Main Topic: This podcast episode of Pivot covers various topics, including Peloton, Facebook, and the ongoing trade war between the US and China. The hosts, Kara Swisher and Scott Galloway, also discuss their wins and fails of the week, listener mail, and predictions for the future.
Key Points:
Takeaways:
Support for this show comes from Robinhood. Wouldn't it be great to manage your portfolio on one platform? With Robinhood, not only can you trade individual stocks and ETFs, you can also seamlessly buy and sell crypto at low costs. Trade all in one place. Get started now on Robinhood. Trading crypto involves significant risk. Crypto trading is offered through an account with Robinhood Crypto LLC. Robinhood Crypto is licensed to engage in virtual currency business activity by the New York State Department of Financial Services. Crypto held through Robinhood Crypto is not FDIC insured or SIPC protected. Investing involves risk, including loss of principal. Securities trading is offered through an account with Robinhood Financial LLC, member SIPC, a registered broker dealer.:
If you're a lineman in charge of keeping the lights on, Grainger understands that you go to great lengths, and sometimes heights, to ensure the power is always flowing. Which is why you can count on Grainger for professional-grade products and next-day delivery, so you have everything you need to get the job done. Call 1-800-GRANGER, click grainger.com, or just stop by. Grainger, for the ones who get it done.:
Kara Swisher
Hi, everyone. This is Pivot from the Vox Media Podcast Network. I'm Kara Swisher.
Scott Galloway
And this is Scott Galloway.
Kara Swisher
Scott, are you still on vacation?
Scott Galloway
Well, define vacation.
Kara Swisher
You're just still in Nantucket with the sharks. Seriously. What? Define vacation. You've been like a beachfront property looking out at the sand. I don't know. I just saw a lot of your videos, and there seemed to be a beachy kind of feel to them this week. You were going on about various things from somewhere that looked lovely.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, it's been wonderful. More importantly, what did you think of the videos? Were they insightful and hard-hitting?
Kara Swisher
I was delighted with them. I can't believe I was watching them when I have other things to do, but there I was.
Scott Galloway
There you go. She's watching the dogs. She's stalking the dogs. Hashtag hot takes.
Kara Swisher
Hot takes. Yeah, that's right. So are you going back to school? Isn't school starting? My kids are already in orientation or whatever. My one kid went to senior orientation. My youngest kid went to ninth grade. Aren't you in school? Aren't you a professor of some sort?
Scott Galloway
Supposedly. "Some sort" is the operative term there.
Kara Swisher
What are you teaching this semester? What's your next book, in other words?
Scott Galloway
No, I'm not teaching until the spring. The key is scarcity. I used to be known as a good professor, and I was teaching five courses a year. Then I said, no, I'm going down to one now. Everyone thinks I'm great because I'm never around.
Kara Swisher
What's the topic? Scott 101, the big dog 101. What is it this year?
Scott Galloway
No, I always teach the same course: brand strategy. But going back to school starting, it is a really hopeful and wonderful time. It's like this army of ants descending upon Soho, moving towards the campuses. It's all these young people. It's actually a really nice time of the year. Other than commencement, it's the most optimistic time of the year. I wake up and think, well, I don't hate today as much as I usually hate it, because there's all these young people who seem happy. It's a nice time of the year.
Kara Swisher
It's a luxury house in Nantucket. Listen to me. Do you have a theme for the year? Any thematic ideas you're going to push upon these young, impressionable minds that you will warp?
Scott Galloway
My theme is get through the fucking year. What do you mean theme? I don't theme years.
Kara Swisher
You said the algebra of happiness came from an idea. Do you have a theme? Is there a thematic issue for the students of NYU this year?
Scott Galloway
No. My big theme right now is that I think of it in business terms. I think we're in this monopoly era. It's changed the way people approach business, how you're creating shareholder value. My course, Brand Strategy, traditionally talks about the ultimate algorithm for creating shareholder value: intangible associations, traditional brand management. We've really moved to this monopoly era where it's all about trying to establish yourself as a leader, get access to cheap capital, build against those promises, those crazy promises you've made, and hope you can get there without coming across as a Theranos when you get too far out over your skis. Basically, pull away and make the jump to light speed so no one can catch you. That's the strategy now in business.
To a certain extent, in my department, the marketing department of every top 20 business school, the curriculum is training kids to go get a job at Heinz and be laid off two years later. I'm trying to move to a curriculum of: what does it mean to establish leadership in an information network economy? Establish a great story, a great product, network effects, flywheel effects, moats, get access to cheap capital, and then pull away with moats that are really expensive, whether it's a fulfillment network or incredible engineering. Things have changed so dramatically, Kara.
Kara Swisher
I got you to actually think on your long summer vacation. I actually got you to clarify, which I resent.
