Podcast Episode Summary
The podcast episode, "Pivot," hosted by Kara Swisher and Scott Galloway, covers various topics in tech and business. The main topic of the episode is Facebook's recent announcements and their implications on society, particularly regarding disinformation and climate change.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Kara Swisher
Support for this show comes from Robinhood. Wouldn't it be great to manage your portfolio on one platform? With Robinhood, not only can you trade individual stocks and ETFs, you can also seamlessly buy and sell crypto at low costs. Trade all in one place. Get started now on Robinhood. Trading crypto involves significant risk. Crypto trading is offered through an account with Robinhood Crypto LLC. Robinhood Crypto is licensed to engage in virtual currency business activity by the New York State Department of Financial Services. Crypto held through Robinhood Crypto is not FDIC-insured or SIPC-protected. Investing involves risk, including loss of principal. Securities trading is offered through an account with Robinhood Financial LLC, member SIPC, a registered broker-dealer.
Scott Galloway
Isn't home where we all want to be? Reba here for Realtor.com, the pro's number one most trusted app. Finding a home is like dating. You're searching for the one. With over 500,000 new listings every month, you can find the one today. Download the Realtor.com app because you're nearly home. Make it real with Realtor.com. Pro's number one most trusted app based on August 2024 proprietary survey. Over 500,000 new listings every month based on average new for sale and rental listings. February 2024 through January 2025.
Kara Swisher
Hi, everyone. This is Pivot from the Vox Media Podcast Network. I'm Kara Swisher.
Scott Galloway
And I'm Scott Galloway.
Kara Swisher
And first off, thank you, Kara.
Scott Galloway
For what?
Kara Swisher
I got home and there was a box from Kara Swisher. And it was strange. It had two things in it. It had a book written by Edward Snowden called...
Scott Galloway
Which you wanted.
Kara Swisher
Not really.
Scott Galloway
You got it for me because...
Kara Swisher
You told me you wanted to read it to understand him better, but go ahead, move along.
Scott Galloway
And a rabbit. So can you... I haven't... I don't... It's not that often that I receive a small furry animal in the mail from a coworker, but I'm still...
Kara Swisher
Here's the deal. [Laughs] Okay. Here's the deal. You wanted a rabbit coat. I'm not getting you a rabbit coat, but I got you a very soft stuffed rabbit because I have 400 of them as a new parent now. And I felt like it was a nice – it was sort of a comfort rabbit for you. It's very soft. Is that correct?
Scott Galloway
It's very – Yeah, it's very nice. I give it to my 9-year-old and he has it in the zoo that is his bed every night.
Kara Swisher
Fantastic. Well, that's your rabbit, Scott. You really need to like talk to it. You could give—it's the thing you give before you give a rabbit coat, which you keep demanding from me for some reason, something to do with your parents and a rabbit coat and everything else. And I thought I would start off by giving you a rabbit to start with. I thought about a live rabbit. I thought about a live rabbit. I thought about a boiled rabbit, like if we were in Fatal Attraction. I thought about a lot of rabbit situations.
Scott Galloway
I just had a gangster idea. I'm one of the jerks that's abusing the FAA system and has turned my vichla into a comfort dog. and I have this special harness that says comfort dog. I'm going to put it on that toy little stuffed rabbit and take it on a plane with big Jackie Onassis glasses petting my stuffed rabbit and having it. It'll be my comfort rabbit.
Kara Swisher
Listen to me. I don't believe you do that with your dog.
Scott Galloway
Are you kidding me? They're not on to your ridiculous scam. You're not.
Kara Swisher
Oh, God. Yeah, no. It's JetBlue. You don't have to pay them, right? Because of you, I'm being recognized on planes now. I like to get on planes last and people go, hey, man, love the podcast. I'm like, do not talk to me in public. If you hold the rabbit, they won't. I do not deal well with praise.
You like being famous. If it wasn't there, you'd be so sad.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. There's a lot going on. There's a lot to talk about. It never stops. It never freaking stops. This is like a crazy, like I literally slept all day yesterday. But here's the deal. Here's the deal. There's a couple of things. I was going to talk about Ivanka Trump on the stage at CES, which was just horrifying on so many levels. But then Facebook drops news, as usual, on a day where no one's going to pay attention, which they're not going to—trying to say they're for ad transparency, and they released a whole bunch of stuff around giving people control over ads, political ads. They saw what they didn't say, which was they're not changing their ad policy about lying politicians.
So this morning, they obviously gave the story to both The New York Times and Washington Post, But Facebook, as my Mike Isaac said on Thursday, it would not make any major changes to its political advertising policies, which allows lies and ads despite pressure from lawmakers who say the company is abdicating responsibility for what appears on the platform. It was part of a bigger announcement they made about how they're going to manage political ads on their platforms. Yeah, that's right. What do we think about this?
