Main Topic: The podcast episode discusses various business and tech-related topics, including the impact of AI on companies, the latest earnings reports from Alphabet and Microsoft, and the potential merger between Paramount and Skydance.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Wins and Fails:
Podcast Intro Music
Narrator
So, your AI agents. They make the team that uses them more productive, right? But if they aren't connected to other agents, or your data, or your existing workflows, how productive can they really make your teams? Any business can add AI agents. IBM connects your agents across your company to change how you do business. Let's create smarter business. IBM.
As marketing channels have multiplied, the demand for content has skyrocketed. But everyone can make content that's on brand and stands out with Adobe Express. You don't have to be a designer to generate images, rewrite text, and create effects. That's the beauty of generative AI that's commercially safe. Teams all across your business will be psyched to collaborate and create amazing presentations, videos, social posts, flyers, and more. Meet Adobe Express, the quick and easy app to create on-brand content. Learn more at adobe.com slash express slash business.
Podcast Intro Music Ends
Kara Swisher
Yeah, stop chewing. Oh no, he just put something else in his mouth. We just said stop chewing and there he goes. All right, you ready?
Hi everyone, this is Pivot from New York Magazine and the Vox Media Podcast Network. I'm Kara Swisher.
Scott Galloway
And I'm Scott Galloway.
Kara Swisher
Where are you, Scott? You're eating grapes or something.
Scott Galloway
I'm in my favorite place, or my second favorite place in the world. I'm in the Faena Hotel in South Beach.
Kara Swisher
Oh, nice. What are you doing there?
Scott Galloway
I have a book event tonight. I was in Palm Springs for Stagecoach this weekend, and then I was in L.A., and then I was in New York.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, so tell me. How was Bill Maher? How'd it go?
Scott Galloway
You know, it was great. I felt really grateful. I liked the team there. I really liked the producers. It's so much fun for me. I went to UCLA. I get to invite my friends. They bring them backstage. They're totally cool to them. I get to rub my success in my friend's face. It's wonderful.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. Did you get a vest?
Scott Galloway
There's vests. There's vests.
Kara Swisher
You just had to do that, didn't you?
Scott Galloway
There's vests. I did not know there were vests. I gave it to Justin Theroux, my friend.
Kara Swisher
Oh, I finally went on a mandate with him last week. I'm going to steal him back. How was it? How was it?
Scott Galloway
Yeah, there's no way. He's as advertised. He's this really thoughtful, handsome guy.
Kara Swisher
Did you know he wrote Tropic Thunder?
Scott Galloway
Yeah, yeah. It's very impressive.
Kara Swisher
Yes, I'm aware of that because I am invested in our relationship. Anyway, do you have a gun show? Did you have a gun show with him, the two of you?
Scott Galloway
No, I would lose that. He's a different species. That guy is like...
Kara Swisher
So tell me how Bill Maher went in any case. How did that go?
Scott Galloway
I have trouble processing in the moment. I think it went pretty well. I haven't watched the show. But it felt pretty good. I was with Don Lemon, who I really like. Bobby Kennedy was on. I was hoping he would be on the panel, but he didn't come on the panel.
Kara Swisher
Oh, of course not. Yeah.
Scott Galloway
I met him. He's very handsome. He seems like a reasonable guy to me.
Kara Swisher
I don't... But he's not. But he's not. Okay. Let's just get that out of the way. I don't know. I watched his interview. I didn't think he did himself any favors, quite frankly.
Scott Galloway
No, but he never does. It doesn't really seem to matter. People just want an alternate, right? That's the thing.
Kara Swisher
How is LeMond? I don't care about RFK Jr. I think he's a crank.
Scott Galloway
D. LeMond? D. LeMond, yes. He's as advertised. He's a super nice guy. And never sit next to Don Lemon. I kept thinking when I saw the clips on YouTube, I'm like, Jesus Christ, I'm not that fucking ugly. And I'm like, well, no wonder I'm sitting next to Don Lemon.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, he's a handsome man.
Scott Galloway
But he and I hung out a little bit, which was really nice. It was very rewarding. Thank you for asking.
Kara Swisher
Oh, good. Anyway, we've got a lot to get to today, including what Alphabet and Microsoft's latest earnings say about the AI race. Interesting different things and more drama at Paramount. Boy, what a frigging mess that is. Plus, our friend of Pivot is Jan Shramek, CEO and founder of California Forever, the company that's trying to build that new community in Solano County, California. Looking forward to that discussion. He really wanted to come on here and talk to us about it.
Audio Clip Plays
President Joe Biden
I had a great stretch since the State of the Union. Well, Donald has had a few tough days lately. You might call it stormy weather. What the hell? Trump's so desperate, he started reading those Bibles he's selling. Then he got to the first commandment. You shall have no other gods before me. That's when he put it down and said, this book's not for me.
Audio Clip Ends
Kara Swisher
I thought he did pretty well. He did really well. He was very sassy and funny. It was a good opportunity. SNL's Colin Jost was the comedian of the night. He also took plenty of shots at Trump. But he also gave touching remarks about his grandfather who recently passed.
Audio Clip Plays
Colin Jost
My grandfather, a Staten Island firefighter, voted for you, Mr. President. He voted for you in the last election that he ever voted in. I mean, I'm sure someone else will vote twice in this election using his name, but that's just how the democratic machine works. He voted for you, and the reason that he voted for you is because you're a decent man.
Audio Clip Ends
Kara Swisher
So that's pretty good. I thought it was pretty good. The New York Times, for some reason, got all tetchy with Colin Jost. I thought he was good. He was very strong, and they got all tetchy maybe because of the Wordle joke, which was very funny. I thought it was—I went to a bunch of the parties. I went to a Puck party. I went to a Politico party. I went to an NBC party.
Scott Galloway
What was the best party? What party had the hottest people?
Kara Swisher
Oh, you know, hottest people was Washington. So I think that's it. Actually, there's some great look at people dressed. Some of the dress, they had a thing at the Washington Post of the dresses. And actually, some people look just fantastic. Some of these anchors like Abby Phillip and Rachel Scott and what's his name? Lester Holt looked really good. Anyway, there were a whole bunch of people, but it was, they were all good. There was one yesterday, a tea party at the British Embassy. I had been to an evening party there too. The food was the best of the British Embassy. I have to say there were crumpets. There was other things. And the night before there was curry. That was good. And I thought the Puck had a nice party. And then Axios had Jelly Roll at an event at the Organization of the American States. They were jelly rolling. And I saw Paul Ryan there listening to Jelly Roll. That was weird. I like Paul Ryan.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, he was interesting.
Kara Swisher
I said hi. It was good. It was really good. I actually thought Colin Jost was good. And it was nice. It was nice.
Scott Galloway
He was okay. I mean, he was okay.
Kara Swisher
What do you mean? They're never going to be like, Michelle Wolf was like amazing. But that's usually, but that's not what it is. He did a nice job. And I actually think a lot, it's interesting because a lot of people in the room thought it was excellent. Maybe playing it back didn't sound as well. So it just, you know, I think they're never going to be like... You played the nicest moment. The moment about his granddad was really, was very nice.
Scott Galloway
I don't care. I have trouble taking Colin Jost seriously. He looks like my paper boy. The guy looks 14.
Kara Swisher
Well, he was with Scarlett Johansson, his lovely wife.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. You know what it was? It wasn't that it was good or bad. He took it to a different dimension. The comedian's job is basically to be as insulting as possible but get away with it and to be as cutting and as biting. And that's difficult because it's become so politically charged. So the thing I like most about the frame through which he did this was he just took the temperature down. He was like, oh, I'm going to be civil and nice.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. As I think about it. I don't know. It was fine. It was actually very nice. It was apparently very tight. I didn't go to the dinner. I never go to the dinner. Anyway, it was nice to be around Washington. The weather turned out to be beautiful by Sunday. So anyway, it was lovely. It was a very nice time.