Scott Galloway
What are they paying for you there at NYU?
Kara Swisher
I'm soon to be paying a college tuition, so I'd like to know what I'm down for.
Scott Galloway
I'll tell you what I started at. The first class I taught, I was an adjunct professor, and I made $12,000 17 years ago. I make more than that now.
Kara Swisher
No, I want to know what the students pay. I don't care what you make. You are clearly comfortable, my friend.
Scott Galloway
The students... I think the tuition is somewhere between... $277 million a year is our tuition now. I think it's about $62,000 or $68,000. But the reality is at NYU, it's still a great buy because we've decided in our society that the only people who get to innovate or capture shareholder value are monopolies: Amazon, Apple, Facebook, and Google. The only people that get to work for monopolies are people from top 30 schools. The only people that get to go to top 30 schools are children of rich kids. There are more from the top 1% at these schools than the bottom 60%. So basically, we've decided in the United States that all the spoils are reserved for the children of rich kids who get to work for monopolies. What a surprise, Huey Long. This is a big shockeroo to the rest of the United States.
Kara Swisher
Listen to me. Speaking of which, we have a lot of things. We've got so much news. I'm clarifying you. You're coming back after Labor Day. I'm clarifying you for the students. I'm improving your ability to speak to them. You're welcome.
Scott Galloway
It's a pretty low bar.
Kara Swisher
Listen, let's start by talking about Peloton, which Scott has talked a lot about online already.
Scott Galloway
Yeah.
Kara Swisher
So tell me about it. You had some thoughts on this.
Scott Galloway
I have quit SoulCycle, as you know, because I have ethics and you do not. But go ahead.
Kara Swisher
No shit. So what—well, let me ask you first: what are you doing to get your fix of endorphins now that you're not doing SoulCycle?
Scott Galloway
I'm walking everywhere.
Kara Swisher
Well, that's not going to do it. Do you have a Peloton?
Scott Galloway
Yes, I do. It was left to me by the people whose house I bought. They just didn't want to move it, so they left the Peloton. My real estate agent got it for me in the deal. I have not put it together yet. It's still just dead there, sitting there. But I'm going to now, when I get back to Washington, D.C., that's where it is, I'm going to somehow sign up. I like it. It looks great. People love it who use it.
Kara Swisher
So basically you spent $2 million for a Peloton bike and got a house with your purchase.
Scott Galloway
I didn't want to spend that much for a house, Scott.
Kara Swisher
Okay. Yes. Essentially, yes. I will cop to that. It was not that much. But nonetheless, I have one. I haven't used it. I've heard people who use it love it. But of course, it's a thing for rich people, right? So talk to me about this. You had a lot of thoughts on the Peloton S-1 because, again, John Foley said in his public letter to investors: "On a most basic level, Peloton sells happiness."
Scott Galloway
Delivers happiness. Yeah, 100%.
Kara Swisher
Okay. So one thing that was interesting about this is that you and I both received emails on Twitter saying, "Oh, I can't wait for the takedown of Peloton by Kara and Scott." Everyone was expecting us to come out and do a full go-gangster on these guys the same way we did on WeWork.
Scott Galloway
I actually have a Peloton.
Kara Swisher
Well, that's because of the stupid happiness thing. That's why. But go ahead.
Scott Galloway
Peloton is not WeWork. First off, I have a Peloton. I pay the $20 a month. I mostly pay the $20 a month to sit and stare at a screen that has a really hot person bouncing up and down yelling at me, which is sort of like BDSM of the information age. I'll pay $20 a month for that. But this is actually a pretty good business.
Let's break it down. Everybody is trying to be a SaaS business because recurring revenues that you can predict is just a better business. It gets incorporated into someone's workflow or daily use or becomes addictive. Peloton actually has a lot of the dynamics of a software-as-a-service firm. First off, the hardware comprises about 80% of its revenue. It's a $2,000 piece of equipment with 45% margins, which is really impressive when you figure that the highest margin tech hardware company traditionally has been Apple at 30 points of gross margin. The fact they're able to get 45 points of gross margin is really impressive in and of itself.
In addition, the subscription side of the business, the $20 to $45 a month you pay—
Kara Swisher
For people who don't know it, you get on the bike, there's a screen, and then there are lessons. Scott had a shorthand version of that, but they have all kinds of lessons with their top instructors.
Scott Galloway
That's right. You can pick and choose them. You can do them live, taped, different lengths, different intensity. They evaluate you, rank you. That subscription business, which really is similar to a cable company or a software company, is 20% of revenue, and it's grown from 15% of revenue. Within that 20%, about 10% to 20% is the app that's unbundled from the physical bike—people who want to be on a fitness program and run through the park or ride their own bike.