Well, it's just to think the most powerful network in the world with the greatest reach has decided that it's now a war of disinformation, that we have truly become kind of Kremlin-style propaganda. And this is indefensible. I believe that every movement, absolutely every narrative, every word, every action, every coffee or latte that's poured at Facebook headquarters is all headed towards one direction. And that is how do we make Facebook shareholders wealthier regardless of the teen depression, the damage to the Commonwealth, or how it tears at the fabric of our society. And to a certain extent, I get it, and that's why I own their stock. But we have a serious, feckless administration, lawmakers, FTC, DOJ that won't step in and say, look, there's been a fairness in advertising, political advertising act on the Senate floor for a long time. And because of the Freedom Caucus, we can't get just basic IQ legislation through. So I think it's really disappointing.
Kara Swisher
Can you talk also a little bit about, I mean, when they announce what a shocker, they're not going to do anything that gets in the way of them making another nickel. The controversy around Vogue, did you see what happened with the Facebook post on Vogue?
Scott Galloway
What happened?
Kara Swisher
Yeah, that was a strange. Well, in this case, I don't blame Facebook. Look, all these companies try to buy those infomercials essentially. It's called SponCon, which is sponsored content. I don't know where that word came from, but whatever. What happened was they put it up like it was a real article. It was interviews with women who work on their elections team, including Katie Harbeth and some others. Very lovely picture of them, one of those Vogue kind of pictures. And then a story that was largely laudatory about their incredibly extreme efforts to work for our people. That kind of thing, which was, look, if it's editorial content that Facebook buys, I don't fault Facebook for doing that.
I fault Condé Nast for not labeling it correctly. And then, it's interesting to see that Facebook's trying to look nicer in the press, essentially. But that's an interesting thing. But what a surprise. They think they put a thing on it and then took a thing off of it saying what it was. And then it disappeared after people like Sheryl Sandberg had tweeted it, which, again, I don't fault her for tweeting it either. It is what it is. It's a positive story about Facebook. And so anyway, it just looked. It was a bad look on Cunningness. But, the fact that we think some of these magazine companies and things like that don't do this constantly is kind of on us.
But they do. And so they had to sort of apologize. And Teen Vogue, which had sort of a real looming for a while there under their editor who left, is now just online. Remember, they closed down. It was a project of Anna Wintour to start it in the first place. And now it's just an online publication. Anyway, it was just like, it was just another, well, oh, well, just the constant degrading of our standards, pretty much.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, it reminds me, I was interviewing Josh Brown, who I think is really impressive. He's the president or CEO, maybe, of Ritholtz Management. And I was just indignant about all the internet analysts from these investment banks that were about to write a buy on WeWork at a valuation of $48 billion. And he said, Scott, get over it. Everybody who knows anything knows that these companies aren't in the business of honest analysis. They're in the business of pumping and marketing these stocks. And to a certain extent, when you're reading Vogue, I mean, they're not in the business of journalism, right?
Do you remember when they did this fascinating story with this spread, this kind of glamorama shot of Marissa Mayer? And then what do you know? It was announced a few weeks later or a few weeks before that she was, yeah, who was sponsoring the Met Ball to the tune of $3 million. Yep, yep. So the notion that there's a wall between journalists and advertisers, no, there's not. There never has been. It's not even a curb. And the reality is it's pay to play. About the moment Net-A-Porter went into competition with these guys and launched their own magazine, Porter, which I actually think is a pretty well-done magazine, they stopped writing puff pieces on Natalie Massonet about what an impressive female leader she is.
So, yeah, I kind of agree with you. Shame on us. But the notion, it just seems especially brazen to have an article. I mean, some editor really had to close their eyes and put their hands over their ears and say, OK, we're going to talk about how Facebook is helping protect us.
Kara Swisher
And then the second thing they did was announce this whole deepfake videos, which they were yesterday, too. There's a lot of announcements out of Facebook this week. Facebook also said it's banning deepfakes, which allow videos to use AI to change what figures in a video are saying. They came under fire for that manipulated video of Speaker Pelosi that made her appear like she was drunk and slurring, unlike the speech that Trump gave the other day where he looked like he was on Adderall, which is what the internet was talking about. But it still was the minimum they can do, and it wouldn't have pulled that video off because it went through a fact-checking process and then they labeled it. And so this minimum effort by Facebook and maximum effort on your part to figure it out is part of their plan. Like that to me is the most depressing part of this.
Scott Galloway
But the deepfake thing, they will – I'm pretty sure and they're already doing it. They'll announce that deepfakes are a threat to our democracy and we're going to run some shitty software that catches 3 percent of them. But what it is is the following. When an illusionist is on stage, he or she will create a distraction such that you don't see that they're about to fool you with their right hand, right? And that's what the deepfake quote-unquote fix from Facebook is. And that is an illusionist trick, a distraction from the fact that politicians can lie. And whoever has kind of the backbone or the lack of moral clarity or whatever bad actor has decided to lie on behalf of someone else on this platform and leverage kind of what's scary that a lot of the content you get from Facebook is from other people you trust.
So if something's forwarded to you from your mom, right, and it's an ad and it says this is a political ad. that looks like it has some production quality, you're just sort of inclined to believe it. Even if you know it's fake, a little bit of the message will stick. That's the real damage here. That's the real, again, that's why, again, Facebook plays a different set of rules than some of the other folks who we lean on for information and why Facebook, I mean, it's just sort of a, it emblematic of how just incredibly damaging Facebook is and again and buttresses this notion that Mark Zuckerberg and Sheryl Sandberg will go down in history as the people who done the most damage while making the most money in the history of modern business.