Next, the FTC is accusing Jeff Bezos and other Amazon executives of using disappearing message apps to conceal potential evidence relevant to antitrust. An FTC document alleges the executives opted to continue deleting messages about sensitive business and antitrust after receiving notice of an investigation. Bezos reportedly started using the app Signal to communicate with Amazon executives in 2019. This was soon after he was hacked, as you recall. Amazon says the claims are baseless and that it first disclosed the use of Signal to the FTC years ago. And Google got in a little jam with this, is deleting stuff. I suspect the answer is somewhere in the middle, but I don't know if it's that fishy they're using Signal. But, you know, they are a public company, so probably they shouldn't be using that. And then at the same time, he was hacked. So I don't know what to say. What do you think?
Scott Galloway
I think people in a professional setting have the right to secrets. You said this once, and I love it. You said that people have the right to have secrets. And now I just draw a bright line. I think if somebody wants to send personal or professional messages, they get to choose their medium of communication. And if a medium of communication deletes your messages, I think that's their right.
Kara Swisher
If they were personal, that's what the FTC is alleging. They were just plotting amongst and between each other.
Scott Galloway
Okay, but we're in national laws. If they send out something saying you're being investigated and you're part of a case, do not delete any potential evidence, that's a law. And if they did it after that, they have broken the law. But until there's a law that says anything that's quote unquote professional has to be on a digital platform that we can subpoena, they have the right to have disappearing messages.
Kara Swisher
One of the things that I recall in the very early days of Google in particular, they were very sloppy in their communications with each other, right? So was Microsoft back when, right? Because you didn't think, if you were typing something out on a letter, you're not sloppy the way you are online. And I think it just engenders a very sloppiness on the behalf of companies and what they say, right, that they shouldn't be saying. And it never goes and it's just there forever. Same thing with the Trump people and a lot of the stuff that goes back and forth. I think he's going to get hoisted by some of the communications. Now, he doesn't use email. It was interesting, his assistant was talking about she uses email and digital means for him, and probably because he thinks he's guilty all the time, so he knows he's like a mobster. But it's an interesting, it'll be interesting to see if they did this. I think what they have to focus in on is the case itself, the case itself. I'm not so sure there was tons and tons of secret information in this back exchange between people. And there is the excuse of him being hacked, so who knows? Who knows?
Scott Galloway
Yeah, I don't... I mean, I remember once we did, we're very analytically driven in my last cameo too, and we tried to do some analysis of who are the high performers and what do they have in common? And we found that it was three things. We found that women, we had a lot of young women who were just outperforming the men. And then two, they came from elite colleges, which you don't like to admit. And then three, they had had sports in the background. And immediately, someone in the firm goes, delete all these emails. Delete all these. It's like, well, at some point, when you're so paranoid, you have to delete every email, it reduces productivity. So I don't know. I'm starting to live that way. I'm deleting every email. I'm deleting every... and it's just sort of not every email, but when I get something from someone... We've got a lot of track record from you, Scott Galloway, we do. I do well pretty much everything. Everything I do is on tape now. But you do start to think that way when someone sends something about anything, you think, okay, does this need to be public record?
Kara Swisher
Well, it's interesting. Speaking of public record, just very briefly, Kristi Noem and the dog and goat killing is just splendid social media information. I don't know. I know. But I'm just thinking, do you have a thought upon that, what was happening there?
Scott Galloway
Like anyone who has a dog... I'm actually thinking... I am trying to eat less beef because I have this beast in my house. You've spoken of this.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, you've spoken of this.
Scott Galloway
I have this Great Dane. And this Great Dane will go in and get in bed with my 13-year-old to try and wake him up slowly. And when his parents come in, he's inclined to scream at them. And my dog will wait there, lay our Great Dane, will wait there, go in. And I mean, these are just such loving, beautiful, sensitive creatures, right? And so I thought, and then I've seen all these TikToks with people and their cows, and I'm like, okay, a cow can't be that different than a dog. And when I think about what we do to these animals in industrial food production, it's now got me thinking, maybe it wouldn't be a bad idea to start eating less beef. The fact that an individual would even be this insensitive to these such just beautiful beings. I mean, I can... I don't know, you had dogs growing up, right?
Kara Swisher
I did. Yeah, I do. Yeah. I mean, they're just, they're just, it's, they bring so much joy. They're such emotional, wonderful creatures. I don't know. I just think this, okay, character matters. At a minimum, we want decent people. And it's like, it just outed her as like, you're not an especially decent person. Now she's saying she's being irresponsible. She's trying to, she's really screwed herself. Honestly, the way she told it, acting like it was fine. There's nothing fine about what she did. It's just stupid. It's just dumb. She could have given the dog away, all kinds of stuff. And then she said, oh, well, we killed the horses. And who knows? It just seems so ridiculous. It's, it's, she's one of the funny things though, I have to tell you, social media is just all the governors saying to do a picture of yourself with a dog that you didn't shoot in a gravel pit, which was like Governor Whitmer did it. Governor Walt started it. All these governors are taking pictures doing that. So it became kind of a social media phenomenon. And then my favorite one was, why is nobody talking about the goat? Cause she also shot a mean goat, which was kind of, in any case, you're right.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, I don't... Yeah, I thought this would affect you, as you're such a dog man.
Kara Swisher
Well, I can't even, it feels just so out of bounds. I don't, this to me, anyone who has a dog and sees the joy and the love and the affection, and then hears this story... Is this someone you want figuring out child welfare? Yeah.
Okay, let's get to our first big story. Scott, you predicted last week that the Alphabet and Microsoft Q1 earnings would be amazing, and you were right. Let's start with Alphabet. The company reported revenue of $80.5 billion last week, a 15% increase from a year earlier and the fastest growth since early 2022. Profits climbed 36% to $23.7 billion, well above analysts' estimates. Alphabet also greenlit its first ever dividend, as well as a $70 billion buyback. Stock buyback, that's interesting. The company's market close value closed above $2 trillion level for the first time on the heels of all that news.
Microsoft also had strong numbers with their Q1 earnings. Revenue was up 17% from a year earlier. Net income grew 20%. Microsoft is crediting some of the success with its investment in AI. The company said sales of its cloud computing product, Azure, grew 31 percent, very strong, in the last year, with a fifth of that coming from generative AI services. So what do you think? And, you know, Facebook got slapped a little bit because of the spend on AI. And these guys got benefited. There was a great article in the journal about this. And just briefly, Snap had its latest earnings. Revenue was $1.
2 billion in the first quarter, a 21 percent jump from a year ago. Daily active users rose 10% to 422 million. I think they've stabilized. They'll probably benefit from the TikTok, whatever happens to TikTok. But thoughts on all these and start with the two biggies, obviously.
Scott Galloway
Well, you know, my stock pick for 2024. I mean, do you remember what it was?
Kara Swisher
You don't really follow me. I don't. I don't. I don't care about stock. What was it?
Scott Galloway
Alphabet. It was Alphabet. Yeah. Look, they're firing on all cylinders. It's a monopoly. Always bet on up and to the right with these companies. They own 93%, and also to their credit, their cloud business is doing really well. It's really well managed. I think that the scare from AI has been good for them. I think they've been looking at tightening costs. They have, in my opinion, the premier data set for AI. They not only have the most human capital, but with access to your calendar, with access to your video habits, with access to your email, they're just going to, in my opinion, they're going to be able to do a bunch of very boring things that will move the needle from a share. I think they'll be the first real company that brings kind of AI into every day. It's already there. When I was using it, I searched for something and they had a summary of everything at the top of my search. It wasn't the search results. It actually... I forgot what I was asking about. I think it was how do you integrate something into something. And they had the answer right there. I didn't have to click in anywhere.
