Main Topic: The episode discusses various topics related to technology, business, and politics, including the impact of social media on kids, the regulation of tech companies, and the potential for tech executives to be held personally responsible for their actions.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Kara Swisher
Support for this show comes from Robinhood. Wouldn't it be great to manage your portfolio on one platform? With Robinhood, not only can you trade individual stocks and ETFs, you can also seamlessly buy and sell crypto at low costs. Trade all in one place. Get started now on Robinhood. Trading crypto involves significant risk. Crypto trading is offered through an account with Robinhood Crypto LLC. Robinhood Crypto is licensed to engage in virtual currency business activity by the New York State Department of Financial Services. Crypto held through Robinhood Crypto is not FDIC-insured or SIPC-protected. Investing involves risk, including loss of principal. Securities trading is offered through an account with Robinhood Financial LLC, member SIPC, a registered broker-dealer.
Let's play Burlington's Guess That Price. Back to school means back to saving. We're bringing you kids' jeans starting at, hold on a minute, just $11.99. Burlington's acing this test. What about character backpacks? We've got them starting at $12.99. Burlington's done it again. How about sneakers for the kids? A-plus brands and right on trend starting at $11.99. Saving is now in session. Burlington. Deals. Brands. Wow. Styles and selections vary by location.
Hi, everyone. This is Pivot from the Vox Media Podcast Network. I'm Kara Swisher.
Scott Galloway
And I'm Scott Galloway. And, Kara, it is impossible for me to do my job with the president's tweets. It's impossible. I am beyond my limit.
Kara Swisher
[Laughs] I thought you were saying my tweets.
Scott Galloway
I am not coordinating with him. This is entirely independent and an expression of my leadership and integrity. It is impossible.
Kara Swisher
This is not cooked. The president is referring to me, right? You cannot. You're referring to me and my tweets. Is that correct?
Scott Galloway
So it's pretty obvious what's going on there.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. It's pretty obvious. Yeah.
Scott Galloway
They're having sex.
Kara Swisher
Oh, my God.
Scott Galloway
They are having sex, Kara. There is sex in the Oval Office.
Kara Swisher
That is a picture in my head that did not even occur to me. I'm sorry.
Scott Galloway
The AG Barr walks into the Oval Office.
Kara Swisher
No, no, no, no, no, no. You're stopping.
Scott Galloway
And he says, "Mr. President, I have corrupted one of the world's great institutions for your own needs."
Kara Swisher
We're moving on. There's so many stories. Let's talk about the EU.
Scott Galloway
And he says, "Kiss me, you big bear of a man."
Kara Swisher
No, that's done. We're done. And we're moving on. Thank you for putting that in everyone's brains.
Scott Galloway
If Bill Barr has dresses, there's DNA all over them.
Kara Swisher
Listen. Oh, my God. That's so inappropriate. That's definitely not making the end.
Scott Galloway
You know what? We're doing really well and we're growing really fast. But at some point, you're going to drive this into a wall. That is really how it's going to go.
Kara Swisher
I tell you.
Scott Galloway
I'm like NASCAR. That's what you want to do. It's fun while it lasts and then boom, it's over.
Kara Swisher
I was reading your essay about being anonymous and rich versus being well-known and rich. I think you want to be well-known and rich and have nobody bother you.
Scott Galloway
I think that is— I'm neither. I'm on a train to neither.
Kara Swisher
I know. But I'm just saying, I think you actually like being well-known, but you don't want people disagreeing with you.
Scott Galloway
I had all weekend with a story that Recode wrote that I didn't even edit. It had nothing to do with it. I've told you, I'm offensive yet easily offended, which is like the worst combination in the world. And I have to sit and take stuff. I read. I didn't even know what was going on there.
Kara Swisher
And so what? I mean, okay, so you guys aren't microbiologists. I mean, I didn't see the big deal.
Scott Galloway
I did not either. And I was trying to point that out.
Kara Swisher
But I do think, as you know, we argue about it. You don't think this coronavirus crisis is a big deal. And I do, actually. That was the thing. I actually agree with this guy. We aren't doing enough around it. And you think we're doing plenty and that it's overhyped. So that's what the irony was.
Scott Galloway
You're putting words in my mouth. I find that offensive. Anyways, go ahead. We did. We have tape about it. Go ahead.
Kara Swisher
Anyway, we're going to the news. In any case, I dealt with it. I invited him on the show. I've not heard from him. He's talking to other people. That's fine. Whatever.
Scott Galloway
I read that guy's tweets. Yeah. I read his tweets because I was curious and I wanted to see you in trouble.
Kara Swisher
I'm not in trouble.
Scott Galloway
And that guy, he's an IQ bully. Like, he's clearly smarter than all of us.
Kara Swisher
He is very smart.
Scott Galloway
But instead of having any grace about it, he's like, "Okay, let me just bully you with how just ridiculously smart I am." Like, all right, buddy, you win. You're smarter than all of us.
Kara Swisher
I'm going to not comment on that. He's got a lot of, he's in Bitcoin. He's got a lot of followers. He's got a lot of Bitcoin bros.
Scott Galloway
Oh, he's a Bitcoin guy?
Kara Swisher
Yeah, he does a lot of business.
Scott Galloway
Oh, well, that ups his credibility in the medical community. That absolutely.
Kara Swisher
He actually knows a lot about it.
Scott Galloway
That absolutely. Okay, doctor. Where's crypto headed, doctor? Now cut me open. Where's Ethereum headed? Solve my cancer and where is Ethereum headed?
Kara Swisher
All right. We're moving along. Thank you for making another weekend of being in bed. But I handled it rather well. I'm in a good mood.
Scott Galloway
I see that. I see that. I see what's going on. Where are you? Where are you on this lovely President's Day weekend?
Kara Swisher
I'm back in New York in the city. And I had a nice weekend. Hints of spring, right?
Scott Galloway
Hints of spring in New York. Kara, has anyone heard from spring? No. Has anyone heard from spring?
Kara Swisher
Hints of spring.
Scott Galloway
We're going to the big stories. There's a lot going on despite the fact this is a holiday weekend.
Kara Swisher
Listen, EU lawmakers are debating a new policy around artificial intelligence. Sundar Pichai and Mark Zuckerberg are in the EU this week as EU lawmakers debate a new digital policy, including first-of-its-kind rules on the ways that artificial intelligence can be used by companies. New policy set to be released by the Office of Margrethe Vestager on Wednesday. Margrethe's obviously coming to Code, which is going to be great. So what do you think about this? Europe is once again ahead. What do you think of this situation?
Scott Galloway
Well, Margrethe Vestager, that's how you say it.
Kara Swisher
Thank you.
Scott Galloway
She's my hero. I told you I stalked her on a train. She was knitting, and I went up and I got a selfie with her. And she was so gracious. I think she was so excited that someone recognized her in the United States, and she stopped. And she's—anyways, she's a total gangster.
Kara Swisher
She is indeed. I vote for her for king of the world or queen of the world. Anyways, I thought the most interesting thing about that was your guy, your dude, who you think should run Facebook. What's his name? Brad Grossman?