Kara Swisher
You know, interesting. I was, someone was debating that. There was a story in the Times about Rupert Murdoch's publications in Australia trying to, not to blame arsonists and something, I don't know, whatever matches for the problem in Australia. The terrible, obviously, climate change-induced problems in Australia. And I was trying to, I think I tweeted something like, I think the most damaging person is this man who continues to, like, everywhere he goes, spews hate, disinformation, and damage, real damage. Rupert, your old boss?
Scott Galloway
Yeah, it was just sort of like, it was going to be my fail. But to me, they're the most damaging because they do it on purpose and with such purpose. This is something else that is so disturbing because they do think they're right about what they're doing. Rupert Murdoch knows just what he's doing, if that makes sense. And so it's just an insidious situation. I don't know what to say because I agree with the stuff that Facebook is doing is just as bad in lots of ways. But, it didn't prevent a government from doing anything about fires, like that are actually hurting, killing billions of animals or millions of animals in Australia. It's interesting because you're more, you're hopeful about big tech in a weird way. I'm kind of hopeful about Fox because I've gotten to know some of the people there and I like them. And I think at some point they occasionally throw up their arms what Tucker said about the bombing in Iran. I thought that was a moment of integrity. I think Neil Cavuto has tremendous integrity as a journalist. I'm more hopeful, I think, about Fox than you are, but you know them better. You work for them.
Kara Swisher
I didn't.
Scott Galloway
The problem with an administration, there's an attention graph, and attention arguably is our most valuable resource. And unfortunately, we're allocating too much of the most valuable resource in the world to these dumpster fires from an administration that just wants to be in the headlines every day in such that we can't focus on things like income inequality. We can't focus on trying to put a man or a woman on Mars. We can't focus on how we solve global hunger or malaria. We have to focus on what stupid thing the administration has done in the last hour. And one of the things I did last night was I went online to read a little bit more about, I mean, we have a continent that's on fire right now.
And what's interesting is it's climate change, but it's also weather variability. It's like the mother of all bad things that have happened to Australia. The winds from the Antarctic are late this year. The monsoon rains came early. So not only is the place dry, it's not wet. It is climate change, but it's also the perfect storm of kind of bad natural things that have lit this country on fire. And I have a bit of a rant here, and this is just because I want to cause a lot. I want to have more people hate me on Twitter.
Kara Swisher
Oh, good.
Scott Galloway
But I think about 40 people have died, 40 humans. Let's call them 40 species of the human have died. And they estimate approximately a billion animals have died, right? So, what's the difference among these species that, where a billion dies and only 40 million? And it's largely because we as a species have access to more resources and more information than animals who get caught and burn alive, right? And I'm convinced that effectively what we have is our society, run now by baby boomer generation, the most selfish generation in history across Western society, has effectively decided that they're kind of, they're comfortable and they're down with climate change. We'll talk a big game about it, but at the end of the day, we're comfortable because I think implicitly leaders and wealthy people or people who are middle income have decided that climate change will impact the people with the fewest resources and options among our species. and that you and I, Cara, and again, this may be wrong, but I generally believe it. I think climate change is going to be on a massive level over the next 50 years, but I think you and I are going to be just fine because we have resources.
Kara Swisher
Well, yeah, of course. When a hurricane hits Florida, I call my family. I'm like, no, don't think about it. Just get out, and they're fine. And then Katrina hits. Who gets hit hardest? The poor.
Scott Galloway
So I think we've made a conscious decision globally that we're down with climate change because fossil fuels are incredibly, incredibly accretive in terms of shareholder value.
Kara Swisher
I don't agree with you. I think you're completely wrong. I think young people.
Scott Galloway
Let me finish.
Kara Swisher
All right, we're going to get to this. We have a listener mail about this.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, but that—agree, but it's nothing but a transfer of wealth from the poor to the rich and from the young to the old who, A, have to deal with this shit, choking on it, and, B, I think we've effectively sang to the world that if a billion people get displaced and slowly get murdered because of typhoid, malaria, diarrhea, whatever it is, we're down with that as long as the three billion who are the wealthiest can continue this incredible arb around fossil fuels. And what I don't like about Democrats is this bullshit narrative that all the requisite investment we need to make to move to a carbon neutral world is going to create jobs and be economically accretive. No, it's not. It's going to be expensive. And it should be because it's important. But anyways, another massive transfer of wealth from the poor to the rich.
Kara Swisher
You like that transfer of the rich to the poor. That's my big narrative. It's been going on since the beginning of fucking time. But okay. All right. Fine. Whatever. There you go. Where don't the rich do well? I mean, honestly, every place, every, oh, please, listen to me. We're going to throw it to the break after this, but I just want to mention one last thing about the, I'm going back to Facebook. There was an essay by, a memo by Andrew Bosworth, who also in this area, about saying how much he wanted Trump to lose, but that we shouldn't stop him from winning this time, Facebook. And he was talking about not wanting to do anything possible to make him lose, and yet he would not do it, and he compared it, let me just read this quote because it was too much, to Lord of the Ring.