Kara Swisher
It was interesting, but go ahead. But I mean, the thing that was also interesting is the announcement of a dividend and a stock buyback. Yeah. What do you think about that?
Scott Galloway
Well, it's interesting. I think they realized that they can't make acquisitions because they're under so much FTC scrutiny. And basically, to a certain extent, when you issue a dividend or do a stock buyback, you've kind of said, we're producing more cash than we know how to deploy. And that's a sign that a stock has kind of grown from being a teenager to an adult. I think this is directly a function of their CFO, who is an adult. But it kind of signals a recognition. They're no longer a growth company or a teenager, but they need to start returning capital. They're moving in the Microsoft direction. But they're, I mean, Jesus Christ, their earnings were up 62%.
Kara Swisher
What about Microsoft? And both of them benefited in the way Facebook didn't on the stock appreciation.
Scott Galloway
Well, okay, Microsoft revenue was up 17%. Both companies saw their cloud businesses accelerate. The Microsoft DPS is up 20%. Their cloud revenue reached $35 billion, up 23%. And then now about two-thirds of Fortune 500 companies use Azure OpenAI service, and almost 60% use Copilot. So, I mean, these...
Kara Swisher
But why did the shares of Microsoft and Alphabet spike while Metas fell, even though they were talking about similar investments? Because this is going to be multi-trillion dollar investments.
Scott Galloway
Because both Microsoft and Alphabet have figured out ways, their path to monetizing AI seems pretty obvious because they, one, they're starting from a lower base and Meta's acceleration, Meta's at 4x. The reason why I think Meta, everyone's talking about Meta's stock decline. Okay, now it's only up 410% in the last 18 months. One, I think the stock had just gotten out a little bit over its keys and the market was looking to check it back a little bit. But also, I wonder if it's PTSD. The last time Mark had a big vision for the future and said, we're going to spend a lot of money, it was the metaverse and the headset. And that was literally, I mean, at some point, someone's going to acknowledge that it's been a fucking disaster. It didn't make any sense. So when they hear him going all in on AI and saying they're going to be the biggest spender on GPUs, I think the market has a little bit of PTSD around Mark's big visions. Whereas it feels like Satya, who is now the largest investor in AI in history, and has already been able to monetize it with Copilot, Bing is a thing again, and Google with their cloud service and Azure.
Kara Swisher
I don't know. I think you're 100% right. We don't know what kind of business Mark can make from all his data. And then if Google signs a deal with Apple, that'll send it up. There's a lot of discontent at Alphabet, whether Sundar is really being as aggressive as he needs to. But I think he's one of these plotters that tends to get there. There's a lot of plotters that do really well. I would say, you know, like Satya, Andy Jassy, I have a feeling they're going to be better. Tim Cook was seen as that and did an amazing job. I think some of these second-gen CEOs are much better suited for the next phase of these companies, if you think about it. And I'm using the term plotter in a negative way, but it's not. I don't mean it that way. They just, they sort of are like, da-dum, da-dum. So I'll be interested to see who the CEO of Meta is someday who's going to take all this and turn it into something probably more valuable even. God, who knows.
And also the little engine that kind of continues to show that it maybe can is Snap. Their shares were up 28%.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, good product. Revenue up 21%. That's a big deal. Also, I just want to highlight Snap had this product that basically gave you a visual depiction of where you lie in your friend's world in terms of currency. And it ended up that it was really upsetting kids to find out that, oh, actually, I'm not very good friends with this person. I don't play a large role in their life. And they got rid of it.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, they do that. They move fast on their stuff. They had an AI problem. They changed it right away. He's a very – if I had to give most improved CEO as a person, I would give it to him 100%. He's a very thoughtful person now in a way. And, you know, he makes a good product. It's a really good – it's not huge. If I was one of these big companies, I'd buy Snapchat. It's such a good product. And the people love it. My kids still use it regularly. They like it. It's their phone. It's their telephone. I don't know what else to say. You know what I mean? It's their communications product. And then they consume elsewhere, whether it's on Reddit or YouTube. I would say those three things for young people are the three, the troika of popularity. And a lot of kids use Instagram and TikTok obviously, but in any case.
But these, I mean, just some numbers here. Microsoft, Meta, and Alphabet have spent more than $32 billion on data centers and other capital expenses in just the first three months of the year.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, they're going to own everything. No one else can keep up with that. No one can keep up. Microsoft also noted they plan to spend $14 billion quarterly on AI infrastructure, citing early returns from services. Satya Nadella is a badass, I'll tell you. So these guys have said, these guys, I mean, this is the difference. They're like, AI is working for us and we're going to lean into our advantage. What's our advantage? We have more money than anyone else. Whereas Meta said, oh, I'm not afraid to spend a lot of money even before I've connected the dots around how it's going to help us. And the market said, okay. I think what the market was hoping for from Facebook was he was going to say, oh, I've laid off another 20% of my people and my earnings are about 300%.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. Yep. Yep. Yep. Although his ad business is doing great. His ad business is doing great, as you know, in that regard.
All right. Let's go on a quick break. When we come back, Paramount makes a big move in the midst of merger talks, and we'll speak with Jan Schrammeck about what exactly he's building in the farmlands of Solana County near Vacaville.
Break Music
Narrator
Support for Pivot comes from LinkedIn. From talking about sports to discussing the latest movies, everyone is looking for a real connection to the people around them. But it's not just person to person. It's the same connection that's needed in business. And it can be the hardest part about B2B marketing, finding the right people, making the right connections. But instead of spending hours and hours scavenging social media feeds, you can just tap LinkedIn ads to reach the right professionals. According to LinkedIn, they have grown to a network of over 1 billion professionals, making it stand apart from other ad buys. You can target your buyers by job title, industry, company role, seniority skills, and company revenue, giving you all the professionals you need to reach in one place. So you can stop wasting budget on the wrong audience and start targeting the right professionals only on LinkedIn ads. LinkedIn will even give you $100 credit on your next campaign so you can try it for yourself. Just go to linkedin.com slash pivotpod. That's linkedin.com slash pivotpod. Terms and conditions apply. Only on LinkedIn Ads.
Not all journalism is the same. Take The Guardian. Our coverage has something unique. Fierce independence. Nobody owns us or tells us what we can and can't say. So we're free to report the whole picture. We connect what's happening in Washington to the rest of the globe, expose corruption wherever we find it, and give fresh perspective on everything, from wellness and soccer to culture, the climate, and more. Read, watch, and listen to The Guardian for free at theguardian.com.
Break Music Ends
Kara Swisher
Scott, we're back. Paramount is parting ways with CEO Bob Bakish. The company announced Bakish's departure on Monday. All this is happening as Paramount and Skydance continue merger negotiations. The two are on exclusive talks until May 3rd. If the deal goes through, Skydance intends to name its CEO David Ellison to run Paramount, according to CNBC. Redstone reportedly wanted Bakish out before Paramount's carriage negotiation with Charter Communications. Impact we'll see on a merger. Skydance apparently proposed a revised offer on Sunday that would give non-voting shareholders a premium in the merger. They needed to do that, that's for sure. I don't know if the CEO drama matters. We're recording this episode a few hours before Paramount reports its Q1 earnings. Any thoughts? And this seems like unnecessary drama. It happening... I ran into a lot of CBS people this weekend and they're losing their minds. I was like, they don't care about you, CBS. I was like, CBS isn't really the game here. But thoughts?