Scott Galloway
Brad Gross? Brad Smith.
Kara Swisher
Brad Smith from Microsoft, yes. Where did I get Grossman?
Scott Galloway
I think it's William Barr. Bill Barr.
Kara Swisher
Okay, we're moving on from that storyline.
Scott Galloway
Come here. Go ahead. Come here. "You kissed me, you DOJ wanton bitch," says the president every weekend on a Friday. Go, go, go.
Kara Swisher
Anyways, I'm sorry. Okay. So he did a total drop-in on Facebook. He basically said, "Look, we have an obligation to afford our customers some semblance of privacy." What's interesting is now he's gone all Tim Cook on Mark Zuckerberg.
Scott Galloway
He has. Now Microsoft, the most valuable company in the world, is saying it is dangerous. Literally no one will have lunch with Facebook. We're like, "We don't care how rich your dad is. We don't care how cool and likable your sister is. You can no longer have lunch with us."
Kara Swisher
Yeah. And people are set, other companies, and they usually kind of have the ultimate white guy pact. They're like, "No, we will not say bad things about each other." So in a public forum, and I'm sure about 800 PR people starched every word that he said. He said, "Look, Facebook, you got to get your act together. You're hurting the entire industry."
Scott Galloway
No, that's very Brad. That's very Brad.
Kara Swisher
I've spent a lot. I know him quite well. I think that is really—
Scott Galloway
Of course you do.
Kara Swisher
I do. I did a podcast with him. I've known him for 25 years. Yes, you do. He's a great—I like him a great deal. That's why I want him to be at Facebook. I think he's got the right sense. He wrote a book called *Tools and Weapons*.
Scott Galloway
I'm going to fill you in. Why wouldn't I know him?
Kara Swisher
I cover Microsoft for two decades.
Scott Galloway
That's a good title.
Kara Swisher
Let me just— That's a good title. He's giving me a hard time when I know people I actually— Cover Microsoft for two decades.
Scott Galloway
We will not say that at your funeral. Someone who covers—I know that.
Kara Swisher
We will not say that. When someone covers, say, the White House, you're like, "You know, Senator Blah-B-Dee-Blah?" Like, yes, I know them. I cover them. In any case, he's a very intelligent man. He has lots to say. He wrote a whole book about this issue. And I think they're dying for some sort of guidance from regulators on these issues, especially AI. I think even Facebook wants some sort of direction. And so what's going to happen now is the EU is going to determine a lot of things just like GDPR, right? A lot of stuff because of the lack of any action by anybody in our government.
Scott Galloway
Well, so you're—and I'm genuine about this question because I'm cynical, but I think the whole "we need guidance and it's time for regulation" as there are 90 lobbyists who are in D.C. delaying and obfuscating anything resembling regulation. I find it a disingenuous argument meant to, again, create this faux notion of concern that they're actually open to regulation. No, they're not. They're not in—look at what the lobbyists are doing. The lobbyists don't walk into Senator Warren's office and go, "You know what? We really do need stronger—"
Kara Swisher
Well, they know the regulation is coming, so they want to shape it. That I think—you're right. You're right on the base level. But in general, some companies really don't want this sort of—the same thing to happen that's happened with social media. Now, interestingly, Sundar Pichai, because this is the way Sundar Pichai is, while AI promises enormous benefits for Europe and the world, there are real concerns about potential negative consequences. That's a perfect sentence.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. Thoughts and prayers. Thoughts and prayers.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. That's a thoughts and prayers.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, but I didn't take much away from it other than the Zuck went, and I'm pretty sure he had to avoid British airspace for fear that a tornado, gangster jet, gangster fighter plane would show up next to his Gulfstream 650ER and escort him down and arrest him and take him into custody. So I'm very serious. I wonder if on the way to Europe his flight plan includes avoiding UK airspace. I don't know. That's what I'd like to know.
Kara Swisher
I will ask him next time I see him if I ever see him. But it is interesting. We'll see what Margrethe puts out. But I think, as usual, she's far ahead of everybody else. And I think they'll be much more stringent. The same thing will happen around facial recognition. Most of this legislation is not going to be coming from our country, which is interesting. And then they'll have to follow them because when something happens in a market like that, which is relatively large, even though the U.S. market is larger, they're going to have to follow along and they're going to have to do that. And so to me, it's sort of a consequence of the inability of our government to regulate tech in any way, which they keep almost doing. And there's all these bills that are almost there, but none of them really. And the EU lawmakers are leaping ahead as usual. So that is what I say.
Scott Galloway
Well, we haven't had any legislation in this country in a long time. We're effectively the—it really is. D.C. has just decided, especially with the injection of the Freedom Caucus. The Freedom Caucus has basically said we're just not going to let anyone do anything. No, deregulate. And we found McConnell. Hundreds of bills. That's what he said. Hundreds, right? Is that right? McConnell said that. And someone's like, "True, there are like 897 bills." He's like, "Yes, there are." Like that. I was like, okay. I thought it literally that everything had just like come to a grinding halt.
Kara Swisher
By the way, what is an addiction? An addiction is something you continue to engage in despite the fact that it's damaging to the other parts of your life. And I am addicted. And we're going off script here.
Scott Galloway
Oh, no. Off script.
Kara Swisher
I've got to talk about politics. I can't help it.
Scott Galloway
No, you've got to hold it. We're going to talk about Huawei. We can't?
Kara Swisher
In a minute. Erica Anderson-Owes says don't talk about politics.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, I know, because our readers would like us to talk about tech, which this is politics. Please, mommy.
Kara Swisher
No, we're going to talk about addiction later, and then you can be counseled about your problem. Stop it, Chris. Is it disqualifying? Is it disqualifying? Huawei is political. The U.S. charged Huawei with federal racketeering last week. The Department of Justice accused Huawei and your friend Bill Barr and its affiliates of a pattern of racketeering activity. They say the company has worked to steal trade secrets from six American firms, stolen information, good source code, as well as lots of things. Huawei argues latest charges are ridiculous. Andy Purdy, who I've interviewed, says confidently exonerated. Now, this is interesting. Democrats and Republicans are aligned here, but nobody else agrees. Even tech companies are nervous about the inability to work with Chinese companies. And there was a great story in I think the Times or the—I think it was the New York Times about that issue, the difficulty of working. The U.K. recently agreed to work with Huawei with a 5G. But the Trump administration is staying on its lack of information sharing policy, and it warned—it's been warning tech companies, U.S. tech companies about this. So, anyway, what do we think?
Scott Galloway
I have a serious question. I have a serious question.
Kara Swisher
Do you have any?
Scott Galloway
I would love to know. I haven't read anything about this. I don't know the actual logistical risk of these devices in that it's—how easy or difficult are they to weaponize? I'm not—if the Chinese start importing cars and the president were to say "don't drive these cars because of the major privacy," I just don't know how real the threat is of the equipment that they sell can be weaponized and used as a vehicle for espionage for the Chinese government.