He goes, I desperately find myself wanting to pull any lever at my disposal to avoid the same result. So what stays my hand? This guy thinks he's a writer. Whatever. I find myself thinking, what stays my hand? Thinking of the Lord of the Rings at this moment. Specifically, when Frodo offers the ring to Galidriel. I don't watch this that well. And imagines using the power righteously at first, but knows it will eventually corrupt her. If you ask it of me, I will give you the one ring. you offer it to me freely. I do not deny that my heart has greatly desired this. And he apparently spelled the name of this character with an A, not an E.
As tempting as it is to use the tools available to us to change the outcome, I am confident we must never do that and we become what we fear. Now listen to me, Mr. Bosworth. You don't have to have fair things. You don't have to like push it towards Trump. But what you can't do is you create a situation where it advantages him. This is my rant. This is just like Mark's free speech speech. This is bullshit, Andrew Bosworth. This is ridiculous. Your thoughts for 2020, to me, are all about someone who just doesn't have any kind of—can't think critically. It's just astonishing. And you can talk all you want about the shortcomings of Facebook, and you've been late to do this, but the fact of the matter is you didn't do your jobs in keeping your network clean.
It has nothing to do with you intervening in the election because you have this ridiculous Jesus complex of power that you don't have. It's just – it reveals so much about Facebook and the people who run it more than it does about anything else. And so I have to call bullshit on this ridiculous essay.
Scott Galloway
I like Andrew Bosworth, but it's just – it's just – just – I like Andrew Bosworth too. I'm disappointed. After a great college career as a linebacker, he failed in the NFL and then went on to be a mediocre film star. Oh, wait, that's a different Bosworth. But you know what? Pop references are very important. And you know what? You and I have been paid a handsome bounty by Trinet and Mack Weldon underwear to go after people, total bitches that are full of shit. So, Mr. Bosworth, the Mandadogians, Kara and Scott are coming for you. Mack Weldon does his job. My kids love those underwears. It's safe in protecting baby Yoda. Let's just say, Mack Weldon's underwears are excellent. Facebook's efforts here are not. And any reference to Lord of the Rings makes me want to just—I just really want to lose—I lose it when they start that bullshit. It brought us Vito Morganson. That guy's a movie star. Eastern Promises. Great movie.
Kara Swisher
Okay. All right. We're going to take a break. We'll be right back with Listener Mail. It's about us. Thank you for the rabbits. I'm here with my rabbits. Just pet the rabbits, Scott. And then some wins, fails, and predictions.
Ad Break
The Disney Plus Hulu HBO Max Bundle. Plans starting at just $16.99 a month. No one will ever break us apart. Catch Marvel Studios' Thunderbolts The New Avengers on Disney Plus. You can't escape the past. Alien Earth on Hulu. This ship collected monsters. And Final Destination Bloodlines on HBO Max. Death is coming for our family. The Disney Plus Hulu HBO Max Bundle. Plans starting at $16.99 a month. All these and more streaming soon. Visit Disney plus Hulu, HBO, Max bundle.com for details.
Scott Galloway
This episode is brought to you by Amazon Prime. From streaming to shopping, Prime helps you get more out of your passions. So whether you're a fan of true crime or prefer a nail biting novel from time to time, with services like Prime Video, Amazon Music, and fast free delivery, Prime makes it easy to get more out of whatever you're into or getting into. Visit Amazon.com slash Prime to learn more.
Kara Swisher
[Reading listener mail] "Hi, Kara and Scott. My name is Rob and I'm calling from Sydney, Australia. I'm a big fan of the show. I'm calling in regards to the bushfires that are currently burning across Australia. This is the worst fire season that we've ever seen. Around 40 people have died or are missing. Millions of animals unique to Australia have died and 50,000 square miles have gone. We also have a climate change-denying government who have dragged their feet in response to this catastrophe. Given we are more likely to see natural disasters in the future, is there a place for tech in responding to them?"
Scott Galloway
Well, that is a good question. I like your accent too, Rob and Sydney.
Kara Swisher
Doesn't he sound dreamy? He sounds sad and dreamy. Don't you want to comfort him? Send him a rabbit.
Scott Galloway
No, I don't.
Kara Swisher
Send him a rabbit. Listen to me. This is a serious situation. Yes, I do think, as I wrote recently in the New York Times, I do think there is a lot of, not just the right thing to do, but there's a lot of money to be made in whoever figures out this climate tech issues. And so there's all kinds of different technologies. Right now, a lot of the tech is around cleaning up, essentially removing carbon from the atmosphere that's already there, cleaning the oceans, things like that. So a lot of it is stuff that's, to me, not really the point. I think the stuff we have to focus on, you talked about using fossil fuels, is these technologies that do not use that and have different ways of creating the kind of things we want.