The churn rates are really low: 0.7% per month, so that's probably somewhere between 80% and 85% annual retention. For SaaS companies that trade at a ridiculous multiple, the two key metrics are logo renewal—what percentage of your members renew every year—and dollar renewal—of the people who renew, what do they spend relative to the year before? Ideally, you want to see revenue growth of 110% or 120%. AWS has 90% or 95% renewal and 120% or 130% dollar renewal—people spend more. I couldn't find the dollar renewal here, but the logo renewal has strong SaaS metrics.
So what do you have? Really high margins on a tech hardware product, a recurring revenue stream growing at a good clip with SaaS renewal rates, and $910 or $920 million in revenues, up 100%. Explosive growth. It's losing somewhere between $200 and $300 million, but a lot of that is costs like studios, talent, licensing for music. As they get to scale, those margins should go up.
Kara Swisher
It's interesting. They're adding adjacent businesses. There are things like Tonal and Mirror—at-home gyms, fancier versions of Bowflex. Chuck Norris and Chrissy... I'm going to try one because I'm trying all different things in the wake of my SoulCycle debacle. Peloton is not just bicycles; it's all kinds of exercise things. It's an interesting question what it does to places like Equinox. People don't want to go to them. There are definitely innovative ways to exercise now that are very different—like having a trainer without having a trainer. At the same time, there are businesses like Rumble, Orange Theory, all kinds of SoulCycle-like things.
I agree. I think it's an interesting business. We talked to them years ago. It's a question of whether they can make it broader than just a bunch of rich people. The funniest thing—I retweeted a Twitter meme that was hysterical about placing your Pelotons different places, making fun of their marketing, which is all about aspirational rich people. It was like, "I have this down in the basement with my nanny who I make do this while she's doing the laundry." Super funny. So that's the question: do lots of people use these things?
Scott Galloway
When you were talking about class earlier, the first slide in each of my classes is: I don't think you can build a company worth tens of billions of dollars without knowing which instinct you're tapping into. God, love, consumption, procreation—Google, Facebook, Amazon, and Apple, respectively. I think Peloton taps into this instinct that as a species, we're happiest when we are in motion and surrounded by others. When you and I are in our 80s, the things we'll remember most are walking around Rome with our kids or playing a sport. When you're in the company of others and enduring some sort of physical exertion, that's when we're happiest because it goes back to the days of hunting and gathering. This kind of artisanal sweating where you're in a community of like-minded people...
Kara Swisher
Think about it. On my block, we have a SoulCycle, an Orange Theory, a CrossFit, a yoga studio. I think there's a Rumble opening up. All these things are $30 to $40 per session, which is ridiculous. But it's people saying, "I'm going to spend less money on stuff, and I want to go be around other people and be in motion with them, and it's going to make me happy." It's definitely a huge industry.
Scott Galloway
Their last round private valuation was $4.5 billion. It's already trading at five times revenues, which for my mind is pretty rich. They're talking about going out at an $8 or $9 billion valuation—10 times revenues. Josh Brown, downtown Josh Brown on Twitter—I think he's fantastic, on CNBC with Barry Ritholtz. He's such a clear blue flame thinker around stocks. He basically said in response to my hot take on Peloton that it's a great company, but he's not sure it's a great stock. I think he's exactly right. Great company, great SaaS-like metrics. Is it worth $9 billion? Probably not. But it'll probably be one of the taller midgets of the unicorn class when it gets out. It will probably go sideways, maybe go down a bit. But it won't collapse like what I think we have in store with Lyft and Uber, and if WeWork ever gets out.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, exactly. I think it's an interesting business. It's just a question of valuation. But it's definitely the leader in that area. Others have tried to catch it. There are a lot of competitors, but they've certainly got a great name and a great product. We'll see.
Let's move on to Facebook and Casey Newton's really interesting story about what it's doing to compete again with Snapchat. Instagram is making an app called Threads. And guess what? It's like things you do on Snapchat. It's meant to promote constant intimate sharing between users and their closest friends and invite users to automatically share their location, speed, and better life with friends. It's essentially Snapchat—the private Snapchat. During our prediction show last December, we talked about what we thought would come up in 2019. One of my predictions was that social media becomes more about interacting with close friends than sharing publicly.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, we've talked about this. Snap is Facebook's R&D department. And now it's TikTok. What would be interesting is: can TikTok do to Facebook what Facebook has done to everybody else?
Kara Swisher
That's a really good point. Facebook has also responded and launched a copycat product called Lasso, I think, which looks very TikTok-ish. It'll be interesting to see if the elephant is able to dance and continue to innovate or copy other people's products. What Facebook has been able to do that most big companies can't is they're willing to cannibalize themselves. They'll say, "I don't care if it cannibalizes our legacy business. If this is where the puck is headed, this is what we're going to do and we're going to go hard at it." But to Snap's credit, and you predicted this and I didn't, Snap has carved out a nice niche for themselves.