Kara Swisher
Well, I think it's that you get in the guts of these networks, especially the 5G networks, and you both control them and then you're able to do that. I think what it is is that we—
Scott Galloway
So you think the threat is real? You do think the threat is real?
Kara Swisher
I don't—you know, I think it's good to be worried about it. The administration wants to protect national security by restricting the flow of technology to China. But it's also the flow of technology to China and keep the U.S. out of China. That's the other part of it. And so tech companies want to sell into China, but they're—it's part of this longer-running essentially war. But firms that specialize, this is the New York Times, firms that specialize in microchips, artificial intelligence, biotechnology, other industries have grown increasingly alarmed by the administration's efforts to restrict the flow of technology to China, saying it could siphon expertise, research, and revenue away from the United States, ultimately eroding America's advantage. So we have to sell to them. So it's part of a two-pronged thing is this crackdown on both sides, is bringing this Chinese technology in here in the form of Huawei and 5G, and then cracking down on American components and technology going overseas. So it's, you know, look, the Trump administration is anti-China in both these cases. And tech companies have worries on both sides, which is they're getting squeezed, essentially.
Scott Galloway
So I think, and I do think it's tangentially related to this. I think a story that's going to have, so I love the term "seminal." I use that word all the time. And it's something, an event that is ultimately ends up being historic or at the time it creates ripples that are greater than the initial stone, you know, the stone's entry into the water. I think the incarceration of Carlos Ghosn was a seminal moment, and that is geopolitics have intersected with private commerce. And that is I think that I believe he was incarcerated because the Japanese felt they were shamed around the Nissan-Renault deal, and they were very angry.
And they incarcerated him, and then all of a sudden Japan—I think Japan probably has the best brand in the world when it comes to kind of integrity or honesty. And that's why the Gulf was talked into this ridiculous constructor vehicle to repatriate five years of oil export wealth called the Vision Fund One because they were able to basically—I don't want to say wash it through Japan—but Japan has an incredibly strong brand in terms of honor. I sold my first company to the Japanese and we go over there and we just sit in a room and say nothing for a day and then we'd go out and get shitty drunk and then we'd do the same thing for five days and then the guy would come up to me and say, "I can trust you now and we'll do the deal."
None of it made any sense. It was very strange, but you take Japan very seriously. They just seem very steeped in culture and honor. They seem like an honest people. So when they jail the CEO of Nissan Renault and it just—and then all of a sudden we start jailing or putting out a subpoena for I believe it's the CFO of Huawei. By the way, the CFO of Huawei should definitely order like a musical band and say she needs a box for her trumpet and see what they do. Send a big box for my musical instruments over to my house, would you?
Kara Swisher
In any case.
Scott Galloway
But anyways, the notion that they're going to—I think the tech executives and I think executives just in general are like globalization has meant loosely speaking that when corporate executives travel abroad, they're usually not worried about being incarcerated for geopolitical reasons. And that is starting to change.
Kara Swisher
This is also not just the CEO. She's the daughter of the founder, which is really interesting. So, yeah, definitely. And, you know, you have, you know, what you were talking about, joking about with Mark, but they all have these indictments. And so she's arrested and she's, they want to extradite her here and Canada's weighing of it. So it's really become political, just like you were talking about. And then the second part is that then companies in this country, when this is all going on, this is a passage from the New York Times story about doing business with China. "Companies, along with lawyers and consultants who advise them, say firms increasingly have no choice but to locate more research and development outside the United States to ensure that they have uninterrupted access to China, a fast-growing consumer market and center of the global electronic supply chain. New investment dollars are being funneled to research hubs near the University of Waterloo in Canada, as well as Israel, Britain, and other places beyond the reach of the U.S. government."
Scott Galloway
Well, you know, this is—trillion, which is greater than the defense budget of the U.S. and Europe combined and transferring it from young people to old people in the form of Social Security. Our socialist government, which is putting pressure on companies to locate their headquarters in certain cities. And now our socialist government is deciding, "Hey, I know the U.S. should buy Ericsson or Nokia." And it's just, OK, wait, the government is going to get into the business of trying to compete against Chinese companies now. That is the definition of socialism. And it usually doesn't end up that well.
Typically, governments don't make great private enterprise strategies. More to the point is that these rules are just not thought out. And Wilbur Ross looks asleep. Talk about asleep at the wheel. He's actually asleep. But this is, to me, the letter from IBM, which never does things like this, in a comment letter told the Commerce Department to go back to the drawing board and said, "The rules will lead to broad disengagement of U.S. business from global markets and suppliers. Its reach, breadth, and vagueness are unprecedented." I mean, that's like "you're stupid," right? I get it. And when IBM calls you stupid, that hurts.
Kara Swisher
When IBM calls you stupid.
Scott Galloway
Anyway, this is going to be—
Kara Swisher
Jesus, even IBM thinks we're morons.
Scott Galloway
This is a very, very—especially in the background of coronavirus coming out of China. This is—this Chinese—the situation in China is so complex in our relationship with China.
Kara Swisher
I think that's really—to me, Huawei is one of the undersung stories of what's going on here. I do think that. And so we'll see where it goes. Speaking of another tech company, we will get to politics. We have a guest coming soon. Airbnb isn't making profits and expect to go public later this year. It was making money and had a profit a year ago of $200 million. Now it has a loss of $322 million. They're losing money because they're putting in safety cards and things like that. That's what people think. What do you think will happen to—we both have been, like, positive about this company. But they're embroiled in lots of lawsuits. They've been doing more safety things. You know, they've been actually doing the block and tackling compared to other companies that's necessary to create a safe company. This is their attempts, even though they have a lot of critics to that. They're not doing a good enough job. What happens when you change, you go to a loss like this when you're going into a public offering this year?
Scott Galloway
I would argue I think they're doing exactly what they should be doing. And that is if you look at the majority of big tech, where the problems come in is not only do—because we live in a capitalist society and we have obviously feckless government oversight. It's very tempting in a capitalist society where the accoutrements of wealth and power are just extraordinary to ignore and turn a blind eye to some of the externalities created with unfettered scale. And that is, okay, what happens when you don't apply for a business license? What happens when you ignore journalist stories that your drivers are making less than minimum wage?
What happens when you ignore all sorts of evidence that bad actors are on your platform? What happens when you ignore child safety? Because at the end of the day, scale, their ability. I mean, these companies have created—Facebook has created more value in 10 years than the entire U.S. auto industry created in a century. And the ability to do that, the ability to garner the accoutrements, the respect, you generally, these people are, you know, for the most part, good people think "I can do great things with this wealth and power." So the temptation to ignore anything that gets in the way of this kind of blitzkrieg-like scale is extraordinary.
And that is what regulators are supposed to do. They're supposed to step in and say, "No, you're supposed to have a business license. And no, if you're paying people $2.50 and turning their car into a payday loan, we're going to stop that." But we haven't done that. They overrun Washington. They weaponize CNBC and The Wall Street Journal to call them innovators. And anyone who gets in the way doesn't, quote, unquote, "get it" and is a Luddite. And what Airbnb is doing is saying, "You know what, before it's too late, we're going to put in place some friction." And it's expensive and it'll cost them money at the IPO.
