy.
Scott Galloway
All right, I got it. That's virtue. You're right. I think you're absolutely right. I think she's right about the emotion. This is an emotional thing and Amazon does everything by the numbers. They don't have creativity. Although some of their shows do, it's very hard for them to be hyper-creative. They are good at fast following. They're very much like Walmart in that regard. The planes are covered with the bodies of pioneers, and they'll come right on after by either copying or making a fast follow. That's what they're good at.
Kara Swisher
What do you think they should do? I think fashion will be tough for them except in the stuff that's easy to copy. Like, I'm going to buy Allbirds or I'm not going to buy those shoes. I don't want Allbirds, so that's fine. My kids are going to want the Adidas or they're not. You just can't create something like that. You have a relationship with fashion stuff in a way that you don't. Now, I don't dress at all, so I will take whatever stupid T-shirt.
Scott Galloway
Oh, so speaking of fashion, what she could do, but unfortunately Christina Bechhold would get in the way of this. What Amazon could and should do, if they could do it, would be to buy aspirational distribution and to buy Zalando. Because Zalando has played nice with luxury brands, and they would immediately gain distribution.
Kara Swisher
That's true. That's like the Whole Foods trick.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, that's interesting. But the problem is any kind of high-profile acquisition is going to get a ton of scrutiny, so they just make these little acquisitions of unknown companies in fulfillment. But I have had a fashion—I don't want to call it a nightmare, but something that embarrassed my son. I had to pick up my son at school, and I thought, well, I'm just picking him up in front of the school so I don't need to change. So I had on my pajama bottoms, and I sleep in any shirt I just grab. I grabbed this shirt I got at the Lesbians Who Tech conference. Do you know what it says across the front? Lesbro. It says Lesbro. I threw on my flip-flops. I'm wearing flip-flops, pajama bottoms, a T-shirt that says Lesbro. I'm on a conference call, so I have my big Bose headphones.
Of course, my son's not out front. So I have to go back to the field where he's playing soccer. I walk out onto the soccer field in lily-white, conservative Gulfstream, Florida. The place just stops. I yell, Alec. He looks at me, and then he looks away like a dog that's done something wrong and pretends like he doesn't see me. Anyway, my fashion is embarrassing.
Kara Swisher
I like that entire outfit. I like the entire outfit. I'm glad you showed off for them and didn't dress up.
Scott Galloway
Oh, my God.
Kara Swisher
By the way, it's like two degrees here on the East Coast. You're lucky to be in Florida wearing flip-flops and a Lesbians Who Tech T-shirt.
Scott Galloway
All right. Wins and fails, Scott Galloway. We'll see what happens with Amazon. They definitely have an uphill battle in that way. Wins and fails. I've been doing all the talking. You go first.
Kara Swisher
What are your wins and fails? I have a lot of wins and fails. This week, I think our democratic process going through, despite all the ridiculous lying by the Trump people and Bill Barr, once again doing something awful this week by looking like he's got his nose so far up Trump's butt that he's coming out his mouth. That's the fail. It continues to be the fail, that these people will do anything to stay close to Trump.
The biggest fail this week for me is Trump attacking Greta Thunberg and making a remark about her Asperger's, saying she should chill and she should smile more. It was like literally his wife is going, "Be better," or "Be nicer," or whatever the hell her stupid thing is, because it's meaningless. It's just appalling. He's an appalling person to attack a kid. He did it before with her. He's obviously jealous that she's on the cover of Time. That was irritating to me, but it wasn't shocking that Bill Barr and Donald Trump act terribly.
The win was, and I tweeted it, this video that Michelle Obama did. She went to a local school in Washington, D.C., for some Allen giveaway, but ended up giving stuff to this school. It was so meaningful, this video. It just made you go, oh, those people who are good to people. These kids got a new computer lab and a basketball court, and they got iPads. This group of kids in a terrible part of Washington, and this vice principal who's just amazing, just restores your faith in humanity. I know it was a movie trying to talk to my emotions, but it was like, oh my God, good people again. Seeing Michelle Obama and how thrilled the kids were to see her and hear her name. These kids knew who she was, were so happy. She's such a hero to them.
It was such a contrast to me. Those two things—they're just disgusting people. But there is great hope out in the world. These kids deserve the same. We could do that for every school district instead of just handing money to rich people. It was really quite a contrast. Thank you. That's my wins and fails. Merry Christmas, or happy holidays, or whatever you're supposed to say.
Scott Galloway
Okay. So my win was the show *Silicon Valley*. I thought they captured the gestalt of Silicon Valley in a real way. I think humor is so powerful. I thought they did a fantastic job. I learned from the show. You could tell that the consultants on the show really did their job. When they built into the storyline things like encryption or quantum computing, it felt accurate. I think a lot of people learned some of the nuance and some of the problems and upside of technology in a thoughtful, humorous way. A lot of us—they brought a lot of people like me and many others to Costco, was working on the show. Speaking of Twitter, he was involved in the campaign.