Scott Galloway
This is a company in sheer chaos. Board members resigning. The CEO doesn't leave in the midst of an acquisition. I mean, when you're about to do a deal, you keep everybody happy. It's like, okay, we don't need moving parts here. We don't need any reason to give the acquirer the ability to take the bid price down. We need to pretend we get along. We need to speak with one voice. Board members resigning? The CEO leaving in the midst of a deal? Sherry is clearly, quite frankly, demonstrating what I would argue is every rich parent's fear that their kid ends up being an entitled jerk. Like, she's clearly an agent of chaos. She wants a different price for her shares. The board is like, that's not, I'm not cool with that. I'm going to resign in the midst of an acquisition.
Kara Swisher
Well, they're worried about litigation, presumably, correct? I mean, that's really...
Scott Galloway
Yeah, but they're the board. I mean, this is total chaos.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, you don't want to be. There's a big story. It's right now on the front page of the Wall Street Journal's, on the front page and also the top. "A media heiress's bid to sell sets off mayhem, mayhem inside pyramids." That's not good. That's not good. And she wants to cash out so that she can, she has an interest in Israel. She wants to do other things, right? And she knows this is in her area of expertise. I mean, this is not what you want. This is not what you want at all. And I think, you know, it's already, you know, as you call it all the time, these companies are all melting icebergs, right?
And so you're in the midst of that, too. I mean, this story really is not what you want. So when David Ellison, CEO of Skydance Media, and the son of billionaire Larry Ellison, raised the idea of a merger, Redstone was ready to hand over the media empire her family had controlled for nearly four decades. If only it were that easy. And then it goes on, ay-yi-yi. So what happens here? What happens? Oh, I've gotten this wrong. I thought it was going to be Apollo. Now it looks like it's going to be Skydance. Here's the problem: he's got to give the non-voting shareholders more money, that's for sure. Which means the economics here are probably very problematic going forward. But go ahead.
Scott Galloway
It's an automatic lawsuit when it's like, "Oh, because Sherry has leverage, we're going to pay her $30 a share, but all the other people on the back of the car get $20 a share?" And also, the board members, who are pretty thoughtful people, have probably said, "My job is to represent all shareholders." When you try to run roughshod over us and create this Frankenstein-like deal that cedes advantage to you and takes capital away from the other 80% of shareholders, we're not going to allow it. And she's clearly pushed back, and they've resigned from the board. Here's the bottom line: what she doesn't get is chaos does nothing but cede value to the non-chaotic acquirer.
Kara Swisher
Right, right, 100%. And one of the things, this is really interesting. When they were trying to sell off Showtime, Redstone held out hope that a big buyer, maybe a technology giant, would emerge to take the whole company off her hands, including the fast-deteriorating cable channels. That didn't happen. The hope for any company in this space is that Apple will come out and buy them, but that's not a strategy, said Robert Fishman, an analyst at Moffitt & Nathan's. I think that kind of says it all. That's what they were hoping. I know they're hoping, but here's the thing: Tim Cook is like, "I don't want to get involved in that bullshit. I don't want to have to deal with a rich kid who clearly doesn't understand her responsibility to shareholders, and the CEO just left, and a bunch of board members who are lawyering up, and another billionaire son trying to..." The Ellison kid strikes me as very thoughtful and very smart. The Apollo folks are grown-ups. Tim Cook's like, "Life's too short."
Scott Galloway
Well, it's also a comma to them.
Kara Swisher
It was so interesting because the CBS people are like, "Well, who's going to buy us?" I'm like, "I don't know. Nobody." Like some hedge fund. I literally was like, "You're not the game anymore in a lot of ways." A lot of these networks are not. I was talking to ABC people. I'm like, "That's not the focus right now," especially these tech companies. And in a weird way, if David Ellison wins here, it values his company at a ridiculous amount. The numbers they're putting out are very enthusiastic, I would say, of what they're going to do, which is always a problem in Hollywood. When you say, "I'm going to go from $30 million to $4 billion," and you're like, "Oh, okay." I think one of the things is, when they were talking about the Ellison group, and I do like David, I've interviewed him, and he's a very talented maker of those big blockbusters. I said, "You know, Larry Ellison is going to own you now. That's who's going to own you." Larry Ellison is the owner of CBS, if this happens, ultimately. So I was like, "Put that in your pipe and smoke it." Anyway, we'll see. Keep in mind, this company has been in play for the better part of a year.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, more, because it was pieces we were going to get sold off to, if you remember.
Kara Swisher
But go ahead.
Scott Galloway
When a company's in play, it usually elevates the stock price because typically someone has to come in and pay a premium. Okay, Paramount's off. I believe it's off. The stock has dropped nearly 50% in the last year because people are worried that Sherry and all the moving parts here are going to result in a deal not getting done from the only two people who have invested so much time and energy in trying to make this deal happen. If one of them drops out, there's a decent chance one of them goes, "Thanks, we're folding our tent. We can't figure this out." Then she's negotiating unilaterally with the only buyer in the world, which is going to cede a ton of advantage to the acquirer.
This is what Sherry and the folks in media and journalists covering media refuse to acknowledge: they are now the Yellow Pages. There are a lot of people who still read the Yellow Pages. There's a shocking number of homes that get a big fat book on the doorstep and use it to find a plumber or a locksmith. It's fewer and fewer homes, and it's not the people you want to reach. I don't mean to sound snarky. I didn't even know CBS was still around. I'm trying to think of the last time I had the CBS logo anywhere near anything I ever did of any importance. It's too bad because they are very talented journalists.
But it's like saying they're pilots. They're very good at what they do, but they're working for Pan Am in the 70s.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, they've got to rethink. That's what I was telling a lot of these people. I was like, "You just have to rethink it. It doesn't mean it's over. It's just another business." It doesn't mean you have to die.
Scott Galloway
No, no, it's not that they have to die. One of my best investments ever was in a Yellow Pages company, Dex Media. I was doing great. A guy named Joe Walsh, really talented CEO, and a really talented investor named Jason Mudrick. But here's the thing: we realized we were no longer teenagers. We were in a business in structural decline. So we're going to manage it well. What does that mean? We acquired other Yellow Pages companies, and then we look for efficiencies, which is a nice way of saying we laid off people. As long as you can cut costs faster than the business is declining, these companies hemorrhage cash.
But you have to acknowledge you're no longer a teenager, that you're a baby boomer going into your retirement. Whoever ends up with this thing, I think, is actually going to make a lot of money because they will go acquire other distressed cable assets. They will be adults. They will stop the bullshit of "Oh, we're 18 again" and pumping their face full of fillers and human growth hormone. They'll say, "No, we're going to make Nana and Pop-Pop comfortable. We are going to rationalize this business through cost cutting and consolidation." As long as you can cut costs faster than the decline in the business, you make money.
Kara Swisher
You can also do things with the content assets. I always think if you're a great story, there's always a way to experiment around the edges of what's interesting at the right cost. I literally was saying to every one of these TV people, "Let me give you a quick lesson. Costs need to meet revenues, like be less than revenues. That's really pretty much where you are. I don't know why you earn millions of dollars. What's your value?" It's interesting. One of the other things I'll read from this story, because it's quite good in the Journal: "Redstone, who thought scale would help the company thrive in the Netflix-dominated media world when she reunited Viacom and CBS, merged the two companies, even though people said not to.
Redstone would have been better off if she had sold the entire company or pieces of it back when she took control," said Chris Marengi, co-chief investment officer at Gabelli Funds, which is Paramount's second voting shareholder. She did have a chance to sell it if she hadn't merged the companies. It was worth a lot more. There was interest from Apple and Paramount. There was interest from AT&T and CBS. I'm sure Ted Sarandos apparently had expressed interest in the studio, didn't want to do that. There was a moment where they could have done well here. But we'll see what happens. Everybody hold on.