The other thing is the ability of certain tech to sort of watch and know what going to happen and AI to pattern it There all kinds of different things going on with materials There all kinds of solutions from tech none of which is sort of the silver bullet but there not a lot of money put to this. And the only two people that are really investing from a big point of view would be Bill Gates and Elon Musk. So yes, absolutely. I think that beyond the stuff of, Facebook's doing crisis check-in and things like that, there's all kinds of things that tech could do and he's not doing to make this a better planet.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, I worry, Kara, that falling back to a capitalist solution and waiting for the next Elon Musk to address the world's most urgent problems creates cold comfort and creates a gestalt that is dangerous. And that is that if we just expect that we're going to find a company, an individual to come up with a great idea that will create trillions in shareholder value and we'll come up with some elegant, easy solution to it, I think it creates a certain level of dangerous complacency. And I think around climate change, there's just no getting around it. It's going to be really expensive, and we need our leaders to stop irresponsibly allocating capital and essentially creating a policy that reflates asset prices with incredible debt that is nothing but a transfer of time with families and loved ones from our grandkids to us.
and to behave more responsibly and have an adult conversation that if, hey, if somebody, if some kid from MIT shows up and comes with a solution to clear the plastic out of the oceans, fantastic, make him or her a trillionaire. But until then, let's assume this shit is going to be hard and expensive and that we're going to have to pay for it. And the government is the one just as they arrested the AIDS virus or helped with that, they invented the internet with a massive investment in technology through DARPA, just as they made a massive investment to turn back Hitler. We have to make a massive investment as a society.
And it's going to mean we're not going to have as many Hershey bars to be able to get a stake, which is what happened during World War II, to address this war on climate change. But I worry, and I'm not accusing you of anything, but I think we have to be very careful to believe that technology and some, and shareholder value and capitalism is going to fix this.
Kara Swisher
See, I'm trying to appeal to anything. Their greed is something I'd like to appeal to. I'd like them to make more investments here to make breakthroughs and things like that. Because I don't think the greatest minds are being applied to these issues.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, I think that's right.
Kara Swisher
That's what I mean. It's that, look, if you're not going to do it because it's the right thing, if our government's not going to do it, maybe you'll do it because you're greedy. Like in material sciences or, there's all kinds of ways to handle this. It does get to a point where we have to, like, live a certain way. You're right. You have to change the way you actually live unless there are technologies. And we didn't think there would be technologies of trains, of planes, of anything else long ago. So, I just think the stuff we can't imagine that we should start to imagine. And that's what I'd like to see. That's why I'd like to see it, as research projects and things like that. I think it's long past time that major tech people should get deeply involved in this issue. And they're not. They're just not. They're not there in a way that they need to be. That was my point. And I was trying to appeal to their feeling of being the world's first trillionaire. Anyway, thank you very much from Sydney. Rob, we really appreciate it. Thank you, Rob. And best of luck to you. By the way, we stand with our Australian. Have you been to Australia?
Scott Galloway
Yes, many times. It is. Talk about an interesting, maverick, fun, impressive people in a place of just incredible natural beauty. Every time you go to Australia, within 48 hours, you're like, okay, I want to move here. I want to live here. And then within a week, you're like, it's just too damn far. We would all live in Australia if it wasn't literally on the other side of the world.
Kara Swisher
My nephew lives there, and I love it there. And I've visited him in Melbourne. Now he lives in Sydney. It's wonderful. All right. We're going to wins and fails. You know, one that we left behind was CES. My fail is obviously the Consumer Electronics Association with Ivanka Trump talking about tech. I just— Did you hear anything about the speech?
Scott Galloway
I haven't heard anything about it.
Kara Swisher
It just was—nothing, nothing. She's the least—if they wanted to talk about—actually address this issue around STEM and everything else, they should bring in someone who actually was the expert. Someone's daughter talking about things, like whatever topic she wants to. It's just—the president's daughter is just not—she's not qualified to talk about this. And it was one, she was talking about retraining and this and that, which is one of her areas. I just, there's so much nepotism and lack of qualification. I don't know where to begin. And it's just typical. The CES, I was there for a very brief second, not even at any of the CES events, doing something with Snapchat. But it just is really, it was just another step that this is the most irrelevant gathering around. And nothing really much happens there. It used to be a big deal.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, so you think CES has lost some of its value or luster?
Yeah, lost, completely lost. Things don't come out that way. People don't make announcements. It's such an old, antiquated way of doing things. I'm sort of like, let's get the wagon out of the... it's just not the way people do announcements anymore. They do some of them, but it's all stuff you already knew. None of the really important companies go there, and they don't make their important announcements. They save those when they want to make them instead of waiting for one time a year. And then just being in Vegas with all those people at the one time.
Kara Swisher
They do get players though.
Scott Galloway
So my question is, I've only been once, and it was 10 or 12 years ago. Every year I say I'm going to go because I need to learn more about specific technologies. And I want to go because the dog likes to roll in Vegas. He's a lot of fun at a craps table.
Kara Swisher
I can imagine. On seven makers and ginger, baby needs new shoes. We would have so much fun in Vegas. Think about it.
Scott Galloway
Anyways, they must be doing something right in their defense because they get a lot of players. I know a lot of people that go to Vegas and you see the biggest names or some of the biggest names in tech go there. So what are they doing right?