But they're saying safety has become an issue. So they are making a massive investment in screening safety and trying to understand. They're getting in the way of their scale and they're spending a lot of money trying to make these units more safe.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, this is true. I think the problem they face, I think, is this, you know, they're building this big legal team, which is important to them because they've got all kinds of issues all over the place. And they are litigious because they're ramping up, you know, they're fighting with localities. Am I naive? Are they not as snow white as I'd like to think?
Scott Galloway
I think the two questions, and again, I like Brian Chesky's coming to Code also, the whole team actually, the whole original team is coming to Code, all the founders.
Kara Swisher
I do think compared to everybody else, but it's sort of like sometimes you're like, it's the least violent person. Like, you know what I mean? The least violent. And so that doesn't mean they haven't been.
Scott Galloway
Charles Manson's younger brother?
Kara Swisher
Oh, no, no, no. They're not like that. Just beats people up. They have disputes everywhere. You know, they've got so many problems because they're an analog company. Just think, talk about the legal problems they have. They've got, you know, video cameras in people's bedrooms. They've got, you know, at one point they had bedbugs. There were prostitutes operating. There were, you know, orgies. There was damage. There's people dying.
Scott Galloway
That's called a Wednesday night in Soho. What are you talking about?
Kara Swisher
You knew that was coming.
Scott Galloway
But, like, property damage, this is just—there's so much going on.
Kara Swisher
Then they're fighting with municipalities about its impact. And then, you know, it just goes—it goes on and on and on. And then illegal properties being, you know, being gamed. And then there's these parties. And then, like—so this is a very complex company. So I don't—I have to say that anything they can do to assuage that is great. But they're not going to be perfect in this regard. And so it's going to cost money. But I do like that they're spending money, but they definitely have to be aggressive from a legal point of view.
Scott Galloway
The option would be to do what Uber did, and that is just try and delay and obfuscate and overwhelm the media with stories about other things such that they can get public and then kind of all this stuff bubbles up. And I think they've said, "No, we're going to try and—" I mean, there's probably a bigger issue, and it's more of a macro issue, and that is what happens when you continue to take housing stock off the market for the purpose of turning it into what is effectively a makeshift short-term rental or a hotel. What happens to young people who—or people who just can't find housing?
Kara Swisher
Right. They just can't rent.
Scott Galloway
This is another thing that's pushing the price of housing up in the kind of key locations where people want to live and want to be closer to work. So there's some—obviously some big issues. You also have the hotel lobby.
Kara Swisher
Yes, 100%. It said, look. I would agree. We've been paying for the police. We pay—look at your hotel bill. I mean, they're extraordinary taxes on there, right? They pay taxes. They pay taxes at Airbnb. They now do. So Airbnb, do you know if Airbnb, though, in every municipality is actually paying the same tax?
Scott Galloway
I think they, I believe they are. I believe they have fixed that. It's like Amazon.
Kara Swisher
So they fixed that. But I think the issue is, look, they're in these lawsuits with, especially with New York, they're in that same, and Brian was quite frustrated with their situation. Every now and then you hear people inside there, "We're just going to get out of New York. We're just not going to do it." And then they're like, "Well, we've got a lot of—" it's a very complex situation. And I think it requires, I think going public, it'll be interesting to see these numbers when they go public. You know, this is a $31 billion valuation. If there's, like, maybe this is money they have to spend now, the way Amazon did, and then later they can recoup it. You know, they bought a Hotel Tonight, so they're also in the hotel business. They also have to show growth. So it's going to be a really interesting IPO. I do think it's a great product, and it's not one of these products that is going to go away. And I think it's not... Speaking...
Scott Galloway
I think they do it better than anybody else. There's nobody else even close.
Kara Swisher
I agree. They've got monopoly, some of those network effects we talked about. Speaking of New York, did you see the news that Mayor de Blasio endorsed Bernie Sanders?
Scott Galloway
Yes, we're going to get into politics. Go ahead.
Kara Swisher
Wait, we have a mayor, said everyone in New York?
Scott Galloway
Oh, my God. Talk about the weakest flex in the world. I have Mayor de Blasio. You've got to do the impression of Bernie Sanders receiving de Blasio's endorsement.
Kara Swisher
"Thank you very much. Thank you very much. Here you go. Well, I love de Blasio, de Blasio, whatever. We're in New York. We're in New York. And you know, people realize—" I don't even know how to do it.
Scott Galloway
Talk about the weakest flex in the world. He does glom himself onto things, doesn't he?
Kara Swisher
Anyway, we've got to take a quick break because we've got a guest coming. Actually, someone whose brother is running for president, friend of Pivot, Jim Steyer. And we're going to do wins and fails after that when we get back.
Ad break
Okay, we're back. We have our friend Jim Steyer on the line. Jim is a bestselling author, a Stanford University professor, and founder and CEO of Common Sense. It's the world's leading organization focused on helping kids and families thrive in the world of media and technology. This September, he'll be publishing his book, *Which Side of History? How Technology is Reshaping Democracy and All Our Lives*. We are both parents. This is about privacy platforms and how to handle it. So it's the perfect intersection. Jim, welcome to Pivot.
Jim Steyer
Great to be here.
Kara Swisher
So you don't know Professor Galloway, but right before this, you were complimenting each other on your professorialness, although you had a little Stanford NYU face-off. But one of the topics, Scott, we want to talk about because Jim talks about this a lot is how safe are platforms like Facebook and YouTube for kids? This is something he has been very early to, the same complaints you made around addiction, around stuff like that. So talk about that a little bit, Jim, where you are now because this is something you've been talking about for a while.
Jim Steyer
You're right, Kara. I've been talking about it for a long time. And I would just say that the basic message I always give to parents on kids using social media platforms like Facebook or Instagram or YouTube is delay, delay, delay. I mean, they're still the wild, wild west. They still present enormous challenges for the social, emotional and cognitive development of kids. And so we still have a huge issue when it comes to the reality of kids online. And they are, there's an arms race for data, an arms race for attention, and kids are oftentimes the big losers, period.
Scott Galloway
[Interrupting] Oh, my God. I love this guy so much already.
Kara Swisher
Go on.
Scott Galloway
Go ahead.
Kara Swisher
I know. This is your topic, Scott. I'm bringing people of interest. I said I wouldn't get involved in this interview, and I'm 10 seconds in, and I got interrupted. All right, go for it.
Scott Galloway
Okay. What is, can you give us some of the most damaging or some of the data that you find most alarming about kids and privacy in these platforms?
Jim Steyer
Well, I mean, basically, kids today are the most tracked generation ever. And the stakes for privacy are very high. When we wrote the CCPA in 2018, it went into effect just this past month. This is the California Privacy Act. Right. Sort of a landmark law in the United States. To be honest with you, we did it, Scott and Kara, because we were so concerned about the privacy of kids. But basically they're tracked from infancy. We used to look at this in the context of the photos that parents would post of their babies. But we have this, as our friend Shoshana Zuboff at Harvard says, a surveillance economy. And so kids are being tracked. They don't know it. Their parents don't know it. And then sometimes that data is being used in really inappropriate ways. So we've been looking at this forever.