David Ellison is not going to have a nice time either. Up and to the right is not where these companies are headed.
Scott Galloway
Except if your dad is Larry Ellison, I guess that's something you don't have to worry about quite as much as other people. But he still does. He's a very good business person. So he's got to be thinking, he doesn't want to be known as the person who spent all his dad's money, presumably.
Kara Swisher
I don't know. I'd like to be known as that person. Would you? I'd be so good. I stayed at Larry Ellison's resort in Palm Springs. The sunset, it's spectacular.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. That guy's enjoying himself.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. If this doesn't happen, oy, oy, oy. She's going to have to merge it into another entity. She's going to have to carry on business as usual. The annual advertising sales thing is going to get underway soon. Who's going to go on this board? Who's going to run the thing?
Scott Galloway
You and I.
Kara Swisher
What if you're... there are a bunch of talented people in the CBS newsroom. You don't think they're going to start returning calls from other places? This is chaos. It's total chaos.
Scott Galloway
Sure. Get it together. Anyway, we'll see.
Kara Swisher
All right, let's bring in our friend of Pivot. Jan Sramek is the CEO and founder of California Forever. His company, with the help of some Silicon Valley billionaires, has acquired 62,000 acres in Solano County, California, which is north and slightly east of San Francisco, over the last few years with a goal of building a new community. Welcome, Jan.
Jan Sramek
Thank you. It's good to be here.
Kara Swisher
So we've wanted to have you on for a while. We have so many questions. Scott particularly has a lot of questions. But there's been a lot of mystery around California Forever. I need to explain exactly what you're planning. I get a sense of why it was secret at the beginning because you were buying up about 62,000 acres in this area just northeast of San Francisco, centered in Solano County. So talk a little bit about what you're doing for people who don't know.
Jan Sramek
We are trying to get California to build again and solve this problem that we have. It's still the center of innovation. It's still this economic engine for the whole country. But it's the first time in the history of the country where people are moving out of a place like that. We're doing that by building a new community in Solano County, about an hour north of San Francisco. In some sense, this is the oldest kind of business model in the world. We run out of houses. We should find some land that is not prime farmland, that is not sensitive ecological habitat, and build a complete community there. What's different is we're not building a subdivision, we're building a complete community. We're building something that someone who grew up in an old neighborhood like Noe Valley or the Marina, built a hundred years ago, would recognize: a complete community with homes and apartments and schools and shops and jobs and churches. We believe this can be a really unique economic engine for Solano County, which is a part of the Bay Area that has been left out of the prosperity that's happened here over the last 20 years.
Kara Swisher
Most cities just happen, they just sort of occur. Then cities build on top of cities. That's the whole concept: Rome has 10 different versions of itself depending on the era. Creating something from nothing, a lot of cities that do this in history have not worked out well. In Brazil, I was thinking of lots of different things. They've been trying to create the perfect city. Why do you think it'll work by just creating it out of nothing, where people weren't naturally going to build themselves or settle themselves?
Jan Sramek
First of all, in America, it's a fairly young country. Almost all cities are new cities. We have really good examples of cities that were started by a person or a company that turned out to be spectacular. Some of our most beloved cities in America were started this way: Savannah, Georgia, Philadelphia, Irvine in Southern California. We have a lot of really good examples of places that were basically started by a company. The other part of it is we're building in an area that people have said before should be built. The U.S. Commerce Department, the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, the Association of Bay Area Governments all said in the 50s, 60s, and 70s that sometime in the 2020s, we are going to run out of space in the Bay Area and we should build somewhere.
They all concluded that this was basically the best place to build. There's a lot of precedent for why this would happen. The planned cities that have failed, I think they failed for two reasons. I spent two years before I started working on this going back and reading the history of all of these projects, Brasilia and every project you can name. They failed in one of two ways: either people were building them in a place where there was no demand, which is not the Bay Area, or the developers came in with some kind of singular vision they were going to impose on the city, and it was going to be this perfect master plan.
Our approach is very, very different. It's very similar to how a place like San Francisco or New York were built, or indeed locally, Rio Vista or Benicia or Vallejo. You lay down a street grid and you do a really good job doing that. Then you think of the city as a platform. You don't say the houses are going to be beige and they're going to have these windows and this is where the residential is going to go and this is where the small houses will go and this is where the big houses will go. Instead, you do the bare amount of correct planning in the beginning, and then we let the city emerge out of that.
A lot of different people and builders and architects and companies and residents come and they build their lives. Cities are this unique invention where, particularly in the society we live in today, and there are challenges now, but I think cities are still a place where people with a lot of different values can come together and build something really special. Out of that disagreement and chaos and conflict, something really special emerges. That's what we're trying to do here.
Scott Galloway
Nice to meet you. I want to try and describe the tension around what I think some of the questions you're facing are. When I first heard about this, I love the idea of creating massive housing so that young people finally have their shot. I think that slowly but surely, homeowners have weaponized local governments to restrict housing permits. The American dream, if that's buying a home, is increasingly sequestered from young people. So I like the innovation. I like the idea that they're doing something similar in Florida where they're incorporating a city. Tons of new housing units. I love that.
The thing that sent chills down my spine was when I read some of the comments from Balaji Srinivasan. I think people are worried: is this a new techno-neoliberalism where people who are very blessed want to start their own, want to basically secede from the nation, want to create their own government? Everyone has the right to create local politicians. But my question is, is this rooted in opportunity for young people that haven't participated in the spoils that a lot of these people have enjoyed? Or is it a vision for a different type of society, which quite frankly scares me a little bit? Can you walk us through that?
Kara Swisher
I'm going to put some context. Scott was referring to a former Andreessen Horowitz partner. This guy is calling for something like tech Zionism. He said his vision is to ethnically cleanse San Francisco liberals. He has some scheme around colored shirts that people wear. It's demented, actually. But a lot of tech people are trying to take over San Francisco government with donations and their own mayoral candidates, which is their right to do so, although some of the things that pop out of their mouth are just so heinous and stupid at the same time, which is very hard to do. So talk about this, because a lot of people feel like, given some of your investors, which I think does include Marc Andreessen, who is a big backer of California Forever, there's a connection to a movement that wants to build a place where tech elite can live under their own rules, or the idea that you're trying to do a different kind of governance, new kinds of governance. I know Mike Moritz, who has been an investor, has talked about that, the idea of a new kind of governance. So perhaps separate yourself from that or not, or just say what we're trying to do here.
Jan Sramek
No, I mean, I think we're not trying to do any of that. I think there's a lot of baggage that tech has created in building new cities that unfortunately we've been on the receiving end of. My interest in this from the beginning was very simple. I really care about the built environment. I really think that walkable, dense places are special. I think walkable cities have amazing impacts on the sense of community and creativity and human health and knowing your neighbors and all of these things. For me, the primary interest has always been, how do we build more housing so there's more opportunity?
And then how do we make the place walkable? If you look at these old neighborhoods like big parts of San Francisco or Georgetown or the West Village, it's clear that a huge proportion of Americans love them, but they've become these oases for the rich because we stopped building them. These walkable communities today, working families just can't afford them. For me, it was about building a place like that. I have very little interest in innovating on, in particular, two things that tech has done. The first one is this tech libertarian kind of floating cities, network states, and so on. I have zero interest in any of it.
Balaji is not an investor. There's also this kind of smart city component of it, what some other people have tried to do. I have zero interest in that as well. We're building a place that, from that perspective, is really, really boring. We're building a place where if all we did was build a great combination of some of these old neighborhoods I mentioned, like Noe Valley and Marina and Mission and West Village and parts of Philadelphia and Georgia...
Kara Swisher
That are presumably more affordable, correct?