Scott Galloway
They have.
Kara Swisher
I might go see Evan Spiegel next week at the Haring event in Los Angeles. It's kind of interesting. But it's true. I always feel like if you have a creative product, it works. You can't just get by on copying everybody's stuff. People are on to you. Even though the teens complain about Snapchat, they're consistently using it, which is interesting. I don't think he's going to stop using it when he goes to college either. Creativity does win out.
The last thing is, which feels like 100 years ago, and maybe you've been on this island that you've been on: Trump claiming he could use emergency powers to force private companies to relocate out of China. He said he has no current plans to do so, but he hereby orders people if he needs to. This is obviously ridiculous. Apple has this event coming up. Who's going to pay for the tariffs? Tim Cook went and met with President Trump, had dinner with him. Where do you see this playing out, this tariff war? China just said it doesn't want escalation. It seems to change every week.
Scott Galloway
I heard, and I've done some investigative journalism here, that in that meeting between Tim Cook and Donald Trump, based on the recent run-up in Apple stock, Tim Cook has decided to offer to buy America from the Russians for Trump. He said he'll take back America from the Russians. Anyways, that's my bad geopolitical job.
Look, the Chinese have already won. They've won. They think in 2030—
Kara Swisher
How so? Explain for the people.
Scott Galloway
This was absolutely for the right reasons. This is one of the few things the president has got right: the IP theft, the currency manipulation. The trade between the U.S. and China has been disproportionately advantaged to the Chinese versus Americans. A lot of it's our own fault. We decided there are winners and losers, and the winners tend to be information age workers. We didn't take the time to reinvest some of those proceeds in the struggling middle class. So some of it's our fault. But they do benefit more from this than us. A trade war was absolutely overdue.
But instead of going at this war with the full heft of our partners, it's like the analogy I would use: we went to war with Saddam Hussein when he went into Kuwait, but we went in with a ton of nations and allies and intelligence. We've gone into this economic war—the two biggest powers in the world, 40% of the global economy is China and the U.S.—sloppily. We went in without allies, with no strategy. I don't think he can even tell you what exactly it is that we want. The administration hasn't been able to articulate it. So we're angry, and we can highlight why we're angry.
Kara Swisher
He's just saying "unfair." That's pretty much it.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, okay, but what exactly do you want? Then, we think in election cycles, and he's constantly backpedaling. The stock market goes down. Someone tells him that if you go into a recession before the election, you're going to lose. So then he goes, "Well, I'm having second thoughts." Or "Me and Xi, they reached out, and we're going to get a deal done." Then the Chinese go, "Well, actually, no, we didn't reach out." They have won. They have figured out: we have this guy. The election is coming up. Xi gets elected every 30 or 40 years until he dies. Trump could be gone.
Kara Swisher
This is the first time I've thought Trump really could be gone. Everyone's like—100 percent. I'm like, is he? The levels on women, the levels on—
Scott Galloway
Yeah, it's happening. Everyone's tired of this show. This is a show. The Dear Leader show. I think the Chinese have already won. They've said, "You know what? We can easily go another 18 months." At this point, the Chinese are like, "You started this. Let's play it out, boss."
Kara Swisher
I think you're 100 percent right. It still will have impact on companies like Apple and others. Who's going to eat the tariffs? Some reports today say it could cost $500 million to $5 billion. They have this money. Will they eat the costs and not raise the prices? We'll see how long it goes. Everyone's playing the waiting game with Trump. The same thing with the media. He attacked, attacked. He's been crazy attacking this week, even more so around nuking hurricanes, every story he questioned. I feel the media is just going to wait him out, keep banging away. It'll be interesting to see who wins. I think he ends up losing this particular fight because even Fox has started to turn on him a little bit.
Anyway, it'll be interesting. But we're going to take a quick break. When we get back, we have wins and fails, predictions, and listener mail. We got a ton of listener mail. People love us. And of course, we're going to talk about bedbugs when we get back.
[Ad Break]:
We're here with Scott Galloway and Kara Swisher. Scott, what are your wins and fails?
Scott Galloway
My fail is this: probably the most poorly orchestrated war—economic war—in the history of the U.S. that could potentially take the global economy down. If you think about what we were just talking about, the U.S. can hurt China pretty badly. Now it's ego, and he's talking about raising the tariffs. They can endure that, but as they become less confident, they'll purchase less machinery or manufacturing equipment from Germany. Germany, in turn, will feel less confident and invest less. You see this ripple effect. We are in a global economy. This is a poorly orchestrated war with no benefit to us where everyone's going to lose. It's been poorly executed.