Kara Swisher
Back to you. What a shocker. It's been three minutes.
Scott Galloway
I'm just saying.
Kara Swisher
They did. You're so jealous this week.
Scott Galloway
Oh, God.
Kara Swisher
You should be jealous.
Scott Galloway
I am jealous. But that doesn't mean I'm wrong.
Kara Swisher
You should be jealous this week. That's fair.
Scott Galloway
You're not going to break me on this. I love myself.
Kara Swisher
There you go. I've always really loved myself.
Scott Galloway
There you go. I'll be honest with you. Forever.
Kara Swisher
You demonstrate that. You're self-actualized.
Scott Galloway
You're right. The conjoined triangles of success, the lawyer, the guy who played the lawyer, just down to everybody. Russ Hanneman. Gavin Belson was amazing. That guy was in that show *Big Love*, he played a Mormon pastor. Anyway, my win is *Silicon Valley*.
My loss, and this is going to sound very partisan being at NYU, but I think my fail is Cornell Tech. I was really excited about a third world-class university coming to Manhattan. I think it was a coup for Bloomberg. I thought he showed a lot of leadership and vision bringing a third university here. They were going to Roosevelt Island. But see, you said they're going to Roosevelt Island. That's really telling. That's my point. They've been there for three years. I taught there for a semester. I was super excited about it. The tech community in New York is either the second or third most robust, depending on the metric. It's been like a tree falling in the forest. You wouldn't know they're even here if you didn't know they're here.
I think it's because they've taken a traditional academic, slow, totally non-relevant research, uninspiring events approach. How can Cornell Tech not have the premier technology gatherings east of the Mississippi every year? Let's go over there. Let's take whatever you take to Roosevelt. What do you have to get?
Kara Swisher
Well, actually, maybe that's a better way to approach that. We should offer, or we would be interested in doing something at Cornell Tech, although NYU will say, what the fuck are you doing?
Scott Galloway
I was so excited about the potential. Think about the potential for a tech campus in New York. It just has so much potential.
Kara Swisher
We could do a stunt. We could put you in a cannon and shoot it.
Scott Galloway
No, no, no. The only stunt we're going to do over and over—
Kara Swisher
We could shoot you out of a cannon to Roosevelt Island into the seat. You and your magnificent hair, me in a poochie dress and high heels. Hello, Adam and Rebecca Newman. That's how we roll.
Scott Galloway
That's been cast. Cousin Greg is playing Adam Newman, not you. He's going to be great in that. Sorry, my friend. He's a really talented kid.
Kara Swisher
Anyway, my loss, and I feel like it's a little bit—I don't know if it's inappropriate, but I want to.
Scott Galloway
That's all right.
Kara Swisher
I don't think Cornell Tech is living up to their potential. And I think it could be an enormous good.
Scott Galloway
I love you saying, "I don't know if it's inappropriate." That's my favorite thing so far of this show.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, as if that ever stopped me before. Should we go?
Scott Galloway
Anyway, Cornell Tech, an offer out there. We would love to. Maybe we do a live Pivot at Cornell Tech. It could be an incredible asset for Manhattan.
Kara Swisher
Do it. Let's do it. We will do it. We will go there. However, we'll row across the East River, you and I together, a little rowboat. It'll be so safe and fantastic. Anyway, that's a great idea.
Scott Galloway
All right, Scott, predictions, and then we've got to get out of here.
Kara Swisher
I just have one prediction, and Joanna Coles got me thinking about this. I have some experience with this with my boys. I think in 2020, we're going to start hearing a lot more about the effects of pornography on young men. When I think about where people spend their time online, Amazon has massively disrupted retail. Facebook and Google have massively disrupted the media industry. It's kind of naive to think that the next largest category of time spent online—porn—isn't going to have tremendous disruptive impact.
I wonder what it's doing to relationships. I wonder what it's doing to young men's ability to establish relationships, to their perception of the role sex plays in a relationship. When I was growing up, my access to pornography was once a week or two weeks. I would sneak out my dad's *Playboy* and look at it for 20 minutes in the garage. That was literally the entire exposure. Then when cable TV came along, I would watch R-rated movies after my parents were asleep. Nowadays, they're finding that a large portion of teenage boys are spending somewhere between two and five hours a day watching hardcore pornography. And then all that other porn that's local people doing it themselves. Then it turns into revenge porn.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, you're right.
Kara Swisher
We're in the midst of the largest experiment on humanity ever conducted, and we have no idea what the outcomes are going to be. It's going to impact marriages, household formation. No male academic can really get into this because they're immediately seen as weird. Female academics don't seem to be that interested in it. So we have a dearth of real high-quality, evidence-based peer review research around it. I think it's bubbling up. A lot of the things we're seeing about young men failing, about relationships, about people getting married later, about some of the misogyny manifesting itself online—I think we're going to start reverse engineering into one of the biggest usage categories online, and that's porn. My prediction is that in 2020, we're going to start to see a lot more news about porn.