Kara Swisher
They go there for advertisers. No, I just think it's a gathering. There are certain quiet gatherings off to the side that are the really helpful ones, I guess. But no, there's absolutely nothing happening in tech there as far as I can tell. They did have a really interesting discussion with some FTC commissioners and others going back and forth on regulation. But that happens all year round. This is not a particular place to do it. I think it's a place to meet advertisers and if you're selling certain electronics, it's fine. But in terms of being the place where the big announcements are made, it's just not. It used to be that. And before that, Comdex for computers. But it's not anymore. Bringing in Ivanka Trump is so cynical. This is a group of people that many years ago did this thing to get women interested in tech. They had a display of pink-colored technologies, and I just wanted to kill myself. Kill somebody? I literally was like, I'm going to run through this with one of the Humvees.
Scott Galloway
By the way, because I'm so bored with this, I'm thinking about other things right now. I want to say thank you. I like this notion of turning on the lights when you're talking about a problem. This is a total segue, or not even a segue, a non-segue. But you kind of illuminated or got me thinking about two different issues I hadn't been thinking about, and I like that. The dog likes to be thoughtful every once in a while. When we were talking, remember when I was doing my win last week on *Lost in Space*?
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Scott Galloway
And you talked about the professor who was sort of the evil guy of the show?
Kara Swisher
Mm-hmm.
Scott Galloway
And you immediately said, "Oh, you mean the gay guy." And you had brought up a few weeks ago this movie I haven't seen called *The Celluloid Closet* talking about how media...
Kara Swisher
Did you watch it?
Scott Galloway
I haven't seen it. I want to.
Kara Swisher
Of course not. I will see it. Just don't send it to me with a stuffed animal.
Scott Galloway
It's coming. You had basically said, and I was aware of this, but not to the extent that you highlighted it, that as young people, young straight people, we were basically trained to think that there was something wrong with the gay community. And then I look back to that show, and that guy was clearly, I mean, put an ask on him, and he was Charles Nelson Reilly. He was clearly gay, right? But when I was watching it at the age of nine...
Kara Swisher
No, it was gay semaphore. It wasn't gay. It was these qualities of... it was also so subversive, but it wasn't. It was apparent and subversive at the same time, where gay people always end up either evil or silly or dead.
Scott Galloway
Right, 100%. The stereotypical effects of a gay man are associated with someone who's devious, can't be trusted, is bottom line evil. And I was thinking, I was watching that at the age of eight, nine, and ten, along with my favorite show, where a beautiful woman was asked to go to her bottle, and then would occasionally come out of the bottle and say, "Yes, master." That's what I grew up on. And you brought to light for me just how insidious that kind of stuff is. And the second thing you brought up, when we're looking at problems, we have a tendency, I think the analogy I would use, we're in a room with a flashlight trying to find answers. And I've been thinking a lot about AB5. And you sort of turned on the lights when you said, I think it was last week or a couple weeks ago, you said, "This is all about health care." That if we were to figure out a way to get people access to health care that didn't bankrupt them or keep them healthy, we wouldn't be talking about the need for different classification of workers. That was sort of an unlock for me. Anyways, Kara, you've turned on the lights in a couple rooms for me.
Kara Swisher
You're a woke-a-rotty, as some dumb writer wrote. A woke-a-rotty. All right. I need your wins and fails. That was my fail. And the win is Harvey Weinstein going into trial. With the walker? He's obviously... Whatever, just shove that guy into prison as far as I can. That's a win.
Scott Galloway
You're ready for the big house for Harvey?
Kara Swisher
Yeah, we'll see if he wheedles out of it. But the women who have done this are so brave. Even with this ridiculous backlash about it, there's been recently some writers... there's a book I'm reading that is irritating me to no end about this idea of things going too far. I just think it's great that this has happened. Sorry, I just feel good about it. That's my win. What's your win and fail?
Scott Galloway
My win is my favorite comedian is Michelle Wolf, and she has a new show on Netflix called *Joke Show*. You love her.
Kara Swisher
You love her.
Scott Galloway
And I think she's a genius. I think a lot about how do you disarticulate what genius is. Is it practice, commitment? Malcolm Gladwell did an interesting book on genius. And I think also a key component of genius is being literally unafraid. Like, you just never look in the mirror and worry about what you look like. Lenny Bruce said very offensive things. I think Richard Pryor was massively offensive at the time. And these people were just unafraid. I think Michelle Wolf talks about, in a very vulgar way, and I'm a vulgar person, so I relate to her, some of these issues that people don't want to talk about out loud.
I think she's hilarious. I think her comedic timing... I think she's an incredibly impressive comedian, and I do think she qualifies as a genius because she's just unafraid. So it's on Netflix. It's called *Joke Show*. I think it's fantastic. And another quick shout to another strong, courageous, fiery woman: Stephanie Ruhle just got promoted at NBC. She's going to be on the *Today Show*, which is kind of the Hall of Lame every morning, but it is the Super Bowl of broadcast-supported TV. And she's going to be doing more business reporting for *NBC Nightly News*. I met Stephanie 12 or 14 years ago, and of course I'm turning this back to me.
They accidentally called the marketing department at NYU and said, "We need someone to come on and talk about Facebook." And I went on with Pimm Fox, who I love, and Deirdre Bolton, who I adore. And then I started going on with Stephanie Ruhle and Erik Schatzker. He's this super handsome, nice Canadian guy who fishes. I'm coming back as him in my next life. But anyways, Stephanie took me with her to MSNBC, and I do a bunch of stuff with her. I love the way she talks about courage and fearlessness and not watching yourself. I think Stephanie is part of a dying group of people, what I call raging moderates.