Scott Galloway
So what are some of those ways? Because my data is tracked and it usually adds utility. It helps me get to Chipotle or whatever. Why is it bad?
Jim Steyer
You know, Scott, as the father of two daughters, both of whom were always concerned about their weight and their body image, you know, they started getting pro-anorexia messages when they were 11 or 12. And they would constantly be dished up stuff because of tracking on social media and on other platforms.
Scott Galloway
Hold on one second. Pro-anorexia messages. What platform? How did that happen?
Jim Steyer
That happened, I'm sure, because they were tracked, their data was available, and then folks who had weight loss pills or stuff related to weight loss were targeting them with ads. And we've seen this across the board with girls. I mean, I actually think, Kara, I don't know if you and I have talked about this, but the issue of the impact of platforms like Instagram and Snapchat on boys and girls, but particularly girls' body image, is humongous.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. Scott, this is Scott talks about this all the time, this depression issue. The constant comparison. And, you know, I think the data is something like 50 percent of kids and girls on social media Photoshop their images for that perfect look. That's incredibly damaging to their self-esteem.
Scott Galloway
I'm sorry, you're going to have the same question I was, Kara. What do we do about this? Like if you could be governor, if you were advising Governor Newsom, it sounds like you are. What are the two or three things that will help?
Jim Steyer
We wrote the Consumer Privacy Act in 2018. That needs to be strengthened. I mean, there needs to be much stronger enforcement and greater data minimization. I personally think that we need to rewrite COPPA, the privacy law for kids under the age of 13. But I think much more fundamentally, we need responsibility out of the large companies. I mean, they have just basically ignored their responsibilities to kids and families and consumers from the get-go. And I just think it's about time that they were held much more accountable by the government and society writ large for the way some of the really major downsides and unintended consequences of their business models.
Kara Swisher
Well, talk about the U.K. new legislation required social networks, gaming apps, and online services used by people under 18 to overhaul how they handle that information. They require platforms like YouTube and Instagram to turn on the highest possible privacy settings for default by minors, turn off default data mining practices. This is never—we were just talking earlier about Margrethe Vestager and the artificial intelligence stuff they're talking about this week. Why does this never happen in this country? Why is GDPR and California pretty much the only, and even California is weaker. You know that.
Jim Steyer
Not that much. I mean, Kara, we wrote the law. So it's weaker in some ways and stronger in a couple of other ways. But you're correct. And truthfully, we opened a London office for Common Sense, which is going great guns. And we work with Margrethe on an ongoing basis because Europe is much more vigilant about this. I mean, California has a functioning democracy. Brussels and the EU have a functioning democracy, and Washington is not a functioning democracy. That's the bottom line. That's why we wrote the privacy law for the United States in California. So what we need is a new president, a Congress that is competent to deal with these issues, and then to take the companies head on just as they're doing in the UK and Europe. And we are right now lobbying in Europe for the passage of the UK legislation that you referred to, Kara.
Kara Swisher
All right. So you just opened up a big door. Someone you know is running for president, your brother, is that correct? Now, do you advise him on the policy on privacy media? I haven't heard him talk a lot about this, but let's advise whoever is president, not your extraordinarily wealthy brother.
Jim Steyer
Yes, go ahead. Thank you. I knew you were going to throw in that adjective, Kara, but I love my brother very much and I support him and he would be a great president. That said, I would tell whoever is the next president, and hopefully not Donald Trump, God forbid, that we need to, number one, abolish Section 230. We need to just remove the ridiculous provisions of Section 230 that have given these guys a get-out-of-jail-free pass for 15 years. We should have comprehensive federal privacy legislation that's stronger than GDPR. We should hold industry executives, in certain cases, personally responsible when they are involved in or complicit in the hacking of our democracy. The list goes on. To some extent, we're running this legislation or pieces of this legislation in California. But the truth is this leadership should start with the president, whether it's my brother or somebody else.
Scott Galloway
Scott, ask about the personally responsible. Scott was just talking about that. So typically in the U.S., I think the first two are feasible. And California, whenever California does anything, D.C. typically or other states, probably more importantly, as you pointed out, D.C. has become somewhat flaccid around regulation the last, I don't know, 20 years. But everybody looks to California. But the one that I think would probably have the biggest impact is one of these executives shows up in court and there's a chance they're going to be wearing an orange jumpsuit. I think that is probably what is required because these folks have such incredible tools, have so much capital, have so many lobbyists that until there's a decent level— I mean, the rule of law in the U.
S. is an incredible deterrent. There is a very healthy fear of incarceration and shame that applies to most people in most industries that says, even if I can get away with it, I'm not going to pour mercury into the river out of the back door of my factory. I don't think that fear is there among tech executives. And the idea of a corporation is that we give people, private power and private companies and executives, a barrier such that if they do something stupid within a corporation, their stock goes down, they get fired, but they don't go to jail. And to me, that is something that has huge benefits in a capitalist society, but also has gotten in the way of this level of deterrence.
Kara Swisher
What could they potentially do? How could they hold them? Is it realistic, the notion of holding them personally?
Jim Steyer
You know, Scott, I think it's a great question, but I agree with you. I think that was one of the great mistakes of the Obama administration, by analogy, when they failed to put some of the banking executives in prison where they belong for tanking our economy. And you could compare that to the ways in which some of the largest tech platforms, particularly, I think, Facebook in particular, have both harmed our constitutional and democratic norms, have exposed kids and other users to massive violations of privacy. I think if we held tech executives personally liable, it would have a dramatic impact in terms of accountability. I also feel that with bank executives. So I agree with you. And I would—I'm a former prosecutor. I saw this every day when I was a prosecutor. When people are afraid of being in orange jumpsuits, it completely changes their behavior. And I do believe that post the 2020 election, we ought to be having these kinds of discussions, not in a punitive way, but because the impact of tech on society, on democracy, on all of our lives is so profound.
Kara Swisher
All right. But the both of you, this is never going to happen. They're never going to put Mark Zuckerberg in jail.
Scott Galloway
I made this prediction, Kara. I stand by it, and I'd like to get Professor Steyer's view. I predicted two years ago, and I've been wrong so far, that a tech executive is detained and arrested, but it happens on foreign soil. It could be, but I think it'll be for something like pornography or live streaming murder. I mean, one of the things, I'm sure you, I know you, because I listen to your podcast, that we talk about Section 230. I mean, that's one of the worst laws in the United States. It has literally been this blanket immunity. Senator Ron Wyden, Democrat from Oregon, wrote it. And part of the reason when I've argued with Democratic senators to have it overturned, they always say, "Well, you know, Ron wrote it." I like, who cares who wrote it? Let's get rid of it.
Jim Steyer
Ron does not like it anymore. I just saw him the other day. He thinks it's outdated.
Kara Swisher
Kara, then if Ron Wyden doesn't like it, who—a good gentleman from Oregon, he ought to stand up and call for its abolition. I don't believe he thinks that far. But they ought to start from scratch. It's a lousy law. It's irrelevant in the 2020s.