Scott Galloway
I'm surprised by this one. I like it. It's interesting because Representative Katie Hill wrote a piece for *The New York Times* this week talking about revenge porn. The title was "It's Not Over After All. I Overcame Desperation, I Felt, After Stepping Down from Congress. I'm Still in the Fight." Her ex put out kind of naughty pictures of her with another woman. She talked about her suicidal thoughts. It was really quite something about what she ended up doing. You should read it if you haven't. She decided to keep going. I don't think she should have stepped down from Congress, in my feeling.
Kara Swisher
I agree. I don't think she should have either. I think her and Al Franken, I think neither. I think she's the Al Franken of this generation. I think she absolutely should not have stepped down. The manner in which they went after her trying to slut-shame her—it would not have aged well. We needed her voice and we needed that issue to be more present about how ridiculous and oppressive it is. This isn't fucking old Spain. That was ridiculous. Anyway, I agree with you.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, but she talked about a contemplated suicide attempt that impacted this. It was really something. I was surprised to read it. These things degrade humanity, and it's also hard to resist at the same time, I think, in many ways. So you have boys. It appeals to the base instincts. We didn't take away my nine-year-old's iPad, but he was typing in things like "Harry Potter nude," which is pretty innocent. But the stuff that comes up is not innocent. I talk to him about it all the time. What does that do to a nine-year-old boy's brain? I wasn't exposed to anything like that. I talk to him about it almost continually. I talk about online porn. I say, that's not how women are. So far, so good. But it's definitely something you have to battle, especially how people consider women, how they look at women.
Kara Swisher
Well, for people out there, there's a seminal TED Talk by Cindy Gallop, who's been a thought leader around this issue, called "Make Love, Not Porn." She did a TED Talk about 10 years ago that was really—
Scott Galloway
Yep, Cindy's been at the front of it.
Kara Swisher
Again, *The Times* had a good piece this week as part of a series about these impacts about gaming and children and pedophiles. There's a reporter who's written all of them with other reporters. This week's was about video gaming being a hunting ground for pedophiles. Previously, you can't take things back on YouTube, porn, things like that. It's quite devastating, especially to children. It's worth a read. But you're right. Cindy Gallop's a great TED Talk to go to. Big issue. Scott, you surprised me. That's a really good prediction.
Scott Galloway
I love—it's weird. I bring out very maternal instincts in you. You say, "Shush, you're proud of me, you protect me." It's really strange. I feel like at any moment you're going to take away my iPad and then give me a ride to Little League practice.
Kara Swisher
No, I hate Little League. My son did it. It takes 900 hours to sit there and watch them make one hit. It's awful.
Scott Galloway
You know what's really wonderful, though? My boys are really marginal athletes, so it's all going to be over pretty soon.
Kara Swisher
Oh, really?
Scott Galloway
The worst thing in the world is when your kids are good athletes, because then you end up literally roaming the earth and sitting on a sideline.
Kara Swisher
Oh, my God. Lacrosse season starts soon. I'm so not looking forward to it. And now I have another kid who probably will be really athletic. I'm hoping piano or ballet.
Scott Galloway
Even worse. I hate all that stuff. But I go to it. I go to it and I clap.
Kara Swisher
Speaking of games, I'm about to interview Megan Rapinoe. What should I ask her besides her fantastic outfits?
Scott Galloway
Well, my question would be one word: "Next question?" What is she planning to do?
Kara Swisher
All right.
Scott Galloway
You know, what do all athletes do when their athletic career is over? I hope she doesn't end up on ESPN. She strikes me as very substantive and interesting and has strong leadership skills. What's next for her?
Kara Swisher
All right. I will ask her that. Anyway, it's time for us to go. We'll be back on Tuesday for more tech and business. How are you liking these twice-a-week things, Scott?
Scott Galloway
I think they're good. This was a very substantive show.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, so far it's okay, although it's a lot of work.
Scott Galloway
It's a lot of work.
Kara Swisher
I know. It's hard for you to yammer away for an hour.
Scott Galloway
One plus one equals one and a half, I think.
Kara Swisher
I think they're working out rather well. I hope our listeners do. Please let us know. If you're around this weekend and want to tell us what you think of the show, let us know by tweeting to us at #PivotPodcast with your thoughts on our second show and how you like it. If you like more is better or more is not better. Or email us questions at [email protected].
Today's show was produced by Rebecca Sinanis. Eric Anderson is Pivot's executive producer. Thanks also to Rebecca Castro and Drew Burrows. Make sure you subscribe to the show on Apple Podcasts, or if you're an Android user, check us out on Spotify. And frankly, wherever you listen to podcasts, tune in to Pivot. If you liked our show, please recommend it to a friend or an enemy. We don't care either way. Thanks for listening to Pivot from Vox Media. We'll be back next week for another breakdown of all things tech and business. Bye.