And she's unafraid and takes a lot of risks. It's just nice to see her career maintain that kind of trajectory.
Kara Swisher
We will have her along with you at the Code Conference. There you go. We're both going to be there together. Anyways, congratulations to Stephanie Ruhle and watch *Joke Show* with Michelle Wolf. All right. Fail, please.
Scott Galloway
So, look, my continued fail, I've been thinking a lot about this, is this concerted decision we've made. I did a post last week on my blog, *No Mercy, No Malice*, or profgalloway.com, called "The Unremarkables." I think about back when I was in graduate school, the tuition was $1,400, and I got a job at $90,000, yielding a quick ratio ROI of MBA of 60. And now kids are getting out of high school, making somewhere between $125,000 and $145,000, which is an amazing living. But their tuition is $62,000, creating an ROI of two. If you look at what's happened very loosely or crudely across the decisions we've decided to make, or the voters or the people in power, again, baby boomers across our central banks, we've decided in a global coordinated effort to massively reflate the economy at the expense of future generations with massive debt.
What you have right now is more debt. If you took away the amount of debt we're making, it exceeds the positive GDP growth. So without this artificially inflated economy with debt, we'd probably already be in recession because we've decided that we need to massively inflate current assets, which benefits who? Old people. Meanwhile, we've let wage growth stagnate and we let tuition increase. We basically said as a public policy across Western nations, "You know what, young people? Fuck you. I have mine and I want to hold on to it." So the continued feudalism, the continued sharecropping of our leadership...
we have decided to totally disinvest from future generations in the form of massive increases in the cost of education despite the fact the wages are the same. Another ratio: when I got out of business school, a house in San Francisco was $285,000. I got a job for like $90,000, although I decided to start my own company, Profits. So you had a three-to-one ratio. Again, now it's, let's assume, $140,000. The average price of a home in San Francisco is 10x. So everything that gets in the way of young people starting families, starting businesses... we have literally declared war. It's like Andrew Yang's book, *The War on Normal People*.
We have made a decision around how we create monetary and fiscal policy, around what generations do the best and the worst. The reality is you can be very ageist, and we have decided literally to continue to transfer more wealth from our young people. Anyways, that's my rant. That's my fail, the feudalism of the current leadership.
Kara Swisher
I think you're right. I think about the young people, although I give everything to my children. I think you do, too. Whenever they eat even a sandwich, they eat all my sandwiches, everything else. But yes, I agree with you completely. What really struck me, I did a podcast with my whole family this week, which was a fascinating little insight into my world.
Scott Galloway
On *Recode Decode*?
Kara Swisher
Yes, *Recode Decode*. That was the whole Swisher family. And one of the... besides Lucky going on and on about, you know, you've got a vision into someone who Trump has manipulated, and so has Fox News. My son talking about worrying... he's about to turn 18 years old... worrying about being drafted. It came out of nowhere.
Scott Galloway
He's worried about being drafted?
Kara Swisher
Yeah, because of the Iran thing. He was like, "Well, maybe I'll be drafted." And I was like, "Whoa, whoa." So the fact that this weighs on him for this ridiculous, whatever happened last week between Trump and Iran, this whole ridiculous playing games with something that's so serious was brought into stark relief for me. When he mentioned that, I have to say...
Scott Galloway
All right, Scott, you didn't do predictions on Tuesday so that you could dazzle us with your brilliance on Friday. No pressure. What's your prediction?
Yeah, I do have a prediction. All right. I think what you're going to see is, there are massive inbound cyber attacks on the U.S. and attempts to hack different databases or different digital reservoirs, digital caches in the U.S. I think you're about to see an explosion in cyber attacks and hacks. Because if I were the GRU or the Mossad or the intelligence arm of the North Korean government, I'd be thinking, "Okay, it's not open season, but almost any cyber attack of any real danger or credibility, let's leave some breadcrumbs behind. Let's execute the attack through a VPN that runs through Iran."
Every national security agency, domestic security agency is going to immediately default to, "Well, it must be Iran attacking us," which has the double negative of emboldening a lot of other foreign governments to step up and become more brazen in their attacks on the U.S. So that's the first thing that's going to happen. The result is there's going to be a couple attacks that will work, that will get a lot of press. And you're going to see the stocks take a basket of Zscaler, Palo Alto Networks, and Cloudflare, none of which I have a position in. They're going to be up 20% to 30% this year as these cyber attacks committed by governments and bad actors are emboldened by our shit-for-brains, catastrophic geopolitical decision called the White House.
You're going to see the stocks of cybersecurity companies go up 20% to 30% in the next six to nine months.
Kara Swisher
Oh, that's a good one, Scott. That's good. It has money and it has bigger world implications. That's a really substantive one.
Scott Galloway
You're always so supportive around my predictions and I thank you.
Kara Swisher
Thank you. I have one. I want you to think about it. We're going to talk about it on Monday. Twitter in play.