Jim Steyer
All right. Well, that's a big deal. That's a big thing. So you think 230. And then what about, let me just finish because we have only a little more time. That's a big thing. That is not going to happen. But that's a big thing. And I think you're right about redoing it and figuring it out. But I think it's very difficult to imagine them.
Kara Swisher
Fundamental overhaul.
Jim Steyer
Fundamental overhaul of 230.
Kara Swisher
All right. Okay. Okay, two things. Two things, final things. General advice for parents who are concerned, give us three tips. And second, if your brother wins, can Scott and I stay in the Lincoln Bedroom together?
Jim Steyer
We really—okay. Number one. Yes to question number two. Here's what I would say. Number one. So yes to number two. My brother's going to shoot me for that comment, however. But that's okay. I talk to him every day. He's my best friend and he is my younger brother. So he has to listen to me some of the time. No, I think the number one thing is delay, delay, delay in terms of giving your kids smartphones. Number two, have an ongoing dialogue with them about the pros and cons of what they're getting on phones and social media, including addiction, attention, distraction issues. And then third, be a good role model. If you're constantly glued to your own phone or your own social media account, what are they going to learn from you?
Kara Swisher
So true. You're right. I've gotten so much better, Jim, since you warned me of that.
Jim Steyer
I believe that. I have. I put it down. I put them down whenever we're at meals and everything else. And that's the—you know, we have that whole "Device for Your Dinner" campaign. But Kara, I know what a doting mom you are. And Scott, I assume you're a devoted parent. You've just got to act it out in your own life. And by the way, we're all healthier if we do.
Scott Galloway
That is true. 100%.
Kara Swisher
Jim, as usual, thank you so much.
Scott Galloway
Professor Steyer, you are an inspiration. Upgrade to the Bears, the Golden Bears. I love it.
Jim Steyer
Professor Galloway, get out here to the Bay Area and become a visiting professor at Stanford and Cal.
Scott Galloway
I'm a wanted man there. Are you kidding? The question is whether they assassinate me honorably with a long-distance rifle or they strangle me.
Kara Swisher
Oh, my God. All right, Jim. Good talking to you.
Jim Steyer
Good talking to both of you guys. Thanks.
Kara Swisher
All right. See you, Professor.
Guest leaves
Scott Galloway
I love that guy.
Kara Swisher
I know you do.
Scott Galloway
I was a bit skeptical. Some guy named Steyer that's not running for president, I was totally skeptical.
Kara Swisher
All right, there you have it. I sent a snarky email last night. I'm like, "Snooze" to the producers, and they freak out because I never complain.
Scott Galloway
Can I just say—
Kara Swisher
Unlike you, I never complain.
Scott Galloway
That guy's a gangster. Can I just say, you should listen to me on my advice to you. I do know some people.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, I do listen. You don't need to complain. By the way, just because I made a Lincoln Bedroom remark, you literally just talked about the AG having sex with the president and I just made one single Lincoln Bedroom remark.
Scott Galloway
That is literally—that is the worst Cinemax show ever invented. You and me in the Lincoln Bedroom.
Kara Swisher
No, you're on the floor. You'll be sleeping on the floor and talking to the ghost of the president. But I think we need to use this relationship, get into the White House.
Scott Galloway
Literally, that's the night. You and I in the Lincoln Bedroom—that's the night they find out the White House was built on an ancient Indian burial ground or whatever it is.
Kara Swisher
Oh, my God. Poltergeist shows up.
Scott Galloway
We have to get to the White House. We have to get in the White House.
Kara Swisher
I've never been to the White House. I have, in fact, several times. I used to cover it for the Washington Post.
Scott Galloway
Well, of course you have. How many times have you been to the White House?
Kara Swisher
No, I covered it as a reporter. I didn't get invited by anybody. Oh, actually, you know what? That's not true. My ex-wife worked at the White House, so I've been in there.
Scott Galloway
Oh, yeah. That's right. But not very—they don't let me very far.
Kara Swisher
I mean, like, really? We should run around the White House. That's what we need to do. Upstairs.
Scott Galloway
That's what we need to do. Now the Secret Service is dialing in right now. I'm in.
Kara Swisher
Anyway, I did get my hand shook by President Obama. When you leave, all the members of the White House get to have little pictures taken with them. He was zombie and was horrified because we had done a very testy interview.
Scott Galloway
Really?
Kara Swisher
That's right. He's like, "How did you get in here?" And I think that's what he said to me, I believe. That's what he said to me. It was very funny. In any case, Scott, wins and fails now. Who won?
Scott Galloway
Wins and fails. So my fail is Senator Tom Cotton.
Kara Swisher
Oh, good one.
Scott Galloway
Implying that a super virus has been developed at some covert facility. I think it's irresponsible. I think the brand of the Senate and senators is distinct of their partisanship that they don't make statements like that. And when senators say something, we take it seriously. And Senator Tom Cotton, when he manufactures conspiracy theories about super viruses from nations that he may see as our adversary, but they're not our enemy. And then biologists with any credibility come out and say, "This virus does not look like—there's no evidence it was engineered in any way." He not only weakens our position in the world, he diminishes the credibility and the standing of the United States Senate. And it's distinctive how, whether he thinks there's crazies he's trying to throw red meat at, he should command the space he occupies. He wants to be Trump 2024. Well, Senator Cotton, just stop it. Just stop it. That is a definition of an irresponsible statement. And it's, again, more cloud cover provided by the mother of all irresponsible statements such that people like Senator Tom Cotton can say these stupid things and people don't even notice. Anyways, my fail is Senator Tom Cotton.
Kara Swisher
Can I just say, I'm going to add to your fail, that Maria Bartiromo on that interview, not questioning him. What was she thinking? Come on. She lost the narrative a long, long time ago. Acting as if there was some legitimacy to that. I just, she's done that many times. Horrible. What happened to Maria Bartiromo? Literally, what happened?
Scott Galloway
It was depressing. Where'd she go? Somewhere else. I don't know.
Kara Swisher
I just, that to me was sort of shocking. That's my fail. What's your fail? Are you just—we have fail squared?
Scott Galloway
No, no, I want your win now. I want your win.
Kara Swisher
So my win, this is sort of strange, but when I was at UCLA, the O'Bannon brothers, Charles O'Bannon and Ed O'Bannon. Charles O'Bannon played point guard. Ed O'Bannon was a power forward. And you had Charles O'Bannon with like this buttery ball handling skills. And Ed O'Bannon was like if Superman was 10 inches taller and stronger. And these guys were just a joy. And I'm not into sports, but at UCLA you go to basketball. And we used to go to Pauley Pavilion. And these guys were just incredible. And I don't know exactly, but I think Ed O'Bannon, like most amazing basketball players, got to the NBA, made a little bit of money.