What's interesting is it could have been a good war in the sense that the Europeans were ready to line up behind us. They agreed. They quietly nodded their head that this war was overdue. It's just been so poorly executed. So my lose is what could have been—I don't want to call it a righteous war, but the right war with good outcomes had we realized our strength and powers in the agency of others. Instead, we have botched it. I think the Chinese have already won. That's my lose.
Kara Swisher
What's your lose?
That's your lose. There's a couple of them. There's a wide range of things this week.
Scott Galloway
I do think this thing that I work for. Listen, I work for The New York Times. I write a column for them. But a lot of these letters people are writing, angry, you know, two people at the Times wrote letters to people over fights on Twitter. And one was Bret Stephens. The other was an editor, a political editor. I'm totally blanking on his name.
Kara Swisher
And I think it's really important during this time of real attacks on the press not to act like jerks, like to readers that call us names. In one case, this professor who's a very clever professor, he wrote a great piece in Esquire actually, at George Washington University, tweeted a joke and it got no retweets. It got very small likes. And Bret Stephens, who works in the same section I do, the opinion section, he's an employee of the Times. I'm not. Emailed his boss to complain and him and didn't want to be called a bed bug. And I just cringe when reporters do stuff like this. Like write – I get called names all the time.
I don't know if you do. I don't care. Like fine. Like in fact someone didn't like an interview I did with Huawei, which I – and I agreed with him in some place. I didn't think it was as successful as it could have been. And I just like engaged and agreed. Like I didn't like write a letter because he was kind of strafing me. It was – I deserved it. And it was just – it's really important for the press right now to like do their job and do a great job at journalism and have any opinion you want. But when you have an opinion or write something that people, you know, that's controversial, expect to be called names and don't like just – it's just – we have to take it.
We have to unfortunately – especially because the president is doing this. And it's offensive and damaging what the president is doing against fake news almost constantly. And we just can't play into it by – just take it like if someone calls you a bed bug, just live with it. Like live with the frigging bed bugs.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, I thought of you when I saw this because I like Bret Stephens. I think some of the more thoughtful people at The New York Times, one of the reasons I love The New York Times and it separates them from, I don't know, News Corp, is they actually try to bring on thoughtful people to provide the other side. I don't know if you've ever seen – whenever – like when The View decides to bring on a conservative, it brings on Meghan McCain. And I don't – they're like just to kind of make their point. And whenever Fox brings on a liberal, they bring on the most unattractive, unlikable liberal in the world to again make their point.
Kara Swisher
Right. That's you, right?
Scott Galloway
That's me.
Kara Swisher
Bingo. We have a bingo. The big dog is in the house.
Scott Galloway
Anyway, so anything – Hello. I'm here to get beaten up. I remember they had Kennedy and Combs. Remember that?
Kara Swisher
I'm making their point. I am literally making their point.
Scott Galloway
Anyways, but they do a good job of bringing on these softball conservatives. And Bret is very good. And I thought of you because occasionally people get in your face. And what you do is you clap back and you get in their face. And you do get into these kind of these little, what I'll call these little Twitter skirmishes. But what he did, and this has happened to me, and this really pissed me off. Oh, someone wrote a letter about you to your provost?
Kara Swisher
Oh, my God. I think that was me.
Scott Galloway
Do you know how many times the dean has had headaches over me?
Kara Swisher
I bet.
Scott Galloway
Think about this. I bet. And every time, and I'm just, just, just Bret, let me tell you what happens. It's a pain for the dean or the provost. They don't like it. And you know what they do? They say, this is about academic freedom and we're behind you. And I can't imagine that the provost of George Washington or wherever this professor is didn't have the exact same response. So just, just.
Kara Swisher
He invited him to like a moderated, to moderate a panel between the professor and Bret. I'd be happy to moderate the thing. I'd be, I'd love to do that one in Georgetown, George Washington. This professor is really funny too. And so I just – I agree. It's like don't write letters. Like you can clap back on Twitter. You can – especially when you're an opinion columnist. But being perpetually – press being perpetually offended when actually real people have problems on Twitter like are really attacked. Like it just – New York Times columnists or people of privilege should not be – they can complain. But honestly, it's just not a good look.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, but the bottom line is if you don't upset people, if occasionally people don't go back in your face as a journalist or an academic, you know what? You're not doing – you're not saying anything. So expect a little bit of it. And there's two ways to go. I've actually – I used to get back in people's face and you were sort of a role model for me. And now I decide that when I get back in their face, I start thinking about it too much and it weighs on me and it upsets and it impresses me. Now I just ignore it. I just don't respond.
Kara Swisher
Do you know, I end up being pals with most of those people because I actually am not that mean. I'm funny or I sometimes like – it's funny. I end up like, you know, like my whole Scaramucci thing. I went after him for a long time and then – he's not my pal, but you know what I mean? Like it was – I tend to use humor a lot more in the thing. I just think you should expect to be attacked as a journalist. Welcome to the kitchen.