Scott Galloway
Twitter in play. Say more.
Kara Swisher
By the way, full disclosure, I'm a shareholder. I hear things. I just hear things.
Scott Galloway
Really?
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Scott Galloway
Are you starting something? You know, you talked about it being the lower than... I don't know. I just feel like a lot of investors are looking at it. Looking at it hard.
Kara Swisher
Well, so I can validate, I can confirm your thesis here, Kara.
Scott Galloway
Okay. All right. Yeah, and so say more because I feel funny talking about this, but I want you to talk about it.
Kara Swisher
I'm just saying, hard. People are looking at that company hard, especially given how the stock is not performing and the big value around it that people feel they have in terms of being the news distribution. I'm just going to take the ball and run with it a little bit here. But if you were to talk about any other media company that has anything regarding the reach and influence of Twitter, it trades at 20 to 40 times the valuation.
Scott Galloway
Right. Well, just a lot of noise. You and I love Twitter, don't we?
Kara Swisher
I know. We do. But I'm just saying, I'm hearing a lot of investor noise suddenly.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. No, I think you're right, as evidenced by I'm voting with my wallet here. But what do you think of this idea of them banning or making it such that you can't reply unless that person is following you?
Kara Swisher
I like it.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, I like it, too.
Kara Swisher
I like it. It cleans up the... I like what they're doing. They still should be doing so many more things. They have not worked on that product at all for a long time. I do think that they should be doing more and be more creative.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. I think the... I'm writing about innovation and where it comes from this week. And I find them to be like... they could do so much more on that platform.
Kara Swisher
100%. Snapchat has evolved. Everybody has evolved their things. Even Facebook has evolved its platform. Twitter feels very 2016.
Scott Galloway
Yes. They need to do something about it.
Kara Swisher
Yes. Anyway, that's my prediction. We'll see what happens because I've had some good luck on the predictions. I'm getting good because of adjacency to you.
Scott Galloway
Anyway, I'm just thinking harder. Adjacency to me. That's the sexiest thing you've said to the dog. That's as close as I'm getting to adjacent.
Kara Swisher
That's right. Adjacent on up to the dog. That's right. He's just come from the groomer. That's right. You need to be groomed if I'm going to be adjacent to you. I get it. I'm glad you're finally in touch with your emotions.
Scott Galloway
A little hot for daddy. I get it. A little hot for doggie.
Kara Swisher
No, God, Jesus. Honestly, you take any good moment and turn it into that.
Scott Galloway
I showered this morning. I did shower this morning.
Kara Swisher
Okay, it's time to go. Obviously, it's time to go. You've obviously woken up. And we'll be back together in New York on Monday. Are you going to be here physically in person speaking with Jason?
Scott Galloway
I'm coming back to New York. We're doing it together? We're in the same studio?
Kara Swisher
I'm in New York. Yes, I'm in New York because I have to talk to Paul Ryan next week, which I'm just...
Scott Galloway
You're talking to Paul Ryan, the Wisconsin guy?
Kara Swisher
Well, I just don't. It'll have happened when I see you maybe. So, yes.
Scott Galloway
For *Recode Decode*?
Kara Swisher
No, it's some event, the NRF event, and we're going to be on stage together. I don't know how I'm going to whisper a string myself.
Scott Galloway
That means mommy's making some cabbage. You've totally been paid for that.
Kara Swisher
No, I'm not. I didn't get paid for it. I'm doing it for whatever reason. Don't even ask me. But I'm just not going to be able to hold back. If this guy makes one sideways glance at me in a way that like, "Hey, I had nothing to do with it," I'm really going to pounce. I'm sorry, Paul Ryan. I'm warning you in advance.
Scott Galloway
Very likable. Paul Ryan is very likable.
Kara Swisher
Oh, no, no. No? You don't think he's likable?
Scott Galloway
I think he's very likable.
Kara Swisher
No, no. Anyway, I'm also interviewing Ben Silbermann. I've got a lot going on next week, but I will be here for you.
Scott Galloway
Ben Silbermann is Pinterest?
Kara Swisher
Yes, yes, yes.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, Ben's nice. Ben's a nice guy.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, he's really nice. Anyway, we're going to be together in the same studio. I'm very excited. So I'm excited to see you. Thank you. Likewise. Sort of. Anyway, I would love you to read your line that you're supposed to read, but I shall read it for you. As always, if you have questions about a story you're hearing in the news, for us to answer next week, questionspivotatvoxmedia.com. Please send us anything you want to talk about, and we will be happy to respond if it's a really good one. Good. And today's show was produced by Rebecca Sinanis. Erica Anderson is Pivot's executive producer. Thanks also to Rebecca Castro and Drew Burrows. Make sure you've subscribed to the show on Apple Podcasts, or if you're an Android user, check us out on Spotify, or frankly, wherever you listen to podcasts. If you like the show, please recommend it to a friend. Did I just repeat you, Kara?
Scott Galloway
No, you didn't.
Kara Swisher
Okay, good.
Scott Galloway
You got it right, except you missed... Thanks for listening to Pivot from Vox Media. We'll be back next week for another breakdown of all things tech and business.
Kara Swisher
Word, my sister, word. Thank you.