But the top of the pyramid in professional sports is basically the employment rate is like 0 percent in terms of the number of people who can actually make a living in professional sports. And what I think you continue to see, and I saw this, the NCAA president again, a guy who makes $4 million a year, talking about how kids should not be—or student athletes should not be paid. And it's just, to me, it's ridiculous. And that, again, we have another construct where March Madness, incredible basketball teams, incredibly talented young people are—we place on top of them this construct that transfers the wealth they create to a bunch of old white dudes sitting in Kansas at the NCAA or at CBS headquarters.
And it's enough already. These folks deserve some compensation. A lot of them aren't going to make any more money post-college. A lot of them give their best years in terms of their ability to create economic value for other institutions. So enough already. NCAA, get out of the way. There needs to be legislation to pay college athletes. So we need to get in the way. And then you have all these, again, 50 or 60 something year old baby boomer white guys who are coaches who all make between four and 20 million dollars each saying that it would somehow pollute the game when they're the—when they're literally the mercury.
You know, they're the cyanide of this thing, being around young people talking about integrity when they're doing their Cheetos commercials. But oh, no, you can't make any money. Anyways, my win is Ed O'Bannon. And I don't know where Ed is, but he provided so much joy and so much value to the Bruins. And I think we probably captured so much economic value in the fact that he didn't get to participate in that in a meaningful way. Anyways, Ed O'Bannon is my win, and I hope that college athletes start recognizing some of the economic value they're creating.
This is really interesting. This idea of transfer of wealth to the old and infirm view is a very interesting—
Scott Galloway
Everything we do.
Kara Swisher
It's a very interesting theme of Scott Galloway these days.
Scott Galloway
Everything we do.
Kara Swisher
I think that's your next book, this transfer. This idea of how we're sort of transferring all the money to the wrong places.
Scott Galloway
Well, you know why Bernie has so much momentum? When you think about it, it's not that crazy. People go, "Oh, well, it's socialism. It's scary. Old people, all of us old people, like, don't they know what socialism is?" Well, I'll tell you what. They want their student debt eliminated, and that's what Bernie's saying. Well, it's because I got free education. Why shouldn't I? I got free education. In the 80s and the early 80s in California, I got free education. So they're like, "I want some of that, boss." And then they see a trillion dollars going to old people, two-thirds of whom do not need it. And they think, "You know what? I'd like my trillion. I'd like my trillion." So they immediately go to the same socialist policies that we call capitalism. We just call it something else. We call it Social Security. We call it—I mean, we just have different names for it.
Kara Swisher
That is true.
Scott Galloway
But we are effectively socialists who've decided the most noble people in the world are also the wealthiest people in the world, and they deserve all our transfer payments. Anyways, drop the mic. I'm sorry. What is your win?
Kara Swisher
My win is an essay that Hunter Walk wrote, speaking of who is a tech executive and stuff. And he wrote, "What's wrong with tech folks who attack the tech media and what's wrong with tech media today?" I thought it was a great piece. One of them was "Not all critics are haters. Please stop adopting language. Our president is deriding reporting. You are not as much of an underdog as you think. You want to content market yourself and then think follow-up questions to the press are not worthy of your response. Pay for media." And for reporters, he says, "Don't red team yourself into a biased corner, overgrant anonymity, especially in direct quotes.
I think that's a really good—blame the media business model editor for your content or headline." So I thought it was a very thoughtful piece. He did it on his blog called Humblebrag. And I think it's called Humblebrag. I mean, Hunter Walk, that was a great piece because really tech people are now like—when I had this argument, half of them were about media hating and nothing. No one had read the article that they were so angry about. And that drove me crazy. And they just, all they want to do is bash the media. And it's just, it's crazy. And at the same time, you know, then the media came on our side and it was just like, it was just like ridiculous.
No one had actually read the actual thing. And so I just felt that was, the victimization thing is just like exhausting.
Scott Galloway
I'm a bit confused though. He's saying that we're not—that we should be less critical of big tech or that we shouldn't just have a gag reflex?
Kara Swisher
No, no, no. He said we shouldn't do sort of—I think what he's saying is just do your reporting. He said, "A reporter told me a job is to find red team versus tech. I feel frat. It's not a reporter's job to write both sides of the story or to balance their negative coverage with positive stories. But I fear over time this type of newsroom culture narrows the perspective and also applies the same level of red teaming, outrage, equally different circumstances. For example, highlighting a young individual who made a stupid tweet or blog post versus speaking truly to power." I think that's right. I think he's right. I think mostly he was sort of shocked by how much anti-media bias is now coming out of tech. And Mike Isaac wrote about it towards reporters. And it's just because they had years of being licked up and down, and now they're not getting that. They're getting like just a second here. And I don't think they like that very much. That's my—
Scott Galloway
You have a generation of tech leaders. If you look at just the sheer data, the number of corporate PR professionals, which are basically lobbyists who make more money, has tripled. And the number of journalists has been cut in half. And so all they have experienced as working adults is more momentum and narrative towards them. And so when that momentum shifts and people start saying, "No, you're full of shit and no number of press releases and appearances, cooked appearances on CNBC are going to save you," it's shocking to them. It feels anti-American. And they don't realize that when journalists used to show up, shit used to get real. And journalists would track stuff down and they had the resources and they had the license and they didn't have the president attacking them. You know, people just had a lot more.
Kara Swisher
I feel like this generation doesn't appreciate that the largest, most effective police force in the history of Western democracy that doesn't carry guns or badges are journalists.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. And there is a lack of appreciation for—and it's—what's interesting is even a guy like Bezos, I think, sees it and says, "OK, it's important these institutions are around." But it's—when you really think about journalism, it's been decimated.
Kara Swisher
His PR guy went on a complainy tech reporter rant the other day. You know what I mean?
Scott Galloway
Oh, did he?
Kara Swisher
Yeah, he was calling hipsters in Brooklyn.
Scott Galloway
Oh, Jay Carney. Yeah.
Kara Swisher
Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah. You know what I mean? Too bad. You get paid a lot of money. And you should—it's fascinating. You know, I try—you'd be shocked about how relatively good relationships I have with most PR people at these companies. But one of the things I like about it is I've always been a grumpy pain in the ass to them. So they're used to it from me.
Scott Galloway
That's believable. That's believable.
Kara Swisher
Thank you. But it's a really interesting time. And I just, it's just really, it's emboldened by Trump. It's bullying of the press, which I think is really dangerous. And I don't—listen, one of the things is, someone wrote, just tweeted me, like, "How do you like it now you're being criticized?" I'm like, "I'm good with it." Like, I'm always getting criticized, so it's fine. It's just, they like to try to, like, "How do you like it now?"
It's like, you know, fuck you. I get it all the time. It's an interesting moment. And anyway, I like this essay. For my fail, I would say, it's still Bill Barr and his dating Donald Trump. I just think Bill Barr continues to just make everything dirty over there, just dirty. And I don't mean it in that way. You were replying. But it just creates this letter from all the ex-Justice Department, 1100 Justice Department. That's incredible.
Scott Galloway
Say that again.