Jan Sramek
More affordable, absolutely. They are expensive because we don't have very many of them. If all we did over the next 30 or 40 years was build something that people looked at in 50 years the way they look at those places, I would be over the moon. We don't need to do anything else.
Kara Swisher
But you are going to get saddled with that tech thing because of some of your investors. They're among the wealthiest people on Earth. Some of them have their nonsensical "I'm moving to Australia" ideas. Some of them, "I'm going to go into space" — that's a Jeff Bezos thing, the floating city. That's his dream of the world. Of course, in sci-fi, that's always a bad dream for most people and a good dream for rich people. So you're going to carry that baggage no matter what, given your investors. One. Two, they feel anti-democratic in a lot of ways. So presumably the governance here, even when Mike and I happen to like Mike Moritz talking about new kinds of governance, presumably democracy is at the center of that, correct? It's not. What's a new kind of governance? I don't even understand.
Jan Sramek
I think what Mike was referring to in that email, I think that's an old email from 2017. It was new kinds of governance when it comes to making it easier to build.
Kara Swisher
I see.
Jan Sramek
The thing that we've been obsessed about since the beginning is, why does it take two years to get a permit to build a small apartment building in San Francisco?
Kara Swisher
I just added a door. It took me forever in San Francisco. But go ahead.
Jan Sramek
Exactly. If you look at the ballot measure that we proposed, the only innovation on governance that's in it, the only one, is it says it should be easy here to build buildings. We're going to do an environmental impact report on the whole community. We're going to study all of the impacts.
Kara Swisher
Safety is important because it's San Francisco.
Jan Sramek
Exactly. We said, as long as you're building something that fits in here, you should be able to get a building permit in 60 days. That's the only kind of governance innovation that we have.
Kara Swisher
But the governance is democracy, correct? It's not like you're going to innovate on some "let's have a king" or "let's have Marc Andreessen be king for a day" or whatever. Let's not have him be a king any day. When you were doing this at the beginning, you had to be very secretive. There was a lot of back and forth with local landowners. Did you talk about why you did it that way? Presumably because you didn't want the prices to go up like crazy, like "Oh, rich people are here with their money bags." You also filed a lawsuit accusing 40 Solano farmers of price fixing their land, which they've denied. So talk a little bit about that, because you've got to get the support of the community and the elected officials moving forward.
Jan Sramek
On buying the property quietly, we did the same thing that, for example, Disney did when they were buying the property in Florida for Disney World. It's standard practice. For us, it was partially about the prices, but it was also that we felt you could design a really great community here, but someone had to basically control a large amount of the land so you could place things correctly. For example, one of the things we did in the ballot measure is we're doubling the security buffer around the Air Force Base here. We would not be able to do that if there were 40 different landowners trying to build a project in the community.
Kara Swisher
Just so people know, there's a big Air Force Base nearby.
Jan Sramek
Right, exactly. One of the biggest challenges for the Air Force Base is, number one, the people who work there are struggling to afford to live here. Number two, their spouses often commute one and a half hours every day to Palo Alto because there are very few jobs here. We've had an amazing response from many of the people who serve on the base saying, "Actually, this is the best thing that's happened to the base." On the lawsuits, the main thing I would say is we've settled the majority of them. There was a recent ruling in the case from the court that basically said there is evidence that this happened, but we've been very reasonable on settling it. We hope to be able to put that behind us soon. We just want to build something.
Scott Galloway
We don't want to build something. [Laughter] So first off, I find your comments really heartening. I also want to point out that masking your identity when you're a buyer is common practice. NYU does the same thing. For a lot of reasons, you don't necessarily want the seller to know who you are. It gets our greed glands going. Young people have been held out from the American dream of buying a home. What do you envision? What does victory look like in 10 years out in terms of the price of the home, the amenities? Paint the vision for why this will be a net positive for society.
Jan Sramek
That's a really good question. In terms of the win for young people, affordability was a really big criterion for us from the beginning. We designed the whole community with that in mind. The biggest component of that is, if you look at what developers are actually building today, we've basically stopped building starter homes. That's a big part of the problem. If you talk to people who bought a home in the Bay Area in the 70s or 80s or 90s, their first home would be 1,000 square feet, 1,200 square feet, kind of three bedroom, one bathroom, small single family home. Then they would build equity and grow in it and eventually trade up.
For all kinds of reasons in the real estate business, we've stopped building those homes. The community we proposed is unusual in that California has a standard that says "affordable by design." It basically says if you can build a walkable community where you have row houses and ADUs and small apartment buildings, they can be affordable by design. You can actually build units that you can buy that are not deed restricted from the beginning. I think we would have homes or apartments starting at probably $400,000, which even by Solano County standards is really affordable. You can't buy a new home here for $400,000.
We do that by really innovating on what we build and the density and using the land much more wisely in a much more compact footprint.
Kara Swisher
So you want to get this built, presumably. What do you think the timing is on this and how it's happening? Is there a chance it wouldn't happen and that it couldn't happen? What do you need to succeed to go forward? Certainly there is interest in more housing in California. That said, a lot of people are in fact moving back. All those people who insulted California on their way out are now back because AI is back. You can see it in San Francisco and the Palo Alto area. There's real growth. Google killed it. They haven't moved anywhere. There's a little more excitement around living in California than there was a year ago, or two years ago when you started this. What are the prospects and what's your biggest challenge? If you had to go back and repair a mistake you made, what would it be?
Yeah, I mean, first of all, I started this eight years ago, not two years ago. I've been working on this for eight years. And so we've been through the whole cycle in California of excited, people are leaving, people are coming back. I think to your point of people are coming back to California, that makes the need for this even more prescient. Because if the AI boom continues and the salaries continue in the Bay Area, that's going to just increase the pressure on the housing market. And it's going to be harder and harder and harder for working families to stay in San Francisco or in Palo Alto. And so I think the AI boom is just another huge reason for why this needs to happen because the Bay Area needs more housing. Otherwise, it's just going to be an oasis of the rich.
In terms of what we would do differently, I think we would have liked to introduce the project to the community differently. We were preparing for that when Connor wrote the article. We were probably a month away. [This is a New York Times reporter.] Yeah, exactly. And so we were about a month away from wanting to talk about it. I also wish that some of the elected officials had kept more of an open mind instead of condemning the project in the beginning. I think it's totally fair for people to say, "This looks like a really big idea. I'm not sure it works, but I'm going to stay open-minded and I'm going to look at it when there's more details." I think a lot of people rush to conclusions without merit. And I think that's particularly concerning when they have presided over the situation getting worse and worse and worse for working families for the last 20 years and they haven't been able to do anything about it. And I think we should be a bit more open, to Scott's point, about new solutions. Because whatever it is that we're doing, California is no longer working for working families.
Yeah, I think that's a very good point. I just think when you're coming in hot with a lot of rich people and you already experienced some of their behavior, you don't trust them necessarily even if it is a good idea, which I think this actually is. Scott, do you see this more as the folks who are funding this—and there's nothing wrong with the profit motive—but do they see an opportunity to find a place where there's less zoning requirements and they want to be in the business of development? Or do they see this as an opportunity—and the two aren't mutually exclusive—a social ill? How important is it a new form of governance or just bringing housing prices down? What are your investors up to here? When they sit down with you, what does success look like for them? Because these guys have enough money. That's ridiculous. They always want more money. What do you think their objective is? Do they see this as a social good or do they see this just as a great economic opportunity?
Jan Sramek
I think it's both. I mean, we've been very clear from the beginning that it's a for-profit investment. And over the long run, this can be a pretty good investment. It does require kind of a 20-year time horizon, which is part of the reason why I went to the people that I went to to raise the capital. It's much longer term, much more patient capital. I think for all of our investors, it's a—I've started to say—"profit plus" investment. And so if you look at the people who've invested in it, they all have causes that they really care about.