Scott Galloway
Welcome to the kitchen.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, exactly.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. I think no more letter writing, New York Times people, or any reporter. No more letter writing to their bosses. That's just –
Kara Swisher
100%.
Scott Galloway
So Wynn. Let me talk about a Wynn that's along the same vein. Josh – I think his name is Josh Hawley, a reporter at the Wall Street Journal, wrote a fantastic article about how big tech used to be innovators. Now their primary form of innovation is to exploit people. And it was really powerful that now the way they're adding shareholder value is, okay, how do we figure out a way to pay 4 million driver partners less than minimum wage and delay and obfuscate the actual analysis of their pay? And some great articles have come out recently saying that now they are actually making less than minimum wage, or to have more and more contractors or what have you.
But the new era of innovation, is exploitation. And it's not only sad, but it's an important topic that needs more discussion and more examination. I think about, I seem to think about AB InBev. There was so much innovation in the drinks category in the 70s and 80s, and then AB InBev came in and said, all right, our primary source of innovation is to cut costs. And now they've kind of cut down to the bone and they need to start innovating again. And they're coming out with all these great little kind of malt brews and different things. But we're in this really unfortunate stage with big tech, where the primary source of innovation is exploitation.
And it goes back to another key theme, and that is, without more journalists, I'm jumping all over the place, I apologize, but I thought one of the biggest stories this week, and it just made me really sad reading about it, was Oklahoma's decision to fine Johnson & Johnson, I think it was $550 million, And the fact that Purdue may, in fact, be bankrupted or take themselves into bankruptcy and then come out as an upcorp and all the proceeds and profits go to the victims of opioids. And I really wonder if there had been as many journalists in this nation doing long-form journalism as there were 30 years ago, would we not have recognized the devastation, misery, and just general tragedy of the opioid crisis sooner?
Kara Swisher
Well, that is what we're doing with the social media, Scott. But I feel like we are ringing the alarms and stuff like that. I think it's a similar thing. Or it's not as devastating as the opiate crisis. But I'm saying I think journalists did write a lot about it. I think the question is people were OK with it. And it takes a while for people to finally act on these things. That's I just I don't know how. It seems like every kind of crisis like this, whether it's a water crisis or pollution or whatever, someone goes too far. just like Trump removing the methane rules today, you know. And then there's going to be cancer and deaths and everything else, and the press will write about it, and then there'll be lawsuits. It seems like the American way.
Scott Galloway
Well, it goes to the notion that Americans, because, you know, we're in love with the macho, right? We're Clint Eastwood and General Mattis, who I'm actually interviewing next week, and I do think he's an incredible—
Kara Swisher
Oh, ask him. Get him to say Trump's name.
Scott Galloway
Yeah.
Kara Swisher
People who don't do allies are bad. Like, which people? Which one? Like, did you notice that book? He never says Trump's name.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. Well, I don't think I think he's I think that's the way he I think that's his punishment. I think I think Trump would rather use his name in a negative sense and not use it. But anyways, there's this macho where we've decided, OK, regulation is wimpy and European. And the reality is some of the tragedy of the comments has been because we haven't had enough regulation.
Kara Swisher
That's right.
Scott Galloway
We haven had enough scrutiny We haven had enough thoughtful people elected officials saying well what happens when people become addicted to opioids and who responsible for that And you know even weird things like I was thinking about it George Michael Tom Petty Prince, we think that they died of heart attacks or overdoses, but weren't those really opioid deaths? I mean, how come it's just strange we haven't connected the dots sooner?
Kara Swisher
Don't go near Elvis. I love Elvis.
Scott Galloway
Thank you. I don't know how you brought up Elvis.
Kara Swisher
Because he died on the toilet of drug abuse.
Scott Galloway
Oh, I thought he died of ice cream.
Kara Swisher
No.
Scott Galloway
Anyways.
Kara Swisher
Well, among the other things, but it was drug abuse.
Scott Galloway
But look, I wonder if we're going to about to acknowledge that regulation isn't necessarily a bad thing. It doesn't mean we're wimps if we ask our elected officials to be more thought or have greater scrutiny and also hopefully armed by the greatest police force in the history that doesn't carry a gun or badge, journalists.
Kara Swisher
Guess what? Real women regulate.
Scott Galloway
Real women regulate?
Kara Swisher
So get ready for Elizabeth Warren, President Elizabeth Warren. So are you all in on Elizabeth? Do you think she's here?
Scott Galloway
You know, now that they've—I'll tell you, my win for the week is now there's just 10 of them on that stage, which we can see them all together. Sheila Brown out, Hickenlooper out.