Kara Swisher
1100 people from the DOJ are willing to put their careers on hold and basically said this guy needs to step down. That is staggering. Staggering. Staggering. They don't care. They're brazen. And so I think that was my—just that Bill Barr continues to be, I think, the most dangerous person in our—except for Mitch McConnell. I think those are the two—you know, Trump is one thing, but—who facilitates it all. But these people who do know better, I think, on some level. And I'm not abrogating Trump's responsibility, but on some level, he's got some problems. But these guys, I don't understand the trade at all. I don't understand the trade at all.
Scott Galloway
I need to bring you out of this funk, this mood. Read our letter for Valentino. Valentino, read our letter. We'll end on this letter.
Kara Swisher
You're right. I'm not in a funk. I'm just like, I had a weekend of dealing with assholes. All right. This is a letter, Valentino. This is a letter from Valentino's mother, Camilla, who was writing to us. And the subject line was "Questions from Valentino," which, of course, that immediately piques our interest, right? So, first of all, I am a big fan of yours since L2 days. Pivot is brilliant, and I am a loyal listener.
Scott Galloway
Oh, go on.
Kara Swisher
My son, Valentino—I love her for naming her son Valentino—listens to the show on the way to school and knows your voice. Scott, you have a five-year-old fan.
Scott Galloway
Isn't that nice?
Kara Swisher
Questions from Valentino. All right, you have to answer them too. "Why is this guy so angry with Amazon that he wants to break it? It's beyond me to explain why AWS is." Oh, my God. This literally—this, thank you for reading this. This email made my night. And I don't know if you know, no email we've received, actually nothing that's happened, has changed my behavior more than this young man. Because I don't know if you've noticed, I have not used a single expletive because the notion that a five-year-old is listening has me totally freaked out.
Scott Galloway
That is true now. That's true.
Kara Swisher
But you did talk about presidential sex, but okay. All right. Next question. "I love Tesla. Why is so angry?"
Scott Galloway
Let me answer. Let me answer Valentino.
Kara Swisher
Okay. Answer the first one, Amazon, then we'll get to the rest.
Scott Galloway
Okay. The reason I want to break Amazon, I don't want to break it. Think of it this way, Valentino. You know, in your class, there are twins. Have you ever met twins? And that is the people kind of look like each other, but they have their own personality, and it's better than one. They're more fun to play with because there's two of them. I want Amazon to be twins. I want two companies that kind of look like each other but are even more fun, and there's more of a good thing. So I don't want to break them. I want to turn Amazon into twins.
Kara Swisher
Next question. Okay. "I love Tesla. Why is so angry at Tesla? Dad drives one." I drive one, too. They're great cars. I love Tesla. And by the way, ask your dad to make the Tesla dance. Say, "Dad, make our Tesla dance" and force Dad to go on YouTube and figure out how to make Tesla dance. But I like Tesla, too. I think it's a great car. And your daddy has great taste in cars. Why so angry? Answer his very pointed question, Scott. Why so angry at Tesla?
Scott Galloway
Why so angry at Tesla? Because, well, okay, so Tesla, I think sometimes people at companies say mean things about other people and they shouldn't. And some of the people, the guy who's the big boss at Tesla is a genius, but sometimes he says mean things, and I don't like that.
Kara Swisher
All right, okay. And you also don't like the stock, too, which we can explain, but that's okay. Thanks for that. Thanks for that. Okay, three. "Is Donald Trump in jail yet? What do I do to make it happen, given me and my friends can't vote?"
Scott Galloway
So the first thing you need to do is do really well in history. History is important because it'll help you predict the future. And then, Valentino, we need you to go to law school and join the Department of Justice and then run for Senate. So, history class, college, law school, Senate. Valentino, Senate. I will be there. I will be there.
Kara Swisher
This kid—you can tell this kid big things are in store for Valentino. Oh, my God. I love that. You explaining things to a five-year-old is my favorite, Scott Galloway. That's just looking in the mirror. All right. The last part she wrote: "The next generation is listening. Thank you for your time, Camilla." Camilla, thank you so much. And obviously, you brought up the best. Made my night. Made my weekend. Seriously. Elementary school, Scott, is the best Scott.
Scott Galloway
There you go. That is how I like to write that.
Kara Swisher
I would love to know you at five years old. How awesome is that? What were you like at five years old?
Scott Galloway
Oh my God. I was shy and a nice kid. What were you like?
Kara Swisher
I was just the same. Just the same. Just the same. I ran the freaking playground. I ran the playground.
Scott Galloway
Listen to me. I know him. I know him. I know the vice principal at the other school. I know him. I know him. I ran that playground and I was a benevolent dictator. Stick with me, kid. I know the lady that runs the cafeteria. We're getting an extra scoop of potato salad. Stick with me. Stick with me. It's the way it is.
Kara Swisher
I can't, I don't know what to say. It's genetics. Anyway, Scott, please, you wanted to give a special shout out before we go.
Scott Galloway
All right. So before we go, more virtue signaling on my part, this incredibly impressive young man, a guy named Dom Phillip—I think his name is Dom Phillip—is over here from abroad, who's had some struggles with health. And he's just incredibly—or he isn't, he's an incredibly impressive 37-year-old. Sent me a picture. Handsome dude. And him and his wife are here in the U.S. because we have some of the best—we still have distinctive some of obviously our big problems on health care—we still have some of the best health care in the world. And he wrote this very nice email to him. Anyways, I just wanted to say hello and that I was thinking about him. And I'm so glad that he is here in the United States of America. And anyways, I'm just going to leave it there. But a quick shout out to Dom and his wife.
Kara Swisher
And more five-year-olds, please write in because it makes—There you go. A better person. More people, write in. This is the best side of Scott. Remember, we love your questions. If you have a question or you just want to say something like this about a story you're hearing in the news or anything we say, email us at [email protected] to be featured on the show. Scott, read us out the credits.
Scott Galloway
Today's episode was produced by Rebecca Sinanis, our executive producer is Erica Anderson, and special thanks to Rebecca Castro and Drew Burrows. If you like what you heard, please download and recommend to a friend our episode or our podcast. Listen to it wherever you listen to podcasts. And also be sure to tune in next week for a breakdown of all things tech and business.
Kara Swisher
Professor Steyer, 2024. I like that guy. I like that guy. I am basking in the glow of that episode. I am basking. I am basking in the glow. The glow. Oh, my gosh. Hello. Hello. I feel like that guy. What was that movie? Did you see Purple Rain? A long time ago. God, a hundred years ago. Yeah, the guy from—I don't know, it popped in my mind—the guy who was the lead singer for The Time. I don't even remember that movie. I feel like that guy right now. Do you? I feel like that guy.
Scott Galloway
Well, sing on, Scott Galloway. All right. Okay. Thanks a lot. We'll talk Thursday. See you. Bye now.
Ad break
Announcer
This episode is brought to you by FX's Alien Earth, the official podcast. Each week, host Adam Rogers is joined by guests, including the show's creator, cast, and crew, in this exclusive companion podcast. They will explore story elements, deep dive into character motivations, and offer an episode-by-episode behind-the-scenes breakdown of each terrifying chapter in this new series. Search FX's Alien Earth wherever you listen to podcasts.