For someone like Laurene Powell Jobs, a lot of her work has been about economic opportunity and economic mobility and sustainability. And whenever I talk to her or the team, those are the questions I get asked: how do we make it more sustainable? How do we make sure that teachers can live in the community? The way you build it. How do we make sure that it's not a food desert? How do we make sure that there's really high-quality food available for kids in the schools?
When I talk to someone like Reid Hoffman, for him, Reid is an eternal optimist. He believes that we can solve things. He believes that technology can solve them. And he believes that a lot of the innovations coming out of the Bay Area have really made the world better. And so he asks, how do we make the opportunity as broad as we can possibly make it?
For someone like Nat Friedman or the Collisons, they are really passionate about high quality walkable places. And so we talk about design and how do we make this an amazing place?
I think Mike Moritz has been extremely invested in improving things in the Bay Area. He spent hundreds of millions of dollars in philanthropy in San Francisco trying to make it better. And so when I talk to Mike, it's about how do we create homes that people who work in the Bay Area can afford. The last discussion I had with Mike was about can we help nurses be able to live here instead of flying here from Idaho? I mean, that started to happen. It's so expensive to live here. The nurses are flying in from Idaho.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, I think it's easy to be suspect of some of the people and intentions of them from the get-go because of past behavior. But I think at the heart of the good part of it is believing in California. And one of the reasons I call my book "A Tech Love Story" is because I do believe in the great possibilities. And I hate what they've done to the place. So why don't they use the better parts of their nature to do things? I'm glad to hear you saying it's not going to be some demented smart city. I hate the term.
Jan Sramek
I hate the term. I've banned the term internally. Cities aren't smart. That's why they're great.
Kara Swisher
Exactly, exactly.
Jan Sramek
And if I can just comment on the investors. When I started working on this in 2016, there was this popular narrative that venture capitalists and billionaires in general are wasting the capital they have investing in dumb messaging apps and they should really do something in the real world to make life better for working families. And then three or four years ago during COVID, the popular narrative was, "How dare all of these people who've made their fortunes in California take the money and go to Texas and go to Florida and just take it away?" And I think we found a group of people who really believe in California, who really want to double down, and they did exactly what people have been calling for. Invest in hard things in the physical world with an uncertain payoff that requires 20 years patience and that doubles down on California. And so I'm really proud of the cap table that we have. And I know why people kind of see this as controversial, but these are just people who love the Bay Area and they wanted to work for everyone.
Kara Swisher
I just want to say that's a great point. And some of the people on your cap table I do not think a great deal of, but I think what you're doing here, assuming that you're being honest about this, you're exactly right. They're not going into space. They're trying to make this place more habitable. I think it's a really excellent point. If you could say anything, what is the level of cooperation or non-cooperation from either the state government or the federal government? Have they embraced this as another signal of innovation that'll bring more people to California, or are they suspect of it and feel threatened by it?
Jan Sramek
The state government and the federal government is not a unitary body. There's a lot of different stakeholders in there. But I think what we've seen in general is people are really excited. Housing used to be a priority for the California government. To your point, Scott, it's become a priority for the federal government because house prices across the country have just gotten so crazy in the last five years. And so what we've seen is a lot of excitement from people saying, "If you can get the buy-in of the local community, we would love to help."
The opportunity for Solano County, which is a part of the Bay Area that really has been left out—one data point that is incredible: in 2002, the average household income in Solano County was 90% of the rest of the Bay Area. It was about $6,000 a household less. Over the last 20 years, the gap has widened to 30%. The average household in Solano County makes $40,000 less than anyone else in the Bay Area. And the county hasn't gotten its fair share of employers. It hasn't gotten its fair share of tax dollars, infrastructure dollars. And so the opportunity that we've seen from state and federal government is to say, if you can get the buy-in of the local community, we would love to help.
And I think there's a real opportunity to bring a lot of state and federal funds to Solano County and really make the county better for the people who live here. It's a really special place. I mean, I moved here with my wife and two kids. We live here. We've made so many friends in the last year that we've been here. And I really care about it getting its share of the economic opportunity in the Bay Area. And I think we have the most credible plan to do that that's been proposed here in the last 30 years.
Kara Swisher
But what about the cows? What about the cows? It's one of the main towns there was Vacaville, which means "cowville."
Jan Sramek
[Laughs] It's a good question. We're going to build an amazing place for the cows in the green belt. You know what we're doing now? The community is going on about a third of the land that we're building on. On the rest of it, we're building solar farms. It turns out that the sheep really like grazing underneath the solar panels because they don't have to stand in 105-degree heat in the summer.
Kara Swisher
It can be hot out there. That's the other thing. And it's hot out in Solano County, much more than people realize how warm it is because the Bay Area seems like a cooler environment. Not out there. It's warm.
Jan Sramek
You know what's the most special thing about designing this? It turns out that it's windiest in the summer. And so if you design the street grid correctly and you orient it correctly, the wind can cool it off kind of like it does on some of the islands in the Caribbean or the Mediterranean. It's beautiful land out there. I love it out there. I think it's so beautiful.
Kara Swisher
Well, in any case, Jan, thank you for coming on and answering questions. We'll be watching it carefully. You're right. You're 100% right. Bugging them to do bigger things is what I've been doing. And this is definitely a bigger thing. And they're not building space colonies. That's always a plus.
Jan Sramek
You should come and visit.
Kara Swisher
I'm going to. I'm coming out soon. I'm coming out in a couple of weeks. You're going to give me a tour, okay?
Jan Sramek
All right. I'll see you then.
Kara Swisher
Jan Sramek, thank you so much.
Scott Galloway
Thanks, Jan. Nice meeting you.
Jan Sramek
Great. Same here.
Jan Sramek exits
Kara Swisher
All right, Scott. That's kind of cool.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. I think there's just a little too much secrecy around it, and some of the owners are kind of terrible people, but some of them are great. We'll see. I have a checkered history with some of the bigger players here. I think this is—assuming he's being genuine and he sounds genuine—we need more housing. We need more innovation. We need to restore the American dream, and a lot of it has been sequestered from young people because as soon as someone has a house, they become very interested in traffic and start making it impossible to have new housing. And with interest rates going from 2.5% to 7.5%, the average mortgage has gone from $1,100 to $2,200. In four years, we've gone from two-thirds of Americans being able to afford a home to one-third. Starter homes. That's what he's talking about. Anyway, we'll see where it goes. There's a great story in the Chronicle: to be rich in California, most be rich in the United States is $400,000. In California, it's $800,000 or $700,000. Anyway, we'll go on one more quick break. And by the way, San Francisco is coming back and it's just going to get more expensive. Anyway, we'll be back for Wins and Fails.
AD BREAK
Kara Swisher
Okay, Scott, let's hear some Wins and Fails. I think I shall start if you don't mind. I think there's a story—Jeff Skoll has closed down his Participant Media, which made a lot of cool films over time. And I felt sad about that. They've created a lot of amazing movies: An Inconvenient Truth, Roma, Green Book, all kinds of stuff. And he was a former eBay executive. I've known him for a long time. It was going to do things addressing issues like climate change, civil rights, democracy, free press. And they're dissolving it. It just doesn't make money, that's all. And I think basic math: rich people don't like losing money eventually. But he was a progressive social change—it had a double bottom line—but they just had to make money. Of course they also made the Oscar-winning Spotlight. By the way, so serious movies. He was making very serious movies. But moviemaking is a profitable enterprise on most good days. So sad, sad to see. Glad he spent his money. But unfortunately, the numbers don't work out. So that's my fail. It's sad.