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. And predictions. Do you have a prediction?
Kara Swisher
No, bro, I guess. I do not have a prediction. But first, we're going to—we have the listener email and voice email. So before we get to predictions, let's hear from some listeners, shall we?
[Listener Voicemail]: Hey, Kara and Scott. This is Dan Alasso. I'm a history professor in Bemidji, Minnesota, and a big fan of Pivot. Super sympathetic to your approach, Scott, to inequality and class. But I got to ask, what's the beef with Tesla? EVs are not as dirty as ICE cars. And Tesla is unlikely to increase the number of cars purchased, especially if autonomy ultimately works. It's more likely to shift cars off of petroleum while we're waiting for overall volume of vehicles to decrease, which could make all the difference to the carbon tipping point. And VW, give me a break. Dieselgate 2 with a new defeat device that apparently turns off the cleaners above 90 degrees Fahrenheit and below 50.
I don't think it's inconceivable that Tesla would ever sell, but I can't see Elon with 22% of the stock and supermajority voting rights to sell to VW. And I really don't see where you're coming from with the idea that the wheels are about to come off. If you guys really wanted to go after Elon, the question to ask would be who's going to rule in space? Are we really going to hand the moon or Mars or the asteroid belt or even low Earth orbit over to billionaires to try to create some type of Robert Heinlein millennium just because they're the guys that can get there? Thanks for listening.
Wow. The Bemidji people are smarter than you are, Scott. I want him as my new host.
Scott Galloway
God, I hate it when thoughtful people call me out. So what do you say? Answer. So first off, you know, word to your mother, that was really impressive. And I think a lot of your points are really accurate. And he said a lot there, and I'll go in kind of reverse order. Where do we agree? I don't like it when wealthy people become the new arbiters of giant social projects. I don't think that we continue to allocate more and more of our government expenditures on the interest on debt, which is now greater than our expenditures on military, such that it crowds out all discretionary spending. And all discretionary spending around how we move forward humanity is left up to rich people.
I call it the Pablo Escobar building parks phenomena. I don't like rich people getting to decide how we allocate big leaps in our society. So I agree. I think it should be NASA, not this sword fighting with your dick competition between Musk and Bezos in space. I just don't like it. I think it's an externality of this incredible income inequality where we have people worth the GDP of Norway. As it goes to Tesla, I think there's a fair point. And that is, I've basically said, I've said, bullshit, Tesla is not good for the environment. And a lot of smart, thoughtful people get back in my space and say, you know, on the whole, it is good for the environment.
And I think I have to acknowledge that some of my own personal bias comes into this because I do not like Elon Musk. I think an individual who feels that he's beyond or above corporate governance and above what I call just general standards of behavior, calling strangers he's never met pedophiles. I have found that personally I want Tesla to lose. So there's some personal bias creeping into my viewpoint, which is quite frankly incorrect and inappropriate. So he's right. I do think on the whole, Tesla is probably going to be a good for mankind. Now, on valuation, I disagree. This thing is absolutely going to crash.
And it's not a function of whether it's a good company or a bad company. I just think the structural economics of the automobile industry make it almost near impossible for an independent automobile manufacturer to survive long term. Now, whether VW or Toyota or Daimler could buy it, that's a fair point. They may not have the balance sheet. But be clear, boss, Elon Musk is going to decide that rather than have the embarrassment of taking his company into Chapter 11, he is going to sell this thing. And every day he waits to sell it means he sells it at a lower price because this company is an auto company.
It should trade at a multiple like an auto company, which means it's barely worth the obligations, the repair warranties, and the debt they have on it. So I agree with him. I acknowledge his point. By the way, that was a really thoughtful point, and thank you for taking the time to actually do that. All you – everybody, please call in and do these. We like answering them, especially when you argue with us, especially Scott.
Kara Swisher
Really, I'm always correct.
Scott Galloway
There you go.
Kara Swisher
But he's absolutely right. There's a really tough article on Elon Musk this week in Vanity Fair about SolarCity. And I think one of the things that I came away from is there's some really troubling things in the story. But these are big ideas and ahead of their skis is a very good way to put it. Some of them, like with stuff that's going on at SpaceX or Tesla or SolarCity are great. They're not small ideas. And so it's complex is what it is. It's what it is. Anyway, thank you, Dan. From Bemidji, we really appreciate it. So, Scott, we're going to do predictions, but here's a question that came into our inbox. It's how you come up with your predictions, Scott. What is the formula? Is it a magic eight ball? Do you have chicken entrails? What is your methodology around your predictions? Or you just, I don't know. sit and stare at a wall? What is your manner?
Scott Galloway
Sativa.
Kara Swisher
No, look, I spend all day. How do a lot of people want to know?
Scott Galloway
I spend all day, I work with a group of really talented people, and we spend all day kind of marinating in data, looking at trends and data. And some stuff just kind of bubbles up to the top that seems fairly obvious. And one of the keys, so the, if you will, the steel in the ground or the pillars of predictions are data. And you will see trend lines start to appear around data. So there's some fascinating things coming out of retail right now. We're going to see the resale market, secondhand clothing be bigger than fast fashion in 2028. That's incredible data. So I'm thinking about a lot of predictions off of that, what that means for retail.
And then the key around making predictions, that's the underpinnings, that's the steel. But the key is to be fearless. And that's to say, all right, take your gut, take the data, and then think of something. And regardless of how stupid that sounds, regardless of the actual likelihood of that at the current time, make the prediction. Because the thing about predicting is that people, as long as you're predicting to learn, you're not predicting to be right, people respect you for it, and it catalyzes a dialogue. That's the key. So I am absolutely fascinated with predictions. But the way you reach the promised land of predictions is to say, I'm going to use predictions as a means of learning and catalyzing a conversation and not trying to be right.
Because if you're trying to be right, You're never going to have the confidence or the cojones to make predictions because eventually you're going to be wrong.
Kara Swisher
Yep. That's very good. Thank you for that cogent. I see we're getting you very serious, Scott. I'm liking that I'm focusing you on the year to come. And next week, do you know what next week is? Our 50th episode.
Scott Galloway
Wow. Our 50th.
Kara Swisher
Wow. And we have lots to talk about because next week is right after Labor Day. But the week after that, Apple has an event. It's just sent out the invitations this morning. I don't know if you got one. to its September 10th event where they're expected to announce the iPhone 11, which will be interesting. There's all kinds of things coming up. A lot of people think there's going to be first triple camera system on the rear of the device, all kinds of things, a little bigger display, all kinds of stuff. So we have lots to talk about, but this is our 50th episode. What should we do? We're going to do more live events, obviously, but what should we do for our 50th episode?
Scott Galloway
Well, first off, it's nice that you've noticed that we're going into year two of our relationship, which I would loosely describe as a triumph of hope over experience.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, we're a year into this. You know what? You know what the first podcast I ever listened to?
Scott Galloway
What?
Kara Swisher
Was the podcast on Recode where you interviewed me. I'd never listened to a podcast. Of course, I'm a narcissist. The first podcast I ever listened to. And it spawned all of this, Kara. All of this.
Scott Galloway
All of this.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, year two. So what should we do? We're going to bring you more. What should we do?
Scott Galloway
In a word, Toronto. We're going to Toronto.
Kara Swisher
That's right. Did you see all those tweets? Every city, we're like Amazon. What should we ask for? We should ask for things. Us and Amazon. We had Minnesota asking us. We had all these weird cities.
Scott Galloway
All I want is a helipad. I don't have a helicopter, but I'd like a helipad. I want a goat. I want one city to offer us a goat of some sort or something interesting or a big dog, for example.
Kara Swisher
What city will actually offer us a big dog?
Scott Galloway
Toronto. Have you seen how many tweets we've gotten from Toronto?
Kara Swisher
Toronto. We are huge in Toronto.
Scott Galloway
We're going to Toronto with the Canadians. So I'd like to announce here, because of all the online heat we've been getting and people saying, come to Toronto. We're going to figure—year two, our anniversary, you and I are going to Toronto.
Kara Swisher
All right. Fantastic. That sounds great. And other cities, please. We are—well, we are bribe-able. We are absolutely—
Scott Galloway
100%.
Kara Swisher
100%, especially Scott. Anyway, I'm really excited, Scott. I've had such a lovely time.
Scott Galloway
Here's the bad news is I'm a whore, but the good news is I'm a cheap whore. So just send me a little bit of merch and the big dog's coming to your park. It can be an old tennis ball. It can be a pig's ear. It can be a promiscuous poodle. Anything you want. Just bring it and I'll be there.
Kara Swisher
This is how it ends. Not with a bang, but a poodle.
Scott Galloway
But a whimper.
Kara Swisher
Anyway, Scott, thank you. I'll talk to you next week, and I will see you soon in New York. Anyway, finish your vacation, please. It would be really nice if you came back from vacation. Anyway, today's show was produced by Rebecca Sinanis. Eric Anderson is Pivot's executive producer. Thanks also to Rebecca Castro, Drew Burrows, Eric Johnson, and Nishat Kerwa. Special thanks to Gautam Shrikashin for engineering this episode. Make sure you subscribe to the show on Apple Podcasts. And if you like this week's episode, leave us a review. Also, we got so many emails, so shoot us more emails at pivot at voxmedia.com. Thanks for listening to Pivot from Vox Media. We'll be back next week for another breakdown of all things tech and business.