My win is I thought President Biden had a good week in terms of a lot of stuff happening. And it also seems that there's a little more—even though it seems like all the protests are getting worse—I think they are moving towards discussion, which I hope they do over the next couple of weeks in terms of people sort of talking past each other, talking to each other. So that would be my win, hopefully. That's my hopeful win. I don't know if it's going to happen.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, look, there's a lesson there to young people. The sexier the industry, the lower your return on invested capital. There's just too much capital. Rich people. Whenever I meet someone who's a documentary filmmaker, I'm like, "Oh, so your spouse is rich." It's just the amount of money. And storytelling is important. And I don't mean to be snarky. I think a lot of wealthy people are making a huge difference in the world because storytelling and creativity is a great way—art is a great way to communicate on social justice issues. But kids, be careful. If you're not in the top 1%, don't go into the romance industries. It's going to be really hard, including this industry. The richest people can't figure out how to make money in this industry oftentimes.
Anyways, by the way, I'm still owning the dispensary and the whorehouse in that new Solano town. Can you call Jan and say that I absolutely want to be—you and I are going to retire there together. I'm going to move there with a Filipino nurse with well hands named Manny who's 300 pounds. I'm going to be the little finger of the whorehouse and I'm going to have a dispensary and everyone will love me.
Kara Swisher
Everyone will love me. Oh, best little whorehouse. They could call it Scottsville.
Scott Galloway
Scottsville, there you go.
Okay, so my fail. I can't help it. I hate to give this guy any oxygen. This "tech Zionism" bullshit.
Kara Swisher
I know.
Scott Galloway
I've wrangled with this fellow Balaji Srinivasan. And I wouldn't bring it up except he has a huge following in the tech community. Andreesen—he does. Mark Andreessen called him having the highest velocity of genius ideas. I just want to read this because I don't—I think this shit is so fucking strange and weird. I want to make sure I don't get it wrong. He says, "What I'm really calling for is something like tech Zionism." He said after comparing the movement to the—started the biblical Abraham, Jesus Christ, da da da da—Balaji then revealed his shocking ideas for a tech-governed city where citizens loyal to tech companies would form a new political tribe clad in gray T-shirts.
"And if you see another gray on the street, you do the nod," he said during a four-hour talk on the Moment of Zen podcast. "You're a fellow gray." The gray shirts would feature Bitcoin or Elon or other kinds of logos. Y Combinator is a good one from the cities of San Francisco in particular. Grays would receive special ID cards providing them access to exclusive gray-controlled sectors of the city. In addition, the Grays would make an alliance with the police department, funding weekly policemen's banquets to win them over. "Grays should embrace the police," said Srinivasan. "What does that mean?
That means every policeman's son, daughter, wife, cousin, siblings, whatever, should get a job at a tech company in security. And then they could overnight ask them to switch to their loyalties."
To be clear, he has the right to say what he wants, but he should have greater fidelity to the meaning of the word. Zionism is people who support the creation and survival of Israel. This isn't tech Zionism. It's tech fascism. Get your words right. Your own police force and then people who sign up for this techno only have access to certain areas and a slow creeping takeover of our police force—that's called fascism. It happened before. You have a model for it. Tech is doing just fine. It has nothing to do with Zionism. But this shit just strikes me that the most blessed people in America are the least patriotic. And also just constantly angry about something.
Kara Swisher
This guy—I don't even want to go into it. We had a number of rounds with him at Recode and he was just always, as far as I was concerned, just heinous. I don't know what else to say. He'll come at me again. I don't care. Fuck you.
So my win is actually—I do believe there's been so much media around what has gone wrong on campuses. I do think that some campuses are doing their best and getting it right. My win is President Linda Mills at NYU. When I went to NYU and saw the protests, and also I genuinely believe—and unfortunately because it doesn't make for interesting media—that 95 plus percent of these protests are exactly what they should be. They're peaceful. They're respectful. Students have the right to explore the boundaries of their intellectual thoughts and say things, even if they're vile, even if they're mean, even if they're whatever it is, they have that right as long as it's peaceful and as long as it's not in any way intimidating or harassing other people. And I do believe that the majority of these protests are that. It's just not interesting to cover when they're that.
What Linda Mills did was when someone sets up a camp on private property, she removed them. When someone in any way intimidates anybody, she has them moved out and arrested. And to be clear, "arrested" is a really strong word. Almost all of them have their records expunged and they can come back to campus. They bring—as they should be—they're cutting a wide berth for young people. Where I want to draw sharp relief is I do not buy that professors have a First Amendment free speech right to go down and sow chaos. We are paying them. And if you are not helping take the temperature down or you lack the critical thinking to not support an ideology where the gay students on campus, the Christians on campus would be summarily executed—I agree you have a right to free speech. But try going into Walmart in the lobby and screaming "white power." We have the right to fire you. And I think more faculty should be held to a much higher standard than they are being held right now. I think it is ridiculous that these faculty are claiming First Amendment or free speech rights at a private employer where they are employees.
But my win: I do think a lot of university administration who are in an impossible position right now are in fact threading the needle and allowing kids the right to aggressively express their views regardless of whether or not we agree with them. That shit does not get coverage when there is a polite civil protest. What gets the coverage is when things spin out of control. But I think a lot of university leadership—and I'll use President Linda Mills as an example—are doing their level best and striking the right balance or attempting to strike the right balance. Also, you're starting to see universities take a heavier hand sometimes and say, "We have zero tolerance for anyone who intimidates or threatens another student." They have rights too.
Yeah, yeah. I agree. I fully—I think sometimes kids can say stupid things, and I think they should be allowed to.
Scott Galloway
I agree.
Kara Swisher
I had an interesting set of demands about this, and we actually both agree. It's like, if you work at work, you can't walk into work and do this. And you can do it. You can just get fired. And you may not like it, but work somewhere else where you can do it. And by the way, First Amendment free speech means the company can't prosecute you for it. Good.
Scott Galloway
Right, right. But they can fire you.
Kara Swisher
Exactly. Yeah, that's true. Anyway, I think we agree on that. But I do think students say stupid things. It's called youth. I was arguing with a friend of mine who's very, very moderate and even a liberal Jew. And he was saying, "I just can't stand hearing the Intifada thing and this and that." And I said, "It's kind of reminded me when I was younger when the straight people of Georgetown University would yell at all the gay people and say terrible, heinous things." And I remember thinking, "Was I unsafe or just fucking annoyed by these assholes?" And I probably did feel unsafe at the time. Maybe I didn't. But I thought even today, I'm like, "I'll let them say their stupid shit because they ended up being wrong." So I don't know. It's hard. It's difficult. But it's very difficult to hear those things and kind of heinous for them to say it. Anyway, including what these tech fascists say. And that's what they are. You're right.
Anyway, before we go, we have a listener mail episode coming up. We want to hear from you. Send us your questions about business, tech, or whatever's on your mind. We love listener mail. Go to nymag.com slash pivot to submit a question for the show or call 855-51-PIVOT. Sometime we'll bring the listeners in again. I've met a couple of them. They've come up to me at book events who are on our listener mail call-in show, which was great.
Okay, Scott, that's the show. We'll be back on Friday for more. Today's show was produced by Lara Naiman, Zoe Marcus, and Taylor Griffin. Ernie Natad engineered this episode. Thanks also to Drew Burrows and Neil Silverio. Nishat Kurwa is Vox Media's executive producer of audio. Make sure you subscribe to this show wherever you listen to podcasts. Thank you for listening to Pivot from New York Magazine and Vox Media. You can subscribe to the magazine at nymag.com slash pod. We'll be back later this week for another breakdown of all things tech and business.
Scott Galloway
On the menu today: fisting from a former New York Times number three bestselling author. That's right. Welcome to the dog pound here at Solana Ho House. Welcome.
END OF EPISODE